The Hidden Cost Of 'Keeping It Together' (High Functioning Depression)
459 segments
In psychiatry, we define a depressive
episode by impairment of function. Is
your energy level so low that you can't
go to work, you can't fulfill your
family responsibilities or take care of
yourself physically, feed yourself, etc.
So, when we think about depression, we
think about being unable to function. I
don't know if you guys have seen these
posts about, you know, the messes that
depressed people will have in their
homes that take hours or days to clean
up. It turns out that there is a
condition called high functioning
depression which is not technically
recognized in the DSM5 or psychiatric
diagnosis which is actually potentially
even more common than regular
depression. So if we look at sort of a a
depressive episode the incidence or
prevalence is somewhere between 5 and
7.8%.
So in a given year about 5 to 8% of
people will have a depressive episode.
If we look at high functioning
depression the ranges are a lot wider.
It's somewhere between 5 and 41%.
With about an average rate, if you pull
together these 113 studies, the rate is
around 11%. So, what separates people
who have a mood disorder from high
functioning depression is kind of
shocking. It is an over reliance on
coping strategies. So, I want you all to
think about this. Okay? So, let's say
I'm in a in my life, I'm struggling in
some way. Let's say I'm a new parent.
Really common for high functioning
depression. And as I'm not sleeping
well, as my my spouse is struggling as
well, we have a newborn at home who's
crying all the time. My spouse is taking
maternity leave, but I still have to go
into work. You know, it's really
important that I go into work because
now I'm providing for a family of two.
So, I'm under a ton of stress. And so,
the key thing here is that people who
don't crack under the stress and get
into a full-blown depressive episode
will often times end up with high
functioning depression. And that's
what's so confusing about it. The way
that people are able to continue plowing
forward is because they're actually
using coping mechanisms to keep it
together. The problem is that while
these coping mechanisms may allow you to
keep it together, they don't address the
underlying problems. So, when I'm trying
to figure out, does this person have
high functioning depression? I'll kind
of ask myself a question. When I sit
with this person and I listen to them
talking about their lives, does this
sound like someone who is has a boat
that is taking on water? They're there's
damage to the hull and it's taking on
water and they've got a pail and they're
scooping water out. If when I sit with
someone, this is sort of the feel that I
get from them. If it kind of feels like
they're working really hard to barely
not drown, that's when I think about
high functioning depression. So really
great example of this is the medical
students that I used to work with. So
you know these are kids that work really
hard to get into medical school. They
start studying arguably in high school
and spend four years in college here in
the United States. They study really
hard for the MCAT and many of their
friends end up in med school. Many of
their friends don't end up in med
school. It's incredibly competitive. And
so they're thrilled to finally be in med
school and now I'm going to be a doctor.
And then they wake up maybe somewhere in
first year, second year, third year,
fourth year and they wake up one day and
they really realize, oh my god, I
actually don't like medicine. I don't
like patients. Like I had this idea of
what being a doctor is, but I hate like
spending time in the clinic or spending
time in the hospital and dealing with
patients. This sort of happened for me.
This is like how I wound up in
psychiatry. So when I was in med school,
I was planning on becoming an oncologist
like my dad and doing holistic cancer
treatment and saving lives and all that
good stuff. And then one day I was in
the clinic and and I was working as a
with a primary care physician, a GP. And
I realized that like I had to look at a
lot of feet, like a lot of like
diabetic, ulcerous, smelly feet. You
know, this is stuff that I I sort of
appreciate that I had this training, but
you have to deal with a lot of really na
nasty smells. If y'all have worked in a
hospital, you know the smell of sea
diff, claustrodium difficil, right? So,
there's like just a lot of nasty smells
that come with being like a real
life-saving doctor. And I just wasn't
super interested in that. And what I
loved about psychiatry, there's a lot of
bad smells in psychiatry, too, if you're
working with homeless population and in
the emergency room, but it's not like
you're, you know, dealing with it day in
and day out. And then I have this
outpatient practice where I'm working
with high functioning depression, highly
successful people which is just so
different. And most of them smell pretty
good and have good hygiene. So this is
sort of what happens is we have this
kind of idea of okay like I I worked so
hard to get into med school and I don't
want to quit. I don't want to be a
quitter. I want to be a gunner. I want
to be a doctor. I want to be successful.
And what we find in high functioning
depression is that there is an
overemphasis
on the idea of role or identity. So I
would say to a te every single patient
that I've worked with who has HFD is
obsessed with the idea of living up to a
role or embodying an identity. If you
all want more information about what the
root of those problems looks like, I
definitely recommend y'all check out Dr.
K's guide where I have five videos about
the most common problems like the the
most common psychological complexes that
I see in my patients. Turns out these
are also the most watched videos in the
depression guide. Also really common for
new new parents, right? So like I want
to be a good dad. I want to be a good
dad. And good dads don't cry. Good dads
don't take days off. Good dads are there
for their wives, there for their kids.
I'm going to be a present dad. I'm not
going to be a deadbeat dad. I'm going to
spend time with my kids. I'm going to
teach him how to cook. I'm going to
teach him how to ride the bike and I'm
going to be a good husband. I'm going to
be an involved husband and I'm going to
be a provider and I'm going to go to
work and I'm going to work really hard.
I'm going to get promoted and I'm going
to take my kids on vacation. This is
what it's like. They sort of have this
idea of living up to a role. And
whenever they face hardship, they will
double down on this idea of role. Now,
here's what's really scary. So when we
get overly involved with a sense of
identity or role that we want to live up
to, this probably activates the part of
our brain called the default mode
network. The default mode network is the
part of our brain that allows us to
reflect on ourselves. So when I think
about myself, this kind of metacognition
is when the default mode network
activates. The tricky thing is that when
the default mode network activates or
hyperactivates, this is associated with
feelings of depression. So when I have
patients who are do have mood disorders
or even HFD, right, what we tend to see
in them is that they think a lot about
themselves. Oh my god, I need to do
better. Like literally the content of
their mind is about themselves in some
way. Now this isn't like narcissistic.
It's not like they're thinking they're
great. It is literally if you like map
out their thoughts, they're like
thinking like, oh my god, like I need to
do better. I need to be better. Right?
So they're thinking about themselves in
a metacognitive way. And we also know
from many studies on things like
ketamine. So ketamine is probably the
fastest acting treatment for depression.
And the way that it works is it
basically shuts off the default mode
network. And when I sit with these
patients who are have full-blown
depression, you know, they're usually
thinking about how much like they're
losers and how their family would be
better off without them and how other
people are so much better than they are.
So it's once again thinking about
yourself, thinking about yourself,
thinking about yourself. Now in HFD,
when the default mode network turns on,
there's sort of a different spin to it,
which is they focus on role or identity,
right? Like I want to be a good person.
I'm not going to give up. I'm not going
to be this loser. So, they sort of take
their lived experience of the moment.
This is what I'm feeling. This is what
it's like to be me. It's tiring. It's
exhausting. I'm frustrated with my wife.
I'm angry at my kids. I'm regretting
being a parent, which is such a scary
thought to have. Like, oh my god. Like,
I'm annoyed with my child. Incredibly
common, right? I sometimes wish I had
never had kids. Incredibly common. So
they have all of these negative thoughts
and then they run away from them. They
push them away and they go towards this
sort of idealized role. We also see in
high functioning depression a high
amount of avoidant coping. So avoidant
coping involves denial of what you were
feeling or even denial of your
circumstances. So we'll see some of this
weird like toxic positivity kind of
stuff where they'll like you know tell
themselves all kinds of things to deny
their experience. So if I am frustrated
with my kid cuz I haven't slept in 6
months and I'm trying to be a good
husband and trying to be a good father,
then instead of like being a [ __ ] about
it, I'm going to like man the [ __ ] up
and like oh my god like I have all these
negative feelings like [ __ ] that man.
Like I'm not going to be that loser. I'm
not going to be someone who dislikes
their kids. I'm not going to be that. So
they push or deny those feelings away or
they even deny their circumstances. I'm
so privileged. I'm so lucky. Which is
true, right? So this is the key thing to
remember about high functioning
depression. These are coping mechanisms.
These are things that are actually
adaptive and healthy when used in a
short-term scenario. So if my boat is
taking on water, I absolutely want to
have pumps or a pale to like bail that
water out while I engage in more
permanent fixes. The problem with high
functioning depression is that these
people will rely on these coping
mechanisms to power through while they
keep going. The other really scary thing
is that avoidant coping is actually
associated with a higher level of
suicidality, especially in men. And so
this is sort of what happens with HFD is
that we're coping, we're surviving, I
don't want to be a loser, I don't want
to give up. And then eventually things
will start to crack. There's one other
coping mechanism that we have to talk
about. And this one is really
fascinating. So this is sublimation. So
when people have HFD, they do something
really interesting, which is that when
they feel like quitting, they actually
double down and do an even better job.
So like this is where I don't know if
you guys watch anime. Like my kids are
watching Naruto right now which is like
lots of fun because I watched Naruto
like 20 years ago and wow the show is
moves so slowly like in one episode
there's so little that goes on but
anyway so if you sort of look at like
the way that our society glorifies
powering through right so like when
someone feels like quitting and oh my
god I'm crying and I'm sad and I'm a
loser and they're like no I'm not going
to do that I'm going to get better. So
all of this shown in anime is about like
taking that weakness and turning it into
badassness. In psychiatry, in
psychology, we call this the process of
sublimation. So this is something that
happens like it's literally been studied
in medical students where you feel like
quitting when you're in undergrad and
you're thinking about going to medical
school. You feel like quitting. And what
you do is you take those feelings,
you're like, I'mma show that quitter in
me. I'm gonna do even better. I'm going
to work even harder. So some people
discover this really really interesting
kind of toxic but wonderful coping
mechanism of taking that negative energy
and doubling down into effort. And so
these people will become usually pretty
successful, right? Because instead of
quitting, I'm now working twice as hard.
I'm going to show them and I'm going to
show myself. They do this really
interesting inner alchemy. The problem
is that as these people continue to do
this, they wind up in a place that is
really not healthy or happy because
maybe the reason that I wanted to quit
med school was because I didn't like
being a doctor. But if I use sublimation
and double down and show the world that
I'm not a quitter, I will end up in a
profession I don't enjoy. Right? So
that's like really scary and that's what
I see in high functioning depression. I
see people who come into my office and
have a midlife crisis or a quarter life
crisis and these are people who when
they felt like quitting they didn't want
to be a loser so they kept going and
then they end up getting promoted which
is great on the surface except now
you've got 5 years into this career that
you don't enjoy and then you've got 10
years into this career that you don't
enjoy because you're not a quitter. So,
it's kind of scary, right? Because then
then you're sort of in this situation
where it's like, "Okay, do you want to
not be a quitter, but end up miserable
every day doing something that you don't
enjoy?" And people with HFD will be
like, "Fuck yeah, son. That's exactly
what I want." So, this is when things
get really scary because what we see
with HFD is that a lot of people end up
cracking. Okay? they'll end up sort of
the coping mechanisms. Since you're sort
of propagating a system that you're not
happy with, you're denying your negative
feelings, you're always doubling down
and pushing forward, you may wind up in
a situation that you don't enjoy at all.
And at some point, sometimes what
happens is you you've been bailing water
for so long that you get exhausted and
eventually things will end up overtaking
you. There's about a 3 to four times
risk uh compared to the regular
population of people with high
functioning depression. winding up
depressed eventually. So there's about a
300 to 400% risk that at some point your
coping mechanisms mechanisms will fail.
Now for a lot of people this doesn't
happen, right? So just because there's a
three to four-fold risk doesn't mean
it's permanent by any means or that it's
going to happen to everybody. I've
worked with a lot of people who are like
parents who have a really tough period.
And once they start sleeping again and
processing their emotions and start
having sex again, you know, then things
can actually get a lot better. So it's
not that this happens to everybody, but
eventually things do kind of feel
overwhelming. So now the question
becomes, okay, so if you've got high
functioning depression, what do you do
about it? And so this is where we have
to understand a couple of basic things.
The first is that coping mechanisms are
great, but you have to solve your
underlying problems, right? If my uh
boat is taking on water, I got to patch
that up. So often times what I'll do
with with people who have HFD is the
first thing that we'll do is take a
serious look at your life. And what
we'll sort of do is I'll I'll kind of
give this exercise where like nothing is
off the table. Okay. So in psychotherapy
this becomes really important because
when I offer reflective listening right
when someone says yeah I'm kind of tired
from having you know kids and stuff like
that like I want to be a good dad but
you know I'm tired. And then sometimes
I'll be like yeah man it really sucks
dude like you know is there any part of
you that regrets having children? Right?
And you got to ask that question in a
very specific way. You got to create a a
space that is safe. Because if I ask
them, do you regret having children?
They're going to be like the avoidant
coping mechanism. Well, no. Denial of
problem. No, I'm lucky. I'm blessed. So
many people struggle to have children
and I should be grateful. It's such a
privilege. But if you pay attention to
their words, what you'll notice is that
there's little cracks around their toxic
positivity. The first thing that you
have to do is acknowledge that you
actually have problems and let those
negative emotions come to the surface.
The second thing that we have to focus
on with high functioning depression is
this idea of a role. And the problem
with this is that often times what my
patients will do is they've invested so
much in the role that it feels really
hard to quit. Right? So I had this idea
of being a doctor when I was like 15
years old and I invested my high school
years. I invested my college years. I
invested so much and now I don't want to
quit. They have this idea of being a
quitter. So what I'll ask my patients is
is maintaining the role worth
sacrificing your life and ultimately
overcoming high functioning depression
is about understanding that you are
using these coping mechanisms to
propagate a life that is fundamentally
flawed. And as we start peeling back
those layers then we can get to the root
of the problem which is ultimately what
you have to solve. So, if y'all are
struggling with waking up every day and
feeling like there's no joy in life, if
you have spent your whole life devoting
yourself to a particular role, consider
high functioning depression and consider
talking to someone to get some help
about it.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The video discusses "high-functioning depression" (HFD), a condition not formally recognized in the DSM-5, which is characterized by an over-reliance on coping strategies to maintain functionality despite underlying distress. Unlike typical depression, HFD sufferers often appear successful but are internally struggling, sometimes described as a boat taking on water with a pail to bail it out. This condition is more prevalent than regular depression, with estimates ranging from 5% to 41%. Key indicators include an overemphasis on role or identity, avoidant coping mechanisms (like toxic positivity), and sublimation (doubling down on effort when feeling like quitting). These coping mechanisms, while adaptive in the short term, prevent addressing underlying issues and can lead to a sense of unfulfillment or even exacerbate depressive symptoms. The video also touches on the role of the default mode network in the brain, which, when hyperactivated, is associated with rumination and feelings of depression. For those struggling with HFD, the advice is to acknowledge underlying problems, allow negative emotions to surface, and re-evaluate the importance of maintaining a specific role at the expense of personal well-being. The risk of eventual breakdown or a full depressive episode is significantly higher for individuals with HFD.
Videos recently processed by our community