This Statistically Is The Best Age To Get Married So You Don't Get A Divorce!
3192 segments
Some of the studies I was looking at
shows that if you get married after 30,
each additional year of age increases
your chance of divorce by 5%.
I couldn't figure out why. Oh, I think
there are several reasons for this. So,
first of all Lori Gottlieb
renowned psychotherapist
bestselling author
couples counselor
who's helped thousands of people find or
save their relationships. People use the
first date as I'm supposed to feel this
one thing or else forget it and people
will come into therapy and say, "I
didn't feel like butterflies, so I'm not
going to go out with him again." People
said they wouldn't go on a second date
with somebody because he ordered tap
water. He must be really cheap. There
was one where somebody said, "Oh, he did
this impression from Austin Powers."
Yeah, baby. He's just nervous. He was
trying to make you laugh.
What about he asks to split the bill?
Would that be an ick?
If he doesn't pay, that would be a huge
ick for me. Really? But it's really
important to understand why, which is
interesting. Now your partner has to be
your best friend, have the same
interests, has to rock my world in bed
or someone who's really ambitious, but
also really family oriented. No one
human could possibly do that. If you
look at what are the most important
things that would predict whether a
relationship is going to last. is really
important
are very important. And then emotional
is really important.
What does that mean? It means
You went to therapy because of
heartbreak. Yes.
How do we navigate through that dark
cloud? One strategy that might be
helpful is
It's absolutely crazy to me that so many
of you have decided to watch our show um
and so many of you have decided to
subscribe to our show. We now have 5
million subscribers on YouTube, which is
a number that I just can't comprehend
and it's a dream that I absolutely never
could have had. We started The Diary of
a CEO just over 3 years ago now and in
my wildest expectations, we might have
had 100,000 subscribers by now. So, you
can imagine how shocked I am
that so many of you have chosen to tune
into these conversations every week um
and spend some time with us. So, thank
you. And I made a deal with you. I made
a deal that if you subscribe to this
show, that we would continue to raise
the bar and in 2024
we're going to raise the bar like never
before. I've been working for the last 9
months on a surprise for all of you that
have subscribed to this show and I'm
very excited to deliver that for you.
The production's going to change. We're
going to go even further with our guests
and we're going to tell even more global
stories. So, as always, if you
appreciate what we're doing here, the
simple free favor I'll ask from you is
to hit the subscribe button. Let's get
on with the episode.
[Music]
Lori,
if you had to summarize what it is
you have done for people over the last
couple of decades, how would you
summarize that? I would say that I help
people to learn what gets in their way
from living the life that they want to
live. And what departments of their life
do you tend to focus on? All of them.
They're all so important, but I think
it's really about people's relationships
and I mean relationship to self. What is
going on with the way that I talk to
myself, the way that I make decisions
and choices, the way that I hold myself
back, relationships with friends, with
romantic partners, with family members,
with um professional colleagues, all of
it. And of all of those subcategories,
what are the categories within that that
people come to you advice for
most often through your podcast, through
your articles, through your therapy
work? Well, it's interesting because
it's usually somebody coming in and
saying, "I really want something in my
life to change." And what they want to
change is someone else.
Right? And so, I think what they're
surprised to find is that yes, there are
difficult people in their lives. You
know, we like to say that before
diagnosing someone with depression, make
sure they aren't surrounded by
So,
um you know, there are really difficult
people out there. But the question is,
where's your agency? What are the
choices that you're making? Um are you
setting boundaries with these people?
Are you adding to the tension between
the two of you because you're kind of in
a dance and you're doing some old
pattern that you're in with this person.
So, I think it's really important to
become self-aware and say, "What am I
doing in the world that gets me closer
to the way that I want to live and what
am I doing in the world that keeps me
from getting there?"
And since you got into this line of work
and since your sort of education in this
area began,
what changes have you seen in the types
of questions and the types of issues
that are being presented to you in a
sort of clinical setting or online or
through your DMs, etc.? I think most
people are really seeking connection of
some sort that they don't have in their
lives.
And there's a sense of being alone,
whether it's I'm the only person who
feels this way, I'm so ashamed, I don't
know why I'm so anxious or I'm so
depressed or it's a feeling of I feel
like I'm I have all these sort of
friends, you know, kind of peripherally
or friends in the world, if you look at
their social media, but they don't
really have someone that they could call
and say, "I really need to talk to you
about this." Who's this person you can
confide in? You know, there are these
studies that have been done where they
they looked at, you know, several
decades ago, how many people said, "I
have someone close that I can call." And
most people had at least someone,
usually a few people. Now most people
have zero people. They have said zero,
"I have nobody that I can call and
confide in in that deep way." Does that
mean that there's a greater pressure now
put on our romantic partners to meet
more of our needs? Yes, absolutely. And
that's one of the things that I think
you see in dating, especially with
younger generations, because it used to
be that your community was there to meet
all different kinds of needs. So, now
it's, you know, people like to say,
"Well, my partner is my best friend."
Well, but you also have a best friend.
Most people also have a best friend,
right? So, so what happened or maybe
they don't anymore because of what we've
been talking about. So, the question is
now your partner has to be your best
friend where they are there to meet all
of your emotional needs. Whereas before
you had, you know, I could talk to this
friend about this and I had this friend
that my partner doesn't like this hobby,
but I get to go. My partner doesn't like
move these kinds of movies, but I could
go to these kinds of movies with this
person or, you know, whatever it is. And
now it's like we have to kind of have
the same interests and we have to be
able to talk about all the same things
and we have to, you know, he has to rock
my world in bed or she has to rock my
world in bed or they have to um read my
mind. Right? And so, no one human could
possibly do that. There is no human who
can do that. And so, what happens is we
think something's wrong with this
relationship if I'm not getting that
from this person. And what are the other
sort of big picture items that are
making it harder for us to be satisfied
romantically these days? I think again
the sort of expectations of what it
means to be loved. I think that when
people really put everything into this
other person, they aren't getting the
the kinds of emotional nourishment that
they would be getting from the larger
community. So, whether it's extended
family that used to be around, most
people a lot of people don't even live
where their fam where they grew up
anymore. So, they're kind of putting
down roots somewhere else. Um they are
kind of, you know, they they have to
form like a whole new group of people.
There's something to be said for the
people who knew you when you were young.
There's something about that about
really being known because I think in
relationship, people really want to know
and be known. I remember I had a couple
come in and this was so striking to me
where um she said to her husband, "You
know what three words I really want to
hear?" And he said, "I love you." And
she said, "No, I understand you." And
that was so profound that how deep a
yearning we all have to want to be
understood. And I think that that comes
from, you know, you have history with
people and you have shared experiences
with people, but we're moving around so
much nowadays that we don't have that
history or those shared experiences and
people didn't know us at different times
in our lives. When you're truly known,
oh, you went through this transformation
or you went through this difficult time
or I remember that fun time we had when
we were 16 years old.
And so, a lot of people just don't have
those kind of deeper connections
anymore. What is it about being
understood that
we want? Like what is it what is the
fundamental there? Is it does it make us
feel psychologically safer or what what
is it?
Oh, it makes us less lonely. Okay. If
you feel like you're the only one who
understands what's going on for you,
you're all alone.
And that's why it's so interesting, you
know, having the Dear Therapists podcast
or having the column, where most people
write in and think that they are alone
and yet I have thousands of people
writing in the same exact thing. So,
they're not alone, but they think that
they're alone. They feel no one
understands or no one would understand.
And I see this more with men also than
with women, although both I get that,
but it it's interesting because I think
that with with men, you know, often
they'll come into therapy. Men get into
therapy sort of one of two ways. They
either come in because they're in a
couple and there's a problem in the
relationship and so they come into
therapy or they come in kind of
secretively. Like, you know, no one
knows I'm here. And they'll say, "I've
never told anyone this before." And the
thing that they tell you is something
that women will talk about quite easily.
And it's not that men are less deep than
women. It's that women feel more
comfortable to over lunch with a friend
say something like that. And when women
come in and they say, "I've never told
anyone this before." They'll say,
"Except for my mother, my sister, my
best friend." So, they've told a few
people. Maybe one person, maybe two,
maybe three.
And so, I think it's interesting because
I think that, um, you know, men can be
particularly lonely because they really
don't have the place to kind of connect
in the way that women are more
culturally
acceptable to do so. Women sometimes
have an expectation that their partner
will open up in the same way that their
best friends will open up. Yeah. And
many men fall short of that expectation.
I,
you know, I think there's often a
narrative that women want a man to kind
of sit down and talk about his problems
and open up and listen and all those
kinds of things that a woman might do
with her best friends, but men for some
reason tend to struggle with that. Yeah.
Well, they they women want that and they
don't want that. So, women say they want
that and they think that they truly mean
it when they say they want that. But in
couples therapy, I'll I'll see something
like a woman will come in and and, you
know, she'll say that exact thing to her
partner, you know, I really want you to
open up. I feel like we're not
connecting. I want you to be more
vulnerable with me. I want you to tell
me what's going on inside.
And if he does, and let's say he starts
crying,
tears up, or really starts crying, she
inevitably will have this reaction of,
"I don't feel safe when he doesn't open
up to me because I don't feel connected
to him, but I don't feel safe when he's
that vulnerable with me either because
there's something just some cultural
programming in her around what it's like
to be with a man who's crying or a man
who is vulnerable. And so, I think
that's that's really problematic and I
think that makes it, you know, kind of
harder for men to feel like, "Well, I
have a safe space to open up." Like it
takes a lot for a man to really feel
like, "Oh, this is something that I want
to share." Whereas I think women just
feel a lot more free to do that with
their partners. I saw a video yesterday
that I'm actually going to play to you
cuz I saved it
ahead of this conversation. It caused a
lot of discussion online on Twitter.
Okay. So, this is the video, okay? Yeah.
I just want somebody who's so obsessed
with the Bible and so obsessed with
Jesus and who understands and like you
said, like who can teach us things.
Yeah. Like I want my dude to speak in
tongues and have tattoos. I just want a
good man. Like a nice classic man. I
want somebody who will literally protect
me and beat someone's butt if they need
to, but also will sit there with
compassion and just like a good-hearted
man. That's what a true man is. There
has to be that dichotomy. It's the same
thing with feminine women, too. There's
always a dichotomy. But there's a
softness and a strength. And for men,
being masculine is being able to beat
someone's butt, you know, maybe not
physically, but like being a protector
and like doing what he needs to do to
protect his family, but then also being
soft enough to like be able to tend to
his wife's feelings and like to be able
That's hilarious. But that's that's, you
know, people would say, "Well, I'm not
like that."
But yet, when you actually talk to
people about when you when they're
dating and you're talking to them about
what's going on and why they're not
going out on another date with somebody
or, you know, why they won't even go on
a first date with somebody, um, those
are the kinds of things that's an
exaggerated version of the kinds of
things that you will hear. Which is what
kind of things? Like they're they're
they're not 6'4", they're not strong and
soft at the same time.
Yeah, yeah, it's you know, they have to
be this and this, these two, you know,
they want someone who's, you know, "I
want someone who's really, really
ambitious, but also really
family-oriented. I want someone Right?"
The these kinds of things that are hard
to find both of those in equal measure
in the same person. Someone who's
extremely ambitious is probably going to
spend a lot of time at work. You know, I
want some, you know, someone So, I'm
5'2" and it would be, you know, someone
like me saying, you know, "And and he
has to be over 6' Really?"
You know, just all all of these kinds of
things I So, in in my book Marry Him, I
I wrote a whole book about this because
I was looking at how do we date today?
And what are the expectations that we
have? And, you know, the the publisher
called it Marry Him, The Case for
Settling for Mr. Good Enough. It's not
about settling at all. It's actually
about having higher standards, not lower
standards, but having higher standards
about the things that actually matter.
So, I looked at all of the data and I
talked to uh, behavioral economists and
sociologists and historians and I talked
to, um, you know, people therapists who
specialize in divorce, who specialize in
couples therapy. And it was really
interesting to hear, um, to see like how
expectations have changed over time. And
then also
to see what it is that actually matters
to have a happy, fulfilling,
long-lasting relationship and how when
we're dating, we're not even looking at
those qualities.
And so, for example, the character
qualities. If you look at what are the
most important things that would predict
whether a relationship is going to last,
what qualities do you want in a partner?
Flexibility is really important. What
does that mean? So, flexibility meaning
you're not a really rigid person. People
who are really rigid, it has to be this
way. I need it this way. Um, I expect
this of you, right? You know, on social
media, we might call that, uh,
boundaries
right now. And boundaries are really
important. Don't get me wrong. Healthy
boundaries are very important, but
rigidity is when you say that, "Well,
I'm just very boundary," but you're
actually really have room for the person
to also be them.
And that you are a separate person from
the person that you're with. And often
times, it's hard for people to see that
because they're so focused on what I
need without thinking about what does
this relationship need? And what does
the other person need, too?
Emotional generosity
is really important that you give
someone the benefit of the doubt, that
you're not bringing your your old wounds
into the relationship and projecting
them onto your partner. Um, so I would
call emotional maturity or emotional
stability. So many times people overlook
that when they're dating. So, that looks
like, you know, someone comes into
therapy and they say, "I don't
understand why, you know, I I I love him
so much and I don't understand why he
didn't call when he said he would or I
don't understand why he canceled."
And I will say, "What do you love
exactly? Do you Is this
how you want your life to go? To always
be on edge? To always wonder? To be with
someone who's unreliable? Who doesn't do
what they say they were going to do?
What what part of this do you love? Oh,
but he's so funny and attractive and,
you know, um, he's so smart. You like
qualities about him, but you don't like
the way he is with you in relationship."
And so, people need to have higher
standards about the character qualities,
things that are important to them like
loyalty, reliability, emotional
stability,
um,
again, emotional generosity. Can they be
supportive of you when things are going
well for you? Uh, on that point of
expectations and how expectations are
evolving, I I found some stats. I think
some of them are very much inspired by
your first book, um, Marry Him.
One of them is that 80% of women want to
date a man over 6' tall when only 15% of
men are over 6' tall. Yes, that's that's
in the book.
Um, I found some other studies. Uh,
an eHarmony study found that 40% of
single people have deal breakers that
are associated with physical appearance.
And 50% of singles expect their partner
to be their best friend, soulmate, and
to fulfill all of their emotional needs.
That was a study done by match.com.
Um, and then the other ones that I found
quite interesting were
you talk about in the book how this sort
of generational shift in expectations
and where that's come from. But in, like
my my granddad's generation or even my
dad's generation,
I would assume they wouldn't have had
the same set of impossible expectations.
I would assume. Is that Is that what you
found in your research? I think
everybody wants to feel that really deep
connection with their partner. And so, I
think that the way that society has
improved is that we are not just
marrying for sort of practicality, but
we are also marrying because we
genuinely enjoy being with this person
and want to go through life with this
person. But I think what we're losing a
little bit is do our values align? Like
the practical part matters. So, I think
the pendulum swung in the other
direction, went from almost pretty much
all practical Mhm. to now it's all like,
"Is this person my soulmate and do they
move me?" And I think you have to have
both. I'm really attracted to this
person's essence. And what I mean by
essence is you're, you know, most people
will say, this is I I I I don't know
where the study came from, but I
remember reading this study, that most
people will say that the person that
they are that they chose to spend their
lives with is not the most attractive
person they ever dated.
And I think that a lot of people say,
"Well, I wouldn't want my partner to
think that." But you're a you're more
attracted to your partner holistically.
That's why they chose you. That's why
you chose them. That's why you're
together. So, it's not just about is
this the person who was the most, you
know, the hottest person you've ever
dated. And so, I think we really have to
think about holistically who do we want
to be with. And that's what kind of
trips us up because the practical side
matters. Do you have similar ideas about
the kind of life you want to live? Do
you have similar ideas about, um, how if
you want to have kids or if you don't
want to have kids and how many you might
want to have, where you want to live,
um, what kinds of what kind of things
you want to do in your lives. Um, what
matters to you, who you are in the
world, um, political beliefs. Often
people say, "Well, that doesn't matter
as much. Um I think when you have very
different views, not necessarily about
like what political party you're with,
but more about how you see the world, if
you see the world very, very
differently, that can cause a lot of
problems in the relationship later on.
Not cuz you're fighting about the world,
but because those differences will show
up in the way you treat each other. I
hear you saying all of that, and I have
to say I agree, and I think everyone
would really agree because it makes
perfect sense. But in reality,
I was thinking about if I turn to some
of my friends that are really struggling
with dating
right now, and I said all of that to
them,
um I don't think any of it would work
because they are so hardwired
to
to be
in search of this like perfect person.
You know, when I when I speak to some of
my friends who are single and they're
say they're over 35, they've really like
never been in a relationship before.
This The things that they say
as reasons for why they're not giving
this person a chance are so unbelievably
petty. Like I have one friend, and she
knows who she is. She's a really good
friend of mine. She's been a good friend
of mine for over a decade. Shout out to
your friend.
Yeah. But I was I was on her profile
once, and she told me that the reason
she wasn't going to give this guy a
chance on this dating app was because in
the back of the picture that he his
display picture, he had boxes on top of
his cupboard. Mhm. And she was like, oh
god, he's he puts boxes on top of his
cupboard like
And she So that's why she didn't give
him a chance. So here's here's the
thing. What happens is people look at
dating profiles when they're going
through the apps, and I think, you know,
men and women tend to do this a little
bit differently. Men are like, am I
attracted to this person? Swipe.
Which also doesn't necessarily work out
for them. Like they're not really
looking for who do I want to be with?
And women do the opposite. They look at
it at, you know, they look at all the
pictures, they'll read everything that
the person wrote as if, do I want to
marry this person potentially or not? As
opposed to, do I want to spend 45
minutes having coffee with this person?
Mhm. That's really different. And also,
on a first date, it's the same mentality
where a lot of people think, oh, you
know, like people will come in to
therapy, or even friends will say,
you know, I went on this date. I had a
good time. It was fun.
I just I don't know. I didn't feel
chemistry. I didn't feel like
butterflies. I didn't I wasn't didn't
feel that that what I feel like I should
feel. So, I'm not going to go out with
him again.
And I'll say, well, why don't you just
go spend, you know, another hour with
this person and get to know this person
and see if something develops. No, no,
no, no, no, right? And so, but it's like
you had a good time. You did think you
know, they said, I did think he was
attractive, but I didn't feel chemistry.
So it's interesting because there's a
study in Marry Him where
it was a longitudinal study, and it
followed people from the time that they
met their partner, like that first date,
all the way through. They checked in
with them every 5 years for I think 20
years. And what happened was they found
that the people who were very happy
together
had kind of revisionist history about
what it was like on their first date. So
people who were really happily married
said, oh yeah, I knew immediately. I
felt immediate chemistry with this
person. I knew this person was the one.
But if you go back to what they reported
at the time, often they reported at the
time, yeah, nice person, not sure.
Okay? So so but they've changed the
story. They really truly believe that
they felt something different, but we
have data saying, no, you didn't. On the
other hand, if people did not last, if
people are divorced, that kind of thing,
um they will say, oh, I was never
attracted to the person, or I knew there
were red flags in the beginning, but
that's not what they reported at the
time. At the time, they reported, wow,
this person's amazing. So it's really
interesting that people use the first
date as as like, I'm supposed to feel
this one thing, or else forget it. When
people who are very, very happy
together, totally in love, totally
attracted to each other, often didn't
feel those sparks on the first one, two,
three dates. You know, maybe they were
even friends for a while.
But people don't give each other the
chance to get to know the other person,
or to let the other person get to know
you. And I think that because the apps
give this illusion of um so many people
are juggling multiple people at a time.
So someone will go on a date with
someone, and then they'll say, yeah,
that was fine. Uh not, you know,
maybe it was like a seven. So, nah.
And then they they're like, I have
another date tomorrow. Or they just
they're leaving the date and they're
walking to their car and they're swiping
on the apps
already.
Because they have the illusion that
there's so many people out there, but if
you just keep juggling people, you're
never going to get to know anybody and
to know if that person is someone that
you want to be with.
So what would you say to a serial dater
then? You would say to
go on the second date even if the person
is a seven? Or is there Cuz I know so I
know people that have gone to go on
hundreds of dates a year, and I think
statistically they must have met someone
that they would have been happy with
by now. Yeah, maybe. It depends if
they're making good choices about who
they go on dates with. So some people
will just go on dates to go on dates.
Other people, if they're being really,
you know, if if they're saying, hey,
this person seems like someone I would
want to be with, and that's who they
choose to go on a first date with, then
yes. But I would say the question you
ask yourself at the end of a first date
is,
did I have a good time? The answer is
yes, I would go on a second date.
Doesn't have to be I had a
life-changing, transformative,
you know, I was Cupid's arrow shot me.
No, it just, did I have a good time with
this person? Yeah, go on a second date.
See what happens the second time.
Who has higher expectations typically,
men or women? And who is most likely or
most willing to adjust their
expectations? Mhm.
Um I think it really depends on the
person. And I think that the
expectations are higher in different
areas. I think for men, um the
expectations are very high around
physical appearance.
And and I think for the younger
generation especially because they're
growing up on all of these thirst traps
that are posted on social media, and
they're seeing all of these girls just
posting, you know, all of these really
provocative pictures that have been
filtered, that have been, you know, it
took them 30 shots to get that one shot
that they put up. And so when they see
people in real life and what they really
are like on a day-to-day basis, they
have these very unrealistic
expectations. And I think that's
different from in the past when you saw
many more people in real life than you
do now, where you're seeing more people
online most of the time. And I think for
women, the expectations
are, you know, I think it's confused
with feminism. So feminism is great. I'm
a feminist. Um but I think that feminism
is not this person has to meet all of
these criteria that are not really
human. And I go through them in the
book. You know, the kinds of things that
people say, and I have all these surveys
in the book about the kinds of things
people say they're looking for and
they're not finding the right person.
And I talk about this study that Barry
Schwartz did. He wrote The Paradox of
Choice, and he looked at the difference
between maximizers and satisficers.
And this applies to dating as much as
anything else. But, you know, the way it
doesn't apply the way that you can look
at it, the way he did in his study was,
he said, look, if you go into a store
and you want to get some jam, and they
have 30 different varieties, most people
just leave because they can't choose.
They're just they get they get anxious,
they don't know what to pick. It's not
like more is better. If you have two
different choices, it's easy. You say,
oh, I like this one, and you're really
happy with it. The people who did choose
from the 30, they're less happy because
they they're trying to maximize, and
then when they taste it and they go home
with it, they think, oh, I wonder what
that other one would have tasted like.
You know, because there were so many
choices. The person who picked from one
of the two is very happy with their
choice. So if you look at the kind of
dating analogy, it's like I I like to
use In the book, I talk about a sweater.
Say you want a sweater, and you know
exactly what you want. It needs to be
this material, so it's not itchy, this
color looks good on you, this is the
right size, this is the right price,
this is the style you're looking for.
You go into a store and you find it. The
satisficer will buy it, be really happy
that they found it, and really enjoy it
for a very long time. The maximizer will
say, oh, I found this, but while I'm at
the mall, I might as well just put this
one, you know, back on the on the shelf,
and I will go look at a few other stores
to see if I can find something that's
maybe a little like the color is a
little bit better, or the the price is
maybe there's something on sale, or
maybe there's something that's a
slightly different material,
and they keep looking, and then they
find something that's maybe slightly
better in their mind,
and they buy it, they're less happy with
it because then it took them all this
anxiety and energy to find it, and then
they find it, and they're always looking
over their shoulder, well, maybe there's
another one, maybe there's a better one,
maybe there's a different one. And the
next time they're walking and they pass
a store window, they think, oh, I should
have gotten that one. So maximizers
think that they're putting in all the
research to find the thing that's going
to make them happiest, but going through
that process makes them unhappy, not
only by going through that process, but
when they get the thing that they decide
on.
So with dating, we want to be
satisficers, which means we have very
high standards. It's not like, oh, I'm
satisfied, that's enough. It's like,
you're satisfied because your standards
are very high, but you're not always
looking over your shoulder to wonder
what you're missing out on. You're not
always in this state of FOMO. Do you see
a gender difference between satisficers
and maximizers at all? Again, it depends
on the person. It really does. I mean, I
think that when you when when you look
at the surveys in Marry Him, women do
tend to be maximizers more than men.
But, I think that I think that men do
have very high standards, but I think
that men are also like after they get
over the oh, I need to be with a
supermodel and then they come back down
to earth and they say, "Oh, I need to be
with someone that I'm really attracted
to." which is different thing.
They're much more holistic. Like, who do
They ask the right questions. Who do I
enjoy being with?
And I think for women, it's there's so
many different things. There are, you
know, in Marry Him, I talk about the
things that people said they wouldn't go
on a second date with somebody over and
it was like, "He ordered tap water
instead of sparkling water. He must be
really cheap."
You know, these assumptions that people
make. Like, when they came by and said,
"Which kind of Which kind of water do
you want?" And maybe he's just
accommodating. Maybe he just said, "Tap
water's fine." Um or, you know, he wore
this he wore those kinds of uh shoes
with that kind of belt. He doesn't have
any fashion sense.
There was one where somebody said, "Oh,
he did this impression from Austin
Powers, this movie. He did this
impression and it was really
embarrassing and I I I was so cringey."
And it was like, he was just nervous. He
was on a first date and he was trying to
make you laugh. Why don't you go on a
second date and if he does something
cringey on the second date, okay, then
you know. But, a lot of times on a first
date, people are just really nervous.
So, they did one thing, but the rest of
the date was great, go on another date
with them. Do you think it's really that
like in the case of the like the Austin
Powers impression or whatever it was, is
that really the truth? Is it Was it
really that or is there something else
going on in their psychology where that
they've got commitment issues or, you
know, the
cuz I just think surely it can't be
that. Yeah. Yeah, I I think you're
right. I think when you really get down
to it, you see that, you know, there are
reasons that people will find something
wrong with a partner if they are
avoidant of intimacy.
So, you do see that. But, also I I write
about in Maybe You Should Talk to
Someone, one of the patients that I
write about is this young woman uh who I
call Charlotte in the book. And
Charlotte is somebody who is in her 20s,
she's attractive and professionally
successful, and um you know, like a
lovely person, but she keeps going after
men who replicate her childhood. And
she's not alone in that. Most of us, if
we haven't really worked through
whatever it was that that we didn't get
growing up or that we got too much of or
not enough of, what happens is we end up
seeking out the familiar. We end up Our
unconscious has Our subconscious has
radar for people who are like the person
that hurt us in childhood because it's
our experience of love. Even if it
wasn't a positive experience, it's the
only experience that we have had of
love. And so, the imprint that we have
is, "Oh, that's love." So, what happened
for Charlotte was she would meet
somebody and he would seem very
different from her parents. Her mother
was very depressed. Her father was very
kind of either
very present for her or then abandoning
her. And um
he also drank too much and had alcohol
issues. So, she would find somebody. She
would think, "Oh, this person's so
different from either of my parents."
Then she'd get to know him and realize,
"Oh, wow, he drinks a lot, too. Didn't
realize that." Um except her
subconscious did. Like, she somehow had
radar for that person. Or, this person
yells a lot, too. Or, this person's
really inconsistent with me. They're
either love bombing me or they're
disappearing and I never know where I
stand with them. That was her experience
of her father. So, if Once she really
kind of processed what happened with her
family, she started going out with
different kinds of people. Meaning, she
started being attracted to different
kinds of people. In that transition
period, she was like, "Oh, I'm going out
with this person, but I'm not He seems
really good for me, but I'm not really
attracted to him." That was because she
was still attracted to sort of the
father and the mother, the different
qualities, the victimy mom and the and
the unavailable mom and then the dad who
was kind of inconsistent with his
availability and also his temper and his
drinking. So, it's interesting to see
that she would date people just like
that without realizing it at first that
she was choosing them. So, I think that
one thing that therapy can really do for
people is to help you see, why is it
that you're having trouble meeting
someone? Why is it that you're having
trouble once you're in relationship with
someone, if you get that far,
maintaining that relationship or finding
someone who's good for you? If you sat
down with someone who had repeatedly
made the choice to date and have
one-night stands with people that were
clearly
going to hurt them or were clearly not
going to call them back the next day,
but they had this pattern of continually
going for people that were clearly
either not interested in them or saw
them as like a one-night stand
transaction.
What would your assumption be about that
individual's
backstory? You know, I hate to make
assumptions, but I would say in general
what I would probably find would be that
this person um
is terrified of intimacy.
This person doesn't feel that anybody
will love them. They feel unlovable.
They feel like nobody would would want
to be in a relationship with them. So,
it's you can't fire me, I quit.
Right? So, it's I'm not even going to
put myself in that position. I know this
is going to be a one-night stand. I
don't have any expectations. I'm
empowered, right? This is the story they
tell themselves is, "I'm so empowered
that I don't have to feel. I don't have
to get attached. Look at me. I I am
above my feelings." But, the thing is
they're really terrified of their
feelings. They're terrified of being
attached. They're terrified of seeing
whether somebody can love them.
Because they're worried that they're
going to get what's confirmed uh by
somebody else, which would be the
confirmation would be, "Oh, look, I
tried. I got attached to this person and
they didn't reciprocate it. Or, we dated
for a month and then they broke up with
me. So, see, that proves that I am
unlovable."
And that doesn't prove anything. It just
proves that this person was not the
right person for you. Where would you
start with trying to help somebody that
was in that situation? I would go
straight to the the question of
lovability. I would go straight to the
question of, you know, what would it be
like to feel your feelings and how
terrifying is that for you? To feel
attached to someone, how scary is that?
To feel like they are the arbiter of
your worth. And how can we switch that?
So, when you go on a date, it's not will
they love me, but am I interested in
them?
Do I want to spend time with them? So,
it's not about am I going to be chosen,
but I get to be the chooser. What is
that like? Because that person has never
been able to be the chooser. And yes,
sometimes you will choose someone who
doesn't reciprocate that, but you also
get to choose someone. Sometimes you
will choose some You someone will choose
you, but you don't reciprocate that. So,
you just you know, so it's not the this
person is not saying, whoever you go out
with, they are not determining your
worth, that you know what your worth is,
no matter what happens. And I think you
really have to work on the self-worth
part and where the story came from
because we all come into therapy with
narratives about ourselves. And there's
stories that someone told us about
ourselves, either verbally they told us
like, "You're not good enough. You're
not this enough. You're not that
enough." Or, they told us with their
actions like they they weren't nurturing
to you. They didn't love you in the way
that you you saw other kids being loved.
And so, you took in the story of I must
not be lovable. Jumping back to
something you said earlier cuz I was
thinking about this the the the disc the
general disconnect amongst men and women
these days. You used the word feminism
earlier. Mhm. There's been a lot of
changes in societies'
expectations and um views of the role of
a man and a woman
in a relationship, but more broadly in
the workplace and society. And this has
caused a lot of
interesting dynamics that I think might
be having a an impact on
um people's expectations and the amount
of satisfaction in dates.
Some of the studies I was looking at
ahead of your arrival today was one
study that shows that 71% of people say
it's very important for a man to be able
to support family financially, to be a
good husband or partner, but by
comparison, only 32% say it's very
important for a woman to do the same
thing and that's Pew Research survey.
Um but also, another study that said
this is on Sage Journals that men showed
less attraction towards women who
outsmarted them.
And when you look at the changes in
income and intellect, in 1980, women
earned about 60% of what men did, but by
2020, that had risen to 83%.
Um there's obviously still issues with
gender pay gaps and and such, but what
we're seeing here is the kind of macro
trend is that women are more educated
and have more money.
The expectation that a man is going to
be the provider in the household still
persists.
And men don't want to date again,
speaking generally, according to some
studies that show attraction
preferences, women that outsmart them.
Right. So, the the interesting thing is
that
when people say, you know, I want I want
to have flexibility, meaning a lot of
women will say this. I want to have
They'll say, "I absolutely expect that
I'm going to have a career,
but I also don't want to be the sole
provider for the family."
Um and if they're really honest, a lot
of women will say, "I would like my
husband to earn more than me." At the
same time, more women are getting
college degrees. More women are getting
graduate degrees. More women are getting
ahead of men in those areas. And so,
women will also say, "And I want someone
who's as educated as I am." But, there
aren't as many men, just number-wise.
So, if there are more women who are
educated, meaning college, graduate
school, than men, but those women want
men who have those degrees, they're not
the There's low inventory of men who
have that. And so, there's a There's
sort of a problem with that.
Um and so, what I really want to
encourage people to do is when they're
dating, and this is not about lowering
your standards, it's about saying to
women, there are lots of kinds of
intelligence. So, you Yes, you want to
be with someone who is equally
intelligent,
but that doesn't mean that they have the
same degrees that you have. Who do you
want to talk to? Who do you have
interesting conversations with? Is this
causing an issue for successful women
that are that are over 30? I was reading
an article, I think it was in the
Washington Post, where um a lady was
interviewing another lady who'd written
a book called, I think it's called like
The Gender Gap or something, and they
concluded that much of the reason why
successful women above the age of 30
were struggling in dating is because of
this issue that men don't want to be
with a woman that is like better than
them, and it's somewhat emasculating to
a man.
And so, I I've had lots of private
conversations with very successful
women. I know for men a lot of
successful women that are very
exceptional in their relationships, but
I've also got a small cohort of women
that tell me
that they're struggling in dating
because they're too successful and men
don't like it and are emasculated. Is
that true? I think there's this
narrative in our culture that
women are Women who are successful are
not finding men because they're focused
too much on their career, and I think
that's absolutely false. I think that
when you are out there in the work
environment, you are meeting men.
And that's where you're And you're
meeting other people, you're meeting
other women who maybe are married and
their husbands have friends. You're out
there in the world and people are seeing
you. So, I think And also, you have
meaning and purpose in your life and
you're doing something you enjoy, and I
think that that's very attractive. I
think that there are, you know, I think
that people
are wanting someone who can not live
their work,
which is different from being
successful.
And because you want a partner who's
also available to you, but I don't think
that it's because women are too focused
on their careers that that's what's
happening. I think it's because of this
gap that the women who are maybe
achieving certain things in the world
are not finding men who are achieving at
the same level, and so they're not
They're just aren't enough men for those
women.
The numbers just don't work out. And so,
then there's this question of
as a woman who is a very high-achieving,
do you have to be with somebody who is
high-achieving in the same way?
And that's a very hard cultural shift
for a lot of women to make. And the
other problem is that when
high-achieving women want to be with
high-achieving men, a lot of those
high-achieving men are not great
partners. And that's the thing that So,
so they might be dating a lot of
high-achieving men, and they maybe they
are finding them, but then they find
that this person doesn't have time for
me, or this person isn't really
nurturing, or this person is, um you
know, married to his job, and I don't
like that. I think it's hard when you
have two people who are extremely
focused on their professional lives, and
neither one of them has time for the
relationship. So, I'm not saying, you
know, there are a lot of relations where
that works really well, where both
people are very focused on their
careers, but they also understand each
other in a way that helps them.
And then there are the relationships
where you have two very high-achieving
people, and they both expect that the
other person is going to be more
involved in the relationship to help
them support their own career, and they
can't because they're supporting the
their career. So, you can't You can't do
both. Yeah, just with this stat in mind
that 71% of people say it's very
important for a man to be able to
support a family financially to be a
good husband or partner.
If we get to the point a point, which is
kind of the the trajectory we're on,
where women and men are earning the
same, women already have more sort of
college degrees than men by about, I
think it's roughly about 10% at the
moment, roughly.
We're going to find ourselves where,
yeah, expectations
for what a man can offer are really,
really high, but reality is really low,
and then you that it feels like that
the amount of women that are not finding
what they want is going to continue to
increase.
And the amount of men that don't feel
like they are good enough for a woman
because they're not smart enough, they
don't have enough money, they can't
contribute in the same way, is also
going to increase. But then also, with
general working dynamics, we're seeing
that people are getting married later
and later, they're having less and less
kids.
So, are you at all concerned about this
trajectory? Yes, very.
Um because I think it leaves a lot of
people who really want a partner and and
could really enjoy having a partner who
maybe is different from what this
cultural norm is,
they don't go after that. So, a woman
will say, "Oh, I'm not going to even go
on a date with this guy because he's not
successful enough."
Um you know, "We're too different." And
a man, on the other hand, might say,
"I'm not going to even go on a date with
her because she's so focused on her
career, or, you know, she Or I'm not
good enough for her." So, they they
don't even get a chance to even see if
they might be a good match. And And
sometimes it's a great match because you
don't necessarily want two people who
are exactly the same. And I see this all
the time with couples who come in for
couples therapy, where they thought that
what was so good about the relationship
when they first got together was, "We're
so the same." And then they find that,
"Wait a minute, but there's no one here
to be more of the nurturer, or there's
no one here to spend more time with the
household, or there's no one here to do
more of kind of the logistical things in
the house because we're both doing
exactly the same job."
I was going to say, isn't that sort of
essential to the equality narrative that
you should share the responsibilities?
Right. So, equality doesn't mean that
you have exactly the same
responsibilities. It means that you feel
that there's not a power dynamic. So,
equality means one person doesn't have
more power than the other person, but
that doesn't mean that, you know, I do
laundry 2.5 days of the week, or 3.5
days of the week, and you do laundry 3.5
days of the week. Maybe someone only
does their Their responsibility is the
laundry. That doesn't mean that there's
a power dynamic. It means the other
person maybe they're always doing the
dishes, or whatever it is. It doesn't
have to be split up in this way. So, I
think that when people think about
having an egalitarian marriage, we're
talking about that there's not a power
differential, but you still get to
choose. Like, a woman might say, and I'm
being stereotypical here, it might be
the man, but often it's the woman who
says, "You know what? I want to do I
want to switch to part-time with my
work." So, that doesn't mean she has
less power in the marriage because he
makes more now because he's working
full-time. It means that they've divided
up things differently because that was
their choice.
That was That was something that was
chosen. It wasn't like, "You can't
work." It was, "I would like to do
less." Do you tend to see issues unique
to relationships when a woman is earning
more than a man? Yeah, I do. I still
think this is something that is is very
primal for us around, um you know, what
it means. I think that women sometimes
feel resentful. That's why they want to
be with someone. It's funny because a
woman can be making a lot of money, and
she won't even go out with someone who
makes the same amount. She has to go out
with someone who makes more, which is
interesting because she won't
necessarily say that. I think it's hard
to acknowledge the contradictions. And I
think for men, the same thing, that a
man will say, "You know, I want a woman
who has her own life. I want somebody
who is doing something in the world that
is important to her, but I don't want
her to make more money than me." It's
hard to say that out loud. This comes
out in couples therapy where people
start talking about, "Wow, there is this
difference." And maybe it didn't even
start out that way. Maybe it started out
where he was making more, and then
things shifted, and then she started
making more, and it changed something in
their dynamic. And so, they start
fighting a lot, but they're not fighting
about that. They're fighting about all
different kinds of things, and so it
comes out in different behaviors, and
they come to couples therapy saying,
"We're having a We're fighting all the
time, or we're not having sex, or here's
what's happening." And it turns out it
was really about this issue of who has
power now.
But they didn't realize it was about
that, or they weren't willing to kind of
look at that. Do you think it's getting
increasingly harder to know what the
role of a man and a woman are? Cuz I
think, you know, I I've had so many
conversations on and off this podcast
with people who
uh have sons or daughters. It's often
the the ones that have sons. I'm
thinking about a lady that I know, and
she says she's so confused by what to
tell her son a man is these days. And,
you know, when I think about suicidality
and how how much of a a big killer it
is, especially in the UK, I I know it's
a sort of a Western trend, but uh I
think it's the biggest killer of men
under the age of 45 is themselves. I'm
thinking, you know, there's often a
narrative that that's because
masculinity is changing, they're not
being masculine enough. And then there's
another narrative that says, "No, it's
because they're not being feminine
enough."
What's typically associated with sort of
feminine traits? Yeah. Well, it's true
that more men die by suicide than women
do, and some people say, "Well, that's
because the method that men choose is
more lethal." But I also think that
that's only part of the story because
when men do come into therapy, they they
truly, truly feel that conflicted about
exactly what you said, that I don't know
how to be a man in today's world. It
used to be much more clear. Now, I'm not
saying that was a good thing that it
used to be much more clear because there
were all kinds of power dynamics that
that weren't so healthy for men and
women. But I think now what men are
saying is, um you know, I maybe don't
want to be the person solely responsible
for, you know, like I would like my
partner to also bring in some income,
but, you know, that creates all kinds of
problems, or I want to be able to,
again, open up to and talk to my partner
in this way, but I'm afraid that it
makes her feel unsafe. So, so what do we
do? What what does it mean? And and I'm
raised so I could say I'm raising a boy
who is now 18 years old and even things
like, you know, does he still pay? He
always wants to pay on a date and then
some people don't like that. And he
thinks, well, I'm just being I'm just
being sort of chivalrous or, you know,
but but there are all these ways in
which you don't know sort of like what
is expected of you. So, it's like if he
pays, then some people take offense. If
he doesn't pay, then some people take
offense and he just doesn't know what to
do. You know, like how much of these
things that I feel are being sort of the
role of a man in a nice way. Like
protecting, taking care of,
will be offensive to some people because
they see it as kind of a power dynamic.
So, what is the role of the of a man?
It's really unclear. I mean, that's the
thing and I think that that it really
needs to be discussed and that's where I
think there's hope is that when people
can actually say, "Hey, I'd really like
to pay on this date and, you know, if
she says, well, I don't feel comfortable
with that." I think a question is,
"Okay, that's fine. You we can split it,
but I want to let's talk about why." And
to be able to talk about, you know, what
are what does this mean that I pay? What
does that mean to you? You know, I think
a lot of people would say, "Oh, well, it
means like, you know, that that you
expect something back from me. You
expect, you know, that that we're going
to have sex or you expect, you know,
whatever these old ideas are."
Yeah. And and I think that we need to be
having these conversations. That's my
point is that it's not so important that
we that we know what it means. It's more
important that we know what it means to
the person that we are interested in.
What does it mean to them? It's going to
mean something different to everybody.
So, if we can't talk to this person that
we're interested in about what it means,
then we're just going to both people are
going to be mired in confusion. Yeah,
I'm a bit of a old school romantic, as
they say. My my partner, she has a a
great job. She has her own money.
But I just absolutely feel the need to
open up every door for her, pay for
every bill for her. I would absolutely
not have it any other way. Maybe that's
cuz I'm insecure or something, I don't
know. But I just
I watched my dad do it for my mom
and it's like hardwired into my DNA that
my role is to
protect, take care of, do everything I
can to support and if she
I I yeah, God, I I
I really struggle with her paying for
me.
And she's got her own money. She's she's
got her own business, her own job. But
have you talked about it or it just
worked out that way? She never said she
never said, "Can I pay this once or can
I
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. She pays she pays. You
know, she's she it's like a bit of a
competition. She'll like sneak off to
the bathroom and pay and stuff. But
generally I I think it's I've always
wanted to do that on dates and I I
think, you know, if you sat people down
and asked them the question, you go on a
first date with a guy
and he asks to split the bill or he asks
you know, he doesn't immediately pay,
Mhm. would that be an ick for you? Would
that turn you off them? That would be a
huge ick for me. Yes. Even for you it
would be? Yes. Yes. If you go on a first
date with a guy and he didn't pay? Yes.
Would you
Absolutely. Why? It's hard to articulate
because and this is what people, you
know, will say all women will say of all
ages.
I think for my age we grew up with that
was the expectation. I think for younger
generations maybe it's not the
expectation, but I think a lot of people
still like it or want it. Mhm. There's
something there's something about it
that that says, I really
I really valued our time together. I
care. I'm interested. Mhm. It's a way of
signaling interest, but I think even if
the person isn't interested and you're
never going to see each other again,
it's just a nice gesture. Mhm. But I
don't have any any rational
way of explaining why.
And if and if I were to get rational
about it, I would talk myself out of it.
Yes. I think that's a very honest
answer. And then the counter sort of
rebuttal to that means okay, so if men
are expected to pay, then
we're going to need more money. Yes.
Yes, and it gets very expensive to date.
Yeah, really does.
I mean, you know, people will say, "Oh,
you can go on a hike. It doesn't doesn't
cost anything. You can do a picnic. You
can,
you know, watch a movie." There are all
kinds of things you can do, but the
reality is it's kind of like I remember
that that old Chris Rock joke in the
first 3 months of a relationship you're
not you, you're the ambassador of you.
So, you know, you want to impress
somebody. You're you're trying to show
interest in somebody.
But I do think there is that that really
primal
need for safety that is gender based
that we don't like to talk about or
acknowledge, but that I think women
really I think if if somebody doesn't
pay on a first date if a guy doesn't pay
on a first date, I think a lot of women
don't feel safe. That's what it comes
down to. It's a it's a tricky world and
it's getting increasingly trickier it
feels, you know. It it feels like an
insult almost that the person doesn't
pay. Not many people. Some people would,
but no one would really publicly say
that though because it's like not
socially acceptable to say that you
expect them to say that. But in private
conversations, of course, everyone I
know is that if they went on a date with
with a man, so in a heterosexual
relationship and the man either asked to
split the bill
or to or suggested that you might pay,
Mhm.
this person's not going to get a second
date. Of course not. No.
No, unless it was the woman who said,
"Oh, no, let me split that with you."
But if he it was his decision
and he said, "Oh, let's split this." Or
he put it in the middle. No.
No. I I I in therapy the young woman
came to me recently and she said she
went out with this guy and they went to
a cafe and they got
coffees.
And he
uh
asked her to split it. Coffee.
And she said and she was having so much
fun on the date until the bill came.
And she was shocked and she thought,
"Okay, well,
she made it was very personal to her. At
first she thought, I must he must really
really have had a horrible time with me
to have want to not pay for my $5
coffee."
And then he asked her out again. And she
said to me, "I don't understand this at
all. So, he was interested in me and he
didn't pay for my coffee."
And she did not go out with him again.
So, these are the kinds of signals that
it it very much is emblematic of
something.
Who pays on that first date? Do you
agree with that decision that she made?
100%.
And I I didn't say that as her
therapist. It's really about
understanding it for her, but but I I do
agree with that decision and I and I
think it's because
there's something there's something
like a half note off
about a person who doesn't even see that
it's a $5 coffee and you're interested
in this person
and she wasn't making any moves to pay.
She was just sitting there for a very
long time and the the she said, this is
the way she told the story was that the
person came around and couple times and
said, "Are you ready?" And the guy said,
"Oh, no, we're not ready yet." And then
at a certain point he said to her, "Oh,
do you want to
put your credit card down, right?" to
her. And so, she just said I could never
go out with somebody like that.
Even though they had a really good time
before that.
So, if we zoom back out then, Mhm. so is
are you saying that that is a
tell tale sign of a broader character
issue that this individual has cuz
earlier you said that we really should
be focusing on like character traits. Is
that a red flag of some kind of other
character trait? I think that when
things are hard in the beginning, that's
not a good sign.
So, I think that when there's like a big
disconnect in the beginning, that you
should pay attention to that. So, a a
big disconnect is not he, you know, the
example I gave earlier of, you know, he
said yes to the tap water. Mhm. That's
different from he didn't pay for my
coffee. That's that's different. The tap
water might be, "Oh,
I don't know. Is he is he cheap? I don't
know. Let's see. Let me get to know him
better." This is
this is about generosity.
They're different things. And so, you
know, I I feel like relationships, I
always say to people when they when they
overlook things in the beginning, I
think there are two camps on this.
There's the people who think everything
is a red flag that's not like the tap
water, not a red flag. But there are
people who don't pay enough attention to
the red flags in the beginning. So, they
say, "Yes, this person they kind of
disappeared for a couple days and I
didn't like that and, you know, but but
or they they were they're late all the
time or,
you know, whatever it is. It doesn't
necessarily mean it's a deal breaker,
but it's kind of a
a flag that you want to discuss early
on. So, what what happens is if you
don't discuss it is a person will say,
you know, after they're now they're in a
relationship and they've been dating for
several months and and and they're
moving along and the person says, "I
can't stand it when you're late every
time." Mhm. And he says, "Why is this a
problem? I've always been late. Why is
this a problem now?" Mhm. Right? So, if
you bring it up early before the cement
dries. So, you know, I always say
relationships are like cement that
there's room for things to move in the
beginning before things kind of really
get hard and difficult to change. But
once the cement dries, it's much harder
to change those habits or those
interactions or the dance that you're
doing with the other person. So, if you
don't like something in the beginning,
you might want to bring it up to see how
much wiggle room is there here. Can this
person
be more aware of being on time because I
don't like sitting there for half an
hour every time we make plans.
We're getting married a lot less and
we're getting married
later later. Yeah, so there was a stat
that I I found that said
for the first time ever,
people over the age of 30 have been
haven't been married in high numbers
than ever before. So, yeah, marriage is
getting later and later in people's
lives. But, I also found this really
interesting graph, which I printed out,
which shows that there seems to be an
optimal time to get married.
Yes, I was just going to mention that.
That there's a window. So, I'll put it
up on the screen for anyone that's
looking, and I'll put it in the
description below.
But, it essentially shows that if you
get married after 30,
Mhm. you're more likely to get divorced
than if you got married between 25 and
30. Right. So, there's a sweet spot. So,
if you get married too young,
you're more likely to get divorced.
Meaning, if you get married sort of
under 20, I think it's 22 or 23, Mhm. um
but if you get married over, I think
it's 28,
you have more likelihood of getting
divorced. So, this study, which I have
in front of me by the Institute for
Family Studies, says there is an optimum
age to get married if you want to
statistically avoid a chance of divorce.
And it seems to be around ages 25 to
30-ish. Someone who marries at 25 is
over 50% less likely to get divorced
than someone who weds at age 20. Mhm.
Before the age of 32 or so, each
additional year of age at marriage
reduces the odds of divorce by 11%.
However, after 32 years old,
um every year increases your chance of
divorce by 5%.
And I couldn't figure out why.
Oh, I think there are several reasons
for this. So, first of all, I think it's
sort of obvious about marrying too
young, that you you don't necessarily
have the skills, you aren't really um
established in your own life, and uh you
don't necessarily have the maturity to
do what you need to do to be in that
kind of relationship for the long term.
You also don't really know who you are
yet. And so, you might think that you
want a certain kind of life, and you
find out your partner wants something
very different. But, once you get into
your mid-20s and even sort of later 20s,
it's an optimal time because you have a
better sense of who you are, um you know
more of what you want, and you can grow
together
as a couple.
And I think that's really important.
You're going to have more shared
experiences. You're going to know more
of each other's families. Your parents
are probably still alive on each side.
Um you're going to get to know each
other's siblings, if you have siblings.
You're going to be more integrated into
each other's lives as you get older.
First of all, you're more sort of set in
your ways. You're We talked about
rigidity earlier. You're more rigid.
Um you have different expectations. I
think when you're younger, you're more
flexible in terms of uh just being more
open-minded. We get less open-minded,
generally, as we get older
um around relationship, around the
things that we expect.
And we also have a history as we get
older. So, we have more negative
experiences
of maybe heartbreak, being broken up
with, breaking up with people, um
relationships that didn't work out that
then inform the way we behave in our
relationships. And I like to say it's
almost like we're we're punishing our
current partner for a crime they didn't
commit. So, if you were in a
relationship before where maybe you were
cheated on or someone didn't treat you
well, then you are less trusting of the
partner that you're with, or you're more
on guard or more closed off because
you're worried you're not going to get
treated well. So, it's almost like the
the more dating experiences that you
have, some people would think,
counterintuitively, they would think, um
you know, if I have more dating
experience, then I'm going to be a
better partner later on. But, often
because those were not great dating
experiences, sure you might have learned
something in them. But, if you have too
many of them, it's good to maybe have a
relationship or two before you get
married, but to have five, um it's
harder, right? Because you have all this
baggage that you're bringing in, and the
other person, who's also your age, has
all this baggage that they're bringing
in. And there might also be something
It's kind of like if a fight breaks out
in every bar you're going to, maybe it's
you, that maybe you are doing something
in relationship, and that is why. It's
not that you haven't been able to meet
someone, it's that you've been pairing
up with people in a way that is not
really healthy. So, you and you haven't
spent the time to really figure it out.
So, you're just going to keep repeating
and repeating those not-great
relationships. Even if you marry the
person, it might not last because
something has not been working in those
last five relationships, and you haven't
figured that out yet.
In your TED Talk, you talk about
part of getting to know yourself is
getting to unknow yourself.
Why do we have to get to unknow
ourselves?
Well, I think that so many people think,
I'm going to come into therapy, and I'm
going to learn so much about myself. And
you do, but part of learning about
yourself is learning what the faulty
narratives are that you've been carrying
around, whether it's I'm unlovable, or I
can't trust anyone, or I'm no good at
this, or this thing is wrong with me.
These, again, are stories that you
picked up about yourself from a long
time ago. And it might not even have
been your parents, it might have been at
school. Maybe you were bullied in
school, or maybe you were in an
environment that maybe you had ADHD, and
you were told you weren't smart because
people didn't realize that you learned
differently, and you actually are quite
intelligent. So, you have these stories.
So, it's to unknow. People will come in
and say, "Well, I'm not that I'm not
really smart." Well, you have to unknow
that because that might not be true.
Let's find out.
So, it's really, you know, I it's
interesting because I was a writer long
before I was a therapist, and I still am
a writer, but I use so much of of
writing and narrative in the therapy to
kind of help people edit their stories.
Let's look at, you know, is the
protagonist going in circles, or is the
protagonist moving forward? Who are the
supporting characters, and and do the
major characters need to be more minor
characters in your life, and do some of
the minor characters need to be more
major characters, and and
what is going to be the next chapter?
How do we look at where the story is
going? So, a lot of this is unknowing
stuff about the character, which is you.
You know, if you come up with a
character as a writer, and you say,
"Well, this person's not very smart, and
they're kind of weird, and they're
unlovable."
Well, you're going to write the story a
certain way thinking the character has
those traits. But, if you say,
"Actually, this person's quite smart,
and they're quite lovable, and they're
quite attractive." Well, you're going to
write a different next chapter for them.
I've always, on that point about sort of
narratives we've written, I've always
considered myself to be
very productive.
Maybe the more honest answer is a bit of
a workaholic to some degree. I think
that my work is fundamentally
attached and associated with my own
self-esteem.
So, I think when I'm working really,
really hard, and I feel really
productive, I think at some deep level,
I think I'm worth more, or I'm like I
fit in. It kind of it goes back to when
I was younger and I felt like I didn't
fit in. It feels like I'm more valuable.
Now, the problem you have as an adult
when you're trying to achieve a
different set of goals, like have a
healthy relationship, is this kind of
gets in your way. And I I think I found
that in myself, that I still have this
urge to be really successful and work
really hard because at some level it's
making it's doing something for my image
of myself.
But, as I get older, I kind of need to
figure out a way to drop that down a
little bit, or else I'm going to miss
out on something that's going to make me
happy, which is relationships. And a lot
of people that I speak to, a lot of
people that listen to this podcast, are
in a similar situation where they just
can't get off the train in terms of
their work. Yeah. Yeah, so we were
talking about defense mechanisms. And
so, one of the defense mechanisms is
where you take something that comes from
an unhealthy place, and you put it into
something that looks on the surface
healthier. So, I don't feel worthy, uh
or as worthy as I would like to, so I'm
going to succeed in this incredible way.
So, on the surface, it looks great. It
looks like you're doing something really
healthy. But, actually, you're not
really working on that self-worth piece.
Another example might be um somebody who
has a lot of anger, and they take up um
boxing, right?
Mhm. Um or they become a surgeon because
they cut into people. You see this a
lot. Um where somebody takes their
anger, so they put it into something
that looks healthy.
But, they're not really dealing with the
underlying issue, which is the anger.
You see that a lot, that people that
have anger issues sometimes take up
roles like surgeons? Sure. Yeah. Really?
Yeah. Anything where you where you can
do Again, boxing, it could be anything
where you where you're putting it into a
socially acceptable container
as opposed to dealing with the issue.
So, there's nothing wrong with being a
great surgeon. There's nothing wrong
with being somebody who succeeds in work
that they love. But, then what happens
is
when you're not doing the thing that
gets the societal approval, then where
does, you know, what do you do with in
one case your anger, and the other case
your self-worth? And so, I'm glad that
you're looking at at the self-worth
piece because that's going to be
important because you're not always
going to get it from your work. How do
you improve your self-worth? What would
you do with a patient like me?
I would you know, I I think it's we we
do this on the podcast where we do
something very practical, where we have
people make a list of the things that
other people would say So, there's two
columns. There's one, what would other
people say are your best qualities that
have nothing to do with your work? Okay.
What do they appreciate most about you?
And then, what do you appreciate most
about yourself that has nothing to do
with work that you think other people
don't see? And when you when you start
to look at those, they're very quiet at
first. You know, people don't have a
long list. They're kind of like, "I
don't really know." And and I'm looking
for really tiny things like this person
really appreciated that when they were
sick I called them.
This person really appreciates that I'm
funny, that I make them laugh. I
appreciate that about myself, you might
say, right? You might say like I really
appreciate that about myself or I
appreciate that I can be calm under
really stressful circumstances.
Um I appreciate that I um
I notice my partner.
And I do nice things for my partner. I
appreciate not my partner appreciates
that, that'll be on one column, but the
other column is I appreciate that about
myself. So looking at how can I pay more
attention to some of these areas that I
I don't pay enough attention to because
I can only see the real shiny thing out
there, which is how many people, you
know, how many millions of people follow
me or how many people um you know,
download the podcast, those kinds of
things. And is there a reason why okay,
the reason why you separate work from
that is because you're trying to find
your self-esteem in other places outside
of the work. Right, so it's both and.
It's not to say don't get don't don't
feel worthy because of what you do with
your work. That's a big part of what we
do with our lives. Think of the number
of hours that we spend in work. We're
spending most of our days doing work. So
of course we want to get self-worth from
that. But we also want to know that we
have other areas in which we are worthy.
And that we don't pay enough attention,
we don't give ourselves enough credit.
It's kind of like in a relationship,
there's a statistic about the bank of
goodwill. So in a healthy relationship
there are that we think of deposits of
how many positive interactions do you
have with your partner to how many
negative interactions do you have? And
so you want to have 20 positive
interactions for every one negative
interaction
in a relationship.
Hm. And when things are not good, you
want to have you you know, you you hope
you can do five positive ones to one
negative one.
But that's that's a lot. So it's it's
really noticing. These are these are
small little deposits that you make.
Like I held I I took my partner's hand
when we were walking down the street.
You know, those are like small positive
interactions. You're not counting them.
It's just a way of being. But what
happens is when your self-worth is all
in one bucket, you don't notice. You're
not making enough deposits to yourself
of into the self-worth bank. So it's it
really is about noticing what are the
deposits that I'm making. So I'm making
a lot of deposits in the in the work
bucket, but I'm not making a lot of
deposits and noticing that was really I
really liked that. I was really funny in
at that dinner that was really fun. Um I
was really kind to that stranger on the
street. That was really nice of me.
Do you think that some people are scared
to go to therapy because they think
if they are to heal from something,
whatever that means, it will rob them of
something that they value. I if I go to
therapy and I work through my childhood
trauma, then maybe I won't be as
ambitious or successful or driven etc. I
think the fear is I will have to change.
I will have to change and I will have to
do something different and I might not
like that. Hm. And that's why people are
like if I go to therapy and I take off
my mask and this person sees the truth
of who I am and I see the truth of who I
am, I might need to do something
difficult and I might need to get rid of
one of my defense mechanisms like I'm
avoidant maybe, right? Or I'm or I might
not be able to um you know, to do things
that maybe I get away with that are not
very healthy
because they're easier.
In your book you you say something in
your new
book
maybe
you should talk to someone. You say
something that really surprised me,
which is that sometimes when someone
changes, those around them will sabotage
them and basically get in the way of
that change because it changes the
dynamic that that relationship has with
a person. And I mean we see this
generally when someone becomes
successful for example, their friends
from their hometown might be a little
bit resistant because they want to keep
the dynamics the way that they are. But
the examples that you talk about in the
book about like, you know, someone gets
over their alcohol addiction and then a
friend might sabotage them by I don't
know, giving them alcohol or taking them
to a bar. Yeah. Which is really really
striking. Yeah, that happened with
Charlotte in the book when she realized
that her drinking was a problem. She was
the young woman who's in her 20s and was
dating and she realized that she drinks
too much and it's really affecting her
life and her functioning. And so she
decided that she was going to do
something about that and then when her
she was having a birthday party and her
friend said, "Oh, let's do it at this
bar." And she said, "No, I'd rather do
it at this other place because I don't
want to be in that environment." And her
friends were just like, "You're no fun
anymore." And you don't come out with us
anymore. But the but the real issue is
that she was holding up a mirror without
realizing it to her friends because they
were saying, "Oh, maybe we aren't
drinking in a healthy way." And they
didn't want to look at that. So if they
could get her to go back to the old way.
You see this in couples a lot. When one
person decides they're going to get
healthy in a certain way. Like I'm going
to start exercising and the person
starts exercising and the other person
doesn't exercise at all and they're
really unhealthy and that person says,
"Why do you get up early and go to the
gym? You're no fun anymore. You know,
you're obsessed with exercise." When
they're not, they're just going to the
gym in a normal way. And really they're
feeling threatened. They're like, you
know, this is changing the dynamic
between us cuz we used to be both unfit
and now my partner's looking really
healthy and hot and now it's really
clear that I'm not really healthy and I
don't look as good as I could look. And
maybe I'm going to have to do this and
they don't really want to, they're
resistant to doing that. And the
partner's not asking them to do to go to
the gym. They're saying, "I'm going to
the gym. You do what you want." But
there's this
implicit pressure
of I have to look at myself. That's why
people again don't come to therapy is
because I'm going to have to look at
myself and maybe make some changes that
are healthier and I'm not sure I'm ready
to do that yet. And I write in the book
about the stages of change because I
think it's so important that people
understand that New Year's resolutions
for example, don't often work because
people think I just decide this thing, I
have this goal, I'm going to do it and I
either succeed or I fail.
And that's just not true. There are
these stages that people go through and
it starts with precontemplation where
you don't even know you're thinking of
making a change. And that's usually like
if your partner starts exercising you
didn't realize that maybe in the back of
your mind that that was something you
had been thinking about but weren't
ready to deal with. Contemplation is you
know you're thinking about making a
change but you're not ready to do it
yet. That's usually when people come to
therapy. They're thinking about it but
they don't really they're not really
ready. Preparation is when you you start
to get ready, you're preparing, you're
you're maybe getting a gym membership or
you're taking an anger management class
or whatever you're doing.
And then action is when you put the
change and and it might also be like
you're preparing to break up with
someone who's not good for you. So
you're getting thinking about how am I
going to do this, what are the logistics
of this? And then when you action is you
actually do the thing. You break up, you
go to the gym, you change jobs, you
apply for a job that you always wanted,
you go back to grad school, you do the
thing you wanted to do. But then the
next stage is the most important stage,
which is maintenance. And maintenance is
it's not like you're on this upward
trajectory and and if you if you you go
off the trajectory, then you failed.
It's not like that. Maintenance is how
does this become more habitual in my
life? So let's use the breakup example.
You broke up with this person, you're
having a really bad day, you're feeling
really lonely. You called them at
midnight or you texted them at midnight
because oh, I don't know, you know, like
and so now you say, "Oh, well, I better
get back in a relation I guess I'm back
in a relationship with them." No, no,
no, no, you you slipped off, it's okay.
Then you say, "You know what? I was
feeling really lonely. I didn't know how
to cope with it. I'm going to go to
therapy. I'm going to have an extra
session. I'm going to call my friend.
I'm going to watch a TV show that that
that I like. I'm going to read a book
that I like. It will feel different in
the morning. Next time that's what I'm
going to do."
And so you you have to get used to, you
know, we talked about the familiar
earlier about going toward familiar
partners. Making a change is really hard
because we're changing something that
was familiar to us. It's like when I was
in therapy um
my therapist said, "You know, you remind
me of this cartoon." And it's of a
prisoner shaking the bars desperately
trying to get out. But on the right on
the left it's open. No bars. So that's
us where we think you know, I would like
to make a change but I'm really afraid
of going outside I'm more comfortable
being in jail in this miserable
situation than knowing that I have
freedom but I have to change. I'm going
to have to take responsibility for my
life if I walk around those bars.
And so I think with change it's really
about
how do I give myself self-compassion
when I
have trouble making the change and help
myself get back on track and what kind
of support do I need. People think if I
beat myself up, if I self-flagellate, if
I tell myself I'm awful and I'm a
failure, I'm going to get back on track
because that's going to help me. No,
it's not going to help you. In the short
term it might help you a little bit, but
what's really going to help you is to
have self-compassion because that
actually gives you more accountability.
You're more able to say to yourself,
"Okay, let me think about what I can do
differently." It's kind of like if your
kid comes home from school and says, "I
did really badly. I failed this test."
Are you going to scream at them? Is that
going to help them do better on the next
test? Or are you going to say, "Let's
sit down and figure this out. What do
you think happened here?" And your kid
might say
"I didn't really understand it and I
didn't get help." Or your kid might
really be honest and say, "I didn't
study enough."
So we can say, "Okay, well, what can you
do next time? Let's kind of think about
can you make a schedule? Can you do you
need to study with a study partner? What
do you need to do?" That's what helps
people make long-term change. Is that
the wise compassion that you spoke about
versus the sort of idiot compassion,
which you talk about as well. Idiot
compassion is what we tend to do with
our friends. So, your friend says,
"Listen to what my partner, my
co-worker, my you know, my sibling, my
parent did or said." And we say, "Yeah,
they're wrong. You're right. How dare
they?" Cuz we're just validating their
perspective. And like we were talking
about in my TED Talk, there are many
different versions of a story, all of
which are true. So, you you're only
getting one narrow perspective when
you're hearing one one person's
perspective. That's why couples therapy
is so great, because I can hear the same
incident told by two different people
who were there, both of whom are telling
the absolute truth of their experience.
But they're leaving out the other
person's experience.
And that's where things get dangerous.
So, in idiot compassion, we don't
consider what the other person's
perspective might be when our friend is
telling us something. We just back up
our friend. But they're not learning
anything from that experience. It's And
And when you hear them over and over,
you kind of get a sense that maybe
they're doing something. Like an example
would be
um
your friend keeps getting broken up
with. And
we can say, "Yes, these men are jerks.
They're terrible. You deserve better."
Or we can say, "You know, I think that
sometimes you're a little bit too
possessive early on in the relationship,
and I think they start to feel
overwhelmed, and then they break up with
you. But if you could just hold your
anxiety a little bit more at the
beginning of the relationship and not be
so
overwhelming to them, that you might
develop something different the next
time. That would be wise compassion.
That's what they're going to hear in
therapy. So, in therapy, we hold up a
mirror to them and help them to see
something about their role in the
situation that maybe they haven't been
willing or able to see.
And so, we think we're being a good
friend by offering idiot compassion, but
we're not actually helping our friends.
And that's where therapy I think could
be really helpful. When you sit with a
man and a woman in a therapy session, do
you typically find that the woman
expresses more emotion
tears than the man? Sometimes, yes,
often.
I also think that emotions can be used
as manipulation. So, an example is
uh a pattern in a relationship might be
that he brings up something that he
wants to talk about. She cries because
of what he said.
And he said it nicely, but it's
something they need to deal with.
And she cries, and then he gets
terrified by her crying. He thinks, "Oh
my gosh, I've hurt her."
And so, then he shuts down.
And so, really her crying is a
manipulation. It's a I don't want to
hear anything that I'm {quote} doing
wrong.
And so, I'm going to shut that down by
crying and being the victim and being
hurt. Being a victim is actually a power
position, because you are making it
impossible for anyone to deal with
whatever is going on between the two of
you. Because now you're the victim, and
now they look like a horrible person if
they're making you cry. So, I will call
that out in therapy, and I will say,
"You know what? He's going to talk,
and we're going to do something
different. He's going to be able to say
what he wants to say. She might cry, but
if she cries, I want you to please go
on. She's going to be fine. I'm going to
be here with her,
and you don't have to manage her
feelings. You're going to tell her about
your feelings. I will be here to help
manage her feelings." Mhm. Interesting.
And you see that if you're not in
therapy, you'll see that pattern where
it's just, you know, someone will play
the victim in the relationship. And it
could go either way. It could be anyone
in the relationship. But when someone
plays the victim, the other person
actually becomes the victim. They become
so helpless in the relationship. The
true victim is the person who has to
interact with the person who plays the
victim. Dreams. Something I was quite
surprised to find in your book, but
pleasantly surprised. Yes. Do our dreams
have meaning, or are they just random? I
think both, but I I think that dreams
are really helpful. And in the book, I
do give examples of dreams where dreams
are often
kind of a story that we tell ourselves
that we aren't giving ourselves
permission to think about when we're
awake. So, an example might be somebody
who has been who is worried that they
have been doing something financially
that is not legal.
They have a dream that they were
speeding on the highway, and they got
caught.
Well, what is that dream really about?
It's this I don't really want to think
about this thing that I'm doing that's
not quite above board, and I know I
shouldn't be doing it, but I'm not going
to think about that. Um you know, the
dream that that I have in the book,
where so I come into therapy because of
a breakup, and um and I have a dream
that I ran into my ex,
and uh
and it's this very elaborate dream, but
the the point is that in my first
therapy session, I had said to my
therapist when I was talking about the
breakup, I said, "Well, half my life is
over." And he really glommed onto that
statement that that was really why I was
in therapy. What was this about for me?
It wasn't so much about the breakup. The
breakup got me into therapy, but this
whole question of what am I doing with
my life and how I'm living my life, and
this question of mortality was really
what was on my mind. And so, in the
dream,
I think I see that he has a new
girlfriend, and I see that she's older
than me, and I feel very self-satisfied
by that in this petty way.
And then I look at myself in the mirror
in the dream, and I'm like this
80-year-old
wrinkled person.
And I realize, "Oh, this is really about
this fear that I have about getting
older and that half my life is over."
And so, dreams really do inform our
biggest fears and our biggest
preoccupations that feel too
scary to think about in our waking life.
And if we pay attention to our dreams,
and what I mean by that is, when you
wake up and you remember your dream, if
you write it down immediately, but you
write it in the present, not we were
here and this happened, but I'm here and
I see so-and-so, and so-and-so says to
me. If you write it in the present, it
will bring back more of the dream for
you, and it will help you understand
what connection it has to something that
you really do need to be dealing with in
your life that you're probably not
dealing with.
Dreams can be a precursor to
self-confession. Yes, that's what I say.
Self-confession. They can tell you
things about yourself before you're
willing to admit them about yourself
into yourself. Yes, and and and it's so
liberating. I think that there's
something about the safety of a dream.
Sometimes our dreams are really scary,
but you wake up and you say, "Okay, now
I can deal with it. Now that I've
acknowledged it to myself, I can deal
with it. In the dream, I just had to go
with the flow of the dream. But now I
can actually make choices about what I
want to do in my waking life." At the
beginning of each therapy session, um
you'll often ask your patients to
describe their last 24 hours. What Why
is that useful
to know what someone's been doing for
the last 24 hours? I think most of us
don't realize how we spend our time. We
have no idea. If you said to somebody,
"You spend 3 hours a day scrolling on
Instagram," they would say, "No, I
don't."
We don't realize And I think that at the
end of the day, most of us want to live
our lives with intention.
And what I mean by that is, I think that
knowing that life has a 100% mortality
rate, that all of us
has a limited time here. We're living on
borrowed time. That's not to freak
people out. It's to make people say,
"How are you actually spending this
borrowed time that you have here?"
Because one day you might look back and
wonder why. And I always say that regret
can lead us in one of two directions. It
can be a way of self-flagellating and
living in the past, or it can be an
engine for change.
And I really think regret is the most
powerful engine for change. I regret
that I lived my life this way. So, if we
don't realize how we are living our
lives, we don't have the engine for
change. In that chapter 24, you say the
opposite of depression isn't happiness,
but vitality. Yeah, that's Andrew
Solomon that I'm quoting there. Um and
I thought that that really struck me
when he said that in his own book, in
his own TED Talk, because I think that
people think about, "Well, I'm either
happy or I'm sad."
And And
I think what we're There's no You can't
be happy all the time.
There's no such thing. You would never
know any other emotion if that's all you
were feeling.
So, I think that that vitality is what
people are looking for in life.
What is vitality?
It's a sense of aliveness. Okay. And
this is why people have affairs, by the
way.
Often, when you ask people, "Why did you
cheat when you love your partner?"
I didn't feel vitality in my life. I
felt this sense of aliveness and a
wokeness when I was with this other
person.
And it wasn't had not much to do with
the other person, and it really didn't
have much to do with your partner. It
had to do with you didn't feel vitality
in your own life. And instead of looking
at yourself and saying, "What can I do
to create vitality in my life?" I blamed
it on my marriage. I blamed it on my
partner. I said I was going to find it
with this other person. And what they
find is, yeah, that works for a little
while, but not very long. Does menopause
play a role in this in terms of I heard
a a stat from um someone that was on the
podcast previously, where they said
postmenopausal women, but also women
going through menopause, will often
divorce their partner because they um
have a lot of sort of
psychological
doubts about themselves, and they maybe
their expectations I think someone said
to me that their expectations go up. So,
they end up divorcing their partner
because they're clearer on what they
want now.
But I was just wondering what role
menopause will play in someone's
marriage and their expectations, their
view of themselves, their chance of
maybe getting a divorce. And if you see
anything in therapy associated with
this?
I think what menopause does is it goes
back to this idea of I don't have
forever here. And if they weren't happy
with the marriage that they were in,
then I think people really wake up and
they really say, "What do I want in my
life?"
It's a It's a very There's a lot of
psychological changes that come with.
It's not just the hormonal changes, but
it's what does that represent? That I am
done with that chapter of my life. And
I'm now I'm I'm, you know, halfway
through. Again, half my life is over.
And what do I want to do to more
intentionally? Because often women have
been serving others.
So, that's what they've been doing.
They've been taking care of other
people's needs, whether it's their
partners or their children or their
parents.
Um, you know, they tend to be the
caretakers.
And now they're saying, "Wait a minute.
I only have this much time left and I
really want to find that vitality in my
life." You went to therapy because of
heartbreak. Yes. I've been through
heartbreak. Who has not? It's one of the
It's one of the worst feelings in the
world. And it's it's really hard to give
someone advice when they're going
through heartbreak. I had a friend reach
out to me recently and said, "Listen,
I'm going through a heartbreak and I
just don't know what I who else to turn
to. It's this big dark cloud that hangs
over everything I do, think, and say
that just won't go away." What have you
come to learn about heartbreak from your
own experience, but also from your your
patients? How do we navigate through
that dark cloud?
I think what people don't understand
about heartbreak is the grief.
And And so, this is why I talk about it
so much in Maybe You Should Talk to
Someone because it's not just that you
lost the present with that person. It's
that you lost the future that you had
created in your mind. So, you're losing
the daily-ness. There's something
really profound about the person you
tell all the minutia of your day. The
person you you know you know so much
about each other and you know each
other's habits and quirks. This again,
being understood, being truly known.
That's such a delicious feeling, being
truly known.
And so, this person knows like what you
what kind of pizza you like or or, you
know, this quirky habit you have or what
TV shows you watch or that that thing
that you do with your eyes when you're
excited. They know all those little,
seemingly, trivial details that are so
important about being known. And they
know your history and they know about
your family and they know who your
friends are and they You've had shared
experiences with this person. So, you
have all that history together. Even, by
the way, if it was only 6 months. Mhm.
You have a lot together or a year.
And so, in that time you started to
imagine
"Oh, and then this is going to happen
next year and then in 5 years this will
happen or we're going to grow old
together." Whatever you imagine will
happen. And you become attached to their
friends and they attached to your
friends. And then you lose the
daily-ness of being known, you lose the
bigger circle that you had, and you lose
the companionship, you lose the physical
connection.
You lose all of that, but you also lose
this idea of what was to come.
And so, every day you're living in this
future that is radically different from
that day as it would have been if you
were in that relationship. So, it's very
hard. People think, "Well, how's it been
this long? How come you're not over this
person?" It's kind of like the same
thing when um
you know, someone has a breakup instead
of a divorce.
People think, "Well, it's not that big
of a deal." Why? Why is it less of a big
deal? It's still loss and grief. Or um,
you know, it's like when if if someone
loses a child, everyone surrounds them.
There are all these rituals for How do
we help people through that kind of
loss? Someone has a miscarriage. People
are like, "Well, you can still get
pregnant again. At least you got
pregnant, you know." Or the the the
things There's a chapter in the book
called What Not to Say to a dying person
because one of the patients that I work
with in the book is um is somebody who's
a young person in her 30s who is is new
newly married and then gets a cancer
diagnosis. And people say the most
well-meaning, but ridiculous things to
her. And so, I think the same thing
happens in heartbreak where people try
to minimize it, they try to cheer you
up, they they won't sit with you in your
loss. And that's what you really need is
someone to sit with you in your loss and
to acknowledge how profound the loss is.
And people don't do that. They don't
They either don't see how profound it is
or they do, but they they feel like,
"Well, we don't want the person to
wallow in it or if I bring it up, you
know, they're going to be worse." No,
what they need to be seen and actually
that's going to make them better and
it's going to make them heal faster.
What impact did it have on you? The way
people reacted or The heartbreak.
The heartbreak.
I think for me it was a big wake-up call
again around this idea of half my life
is over and what do I want in my life
and why was I willing to overlook
certain things in my relationship that
were clearly there,
but that I didn't want to see.
And how
did you go about recovering is not the
right word. Moving forward.
How did you go about moving forward?
That's That's the whole narrative of the
book. Um, I went to therapy and it's
really about what I learned about myself
in therapy that that helped me heal and
helped me move forward.
I was thinking about the uh the advice
that I could give to
my friend and how I could have been a
better support act cuz my natural
disposition is to try and fix. And from
what you've said, that's not necessarily
the best approach to take.
It You know, cuz my my natural um
inclination is to go tell them the
future will be better. Mhm. Share my
experience of my heartbreak. And those
are all good because as a therapist, I
want to hold hope for somebody who's
really really dealing with a difficult
situation, whether it's a breakup or
something else. I want to hold hope that
they can't access. They can't access any
hope at that point. So, I'm going to
hold the hope for them.
But I'm not going to try to cheer them
up. I'm just going to be the container
for that hope. So, that they know that
someone else is holding that hope. So,
you did two things really well. One was
that you shared your experience so that
this person knows this happens. This
person isn't alone in this. They Cuz I
think when you go through a heartbreak,
intellectually, you know other people
have gone through it, but you feel like
yours is so much worse than anybody
else's.
And so, to know that that you went
through it, too,
and here's what helped you. Mhm. And it
also took time and it sucked and all of
those things. And then I know that it
will get better even if you can't see it
right now. To let them know that piece.
I know it will get better for you even
if you can't see it right now. And the
third But the So, those are the two
things that that went well. The third
thing, though, is to be able to sit in
the grief with them.
To say, "Tell me about how things are
different for you. Tell me what you
miss. Tell me" And people think, "Oh,
they're just going to stir up all the
stuff. They're just going to ruminate.
This isn't helpful."
You need to give them a place where they
can feel understood. And you can say One
strategy that might be helpful is you
can give yourself 30 minutes a day
to go through all the things you miss,
everything that sucks, how horrible it
is. You get that 30 minutes so that the
rest of the day they're not ruminating
cuz every time they catch themselves
thinking about it, they say, "Wait a
minute. At 6:00, I get to do this
non-stop for 30 minutes." And so, if you
can hold it, you're you rewire your
nervous system neurologically. This
actually happens. Where
that pathway gets interrupted. If we can
put a stop sign up between the feeling
and the behavior, which is the
rumination. I feel sad. Oh, now I'm
going to ruminate on this. We put a stop
sign up and say, "I get to go there
later." Then later, when we start having
more of these feelings, we have a stop
sign that we're used to now. Now we're
wired that way. So, we put more time
between the thought and the rumination.
As you know, Whoop are sponsors of this
podcast and I'm an investor in the
company. And last month I had the chance
to sit down with Kristen Holmes. She's
the VP of performance at Whoop and I
learned so much from our conversation
about circadian rhythms and things like
sleep. Studies show that for every 45
minutes of sleep that that you accrue,
that your decision-making ability will
drop by up to 10%. And when you're
chronically under-slept, you'll only be
a fraction of the person, the fraction
of the boss, partner, friend, manager
that you can be. That's why I'm obsessed
with Whoop, which not just tracks, but
coaches you on how to get better at
sleep so you can bring your best to
everything that you choose to do. If
you're not convinced, you can try Whoop
for 30 days completely risk-free with
zero commitment just by going to
join.whoop.com
/ceo.
That's join.whoop.com/ceo.
And let me know how you get on. If you
don't like it, there's no commitment.
join.whoop.com
/ceo.
On on the point of heartbreak,
at
the deepest human level,
is it about You know, you talked about
the the bigger picture, the loss of the
future, etc. in the past.
Is the fundamental reason we have
heartbreak as a device built inside of
us because we are creatures that need
connection and it's a mechanism to make
us stay connected and avoid becoming
disconnected? You literally could not
survive in early societies without being
part of the group.
You had to belong. If you did not
belong, you couldn't survive. You
wouldn't get food, you wouldn't get
shelter, you wouldn't survive. So,
belonging is just hardwired in us. It's
It's something that keeps us alive.
And we actually do need it to stay alive
even now. And what I mean by that is you
take for example when they did these
studies and they looked at babies who
were in orphanages and they thought all
they need is they need they need food
they need you know they need to get they
need to be fed they need to be nourished
they need to have their diaper changed
they need those things. These babies
didn't develop and many of them died.
It's called failure to thrive because
they weren't held.
They weren't held. They needed love.
They literally died from lack of love.
They just they couldn't they couldn't
survive no matter how much you could
they just stopped eating. They
failure to thrive. They wouldn't meet
their developmental milestones. This
happens this happens in really traumatic
childhoods even. Um so you actually
cannot live without love. You need some
kind of love. It doesn't have to be
romantic love but you need love.
So we need that. So our main goal in
life is to love and be loved. We may
think it's about success and it's about
appearance and all the things that we
see on social media. We may think that's
what life is about and everything that
our culture sells us but ultimately what
we need is we need love. We need to love
and we need to be loved. And so when
that gets cut off we forget that we have
other people who love us.
Um we forget everything else everything
just feels extremely
black or white.
It's like I I was loved and then I
wasn't loved.
And that's how it's going to feel for a
little while.
Mhm.
It's scary. It's scary because so much
of your work is centered on connection
at like the fundamental level and we're
living in a world that feels like it's
getting more and more disconnected than
ever before.
Um if you go back a couple of decades
young people used to see their friends
once a week or twice a week about about
80% of peop- people did. Now it's
getting down to about 30 40% which is
really really crazy.
I did a talk on stage the other day and
and there was five 600 people in the
audience and a kid sat to my far bottom
left here raised his hand and his
question in front of 600 people was
essentially I'm lonely and how do I make
friends?
Mhm. He sat in a room with 700 people
that are his exact age and he's asking
me in front of all of them which I I
respect.
He's asking me the question how do I
make friends? A lot of people ask that.
A lot of men come up to me and whisper
it to me at talks. They'll say it to me
so they'll they'll make cuz we film a
lot. They'll come up really close to me
and and basically express that. They'll
say it in my DMs. How do I make friends?
Yeah. I get that all the time to the
podcast to the column. That is one of
the most frequent questions is I'm
lonely how do I make connections how do
I make friends from younger people
especially but older people too and I
think that it's really frightening
because when I watch my son who's 18
um
people think look going back to your
graph that they are quote seeing their
friends because they're sending pictures
of themselves back and forth on Snapchat
to their friends and they think that
that's socializing but it's so
different. We learned this during COVID
that there's such a difference between
being in a room with someone
and you know being mediated by a screen
but they're not even having
conversations like you would if you were
with your friend. Things happen you have
shared experiences you're doing things
together conversation just more
naturally flows. Um they're literally
you know they're sending texts to each
other that are just emojis or you know a
picture of this. They're not really
learning. So it's not just how do I meet
friends but it's how do I be in
friendship with someone? And it's hard
because a lot of people aren't
interested in doing that. Like if you
said at that age you know let's hang out
sometimes people will but really more
people are just
on their phones 24/7 and they think
they're super social but they're not.
It's like the difference between
vulnerability online and true
vulnerability. So a lot of people in
fact I was just on Instagram and I saw
somebody saying
I'm going to be so vulnerable. I see
this all the time. I'm going to be so
vulnerable with all of you and share
this thing and
all their followers say you know that
was so brave and and lots of heart
emojis and all of that. That's not
vulnerability to put that out on a
public platform. True vulnerability is
what this kid was asking you which is
when you are face to face with someone
if you're with your partner or a close
friend or a family member and you want
to share something you need in the
relationship or something that you feel
shame about or something that is scary
for you to take the mask off and
and share with somebody. That's true
vulnerability because the stakes are
high. What is this person going to think
of me again going back to I need to be
loved. We all need to be loved. What is
this person going to think of me? How
will they love me if they know the truth
of who I am this thing that I'm about to
share?
Very different from sharing it on
Instagram or
TikTok or whatever. So I think that it's
really important that we as adults look
at how much face time do we have face
time in person time do we have with
people? Are we really prioritizing that
and are we modeling that for the next
generation? What would you have said to
him? Cuz what I ended up saying to him
cuz it really took me off guard. No one
had asked me that obviously in front of
a huge group of people. I said to him um
what you've just done
do more of that. And what I meant by
that is he had been so vulnerable and
open and I've come to learn that
vulnerability in and of itself is a
magnet not a repellent that we think it
is. So I I said do more of that but I I
thought maybe that's not the best
possible answer I could have given him.
I love that answer. That's a great
answer. I also might have said um turn
to the I want everybody in this room to
turn to the person on your right
and introduce yourself to them
and ask them about one thing that they
want you to know about them. Because
that's how you're going to start making
friends. We don't do that anymore.
Yeah but we can. You see they're simple
things. It's not like you know people
say it feels so overwhelming. How do I
make friends?
And they think they're going to have to
learn all these tactics and techniques
when really it's just about be curious.
Ask someone about themselves.
And the people who are receptive to that
they might become your friends. People
who aren't I'm not really interested in
them. Doesn't really matter.
Lori we have a closing feature on this
podcast where the last guest leaves a
question for the next guest not knowing
who they're going to be leaving it for.
Ooh.
Ooh this is a fantastic question.
If you had 60 days left on Earth
what would be the first and last thing
that you'd do?
Mhm. Hug my son.
No question.
It's simple for me.
There are so many things that I would I
would like to do but I think that if you
read maybe you should talk to someone
you'll see that what I did was I made
sure that I'm already doing the things
that I want to do now
instead of putting them off for later.
So there's nothing that that I would be
doing in these 60 days that would be
drastically different from what I'm
doing now and I think that that's where
I'm trying to get people in therapy is
to live the life that you want to be
living now so that you don't when you
get these questions about if you only
had 60 days left you're not like I would
do things entirely differently. Why?
What are you waiting for?
We shouldn't have to wait.
Lori thank you so much. Thank you for
writing a book. There's this quote on
the front of the book which I think
perfectly encapsulates
how many people will feel if they
get this book which is rarely has a book
challenge me to see myself in an
entirely new light and was at the same
time laugh out loud funny and utterly
absorbing. It's a quote by Katie Couric
on the front of the book. And the
remarkable thing about all of your work
is that it's both so incredibly
accessible
but it it's so clearly built on real
world experiences that I think so many
people can relate to and you really tend
to focus on the fundamentals of a
problem not the things that just appear
on the surface. And an ability to get to
the fundamental of the problem I think
is a really magical thing to be able to
do.
And I just wish there was you know I
would
I wish you could be everyone's therapist
but I think the book can be if you can't
be because you only have a certain
amount of time in the day. It's really
really remarkable the mission that
you're on and how many people you're
serving by your column by your podcast
by the books that you've written um and
everything that you continue to do.
Thank you so much. Appreciate it.
Thank you.
[Music]
Let's talk about Zoe who you may know
because they're a sponsor of this
podcast and I'm an investor in the
company. You guys know health is my
number one priority. Zoe's growth story
has been absolutely incredible so far.
They're doing science at a scale that
I've never seen before. Because of their
numbers and recent breakthroughs in
research they can now continue to offer
the most scientifically advanced gut
health test on the market. Previously
the test allowed them to analyze 30
bacteria types in your gut but now
thanks to new science they've identified
a hundred bacteria types. This is a huge
step forward and there's nothing else
that's available even close to it on the
market at all. So to find out more and
to get started on your Zoe journey visit
zoe.com/steven.
You can use my exclusive code CEO10
for 10% off. Don't tell anybody about
that okay? Just for you guys.
[Music]
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This episode features renowned psychotherapist Lori Gottlieb, who discusses the complexities of modern dating, relationship dynamics, and personal growth. Gottlieb emphasizes that people often struggle in relationships due to unrealistic expectations, such as wanting a partner to fulfill every emotional need. She highlights the importance of character traits like emotional stability, flexibility, and generosity over superficial requirements. The conversation also covers the challenges men and women face in navigating shifting societal roles, the necessity of being understood in a relationship, and the value of self-compassion when dealing with heartbreak and change.
Videos recently processed by our community