I can’t believe they put ads there
205 segments
Well, welcome back to the channel and me
talking about Microsoft. Now, I know
this is turning into a weekly ritual
where uh Microsoft is going to do
something stupid and then we're going to
make fun of it on this channel. But
today, it was so bad. It was so
unbelievable. I actually didn't believe
it. When I saw it, I said, "No, no, no,
no. This is one This is It's almost
April, fools. Okay, it's almost April
1st. I'm not going to fall for this kind
of gag." Okay, this is one of those
little foreplay, a little pre-warmup to
the actual big game on April 1st. Not
this time. Not me. But I was wrong. This
is in fact not a joke. This is in fact
Microsoft doing perhaps the dumbest
thing I have ever seen Microsoft do.
And this says a lot. This says a lot
because a this same company also had a
remote code execution vulnerability
added to Notepad. Yes, Notepad. the
thing in which has not changed since
1995 only for the last year to start
changing it and then immediately become
a security vulnerability. Thanks Notepad
team for that markdown vulnerability.
Just a just a real winner from all of
us. All right, enough with the yapping.
Let me show you the news line that kind
of caught my eye. Microsoft Co-Pilot is
now injecting ads into poll requests on
GitHub. If this does not send a shiver
down your spine, you have no soul, my
friend. Okay, you need to go. You need
to go bathe in HOLY WATER. STOP. JOEY,
STOP THE RECORDING. HEY, HEY, HEY. It
turns out news has changed so fast I
couldn't even get this video out. So,
yes, there actually was what appeared to
be ads inside a poll request being made
by Copilot or even being lightly touched
up by Copilot. And yes, the feature or
the feature has already been pulled.
Okay, so to kind of show you what it
looked like and why everyone thinks it
looks like an ad, this is what it says.
Quickly spin up a co-pilot coding agent
tasks from anywhere on your Mac OS or
Windows machine with Raycast. Now,
Raycast does make a lovely product.
We've actually done a little partnership
and made some coffee for them way back
in the day. I can't imagine that Raycast
was probably too happy to see this
so-called definitely not an ad placement
on everybody's PR that co-pilot touched.
Like, no. Seriously, look at this. After
a team member summoned Co-Pilot to
correct a typo in the PR of mine,
Copilot had edited the PR description.
It included an ad for itself and
Raycast. So, you could imagine there was
some people, you know, panicking a
little bit. Okay, people were a little
bit uh shocked at what they were seeing.
So, in just a few hours, it ended up
that 11.4,000
PRs had this extra definitely not an
advertisement added to it. In
Microsoft's defense, to be fair, they
also had a hidden comment that said,
"Start Cop-ilot coding agent tips." I
mean, these guys legitimately thought
that this felt like a tip and definitely
not an advertisement. Really? Third
party link and everything. And it also
sounds just like it just Yeah, I can't
tell why. Why would uh why would this
sound like an ad? I'm just telling you,
yo, you could quickly just spin stuff up
with our partners at Raycast. But
swiftly, pretty early on in the day, it
turns out that they disabled it right
away because the product tips were just
supposed to be little helpers, but then
apparently it just spread everywhere.
Our goal was to share novel ways to use
C-Pilot coding agent. And in this case,
we highlighted our integration with
Raycast as part of a broader set of
product tips, but this was surfaced more
frequently than intended alongside other
feature suggestions. See, the thing is
is I may have a bath towel on, but
underneath every good bath towel is a
tin foil hat. I'm not even sure. I I
honestly I'm not even sure if this is
actually the truth or if they were
trying out something that was a bit
experimental because as of right now,
GitHub is uh they they're kind of down
bad. Okay, they've had 90 incidences in
90 days, giving them a total of 90.84%
uptime. They do have three nines. It
just happens to be in the amount of
incidences, the amount of days, and the
amount of uptime kind of spread equally
between them all. Also kind of fun side
story. If they screw up one more time,
they'll have more incidences than they
have percents of being up. [laughter]
Dude, you got 5 days, Git not to screw
this up, okay? You have to make it all
the way past January 5th. See, the thing
is is that I actually I I do feel bad
for a lot of the people working on
GitHub. Uh because we've all
accidentally made some oopsy daisies.
Like, if you haven't done something
stupid in production, honestly, are are
you even a programmer? No. That's
because programming actually turns out
to be quite difficult. And it does turn
out that implementation in fact does
matter. But I think the thing that
really just gets all of us devs is we do
see this uptime. I mean, you can't go a
day or two without seeing a unicorn for
a little bit on GitHub. And yet, what's
their focus? Their focus is on
increasing co-pilot usage. That's what
this was. This pro tip was really just a
means to increase more co-pilot usage
such that some VP somewhere can get that
pat on the back and that big, you know,
seven figure bonus for making the
company's bottom line get bigger because
they're doing what the company needs
more of, which is AI adoption instead of
just doing what everybody actually wants
them to do. Quit fumbling the bag on
GitHub. This is one of those rare
moments where I I genuinely do feel we
are watching the downfall of something
that I just I could have never been
convinced would have fallen down. I
think the saddest part about this whole
thing is I just got done sitting down
with someone who formerly was at GitHub
during, you know, the heyday of GitHub,
the 2012 to 2018 era. And he was talking
about how GitHub's engineering was
really excellent. They had some of the
best uptime. They're providing a service
everybody could use. And when Microsoft
took over, he just knew right away like
this this is the end of that era. We are
entering into a new era in which people
will not look at GitHub as the shining
star, but instead it's going to become
the lol cow of the dev world. And it's
this message that just perfectly
encapsulates everything. They're still
ad nauseium pushing AI features while at
the same time not prioritizing the
things that actually matter to devs on a
platform specifically designed for devs.
So, even though this definitely not an
ad, just happened to be mentioning a
third party and completely looks like an
ad, is definitely not an ad, is being
cancelled, it just makes me realize just
how out of touch Microsoft truly is. And
again, the reason why GitHub is under
the core AI of Microsoft is because it's
not going to be a coding platform, it is
an AI platform. And as much as I don't
want to believe that, this right here
just reminds me completely where the
real priorities are at. The name is I
can't believe you interrupted my shower
time. Look at I was so I mean look at
this. I have some beautiful Oh my Oh my
gosh. Uh I It's getting deep in there.
By the way, you're wondering why I'm
hunching over funny. It's It's all
coming undone. This is Okay. This shower
setup is meant to be a personal and
intimate experience, not meant to be
shared on the internet again. Hey, is
that HTTP? Get that out of here. That's
not how we order coffee. We order coffee
via ssh terminal.shop. Yeah. You want a
real experience. You want real coffee.
You want awesome subscriptions so you
never have to remember again. Oh, you
want exclusive blends with exclusive
coffee and exclusive content? Then check
out Cron. You don't know what SSH is?
>> Well, maybe the coffee is not for you.
[music]
Living
dream.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The video discusses a recent controversy where Microsoft's Co-Pilot was caught injecting promotional content, which many users viewed as ads, into over 11,000 GitHub Pull Request descriptions. The content promoted both Co-Pilot and Raycast. Although Microsoft quickly pulled the feature and labeled it as 'product tips,' the speaker criticizes the company for prioritizing AI metrics and adoption over the actual stability and reliability of GitHub, which has suffered from significant downtime and numerous incidents recently.
Videos recently processed by our community