S&P's Yergin: "The Biggest Energy Disruption We've Ever Seen"
151 segments
We talked about, this notion of kind of energy price relativism that the president seems perhaps
pleasantly surprised that oil prices haven't climbed as much as maybe he feared they would, raising
the specter of $200 a barrel oil. Oil prices are higher, but we're not at 2,008
prices, for instance. What do you make of what he's talking about there? The fact that
the spike has been sizable, but maybe not as bad as as he and others might
have feared.
I think that's well, that's true. If you go back to the 2008 or 02/2014, prices
were over a $100 a barrel. If you put that in today's dollars, that's like a
$160 a barrel. So we haven't seen that, and there wasn't that same kind of disruption
that we're seeing now. But the question is, is still the relative calm before the storm?
The longer this goes on, the more the risk on the upside grow because the impacts
are being felt. The last cargoes have arrived in Europe, in in Asia, and, and inventories
are being drawn down.
Is that what we're waiting for? Because my question is why isn't it that bad? I'm
confounded as a foreign policy person about the markets and their resilience and how any sign
of life from these negotiations from the White House, they seem to look for any shred
of evidence that things are gonna be okay. Why is that happening?
See a divergence between the financial markets, you say, respond to the news. You know, a
deal is near or they're going to negotiate, and the reality of people in Asia actually
not having enough oil, shortages, rationing, businesses closing down, restaurants not operating because they don't have
energy. So Asia is one area. Europe is starting to feel particularly jet fuel, and we're
seeing it at the gasoline pump, but it's been there before.
Talk a bit more about that, the the pain that many people around the world are
feeling. And, yes, we're fixated on the market price and futures and all of that, but
there's a very real cost that's already taking effect here. And I'm I'm curious sort of
how you assess that level of pain.
I think what was you know, I think one of the things that people didn't think
about before this happened, if they thought about the Strait Of Hormuz, they thought about oil.
Maybe they thought about natural gas and LNG. They didn't think about fertilizer. They didn't think
about helium. They didn't think about aluminum. They didn't think about petrochemicals. And it turned out
that that region is much more integrated into the global economy because of all the economic
development there. So it produces, what is it, about 40% of the world's helium, which you
need to make semiconductors or MRI machines. So this is actually unlike all the other things
we've talked about in the last twenty years, this is a much bigger disruption to the
global economy, but it's Asia because, basically, economically, the Strait Of Hormuz went east. 80% of
the oil, 90% of the LNG went to Asia, and that's where the shortfall is in
ways that people really didn't model.
I saw at the International Energy Agency saying we are facing the biggest energy security threat
in history. And I wonder if you agree with that assessment of the moment that we're
I'm very curious. But, Dan, your perspective is on this moment in the wide the wider
screen.
I think this is this is the biggest energy disruption we've ever seen. But as you
say, it's it's ironic that we're not seeing the full price impact, and so time is
really the key factor here.
When you look at this, is it so bad because geographically, there's just really no alternative
as there have been in some other conflicts? There, you know, obviously, there are pipelines that
go out to the Red Sea, but you just can't get that volume through anywhere else.
And as we've also been talking about, how concerned are you that this could be a
chronic problem? You know, just because Iran agrees to something in the room doesn't mean they're
gonna change their minds if they've shown they have the capacity to shut this down.
Yeah. There was, until this happened, there was a thing called the TSS, the traffic separator
system, where people understood that, okay, in an orderly way, this goes this way. This goes
this way. Now there's gonna be uncertainty over it, and it raises questions not only about
the straight, but it raises the question about freedom of seas on which the world economy,
and world trade really depends. So I think there's we come out of this. There's going
to be an uneasiness about it, and so much will be critical as to what the
outcome will be. Will there be an actual system and understanding of how this operates, or
is this something that will fluctuate?
We last spoke with you eight weeks ago, I think, at the beginning of this conflict.
Yes. And it was on the
eve you. Eight weeks ago. I feel like you were just here.
Okay. Sorry. Continue. You are on the eve of going to run your conference in in
Texas, Sarah Week, and I'm very curious with that in the rearview mirror what those conversations
were like. I I imagine that your agenda had to be, adjusted and and changed as
a result of what was happening in The Middle East. But what were the conversations like
among executives that you had on stage and did have on the sidelines about
this topic? Things. One goes to what we were talking about, which is the sense that
that the market was underpricing risk the longer it goes on. And I think that was
a very strong message. And from the company people, you heard they were focused on constraints,
logistics, how do you get supplies, how do you make up for supplies. So they were
not looking at what the futures markets were doing expectations. They were saying, how do we
deliver oil? The other big thing, of course, the theme of the conference was big tech
meets the energy industry. Where are you gonna get the electricity for all the AI development
and what will be the sources? And so that was the theme that was in place
before the crisis. But you could see really when it was in late January when the
military buildup started, and that prices were already rising before the the war started.
So what is the solution for that? I mean, as we talk about big tech data
centers, this sudden spike in requirement coming at the same time there is an energy crunch.
Green energy is not very popular right now. Alternatives are not very popular right now. Is
that something that needs to be reevaluated? Do they need to reevaluate how they move this
oil through the region? Is anyone talking about an alternative long term plan so that we're
not dealing with this every few years if this happens again
and Well, I think they're out of this is gonna come a bigger focus on energy
security, and The Gulf countries themselves are gonna say, what do we do to protect ourselves?
What do we do in terms of investment within The Gulf and outside The Gulf? But
I think that, you know, this is the first you know, we're in the China EV
era. 20% of the cars built in the world this year will be EVs, and that's
gonna get a tick up from this, certainly.
In our last block, we talked about the the blockade, the utility of it, the degree
it's weighing on negotiations that are unfolding. And I know that there's been some debate about
what that, the presence of that blockade, the strait being effectively closed, is going to mean
for oil prices going forward. We have the president of The United States saying I'm gonna
paraphrase him here. He's got all the time in the world. If if that blockade persists,
if we see the kind of stalemate that we have been seeing for three months or
six months or whatever, what is the effect that's going to have here?
Well, you know, of course, sitting here, it's hard to believe that it will last for
another three months or six months, but a lot's happened that we already this was all
war was gonna be over in five days. I think there are two things. One is
a question and the leverage point about how bad is the Iranian economy, how much strain
can it take without the resources, and that's the bet of the of The US blockade.
I think the Iranian blockade, it basically is is that they can wage war on the
world economy and the pressure will be so great that they'll come out in a better
position. And in a sense, it's a clash between these two blockades that's unfolding now.
Haven't talked about sorry.
No. No. Go ahead.
On this point, we haven't talked about Carg Island in many weeks now, but that was
something that was kind of looming as something The US might do, try to take Carg
Island or destroy Carg Island. Play out that scenario for us here too. If things really
go south in Islamabad, if there isn't any advancement in these talks, and president Trump, he
says he will pursue his military action once again targeting power plants, infrastructure, and perhaps the
the refining capabilities of Carg Island. What what does
that Winston Churchill said once that once the war starts, what happens, whatever your plan is,
what happens is unforeseeable and uncontrollable, and we're sort of in that state right now. I
think Carg Island, as I understand, it's doable, but it's also very vulnerable from the shore
because it's fairly close in and Iranian artillery and drones and so forth. I think one
of the factors here that is new is that really the new form of warfare that
was really beta tested in Ukraine is now being played out in the Gulf Region, and
that would affect decisions about Karg Island. These are
the cheap drones and other yeah.
Yeah. Cheap drones.
And we were talking about it's been fascinating to see this pivot for Volodymyr Zelensky. He's
had a good run of luck with Orban being ousted in Hungary and getting new allies
in The Gulf as he's in Saudi and visiting the region and then
trying to paraphrase. He has some cards now.
He he does indeed. I wanna go back to something you were saying earlier. When you
look at these two economies, talked about the Iranian economy and how long they can last.
But there's another issue here, and that's The US economy. And then we were just talking
against the about wars of attrition. When you look at who can outlast if this becomes
a waiting game, you've got the very serious straits the Iranian economy is in. But you've
also got some not happy American consumers and a midterm coming up and a president and
a party who wants to get reelected. If this lingers into the fall, who blinks first?
Well, we certainly know that there's one thing. We see it every two years, every four
years, that gasoline prices really matter, and they really matter at the polls. And clearly, that's
in in in everybody's calculations right now. But you look at the position of The US
economy, we're gonna grow at 2% or more this year that the and I think this
is one of things that the financial markets are so driven by what's happened with AI
data centers that vast. Is it gonna be 800,000,000,000 or trillion dollars of investment this year?
That that's bolstering the overall economy. Obviously, gasoline prices remain. It's the most sensitive political price
in this country, but, our economy overall is, you know, is the envy of many other
people, and Iran's economy is actually in shambles.
Let me put an unfair question to you as the last one. I know you're not
next for a monetary policy, but we have a Fed that's adamant they can kind of
see through this conflict, or they said that at the beginning of it. How difficult does
that become if this conflict persists? I mean, what's the effect gonna be inflation that you're
coming from?
The question is, were we in an inflationary period beforehand for a lot of reasons, including
the amount of expenditure and so forth? What's happened to supply chains. Once you build energy
security, resilience in that as cost, and then simply all the inflationary impacts that come from
these higher prices. And so, you're gonna in order to see through, inflation through this period,
you're gonna need really good glasses. You're gonna need
really good glasses. We will leave it there.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The video discusses the ongoing energy crisis and the resulting economic disruptions caused by tensions in the Strait of Hormuz. Experts analyze why the global impact on oil prices has not been as severe as feared, despite real-world shortages in regions like Asia and Europe. The conversation covers the integration of the Gulf region into the global economy, the risks of long-term conflict, the impact of AI and data center energy demands, and the political and economic pressures on both the U.S. and Iran in this war of attrition.
Videos recently processed by our community