Sarah Paine: What Everyone Gets Wrong About Russia and China
132 segments
Well, Sarah, I want to know more about
the Russian Chinese relationship. This
is the one thing I wanted to deep dive
with you because
>> my expertise finally.
>> There you go. But right now, you know,
Russia has it bad. It has a triple
header of issues. It has sticky
inflation. Growth is stagnant. Uh, and
the economic or the trade policy,
specifically oil prices. We mentioned
them in passing, but right now they're
selling at about what $346
a barrel. And that's without taking into
consideration concessions for the
Chinese or the Indians
>> and high Russian production costes cost
because they can't modernize their
facilities.
>> Yeah. Because of the sanctions. So how
much is Russia relying on China at this
point without the
>> I don't know what the data is. That must
be highly secret. Uh Russia has well the
Soviet Union lost its not all of its
empire but an awful lot of it. And then
China popped the belt road initiative
right there which is a Chinese bid to
take over that empire. And then China,
this is the the real positive about
China. They have no interest in a pro
economy, right? Because they don't have
enough. And so they are going to be the
big movers and shakers in the green
revolution. And that will be positive
for all of us since um the United States
is apparently not interested in these
things anymore and China has a mass
market for uh creating green energy
sources that it needs itself and it will
and it's been rapidly developing these
things. So that is very positive but it
suggests that while oil oil is going to
remain important because you need to use
it for certain things it's not going to
be uh the only energy that this it has
lost its centrality as the energy source
uh forever the way coal uh lost its
centrality when you get the oil
revolution and now we're going to go to
the next phase which will be
tremendously important. So Russia's
problem is it's blown its opportunity
to take
uh this period of high oil prices to
really make enduring
uh investments if leaders were all
operationally focused me staying in
power that's what Vladimir Putin's done
very successfully
instead of how can I make Russia itself
more prosperous and also the guy isn't
well educated, so he knows all his KGB
stuff and knows how to send Vagner
groups in to cap other people. That
would be And also disinformation. Boy,
the Russians are good at that. Uh
they've been excellent at it ever since
the Bolevixs. Understanding how to use
printed word podcasting now. Everyone's
social media accounts to stir things up.
They're all good at that stuff. But
fundamentally, it's not making Russia
more prosperous. And then with the
Ukraine war, a whole bunch of people
your age left,
>> right?
>> And they were some of the most promising
people Russia had.
>> And uh now when you're throwing out your
business partners from six floor
windows,
it's going to make people even more. How
can you be innovative in a country like
that? You can't be. So Russia's toast. I
can't imagine.
Well, Vladimir Putin is going to keep
doing just doubling down till he dies.
Obviously, he'll die like as we all
will. Who knows whether it'll be like
Stalin where the guy goes thud in the
next room and no one opens the door
until they go he must be dead by now. We
can now open the door. Literally, that's
and who knows if the story is really
true or whether something someone put
something interesting in his kasha that
morning. Unknown.
>> No, but I I I think that's true. It was
>> and then and then there's going to be a
leadership struggle, right? A real uh a
fight, no holes barred fight for who
becomes the next one. And the next one
will take a a good deal of time to
consolidate their power. And this is the
problem with dictatorships. They're
incredibly inefficient. They blow
through wealth. They uh suppress growth
because no one can be assured that their
work that they'll actually benefit from
it, right?
Uh there is no rule of law law. It's
just the desperates law. Whoever they
want to kill, that's it.
Um also unlike China, Russia doesn't
have this vibrant commercial tradition.
China always has had one. Since the Silk
Road, China's been producing
manufacturers, state-of-the-art
manufacturers that everyone has coveted.
It used to be silks and porcelain
manufacturers of th those days. And now
it's just all manner of of uh appliances
and things. I'm sure you've got some in
your in your flat and they're very good.
Right. So, Russ Russia's toast. They're
they're back to the Mongol yoke. Um and
their only way out of it would be to
settle to uh pull themselves out of
Ukraine, pay some reparations, and get
back into Europe. That's never going to
happen.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The video discusses the current economic and political state of Russia, highlighting its reliance on China and its missed opportunities during a period of high oil prices. The speaker suggests Russia's economic future is bleak due to its current policies, sanctions, and the ongoing war in Ukraine, which has led to a brain drain. Unlike China, which has a strong commercial tradition and is a leader in the green revolution, Russia is seen as inefficient and suppressive of growth. The speaker speculates on Vladimir Putin's future and the potential for a power struggle within Russia, ultimately concluding that Russia is "toast" and unlikely to reintegrate with Europe.
Videos recently processed by our community