His money is my money: modern slavery
239 segments
I'm Dr. Orion Taban and this is Psychax
better living through psychology and the
topic for today's short talk is his
money is my money. This is a not
uncommon phrase that you will
occasionally hear in the mouths of women
namely my money is my money and his
money is my money. That is, the money
that I, the woman, earn through my own
effort and labor is my own. And no man
has a right to determine to what uses it
is spent. But because I'm in a
relationship with a given man, I am
justified in assuming that at least part
of the money that he earns ought to be
deployed in the service of my own care,
comfort, and well-being. This is a
proper and expected use of his
resources. Now, this is entitlement in
the most literal sense in that such
women believe they are enacting a
natural right and that nothing could be
more reasonable and just. And I'm here
to argue that this is not in fact a fair
or reasonable expectation at all. And
today I'm going to help people, men and
women, understand why this is the case.
I don't think you've heard this argument
before. It goes well beyond a simple
question of female delusion.
To begin with, let me ask women a
complimentary question. Do you believe
that your body belongs to your man?
Like, do you believe that your man is
entitled to your body to use it whenever
he wants, wherever he wants, however he
wants? This is after all a portion of
the traditional marriage vow, you know,
the flesh of my flesh part and was long
used as an argument for why marital rape
literally was impossible as you couldn't
rape yourself. I'm willing to bet that
most women today would find such an
attitude horrific. Of course, my body
doesn't belong to a man. It's my body. I
have a right to my body. It belongs to
me. So I give it if and when and how and
to whom I choose. And any man who thinks
differently is a toxic sociopath, etc.,
etc., etc. In any case, we're not
talking about a man's body, Orion. We're
talking about his money. A body is far
more precious, far more valuable than
money. Money is just money.
All right. Well, let's talk about money,
shall we? People often say that time is
money, but that isn't really true. It's
much truer to say that money is time.
Though all the money in the world can't
buy another minute of life, it's also
true that money can and does buy access
to better health care, which is a form
of buying time, and that money can and
does expedite things, which is another
form of buying time, etc., etc. However,
money is time in an even more
fundamental way. It is the
transfiguration of time spent in labor.
That is the meaning of money for the
majority of people. It is disembodied
labor and labor is always spent in the
application of the body. This is true
whether you are a brick layer or a brain
surgeon or a graphic designer. Your
labor requires that your body performs
certain tasks over a duration of time.
So I want you to understand that money
is the abstraction of a particular form
of physicality, namely the physicality
of the laboring body. So what does that
mean? It means that believing you are
entitled to another person's money is
essentially believing that you are
entitled to the labor that earned that
money. And since labor always involves
the application of the body,
this is tantamount to believing that you
are entitled to use that body according
to your desires. Oh [ __ ] Now if your
right means and requires the labor of
another person to realize, then guess
what? It's not a [ __ ] right. It is
not and it cannot be a just and
reasonable entitlement.
Stay with me now. I'm not sure how you
define things, but there is an
institution on this planet that is
founded on the belief that one person is
entitled to another person's labor. And
it begins with S and rhymes with
blavery.
I'll say this as plainly as I can.
Anyone who feels entitled to another
person's money is a slaver with a couple
extra steps. And this is because, as
previously discussed, money ties back to
the body just as surely and inevitably
as sexuality does.
Introducing my innovative first novel,
[music] Starry Night. Step into the
world of painter Vincent Van Gogh.
Genius, sinner, prophet, madman. Relive
the final 10 weeks of his life in this
breathtaking tale of art, love, loss,
and meaning, [music]
and challenge what you think you know
about life and relationships. [music]
Once you see through Vincent's eyes, the
world will never look the same again.
Starry Night, now available in ebook,
audiobook, and paperback formats.
[music] The links are in the
description.
Now, this isn't one of your average
double standards. This is a big and
scary one. Just as we collectively
believe correctly, in my opinion, that
men are not entitled to use the bodies
of women without their consent, even if
the bodies in question belong to their
wives. We must collectively stamp out
the belief that women are entitled to
the resources of men, even if they are
their husbands, simply because they are
in a sexual relationship with them.
Both ideas presume ownership over
another person's body for a specific
purpose.
This is dangerous because the desire to
control another person's resources
always always always
masks a desire to strip them of their
freedom.
Money and freedom are very closely
related to each other in more ways than
one. Most of the rights and civil
liberties that people enjoy today really
came into being during the Enlightenment
in the 18th century, which wa wow, what
a strange coincidence just happened to
coincide with the industrial revolution
and the global birth of capitalism.
Capitalism and liberal democracy are
really two sides of the same coin. the
one preserves the other. And it's
actually pretty easy to demonstrate why
this is the case. You've heard of [ __ ]
you money, right? [ __ ] you money is
possessing enough money that you feel
free to walk away from any situation or
relationship that doesn't serve you
anymore. You don't need any given job or
relationship. So, if they piss you off
or do you dirty, you can tell them to
just [ __ ] the ride off. Now, what
happens
if I take away some of that money? Now,
you're you're still free, like in an
existential sense, to walk away, but
your freedom, like in a real practical
sense, has been compromised. You can
still walk away from a bad situation.
But you might not be able to pay your
bills or put food on the table. So, you
will likely put up with worse treatment
and poorer conditions than someone with
greater financial means. You are much
easier to control and much less likely
to fight back. Now, imagine what would
happen if we take away your money
entirely. Like unpopular opinion, but
individual freedom is actually
predicated
on the existence of private property.
Any person's practical freedom depends
directly on his capacity to enact that
freedom in a meaningful way. Remove the
means to enact that freedom and you can
control the person as effectively as if
he were in chains.
This is what I want you to understand.
When a woman feels entitled to a man's
money, she's laying claim to a lot more
than just his money. She's laying claim
to his time, to his labor, to his
physicality for a specific purpose, and
in a real practical sense to his
freedom.
This is no small thing. A woman who
talks like this and who talks like this
with impunity is like a modern-day Marie
Antuinette. She's so out of touch with
reality and she feels so removed from
the consequences that her beliefs
naturally produce that she is
functionally from another [ __ ]
planet. This is a dangerous dangerous
belief and it's one that should be
resisted whenever and wherever it
emerges.
What do you think about this argument?
Let me know in the comments below. And
please send this episode to someone who
you think might benefit from its
message. I know you know someone who
needs to hear this because it's word of
mouth referrals like this that really
help to make the channel grow. Other
value propositions. Anyone looking to
join my free weekly newsletter for which
I write original content, no AI, or book
a paid one-on-one consultation with
yours truly can find out more on my
website. There's also my books, The
Value of Others, my best-selling
examination of the economic model of
relationships, and my psychological
novel, Starry Night, where I explore the
final weeks of painter Vincent Van Go's
life. There's also my private member
community, The Captain's Quarters,
where, among other things, I host
bimonthly group consultation calls with
a wonderful group of folks. Check them
out if you are so inclined. A lot of
great value there. The links to
everything are in the description below.
As always, I appreciate your support and
thank you for listening.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
Dr. Orion Taban explores the psychological and ethical implications of the mindset "my money is my money and his money is my money." He argues that because money is a transfiguration of labor—which is the application of the body over time—feeling entitled to another person's financial resources is a form of claiming ownership over their body and labor. This mindset, he contends, strips individuals of their practical freedom and is logically equivalent to the entitlement structures found in slavery.
Videos recently processed by our community