HomeVideos

Better Movements: Glassman Archive

Now Playing

Better Movements: Glassman Archive

Transcript

377 segments

0:00

[music]

0:05

[music]

0:08

>> If we look at

0:11

shoulder press,

0:13

push press, and push jerk.

0:16

Whatever load you can shoulder press,

0:19

you'll get somewhere in the neighborhood

0:21

of 30% up more load up push press.

0:25

Whatever it is you can push press,

0:27

you'll get about another 30% maybe more

0:30

up push jerk.

0:33

We argue about those the numbers and

0:35

I've had some considerable variance on

0:37

where that lies, whether it's 20%, 50%,

0:40

different men, different women,

0:42

different trained, untrained.

0:44

But without a doubt, you'll get more

0:45

weight up

0:46

push pressing than shoulder pressing,

0:48

more weight up push jerking than push

0:50

pressing.

0:52

So, the loads force is definitely up.

0:56

There's a continuum here of shoulder

0:58

press to push press to push jerk

1:02

where the load is increased.

1:04

Load sits on this continuum.

1:08

Which is what? Force.

1:10

Um

1:11

if you look at the movements here in the

1:13

shoulder press, boom, the weight travels

1:15

but my body moves none.

1:18

In the in the push press, I dip lowering

1:21

my center of mass, no chest come forward

1:23

but dip.

1:25

I drive, I'm moving that mass, the body,

1:28

the load went down with me and came

1:30

back.

1:32

Then goes overhead. It's moving farther.

1:34

There's more distance, true?

1:38

You with me on that, right?

1:40

I've got distance on here, too.

1:45

In the jerk,

1:46

I go down, I come up, I go down again, I

1:49

come up. The load makes an extra trip as

1:51

do I.

1:55

Whatever your max shoulder press is

1:58

for any rep count, whether it's 1 3 5 10

2:02

rep max,

2:04

you'll move those same number of reps in

2:08

the push press in less time.

2:11

A failed shoulder press that last rep

2:14

well and I go in here on the push press,

2:17

boom,

2:18

at the same rep count.

2:23

Whatever your max load is at whether

2:25

it's a 1 3 or 5 or 10 rep max load on

2:28

push press,

2:30

for the same reps at that same load, the

2:32

push jerk will have a faster cycle time.

2:35

Bam, just quicker.

2:38

Cuz that max push PRESS WILL GO

2:42

THERE'LL BE SOME IT'LL BE SLOW.

2:45

SO, what I've got here is decreased

2:48

time on this continuum. Look Look at our

2:51

fraction again. Force, distance, time.

2:54

I've got the two pieces of the numerator

2:56

are going up. I've got the denominator

2:58

going down. What does that say for

3:00

average power?

3:02

It goes up.

3:05

In total here, what's happening is that

3:07

the intensity is higher.

3:10

The power is higher.

3:13

And what I would expect to find is that

3:15

there's this movement there'd be a

3:16

progression here of movements that would

3:19

have

3:20

greater impact on whatever favorable

3:24

adaptation I was looking for.

3:26

If I were looking to increase bone

3:27

density, I'm going to tell you that

3:29

there's more promise in the push jerk

3:31

than the push press than the shoulder

3:32

press.

3:34

If I was looking to elicit max heart

3:35

rate, I can assure you you'll get higher

3:37

heart rates at push jerk than you will

3:39

push press than you will at shoulder

3:40

press.

3:42

How about the coordination, accuracy,

3:43

agility, and balance, those neurological

3:45

components?

3:47

There's no without a doubt more

3:49

athleticism in here, more whole body

3:51

qualities.

3:52

Um I make a list, big long list of

3:55

attributes that sits on this continuum.

3:59

Athleticism, power, intensity,

4:01

uh uh

4:03

skill.

4:07

You develop a very compelling argument

4:10

that the moves are better.

4:13

Once you learn how to jerk, so it's and

4:15

that's how hard it is, once you learn

4:17

how to jerk, you will it only

4:20

insignificant loads push press. As soon

4:23

as that thing gets heavy at all and you

4:24

feel that stall, it's too easy to drop

4:26

and come back up. So, you'll find

4:28

yourself somewhere in the field.

4:30

Oh, and you won't even know why because

4:32

something in your brain felt the

4:34

lowering velocity and you dropped the

4:35

hip to lock it out.

4:37

And once you know how to push press, you

4:39

would never even a

4:40

even a little bag of kitty litter you're

4:42

going to put on a shelf, it just feels

4:43

entirely unnatural to lock out the

4:44

midsection and press. I mean,

4:47

just get it up there.

4:51

The argument for the advantages of the

4:54

push jerk over the push press of the

4:56

shoulder press, the utility of this

4:58

thing in developing athletes in

5:01

maximizing the rate of return on any

5:05

for for anyone regardless of their

5:07

stated goals,

5:10

the physics here, the physiology here is

5:13

perfectly analogous to the very last

5:15

detail in the value difference between

5:17

the kipping pull-up and the strict

5:18

pull-up.

5:22

Will you repeat that?

5:24

Yeah.

5:25

Yeah, all of the physiological and

5:27

physical advantages of the push jerk

5:29

over the push press of the over the

5:31

shoulder press is found again in looking

5:33

at the difference between the kipping

5:35

pull-up and the strict pull-up.

5:39

It's more athletic, it's more whole

5:41

body, I can get higher heart rate. We've

5:43

actually measured the two, strict

5:45

pull-ups and kip pull kipping pull-ups,

5:47

and at the higher rep ranges for greater

5:49

capacity, we almost it's almost a two to

5:51

one. So, if you've got 20 25 30 15

5:56

strict pull-ups, you'll do the same

5:58

number of kipping pull-ups in about half

5:59

the time.

6:02

Twice the power, twice the intensity.

6:05

Twice the benefit. Check this out.

6:08

When we alter the rules in a pull-up

6:10

competition, it doesn't alter the order

6:12

of of of of return.

6:15

So, the CrossFitters step into strict

6:18

pull-up competitions and win.

6:20

The gymnast default pull-up is the is

6:23

the kipping pull-up.

6:25

Only CrossFitters have more pull-ups

6:27

than than gymnasts now. It wasn't always

6:30

that way, but it's something new.

6:32

We've worked with have close ties to a

6:36

Olympic repeat medalist ring men.

6:39

And they don't have as many pull-ups as

6:40

our best guys.

6:42

Isn't that interesting?

6:44

We've kind of become the pull-up kings.

6:45

Jeff Martone, the kettlebell guru DOE uh

6:49

uh

6:50

operator, was at a did did the shot show

6:53

with his uh pull-up towers, tactical uh

6:56

pull-up structure. And he had a 90-lb

6:59

sandbag. And the whole weekend he was

7:01

there, there was nine people that could

7:02

do a pull-up with the 90 lbs. Nine of

7:04

them CrossFitters.

7:06

Now, yeah.

7:08

We do we do strict pull-ups. We do

7:10

weighted pull-ups.

7:12

We You can't clip You can't kip the L

7:15

pull-up.

7:16

The it it the inertia makes the legs too

7:19

heavy in the L virtually impossible. You

7:21

realize you you can kip one, but you

7:23

won't do the next one. You're like, "No,

7:24

that isn't going to help me." It's a

7:26

becomes apparent, makes your legs way

7:28

too heavy to kip.

7:30

We do kipping pull-ups, we do strict

7:32

pull-ups, we do L pull-ups, we do

7:34

weighted pull-ups, we rope climb. You

7:36

can't really kip there, not the same

7:38

kind of movement, but it's it's more of

7:40

a strict kind of movement.

7:43

But our default pull-up, the thing that

7:44

sits there kind of at the

7:46

at the

7:47

at the you know, peak of our of our

7:50

efforts is that it home base is that

7:52

kipping pull-up.

7:54

You want to get more strict pull-ups,

7:56

introduce the kipping pull-up and keep

7:57

practicing the strict.

8:01

But the advantage lies in the power

8:03

expression in the power output.

8:05

Now, I told you that we can

8:07

we can take a tape measure to you. And

8:09

I've got precision and accuracy. I got I

8:11

got good mil crowd here, law enforcement

8:14

crowd here. You know the difference

8:16

between precision and accuracy. Um

8:18

accuracy is by proximity to the to the

8:20

target and and the precision is the

8:23

clustering of these of these efforts. We

8:25

have greater We have great precision and

8:27

accuracy in assessing, in measuring um

8:31

the work output.

8:34

It's a Well, how do we know this? Well,

8:36

I'll measure someone's first center of

8:37

mass and travel, take five measures,

8:39

leave the room, have someone else do it,

8:40

and we look at it and we're like, "Man,

8:41

we're we're hovering around the same

8:43

mark."

8:44

The round off error, the the variance is

8:46

less than the round off error.

8:51

How accurate is your scale?

8:53

Pretty damn accurate.

8:55

Great precision as well.

8:57

How about the watch?

8:59

Pretty damn good nowadays.

9:04

So, we distill these numbers down, we

9:06

get this power output, we can certainly

9:08

very easily measure the differential in

9:11

terms of time output.

9:13

And what we end up with

9:15

is a data point

9:18

for each workout

9:20

that suggests work capacity.

9:22

And this kind of starts to look like

9:24

this. I can put time on this axis and

9:28

power here.

9:29

And what I can do is get a bunch of data

9:31

points of different modalities,

9:33

different efforts, say for 10 for a

9:35

5-second effort. That might be two pulls

9:37

on the Concept 2 rower. I can get the

9:39

power from that. It might be how big a

9:42

weight you can clean and jerk.

9:44

It might be what you max thruster. And I

9:46

can play this game across multiple

9:50

training modalities.

9:52

Use 10 different things at 5 minutes, 10

9:55

10 things at 3 minutes, 10 different

9:56

things at 5 seconds, 10 different things

9:59

at an hour,

10:00

and get this data here, get these

10:02

pieces, and find some average, and plot

10:05

a curve for your power output.

10:11

And what we know, what we can say now,

10:14

is that this area under the curve

10:20

well defines your physical capacity.

10:24

In fact, what we've come to see is that

10:27

what we're doing here, what we're

10:29

developing, is increasing work capacity,

10:31

and that's what this is.

10:33

If this height, this Y axis represents

10:36

power, and this time, the area under

10:38

here is work.

10:40

For those of you with math background,

10:41

we're integrating the power curve, it's

10:43

work.

10:44

And what we know is that what CrossFit

10:46

is doing is increasing work capacity.

10:48

Now, lock on here, this is really good.

10:49

For those of you taking notes, you want

10:50

to write this down. We're increasing

10:52

work capacity across broad time and

10:55

modal domains. It's a mouthful, but let

10:59

me break it down. We're increasing the

11:00

ability to perform work across a

11:04

multitude, multiple modalities. Row,

11:07

jump, throw, swim, run,

11:10

punch,

11:13

and across broad time domains, from the

11:14

short end to the to the to the long end.

11:18

Modal domains, by by varying

11:21

protocols, hopefully what? Functional

11:24

movement.

11:27

Thruster, clean, pull-up, rope climb,

11:31

Fran, Helen,

11:34

wrestle,

11:36

throw, it's all good.

11:38

I can measure the work.

11:44

Now, we might compare this I just give

11:46

you a for instance. I would expect

11:48

Suppose this were the work capacity of a

11:50

Greg Amundson.

11:53

I would expect a power lifter to have a

11:55

much bigger number here, and then fall

11:58

apart.

12:01

Kirk, we have Casey's Helen and Fran

12:04

times.

12:06

We know what those are.

12:09

We get these guys out past the 15, 20

12:13

seconds, and it's not pretty.

12:15

Now, here's what we would see in a

12:17

triathlete. It would start much lower,

12:19

and your hope is that it wouldn't decay

12:21

as much and sit high, but it's only

12:23

going to sit high if I test them bike,

12:25

run, swim long.

12:27

If I really expose them to mixed modal

12:30

training, if I get them out of that,

12:32

what you find is that their decay is

12:34

really not that unlike that of the power

12:36

lifter.

12:38

We have seen world ranked

12:41

uh uh triathletes

12:43

gas under a stimulus like Fight Gone Bad

12:46

or Helen or Fran.

12:48

It's interesting cuz they're they're

12:49

they're loath to to face the fact that

12:52

they've gassed.

12:54

And but uh understand, the guy's using

12:56

the bar to hold himself up.

12:58

He's got this super high ventilatory

13:00

rate. Ah, ah, ah. Lips are blue or gray,

13:03

eyes bugged out, and can't answer

13:05

questions or communicate.

13:08

Dude, you're gassed.

13:11

What they'll often tell me is, "No, I

13:13

haven't gassed." This is once they

13:14

recover and can talk again, even though

13:16

they're at max heart rate.

13:18

"The problem is the weight's too heavy."

13:20

And I go, "Well, ace, we got a solution

13:21

for that. Here, I've got a lighter bar.

13:23

Keep moving."

13:24

You get about five more reps, and look,

13:26

let's suppose it's you know,

13:28

push jerk or or

13:30

thruster. That last weight, boom, goes

13:32

to overhead, and they flag pull the bar,

13:33

and they're breathing hard. Is that

13:35

muscular failure? Last rep, pow, to

13:37

extension.

13:39

No, it it should be like, "Ah!"

13:40

We know what muscular failure looks

13:42

like. You'd never confuse Muscular

13:44

failure is

13:45

it's too heavy, and you're normal.

13:48

Gassing is when you can't talk to me,

13:49

you're breathing so hard.

13:51

I tell these guys, "You look, you're

13:53

What would you think if I went running

13:55

with you, and after a few laps on the

13:57

track, I said, 'Hey, I got to stop. I'm

13:58

clearly Look, you can see I'm out of

13:59

breath, and I'm You got that panicked,

14:01

cyanotic kind of look.' And I tell you,

14:03

'I'm not gassed, it's just the track's

14:04

too long.'"

14:06

>> [laughter]

14:07

>> It's no you've gassed. It's

14:09

obvious. It's obvious.

14:12

VO2 max is that gold standard for

14:15

aerobic capacity. It is unfortunately

14:18

highly modal specific. Highly modal

14:22

specific.

14:24

Everyone's VO2 max is modal specific.

14:27

Ours is specific to constantly varied

14:30

functional movements.

14:32

>> [music]

14:37

[music]

Interactive Summary

The video discusses the continuum of shoulder press, push press, and push jerk, highlighting how the load and complexity increase with each movement. It explains that the push jerk allows for the heaviest loads and fastest cycle times due to increased body movement and extra 'trips' of the load. The video also draws an analogy between these overhead lifts and the difference between kipping and strict pull-ups, arguing that the more dynamic movements (push jerk, kipping pull-up) lead to higher power output, greater athleticism, and potentially more significant physiological adaptations. The concept of 'work capacity' is introduced, defined as the ability to perform work across broad time and modal domains, and how CrossFit training aims to increase this capacity by varying functional movements and training durations. Finally, the video differentiates between muscular failure and 'gassing' (extreme fatigue), emphasizing that gassing is a failure of the cardiovascular system to keep up with the demands of the exercise.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts