Team Favorite: AI-Era Internet, Spaceport Investment, Bolivia’s Investability | Wall Street Week
1210 segments
[music]
This is Wall Street Week. I'm David
[music] Weston bringing you stories of
capitalism coming to an internet near
you. Artificial intelligence. Will those
helpful chat bots kill the search and
advertising paying for all that content
that you enjoy?
and liftoff of Falcon 9.
>> Plus, the race to make money in space.
Companies are competing to launch
100,000 satellites in the next 5 years
as China builds out its own space
infrastructure in Latin America.
And investing in Bolivia, a new regime
aims to be friendly to private
enterprise. But when is the right time
for investors to dip their toe in the
water?
But we begin with the continuing
conflict in Iran. Harvard professor and
former IMF chief economist Ken Rogoff
chronicled the US dollar's rise in the
beginning of its decline as a global
currency [music] in his latest book, Our
Dollar, Your Problem. It turns out that
it's not just oil and aluminum at risk
in the Iran war. It also may be the
status of the [music] dollar.
Ken, in your book, Our Dollar, Your
Problem, you talk about the position of
the US dollar as declining gradually
over time in relation to other
currencies. We now have a conflict in
Iran. Is that affecting that decline?
Oh,
>> I don't think there's any question that
it will affect the decline. It could go
either way. It depends on how it comes
out. If the US comes out incredibly
triumphant, there's peace in the Middle
East.
uh everyone, you know, looks to the
United States to maintain peace. That's
one outcome. Another outcome where where
it's viewed as a strategic defeat and
China gains. But, you know, it's it's a
step. I don't think either way it's
changing a dynamic that was going to
happen anyway. There are things on the
outside that it influences. So they're
it's definitely going to help China
accelerate getting other countries to
use its currency particularly for
Chinese imports. For example, if China
buys oil or China buys anything, it's
going to help in that dimension. Uh but
it's also affecting global debt because
everybody sees a lot of need for
military expending. The US is the
biggest debtor in the world. We lose the
most when global interest rates go up.
So there are pressures from the outside
coming from everybody's trying to look
for other options and pressures from the
inside that we're you know running this
big debt that is manageable if we wanted
to but there's not a lot of will to want
to
>> is the strength of a currency reflective
of the strength including military
strength of the country in your book you
graduate to the Armada actually with
Queen Elizabeth I and the Spanish as Is
this potentially a barometer of how the
world is perceiving the relative
military strength of the United States?
>> The military strength's a piece of being
the dominant currency. And here, just to
be clear, we're talking about the
dollar's market share, which reached an
incredible peak about 10 years ago. But
also, military strength gives you the
ability to affect negotiations. They can
be over very unrelated things. They can
have to do with how the IMF works. they
can have to do with how global banking
regulation works. So having the military
power at the end of the day says well
you know of course of course it matters
for a lot of things and if you're looked
at as weaker it hurts you and part of
the protection historically going back
to like 1974 was of the Gulf states
countries like Saudi Arabia because of
US military protection. Now, as you say,
it depends on how this all plays out.
But if in fact the United States does
not uh have a triumph of some sort over
Iran, does it really undermine the
confidence of the Gulf States in using
the US dollar?
>> Well, the Gulf States are a really
important anchor of the US dollar. And
you know, it's interesting you picked
the 1970s because it really fell in the
1970s. Europe left the dollar. That's
worth remembering. And the Gulf States
when they sort of did their recycling of
their petro dollars through the United
States and priced oil and dollars, I
think it was sort of helpful. Although
nevertheless, you know, that period uh
was down. I don't want to overstate the
petro dollar. I want to be a little
careful about that because oil is a very
flexible price. We're all staring at
Brent crude and it's still here and it
goes here. it can move very fast. So
it's a little bit like my paying with
Visa or Mastercard.
It matters a lot more whether uh goods
manufactured goods are priced in
dollars. But it but it's important. I
mean it fills a lot of roles. The Gulf
States use dollars. Saudi is still
pegged to the dollar. I don't know how
long that's going to last but they still
are. And because uh so many of them uh
are pegged to the dollar, rotate around
the dollar, they hold more dollars.
They've been very important to our
business model. Not as important as
China, but they've been important. And
it's unclear how this is playing out. I
mean, I think a lot of the Gulf States
are looking at us and saying, "Wait, I
thought you built those bases to protect
us. I didn't know you built those uh you
know uh various military complexes in
our country so we could be target
practice and are you on our side or you
on their side like what's going on?
That's been a delicate dance. I I don't
think we know how it comes out yet. So,
you know, China's kind of playing it
cool. A lot of people say they may
benefit. They might, but but I I just
think we have to see what the endgame of
this is. the Chinese might benefit. Will
will the yuan benefit? Because we see
Iran saying, "We'll let oil through the
straight moves if you if you sell it in
yuan, for example." And China certainly
wants more transactions denominated.
>> They're doing quite a bit in crypto,
too, also, by the way. Yeah. I mean, if
they get paid in dollars, we can
sanction them immediately. They're
putting it hostage. Why the heck should
they do that? That's certainly
significant. But the big thing of the
Iran war in the future of the dollar is
it's raised global interest rates. They
were going up and up and up. So if I
look at the dynamic of how I see things
unfolding, it's that there's this
pressures from the outside that are very
slowm moving but they're happening to
have a more multipolar system. And there
are problems on the inside where we're
the richest country ever, ever, ever.
But we still have trouble paying our
bills and running these crazy large
debts. There's no political consensus in
either party. The Republicans don't want
to tax anyone. The Democrats think 1% of
people can pay, which doesn't add up.
And so we are racing towards having a
fiscal problem. And then central bank
independence becomes a problem because
when you have a fiscal problem you're
kind of looking for the central bank to
bail you out and if all that's happening
that's sort of what happened in the 70s
in a way it undermines the dollar.
>> So so what are the metrics that people
should use in figuring out where we are
in the relative prominence of the
dollars? What do you look at? I mean for
example were you surprised that the
dollar was not more of a safe harbor
when the Iran conflict broke out? So uh
there are people in finance uh who are
doing all these papers showing that the
premium we used to extract on longer
term debt is gone. So on short-term debt
there's still a premium to dollars. It's
still the safest asset. Long-term debt
it's not there anymore. I mean it's
safer than let's say uh you know some
African or South American countries debt
but if you compare it to many European
countries uh Japan it doesn't rank that
way they used to and so there are ways
in which what we're getting out of the
deal is going down. Now we can crowd
everything into short-term borrowing and
Secretary Bessence said I think interest
rates are going to go down. I'm going to
borrow more short-term.
Okay. But that's very risky. In fact, I
think he was saying not to do that 10
years ago. And so we're losing you you
see that in many uh measures. On the
other hand, you know, these things are
very slow moving. If you do uh foreign
exchange trading is overwhelmingly goes
through dollars. If you do uh currency
of denomination of debt, it's
overwhelmingly dollars. Of course, part
of that's because more than 50% of the
debt of the advanced countries is ours.
More than that in global bonds, it might
even be 60 or 70% is ours. So there's
there's a lot of liquidity in it. I
still remember 20 years ago a prominent
European economist getting up at a
meeting and saying, "Today is a big day.
There's more euro euro debt than dollar
debt." Which was true that day. Well,
how did that work out? You know, I mean,
it's I I think this is a slowm moving
thing. We're seeing it in the interest
rate spreads. We're seeing it in
reserves. So what countries are choosing
to do uh we're seeing it in uh actions
that the Europeans and the Chinese are
taking to develop independent systems.
But this isn't something the private
sector is just going to do. It's mostly
the Chinese, the Europeans are leading
the way. We are digging our, you know,
grave so to speak. And it's all the
actions of the governments. It's not
something that's happening overnight.
>> Coming up, the content business made a
long and difficult transition from print
to the internet. But what happens if
scrolling online is now replaced by AI?
We bring you the story of another
revolution in how we get our information
and entertainment.
>> [music]
>> This is a story about big changes on
tiny screens. Since its inception, the
internet has become where we turn for
content. Content we mostly access
through search. And that's mostly free.
But of course, it's not really free.
When we searched on platforms like
Google, we were directed to web pages
created by publishers who got paid for
all those ads we spent time looking at.
Now all that is changing and as AI
becomes the new gateway to the web, it's
transforming the economics of the
internet.
We believe the high water mark for
internet traffic like [music] that was
sent out from social media and search
and AI tools which are quite nent at the
time was 2022. [music] Essentially over
the last 4 years those numbers have been
dropping. [music]
>> Rand Fishiskin is an author and
entrepreneur who specializes in online
search
the main way that most of us interact
[music] with the web. I do a lot of
research with clickstream data which
essentially looks at devices and what
they visit [music] and and don't visit.
Whereas in 2011, Google was sending
north of 70% of all searches to a third
party website, right? A website not
owned or controlled by Google. And today
that number is in the mid40s and
falling. Um that clearly indicates this
zero-click trend.
Zero click. It's a term for an online
search result that doesn't [music] lead
to any other web pages. That can be good
news for users if their question has
been answered quickly and correctly. No
need to spend time scrolling through all
that text and pages of ads. But if you
are a publisher counting on that click
to bring [music] traffic to your website
and to sell those ads, it's very bad
news. Which means the creators of all
that web content have [music] to rethink
the game. Long before AI, Google started
disintermediating content providers by
answering questions right in the search
results. [music] You search for the MET
score, the score is right at the top.
And AI just enhanced their ability to do
this.
>> For an idea of just how big this change
is for Google itself, here's the
company's head of search talking about
incorporating AI just last month. Now
we're entering the next chapter of
Google search where incredible AI
features aren't just in search. Google
search is AI search through and through.
Now this is the biggest upgrade to our
iconic search box since its debut over
25 years ago. The problem is that most
people don't click on the links in
Google and that has
>> Caitlyn Petri is author of all the news
that's fit to click and a professor at
Rutgers who studies the way algorithms
shape online media
>> news sites that were counting on
referrals from Google for their traffic
for their ad revenue to draw maybe
subscribers who might come to the site
get interested and then subscribe are
now seeing in some cases very dramatic
decreases is in the traffic that they're
getting from Google.
>> The move from print to the internet,
many people think actually eliminated
some news sources. A lot of local
newspapers, for example, were eliminated
partly because of the business model
challenge, the revenue challenge. Uh do
we face a risk of that with AI that we
will eliminate even further sources?
>> I think we do. Um I think it's a major
concern.
>> It was really revealing. Perhaps nobody
in the world has a better view of these
changes and what they mean for online
content creators than Neil Vogle.
>> What happened was our audience, right?
And and we're we reach half of America
each month. Our audience on the internet
was 75% from Google search
2022, maybe a little bit more, maybe a
little bit less, but ballpark that. That
is now 25% of our audience.
>> Vogle is CEO of People Inc. The largest
online and print publisher in America.
It reaches 175 million people each month
with dozens of publications whose names
you know well.
>> Better Homes and Gardens, People,
Entertainment Weekly, Travel and
Leisure, Food and Wine. And we put all
of these brands together because we
believed we understood how to run these
classic heritage brands on the internet.
And we've been proven right. Although
Vogle has had a front row seat to the
collapse in search traffic that AI has
ushered in, he also told us something
surprising. His business is booming.
>> We're very profitable and we're defying
the narrative around publishing. That is
publishers can't succeed in this world
and we're succeeding. We feel really
good and really optimistic about the
future of media. Back in the day, before
there even was an internet, believe it
or not, there was a time. Uh if you look
at a publisher, newspaper, magazine,
their revenue came from two sources,
subscription and advertising. What's
your revenue model?
>> If you look at the internet, that is
where we thrive. That is our bread and
butter. 90% of our profitability comes
from our internet and our online
presence. That is very much advertising,
but it's also lots of other things.
Those other things include deals and
branded products, but Vogle says they've
also got a new revenue stream.
>> We licensed content to LLM and AI
engines. We sat with Sam Alman at OpenAI
right before they could launch the first
commercial LLM. This is the fall of
2022.
And we saw this LLM and and
[clears throat] we saw what it could do.
And we were like, uh-oh. Like the world
is going to be different from here. And
there's moments in your life who know
the world's going to be different. Like
you have your first kid or the
Philadelphia Eagles win the Super Bowl
and you know that like your world's
going to be different from there. This
was one of those m this was like the
business version of that moment. And we
took a look at this and our first
reaction is thank god we have brands
because what we knew was this was going
to be a new paradigm in media and we
knew there were going to be risks and
there going to be opportunities and we
made the bet and had the thesis that
says if you have these intangible assets
that really really mean something to
people you have something that is going
to increase in value in an artificial
era. And starting in 22 and 23 we
started to build other ways to
distribute our brands. Tik Tok,
Instagram, YouTube, our own emails,
product licensing, all of these things
we did. And cut to today, five years
later, we've made 10 straight quarters
on Wall Street. We're growing in an area
where at most publishers are struggling.
And we did it because we have these
amazing brands that can live in all
these places and our aggregate aggregate
audience size is multiples what it was
when we started here. You mentioned that
you do have licensing arrangements with
some of the LLM large language models.
>> Uh how does that work for you? Is it
real money?
>> So it's real money. It's material for
us.
>> I think we made a decision. Um
maybe it's right, maybe it's wrong. So
far I think it's right that we wanted a
seat to the table. The important thing
to understand and realize is AI needs
three things. It needs power, which has
been a lot of talk about power. It needs
a model. It's been a lot of talk about
models and it needs inputs. We are the
inputs. We are the training of the
models. Now we believe and I think if
you talk to any of these AI
professionals believe the internet's
been crawled. All the data in the world
is already in the models. So the value
should acrue to those of us that are
still making substantial amounts of new
things that are needed for the search
use case which is a very big use case
and are needed for all the corporate
clients that want to use LLM for their
stuff. So it could be something simple
as we have 50 new recipes with avocados
in them and avocados are important to I
can tell you every single thing Kim
Kardashian did yesterday. But these are
things that are very valuable these
pieces of data. The other thing we did
which is really important here is
part of having a seat at the table is we
wanted to control our own destiny. Last
uh summer and in July, we made a
decision and we partnered with a group
called Cloudflare to block every AI
crawler you could possibly block. So,
you cannot get access to our content
unless you pay us for it.
>> And given your model uh to license the
um training using your content
>> to an LLM
>> is basically found money, right? It's
not taking away from your other business
because that's based on brand.
>> I mean, so it it's interesting. Is it ah
it's funny we have this conversation all
the time like and the answer we always
come back to is cash is cash it would be
amazing if we could make money the way
we made money three or four years ago be
super fun I'd have a lot more free time
but I don't and we have to work hard so
it it is what it is
>> for a publisher with strong
wellestablished brands even the
uncertain future with AI may be bright
but for smaller publishers and for the
web as a whole the outlook may not be as
encouraging potentially in the longer
run. What could this mean for the
internet itself? Because the internet
really has thrived on very rich
production of content. If content
providers don't get paid for that,
sooner or later there's not going to be
as much content.
>> Yeah. This this death spiral that you're
describing has been something that
people have theorized over the last
three or four years with no discernable
solution. I I'm going to tell you what I
think is the most likely scenario, but
it's also the most tragic one, which is
that in a few years, AI tools find
themselves unable to get enough content
to train on, whether that's video or
text or audio, long form, short form,
and they decide to build their own
publishing departments. And in years to
come, a decade, two decades from now, it
would not surprise me if
OpenAI or Anthropic looked a lot like
Tik Tok where they have a creator fund
and they pay creators a certain amount
based on the amount of traffic and page
views and value to the training set that
these creators provide. And so they're
contract employing these creators and we
get a we get an AI shaped internet,
right? an internet that is built not
only for but by AI tools. That um that
seems quite probable.
>> I think that that is something that if I
worked at an AI company, I would really
be thinking about because if the traffic
drops so significantly that we see even
more jobs in journalism be lost. We see
even more, especially local outlets, but
a lot of news outlets shutter themselves
because they can't stay afloat. um that
diminishes the amount of content that
these LLMs can train on too, right? So,
this is something that I think we should
all be concerned about, not just
journalists, but um also those who work
at AI companies, anyone who cares about
the future of democracy should be
thinking about this right now.
>> Tell me how broadly apart from people,
beyond people, how do you think
generative AI is going to change the
nature of the internet, the content on
the internet? I so we can end up being
fairly myopic around here and looking at
our own use case. I am um and I have to
be I'm like a crazy optimistic person
and um I am very optimistic about AI for
us, right? The risk for AI for us is
already out. It's already killed our
biggest piece of traffic from 5 years
ago. But we've built something even
better over here that we use AI to do
more of. Like we are today, we make
about 50% more content than we made when
this whole process started for roughly
the same cost and humans make every
single thing you read and see because
we've been able to use AI in the
background to streamline so many
processes. If you look at as an
opportunity, it's incredible for us and
we have no choice but to look at it that
way. If we look at it any other way,
it's too scary. And it's sort of like
riding a bike. Don't look down. Look
towards the horizon like and you'll
[clears throat] be fine.
>> Since we talked with Neil Vogle, People
Inc.'s parent company made an offer to
buy the part of MGM it doesn't already
own. In making the bid, chairman Barry
Diller emphasized the value of what he
called realworld assets that AI cannot
easily replicate. Pursuing a part of the
media world very different from the
online content brands that Vogle
continues to build. Up next, we've come
a long way from Cape Canaveral. Today,
there's a booming business in space
launches, which means a long waiting
list for satellites trying to get into
orbit. [music] And the latest
opportunity may lie 1,000 mi south of
Florida in the Dominican Republic.
This is a story about making money
22,000 miles up, meeting a commercial
need for tens of thousands of satellites
to be launched by 2030. There is a race
on to get all those satellites into
orbit, but also a race with China, which
has already built a range of satellite
ground stations in Latin America.
Something that's gotten the attention of
the US government.
[music]
So, it's about 45 minutes on a
helicopter flight. It's probably about
four or five hours driving.
>> In the western part of the Dominican
Republic, on the border with Haiti, lies
Pedanales, a quiet coastal province that
will soon be home to the country's first
spaceport and what is slated to be the
first US-owned commercial spaceport in
Latin America.
>> If they were to identify this region as
ideal for commercial space, be
essentially the Straits of Hormuz for
space. When we talk about the straight
of Hormuz, we think of all that oil and
fertilizer and aluminum trying to get
through a narrow sea channel. When it
comes to space, it's satellites. And
[music] the choke point isn't a sea
passage, but launch pads that we simply
don't have enough of. [music]
>> How many pads are you going to have
here?
>> Four.
>> Four pads here.
>> Burton Catage is a former Air Force
colonel who founded aerospace company
Launch on Demand in 2018. The amount of
support that they came back with was
amazing.
>> He's now developing a $600 million
commercial spaceport in this remote part
of the Dominican Republic.
>> The ecosystem at Cape Canaveral more or
less has grown out of ad hoc. Okay. It
has it was not necessarily built with
the idea for the commercial space
industry. The entire market has changed.
You know, the space industry is
something on the order last time I
checked it was like $650 billion. um
it's supposed to be over a trillion um
in by 2030, maybe a trillion and a half.
And some people are even saying that's
pretty low. [music]
>> To relieve the bottleneck in launching
the growing number of satellites we
need, the US has to have more
spaceports, [music]
creating a business opportunity for
companies like Launch on Demand. Right
now, there are over a dozen US
spaceports across the country [music]
and just one internationally, Rocket
Labs launch site in New Zealand. I think
the United States from the space economy
perspective is in a position of extreme
opportunity and they are in a growth
phase. Ryan Brookart is a senior partner
at McKenzie who focuses on global
aerospace, defense [music] and space
companies.
>> I think the infrastructure in in the US
is becoming a bit stretched, right? If
you look at our launch sites, we're
launching, you know, every day or a
couple times a day from some of these
launch sites. There's a huge backlog of,
you know, US companies looking to launch
things into space and to be able to
accomplish their mission and get the get
the return that their investors are
looking for.
>> Right now, uh, I've heard that it's
about three-year waiting list to get a
satellite on orbit.
>> What accounts for that demand ramping up
so dramatically? And do you expect it's
going to continue to increase that much?
>> Well, in order to have global coverage
of the entire Earth, you have to have a
lot of satellites. Right now, there's
about 14,000
satellites in orbit. The FCC tracks all
the number of satellites that are going
to be submitted, and they're looking at
over a 100,000 satellites by 2030. So,
if we got 14,000 satellites, and it's
2026 already, and we have to launch
100,000 satellites by 2030.
That's a lot of launches that have to
happen between now and then. That may
explain the need for more launch sites,
but where
>> the goal for a rocket is to get to space
in the most efficient and effective way
possible. And engineers spend hundreds
of millions of dollars trying to finesse
what does that efficiency look like? But
eventually comes down to two things. How
much fuel can I put on the rocket? And
how much mass can I put on top of the
lift? So they're always playing with
that equation. Well, the geography has
an important part in here this because
in order to achieve escape velocity, a
rocket has to achieve 17,500 mph.
And the Earth closer to the equator
spins faster than it does at the poles.
What that translates into is you could
put more satellites up with less of a
smaller rocket. And so the goal of most
spaceports is to try and get to the as
close to the equator as possible. But
why does it take me to Dominican
Republic?
>> So what we ended up doing about 3 years
ago was doing a technical feasibility
study. We looked at everything we could
possibly look at. But as we did our
analysis, it started shifting to
paradales which has a relatively low
population and because it's on the
coastline and because people don't live
in the water, we have almost a straight
shot to orbit without hazarding the
public.
>> So if something goes wrong, it goes in
the ocean.
>> That's right. So that's why a lot of our
space ports are built next to the coast
is not necessarily because of the water.
It's because of the low population. It's
not really about whether the rocket
explodes or whether the rocket gets to
orbit. It's all about public safety.
>> Safety is no small concern in the new
space race as we saw just last month
when Jeff Bezos Blue Origin rocket test
blew up in spectacular fashion. and
liftoff.
>> Along with the expected trillion dollar
IPO of Elon Musk's SpaceX, it's a
reminder of just how public the failures
and successes can be in this business
and how big the players are.
>> The pad will be 2 miles to the coast.
>> That's one reason that Burton would
rather work with them than against them.
>> You are though competitive with SpaceX,
right? Most of the feedback that we have
gotten from all the commercial operators
is they would like the ground
infrastructure to be more responsive to
be more not we launch on this day we
launch on readiness and right now the
infrastructure and the processes are not
designed that way. So right now um
statutoily the office of commercial
space has 6 months to review it and give
you a decision. We're going to give you
a license in 45 days. That's very
attractive. We don't look at ourselves
as competitors to the rocket customers.
We look at us as enablers.
>> What's the attraction for investors and
what's been your experience so far on
people stepping up?
>> There is a large appetite right now for
space. This is kind of like the early,
you know, early internet age, if you
will. The problem is there's not very
many investment opportunities or good
investment opportunities to get into
space. The first phase of the spaceport
is going to be about $600 million of
investment. Um and uh the response that
we've gotten is has been really quite
significant.
>> As launch on demand prepares to break
ground later this year, a larger race is
already underway in Latin America. Space
infrastructure has become a [music] new
front in the US China rivalry.
>> China is aggressively making investments
in our hemisphere particularly in Latin
and South America. also partnerships
that they have made with Caribbean
nations to have aerospace applications,
satellite demonstrations,
civilian applications, also with
military application components to it.
>> A recent [music] report from the Select
Committee on the Chinese Communist Party
warned about China's growing space
footprint in the region, including more
than 10 satellite tracking stations.
Congresswoman Haley Stevens of Michigan
is a member of the committee.
>> This is a call to double down on the way
our system works and so we don't want to
be seeding ground to China. We don't
want to see them uh continuing to eat
our lunch uh with our neighbors and we
can win this race.
>> I guess you could look at it as a
marathon or maybe an ultramarathon, but
I don't see an end here. There is not a
clear finish line. Carrie Bingan is a
director of CSIS's Aerospace Security
Project.
>> Well, I thought what was really
interesting in the decades that we were
competing against the Soviet Union, so
much of what was happening in space, it
was fueled by government. I think what
you're seeing now, which really sets
this current era apart, is so much of
what's happening in space is commercial.
Over 80% of the satellites on orbit
today are commercial systems. a lot from
the United States, SpaceX, Starlink, but
many other countries are now players in
space. The technology is much more
distributed across the globe. Launch
costs are a lot cheaper. So, so any
country or even entity can put something
in orbit and much of that is now fueled
by private capital, not just taxpayer
dollars. China has ambitions to be the
world's space power.
their presence and their capabilities in
Latin America are part of that strategy.
They want access. They want influence.
They want to be able to band together
with these countries in bodies like the
United Nations to start shaping where
the standards are.
>> We started this program well before
people realized that China was, you
know, very interested in taking over
real estate in Latin America. as we have
gotten the Trump administration and
President Abbena's administration
together, they are aligned on what has
been called, you know, the the pivot to
the Western Hemisphere. So, I would call
the spaceport more of an artifact of the
decision to pivot to the Western
Hemisphere rather than, you know,
anything else. And we emphasize this is
run by a US company that is designed to
be commercial that is complimementaryary
not competitive with the spaceports in
the United States and we work very very
hard to make sure that they understand
we're a friend not a foe and so so much
so that when we have talked to the
president of we said we want to adopt
the US safety standards for launch and
re-entry and he he agreed and so if If
you're a customer that launches from the
United States, the standard will be the
same if you launch from the Dominican
Republic.
>> We have holes. We never thought that
missiles would be launched across the
southern hemisphere. So, we did not put
a lot of radars down in South America or
in Africa, for example. But we're
realizing we need to have coverage
[music] of of everything that's
happening in orbit. We're seeing China,
we're seeing Russia maneuver satellites
much more frequently.
Are they benign or do they have a hidden
weapon? Um, we don't know, but we know
that they're testing these kind of
capabilities and so you need to be able
to monitor that.
>> Are there restrictions on who can use
your spaceport?
>> We want to stay in line with US foreign
policy. And what do I mean by that? So
even though I'm a US company operating
in Dominican Republic, I need to make
sure that my host country, the US in
this case, is aligned with what I'm
doing. [music]
So if I sort of, you know, went kind of
off the off the beaten path, I would
essentially be cutting myself up from
the largest commercial market in the
world, which doesn't make much sense.
Launch on demands being aligned with the
US government on the geopolitics of
[music] space infrastructure in Latin
America is important to CatLage. But
make no mistake, at its heart, this US
spaceport company is a business, one
that Called believes will be a [music]
good one. So, we estimate that by about
the 10-year point after we hit full
operations, we'll be generating about $8
billion. And so, this will be the first
private [music] revenue generating
spaceport in the world. And the reason
why is was because we're leveraging all
the technology that's been invented.
We're bringing that here.
>> Coming up, from the Dominican Republic
to Bolivia for a look at another Latin
American country chasing US investment
with a president trying to shake things
up.
This is a story of rebranding a country.
Rodrigo Paz was elected president of
Bolivia in November, marking a major
shift for the country following two
decades of socialist rule. PA has a
mandate of economic reform, closer
relations with the United States, and
increased foreign investment. But as our
colleague David Guro found out, ideas
and execution are sometimes very
different things.
The Solar Deuni in Bolivia is the
country's crown jewel. It's a sprawling
salt flat on the Andian Alta Plano. So
large, it's visible from space. We are
at u 3,650
m [music] above sea level, my friend.
>> Very high.
>> Very high.
[music]
>> Bolivia's economy benefits from the
tourists who flock to the Solar from all
over the world. What the country's
leadership is banking on is what's
underneath this snow-like layer of salt.
>> So the lithium mining [music] just down
on the salt. The idea of the government
was like do some manufacturing batteries
or electric cars things like that but uh
you know it takes a long time of course
and also we need some technology from
outside you know
>> we're standing on top of one of the
largest lithium resources in the world
[music] and President Rodrigo P says if
the country can develop these reserves
it will transform Bolivia's struggling
economy improving the lives of some 12
million Bolivians.
>> Peru Peru, Bolivia, and Chile
collectively hold the largest
concentration of minerals in the world.
Peru generates $50 billion annually.
Chile generates $65 billion annually.
Bolivia
>> Bolivia possesses the highest
concentration of minerals of the three.
Yet we generate only 6 billion per year.
The question is why do we choose to be
poor?
>> After he was elected last October,
President P signaled Bolivia is open for
business. But as we discovered, there is
a disconnect between his rhetoric and
the realities on the ground. We arrived
in Le Paz to sit down with the president
as violent protests erupted across the
country, shut down parts of the city. We
got the go-ahead to climb through
barricades, part of a police perimeter
that protected Bolivia's Parliament
building and presidential palace.
We were told to wait in a cafe on a
mostly empty plaza.
And as the hours ticked by, we could
hear protesters just a few blocks away
throwing dynamite.
Tear gas hung in the air.
President Paw, we learned, was locked in
tense negotiations. Just before
midnight, we got word from one of his
adviserss the president would have to
postpone [music]
our interview. One week later, we
finally got our chance to talk with him.
It's been a busy week.
>> Three weeks.
>> Three weeks. Many of these protesters
are calling on you to resign, to step
down, and I'm wondering if there's a
point at which that will become
something that you would consider
>> in 5 years from now. When we conclude
our administration, Bolivia will be an
advanced nation grounded in a modernity
made necessary by new institutions,
a frontal assault on corruption, a
controlled fiscal deficit, and a clear
path towards growth within an open
economy governed by clear laws.
Moreover, it will be a country where
racial, regional, and cultural
differences are not exploited to fuel
political conflict. Where I hope I will
leave behind a government characterized
by pluralistic participation.
At a precarious moment for his
presidency, Rodri Pas has gotten public
[music] support from the Trump
administration. Secretary of State Marco
Rubio said the United States stands
squarely in support of Bolivia's
government. [music] Trump and his team
have embraced PZ's new vision for
Bolivia as they've welcomed wins by
other center-right politicians in Latin
America.
Trump
>> I met with President Trump. There is a
relationship regarding the geopolitical
and geoeconomic vision on the
continental level. Bolivia's vision is
very clear. Pragmatic is everything that
is functional for the development of our
economy of the economy of the people. We
will be seated so that we can
collaborate and be part of a global
vision. [applause]
>> I think that investors in general should
have the patience to follow the
situation and see, you know, how well he
pulls it off.
>> Hans Humes has spent his career
investing in frontier markets. He's the
chairman and CEO of Greylock Capital.
the markets generally give a pretty
positive tailwind
um when a right of center government
comes in. So getting the enthusiasm
putting it out there saying we're open
for investment great and then tapping
the markets when they did raising a
billion dollars I think you know was a
good signal. Everybody knows the Bolivia
story. It's an incredibly,
you know, commodity-wise,
it's kind of hard not to see it as a
really easy place to make money. It's
just the sort of the ethnic tensions
there that have always existed. And the
fact that they have a tradition of going
out in the streets, there's been a lot
of turnover of governments and as we're
seeing now, it's pretty easy to sort of
choke the economy.
>> Doing business in Bolivia has not
[music] been easy. And there's been talk
of harnessing its lithium for decades.
Today, a lithium plant owned by the
state is running at [music] just 15% of
capacity, and contracts that Chinese and
Russian companies signed with PA's
predecessor haven't been ratified by
Bolivia's Congress. In the near term,
Bolivia wants to boost tourism [music]
as a source of revenue, but the
longerterm vision is to do more with its
minerals.
>> The country's never been closed for
business, right? uh there there's always
been uh foreign investors coming in and
there's always been the ability to do
business but there was always
difficulties with the administration.
>> Jorge Chow is a senior partner at the
law firm Dentons based in La Paz and he
[music] spends a lot of his time working
with foreign investors on deals
involving Bolivia's natural resources.
foreign investors are are a little weary
and and and concerned right that their
rights won't be respected right and they
won't be able to carry out the project
in the terms that they that they want.
One of the main things uh in in some
strategic se sectors was that you needed
to be in an agreement with the
government and to the extent that you
weren't able to um
have a security that the government was
going to actually you know comply with
their side of the agreement that that
was that was a complicated situation. if
the government had too much of a say,
right? And and and you were not in a
position to, you know, uh make your
rights uh upheld, then of course that
gives everyone pause. The fact that the
Bolivia left the the exit convention and
uh was reluctant to enter into
international arbitration agreements,
that gave a lot of investors pause.
>> What needs to happen over the course of
the next year? for President P has a
5-year term, but uh for Bolivia to get
on track in the way that he wants it to,
what needs to happen in in a year's
time,
>> they need to see results of some sort,
right? So, some of those results have
already been seen, right? Uh we need to
stabilize the economy. [music]
>> To do that, Bolivia has turned to the
International Monetary Fund. It's in
negotiations for a $3 billion package
that P says would go towards social
organizations, entrepreneurship, and
economic development. [music]
But just 6 months into President P's
term, many Bolivians seem to be running
out of patience. Protests have followed
his decision to cut fuel subsidies. And
with inflation at 14% as recently as
April, the pressure has mounted. But the
calls for PA to step down go beyond
economics. Some opposition groups have
sought to force him from office
entirely, and the blockades they've
erected are now causing shortages of
food, gasoline, and medical supplies.
Do you see any missteps, things he could
have done differently or should have
done differently?
>> Pulling away subsidies, it's a uh it's
the right thing to do.
Um but it's a wrong thing to do if you
don't manage it well. One of the
problems that you see in a lot of these
countries, whether it's Ecuador,
Bolivia, is, you know, you want to head
off people going into the street. So
maybe there he should have
tried to have a bit of a negotiation on
the timing of removing subsidies, slow
walking it. He probably should have
recognized that stylistically he might
have wanted to do a Malay, but
practically speaking, he didn't have,
you know, he didn't have the national
support um that Malay did.
I imagine there are investors outside
the country who are watching what's
unfolding in Bolivia and wondering how
much has changed if it's still status
quo that there are protests and
demonstrations and overarching
uncertainty. What would you say to those
investors or those prospective investors
about what Bolivia is like today and how
welcoming Bolivia is of outside
investment?
We were promised 20 years of the
possibility of becoming a Switzerland.
That was the promise made 20 years ago.
20 years later, they have left behind a
shattered economy, stripped of the
natural resources such as hydrocarbons
that we would otherwise export.
>> We possess abundant hydrocarbon
reserves. Yet they have left us without
the necessary investments and without
the security required to ensure that
those wishing to invest in Bolivia find
clear rules and laws during this
transition. Laws that would foster an
investment safe environment in Bolivia.
>> President P is pushing for changes to
Bolivia's legal framework to make the
country more businessfriendly. [music]
He's still making his pitch to the
Bolivian people and also to outside
investors. The country just held its
first dollar denominated bond sale in
almost 5 years. What would it take for
you personally to invest in Bolivia at
this point in time?
>> We own some of the bonds. I mean, we're
already in there. We're bond guys. We're
Yeah, I'm not going to buy a lithium
mine. I have friends who might be, you
know, I just wouldn't know what to do
with it. But, um, yeah, I think the
riskreward now it's tricky. I'm not
going to put 50% of the portfolio in it,
but I think it's a good risk return.
We've had a lot of bad headlines. I'm
willing to keep the focus there cuz the
macro story is a good one.
>> That does it for us here at Wall Street
Week. I'm David Weston. See you next
week for more stories of capitalism.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This episode of Wall Street Week covers three distinct topics: the geopolitical and economic pressures facing the US dollar, the impact of artificial intelligence on the publishing and content creation industry, and the emerging space economy and its intersection with US-China rivalry in Latin America. Additionally, it highlights Bolivia's economic reform efforts under its new president, assessing the risks and opportunities for foreign investors in a volatile landscape.
Videos recently processed by our community