HomeVideos

Grok Bot vs. Claude Cowork vs. ChatGPT: Is $300 Worth It?

Now Playing

Grok Bot vs. Claude Cowork vs. ChatGPT: Is $300 Worth It?

Transcript

211 segments

0:00

$300 a month. That's what XAI charges on

0:04

their own consumer plan to get access to

0:06

Grok bot, or 200 if you go through

0:09

Cursor, or 120 if you buy it for a team.

0:13

Three different doors, three different

0:15

prices for this same exact product.

0:18

There's no free tier, and there's no

0:20

free trial. So, I did the thing that I

0:23

always do before I spend money on a tool

0:26

or product. I went and watched people

0:28

who already spent money on it. Not the

0:30

launch video, the reviews. And I found

0:33

something none of them say out loud. For

0:35

the first creator, that's Brock

0:37

Mezerich, "It feels like a beta. It's

0:39

rough around the edges. There are

0:42

definitely better alternatives for a

0:44

much cheaper price." He names them

0:46

Claude and Co-work and ChatGPT.

0:49

>> First of all, it does feel like a beta.

0:52

Kind of does feel rough around the

0:53

edges. It just doesn't feel very

0:54

polished. I think they have a lot of

0:56

improvements they can do with this

0:58

platform. And then, having to pay $200 a

1:00

month to use this right now does seem

1:03

like a lot of money. I do think there

1:04

are better alternatives out there using

1:06

something like Claude Co-work or ChatGPT

1:08

work for much cheaper.

1:10

>> He's right about the price. I want to

1:12

put a real number on it. Claude Co-work

1:14

isn't a separate product you buy, it

1:17

comes with Claude Pro. $20 a month.

1:20

That's the entry-level price for an

1:22

agent that reads your files, runs

1:25

multi-step work, and hands you something

1:28

finished.

1:29

ChatGPT Plus is also $20 a month. If you

1:33

want the heavy coding tiers, ChatGPT Pro

1:36

runs 100 and 200 for Pro Max. And it's

1:41

very similar for Claude.

1:43

So, the cheapest door to Grok bot costs

1:46

10 times what the cheapest door to

1:48

Claude Co-work costs.

1:51

Now, price alone doesn't kill a product.

1:53

Sometimes you pay more and get more. So,

1:57

the real question is what those extra

1:59

dollars buy you.

2:01

Now, here's the second creator, Nate

2:04

Hurk, runs an AI automation business. He

2:07

likes Grokbot, and he's told you exactly

2:10

when he uses it.

2:12

Not at his desk. When he's

2:14

building something, he's using either

2:16

Claude Code or Codex. He uses Grokbot in

2:20

the back of an Uber, on vacation,

2:23

sitting at a restaurant because it syncs

2:25

with his phone.

2:26

>> Well, if I'm sitting down at my desk and

2:29

I am working on knowledge work, if I'm

2:31

trying to build things, I will not be

2:32

using this. I will be using my Codex, my

2:34

Claude Code. That's what I like to drive

2:36

with when I'm sitting down at my desk.

2:38

Now, if I'm traveling, if I'm in the

2:40

back of an Uber, if I'm on a vacation,

2:42

if I'm sitting at a restaurant, this is

2:44

what I'll be using because my phone

2:45

syncs to it right away, and it just

2:47

keeps things super clean and super easy.

2:49

>> Seems like it's very convenient. I want

2:51

to be fair with him because that's a

2:53

real use case, being able to kick off

2:55

work from your phone genuinely matters

2:58

if you travel a lot. But, here's what

3:00

he's actually describing. He's

3:02

describing a convenience layer, a thing

3:05

he reaches for when he's away from the

3:07

tool he actually trusts.

3:09

That is $200 a month to check on work

3:13

while you're in a car.

3:15

And I almost let that go until I checked

3:18

whether the cheap tools do it, too. They

3:21

do. Cowork has been in the cloud app on

3:24

iPhone and Android since July 7th, not a

3:28

separate app, a tab in the one you

3:31

already have. ChatGPT work shipped agent

3:34

mode on mobile July 9th. Both run in the

3:38

cloud, so the work keeps going with your

3:41

phone in your pocket. And Grokbot

3:43

launched August 11th. So, the Uber thing

3:47

was a $20 feature a month before Grokbot

3:51

even existed. And this is a pattern

3:53

across every review I watched. The demos

3:56

are very impressive. The verdicts are

3:59

some version of this is cool and here's

4:02

when I don't use it.

4:04

Now, here's where I have to be honest

4:07

with you because the third clip cuts

4:09

against my own argument. Uh creator

4:12

number three is Claire Vo How I AI.

4:15

She runs benchmarks. She's technical.

4:18

Her complaint about Grokbot

4:20

is that it's too easy, too simple. She

4:24

can't hack it. She can't pick the

4:26

models. She doesn't get the config file

4:28

level of control she likes.

4:31

>> What I don't like about Grokbot? Well, I

4:35

don't like that it's so simple and I

4:38

don't like that I can't hack it.

4:40

>> And she says something at the end that

4:43

I'm not going to skip past.

4:45

>> That being said,

4:46

it works and the connector and kind of

4:50

like UX affordances are quite nice.

4:53

>> It works. The connectors are nice. The

4:55

experience is good. I think she's

4:58

telling the truth and I think it

5:00

matters. If you have never set up an AI

5:03

agent before and the technical stuff

5:05

kind of scare you, it has been the exact

5:08

thing that stopped you from working on

5:10

AI,

5:11

then a product that just works out the

5:13

box is something real and maybe

5:16

something worth um something to you. But

5:20

notice what her complaint reveals. She's

5:22

used it for about a week and went back

5:25

to her old setup. Her words and her

5:27

description, she still reaches for her

5:30

open claw.

5:32

Three creators, three different reasons.

5:34

All three ended up back in the tool they

5:37

were already paying for.

5:39

There's one more thing I want you to

5:41

know before you decide and it has

5:43

nothing to do with price.

5:46

To do anything useful with Grokbot,

5:49

it signs into your accounts, your email,

5:52

your file, using your credentials,

5:54

acting as you.

5:56

I went looking for the security posture

5:58

on that. There's no SOC

6:01

2 claim, no ISO 27001,

6:05

no GDPR,

6:08

no HIPAA,

6:09

no FedRAMP, no published retention

6:12

period, no data

6:14

residency option.

6:16

It's

6:17

still an early beta product, and there's

6:20

no reliability data out yet.

6:23

And the part that actually stopped me,

6:25

the documentation says a test run does

6:28

real work. It's not a sandbox.

6:31

If it does something wrong on your live

6:33

accounts, refusing to approve it

6:35

afterward doesn't undo what had already

6:38

happened.

6:40

Compare that to what the cheap one does.

6:42

ChatGPT work has a watch mode that

6:45

pauses before anything consequential or

6:49

irreversible,

6:50

and asks you first. Same category of

6:53

product, opposite default.

6:55

Maybe that will get fixed in the short

6:58

term.

6:59

It's 3 weeks old. Beta products ship

7:01

without compliance paperwork all the

7:03

time, and most of them are fine.

7:06

But,

7:07

you're being asked to hand over your

7:09

logins to a product with no sandbox at 2

7:13

to $300 a month to do work that a $20

7:17

subscription

7:19

has already been doing at your desk.

7:21

So, here's where I land. If you're

7:23

already paying for a Claude or ChatGPT,

7:26

you're getting your work done. I don't

7:28

think Grokbot changes anything for you

7:30

right now. The people who liked it the

7:32

most told you when they don't use it.

7:36

That's not a hit piece. That's just

7:38

what's in their videos.

7:40

If you travel constantly, and the phone

7:42

first thing solves a real problem you

7:45

have,

7:46

that's the one case where I understand

7:49

paying for this product. Going through

7:51

the cheapest store and connect the

7:53

accounts you'd be okay losing.

7:56

And if you never use an agent at all,

7:59

start with the $20 one, learn what these

8:01

things are actually good at, then decide

8:04

whether you're missing anything.

8:06

This is not financial advice. I don't

8:08

know your situation. Do your own

8:10

research before you make a big decision.

8:14

The thing that surprised me here wasn't

8:17

the Grokster is bad, that the reviews

8:19

telling you it's incredible and the

8:22

reviews telling you where it falls short

8:25

are the same reviews. You just have to

8:27

watch past the demo. So, what am I

8:29

missing? If you're paying the $30 and

8:32

it's replaced something for you, I want

8:34

to hear it because I couldn't find that

8:36

in person. Tell me in the comments

8:37

below. Thanks for watching. My name's

8:40

Brock Mayo. Peace.

Interactive Summary

This video provides a critical analysis of Grokbot, evaluating its high price point compared to existing alternatives like Claude Pro and ChatGPT Plus. The reviewer examines user feedback, highlighting that while some appreciate its simplicity and mobile convenience, many users find it feels like a beta product lacking the necessary control and security features for professional work. Ultimately, the reviewer suggests that current alternatives offer more robust features and better security at a significantly lower cost.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts