HomeVideos

Property Brothers Talks Housing Affordability, New Show | Bloomberg Talks

Now Playing

Property Brothers Talks Housing Affordability, New Show | Bloomberg Talks

Transcript

262 segments

0:02

Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts,

0:05

radio, news.

0:07

>> Pending home sales here in the US seeing

0:09

a surprise uptick in February as

0:11

mortgage rates fell to their lowest

0:13

since 2022. It's a good backdrop for the

0:15

new HGTV show from the Property

0:18

Brothers, Drew and Jonathan Scott. That

0:20

show is called Property Brothers Under

0:22

Pressure. It just premiered on Sunday

0:24

and it's a deeper look here not just

0:25

into the homes but really into the home

0:27

buyers themselves and how they navigate

0:29

a competitive market and make budget

0:31

conscious decisions for their new homes.

0:33

I had a chance to sit down with them

0:34

exclusively earlier today and talk about

0:36

the state of the housing market and

0:38

their journey to HGTV stardom. Take a

0:41

listen.

0:44

It's

0:44

>> unlike anything we've ever done because

0:45

people always ask us, "Well, what

0:46

happens when the cameras aren't rolling?

0:48

What happens behind the scenes?" We show

0:49

it. We show we You see our crew. you see

0:52

us disagree. You see moments that the

0:54

homeowners, you know, I think it's very

0:56

relatable for everyone out there because

0:58

there's so much pressure on everybody.

0:59

>> Well, in an affordability crisis like

1:01

there is across the country here. The

1:02

stories, we have 14 episodes and they're

1:04

all very different stories. Uh we have

1:06

families who have lost their house from

1:07

the the fires in in LA. We have other

1:10

families that are trying to pull two

1:12

families together to live in one house

1:13

because that's the only way they can

1:14

afford. We have so many stories that

1:16

will be very relatable for Americans

1:17

watching. And we're trying to solve with

1:20

really tight budgets. for trying to

1:21

solve what everybody out here is trying

1:23

to solve to be able to get a home that

1:24

they deserve.

1:24

>> We talk about the evolution of HGTV and

1:27

just these types of programs. It used to

1:29

be more about the homes themselves and

1:31

they are becoming a lot more about the

1:33

people uh and what they're going

1:35

through. And you know, here at

1:36

Bloomberg, we've talked a lot about the

1:38

affordability crisis in the housing

1:40

market and particularly out west where

1:42

where you guys do a lot of your work. I

1:43

am curious if you've seen any sort of

1:46

movement in maybe a sort of a future

1:48

where you have real starter homes, real

1:51

affordable starter homes for people in

1:53

some of these markets.

1:54

>> There's definitely been a lot of

1:54

movement. Unfortunately, it's in the

1:56

wrong direction. We have, you know,

1:58

about a 4 million short house shortage

2:01

of healthy inventory right now. And the

2:04

challenge is people don't seem to

2:05

understand that we need affordable

2:08

housing. any successful city in the

2:10

world that has embraced affordable

2:11

housing, the cities have flourished and

2:13

the costs have come down. But I love the

2:15

idea that people can live where they

2:16

work. And I think some people hear

2:18

affordable housing, they think, well,

2:19

that's going to be, you know, drugs and

2:21

crime and everything. Absolutely not.

2:23

These are teachers and uh, you know, uh,

2:26

nurses and police and, you know,

2:28

household pe workers, people who want to

2:30

live in the same community that they

2:31

work. And so that's our our goals from a

2:33

messaging standpoint. Show people that

2:35

it's okay. You don't have to be a nimi.

2:36

you don't have to stop projects that are

2:38

being built, you know, in your

2:39

neighborhood. On the flip side, we've

2:41

invested in companies like modular

2:42

builders. So, we're trying to find new

2:44

technologies that will physically bring

2:45

down the cost of construction. At the

2:47

same time,

2:47

>> in the hard time though, too, because

2:48

there's a lot of talk about rate cuts to

2:50

help, you know, government trying to

2:51

stimulate, but the problem is when you

2:52

have no inventory, cut rates if you

2:54

want. That gets people excited to buy,

2:55

but if there's nothing to buy, you're

2:56

not really solving the problem. We need

2:58

to find ways to incentivize or make it

3:00

um possible for developers to really

3:02

focus in. For example, we I have a real

3:04

estate portfolio in Calgary in Canada.

3:06

the government in Canada really

3:07

incentivizes builders to do affordable

3:09

housing. So, it makes it worthwhile and

3:11

I can keep rolling money from one

3:12

project to the next to the next to

3:13

actually make a difference. Down here, I

3:14

don't have that same opportunity.

3:16

>> Where do you see potentially where those

3:17

incentives come from? Obviously, in a

3:18

city like New York, affordable housing

3:20

has been a huge topic of conversation.

3:22

It pretty much swayed our most recent

3:24

mayoral election. I'm sure out west

3:26

where you guys are, whether it's

3:28

California, Vegas, Vancouver, you're

3:30

also seeing similar issues there. Are

3:32

you seeing things at the state level or

3:33

the local level that could potentially

3:35

alleviate?

3:35

>> Well, one of the biggest things is I

3:36

think federally there needs to be better

3:38

policy that allow and incentivize uh

3:41

builders and developers to pull out more

3:43

cash. So, for example, in in Canada, if

3:45

you create a certain amount of

3:46

affordable housing units within your

3:48

building that you can finance up to 95%,

3:51

whereas here, not even close. And so, a

3:53

lot of builders are leaving 40% of their

3:55

cash in a building and that prevents

3:56

them from building forward. Also on the

3:58

building side, if we're you if you're

4:00

using uh you know, say you're building a

4:02

building for easy figures, $20 million

4:04

building, if you do that as an

4:06

affordable building using uh public

4:08

funds for some of that construction,

4:10

there's all this regulation that all of

4:12

a sudden the cost is about 40% more just

4:14

to do the exact same building. So I

4:16

think we're getting tied up in, you

4:18

know, the minutia and we're not stepping

4:20

back and looking at the fact that we

4:21

haven't seen rapid enough growth to

4:23

solve the problem uh when it comes to

4:25

actually supplying inventory and it's

4:26

also adding density again there there

4:28

are different areas that are doing great

4:30

things but when you can add some some

4:31

more density even in California so for

4:33

example my house I'm allowed to have two

4:34

suites I can have two ADUs which is

4:36

great cuz I could rent both those out

4:37

and it's helping with the crisis however

4:39

the backlog to get to that point one of

4:42

my my ADUs it should have been approved

4:44

in a week I wait to 5 months and there's

4:46

such a backlog and the process is so

4:48

archaic. We need to revitalize the

4:50

process to get people moving to add

4:52

density. This is one of the things where

4:53

I'm hoping that AI is actually helpful

4:56

because the bureaucracy behind trying to

4:59

wait through the planning process.

5:01

Anyone who's taken on a renovation knows

5:02

how annoying it is to wait on your

5:04

permits, wait for the city, also wait

5:06

for the utilities to go through and

5:08

process everything. I would love to see

5:10

something that automates a lot of that

5:11

to make sure that the, you know, eyes

5:13

are getting dotted and the tees are

5:14

getting crossed, but you can actually

5:15

get in and do the work. And I was going

5:17

to say you this, this literally is right

5:19

now in modern uh history, this is the

5:22

absolute worst affordable housing market

5:24

in history for first-time home buyers.

5:26

Look at first- time home buyers are less

5:28

than 25% of the market right now, and

5:30

that should be a lot higher. It's just

5:32

not feasible for people to get into real

5:34

estate like it used to be. Obviously,

5:35

you've had a presence uh specifically on

5:37

HGTV now for more than a decade. Uh

5:40

you've had a lot of iterations of your

5:42

uh of your show and and obviously shows

5:43

that don't actually uh feature you two.

5:46

How much has that changed in terms of

5:48

being able uh to produce a show like

5:50

that at a reasonable cost uh have

5:53

whatever relationship you have with HGTV

5:55

and actually make it profitable for

5:56

everyone?

5:57

>> I mean, so we are one of the largest

5:58

unscripted producers in North America.

6:00

We have 15 series that we produce. We

6:02

host two of them. Um, but we we have

6:04

found a huge shift because what we used

6:06

to have for budgets for our shows down

6:07

here on HGTV or with other partners, we

6:09

don't have that anymore. So, we as

6:11

producers have to get more creative and

6:12

sometimes that means going to Canada,

6:14

greenlighting with a co-pro out of

6:15

Canada and then coming down with a

6:17

license um or or co-proing with the US

6:20

down here. So, we we're really good at

6:22

getting creative, but plus our company

6:24

stands out from other production

6:25

companies because we are up in Toronto

6:27

for our production base. that we can

6:28

actually take advantage of a lot of tax

6:30

incentives up in Canada that are great

6:31

that a lot of US producers can't. Well,

6:33

and we're also seeing explosive growth

6:34

in, you know, digital and, uh, other

6:37

forms of media, uh, you know, YouTube,

6:39

everything else. So, you know, find

6:41

trying to, we've always stayed a step

6:42

ahead. We're always looking at where the

6:44

industry is going. Right now,

6:45

television, traditional television,

6:48

>> I mean, what's the word imploding? Uh,

6:51

[laughter] everything is everyone's

6:52

uncertain. There's a lot of mergers

6:54

happening and so things are on are

6:56

paused. But that's that's what I like is

6:57

the fact that we're constantly looking

6:58

ahead. So there's enough opportunity

7:00

that we can still find placement

7:01

>> as has some of the mergers particularly

7:03

Warner Brothers being absorbed into

7:05

Paramount has that affected at all maybe

7:07

your outlook for what HGTV and Discovery

7:09

ends up being?

7:10

>> Yeah, absolutely. It's it's it's more of

7:11

a pause. That's what it is right now cuz

7:13

nobody wants to jump in a direction if

7:15

they don't know who's going to own the

7:17

company or what the focus is going to

7:18

be.

7:18

>> But if you look at Netflix, they were

7:19

only interested in studio side

7:21

streaming. They weren't interested in

7:22

linear cable. So Paramount's taking

7:25

everything. So that does mean that we as

7:27

we're the largest producer for HGTV for

7:29

Warner Brothers on the Unscripted now

7:31

will have that opportunity to do the

7:32

same with with Paramount.

7:35

Jonathan and Drew Scott there, the

7:36

Property Brothers, uh, on the launch of

7:38

their new program. But more importantly,

7:41

an interesting conversation there about

7:42

housing affordability, particularly in

7:44

the markets that they're focused on,

7:46

primarily out west and in

Interactive Summary

The new HGTV show, "Property Brothers Under Pressure," focuses on the personal challenges of homebuyers navigating competitive markets and making budget-conscious decisions. The hosts, Drew and Jonathan Scott, highlight the severe US housing affordability crisis, noting a 4 million-unit shortage and the critical need for affordable housing for essential workers, not just low-income individuals. They advocate for federal policy changes to incentivize developers, streamline archaic permitting processes, and adopt new construction technologies to reduce costs. The current market is described as the worst in history for first-time homebuyers. Additionally, the brothers discuss the evolving landscape of TV production, citing shrinking budgets, the necessity of creative financing and Canadian tax incentives, and the uncertainty caused by industry mergers and the shift towards digital media.

Suggested questions

5 ready-made prompts