Former US Envoy Warns of Wider Middle East Conflict
165 segments
We're gonna start this section with Brett McGurk. He served as the national security council coordinator
for The Middle East under president Biden. He's also the author of a new book, Brink,
inside the race to free the October 7 hostages. Brett, thank you so much for joining
us. We wanted to have you on first to talk about the book, but you're such
a relevant guest for everything we've been talking about all morning, geopolitics on fire. So we're
gonna we're gonna start there, I think. Look, I'm really curious to get your take because
under your your wide remit as as you've been an official for different presidents, different state
departments, different national security advisers, is the Mid East Mid East and terrorism. So as you
look at this attack on the airport in Riyadh and where the Houthis are both as
a group and as an aspiring political player in the region. Can you just kind of
walk us through how we got here and what you think the threat level is, and
whether or not it's going to expand?
Yeah. Christine, thanks so much for having me. And, actually, in Brink, the first chapter lays
out some of these issues, particularly with Iran, the Houthis in Saudi Arabia. The Houthis are
an indigenous group in Yemen. They overthrew the legitimate government in Yemen a number of years
ago, actually, during the Obama administration, and there's been a civil war there going on. But
they're heavily backed by Iran. Of course, their motto is death to America, death to Israel,
curse the Jews. That's who these guys are. But massively backed by Iran, and Iran has
supplied these, you know, very advanced ballistic missile capabilities, anti ship missile capabilities. And we've tried
to deal with it in a number of ways, the Obama administration, the Trump administration. Trump
administration was heavily supporting Saudi Arabia in the conflict in Yemen. When we entered office in
the Biden administration, it's actually the first chapter in Brink. I went to see the crown
prince of Saudi Arabia very early, like the first few days of the Biden administration, and
my instructions were to explain to him that we're making changes in our policy. We cut
Saudi Arabia off from significant weapon systems. We lifted the foreign terrorist designation of the Houthis
that the Trump administration had put on. And we also, over the course of that first
year, significantly withdrew our military presence in the region. Actually, there's a scene in the in
the book where I see Adam Brad Cooper. He's a current CENTCOM commander. He was a
deputy back then. And I said, hey. What are you seeing with the Houthis and Iran's
supply to the Houthis? And he said to me, you know, Brett, I only got one
ship in the water, so it's hard for me to see much at all. And what
happened in that period was that Iran just kept supplying the Houthis. So we, you know,
we can cut off our partners and allies, but our adversaries then just kinda amp it
up. And after October 7, we saw for the first time ever anti ship seeking ballistic
missiles going 4,000 miles an hour, targeting commercial ships and our ships, a massive problem. I
went to see the Iranians in Oman. This is also in Brink in a back channel.
So you get a sense of what this is like in real time, what it's like
to deal with Iran, what it's like to deal with these guys. And the attacks, you
know, kept coming. And then we had to engage militarily. And this has kinda continued for
some time. But the attack last night is very emblematic. A very advanced sophisticated ballistic missile,
very accurate, targeting a commercial airport, and now a number of civilian casualties. It's an act
of terrorism. I think there has to be a response. But, unfortunately, you know, this is
who these guys are. And it it gets to a broader question of... And for any
president, you have to deal with this. How do you deal with gathering threats? You know,
do you take them on preemptively? How how do you deal with this? And the Houthis
just got way too powerful. They have no capability on their own. They do now because
all the training over, you know, of course, a decade or so, to manufacture these ballistic
missiles, anti ship missiles, and they're sitting there right on the Red Sea controlling access to
the Red Sea. So a huge problem. I I suspect... I mentioned Brad Cooper. He's a
CENTCOM commander. I'm sure he's coming to the White House now with... To the president with
military options for a response. We have a dead American here at the Riyadh International Airport.
But, you know, the options aren't great. It's a it's a really tough situation. They're heavily
dug into mountains. And in the age of drone warfare, and this ties it into Ukraine,
and, of the course, drones that the Russians are using in Ukraine are Iranian Shahed drones.
The Iranians transferred this technology to the Russians back in about 2022. And the Russians now
manufacture their own Iranian Shahed drones, but they added rocket. They're now rocket propelled, and they
can manufacture these things to such scale and mass. And that's the combination between Russia and
Iran. But the problem with the drones, as you know, they can fly, you know, thousand
kilometers, 1,500 kilometers. You can launch them from anywhere. And when you're when you're targeting, say,
a commercial ship or an airport, they can be very accurate. And they can come in
such numbers that even very, very sophisticated air defenses, some of them get through. Mhmm. I
can just finally make one final point. I have a scene in the book. I'm in
the situation room, and a reader is right there. And we are seeing in real time
a 170 drones, 30 cruise missiles, and then ultimately a 120 ballistic missiles at the same
time launched from Iran. The launches are timed to converge converge on Israel at the same
moment. And, you know, we we scrambled to build a coalition to help defeat this attack,
but you're right there if you read Brink. You're in the situation room what this is
like, and it's just a a wicked problem. But it's Russia. It's Iran. China is part
of this. Unfortunately, this is the world we we live in, and and The United States
has to work with our allies and partners to coordinate and try to deter and contain
as best we can. It's
just really That that scene is so vivid in the book, and I wanted to ask
you just about the seeming intractability of this conflict and and so much of what you
experienced in in this last stint in government centered on the the prospect of there being
this kind of wider war in The Middle East. And I... I'm genuinely curious at this
moment in time who the cooler head is who might prevail here in in this conflict.
Were you in your position today with whom you'd be negotiating? It does seem like it's
widened so much here, and there is so much discord throughout the region. I just sort
of wonder who the principal is or principals are with whom you you think you would
wanna be dealing to kind of calm things down, if anyone.
Well, we're in a tough situation now. You know, I've always... And and if you read
Brink, you're in you're in the room as we're we're debating the use of military. When
do we use US military power? What are the objectives? What are the... And I've always
believed in being very, disciplined in the use of US military power. What's the... What are
the ends, ways, means? What are the objectives? Like, what are we trying to do? I
thought president Trump's Operation Midnight Hammer last year was a very effective use of US military
power. It a it was a clear objective. We're gonna take out Forteau and Natanz and
nuclear sites. That's an operation that had been planned for years, and it went very well,
kinda textbook. This current war started in February. In the first night, you took out almost
the entire Iranian leadership. And once you do that, it opens a question, what is the
objective? Is it regime change, a kind of infinite objective? That's how we got ourselves in
trouble in Iraq. I lived through that. And now it is, you know, eight or nine
months later, and we're still kinda trying to figure out what exactly we want. But you
also asked a good question. Who do you talk to? And I've had this experience with
Iran... Iranians. I've I've negotiated with them a number of times. For example, in a hostage
negotiation with the Iranians, I did in the Obama administration, you don't wanna talk to the
English speaking foreign ministers and diplomats because they don't hold the keys to the hostages. So
I had to talk to the guys from the revolutionary guards and the intelligence services. Similar
here, who is actually making decisions in Iran? Is the supreme leader even alive? We don't
know. And it seems, from everything we can tell, the revolutionary guards and Ahmed Vahidi, he
is a... Just a diehard revolutionary ideologue. He has basically see... He's been now leading the
revolutionary guards. He's the decision maker, and it's gonna be very hard to ever get a
deal with him.
Brett, do you think the do you think the regime in Iran is more extreme now
than it was before the conflict began?
Well, they have consolidated the very hard line. Although I would... They were hard line before.
I don't... I've never put much stock in in in dealing with... And I've done deals
with Iran. I've been involved in conflicts with Iran that there's a moderate... You know, that
you can deal with a moderate camp. And they will make tactical deals with us, but
ultimately, their goal in Tehran, this system, is to get The US out of the Middle
East. They ultimately wanna see Israel, as they say. They wanna they wanna get rid of
Israel. That is their objective. And so you're dealing with that reality as you find tactical
deals such as the Obama era nuclear deal to put some time on the clock. But
to your question, yes. I mean, I... Go back to Ahmed Vahidi. It... For... In June...
Go back to June, the MOU that president Trump signed with Pojeskin. Pozhakian is the president
of Iran. He's one of the more pragmatic guys. Mhmm. They actually signed a deal, Trump
and Pozhakian, unprecedented. And that was the most favorable deal Iran was ever gonna get. It
it lifted all their banking and oil sanctions. The sanctions relief even went broader in many
ways than the Obama era nuclear deal. But one of the requirements was ships have to
go through the Strait Of Hormuz. And what did Iran do? They fired drones at two
commercial ships. Yeah. And the deal fell apart. And that... That's Vahidi. K? I'm sure Pajjaianz,
Basarachi, the foreign minister, they would not have given orders to fire those ships and and
break that deal. That was so favorable to Iran in many ways. But that's what we're
dealing with. So I just... I do not see near term prospects for a deal with
Iran. I think we're going to be in this kinda stalemated situation where we're applying economic
pressure, and it is real pressure. Iran has never had a blockade like this ever, but
they are then imposing costs on us. You know, they can't close the Strait Of Moose
anymore. I think we've gotten a decent handle on that, but they can... As you just
had in your last segment, they can impose costs on on using that channel, and that's
what they're doing. So they're trying to apply macroeconomic pressure. We are applying very clear micro
pressure on Iran's economy. You know, this system, eventually, let's hope it it cracks because the
Iranian people is one of the most pro West populations in the region. Anytime you can
get a a reliable pull out of there. But the the system, and I've dealing with
this for so many years, is what it is. And I would try to... As you're
playing economic pressure on Iran as we are, then you gotta think about how do you
use that in a negotiation. Right? Sure. That's really the trick here, but it's gonna be
really hard.
We just have a couple minutes left. I wanna ask you about patience, diplomatic patience here,
and that's a theme of this book as well. How much patience you had to have
in these negotiations? You have praise for Steve Witkow, as well. I'm I'm curious as you
look at him and Jared Kushner in compliment trying to find a solution to both of
these conflicts, how much confidence do you have in their ability to do that and and
their sense of how much patience it requires to get it done?
Well, and and, Brink, as you know, we had a key moment. Synagur is dead, the
leader of Hamas. Hezbollah cuts a deal. It was a key moment to go back to
the deal. And right around that time, Trump wins the election. So I knew we had
to work together if we wanted to get that ceasefire, get the hostages home. I called
Jared Kushner, started working with Steve. That's all in the book. I think it's a story
of unlikely in Washington these days, two teams coming together for the good of the country
and trying to stop a war and save lives. But, yeah, I worked closely with Steve
in that negotiation. He was extremely effective when it came down to these final two issues
that we had to bridge. But, look, they now have the most difficult files in the
world. I mean, Russia, Ukraine is so hard because Putin is a 100% determined to continue
his war in Ukraine. Yeah. He's impervious to the cost. And then the Iranians, we... I
just I just talked about. So, you know, I... They got their work cut out for
them. I'm not gonna take shots here from the chief seats. I I just... I hope
we succeed. I think to succeed on Ukraine, we gotta support Ukraine. I think the diesel
deal we cut over the weekend sends all the wrong wrong signals, and you gotta work
with your allies so that Putin realizes the cost he's suffering. You know, he's not gonna
get out of it without without cutting a deal. I think he believes... All these countries
believe, Russia, Iran, China, that time is on their side because The United States, we have
short attention span. So they can just kinda wait us out. I think that's what Putin
right now believes, and that's why this horrible war, is poised to continue. But, boy, I
hope they can succeed and find a way a way to wind down that conflict and
and find a way to some sort of arrangement with with Iran.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video features an interview with former National Security Council coordinator Brett McGurk, who discusses his book 'Brink' and provides insights into the geopolitical challenges in the Middle East. McGurk details the rise of the Houthis, the complexity of dealing with Iran, and the strategic difficulties involved in navigating conflicts involving Russia, China, and Iran. He also reflects on his past negotiations, the need for disciplined use of U.S. military power, and his collaboration with the current administration's transition team to address critical regional issues.
Videos recently processed by our community