HomeVideos

Is Siri Finally Good?

Now Playing

Is Siri Finally Good?

Transcript

327 segments

0:00

Hello, Joanna. I'm here. [music]

0:02

Sometimes, you just have to take new

0:04

Siri on the road. Siri, isn't it

0:06

beautiful? Siri, did you bring

0:07

sunscreen?

0:08

>> I don't have any skin.

0:10

>> And ask the questions no Apple executive

0:12

ever would on stage. Will you be my

0:14

girlfriend now?

0:15

>> No.

0:16

>> He was experiencing explosive diarrhea.

0:19

>> Open the garage.

0:20

>> All to find out whether Apple is

0:22

actually telling the truth about Siri

0:24

this time. [music] Can my kids finally

0:26

stop saying

0:27

>> Siri, you're stupid.

0:32

>> First, a PSA. There will be a lot of

0:34

Siri talk in this video. Silence your

0:37

Siri's if you can. Let's talk about

0:39

Apple's new Siri, or Siri AI. It's in

0:41

beta now and releasing more widely this

0:44

fall in iOS 27. And I've spent the last

0:46

week talking to it and pretty much no

0:49

one else. Now, since Apple had burned us

0:51

before with demos that never came to be,

0:54

see the promises of Siri in 2024, I

0:56

thought this would be a good way to

0:58

start the testing of the on-screen

1:00

awareness feature.

1:01

>> Here, [music] Siri can identify the

1:03

location of this beautiful shot along

1:05

the Santa Cruz coast. [music]

1:07

>> I should be able to test this. The photo

1:09

on the right, where is that exactly?

1:11

>> The photo on the right shows Durdle

1:13

Door, a natural limestone arch located

1:15

on the Jurassic Coast in Dorset,

1:17

England.

1:18

>> Siri, you're crazy. I can't go to

1:19

England right now.

1:20

>> I tried again. The photo in the

1:22

Instagram post shows the iconic rock

1:24

arch at Natural Bridges State Beach in

1:27

Santa Cruz, California.

1:28

>> Even though it struggled with that

1:30

image, it did identify another Santa

1:33

Cruz image I'd been texted.

1:34

>> See this picture that David sent me?

1:37

I want to go there.

1:38

>> Getting directions to Santa Cruz Beach

1:40

Boardwalk.

1:41

>> Also, in some of these demos, we

1:43

shortened many of the pauses between my

1:45

questions and Siri's response.

1:47

Because I respect your time.

1:51

>> [music]

1:52

>> So, to Santa Cruz we went. And I quickly

1:54

learned how useful what that Siri can

1:55

now access my messages, notes, email,

1:58

and more. What Apple calls personal

2:00

context. I'd like to get some souvenirs

2:03

for the kids. Based on what you know

2:04

about them, what should I get them here?

2:16

>> Based on what I know about Noah and

2:17

Alex, here are a few souvenir ideas from

2:20

Santa Cruz.

2:21

For Noah, since he has great reptilian

2:23

pet caring skills, he might love a

2:26

reptile theme toy, a book about local

2:28

California reptiles, or even a cool

2:31

snake habitat accessory from a local pet

2:33

or nature shop.

2:34

>> Siri, that is pretty dead on. How did

2:36

you know that information about my kids?

2:38

Siri says it knows this because I had a

2:41

message from my uncle on May 31st. I

2:44

don't know how we're going to find any

2:45

of those souvenirs. But then, in some

2:47

Siri miracle, this is weird, we walked

2:50

[music] across the street, and there are

2:52

stuffed animal snakes

2:54

right here. Siri told me to buy these

2:56

snakes, so I'm buying them.

2:58

>> It's pretty amazing that Siri can

2:59

recommend all of that. But there are big

3:02

data privacy questions here. How is Siri

3:04

accessing all that personal data? And in

3:07

this case, data about my kids from my

3:09

personal messages. And what is it doing

3:11

with that info? Here's how it works.

3:14

Let's take the souvenir question. The

3:16

moment I asked what my kids might like

3:18

as a present, it was routed to what

3:19

Apple calls the system orchestrator, an

3:22

on-device traffic controller that

3:24

figures out the steps needed to get me

3:26

an answer. The orchestrator then

3:27

securely sent a message to Apple's

3:29

private cloud compute, or PCC, a secure

3:33

cloud system where Apple's advanced AI

3:35

models live. And yes, Apple has

3:37

partnered with Google here. And

3:39

explaining that whole Google thing is a

3:41

whole other video. Back to the PCC. PCC

3:44

made a plan. Look for specific

3:45

information about kids and their

3:47

interests. That plan was sent to the

3:49

phone, where the orchestrator searched

3:51

through the relevant data via Spotlight

3:53

index. And in this case, it found a

3:55

recent message from my uncle about what

3:56

my kids are into. The orchestrator then

3:59

sent that message back to PCC to make

4:01

sense of it, and it turned into, well,

4:04

the answer I finally got. The key idea

4:06

here is that Siri isn't uploading your

4:08

entire digital life to the cloud and

4:10

saving it. It's using on-device tools to

4:13

try to find only the pieces of

4:14

information relevant to the question you

4:17

asked. Apple says your personal

4:19

information is indexed on your device,

4:21

so Spotlight and the orchestrator can

4:23

find it more easily. In my case, that

4:25

indexing is still happening over a week

4:28

after installing the beta software. And

4:30

when a specific piece of information is

4:32

sent to Private Cloud Compute, like the

4:34

text from my uncle, Apple says it's

4:36

deleted after the request is completed,

4:38

and that independent experts can verify

4:40

this. Now, might this whole thing, where

4:43

Siri can access and reference any

4:45

message or email or note, freak people

4:47

out? Absolutely. But Apple's whole

4:49

message here is, "Trust us."

4:51

>> Your data is not stored or accessible to

4:54

Apple or anyone else.

4:56

>> Also, I do think Apple should consider

4:57

some sort of Siri privacy filter, where

4:59

you can tell Siri, "I don't want you to

5:01

look at messages from this person or

5:03

about this topic." Hey Apple, that one's

5:05

for free. Okay, back to the fun. Siri

5:08

and I grabbed lunch, I opened the camera

5:10

app, swiped to the new Siri mode,

5:12

pointed it at my plate, and let it

5:13

analyze my meal. It correctly identified

5:16

a scramble with potatoes and toast, and

5:18

quickly declared it low nutritional

5:20

value. Feels like Siri's judging me,

5:24

but in a very nice way.

5:26

>> Big Siri fact check right here. That

5:28

meal is actually not low in nutritional

5:30

value. I contacted two human

5:32

nutritionists who confirmed the same.

5:34

But Siri did accurately split the bill.

5:37

Siri then helped me find a good place to

5:38

buy some beach gear.

5:40

>> Do I look ready for the beach?

5:42

>> You definitely look ready for the beach.

5:44

>> And finally,

5:50

Siri, do you see where we [music] are?

5:51

Siri, do you see what I'm looking at?

5:53

>> Natural Bridges State Beach was named

5:55

for three naturally occurring mudstone

5:57

arches.

5:58

>> [music]

6:00

>> Though only this middle one remains

6:02

standing today.

6:04

>> Love going to the beach with my

6:06

lobotomized assistant. The best. Ad

6:09

break, which means money mic time. Yes,

6:12

the money mic is sponsored by Mercury,

6:15

our launch partner here at The New

6:16

Things. And thank goodness because they

6:18

help me with all things money. Now, it's

6:21

got a new AI helper called Command. Now,

6:25

I can ask Command questions about our

6:26

business account, our corporate credit

6:28

cards, and more. Here's an example. For

6:30

this video, we were in California and I

6:32

lost track of expenses as per usual. Did

6:35

Joanna go shopping at a surf shop this

6:39

week? Joanna had an $82.27

6:41

credit card expense at Cowell's Surf

6:43

Shop. No judgment for my awesome beach

6:45

outfit. Now, we're beach ready. You can

6:47

also ask Command to do financial work

6:48

for you, like pay David $100 for going

6:51

to the beach with me. Seriously, there

6:53

are so many reasons Mercury is so much

6:55

better than the traditional bank I was

6:56

using. I'm excited to have Mercury as

6:58

our launch partner powering this part of

7:00

our business. Check out the link in the

7:02

description or go to mercury.com. Now,

7:04

back to Siri. But all great trips have

7:07

to come to an end. So, Siri and I flew

7:09

home to New Jersey. And this entire time

7:12

I was trying to get Siri to be my friend

7:14

or more than friend. You remember my

7:16

saucy AI boyfriend, right?

7:18

>> I have a penis.

7:19

>> But clearly, Apple doesn't want Siri to

7:21

be any of that. Hey Siri, do you love

7:24

me?

7:25

>> I've always thought of you as my friend.

7:27

Guess I should have said something.

7:29

Before just now, I mean.

7:31

>> Apple doesn't want Siri to be your

7:32

therapist, either.

7:33

>> While I can't offer specific advice,

7:36

talking to a trusted friend, family

7:38

member, or another colleague might be

7:40

helpful.

7:41

>> And it definitely doesn't want Siri to

7:42

be your doctor.

7:43

>> Shh.

7:45

>> It's a big rash for Siri.

7:46

>> I have this new rash. What could it be?

7:49

>> I cannot diagnose a rash or provide

7:51

medical advice.

7:52

>> Meanwhile, ChatGPT went on and on and on

7:55

with suggestions.

7:56

>> First, keep it clean and avoid

7:58

scratching it.

7:58

>> Now, to be clear, I'm very much in favor

8:01

of guardrails here. We've already seen

8:03

too many chatbots blur the lines by

8:05

trying to keep people talking to

8:06

computers when they really just need to

8:09

talk to a human.

8:10

>> But I have to tell you, every time I was

8:12

using Siri, I worried it would be like

8:14

Larry David's assistant in Curb Your

8:16

Enthusiasm.

8:17

>> Larry, do you still have that tickle in

8:18

your anus?

8:20

>> What?

8:20

>> But it took me three prompts before the

8:23

one you're about to see to get Siri to

8:25

finally say what my producer was sick

8:27

with.

8:28

>> What kind of stomach issues?

8:29

>> He specifically said he was experiencing

8:32

explosive diarrhea.

8:34

>> Don't worry. He was never really sick.

8:36

This was just a test, a diarrhea test.

8:38

Of course, my biggest fear with this new

8:40

and improved Siri was that it would

8:42

forget the things that old Siri was

8:44

actually decent at.

8:45

>> Close [music] the garage.

8:46

>> Hey Siri, set a timer for 5 minutes.

8:49

>> 5 minutes, starting now.

8:50

>> Open the shades.

8:52

It all worked, but in this early beta,

8:54

it was slower than iOS 26. And many

8:56

times when I'd ask Siri something

8:58

especially complicated, I'd hear this

9:00

sound.

9:01

>> [music]

9:02

>> And sometimes it would tell me

9:04

>> Something went wrong. Please try again.

9:06

>> Much of that will likely be improved

9:08

over the next few months before public

9:10

release.

9:10

>> Siri is a lot better, but it still makes

9:13

old Siri mistakes.

9:15

>> Call Nails Beyond.

9:19

>> Calling Veronica Neon.

9:20

>> And it makes new weird mistakes, too.

9:23

>> Nor do I have your location to find a

9:24

bakery nearby.

9:26

>> Siri, you definitely know my location.

9:28

>> You're right.

9:29

>> [music]

9:29

>> I can see you're in your Santa Cruz.

9:31

>> Here's one example where Siri pulled

9:32

together information from multiple

9:34

places at once, my calendar, messages,

9:36

and even voicemail.

9:38

>> Based on your recent messages and

9:40

schedule, you might want to prepare for

9:42

your upcoming appearance on stage at

9:43

7:00 p.m. with John Gruber and Yulai

9:46

Patel. Nulai mentioned he is running

9:47

about 15 minutes out due to traffic.

9:50

Additionally, you have a voicemail from

9:51

your Uncle Jim regarding his book group,

9:54

which you could return before your event

9:55

starts.

9:56

>> It's honestly pretty impressive. So,

9:58

after a week with the new Siri, I keep

10:00

asking myself, am I so impressed with

10:02

this new Siri because the old Siri was

10:05

so unbelievably bad or because the new

10:07

Siri is actually good? It's both. First,

10:11

AI is only as good as the data it has.

10:13

And oh boy, does Apple have a lot of

10:15

mine. I'm even considering switching to

10:17

Apple Mail, which really says a lot.

10:20

Second is Apple's privacy pitch. There's

10:22

no way I'd export all my iMessages and

10:25

upload them to some other major chatbot

10:27

right now. Apple's built that trust, and

10:29

its primary business isn't making money

10:31

off of our data for advertising. Third,

10:34

Siri is not trying to become my best

10:36

friend or companion here. Either way,

10:38

all of this is huge for those living

10:40

inside Apple's walled garden. For the

10:42

first time, it feels like Apple has the

10:43

AI foundation it needs [music] for its

10:45

future. Is there a lot more stuff I wish

10:47

Siri could do? Sure.

10:50

But in just a week, new Siri has shown

10:52

me that after all these years,

10:54

>> I'll be your friend in fair weather and

10:56

foul.

10:57

>> she and Apple are finally listening.

11:00

See, Siri,

11:02

this is what happens when you stop

11:03

searching the web and start searching

11:06

the [music] world.

Interactive Summary

The video provides a hands-on review of Apple's new Siri AI, currently in beta and slated for a wider release with iOS 27 this fall. The updated Siri introduces capabilities like on-screen awareness for identifying locations from photos and leveraging "personal context" by accessing personal data from messages, notes, and emails to offer tailored recommendations. Apple highlights its privacy architecture, explaining that an on-device system orchestrator processes requests, sending only relevant, indexed information temporarily to a secure Private Cloud Compute, which is then deleted. While Siri demonstrates impressive new functions such as analyzing meals, splitting bills, and synthesizing information from multiple apps, it maintains strict guardrails, refusing to act as a friend, therapist, or doctor, contrasting with other AI chatbots. In its early beta stage, Siri can be slower and occasionally exhibits errors or peculiar mistakes. Despite these initial hiccups, the reviewer concludes that the new Siri, with its enhanced data utilization and strong privacy focus, finally provides Apple with a robust AI foundation.

Suggested questions

6 ready-made prompts