HomeVideos

Johann Hari: They’re Lying To You About The Side Effects Of Ozempic!

Now Playing

Johann Hari: They’re Lying To You About The Side Effects Of Ozempic!

Transcript

4240 segments

0:00

we've not spoken for 2 years but I have

0:02

to say you look remarkably different so

0:05

I lost three stone in a year and there's

0:07

secret to that statement Johan Hari the

0:11

bestselling author who's using his own

0:13

body to unearth the extraordinary

0:15

benefits and disturbing risks of the new

0:17

weight loss drugs OIC it is literally

0:20

the hottest drug in the country right

0:22

now I really worry about the risk of

0:24

these drugs you're nine times more

0:26

likely to get this particular condition

0:28

which is excruciatingly pain for and

0:30

these drugs are working very hard on key

0:33

parts of your brain in fact there are 12

0:35

significant risks and we'll get into

0:36

that but it seems extraordinary that we'

0:38

reached the point where we would inject

0:40

ourselves with a potentially risky drug

0:41

to stop us from eating and we've had 40

0:44

Years of relentlessly promoting diet and

0:46

exercise as the only solutions and only

0:48

10% of people really do lose huge

0:51

amounts of weight on diets and keep it

0:52

off but now we have the most effective

0:54

tool for self- starvation human beings

0:56

have ever come up with when I started

0:57

taking zpic I was literally 80% % less

1:00

hungry than I normally am these drugs

1:02

really do massively reduce or reverse

1:04

obesity and a few years from now we'll

1:06

have 50% of the population taking it the

1:08

new miracle drug now this is when I go

1:11

through the 12 big risks some of which

1:13

have not really been explained to the

1:14

public So within a year of stopping you

1:17

regain 70% of the weight you've lost

1:19

muscle mass loss is a real problem

1:21

there's concern that it may be causing

1:23

suicidal feelings and then there's one

1:24

of the really big risks and it's

1:26

absolutely Grim beyond belief and that

1:28

is

1:30

congratulations Dio gang we've made some

1:33

progress 63% of you that listen to this

1:35

podcast regularly don't subscribe which

1:38

is down from

1:40

69% our goal is 50% so if you've ever

1:44

liked any of the videos we've posted if

1:46

you like this channel can you do me a

1:47

quick favor and hit the Subscribe button

1:49

it helps this channel more than you know

1:50

and the bigger the channel gets as

1:52

you've seen the bigger the guest get

1:54

thank you and enjoy this

1:57

[Music]

1:58

episode Yan we've not spoken for 2

2:03

years but I have to say you look

2:06

remarkably different there's a secret to

2:09

that Stephen really we can dig into yeah

2:13

what is the

2:14

secret so for me it started it's a kind

2:17

of weird story it started in the winter

2:19

of 2020 so it was that weird period when

2:22

kind of the world was opening up again

2:24

after the

2:25

pandemic and i' gained a lot of weight

2:27

in lockdown like loads of people

2:30

and because of that kind of weird moment

2:32

of reopening I went to a party for the

2:34

first time in like I don't know a year

2:36

and a half two years and it was a party

2:38

thrown by a kind of famous Hollywood

2:40

actor and on the way there I remember

2:42

thinking oh this is going to be kind of

2:44

funny because all these Hollywood people

2:46

are going to put on weight as well right

2:48

they're going to have gained weight what

2:49

are they going to look like so I

2:52

remember getting there looking around

2:55

and having this really weird feeling

2:59

because it's not just they hadn't gained

3:00

weight everyone was gaunt right like

3:03

everyone looked like their own Snapchat

3:05

filter like they had like higher

3:06

cheekbones they looked cleaner and

3:09

clearer and

3:10

sharper and I was kind of wandering

3:12

around feeling bit like oh [ __ ] and I

3:14

bumped into a friend of mine on the

3:16

dance floor and I said to her what it

3:18

looks like um looks like everyone really

3:20

did do Pates during

3:22

lockdown and she laughed and then she

3:24

looked at me and I S looked at her and

3:26

she said well you know it wasn't Pilates

3:28

right and I sort of looked at her

3:31

blankly and she pulled out her phone and

3:35

she showed she Googled an image and she

3:36

showed me an OIC pen and I didn't know

3:39

what it was and I said what are you

3:41

talking about and said it's a drug

3:42

everyone here is on this drug right not

3:44

just the Stars like their wives their

3:46

agents their agents kids everyone right

3:49

and I've been really thrown and then

3:51

over the next few days I I read a lot

3:53

about these these new weight loss drugs

3:55

and I've never I don't remember ever

3:57

coming across a topic where I felt so

4:02

deeply conflicted from the very

4:04

beginning and that conflict remained all

4:06

the way through right the subtitle to my

4:07

book is the extraordinary benefits and

4:10

disturbing risks of the new weight loss

4:11

drugs and that's even right from the

4:14

start I was I was aware that was that

4:17

was the the tension so the benefits are

4:19

kind of obvious right you know I'm older

4:21

than my grandfather ever got to be

4:23

because he died of a heart attack loads

4:24

of the men in my family get really fat

4:26

and die of heart attacks my uncle died

4:28

of a heart attack my dad had a lot of

4:29

heart problem problems um there's a lot

4:32

of evidence that obesity unfortunately

4:34

does cause a whole range of health

4:36

problems over 20000 diseases and

4:39

complications uh there's a lot of

4:40

evidence these drugs really do massively

4:42

reduce or reverse obesity the average

4:45

person who uses them as z p wovi loses

4:49

15% of their body weight in a year with

4:51

the new generation of the drugs the next

4:52

ones that are coming down the line the

4:54

average person loses 24% of their body

4:57

weight it's staggering it's just below

4:59

barrier atric surgery so I could see the

5:01

obvious health benefit and I could see

5:04

that the Alternatives that most of us

5:06

have been pursuing diets have not worked

5:08

well for most

5:10

people but at the same time I thought I

5:13

mean just I had so many doubts straight

5:16

away I thought well we've seen this

5:19

story before there have been lots of

5:21

miracle diet drugs that have been

5:22

announced they caus dramatic weight loss

5:24

at first and we always discover some

5:26

horrendous side effect that causes you

5:29

know cat Ric outcomes that mean the

5:30

whole thing has to be pulled I thought

5:33

that I

5:35

thought well we know what causes obesity

5:37

right the reason obesity is massively

5:39

increased is because of a complete

5:41

change in the food supply we eat

5:42

completely different food to what our

5:44

grandparents ate we need to deal with

5:46

that not kind of drug everyone I also

5:49

thought well what will happen to people

5:50

with eating disorders when they get a

5:52

hold of this what will this do to the

5:54

kind of positive changes that were

5:55

happening in accepting a kind of broader

5:57

range of Weights so I was

6:01

really deeply conflicted so to really

6:03

get to the bottom of this for my book

6:04

magic pill I I spent a year taking the

6:07

drugs and going on this big Journey all

6:09

over the world from rekovic in Iceland

6:11

to Minneapolis to Tokyo to interview the

6:14

leading experts in the world on these

6:16

drugs the biggest supporters the biggest

6:18

critics all sorts of uh kind of alleys

6:21

and avenues that follow from them and at

6:23

the end of it it's really weird I know

6:26

far more than I did before I know far

6:28

more about benefits and risks and far

6:29

more about what this is going to do to

6:30

the culture and it will be

6:33

massive but I'm still really

6:35

conflicted so if we if we start there

6:37

then you're at the party someone

6:39

mentions this zmek thing to you can have

6:41

you got the zmek um pen on you I have it

6:44

as a a prop you've got it here okay so

6:47

it's very simple um you it's just a

6:50

little pen it's like um an epip pen so

6:52

you take that you uh put on the little

6:55

lid I won't take it out because I need

6:56

this one later but the um although this

6:58

one's empty you put a little you twist a

7:01

little needle onto there and you inject

7:04

yourself with it and you inject yourself

7:05

once a week and it's really strange the

7:09

effect it has I remember the first day I

7:12

took the

7:14

injection couple of days later I

7:16

remember waking

7:17

up and I was lying in bed and I had this

7:20

weird feeling you know feeling when you

7:21

wake up and you're not quite with it and

7:23

you think what am I feeling and I was

7:24

struggling to articulate it and I I was

7:26

I thought I felt mly nauseous which

7:28

everyone gets when they start taking but

7:29

that wasn't the thing that was puzzling

7:31

me and then I

7:33

realized I'd woken up and I wasn't

7:35

hungry I don't remember that ever

7:37

happening to me before I mean don't mean

7:38

that as an exaggeration I I used to be

7:40

woken up every day like really hungry

7:43

often I would be woken up by hunger by

7:46

my stomach rumbling and I went on my

7:49

kind of typical routine for the day I

7:51

went to this Cafe just around the corner

7:53

from where I live and I ordered the same

7:55

thing I would always order which was a

7:57

kind of big kind of a Brown roll with

8:00

lots of chicken and mayo in it and I had

8:03

like three mouthfuls and I was full I

8:05

just didn't want to eat

8:06

anymore I remember leaving I remember

8:08

Tatiana the woman who works in the cafe

8:10

kind of shouting after me to see if I

8:11

was Ill or

8:12

something and then for lunch I went to

8:14

the same place I always go or went at

8:16

the time next to my office there's a

8:18

Turkish kind of restaurant I went there

8:21

I ordered a Mediterranean lamb again I

8:24

had like three or four mouthfuls I

8:26

wasn't hungry it was like the kind of

8:29

had come down on my appetite I was

8:31

literally 80% less hungry than I

8:32

normally am and it basically stayed that

8:36

way from then on it was a very uh

8:39

physically and psychologically strange

8:41

experience so on the on the on the pen

8:44

itself cuz I just want to make sure I

8:45

fully understand this is that that

8:47

little pen you have in your hand for

8:48

people that can't aren't watching on

8:49

video there's a it kind of looks like a

8:51

big sharpie yeah exactly and is that one

8:54

dose yeah there's load of doses in there

8:56

so you twist the base yeah and

9:00

um that each time you twist it it would

9:02

release with this pen 1 milligram okay

9:04

yeah and how many twists you get out of

9:06

one pen uh I think each one contains

9:09

four dozes yeah and how much does that

9:11

cost so it varies massively because as

9:14

you know I live half in the US half in

9:15

Britain a lot of the time um so in

9:17

Britain this cost you at the moment

9:19

about £250 a month in the US it's way

9:22

more like $800 a month so £250 a month

9:25

how many sort of doses do I get for that

9:27

£250 you that would cover your whole

9:29

month so each month you'd have to pay

9:30

£250 you get four doses in each one and

9:33

you said in the US it's way more way

9:35

more how much more so it's about $800

9:37

between 800 and 1,200 bearing in mind

9:39

there' have been lots of shortages which

9:40

I'm sure we'll talk about so the price

9:42

has kind of been a bit sensitive to how

9:44

much is actually available at any given

9:46

time okay interesting and are these

9:49

drugs

9:50

new relatively so I interviewed the

9:53

scientists who played the key role in

9:55

the breakthroughs that led to the

9:56

development of the drugs and then

9:57

scientists who worked on it at every

9:59

stage

10:00

so in one sense they're not that new

10:01

diabetics have been using them on

10:03

license now for 18 years so for obesity

10:07

they're relatively new for diabetes

10:08

they've been around for nearly 20 years

10:10

and it was fascinating talking to the

10:12

scientists involved because one of the

10:15

things that's really weird about this is

10:16

there's a huge debate about how they

10:17

even work so there's certain things that

10:19

we know for sure so if you now ate

10:23

something right you it don't matter what

10:25

it is after a while a hormone would

10:28

start to be produced it in your body

10:30

called

10:30

glp1 and that is one of many gut

10:33

hormones that would start to be created

10:35

and it's basically glp1 is a natural

10:37

signal saying Stephen you've had enough

10:39

stop eating right just stop now right

10:41

but gp1 natural glp1 only remains in

10:43

your system for a couple of minutes and

10:45

then it's washed away so if you sort of

10:46

push through it you can carry on eating

10:48

right most people do stop when they get

10:50

the signal um so what these drugs do is

10:54

they simulate glp1 they inject into you

10:57

an artificial copy of glp 1 but instead

11:00

of that glp1 remaining in your system

11:02

for a few minutes and then disappearing

11:03

it stays in your system for a whole week

11:06

so when I go to that cafe and I eat the

11:08

thing I'd normally eat my system is

11:11

filled with signals that say you're

11:12

already full Johan you don't need

11:14

anymore right so that was initially that

11:17

is definitely a key part of how it works

11:19

and it was initially thought that these

11:21

drugs worked on your gut right these gp1

11:24

is a hormone that's made in the gut um

11:27

it's thought that the effect was it

11:28

slows down your gut it slows down

11:30

gastric emptying that is definitely

11:32

happening but The Cutting Edge science

11:34

and the kind of leading neuroscientists

11:36

that I interviewed now believe actually

11:38

it primarily has an effect on your brain

11:40

it changes what you want and how you

11:43

want it which brings with it a huge

11:46

parallel set of both benefits and risks

11:48

interesting so it's once a week and you

11:51

basically feel Fuller for a whole week

11:54

from one injection yeah not everyone

11:57

gets to that state immediately some

11:59

people it takes longer some people the

12:00

side effects are just intolerable and

12:02

they can't take it at all or they can't

12:04

continue to take it and I interviewed

12:05

plenty of people who were in that

12:07

position but for most

12:09

people the best way I can describe it is

12:13

imagine you just had Christmas dinner

12:15

yeah and I came up to you so you're

12:16

completely bloated you're lying on the

12:18

sofa and I came up to you and said hey

12:20

Steven I got you a Big Mac here it is

12:22

and you be like I mean you could

12:24

physically force yourself to eat that

12:25

Big Mac you might throw up but you

12:26

probably could eat it but you just don't

12:28

want to you feel full so it creates a

12:31

very rapid sense of fullness in response

12:33

to far so I used to eat 3,200 calories a

12:36

day roughly I now eat about

12:39

1,800 there a huge drop and the benefits

12:43

are kind of obvious of that but there

12:45

are really big costs I discovered

12:47

there's in fact 12 really big risks and

12:48

there's all sorts of Cu at first when

12:51

you hear all this you're like well this

12:52

is just kaching win win right who

12:53

wouldn't want this but there's a lot of

12:56

risks and downsides as well so I want to

12:58

get on to all those risks and downsides

13:00

but one of the I think rebuttal that

13:02

some people would have when they hear

13:03

this um is kind of contrary to the

13:05

reaction I think you expect which is

13:08

Johan I really love eating food I really

13:11

really enjoy the process of eating food

13:12

aren't you losing happiness because food

13:15

gives a lot of people happiness in

13:17

various ways so aren't you a little bit

13:19

annoyed now that you've lost your desire

13:21

to have you know that role that you used

13:24

to have for breakfast in the morning

13:25

hasn't that taken something from you

13:27

this is a big drawback for lots of

13:28

people I think I'm quite unusual so I'll

13:30

explain how most people feel about this

13:31

then I'll explain how I feel about it um

13:33

you're absolutely right even yenil Holst

13:35

who was one of the scientists who

13:37

developed o zenic said look for most

13:40

people it's just a life without pleasure

13:43

in food is just unbearable and after a

13:45

couple of years they just give up

13:46

because they want to enjoy life right

13:48

and one of the key things that gives us

13:50

pleasure throughout the day is eating uh

13:53

and a lot of people feel that way if you

13:54

look at for example Jay Raina a

13:56

brilliant food critic here in Britain

13:58

you know he just described how he

14:00

started taking it he would go to the

14:02

best restaurants in Paris places he

14:05

loves and he

14:07

just couldn't get any pleasure out of it

14:10

so for him it was just awful it's a very

14:13

common complaint that it drains pleasure

14:14

from

14:15

food honestly I I had almost the

14:18

opposite experience but I want to stress

14:19

I do think I'm quite unusual so I

14:22

realized when I started taking these

14:23

drugs one of the fascinating things

14:25

about these drugs is they will bring to

14:27

the surface whatever psychological

14:29

issues you had with food right because

14:31

it so radically interrupts your eating

14:33

patterns um and that can be very

14:36

challenging for a lot of people I'm sure

14:37

we'll get into that but for me I

14:39

realized how much of my eating from when

14:42

I was very

14:43

young the pleasure I got from food was

14:46

not primarily from like tasting it and

14:48

savoring it the pleasure I got from food

14:51

was mostly from kind of a feeling of

14:52

stuffing myself so stuffing is like you

14:55

you do it at Christmas din we all do it

14:57

sometimes stuffing is when you sort of

14:59

eat deliberately beyond the point at

15:01

which you're full and you feel it as a

15:02

physical sensation you can feel it sort

15:04

of pushing up on your esophagus and out

15:05

on your stomach and I think from when I

15:08

was very young I grew up in a very

15:09

violent and crazy environment I think

15:12

one of the ways I learned to cope with

15:15

that there are many productive and

15:17

positive ways I learn to cope with that

15:18

but one of the kind of downsides is I

15:20

learned to really eat to soothe myself

15:21

and I would stuff and when I started

15:23

taking o zenic I actually couldn't eat

15:25

like that anymore you you can't stuff

15:27

yourself I would literally throw up if I

15:29

you know tried to stuff myself so

15:31

actually for me it massively slowed down

15:34

my eating and I actually enjoy food a

15:36

fair bit more now I don't want to

15:37

overstate it I'm not a foodie I'm never

15:39

going to be that person but like I

15:41

remember going for dinner with one of my

15:43

friends I know maybe three or four

15:45

months after I started taking it and I

15:47

saying to me you know it's always been a

15:48

bit stressful to eat with you because

15:49

you eat so quickly but you don't seem to

15:52

really enjoy it and now you do actually

15:54

look like you're enjoying your

15:56

food but I stress again I don't think

15:59

I'm typical in that respect there are

16:00

far more people like J Raina than there

16:02

are like me I really want to go

16:05

into why people you know people's

16:07

relationship with food more generally um

16:10

but I wanted to close off on that what

16:11

you were saying about a Zex impact on

16:13

the brain you talked about gp1 in the

16:15

gut and the you know the impact that

16:17

hasn't making you feel satiated but you

16:19

also alluded to there's now research

16:21

that suggests it's doing something to

16:22

the brain as well this is totally

16:24

fascinating it opens up a whole new set

16:26

of potential benefits for these drugs in

16:28

relation to add

16:30

and a whole set of potential risks for

16:31

these drugs in relation to depression so

16:34

I want to stress there is very big

16:37

scientific disagreement about what is

16:39

happening in the brain in relation to

16:41

these drugs and it's a bit like when you

16:43

interview people it's like it's like

16:44

looking at a picture that's just coming

16:46

into shape so a year from now we'll know

16:48

much more than we do now but what was

16:52

discovered this actually discovered in

16:53

the 90s um here in London at Hammer

16:56

Smith hospital was that in fact we don't

16:59

only have glp receptors in our guts we

17:02

have glp receptors in our brains in fact

17:04

glp one can be made in the brain right

17:07

which is fascinating it could also made

17:08

in your thyroid which is very

17:09

significant I'm sure we'll come back to

17:11

um so when you take these drugs um as

17:16

John Wilding one of the key figures in

17:18

the development of these drugs said to

17:19

me you can tag the drug which means that

17:21

you can sort of D it and you can give it

17:23

to animals and then cut open their

17:24

brains obviously you can't do that with

17:26

humans and when you do that when you

17:27

just give them the drug and you in their

17:29

brain afterwards what you find is this

17:31

drug goes everywhere in the brain it's

17:33

going all over the brain it is primarily

17:36

having a brain effect right and it

17:38

definitely also much more anecdotally

17:40

feels that way when you take it it feels

17:43

like you want different things right it

17:45

doesn't just feel like a physical

17:47

sensation of I'm full it feels I

17:49

remember taking my godsons to McDonald's

17:51

maybe a week after I started taking it

17:54

and I didn't want a McDonald's and then

17:55

one of my godsons saying to me who are

17:57

you and what have you done with Yan

17:58

right was so contrary to my preferences

18:01

and my fact um one of my low points in

18:04

life was Christmas Eve

18:06

2009 I went to my local branch of KFC

18:09

just around the corner from where we are

18:10

now cuz I used to live in here and I

18:12

said to the guy behind the counter my

18:13

standard order which is so gross I won't

18:15

repeat it and the guy behind the counter

18:17

said oh yoan I'm really glad you're here

18:18

wait a minute I was like all right and

18:20

he went off behind where they fry the

18:22

chicken and everything and he came back

18:24

with a massive Christmas card and

18:26

everyone was working that day and they'd

18:28

written to our best customer and they

18:30

all clapped me and one of the things

18:32

that was so terrible is I thought this

18:34

isn't even the Fried Chicken shop I come

18:35

to the most right how can this be

18:37

happening to me but so when you speak to

18:39

the The Cutting Edge neuroscientists and

18:40

I interviewed them in great depth

18:42

there's basically three theories about

18:45

what these drugs are doing to your brain

18:47

right very broadly I mean they this is a

18:49

quite crude way of putting it um so one

18:52

is you have in your brain something

18:54

called the reward system the reward

18:56

system is what motivates you to do

18:57

anything so you know you have sex you

19:00

eat you meet up with a friend your

19:02

reward centers hum right it's what makes

19:04

you feel good when you do something

19:06

pleasurable and one theory about these

19:09

drugs is they dampen your reward system

19:12

so the reason I don't want a Big Mac is

19:13

that a Big Mac is not as rewarding to me

19:15

as it would have been before I took

19:16

these drugs right that obviously brings

19:19

with it a set of risks because then you

19:22

go okay if it's dampening my reward

19:24

system for Big Mac is it dampening my

19:27

reward system for the things I love

19:29

writing reading there's a big debate

19:31

about this there's concern that in some

19:33

people it may be causing suicidal

19:35

feelings and in some people it may be

19:37

causing depression there is a warning on

19:38

the drug to that effect required by the

19:41

FDA the the fin drug agency in the

19:43

United States that's one concern but

19:46

there are other scientists who say that

19:48

we don't that that's not correct that um

19:51

that the suicide risk is not accurate

19:54

and that they don't work by dampening a

19:56

reward system some people like aelia G

19:59

who's at the University of um Alabama in

20:00

Birmingham said to me what he thinks

20:02

that it does is it resets your

20:04

preferences it's almost like taking your

20:06

phone back to the factory settings it

20:08

resets key elements of the kind of food

20:10

you want to a healthier level can I just

20:12

say on that sorry to interrupt but um I

20:14

was thinking constantly as you were

20:15

talking about your trip to McDonald's

20:17

and not wanting the McDonald's anymore I

20:19

I've come to see in my life that if I

20:21

have something unhealthy if I have sugar

20:23

or a cookie today I'm I feel like I'm

20:26

much more compelled to have another one

20:27

tomorrow I feel like I I I look back on

20:31

certain periods of my life where I

20:33

almost get into a bit of a sugar spiral

20:35

and it could be because of stress or

20:36

some other Factor but it made me think

20:37

that the sugar itself is somewhat

20:39

addicting so when you were talking I was

20:40

thinking is it is it not just a case

20:42

that you're consuming less sugar and you

20:46

know some of these addictive food

20:48

substances so you want it less the next

20:51

day if you know what I'm saying yeah

20:53

there's an experiment that proves you're

20:54

right but in a complicated way um can I

20:57

just finish off one thing about the

20:58

brain and then come back to that raised

20:59

a super important and and truthful point

21:03

the third theory about how it could be

21:04

working in the brain and this comes from

21:06

a scientist called Professor Paul Kenny

21:07

who actually did the experiment relates

21:09

to what you just said he argues that in

21:12

your brain you don't just have a reward

21:13

system you have something called the

21:14

satiety system and this is a crucial

21:17

concept for people who want to

21:18

understand these drugs and what's gone

21:20

wrong with our diets more generally to

21:21

understand satiety is just the feeling

21:23

of having had enough right we've all had

21:25

the feeling of being sated you're like

21:27

okay I'm done I don't want anymore we

21:28

get that with food sex all sorts of

21:30

things right you're just sated um he

21:33

argues that in your brain there there's

21:34

basically alongside the reward system

21:36

there's also a satiety system A system

21:38

that just says Stephen you've had enough

21:41

stop now and he argues that what these

21:43

drugs do is they dial up your satiety

21:45

system they don't dial down your reward

21:47

system right there's a huge and ongoing

21:49

debate about that what we do know is

21:51

they're having some really significant

21:52

effect on the brain and that has all

21:55

sorts of implications that we need to

21:56

think about when I was learning about

21:58

this

21:59

I remember

22:00

thinking this is a much more intimate

22:04

and risky transformation than when you

22:06

first hear oh I'm taking something that

22:07

affects my stomach right so there's a

22:10

lot there about the brain and

22:11

implications for addiction as well which

22:13

we can talk about but to come to the

22:14

thing you asked about which is so

22:16

important of all the things I learned

22:18

there was an experiment that kind of

22:20

freaked me out about this um because

22:22

obious I was trying to figure out well

22:24

how did we get to this point because at

22:26

first glance I can see how it seems

22:27

crazy in a way it did to me you know we

22:31

gained an enormous amount of weight in

22:33

the last 40 years I was born in 1979 the

22:36

year I was born 6% of British people

22:38

were obese it's now 26% right staggering

22:42

increase unprecedented in human history

22:45

and it seems extraordinary that we've

22:47

reached the point where we would inject

22:50

ourselves with a potentially risky drug

22:51

to stop us from eating it seems so

22:53

unnatural and so wrong and I was trying

22:56

well how did we get here right what

22:57

happened

22:59

which is why satiety is so important so

23:01

it's this experiment that I think helps

23:03

to understand that thing you were saying

23:04

about sugar it's done by this guy

23:06

Professor Paul Kenny who's the head of

23:08

neuroscience at Mount siai in New York

23:10

and a brilliant

23:12

neuroscientist so Paul grew up in Dublin

23:16

and he moved to the US when he was in

23:18

his 20s to do his PhD I think and he

23:20

moved to San Diego first and it quickly

23:23

clocked Americans do not eat like Irish

23:25

people right they eat much more sugar

23:27

much more fat they eat just much more

23:29

right and within being within like a

23:31

year of being there he'd gained I think

23:33

a stone and a half or something uh so he

23:35

gained I think it was 23 pound so it

23:37

gained a lot of weight and he started to

23:39

wonder sort of like the question you

23:40

were asking does this food when you

23:44

consume it change your brain in ways

23:47

that compel you to consume it more

23:49

what's going on so he designed an

23:51

experiment that sort of investigated

23:53

this uh which I've nicknamed cheesecake

23:55

park that's not its official name right

23:58

um you get a load of rats and you raise

24:00

them in a cage and they've just got the

24:02

kind of food that rats evolved to eat

24:04

over thousands of years it's pellets

24:05

based on their natural diet and if you

24:07

do that even though they've got far more

24:09

pellets than they could actually eat

24:11

they will eat enough to deal with their

24:13

hunger and then they just naturally stop

24:15

right so when they've got the kind of

24:16

food they evolve to have they never

24:18

become overweight or obese they just

24:20

stabilize their weight they've got a

24:22

kind of natural nutritional wisdom then

24:25

Professor Kenny introduced the American

24:27

diet to them

24:28

he fried up some bacon he bought some

24:30

Snickers bars and crucially he gives

24:32

them a load of cheesecake and they come

24:34

along and they nibble the cheesecake and

24:35

the other stuff and quite quickly they

24:38

just go wild for it they shun the food

24:41

they evolved to have and they just start

24:43

obsessively eating the cheesecake the

24:46

fried the fried bacon the Snickers bars

24:49

he described to me how they would like

24:50

he would put the cheesecake in and they

24:51

would just hurl themselves into the

24:53

cheesecake and then like eat their way

24:55

out and emerge like completely slicked

24:57

with the cheesecake so given this kind

24:59

of food all their nutritional wisdom

25:01

disappeared just went away and they

25:04

became obsessed with this new kind of

25:06

food um and as he put it to me within a

25:10

couple of days they were different

25:11

animals their all their health

25:12

indicators were worse they were

25:14

obsessively eating within a few weeks

25:16

they were their health was really bad

25:17

they became extremely obese and then he

25:20

varied the experiment even more in a way

25:22

it seemed to me as a former junk food

25:23

addict a little bit cruel he took all

25:26

the American diet away and they just

25:28

have the food they evolved to have the

25:30

food they used to eat right and he was

25:31

quite sure he knew what would happen

25:33

that they would eat a lot more of the

25:35

kind of natural food than they had

25:37

before and this would prove that junk

25:39

food expands your appetites that isn't

25:41

what happened what happened was much

25:43

worse they completely shunned the

25:45

natural food it was like they no longer

25:48

recognized it as food at all they just

25:50

refused to eat it they starved and it

25:52

was only when they were really starving

25:54

that they went back to eating the

25:55

natural food there's lots of human

25:57

examples of but there's something as

25:59

Professor Gerald M who's a nutritionist

26:01

at Harvard said to me there's something

26:03

about the food we're eating which I

26:05

think you're getting out in that

26:06

question which is undermining our

26:08

ability to know when to stop which is

26:10

how we got to the point where we so many

26:13

people 47% of Americans want to take a

26:15

drug that will make them stop I was

26:17

reading about this um thing you call the

26:20

Cheesecake Park in your book in Chapter

26:23

2 and the other sort of Step he took the

26:26

experiment to was the whole idea of

26:28

electrocuting the animals when they ate

26:30

certain foods and you say in the book

26:33

that he then um would electrocute the

26:35

animals while shining a yellow light in

26:37

their eyes so that they would eventually

26:38

become scared of this yellow light and

26:40

in the case of um the natural food when

26:42

he Shone the yellow light in their eyes

26:44

they would run away but even if you

26:46

Shone the yellow light in their eyes

26:47

while they were eating the junk food

26:48

they would stay and continue to eat the

26:50

cheesecake which kind of the conclusion

26:52

in Chapter 2 of your book as I've

26:53

written it here is and the thing this

26:56

came from the researcher if you're

26:58

exposed um to this food for a while Paul

27:00

concluded the desire for it is so great

27:03

that you will ignore all sorts of

27:04

negative consequences to eat it as we

27:07

know as I know in my own life right my

27:09

KFC Obsession had obvious negative

27:11

consequences in my life and the reason

27:12

this is so important in relation to

27:14

these drugs so for a long time I was

27:15

looking at two things right I was

27:17

looking at why did we so many of us gain

27:20

so much weight so rapidly obesity has

27:23

trebled globally in my lifetime right

27:25

completely unprecedented human history

27:27

why did that happen

27:28

and how do these drugs work and at first

27:30

I thought they were like parallel lines

27:32

right but actually I realized they were

27:33

like kind of braided plats the answer is

27:35

completely densely interconnected what

27:38

we know is the kind of food we eat

27:40

profoundly undermines our sense of

27:42

satiety it completely disrupts just like

27:45

it did with the rats it we don't get

27:47

that signal you're full you've had

27:49

enough stop from the kind of food we're

27:51

eating and what these drugs do is they

27:54

res restore a sense of satiety Carell

27:56

Laro another one of the key scientists

27:58

who develop these drugs said to me what

28:00

these what these drugs give you is

28:02

satiety hormones they give you back a

28:04

sense of being full and in a way at

28:06

first I thought well that makes the

28:10

whole thing seem crazy right because

28:12

there's a guy called Michael low

28:13

brilliant Professor um at Drexel

28:15

University in Philly he said to me look

28:18

you got to understand these drugs are an

28:20

artificial solution to an artificial

28:22

problem we've artificially created this

28:24

problem through a catastrophic food

28:27

system that is screwing bring us up from

28:29

childhood and then Along come these

28:31

drugs as the artificial solution to that

28:33

and the first thing you think is right

28:36

we' got to deal with the fear system

28:37

right and that is absolutely true and

28:39

correct and I remember going to one of

28:41

my closest friends um I call her Judy in

28:43

the book it's not a real name who you

28:46

know she'd had cancer seven years before

28:48

so I've been with her all through that

28:49

kind of really grueling process and it

28:51

was an absolute nightmare she's a single

28:52

mom and you can imagine how how Grim

28:55

that was um and I said to her I feel

28:59

like a complete fraud taking these drugs

29:01

right I'm always talking about how we

29:02

need to deal with the causes of social

29:04

problems I can see very clearly the

29:06

cause of this problem and this is just

29:09

sort of dealing with the symptom and she

29:11

said to me look

29:15

Johan you can stop taking this drug

29:17

that's fine do it if you want to but

29:20

when I had cancer we know there is

29:22

something in the environment that is

29:24

triggering breast cancer in women right

29:26

one in seven women in now get breast

29:28

cancer that didn't happen in the past

29:30

it's not happening in Japan where it's

29:32

only one in 38 women something is really

29:34

wrong in Britain and the US in the way

29:36

we're living that is triggering breast

29:37

cancer right but she said to me you

29:39

didn't say to me when I got breast

29:42

cancer well [ __ ] me all this

29:44

environmental problem has caused this

29:46

breast cancer and now you want to inject

29:47

yourself with another poison

29:49

chemotherapy in order to deal with it no

29:51

you said okay we've got an environmental

29:53

problem obviously that environmental

29:54

problem needs to be dealt with but

29:56

you've got to stay alive or you you

29:58

can't deal with it right the analogy she

30:00

gave me that really helped me was she

30:02

said if your house is on fire right you

30:05

could say well look we need to build

30:08

houses that aren't made of flammable

30:09

materials and we should make it the law

30:12

that you've got to have Sprinklers and

30:13

of course I agree but the first thing

30:16

you got to do is put out the fire in

30:17

your house right and I after that

30:20

conversation it was just after it I I

30:22

met a guy called Jeff Parker he's in San

30:24

Francisco he's a 66 year old lighting

30:27

designer who was about 16 Stone when I

30:30

when when he first started taking weight

30:32

loss drugs and he was in real trouble

30:34

heart problems liver problems kidney

30:36

problems it was very painful for him to

30:38

walk and he got mjo which is the next

30:41

Generation up of these weight loss drugs

30:43

and he lost loads of weight and all his

30:46

health problems reversed and now he

30:47

walks his dog over the Golden Gate

30:49

Bridge every day and is really happy and

30:51

said look I feel like now I'm going to

30:52

enjoy my retirement and I said to him

30:54

but Jeff I'm don't you feel like we

30:57

should be dealing with the environment

30:58

mental causes and he said absolutely I

31:00

totally agree with you you start that

31:02

campaign sign me up but I've got to tell

31:04

you by the time we achieve that I'm

31:06

going to be dead right we're not going

31:08

to get there in the next few years and I

31:10

want to live and I found

31:13

that I found it hard to

31:15

dispute what what if people say well you

31:17

know you could um you could just not

31:20

choose the role at the coffee shop in

31:23

the morning you could have just gone for

31:24

I don't know a salad or something yeah

31:26

it's a choice you're making Johan

31:28

make better choices so this was

31:29

completely the voice in my head I

31:31

remember another one of my friends when

31:33

I was at dinner and I was doing this I

31:35

was talking through everything I've been

31:36

learning and I was talking about you

31:37

know the r What You Got Away here I

31:40

thought was the risks of obesity which

31:42

are really disturbing when you learn

31:44

about them I was actually surprised we

31:47

all know obesity is not good for your

31:48

health but I was actually stunned when

31:50

you look at the evidence about how bad

31:52

obesity is view in relation to not just

31:54

diabetes but cancer dementia across the

31:57

board we can come back to that so I was

31:58

like well you got to weigh these risks

32:00

of obesity against the risks of these

32:03

drugs and I learned that there are 12

32:04

significant risks associated with these

32:06

drugs and he said what are you talking

32:09

about you haven't got to weigh those

32:10

risks at all there's a third option go

32:13

on a diet exercise right and he said

32:15

I've seen you do it you've done it

32:16

plenty of times right do that and of

32:19

course I had this voice in my head I

32:20

thought I was cheating um and I thought

32:23

well why don't I do why why am I not

32:25

doing that right um and I really began

32:28

to get an insight into this when I I

32:30

went to interview an amazing person

32:31

called Professor Tracy man who's in

32:33

Minneapolis where I met her um who's

32:36

done some of the most important research

32:37

on diet ever I remember actually I met

32:40

her I interviewed her in a place called

32:41

is bun which is um cinnamon bun shop

32:44

famous cinon bun shop in Minneapolis

32:46

when I arrived the guy on the door said

32:48

have you ever been here before and I

32:49

said no and he said I will give you a

32:51

free cinnamon bun then they gave me this

32:53

like 2,000 calorie massive cinnamon bun

32:55

that sat there the whole time we were

32:56

talking about diets and Professor man

32:58

she began to research this in the year

33:00

2000 and she wanted to figure out how

33:03

much do diets work right are they

33:05

effective and at that time the science

33:07

was very clear diets are really

33:10

effective if you go on a diet you will

33:12

lose weight right but she looking she's

33:15

looking at all these studies almost

33:16

24,000 studies and she noticed as part

33:19

of this big it's called a

33:20

metaanalysis and she discovered

33:22

something a bit weird which is most of

33:25

these studies the overwhelming majority

33:27

would follow people who were on a diet

33:29

for 3 months so you you exercise your

33:32

willpower you go on a diet for three

33:33

months you lose a load of weight and

33:34

then they just stopped and the

33:36

implication was you stay at that lower

33:37

rate forever she' be like I know quite a

33:40

lot of people who are not in that

33:41

position that doesn't happen to them so

33:43

she looked in more detail and discovered

33:45

there were 24 studies that had followed

33:46

diers not just over this short period

33:49

but for two years and in a handful of

33:50

cases five years and when you look at

33:52

the longer picture the picture is really

33:55

different after 2 years

33:58

the average person on a diet has lost 2

34:00

pounds in weight right so it's not

34:03

nothing but it's pretty close to nothing

34:05

right it's it's extraordinarily low so

34:08

what we know from the research on

34:09

dieting is there's a very small number

34:11

of people around 10% of people who

34:14

really do lose huge amounts of weight on

34:16

diets and keep it off we all know people

34:18

like that I've got someone in my family

34:19

like that right but for the vast

34:21

majority of people it doesn't work and I

34:23

remember saying to Professor man and

34:24

loads of other scientists who looked at

34:26

this well how can that be because we

34:29

know you only have to know the laws of

34:31

physics to know if you consume fewer

34:34

calories than you burn obviously you

34:36

will lose weight to dispute that you

34:37

have to dispute the laws of physics

34:39

right so how can it be that these people

34:41

are dieting but they're not losing

34:42

weight and BR man and other people

34:45

explained to me um something that's sort

34:47

of missing in this picture that I think

34:49

really helps us to understand it and is

34:51

actually important for understanding

34:52

these drugs I think so a lot of the

34:55

scientists explained that there are

34:57

biolog iCal changes that happen as you

35:00

gain weight which make it harder for you

35:02

to find your way back in a in a way that

35:03

you can sustain so in the 60s and 70s

35:06

there was this theory about weight that

35:08

was almost universally accepted it's

35:11

called set point Theory it sounds a bit

35:13

complex but it's pretty simple if you

35:14

think about your temperature your body

35:15

temperature right your body wants you to

35:18

be at the temperature you and me are at

35:19

right now right and if our temperature

35:21

goes higher than that if we get a fever

35:23

or if we go to the Sahara Desert our

35:25

body will work really hard involuntarily

35:27

to bring us down it'll make us sweat it

35:30

will make us really uncomfortable and

35:32

again if you're and also if your

35:33

temperature goes below the temperature

35:35

we're currently at your body will start

35:37

to shiver again it will make you really

35:39

crave heat right so your body has a set

35:42

level at which it keeps your temperature

35:44

and it works extremely hard to keep you

35:46

in that zone for your whole life and it

35:49

was thought for a long time that your

35:51

weight was a bit like that that when

35:52

you're born or possibly even in the womb

35:54

you have a biological set point for your

35:56

weight that That Remains the Same

35:58

throughout your life and you can go a

35:59

bit higher or a bit lower but basically

36:02

you're fixed there but then the Obesity

36:05

crisis happened starting in the late 70s

36:06

early 80s there's a huge weight rise in

36:09

such a large part of the population and

36:11

it looked like oh set point theory is

36:13

just wrong right that can't be correct

36:15

because if it was true then you couldn't

36:17

possibly have this but then Professor

36:19

low at Drexel and other places and other

36:22

people um discovered what what is really

36:25

happening in my view I think they

36:27

produced very compelling evidence for

36:29

this as you gain weight your body's set

36:32

point Rises right so let's say my body

36:35

wanted me to be 18% body fat as I get to

36:38

30% body fat my body will then fight

36:41

very hard to keep me at that higher

36:43

level right which seems really weird at

36:45

first why would that be so if you if you

36:47

let's say you gained three stone right

36:49

and then you tried to lose weight we

36:51

have think of a hypothetical Robert

36:52

dairo for the movie Raging Bull gained

36:55

you know three or four stone right and

36:57

then tried to cut back but what you'd

36:59

find was your metabolism would massively

37:02

slow down so it would you'd have to burn

37:05

far more to get the same number of

37:06

calories as you do now uh you would

37:08

crave far more sweet and salty foods you

37:11

would have lower energy so you would

37:12

find it harder to exercise so your set

37:15

point has risen and it's trying to keep

37:17

you there and I remember saying to loads

37:19

of scientists well that just seems

37:21

bizarre why would Evolution endow us

37:23

with that that's such a maladaptation

37:25

right why would why would um

37:28

why would it be and they explained to me

37:30

well you have to think about the

37:31

circumstances where we evolved in the

37:33

circumstances where humans evolved in

37:35

fact every human circumstance pretty

37:36

much until like 100 years ago there was

37:40

never a situation where you would have

37:41

completely abundant calories in fact

37:44

hyper abundant calories for your whole

37:46

life you'd have far more calories around

37:48

you than you could ever possibly eat

37:49

that never happened so your body didn't

37:51

Evolution didn't prepare us with good

37:53

instincts for that what you did have

37:55

what was a big risk was famine

37:57

right there was a big risk that at some

38:00

point in your life food would run out

38:02

and you would be in real trouble and in

38:04

a famine the fattest person at the start

38:07

is going to be the last man standing

38:08

right Timothy shalomay will die in week

38:09

one of a famine and you know John Candy

38:12

will still be alive at the end of it Al

38:14

not a great example because John Candy

38:15

has died but you get the point right um

38:17

so actually that's why our Evolution

38:20

prepared us that oh if you gain weight

38:23

fight to hold it cuz sooner or later

38:25

you're going to have to lose it in a

38:25

famine anyway so evolve with this

38:28

Instinct that when we gain weight we

38:30

experience these biological changes that

38:32

make it harder to go back it's not

38:33

impossible willpower is a real thing

38:36

some people can do it but when you try

38:39

you are fighting against your own

38:41

biology you're also fighting against

38:42

your psychology and your environment for

38:44

different reasons we can explore so it's

38:46

not that dieting doesn't work but we've

38:48

got to be honest at any given time 177%

38:51

of people are on a diet we've really

38:54

tried that route right we've had you

38:55

know 40 Years of relentless ly promoting

38:58

dieting as the o or diet and exercise as

39:00

the only solutions and we've gotten

39:02

fatter and fatter and fatter so there's

39:04

something missing in that picture I

39:05

think it's partly set point Theory it's

39:07

also important for the drugs because

39:08

some people argue like the guy I

39:09

mentioned before in relation to the

39:11

brain Professor orelio G some of them

39:14

argue that what the drug may be doing is

39:16

actually resetting your biological set

39:17

point lowering the kind of temperature

39:20

at which your body tries to keep your

39:22

weight it's bringing your set point down

39:24

so that you don't get those effects like

39:26

the metabolism slowing and all the other

39:27

things that kick in when you try to lose

39:29

weight I think on average and this might

39:31

not be accurate but I think on average

39:33

we live more stressful lives than we

39:34

once did as well and I wonder the

39:36

relationship that are more stressful

39:38

more frantic more busy notification

39:40

filled social media driven screen time

39:42

lives are having on our relationship

39:45

with food and if there's a relationship

39:47

there at all you know more more kids

39:49

have ADHD now than ever you know

39:51

cortisol level seems to be skyrocketing

39:53

and it seems there's a relationship

39:54

between stress and appetite which is as

39:57

a gravitational force against our

39:59

willpower no you're totally right and

40:01

this is when I go through the 12 risks

40:04

of the the drugs in the book this is one

40:07

that I really worried about one that

40:08

played out for me so I noticed I had

40:10

this weird thing about six months since

40:13

taking the drug I had this realization

40:14

so I was losing a lot of weight right I

40:16

lost a huge amount of weight I lost

40:17

three stone three stone in what period

40:19

of time from from now to when I started

40:21

so just over a year and how quick how

40:23

quick was that weight loss just out of

40:25

Interest before we move on PR pretty

40:27

straight linear line downwards from from

40:29

the start but I had this strange

40:31

sensation I had a a my friend Danielle

40:33

was pregnant at the time I kept bumping

40:35

into her and it was like we we were on

40:37

opposite trajectories like she was

40:38

swelling and I was shrinking um I

40:41

remember walking away from her once and

40:42

thinking this is really weird I'm

40:44

getting what I want why don't I feel

40:47

better about this right I I didn't

40:49

actually feel that much better for quite

40:51

a long time for about six months

40:53

thinking why is that so what you mean by

40:55

better I felt quite m

40:57

in my emotions I

41:02

felt I felt I wouldn't say I definitely

41:04

wasn't

41:05

depressed but I felt a little bit dulled

41:09

I thought this is strange I thought

41:10

maybe it's just other things going on in

41:11

my life you never know when it's just an

41:13

individual but lots of people are

41:15

reporting this most people are very

41:16

happy when they take drugs but there's a

41:17

significant minority and so I started

41:20

looking at exactly this question the

41:21

psychology of eating and it turns out

41:23

there's kind of five the scientific

41:24

evidence for five reasons why we eat

41:27

um and obviously the first and most

41:29

important one is sustenance right I

41:31

would have thought if you'd asked me a

41:32

year ago why do you eat I would said

41:33

well the main reason is to sustain my

41:35

body but here I am eating so much less

41:37

than my body is sustained so all those

41:39

other calories I was consuming were

41:41

doing something else right and one of

41:43

the things one of the reasons we eat and

41:44

another one is pleasure which we've

41:45

talked about but another reason why

41:47

people eat is Comfort right people get a

41:50

tremendous amount of comfort out of food

41:52

particularly overeating can be very

41:54

comforting we know this partly because

41:56

whenever there's a stressful event uh

41:59

junk food orders massively go up after

42:01

911 there was a huge increase in

42:02

ordering people ordering pizzas and

42:04

fried chicken the night Trump won the

42:06

election in blue States on Uber Eats and

42:08

the other kind of delivery apps there

42:09

was a massive increase in people

42:11

ordering tacos you know um shitty food

42:15

right um if you if you're you're a man

42:17

and you lose your job your chances of

42:19

gaining weight massively increase partly

42:21

because it's so upsetting and you eat to

42:22

comfort yourself um and one of the

42:25

things that happens when you take these

42:26

drugs

42:28

is your ability to comfort eat is taken

42:29

away from you you can't Comfort eat and

42:33

we've got a good analogy I think a good

42:36

precedent for helping us think about how

42:38

that affects you so the best comparison

42:41

for these drugs if we're trying to

42:42

figure out their effects I think is

42:44

bariatric surgery right so up to now it

42:47

was very hard to sustainably lose like

42:49

more than 20% of your body weight the

42:51

only way it was possible to do it very

42:54

quickly was bariatric surgery I think we

42:55

have to look at the outcomes that's

42:57

stomach stapling there's four different

42:59

kinds of it but it's basically what we

43:00

think of a stomach stapling stomach

43:02

operation exactly that's one form of it

43:04

right and so I think you have to look at

43:06

the evidence from gastric surgery and in

43:08

some ways it's very encouraging so we

43:10

know that gastric band surgery and other

43:12

forms of gastric surgery massively boost

43:15

your health if you have one of these

43:17

operations over the next seven years you

43:20

are 56% less likely to die of a heart

43:22

attack 60% less likely to die of cancer

43:26

and 92% % less likely to die of diabetes

43:28

related causes in fact it's so good for

43:30

your health that of you are 40% less

43:34

likely to die of any cause over the next

43:36

seven years right so we know reversing

43:38

obesity massively boosts physical health

43:42

in most cases right sometimes very

43:45

dramatically but we also know from

43:47

bariatric surgery there's plenty of

43:48

downsides to bariatric surgery it's a

43:50

horrendous operation and one in a

43:51

thousand people die during the operation

43:53

it's Grim but we also know where I think

43:55

it's really important to the thing

43:56

you're asking about is that it has an

43:59

effect on your psychology so a lot of

44:00

people are much happier most people who

44:01

have that surgery are glad but 177% of

44:05

people who have that surgery have to

44:07

have impatient psychiatric treatment

44:09

afterwards because they're so depressed

44:10

or distressed your chances of committing

44:12

suicide almost quadruple after you've

44:14

had bariatric surgery and I think

44:16

there's lots of reasons why some of it

44:17

must be the grimness of the operation in

44:19

the aftermath but I think a lot of it is

44:22

you know you take away Comfort eating

44:24

from people right if you go through life

44:27

especially people who had gastric band

44:28

surgery or the other surgeries you know

44:30

those are people who were very severely

44:32

obese so they would have had this effect

44:33

very powerfully in their lives most of

44:35

them if you take away something that is

44:37

a key way of soothing

44:40

people when that goes well you can

44:43

rebuild your life you can find other

44:44

ways to get that soothing and that's

44:46

really valuable and important but a lot

44:48

of people just experience it as

44:50

profoundly painful and distressing and I

44:52

inter a lot of people like that when

44:53

people have those surgeries I read in

44:55

your book in chapter eight that one in

44:57

10 people then pick up a different type

44:59

of addiction to alcohol or gambling or

45:01

shopping or drugs or something else so

45:04

that's pretty clear evidence that

45:05

there's the psychological soothing is

45:07

just moving somewhere else it's

45:09

fascinating and and and distressing and

45:11

OB I spoke to people who'd been through

45:12

those what called an addiction transfer

45:14

um I spoke to this amazing woman called

45:15

Robin Moore who uh had been

45:20

303 she'd had um bariatric surgery

45:24

because just nothing else had worked and

45:25

she felt she was really a slave to that

45:27

was how she put it and it had this

45:29

incredible effect she she knew why she

45:32

had gained her gained weight so much in

45:36

her case it was she when she was a child

45:38

she had been sexually abused she'd been

45:39

raped and she'd never told anyone and

45:42

she quite deliberately gained weight in

45:44

order to keep men away from her she

45:45

thought well if I'm if I'm really fat

45:47

I'm less likely to be

45:48

attacked um which is surprisingly common

45:52

and she lost all this weight and she

45:55

felt great she felt physically much

45:57

better people were treating her much

46:00

better but she had this shift where she

46:05

she'd never been much of a drinker she

46:06

had a periods when she was at College

46:08

where she drank a fair bit but you know

46:09

she'd never been a heavy drinker and she

46:12

just quite rapidly became a very

46:14

full-blown alcoholic she used to work

46:15

out by the airport in Toronto and she

46:18

would you know drink on the way there

46:20

drink on the way back and she got fired

46:22

because she was drunk at work

46:24

eventually and um for her she she kind

46:27

of realized you know and I think it's

46:30

interesting ways to think about this in

46:31

relation to these

46:32

drugs I want to stress this is not going

46:34

to be everyone I don't think there's

46:35

even going to be a majority of people by

46:37

any

46:38

means

46:39

but when you take these

46:43

drugs the underlying psychological

46:45

reasons that drove your eating are

46:48

profoundly disrupted and in many cases

46:50

come to the surface and for me that was

46:53

help painful at first but helpful I

46:55

remember having a day in Vegas as you

46:56

know SP lot of time in Vegas cuz writing

46:57

a book about a series of crimes that

46:59

have been happening there I had dayse

47:01

investigating something really grim and

47:03

I I felt really bad and it was relating

47:04

to someone it's a long story but

47:06

something terrible and I went to the KFC

47:09

on West Sahara it's the grimmest KFC in

47:11

the whole world I have a secret love for

47:12

it and I on kind of

47:15

autopilot I ordered what I would always

47:17

have ordered you know like a load of

47:18

fried

47:20

chicken and I sat there and I thinking

47:23

oh [ __ ] I can't eat this I remember

47:27

Colonel Sanders was on the wall looking

47:28

down and was like he was going to be

47:30

what happened to my best customer right

47:33

so being deprived of comfort eating is

47:35

is quite apart from the being deprived

47:37

of pleasure which I think is sort of

47:38

related but a bit different is is is

47:41

very difficult and again my friend who

47:43

I'd spoken to had cancer went to her and

47:44

said this is really hard right and she

47:47

said look it's not that the drug is

47:50

causing this problem the drug is making

47:52

this problem visible to you and now you

47:54

can deal with that in other ways right

47:56

and that's I've been trying to do and

47:58

write about how in the book but yeah so

48:00

one of the things that fascinated me

48:01

about all the research for for my book

48:03

magic pill

48:04

was how incredibly complex this is every

48:07

time you look at one effect it seems to

48:08

have another effect this is a really

48:12

complicated difficult topic and anyone

48:14

who's coming in telling you either rah

48:16

rah these drugs are great and they're

48:18

going to save us all or these drugs are

48:20

devils it's terrible um I don't think

48:23

it's leveling with people I think it's

48:24

complicated I think there's risks every

48:26

turn and I think we need to think

48:28

through the complexity together in a way

48:29

that's honest and and and honors the

48:33

complexity you talk there about the

48:35

impact that early childhood trauma has

48:37

on our relationship with food and eating

48:38

um I remember reading a little bit about

48:40

that in your previous book lost

48:41

connections as well but what is what

48:43

what is the sort of data in the stats

48:45

that that prove that trauma can cause us

48:47

to have this kind of excessive comt

48:51

seeking relationship with food is there

48:53

any particular studies that stand out

48:54

for you oh yeah I mean a guy that I got

48:56

to know quite well when I worked on Lost

48:58

connections and I thought about this

49:00

Research In a Different Light when I

49:02

worked on this book there's a guy called

49:04

doctor Vincent felitti and in the early

49:07

1980s he was a doctor in San Diego and

49:10

he was contacted by kaisa Permanente who

49:12

were a big not for-profit MediCal

49:14

provider in the

49:15

state and they said to him look we got a

49:18

problem we don't know what to

49:19

do obesity was massively Rising actually

49:22

it was very low by our standards but it

49:23

was hugely rising and they were trying

49:26

giving people diet plans and exercise

49:28

plans and nothing was working and they

49:29

said we don't know what to do can we

49:31

give you a load of money to just do blue

49:32

skies research go away figure out what

49:35

we can do and he said okay so he took a

49:37

load of money and then he's like what

49:38

can I do and he started working with 200

49:42

very very obese people people who were

49:43

severely obese who had tried all sorts

49:45

of ways to cut back and it hadn't worked

49:48

and he's sitting there working with them

49:49

and he's thinking what can I do and he

49:51

had an idea that sounds and actually is

49:53

quite stupid he said well what would

49:56

happen if really obese people literally

49:58

stopped eating and we medically

50:00

supervised it and we gave them vitamin

50:02

shots so they didn't get like scurvy or

50:04

whatever would they would they burn

50:06

through the fat stores in their body and

50:07

get back to a healthy weight so with a

50:09

shitload of medical supervision they did

50:11

it and Incredibly at first it worked

50:14

there was a woman who I'll call Susan

50:15

that's not her real name who went from

50:16

being more than 400 to 138 it was

50:20

incredible right and you know her family

50:22

are ringing the doctor and saying you

50:24

saved Susan's life she's really thrilled

50:27

and then one day something happened that

50:29

no one

50:31

expected she cracked she went to KFC or

50:35

wherever it was she starts obsessively

50:37

eating and after a while she's back

50:39

where she was not exactly where she'd

50:40

been but

50:42

similar and Dr feli called her in he

50:45

said

50:46

Susan what happened she looked down she

50:49

was obviously really ashamed she I don't

50:50

know I don't know he said well tell me

50:53

about that day right the day you cracked

50:56

did anything happened that day that

50:57

didn't happen any other day it turns out

51:00

something happened that day that had

51:01

never happened to season before um she

51:04

was in a bar and a man hit on her not in

51:05

a nasty way in quite a nice way but she

51:07

just felt completely freaked out and she

51:09

went and started eating and that's when

51:11

Dr feli said to her well Susan when did

51:14

you start gaining weight in her case I

51:15

think it was when she was 10 he said

51:18

well did anything happen when you were

51:19

10 that didn't happened when you were 9

51:21

or 11 or anything happened that year she

51:24

looked down and said well that's that's

51:26

when my grandfather started raping

51:28

me Dr Fel interviewed everyone in the

51:30

program he discovered that 60% of them

51:33

had made their extreme weight gain in

51:35

the aftermath of being sexually abused

51:37

or assaulted which is a staggering

51:38

figure right 60% of the women um and it

51:42

was like well how could this be he was

51:44

really puzzled and Susan explained it to

51:46

him really well she said overweight is

51:48

overlooked and that's what I need to be

51:51

right if you're severely overweight

51:52

you're much less likely to to be

51:54

sexually attacked right it's obviously

51:56

can happen but it's it's rarer um and

51:59

when you understand that you begin to

52:01

see again in relation to these drugs

52:04

um why some people get really freaked

52:07

out when they take these drugs because

52:08

some of them experience it as suddenly

52:11

oh my God I'm really vulnerable to this

52:13

traumatic event being reenacted again

52:15

and again now that's one example there's

52:17

lots of if we go down the the list of

52:19

reasons why people eat like I do in the

52:21

book there's lots of other ones that get

52:22

triggered and activated as and disrupted

52:24

as well you talk in the book about this

52:26

this word I've never really come across

52:28

before which is um it's a phrase I guess

52:30

you say the environment is

52:32

oogenic I I've only ever heard of that

52:34

term cogenic carcinogenic carcinogenic

52:38

yeah which basically means something can

52:39

give you cancer but you're saying that

52:40

the environment we live in is I mean the

52:44

way that I read it was like that that

52:45

it's almost contagious like it's going

52:48

to give me obesity just by being alive

52:50

in the modern world um one of the stats

52:53

that really stood out to me when you're

52:54

talking about processed food is that on

52:56

average when we eat processed food we we

52:58

end up eating 500 more calories every

53:00

single day and um that again is

53:04

startling you know I've had a few guests

53:05

on this podcast that I've talked about

53:06

processed food and the rise of it and I

53:09

do Wonder to myself if there's ever

53:13

going to be a change in society if we if

53:15

there's any indication that at some

53:17

point I don't know government will step

53:19

in and ban it or tax it more or

53:21

something will happen what's your what's

53:23

your view on if we talk about the

53:25

optimism of the penic environment

53:27

changing do you think it can change do

53:29

you think it will so crucially I went to

53:31

a country that had completely

53:33

transformed its diet and as a result has

53:35

very low obesity Japan we can talk about

53:37

that and I went to loads of countries

53:39

that are making the changes you're

53:41

talking about so prompt me to come back

53:42

to that but I would start by saying well

53:44

a you're totally right we live in an

53:45

obesogenic environment an obesogenic

53:47

environment is an environment that

53:49

primes you to be obese and where it's

53:51

hard to be a healthy weight right it's

53:53

hard to get healthy food healthy food is

53:55

expensive and rare whereas shitty food

53:58

that makes you obese is cheap abundant

54:00

and constantly promoted to you right so

54:03

that's an obesogenic environment and

54:04

there's loads of evidence that well as

54:06

Professor Michael L put it to me we live

54:08

in as obesogenic an environment as human

54:11

beings could possibly design right um

54:13

and there's seven ways in which

54:15

processed food undermines your ability

54:17

to stop eating that I go through in the

54:19

book so if you're feeling pessimistic

54:21

and I'm

54:22

clearly you're right to feel pessimistic

54:25

someone is charismatic and bril as

54:26

Michelle Obama could not even get us to

54:29

join a campaign to physically move so I

54:31

get it there's big obstacles here but

54:34

when you feel pessimistic about it the

54:37

first thing I would say is think about

54:39

smoking right my mother smokes 70

54:41

cigarettes a day there's a photograph of

54:43

me and her where I'm

54:45

um she's breastfeeding me I'm about six

54:48

months old she's smoking and resting the

54:50

ashtray on my stomach and when I showed

54:53

her this photo I thought she'd feel

54:54

guilty she said you were a [ __ ]

54:56

difficult baby I needed that cigarette

54:58

um but you think about that that was

55:00

normal right when I mean in Scotland

55:01

that was normal when I was a kid right

55:04

um so you think about smoking when I was

55:06

seven years old um more than half of the

55:08

population of Britain smoked right and

55:10

people smoked everywhere people smoked

55:13

on the tube people smoked on planes

55:16

people smoked on game shows the doctor

55:18

would smoke while he was examining you

55:20

I'm not joking I remember that happening

55:21

right so if I could take you back to the

55:24

Britain of 1987 and you could walk

55:26

around you would just you would feel

55:28

sick because the smell of smoke was

55:30

everywhere right and there were just

55:32

ashtrays everywhere funny enough I was

55:33

with my mother when it was the

55:35

anniversary of there was a terrible

55:37

catastrophic fire at King's cross

55:38

station here in London in 1987 I think

55:42

and I was with my mother when it was the

55:43

anniversary a few years ago and uh it

55:45

was a terrible disaster there was a fire

55:47

someone had put out a cigarette near an

55:48

escalator and it killed more than 50

55:51

people it was awful uh and my mother

55:53

said oh that was the worst day of my

55:55

life and I said oh were you there did

55:57

you know someone who died she said no

56:00

that's the day they banned smoking on

56:01

the

56:02

tube anyway the so if I could take you

56:05

back and I said to you right how many

56:07

years we are on from that now um only

56:11

12% of British people will be will smoke

56:13

it will be falling and the British

56:15

government will be about to

56:16

progressively ban smoking you won't be

56:18

allowed to smoke indoors anywhere except

56:20

your own home the rates will have tanked

56:23

young people will there'll be almost no

56:25

cigarette smoking among young people and

56:27

they're going to progressively ban it by

56:29

age that would have seemed ludicrous

56:31

right you would have said well tobacco

56:32

industry is one of the most powerful

56:33

Industries in the whole world uh you've

56:35

got a very motivated half the population

56:38

are addicted it's never going to happen

56:40

these things can change that's a huge

56:42

Public Health uh transformation in a

56:45

very short period of time these things

56:47

can change and I've seen how it can

56:48

change with food so that we're not in

56:50

this situation where we have to choose

56:53

as we are at the moment between for many

56:55

of us not all between the risk of

56:57

obesity and the 12 big risks associated

57:00

with these drugs what are they waiting

57:01

for because the government knows this

57:03

the government knows that processed

57:05

foods and you know the sugar quantities

57:08

that the average person's eating is bad

57:09

so they could presumably get something

57:11

done this year so but they won't there's

57:14

a brilliant writer called Rebecca solnet

57:16

who says politicians are weather veins

57:18

and it's our job to be the weather if

57:20

you're a politician you're constantly

57:21

making a calculation right if I do this

57:24

thing how much praise will I get and how

57:26

much [ __ ] will I get for it right and

57:29

you know some of them are good people

57:30

many of them are good people but you're

57:31

constantly making that calculation in a

57:34

democracy and right now if you do the

57:36

right thing on food and there are loads

57:38

of things we do I saw in Japan we can go

57:40

down the list of all the things we need

57:41

to do um that could transform Health

57:44

particularly for our children you'd get

57:46

some praise but you get a lot of [ __ ]

57:48

right you get a lot of [ __ ] for it and

57:51

for many years of my life I would have

57:52

been one of the people who gave them

57:54

that [ __ ] right so I I understand it

57:57

we have to change that calculation by

57:59

helping people understand and make

58:02

better choices in ways that I saw happen

58:04

so I can explain how they did it if you

58:06

want please Japan is really important I

58:08

think for thinking about how we get out

58:10

of this trap because at the moment um

58:13

the way it's often presented is look

58:16

we're just screwed right there's just

58:18

this huge obese population that's the

58:20

product of being rich if you're a rich

58:22

country you've got lots of calories

58:23

around you inevitably we're going to

58:25

have loads of obesity and inevitably

58:27

we're just going to need to give loads

58:29

and loads of people these drugs forever

58:31

and you know a few years from now as

58:33

many people predicted to me we'll have

58:34

40% 50% of the population taking these

58:37

weight loss drugs right and what Japan

58:39

showed us is we don't have to choose

58:41

that fate right so if you look at Japan

58:44

Japan is the only country that got rich

58:47

without getting fat 4.5% of Japanese

58:51

people are obese compared to 26% in

58:53

Britain and

58:54

42.5% in United States and it's actually

58:57

42% 42% 4.5% are obese 70% are obese are

59:01

overweight right Jesus the norm is to be

59:04

obese or overweight right whereas in

59:06

Japan it's completely the opposite it's

59:07

kind of weird that when we picture Japan

59:10

we often picture sumo wrestlers it's a

59:11

bit like expecting the average American

59:13

to look like a bald eagle or something

59:15

right seers are completely atypical and

59:18

I learned a huge amount about what's

59:19

happening there so the first thing you

59:20

think when you hear that is it must just

59:22

be genetic right theyve just they've won

59:24

the genetic Lottery that must be what's

59:25

going on on but we know that's not true

59:28

because in the late 19th century loads

59:30

of Japanese people went to live in

59:31

Hawaii where I just was um and there's

59:33

now this settled Japanese population in

59:35

Hawaii who've been there for four or

59:37

five generations and they're almost as

59:40

fat as other Hawaiians right so they're

59:42

five times fatter than they're five

59:44

times more likely to be obese than

59:46

Japanese people in Japan so actually

59:48

when the environment changes Japanese

59:50

people become obese like everyone else

59:52

so there's something else going on so I

59:54

wanted to understand how did Japan do it

59:57

and one of the really interesting things

59:59

is it was very consciously done there's

60:01

a guy called Professor Barack kushna

60:02

who's a professor of East Asian history

60:04

in um in Cambridge University who's

60:07

talked about how actually if you go back

60:09

to the 1920s Japanese people had one of

60:11

the worst diets in the world they only

60:12

ate protein once a week they almost

60:14

never ate fish right they only ate fish

60:15

once a week they had a terrible diet and

60:18

the Japanese government at the time

60:20

wanted a healthy population so they

60:22

could form armies that would go and

60:24

invade the rest of Asia

60:26

so they deliberately transformed the

60:28

food culture in Japan very consciously

60:30

so I want to see how do they do that now

60:31

right what's going on so I went to a

60:33

school called COI school um which takes

60:36

kids from 5 to 18 and it was totally

60:39

fascinating so when I arrived there I

60:41

went with my

60:42

translator uh the first you arrive and

60:45

all the kids walk to school on their own

60:47

from the age of five all Japanese

60:49

children just leave the house and walk

60:51

to school on their own so they get a lot

60:52

of exercise in the morning and they walk

60:54

home on their own as well and we were

60:56

greeted at the entrance by a woman

60:57

called harumi tati who's the

60:59

nutritionist at the school by law every

61:03

Japanese school has to employ a

61:04

professional nutritionist it's a

61:06

difficult qualification to get it's

61:07

three years of study on top of learning

61:09

to be a teacher and your job is to

61:12

design and oversee the creation of the

61:13

food in the school all processed food is

61:16

banned no one is allowed to have Pro

61:17

there's no processed food in any

61:19

Japanese schools ever every meal has to

61:21

be prepared from scratch at the start of

61:23

the day um and no one is allowed to

61:25

bring it a pack lunch so every kid has

61:27

to eat the food that's prepared in the

61:29

school uh her job is also to use those

61:32

meals to educate the children about how

61:35

to eat healthily so they teach them all

61:38

sorts of key principles one of them is

61:40

in Japan this is a very deep cultural

61:42

norm you should only eat until you're

61:44

80% full so it it takes a while for your

61:47

body to realize you're full so if you

61:49

get the signal that you're full while

61:50

you're still eating they're like you've

61:52

eaten too much right so you should eat

61:54

until you're 80% full and then stop

61:56

um there's all sorts of norms that are

61:58

very different to ours so if you look at

62:00

a typical Japanese meal it will have

62:03

five portions significantly more than

62:04

USS but they're pretty small right so

62:06

you might have some fish some Mis miso

62:08

soup a whole range of things um and you

62:12

which is important for your gut health

62:14

because there's a bigger variety of

62:15

ingredients which makes your gut much

62:17

healthier but also you eat it

62:19

differently if you gave us you know a

62:22

meal with three bits generally you'd eat

62:24

all of one then all of another then all

62:26

of another you'd have all the lasagna

62:27

then you have the carrots or whatever in

62:29

Japan that's regarded as like a crazy

62:31

way to eat you have a mouthful of the

62:33

Miso soup then you have a mouth full of

62:36

the white fish then you have a mouth

62:38

full of the sashimi and you you have it

62:40

slows your eating

62:42

down massively if you eat that way um

62:45

they're also taught I remember her

62:47

standing there so the the meals in all

62:48

the schools are designed to be

62:49

nutritionally balanced through these

62:51

five components and so she stands in

62:54

front of the class and teaches the kid

62:55

kids you know okay this is a red rope

62:58

this represents calcium what does

62:59

calcium do kids it makes your bone

63:01

stronger like yes that's this on your

63:03

plate this represents carbohydrates what

63:06

do they do they give you energy and the

63:08

kids yell out so then and then she ties

63:10

the rope together she goes you see now

63:11

it's all tied together now it's a

63:13

balanced meal so they use this healthy

63:15

food to educate the children about how

63:18

to eat healthily it's a very um

63:21

beautifully designed system and it was

63:22

fascinating looking at them I mean got

63:25

tast stepen it was really weird this is

63:27

a school of a thousand children I walked

63:29

through that school all day there was

63:31

not one fat child it it it was it's odd

63:35

like it's jarring when you go right that

63:38

they have you know they have

63:39

extraordinarily low childhood

63:41

obesity and I remember with these kids I

63:44

was asking them their favorite foods the

63:47

first kid I asked said my favorite food

63:48

is broccoli it's like all right the

63:51

second kid said my favorite food is

63:53

seaweed and the third one's like I like

63:55

white rice and I said to CH my

63:57

translator are these kids trolling me

63:59

right like what their favorite foods are

64:01

broccoli and like white rice and she

64:04

just looked kind of puzzled and every

64:05

Japanese person I asked

64:07

said but we teach our children to like

64:09

healthy food don't your children like

64:11

healthy food and I was so taken about by

64:14

these kids I I brought up on my phone

64:17

some pictures of like typical British

64:18

school dinners and showed it to them and

64:21

they literally reacted like I had shown

64:23

them an Isis beheading video they like

64:24

screamed they were like

64:26

what is this and one said did you eat

64:27

this every day I was like yes they're

64:29

saying where's the salad I said there is

64:31

no salad they're just completely baffled

64:34

so they partly start with

64:36

this very strong culture creating a very

64:41

deliberate culture of how to eat

64:43

differently that begins at a very very

64:45

young age there are some other steps

64:47

that are a bit more dodgy that we can

64:48

come to I'm sure but that that was the

64:50

kind of um first um that was the first

64:53

pillar of it that I saw and then over

64:56

here we're in we're in this sort of

64:57

craze of injecting ourselves with this

64:59

thing called a zek can I see the pen

65:01

actually I've never actually seen one

65:02

before I won't open it or anything sure

65:03

course I W contaminate it Z I've just

65:06

been so intrigued to see what these

65:07

things are

65:08

like once

65:10

weekly Nova nordis Nova Nordisk now the

65:14

most valuable company in the whole of

65:15

Europe what what are they give me some

65:17

context on Nova Nordisk they're a Danish

65:19

pharmaceutical company so there's two

65:21

companies that are kind of pushing the

65:23

main drugs in this pushing sounds too

65:25

there you know what I mean so Novo

65:27

Nordisk who a Danish company the entire

65:29

Danish economy has had a massive growth

65:31

because of the popularity of these drugs

65:33

since they came out they've become the

65:35

most valuable company in Europe um the

65:38

market for these drugs is predicted to

65:40

be $200 billion do by the end of this

65:42

decade and the other one is Eli

65:44

Lily and if I how do I get this do I

65:48

have to go to a doctor and get a

65:49

prescription or can I just go buy this

65:51

on online or something so this is part

65:53

of the problem and this leads to one of

65:54

the really big risks associated with the

65:56

drugs which is eating disorders I am

65:58

really really worried about this so

66:00

there are lots of young girls in

66:02

particular some boys but it's mostly

66:03

girls who want to starve themselves

66:05

right we know that it hugely Rose during

66:08

the pandemic and this is the most

66:10

effective tool for self- starvation

66:11

human beings have ever come up with so I

66:13

interviewed a lot of Eating Disorders

66:15

experts who are terrified about what's

66:17

coming down the line and the truth is it

66:19

is very easy to get hold of it I went

66:22

you know you could go online now you

66:23

clearly do not meet the criteria for

66:25

getting these drugs right you've got to

66:26

have a BMI of higher than 27 which is a

66:28

BMI that comes from fat Mass not muscle

66:30

mass so you would not meet the criteria

66:32

at all if you went online you could go

66:35

and see a doctor on Zoom lie about your

66:37

BMI and you would get it in the mail two

66:39

days later right um they're meant to

66:42

check your BMI but on Zoom that's very

66:45

hard to do if in the unlikely event you

66:47

were turned down by a doctor on Zoom you

66:49

can just order effectively counterfeit

66:51

ones online very very easily so I'm EXT

66:55

extremely wide I think we're going to

66:57

have a there are many downsides to these

67:00

drugs possibly the worst from my point

67:02

of view one of the two or three worst is

67:05

you're going to have a huge wave of

67:10

young women who get hold of these drugs

67:12

and and do a lot of harm to themselves

67:14

now that is something we can immediately

67:16

do to massively limit that harm uh lots

67:19

of the Eating Disorders experts I

67:20

interviewed like Dr Kimberly Dennis

67:22

who's one of the leading experts in the

67:23

US said to me these drugs should only be

67:27

given by prescription if you go to a

67:29

physical doctor and the doctor you

67:31

physically go to to get them needs to be

67:33

trained in detecting eating disorders

67:35

and referring people for help with

67:37

eating disorders if that's what they

67:38

think they've got so these were

67:40

initially created for people that had

67:42

diabetes they have a dual effect so glp1

67:46

the hormone gp1 and this kind of replica

67:48

of it uh stimulates the creation of

67:51

insulin which is obviously what

67:53

diabetics are lacking either type one or

67:54

type two diab ICS so it was the whole

67:57

thing was discovered by accident I

67:58

interviewed the guy who discovered it a

68:00

guy called Daniel draer amazing man so

68:02

they discovered he was just looking at

68:04

um so your whole body is made out of

68:05

cells right and in the 70s it was

68:08

discovered there were new ways of

68:09

looking inside cells that human beings

68:11

had never had before so by the 80s 1984

68:14

was when he made a breakthrough they

68:16

were just going through different cells

68:17

in the human body trying to figure out

68:19

what they do and they got to the

68:20

glucagon Gene which exists inside your

68:23

your pancreas and they were trying to

68:25

figure out the glucon gene is a long

68:26

chain and at the end of it is gp1 and

68:29

they were trying to figure out well can

68:30

you break off that little bit of the

68:32

chain or if you break it off does it

68:34

just wither and die and he discovered Dr

68:37

duer discovered you can break it off and

68:39

then he was like well what does it do so

68:41

he starts experimenting in lab dishes in

68:43

Massachusetts General Hospital and he

68:46

discovered that if you combine it with

68:48

insulin it produces more insulin so

68:51

that's why it's so valuable for

68:52

diabetics and immediately he was like

68:54

whoa that's really significant so then

68:56

other people in the lab um Professor

68:58

spana mjoy um gave it to rats put it in

69:02

rats and discovered it in fact produced

69:04

insulin in rats a team in Copenhagen put

69:07

it into the pancreas of pigs discovered

69:09

it produced insulin there and that

69:11

setting set in train what later became

69:14

giving it to diabetics so that's the

69:15

most one obviously greatest benefit of

69:18

these drugs that was initially

69:19

discovered is they hugely helped

69:21

diabetics then the effects around

69:23

appetite were discovered separately

69:25

initially here in in London in the

69:27

Hammer Smith hospital that was when they

69:29

discovered oh if you inject people with

69:30

gp1 this is before they had copies of it

69:33

if you inject people with gp1 it reduces

69:35

their appetite oh okay you can see where

69:38

their thinking went from there so

69:39

there's dual uses and the Dual uses are

69:41

kind of incredible if you look at uh the

69:43

effects on diabetics obvious but um if

69:46

you look at the health effects we that

69:47

are emerging around these drugs and this

69:50

is very close to my heart literally

69:51

because of the heart problems in my

69:53

family um if you take these drugs if you

69:55

started with a BMI higher than 27 and

69:58

you take these drugs over the next 5

70:00

years you are 20% less likely to have a

70:02

heart attack or stroke so we're talking

70:03

about this is some people are like oh

70:05

this is Vanity and there's an element of

70:07

vanity in me and in most people taking

70:09

these drugs I'm sure but this is having

70:12

massive health benefits for lots of

70:14

people how many people are willing to

70:17

take it because as you as we discuss

70:19

this now say that there's I don't know a

70:21

million 10 million people that listen

70:23

what percentage of those people on

70:24

average would go do you know what that

70:26

sounds like the thing I've been looking

70:27

for if they're Americans and the polling

70:29

is Right 47% of Americans have said they

70:32

would be willing to take they want to

70:33

take these drugs actively want oh they

70:34

want to so about 50% of this a the

70:36

audience will be actively wanting to

70:39

take it as we sit here now yeah and now

70:41

tell me

70:43

why they shouldn't well there's a huge

70:46

array of risks um some of which are very

70:49

very serious so I'll give you a few

70:52

examples I go through Lots in the book

70:54

there's a professor in France called

70:56

Professor Jean Luke F who works at the

70:58

University Hospital in melier who was

71:00

commissioned by the French medicines

71:01

agency to investigate these drugs and

71:03

the safety around these drugs and one of

71:06

the reasons lots of people have felt

71:07

very happy about the safety of these

71:08

drugs and it's a good reason is that in

71:11

their roll out for obesity if people

71:13

have said like Daniel duer for example

71:14

who I mentioned who discovered

71:16

gp1 they say quite rightly well look

71:19

diabetics have been taking these drugs

71:21

for 18 years

71:23

now if there was some catastrophic

71:25

effect we would know it would have

71:26

emerged in diabetics right now he would

71:28

also add well it could affect obese

71:30

people a bit differently than diabetics

71:32

so there's some gaps in the knowledge he

71:34

said look we this drug has been used by

71:37

enormous numbers of people all over the

71:39

world without some huge safety concern

71:43

emerging but others have said okay let's

71:46

really dig into those diabetics then so

71:48

that's what Professor f e did so they've

71:50

got they've got very good health

71:51

databases in France the best in the

71:53

world so he decided to look at diabetics

71:57

who' taken these drugs for three years

72:00

sometime between 2006 and I think 2015

72:03

so he looks at loads of the diabetics

72:05

who' taken them and then he compared

72:06

them to a group of other diabetics who

72:09

were very similar in every other way but

72:10

had not taken these drugs to see are

72:12

their differences and outcome and he was

72:13

particularly looking for one outcome we

72:16

know that when you give these drugs to

72:17

rats they are much more likely to

72:19

develop thyroid cancer so he's looking

72:21

okay is there a difference in thyroid

72:22

cancer risk in this population

72:26

and what he discovered was very sobering

72:27

it was published so the people who'

72:29

taken the drugs had a 50 to 75% increase

72:33

in their risk of thyroid cancer now when

72:34

I first said that I was like what the

72:35

[ __ ] you have to understand what that

72:37

doesn't mean that doesn't mean 50 to 75%

72:40

of people who take the drug get thyroid

72:42

cancer if it was that outcome they would

72:44

pull it immediately and no one would

72:45

ever take it again what it means is

72:48

whatever your thyroid cancer risk was at

72:50

the start it will go up by between 50 to

72:53

75% if this res Arch is correct right

72:57

this then is being further investigated

72:59

there are some scientists who dispute it

73:01

the European medic medicines agency has

73:03

not been persuaded by the evidence so

73:05

far but that's pretty sobering right

73:09

that's you know 1.2% of people get

73:10

thyroid cancer in their lifetime 84% of

73:13

them I think survive you know a big

73:15

increase in people getting thyroid

73:16

cancer when you're talking about

73:18

millions of people across the world

73:19

taking it is is very

73:21

alarming what about this thing called

73:23

zmek face yeah I'm not worried about

73:26

that purely purely for a selfish reason

73:28

so a zic face is where um I'm worried

73:31

about it for other people a zic face is

73:34

where you lose so much weight that your

73:35

face looks really gaunt and you look

73:38

kind of hollow and a bit my face is so

73:40

naturally round like babies always smile

73:42

at me I think because they think I'm

73:43

their King I'm just like a baby that

73:45

inexplicably got to walk around um I'm I

73:47

could lose so much weight in my face and

73:49

not look G I'm not worried about that

73:50

myself it's there's no um health problem

73:53

with OIC face it's just it's the vanity

73:55

thing well vanity is too negative a word

73:58

it's you know people don't want to look

74:00

gone and Ill that's fair enough

74:02

pancreitis pancreatitis is a rare side

74:04

effect but it's very very unpleasant so

74:07

um pancreatitis is basically where uh

74:10

your pancreas just goes Haywire as a

74:12

result of taking these drugs I

74:14

interviewed a woman called Michelle stnc

74:16

who's in mytle beach in North Carolina

74:18

she she started taking these drugs and

74:20

her doctor said to her you know there's

74:21

a few side effects one of them is

74:23

pancreatitis and she said go no my luck

74:26

I'll probably get it she starts take it

74:27

was really happy with the weight loss

74:29

six weeks later she went to Pittsburgh

74:31

to visit her daughter she woke up in the

74:34

worst Agony she's ever been in she had

74:36

this excruciating pain running all from

74:39

below her breast around to her back she

74:41

was vomiting she was [ __ ] herself

74:44

she was screaming in pain and her

74:46

son-in-law phoned for an ambulance he

74:49

thought she was about to die she was in

74:50

such a state of distress she arrives at

74:52

the hospital and they um discover gone

74:55

really wrong with her pancreas they said

74:57

are you a heavy drinker she said no then

74:59

they said are you taking OIC and it's

75:02

kind of revealing that was the second

75:03

question they asked so we know that um

75:07

if you take OIC there's a study by the

75:09

University of British Columbia that

75:11

found it increases your risk of

75:12

pancreatitis by a factor of nine so

75:14

you're nine times more likely to get it

75:15

it's still rare you're very unlikely to

75:17

get pancreatitis even when you times it

75:20

by nine it's still a very rare outcome

75:22

but you know doctors often compare it to

75:24

the pain of being stabbed Michelle said

75:26

to me it was much worse than the pain of

75:28

child birth right they had to give a

75:30

fenil to take the pain away so if you

75:32

get medical care you recover but so it's

75:34

worth people knowing that is a

75:36

significant risk uh of just an

75:38

excruciatingly painful condition one of

75:41

my friends has started taking a zmek you

75:44

know there's this word on the side of

75:45

this pen in front of me semaglutide

75:48

semaglutide yeah what did I say it's you

75:51

said it the way it's intuitive the way

75:53

the scientist say I think it says it

75:55

looks like semaglutide exactly that's

75:56

how I said it until all the scientists

75:58

kept correcting me in a slightly

75:59

patronizing way but yeah what's the

76:00

actual word semaglutide and is that the

76:03

chemical and is thenex the brand yeah

76:05

exactly so semaglutide so there's

76:07

there's several Brands um so there's

76:10

seaglide which is the drug which has

76:12

this gp1 Agonist effect um OIC is the

76:15

one for diabetes wovi is the one for

76:17

obesity that exactly the same drug

76:19

they're made in the same Factory they're

76:21

identical it's just that wovi is

76:23

marketed for obesity and you you can in

76:25

the US not here yet prescribe wovi for

76:28

higher doses than you would for for for

76:30

diabetics and then there's other drugs

76:32

that are coming along the line so

76:33

there's munaro which is made by Eli Lily

76:35

so oena wovi produces an average of 15%

76:40

loss of body weight over a year mojarro

76:43

causes a loss of 21% on average and the

76:47

next one that will come down the line is

76:48

probably going to come out next year

76:49

Triple G causes 24.2% the reason mararo

76:53

Works differently so this only works on

76:55

gp1 munaro adds another gut hormone Gip

76:59

so it works on two gut hormones not just

77:00

one and Triple G works on three gut

77:03

hormones and there's going to be more

77:04

and more drugs I mean there's 37 gut

77:06

hormones that can affect appetite they

77:08

think so there's going to be lots of

77:10

variance of these drugs with different

77:13

side effect profiles different risks

77:14

different benefits so yeah this is you

77:16

know one of the South African

77:18

psychiatrist called Carell laru who's

77:21

been at the absolute Forefront of the

77:22

developments and they said to me you

77:24

know when a baby starts to walk it's

77:27

been crawling for ages and then it just

77:28

stands up and it walks and we are at

77:30

that point and it was striking how how

77:33

much the scientists kept describing it

77:36

as a game changer you know one of them

77:38

Tim Spectre who I think you might have

77:39

had on described as um it's like they

77:41

found the Holy Grail they found the

77:43

thing that causes weight loss right uh

77:45

Robert Kushner said that to me who's

77:47

another one of the scientists been at

77:48

the heart of it said we cracked open the

77:50

treasure chest we found the thing that

77:52

controls weight it's your gut hormone B

77:56

so I worry about the parallels with

77:59

previous diet drugs and we can talk

78:00

about that these are new drugs working

78:02

in a new way and the the overwhelming

78:05

feeling in the science is no this really

78:07

is different my friend is um a biotech

78:10

billionaire and um when I when I saw him

78:12

so he's at the very Forefront of all of

78:14

these things he takes so many different

78:16

things to optimize his life one of them

78:18

he started taking as a zek and last time

78:19

I saw him he was um we're in the gym

78:22

together and he was significantly weak

78:25

he was significantly skinnier but I

78:28

noticed when we did our exercises he was

78:30

significantly weaker as well and that

78:33

strikes me as a bit of an unspoken about

78:35

side effect is muscle loss it's one of

78:37

the 12 big risks that I write back in

78:38

the book so muscle mass loss is a real

78:41

problem people who don't know muscle

78:42

mass is the total amount of soft tissue

78:44

that you have in your body and it's

78:45

essential for doing anything that

78:46

requires movement and strength basically

78:49

and any form of weight loss causes a

78:51

reduction in muscle mass so if you if

78:53

someone's bur overweight and they lose a

78:55

huge amount of weight on a diet they

78:57

lose a lot of muscle mass hopefully you

78:58

lose more fat mass than muscle mass but

79:00

you lose a lot of muscle mass you can't

79:01

control that right you just there's no

79:03

way to lose a lot of weight that doesn't

79:04

involve some muscle mass loss unless

79:06

you're very very lucky right um so

79:09

obviously this triggers a huge amount of

79:11

muscle mass loss and there's real

79:14

worries with that right um if you lose

79:17

muscle mass so you naturally lose muscle

79:18

mass from when you're 30 onwards anyway

79:20

you lose quite a lot every year it's

79:21

incredibly depressing when you look at

79:23

the figures you lose muscle mass natur

79:25

every year anyway um but if you lose too

79:28

much muscle mass you won't you'll be a

79:30

bit weaker now but the real risks are

79:31

when you're older so if you have really

79:35

low muscle mass when you're older you're

79:37

at risk of a condition called sarcopenia

79:39

which is Greek for poverty of the flesh

79:41

basically just means you'll really

79:43

struggle to climb the stairs do any kind

79:45

of physical activity you're more likely

79:48

to fall if you do fall you're more

79:49

likely to die it's it's quite a serious

79:52

thing and this I think is particularly

79:53

going to be an issue for people who are

79:56

already skinny like the people at that

79:58

party we were talking about right at the

79:59

start none of them were fat at the start

80:01

right people who were already skinny who

80:03

are taking it to be super skinny they're

80:05

going to see they're going to have real

80:06

issues with their muscle mass likely

80:08

when they're older so this is a very

80:10

serious problem we could be building up

80:11

a time bomb of more frail older people

80:14

further down the line you lose up to 20

80:17

to 30% of your lean muscle mass when you

80:19

start taking a zet says in your book as

80:21

one of the RIS Prof that's for for some

80:22

people yeah not actually weirdly was 33%

80:25

fat Mass when I started and I went down

80:27

to 22% I think it is now so I lost

80:29

nothing but fat Mass but I suspect that

80:31

might be for the slightly humiliating

80:32

reason that I had no muscle to start

80:34

with but I'm not sure and then on the

80:37

psychology the mental health side of

80:38

things suicidality there's some cases

80:41

where suicidality things like feelings

80:43

of anxiety and depression increase is

80:45

that because of the underlying reasons

80:47

why we're eating the self- soothing

80:49

stuff or is that a separate side effect

80:51

so it's hugely debated there isn't even

80:53

agreement that the drugs C caus that

80:54

effect in a minority of people you got

80:56

to bear in mind at any given time some

80:59

of the population becomes suicidal some

81:01

of them will be taking these drugs so

81:03

it's very hard to disentangle that

81:05

especially early on uh so some

81:07

scientists would say there isn't even

81:08

any evidence they cause suicidality

81:11

among the scientists who fear that it

81:12

may cause suicidality there's a big

81:14

debate some of it will be you're

81:16

deprived of comfort food uh or pleasure

81:19

some of it will be as Carell Laro put it

81:22

to me a lot of people who are over wait

81:24

for a long time say you know the reason

81:27

my life is [ __ ] is cuz I'm overweight if

81:29

I finally lose weight my life will be

81:31

good and then they lose weight and

81:32

they've still got the same assle husband

81:35

and they've still got the same job they

81:36

don't like and they suddenly go into

81:38

this crisis where they're like oh it

81:40

wasn't the weight that was blocking me

81:41

it was everything else right they say

81:43

don't they that um the difference

81:44

between like happiness is your

81:46

expectations and reality so you can

81:48

imagine if you have that expectation

81:49

that losing this weight is going to make

81:51

me happy and you fall short of the

81:52

expectation because it doesn't the

81:55

anticlimax can cause so much

81:58

psychological discomfort yeah and I

82:00

spoke to people who've been through that

82:02

and I think that's that that can be a

82:03

really a really big issue there's also

82:05

with Su suicidality so some other people

82:07

who would say well okay the

82:08

psychological effects are probably real

82:10

but it might come back to what we were

82:12

saying about dampening the reward system

82:13

in the brain right there were people

82:15

like um Professor Patricia grigson who's

82:18

done some of the really cutting edge

82:19

research on effects with addiction in

82:21

this who said to me you know that's a

82:23

real concern now she stress we don't

82:25

know yet no one definitively said yes it

82:29

is causing these problems we know how it

82:31

was weird it was like a um like I said

82:34

before it's you're seeing this picture

82:36

form it was fascinating that you're

82:37

there's so much we don't know which

82:39

makes it kind of disconcerting it's like

82:41

oh so this is an experiment on millions

82:42

of people and I'm one of the guinea pigs

82:44

great right so it's disconcerting how

82:46

much we don't know um but yeah that is a

82:49

big worry and we've been here before

82:50

with diet drugs as you alluding to where

82:53

we kind of rush into party and then

82:55

everyone rushes out of the party because

82:57

we realize that the history of diet

82:58

drugs Steven is absolutely Grim beyond

83:02

belief so the first kind of modern diet

83:04

drug was something called dinitrophenol

83:06

so there were a load of um people in

83:08

France who were working in ammunition

83:09

factories during the first world war and

83:12

people noticed that they lost loads of

83:14

weight right not that they had didn't

83:15

have weight problems at the start but

83:16

they lost a huge amount of weight and it

83:19

turned out they were ingesting this

83:20

explosive powder you know through their

83:22

skin and breathing it in so after the

83:24

war a load of scientists at Stanford

83:26

were like oh maybe this can be a weight

83:27

loss treatment so they made it into a

83:29

pill called redu alls uh which were very

83:32

popular there was 100,000 people taking

83:34

them in 1934 which when you consider

83:36

there was very low obesity back then

83:38

that's a huge number of

83:40

people and then they discovered just I

83:43

mean it's it it's almost unbelievably

83:45

terrible what happened so loads of the

83:48

people taking them went

83:49

blind and then they went into this

83:51

horrific fever where their bodies were

83:53

burning up so it's an explosive right so

83:55

it was discovered that the way it works

83:57

is it massively speeds up your

83:58

metabolism but when you take a high dose

84:01

it gives you cataracts makes you go

84:03

blind and then your body goes into a

84:04

fatal fever and the way one person put

84:07

it is you become cooked from the inside

84:10

so they stopped marketing that one it

84:11

continued to be used as a pesticide for

84:13

like years and years because it is so

84:14

good at killing anything it comes across

84:17

so then there was a craze for amphetamin

84:19

so during again during the a war during

84:21

the second world war radar um people are

84:24

to watch Radars soldiers who had to

84:26

watch Radars were extremely bored so

84:28

they gave them amphetamines to sort of

84:30

keep them on the job keep them active

84:32

mentally alert and it was discovered

84:34

they lost loads of weight as well so

84:36

after the war they started marketing

84:38

amphetamines as a weight loss drug right

84:39

and they became hugely popular they were

84:41

described as Mother's Little Helper by

84:44

the time you get to 1970 8% of all the

84:47

prescriptions in the United States were

84:49

F amphetamines for weight loss but it

84:51

was discovered that when you take

84:54

amphetamines you develop tolerance to

84:56

them your body gets used to them so you

84:58

need higher and higher doses to get the

84:59

same effect but if you take really high

85:01

doses of amphetamines you just lose it I

85:04

mean you can become psychotic you it has

85:06

a really bad effect on you you don't

85:08

sleep it's terrible so then there was a

85:10

real rolling back of amphetamines and

85:12

then there were some real horror shows

85:13

like Jaw wiring where they would wire up

85:15

the jaws of obese people so they could

85:17

they literally couldn't get any food

85:19

into their mouths but then it was

85:20

discovered if you vomit while your jaw

85:22

is wide you can choke to death I mean

85:23

just like nightmare marish horrifying

85:26

humiliating Solutions and then we get to

85:28

the worst of them all and also the most

85:31

popular of them all until these new

85:33

drugs which is called fenfen so this was

85:36

in the 1990s early 1990s a group of

85:38

scientists decided to combine two diet

85:41

drugs that had existed until then one

85:43

was called Flex fomine it's an appetite

85:45

suppressant but it was never very

85:47

popular because it makes you very drowsy

85:49

so they combined it with phentramine

85:51

which is an amphetamin so it had the

85:53

kind of it counteracted the drowsiness

85:54

and it had an additional weight loss

85:56

effect and it worked incredibly well

85:58

people taking it lost as much weight as

86:00

they lose on OIC and it's actually Eerie

86:03

when you go back and look at the

86:04

coverage front page of Time Magazine the

86:06

new miracle drug was the headline you

86:09

know by the time you got to the mid90s

86:11

there were 18 million prescriptions for

86:14

fenfen every year in the

86:16

US and then a group of ordinary doctors

86:19

in Fargo in North Dakota were like a lot

86:23

of our patients are getting really ill

86:25

when they take this and raised a safety

86:27

signal turned out the drug company had

86:29

known about this risk all along so it

86:32

was discovered that when you take these

86:33

drugs they cause something called

86:35

primary pulmonary hypertension it's

86:36

where the blood vessels in your lungs

86:38

massively contract and you can't breathe

86:41

properly they also damage your heart I

86:43

mean the stories were just horrendous

86:44

there was a um a young woman in

86:47

Massachusetts called Mary linen who was

86:49

about 28 wanted to lose weight for her

86:51

wedding day starts taking fenfen couple

86:54

of weeks later is trying to climb a hill

86:56

and just gets really breathless and it's

86:58

like so weird here goes home is really

87:01

breathless goes to the doctor he takes

87:03

her off the drug but by then she had the

87:05

problem um she needed oxygen her whole

87:08

life she was told she could never have

87:09

children and then one day she she

87:12

couldn't breathe and she died this

87:14

happened to lots and lots of people it

87:16

led to the largest payout in the history

87:18

of the pharmaceutical industry up to

87:19

that point they had to pay 12 billion

87:21

dollar to the people whose hearts and

87:23

lungs were harmed

87:24

and that is not that long ago now I want

87:26

to stress again that was given to people

87:29

with a very poor there was a single

87:31

study of 120 people of fenfen at the

87:33

point at which it was marketed to people

87:36

which is staggering this has a much

87:38

bigger body of evidence so this is not

87:40

going to be in the short-term fenfen but

87:43

when I looked at the 12 big risks

87:45

associated with these drugs some of

87:46

which have not really been explained to

87:47

the

87:48

public one of the ones that was most

87:50

disconcerting and was explained to me by

87:52

a brilliant scientist called Greg

87:53

Stanwood who Florida State University

87:55

and is researching these

87:57

drugs the biggest risk is what he called

88:00

unknown unknown so you remember that

88:01

Donald Rumsfeld thing right so when he

88:03

was talking about um the invasion of

88:05

Afghanistan but um when he was the US

88:08

Secretary of Defense said you know when

88:10

it comes to these things there are

88:12

things there are what called known

88:13

knowns there are things we know we know

88:15

there are known unknowns there are

88:17

things we know we don't know where is

88:19

Osama bin Laden and there are unknown

88:22

unknowns things we don't know we don't

88:24

know that might hit us out of the blue

88:26

and with these drugs there's a big worry

88:28

about longer term unknown unknowns so

88:31

for example we know very little about

88:33

what happens to pregnant women when

88:35

they're taking these drugs right we know

88:37

that in the animal studies um when

88:39

animals are other non-human animals are

88:41

exposed to these drugs they're much more

88:43

likely to get birth defects so one thing

88:46

Dr Stanwood said that we should think

88:47

about and he stressed this is

88:49

speculative we don't know was think

88:51

about antipsychotics right in the 1950s

88:55

doctors started giving people antis

88:56

psychotics they were judged to be safe

88:58

lots of people dispute that but park

89:00

that for a second and people took them

89:02

for many many decades and then it was

89:04

discovered really late in the day that

89:06

when you get into your 70s and 80s if

89:08

you've been taking antis psychotics you

89:10

are much more likely to get Alzheimer's

89:12

disease and other forms of dementia like

89:13

much more likely now there's no way you

89:16

could have known that at the start it

89:17

was an unknown unknown you couldn't have

89:18

known that you had to have people taking

89:19

it for a really long time before you

89:22

could find that out now one of the

89:24

concerns about these drugs is that there

89:25

will be unknown unknowns that we can't

89:27

know about these drugs are working on

89:29

your brain they are working very hard on

89:32

key parts of your brain parts that

89:34

relate to memory processing taste

89:36

processing um gut motility right we

89:40

don't know but there's at least some

89:43

risk there now again you have to weigh

89:45

that against the risks of obesity as Dr

89:48

sha alevy who's at tillan school of

89:50

medicine put it to me we don't know the

89:52

long-term risks of these drugs we do do

89:54

know the long-term risks of obesity and

89:55

they are horrific really horrific and

89:59

much worse than I thought at the start

90:01

you know for example I'm actually quite

90:04

embarrassed to say this diabetes right

90:07

okay I knew that you were much more

90:08

likely to become diabetic if you were

90:10

obese um figures on that are kind of

90:12

shocking if you're obese when you're a

90:13

teenager your your chances of developing

90:15

diabetes are 70% in your life right

90:18

shocking but I thought all right

90:20

diabetics they get insulin and then

90:22

they're basically like the rest of us

90:23

right as long as you've got Healthcare

90:24

you're fine interviewing doctors they

90:26

were like no no no lots of people think

90:29

that if you get diabetes it it knocks on

90:31

average 15 years off your life there's a

90:34

doctor here Dr Max pton a close friend

90:36

of mine and a brilliant Doctor Who Says

90:39

something to me it seemed really

90:40

shocking when he first said it but then

90:42

he went through the evidence he said if

90:44

you gave me a choice between getting

90:45

diabetes or becoming HIV positive I

90:47

would choose HIV every time if you

90:50

become HIV positive as long as you get

90:52

medical treatment you live as long as

90:54

everyone else if you get diabetes you

90:56

know not only does it knock 15 years off

90:58

your life your chances of all sorts of

91:01

catastrophic complications in your life

91:03

are really high it's the biggest single

91:05

cause of blindness in Britain

91:07

preventable cause of blindness it's

91:09

massive cause of leg amputation more

91:11

people get an extremity cut off in the

91:13

US because of diabetes every year than

91:15

because of being shot right I mean it's

91:17

and you go down the list of all the

91:19

harms associated with

91:21

obesity diabetes isn't even number one

91:24

right so every time I talk about the

91:26

risk of these drugs I really worry about

91:28

the risk of these drugs right there it's

91:30

a lot of them people should go through

91:32

it very carefully if you have thyroid

91:34

cancer in your family for example I

91:36

would strongly recommend you don't take

91:38

them if you know you're already um

91:40

worried about your muscle mass don't

91:42

take them there's a whole range of

91:44

caveats and clauses but we have got to

91:46

be honest about the risk of obesity and

91:49

for me if I'm being honest I think the

91:51

choice was ongoing obesity or these

91:53

drugs and so for me personally I have

91:56

made the Judgment call after looking at

91:57

all of this evidence that I'd rather

92:00

take the risk of OIC than the risk of

92:01

ongoing obes it especially given my

92:03

family's history and how many men Die

92:05

Young of heart attacks but loads of

92:08

people will look at the evidence that I

92:09

present in Magic pill and take totally

92:12

the opposite point of view and they may

92:14

well turn out to be right and I might

92:15

well turn out to be wrong right I

92:17

wouldn't debar that there's a fenfen

92:18

like scenario down the road right I

92:21

don't it's not likely but you'd be a

92:23

fool to dismiss it it I am in a

92:26

different camp and I have to say before

92:27

I express my own opinion that I

92:30

understand there's a lot of people out

92:31

there where drugs like this will

92:32

literally save their life and if they

92:35

don't take these drugs then you know

92:36

you've gone through some of the stats

92:37

but they I mean they will probably die

92:40

from something you know some kind of

92:42

form of uh you know we talk about all

92:44

cause mortality a lot like something

92:46

will kill you in the next couple of

92:47

years whether it's a cardiovascular

92:49

issue or something related to another um

92:52

element related to obes

92:54

obesity my thing and this is I think

92:57

developed over time we're doing this

92:58

podcast and speaking to so many experts

93:00

in health and fitness and wellness and

93:01

psychology and psych Psychiatry is I

93:04

just have this really deep innate belief

93:07

that there's no such thing as a free

93:09

lunch in life and I've just The more

93:13

I've done these interviews The more I've

93:14

come to learn that everything is a

93:16

trade-off and I almost see life as like

93:18

a scale so if you if you if you if you

93:22

put a weight on one end there's going to

93:24

be an equal and an opposite Force

93:26

somewhere else you know like the what's

93:28

the law of physics is it Einstein that

93:29

said that that you can't like destroy

93:32

energy you can just move it and I think

93:34

about the same with like drugs often and

93:37

other things that seem like Miracles or

93:39

shortcuts you're you're moving the set

93:41

of issues somewhere else you've talked

93:43

about some of those movements uh today

93:45

like the psych psychological transfer of

93:47

a uh soothing Behavior to an addiction

93:49

for example that's always been my like

93:51

belief that um whenever one my friends

93:54

says Steve I'm taking this uh Limitless

93:56

pill mfil and it's making me super

93:59

productive and it's fixed all my

94:00

problems in life and I'm killing the

94:02

game now I go what's the cost yeah and

94:04

my friend said to me remember when he

94:06

started taking it he was like there's no

94:07

cost there's no side effects and my

94:09

brain goes history shows if you wait

94:12

long enough there's always a cost it's

94:15

just being conscious of the cost and

94:17

when you balance up as you've done in

94:19

your life the pros and cons you say okay

94:22

I'm willing to take the cost now when I

94:23

I see things like a zek and people say

94:25

to me there is no downside I get more

94:28

scared because I can't run the numbers

94:30

to see whether the cost is worth the

94:32

upside for me so I don't know what the

94:35

the big obvious downsides of a zek and

94:37

these magic drugs are but I feel like

94:40

logically there must be one we do know

94:43

there are some

94:44

medications where pretty dependably the

94:47

benefits outweigh the risk think about

94:49

statins right if you have a problem with

94:51

your cholesterol what statins do is they

94:54

block part of your body that makes

94:56

cholesterol right so it's the most

94:58

commonly prescribed drug in the US it's

95:00

pretty close to it in Britain almost

95:02

every doctor would agree there are some

95:03

downsides to statins but sometimes there

95:05

are just like you have to stay on them

95:07

for life right yeah you have toay like

95:08

with these drugs right the minute you

95:10

stop taking them so within a year of

95:12

stopping you regain 70% of the weight

95:15

you've lost right this is one of the big

95:18

questions around these drugs now that's

95:19

not 100% uh of the people regain it um

95:22

but it's most people seem to regain

95:24

their weight so I think there are

95:26

sometimes when a drug a medication I'm

95:27

not saying these drugs are that

95:29

definitely not but there are some

95:30

medications which do seem to be

95:33

just not that there's no cost but the

95:35

benefits are really unambiguous and

95:37

massively outweigh the cost this is a

95:39

much more finally judged thing and it's

95:40

interesting to me it's been funny

95:41

talking to people who read the book

95:43

because remember talking to the

95:44

marketing teams at both my Publishers

95:47

because some people who were the first

95:49

people to read the book apart from my

95:50

friends so some of them came up to me

95:52

and said oh yeah Han I loved your your

95:53

book it made me really want to take oen

95:55

piic someu came up to me and said Yan I

95:58

loved your book it made me think

95:59

convinced that you'd have to be

96:01

completely insane to take o zic and it

96:03

was a bit like you know the dress the uh

96:04

some people saw it as gold some people

96:06

saw it as

96:07

blue and I felt like that meant I'd done

96:10

my job because unlike pretty much

96:13

everything else I've ever

96:15

written I've ended this feeling as

96:17

conflicted almost as I was at the start

96:21

right this is a huge thing it's going to

96:25

change and we've talked a lot about the

96:26

personal dilemmas it's going to have a

96:28

huge social effect Barkley's Bank

96:30

commissioned a very sober-minded analyst

96:31

named Emily field to um make predictions

96:35

that could guide investment based on

96:37

these drugs and she said if you want an

96:39

analogy you have to think of the

96:40

invention of the smartphone right I mean

96:43

this is going to have so many

96:44

unpredictable effects um already crispy

96:47

K cream donut stocks have been tanking

96:49

the head of nestle Mark Schneider has

96:51

said we they're worried about their ice

96:52

cream and infection ranges and Jeff

96:56

Financial did a report for the airlines

96:58

in the US saying they're going to have

97:00

to spend much less on jet fuel pretty

97:01

soon because it cost takes so much less

97:03

jet fuel to fly a much thinner

97:05

population what I was fascinated by is

97:08

um companies that manufacture hinges for

97:11

knee and hip replacements are seeing

97:14

their stocks tank because people are

97:16

going to need far fewer neon hip

97:18

replacements cuz that overwhelmingly

97:20

that's driven by obesity right so not

97:22

entirely but overwhelmingly

97:24

um so yeah if we were talking in 2007

97:27

when the day Steve Jobs unveiled the

97:29

iPhone I don't think we could have

97:31

gained

97:32

out you know one tenth of what was about

97:35

to hit us and I kept having these

97:37

moments traveling all over the world

97:39

interviewing these experts remember one

97:42

day I was in a cafe I was interviewing

97:44

one of the key

97:45

neuroscientists at Cambridge University

97:47

who was working on this we were in a

97:50

cafe and there were loads of people

97:52

walking past and it's you know just

97:53

random British people a lot of whom are

97:55

overweight or obese like I

97:57

was and I thinking wow you don't know

98:00

what's about to hit us all it was a

98:03

slightly weird unreal feeling I mean

98:06

this is is for better and for worse and

98:09

I think there will definitely be

98:10

positive effects and there will

98:11

definitely be negative effects and I

98:13

think we can see early on what quite a

98:15

lot of them are this will change the

98:18

lives of all of us in one way or another

98:21

how do you guys manage your stress this

98:23

is Stress Awareness Month and it's a

98:26

topic that I'm super passionate about

98:27

and we talk about a lot in this podcast

98:29

I personally manage my stress by

98:31

prioritizing my health and well-being

98:32

going to the gym is my number one form

98:34

of therapy and I couldn't be without

98:37

those two things as you guys know whoop

98:39

is a sponsor of this podcast and I'm an

98:40

investor in the company as well for

98:42

those of you that don't know whoop

98:44

actually created a stress monitor within

98:46

this device not only does this helped me

98:48

to identify periods of high stress in

98:49

real time throughout the day but it also

98:51

provides me with the tools I need to to

98:53

deal with stresses as they come up

98:55

throughout the day and it's based on

98:57

scientifically backed breathing

98:59

exercises and research that's been

99:01

developed by Leading neuroscientists

99:03

it's a feature that has been

99:04

gamechanging for me and I highly

99:06

recommend if you're someone that's

99:07

looking to manage your stress levels

99:09

then head over to join. woop.com

99:13

CEO where we'll give you 30 days

99:16

risk-free and zero commitment to try

99:18

whoop let me know how you get on I'm

99:21

just I was thinking as you were speaking

99:22

there about bunch of Statistics that

99:24

I've read recently humans are getting

99:26

more and more sedentary which means

99:27

we're moving a lot less um obviously

99:29

obesity is going up across the sort of

99:32

Western World um most

99:35

obviously uh and then you've got this

99:37

rise in a zmek which allows us to stay

99:40

skinny basically and suppress our

99:41

appetite I was just wondering there's

99:43

going to be it feels like there's going

99:44

to be two groups of people when these

99:45

drugs drop in cost and they become

99:47

really accessible and i' I've saw you

99:49

say in the book that the next sort of

99:51

iteration of these drugs is going to be

99:52

a pill a lot of people won't want to

99:53

inject something I'm one of the people

99:55

that just I'd get too squeamish about

99:56

having to inject myself so the minute

99:58

something becomes a pill it brings down

99:59

one of the psychological barriers it's

100:01

cheap it's a pill a lot of people are

100:04

doing it if you're not doing it in the

100:08

obesogenic whatever that long word was

100:10

environment we live in it's almost like

100:13

you're going to be a an inferior human

100:15

to some degree like there's going to be

100:16

two parts of society the 50% that are

100:18

down to take the pill and they're going

100:20

to be skinny and they're going to be

100:21

whatever and then the 50% that are

100:22

struggling in this this difficult food

100:24

environment we live in with the ultra

100:25

processed food um I can't I almost can't

100:29

play out a scenario where most people

100:32

aren't taking this magic pill so there's

100:35

a few assumptions of what you've said um

100:37

I think you're probably right but

100:39

there's a few assumptions so in a way

100:41

what you're saying there's sort of few

100:43

different dystopias that could

100:45

emerge one is actually that we don't

100:48

even get to where you are because it's

100:50

restricted to a tiny number of rich

100:51

people right so let's start with the

100:53

first like dystopian Vision we could

100:55

have the first is that we never even get

100:57

to that point let's imagine we basically

101:00

we have a situation at the moment where

101:01

the Real Housewives of New Jersey get to

101:03

be super super skinny and the real

101:05

school children of New Jersey get

101:07

diabetes at the age of 12 right so we

101:09

could have a situation where these drugs

101:12

exist and they work very well but they

101:14

are restricted to a tiny Elite of rich

101:16

people which is kind of where we are

101:19

it's not going to stay like that though

101:20

is it in the longer term it won't and

101:22

it's not that far off so 2032 The Paton

101:25

on OIC passes so then it's not actually

101:28

that expensive to make these drugs it's

101:29

$40 a month to actually make them it's

101:31

the rest is profits for NOA Nordisk who

101:33

argue understandably you know look we

101:35

took all the risks of developing this we

101:37

should cash in now um you can see that

101:40

argument although I don't think they

101:41

need to cash in quite as much as they

101:42

are uh so one scenario is it go it will

101:45

go out of patent in

101:46

2032 by then it looks like the main way

101:49

of taking some agati will be pills

101:51

anyway so you can well imagine in a

101:53

situation where you've got $40 a month

101:55

to take a daily pill that will make you

101:57

much thinner I think in that scenario

101:59

you're right now what I'm most

102:03

hope is that a the drugs don't have a

102:05

catastrophic side effect obviously B the

102:08

people who want them get them and see it

102:11

wakes us up and we go how did we get to

102:15

this point how did we get to the point

102:18

where we're looking at potentially

102:19

drugging our children forever not

102:21

knowing the long-term effects

102:23

who did this to us and how can we be

102:25

more like Japan and all the other

102:26

countries that are making these changes

102:28

that's optimistic that requires a lot of

102:30

uh raising of Consciousness between now

102:32

and then but that's the most optimistic

102:34

scenario thing but you're totally right

102:35

there could be a a scenario it's

102:38

probably the most likely scenario if

102:39

there isn't some big risk that emerges

102:42

that we'll just have staggering amounts

102:44

of the population taking these

102:46

drugs unless the government intervene

102:49

that feels like the most likely scenario

102:51

unless the government introdu some laws

102:52

that put restrictions on what children

102:54

can eat at school and all those kinds of

102:56

things in a more severe way I can't see

102:58

a scenario where especially with this

103:00

younger generation you know you hear all

103:01

these stats around young girls on Tik

103:03

Tok being more anxious than ever before

103:05

the suicidality going up men are

103:08

struggling more than ever with body

103:09

dysmorphia which no one's talking about

103:12

I was reading some stats about that

103:13

yesterday yeah shocking the figures on

103:15

that and the antidote appears to be I

103:19

mean

103:20

this it's not a good solution right and

103:24

perfectly normal healthy people who just

103:26

have a little bit of belly fat and they

103:29

hear this you know they hear about this

103:30

stuff they go you know going to the gym

103:31

is hard and I do love those burgers and

103:33

that KFC is really nice it does tastes

103:34

really good so I could eat my KFC and I

103:37

could stay skinny I think that last bit

103:40

then they're wrong you you if you take

103:42

it you won't want to eat the KFC in the

103:43

burgers and believe me I have been the

103:44

king of KFC just three bites I got a

103:47

couple of bites though well but you

103:48

don't get you actually don't even want

103:50

that particularly right and huge numbers

103:52

of people seeing that I mean for most of

103:55

the time I have been eating smaller

103:56

portions of similar [ __ ] but um actually

103:59

even your taste for that tends to kind

104:01

of Wayan over time right so the last

104:03

bit's wrong but I think yeah you it's

104:06

one of the things it's funny I

104:07

didn't it's one of the things that made

104:09

me really angry in

104:12

Japan I was

104:13

thinking all this agonizing I've done

104:16

all this worrying and I worry even more

104:19

about the fact we're almost certainly

104:20

about to start a mass wave of drugging

104:22

children with asmic already begun in the

104:25

US I interviewed parents who drugging

104:26

their kids because their children are

104:29

obese and I thought this whole dilemma

104:32

never had to happen right this happened

104:35

because the food industry screwed us

104:37

over and we didn't regulate them and we

104:39

didn't stop them and we can start to do

104:41

that and I went to places that have done

104:42

it I went to Mexico where they

104:43

introduced a sugar tax usually reduce

104:45

the amount of sugar that people consume

104:47

I went to Minneapolis where they

104:49

prescribe healthy food for poorer people

104:51

who can't afford it has a a really

104:53

positive effect I went to Finland where

104:55

they had a huge transformation in the

104:56

food supply I went to Japan there's load

104:59

here in Britain there was a really

105:00

interesting experiment bread used to

105:03

have far more salt in it and a really

105:05

heroic guy called Professor Gran

105:06

McGregor who I interviewed persuaded the

105:08

government to just to get the food

105:10

companies to sort of lore them I mean

105:12

they would have they threatened

105:13

regulation which meant that the

105:14

companies gave in before they did it to

105:16

just massively reduce the amount of salt

105:18

in bread no one even noticed and it

105:21

reduced Strokes every year in written by

105:23

between 6,000 and 9,000 right and a

105:26

stroke is one of the worst things that

105:27

can ever happen to you now we could do

105:29

it's called reformulation there's loads

105:31

of other things we can do like that we

105:33

could reformulate loads of foods in ways

105:35

that aren't even painful to us right

105:37

there's so much we can do as so much we

105:40

can do to be like Japan I mean it was a

105:42

bit weird in Japan though because there

105:43

were things they did that we can't do

105:46

right so I'll give you an example this

105:48

was one of the weirdest days in the

105:49

research for the book in 2008 obesity

105:53

very slightly went up in Japan it was

105:55

still like laughably low and they had a

105:57

real panic and they introduced this new

105:59

law it's called the Metabo law um it's

106:02

named after metabolic syndrome which is

106:04

a really nasty combination of like

106:06

diabetes obesity and other problems you

106:08

can get when you're when you're very

106:09

overweight and um the law is very simple

106:14

every single company in Japan on a

106:16

particular day every year has to weigh

106:19

every single person who works there and

106:21

if their weight has gone up they have to

106:22

drop a plan with their employer to bring

106:24

their weight down and as a company

106:27

overall if your weight goes up you can

106:29

be fined by the government and I was

106:30

like how could this possibly work so I

106:32

went to a company that does it tanita

106:34

they all do it but a company that let me

106:35

go and see how it

106:37

works and it's really weird right you at

106:40

this workplace you arrive you show your

106:41

face to a video screen it says hi

106:44

Stephen you walked 14,000 steps

106:46

yesterday you're number 121 in the

106:49

company in terms of steps taken cuz

106:50

everyone has to wear like a Fitbit well

106:52

equivalent to a Fitbit everyone uploads

106:55

pictures of every meal they have to this

106:57

system where you can see it it was

106:59

bizarre right um and yeah explain to

107:02

Japanese people who kept going you know

107:04

every morning in this office when we'd

107:06

all be having donuts and coffee they do

107:09

aerobics together it was bizarre and I

107:13

sort of explain to these Japanese people

107:14

right if you tried to do this in Britain

107:15

we would burn the [ __ ] office down

107:18

right like and they would just go well

107:20

why why they couldn't understand why I

107:23

was so affronted by it and that okay

107:25

that's a big cultural Chasm and we can't

107:27

do that and I wouldn't want us to do

107:29

that but if you look at so many of the

107:31

other changes in

107:33

Japan I started to see like what you win

107:36

if you get this right so Japan has the

107:38

longest life expectancy in the whole

107:40

world and one of the best things I did

107:42

for the book One the most moving things

107:44

for me is I went to the oldest village

107:46

in the whole world it's in okanawa in

107:48

the deep south of Japan and there's a

107:50

village called ogimi where there's 20 15

107:53

households and 190 of them have someone

107:55

who's over the age of 90 living there

107:57

right so it's the oldest place on Earth

107:59

um Japan has the by far the longest life

108:02

expectancy in the world and not just

108:04

that um you're far less likely to get

108:07

sick as you age so they have not just

108:09

more life but more healthy life and I

108:13

went to their little Community

108:15

Center and the first person I met was a

108:18

102y old woman called Matsu fukuchi who

108:21

was this like almost like Kind of

108:23

Perfect crumple of wrinkles right she

108:25

was so cheerful chatting to her she was

108:28

like I can't stay for long cuz I'm

108:29

looking after my son who fell off the

108:30

roof the other day fixing it I was like

108:32

Jesus how old is your son um and she was

108:35

like oh I love you know she was so full

108:37

of joy she I love life I spent all of

108:39

yesterday watching volleyball with my

108:41

grandchildren it's so great she was so

108:43

happy she'd walked there on her own and

108:47

then there was this moment where they

108:48

put on some music she put on this red

108:51

kimono and she started dancing and all

108:54

these old in these women as old as a

108:56

century start dancing right and I danced

108:58

with her and I was thinking God this is

109:02

this woman was born before radio started

109:05

broadcasting in Japan and here I am

109:07

recording an interview with her on my

109:10

iPhone this is what you get if you get

109:13

this right if you sort out the Obesity

109:15

crisis you get to have more years of

109:18

health and joy and dancing right that's

109:22

what we're fighting for here I think

109:25

about how many people I know who died

109:29

young because of complications related

109:31

to obesity everyone listening and

109:33

watching will know someone who would be

109:35

alive now if we had sorted out the

109:37

Obesity crisis but has died everyone

109:41

right and it doesn't have to be this way

109:45

you know now part of that solution in

109:49

the short and medium term is going to be

109:50

these drugs in the longer term it

109:52

doesn't have to even be that right Japan

109:54

is a real country it exists they solved

109:57

this problem there are other countries

109:58

in the world that are solving these

110:00

problems we don't have to tolerate this

110:02

being done to our children we don't have

110:04

to accept us being made sick and our

110:06

children being made sick but it requires

110:09

an Awakening around what's really

110:11

happening who's doing this to us at the

110:12

moment you know whenever I my weight

110:15

goes up and down right it has gone up

110:16

and down throughout my life and whenever

110:18

I was fatter I would blame myself right

110:20

I wasn't angry with the forces that have

110:21

done this to us right

110:23

more three-year-old children know what

110:25

the McDonald's m means than know their

110:27

own last name right I didn't choose that

110:30

world I didn't choose to live in a world

110:32

where we were you know constantly

110:34

promoted and fattened and physically

110:37

changed such that it's hard to come back

110:39

right that don't mean I had no

110:40

responsibility in that I did but we

110:44

don't have to continue like this do you

110:46

think you could stay at the we you are

110:49

now without this as EK it's funny you

110:52

holding this I feel like we're in a

110:53

weird dystopian version of QVC right um

110:57

do I think uh honestly well if I'm

111:00

typical we know from the clinical trials

111:01

70% of people regain the weight within a

111:04

year no I don't think so if I'm being

111:06

really honest with myself I don't think

111:08

so I think I have made lots of changes

111:10

in my life that mean I don't think I

111:11

would go back to quite where I was but I

111:14

think I would very rapidly regain a lot

111:16

of weight so you have to take this for

111:18

life now to stay the way you're at

111:19

therefore yeah and there's a big debate

111:21

about we mentioned before with the

111:22

amphetamin based um diet drugs from the

111:26

past that people develop tolerance one

111:28

of the big question marks around this is

111:30

do people develop tolerance does it mean

111:32

that over time it will have less of an

111:34

effect right now some scientists the

111:36

scientists asked about this just were

111:38

wildly all over the place some said no

111:40

we do know diabetics don't seem to

111:42

develop tolerance they because if they

111:44

did they would need higher and higher

111:45

doses to get the same level of control

111:48

for their blood sugar so that's a point

111:50

against tolerance but others said

111:53

it would seem quite likely we developed

111:54

tolerance we developed tolerance for

111:55

most drugs it would be surprising if we

111:58

didn't probably what's most likely again

112:00

Carell luro the South African

112:01

psychiatrist said to

112:02

me again probably the best comparison is

112:05

bariatric surgery you have bariatric

112:08

surgery you lose an absolute [ __ ] ton of

112:10

weight and then you regain a little bit

112:12

of it over the next few years and then

112:14

you sort of plateau at that higher point

112:17

but we don't know the truth is no one

112:19

knows I'm also concerned that if you is

112:21

there a world where if you stopped

112:23

taking this your body had become reliant

112:25

on your gp1 coming from this so your

112:28

body makes less glp1 itself don't think

112:30

it's so much I don't think that's the

112:32

concern I think but there is I think

112:33

you've gone to a really important point

112:35

we know all forms of diet slow down your

112:37

metabolism right that's a reality about

112:41

diet um which is why often people end up

112:44

fatter at the end than they were at the

112:46

start um I'm worried about and again I

112:50

asked lots of scientists and people just

112:51

said we don't know

112:53

I'm worried about

112:55

um is my metabolism slowing down as I

112:58

take this drug if I let's say they

113:00

discovered some terrible problem with it

113:02

and it had to be withdrawn would I then

113:05

have a slower metabolism and be fatter

113:07

than I was at the start yeah no one

113:09

knows that's a significant risk and the

113:11

other big sort of risk here is you've

113:12

talked about a few times is this eating

113:14

disorder um epidemic it seems I think

113:18

you talk about in your book that since

113:19

March 2020 rates of anorexia and bmia

113:21

were 42% higher than they would be

113:24

expected for teenage girls aged 13 to 16

113:27

I think that's cuz of lockdown to be

113:28

fair that's not that's not a result of

113:29

the drugs that's because of the massive

113:31

stress of lockdown yeah some research in

113:33

the lon journal and 32% higher for those

113:36

aged 17 to 19 what I'm saying here is

113:38

that we we do have an issue with eating

113:40

disorders in in the Western World

113:42

especially um they they skyrocketed

113:45

after the the pandemic but when I think

113:47

about eating disorders and bulimia and

113:49

anorexia and I think about this and and

113:52

what it might mean for those Eating

113:55

Disorders I feel somewhat concerned

113:57

especially when kids get their hands on

113:58

them go beyond concerned and we don't

114:01

have to speculate about this we've been

114:02

here before so in the early '90s there

114:05

was a very popular amphetamin based diet

114:07

drug that was marketed in the United

114:08

States and it was huge and lots of

114:12

teenage girls used it and it led to a

114:13

catastrophe there was a guy called Rob

114:15

weyden who was a congressman for Ohio at

114:17

the time who held Congressional hearings

114:19

on this and they are really chilling to

114:21

read because they show what happens when

114:23

a popular diet drug combines with eating

114:26

disordered young women right so there

114:29

was a a woman called Jessica McDonald

114:31

who testified at the hearing she was um

114:34

she was in her early 20s at the time so

114:36

she was a ballet dancer obviously we

114:38

know about the horrendous pressures on

114:40

body shape for ballet dancers and she

114:42

would take this drug like this

114:44

amphetamin based drug until she passed

114:47

out to be thin she would take it to

114:48

starve herself because she wanted to be

114:50

that that ballet shap there's a guy

114:51

called Tony Smith from state center in

114:53

Iowa who testifies that his daughter

114:56

Noel from when she was very young became

114:58

obsessed with the idea that she was fat

115:00

she would go and look at these fashion

115:01

magazines and say daddy do you think I'm

115:03

fat why don't I look like these

115:06

women and she got hold of these diet

115:08

drugs massively starved herself and died

115:10

of a heart attack and he read out this

115:11

heartbreaking poem where she describes

115:14

like you know I'm

115:16

hungry I want to eat but not yet not yet

115:20

right so we know that when a diet drug

115:23

combines with eating disorders it leads

115:25

to catastrophic outcomes we don't have

115:26

to speculate so yeah that's one of my

115:29

three or four biggest concerns now like

115:31

I say we can introduce regulation now to

115:33

mean you only get it from a doctor the

115:34

doctor has to see you that will cut some

115:37

of that but I don't see how and and

115:39

that's really important and anyone we

115:41

save is worth saving but yeah I'm very

115:43

very concerned about that I'm also

115:45

concerned about a more subtle effect in

115:46

relation to that so the worst moment I

115:50

had in writing the book was not any of

115:51

the physical side effects for me

115:53

although there were some Grim moments

115:54

there early on it was a moment when um

115:59

so M I've got a niece called Erin and

116:01

she's 18 now although she's 19 actually

116:04

but in my head she's sort of six years

116:05

old all the time like CU she's the baby

116:07

of my family she's the only girl she was

116:08

the youngest so no one makes me more

116:10

protective and one day a few months into

116:12

taking these drugs I was FaceTiming with

116:14

her she was in a pub in

116:16

Liverpool and she was like oh Yan you've

116:18

lost so much weight and I was like

116:19

preining she's like oh look I can see

116:20

your drawer I never knew you had a

116:21

drawer and I was like oh yeah I was

116:23

looking you're happy and

116:25

then she looked down and she

116:29

said will you get me some oamic she's a

116:32

perfectly healthy weight she always has

116:35

been and I thought what the [ __ ] am I

116:39

doing all her life I've been trying to

116:41

give her this

116:42

message don't be judged by how you look

116:46

don't worry about that you know and I

116:48

thought I've

116:49

counteracted everything I wanted to

116:51

communicate

116:53

and we know and and she decided not to

116:56

take it and all and ended fine with her

116:58

but when I was a kid there were no fat

117:00

people on television except as the butt

117:01

of the joke and I think about my niece

117:03

she's grown up seeing actually quite a

117:04

lot of women who have a broader range of

117:06

body shapes in the public eye and in the

117:08

last two years almost all of those women

117:11

have massively shrunk now they're not

117:14

talking about a zic but unless there's

117:15

been some kind of outbreak of dentry in

117:17

Malibu I think we know what's happening

117:19

right some of them are talking about it

117:20

but most are not can I just ask on that

117:22

cuz we've seen a lot of very famous

117:25

faces suddenly shrink over the last

117:27

couple of years and when you read their

117:29

autobiographies they talk about like

117:30

going to the gym and eating getting

117:32

their lifestyle right do you think

117:34

they're lying I mean

117:36

obviously yes it does appear I wasn't

117:39

sure if it was just me but I look I look

117:41

think about a lot of people that were a

117:43

little bit bigger and it seems that

117:45

suddenly everybody's kind of

117:47

cracked weight loss and it's rapid and

117:50

it's super fast I don't want to name any

117:52

particular names cuz it's not my place

117:54

to talk about individuals like that but

117:56

it really does seem like Hollywood has

117:59

found a p a great personal trainer and

118:02

I'm I'm just like I'm wondering if um if

118:06

this is what it is yes although I think

118:10

I would say the people you and I think

118:12

about are almost all women and I do

118:15

think we should be I know you would

118:16

agree with this I'm not making this as a

118:17

point against you women get so much more

118:21

[ __ ] than men men for this sort of thing

118:23

right like actually one of my editors

118:25

said to me you know I was saying why has

118:28

no one else written a book about OIC yet

118:29

why am I the only one and they said cuz

118:32

only a man could write this because a

118:33

woman would be crucified for writing it

118:36

right she would be monstered and if you

118:37

look whenever even someone as

118:39

unbelievably popular and amazing as

118:41

Oprah slightly C is my friend um gets

118:45

Savaged for it right and there's lots of

118:47

deep underlying reasons for that that

118:51

came out for me as well actually that I

118:53

I I projected towards myself I remember

118:55

for a long time taking the

118:58

drug I felt like I I mentioned this a

119:00

little bit before but I felt like I was

119:03

cheating I felt like I was sinning

119:05

almost and I started to look at the kind

119:07

of deep ideas they're so deep in our

119:10

kind of collective unconscious if you

119:13

look at so for example in the 6th

119:15

Century the pope Pope Gregory the first

119:17

draws up the seven deadly sins right and

119:18

one of them is gluttony and it's this

119:20

image it's always depicted with an image

119:21

of some hugely fat person looking like a

119:24

pig you know and it's

119:26

horrible it's very deep in our culture

119:29

the idea that being obese is a sin right

119:32

if you look at the forms of weight loss

119:34

we admire they follow the pattern of sin

119:37

right the kind of classic Catholic

119:38

pattern of sin you sin then you have to

119:41

suffer and redeem yourself and then we

119:43

forgive you right so if you look at the

119:45

forms of weight loss we admire there're

119:47

ones where people are humiliated and

119:49

suffer terribly you starve yourself you

119:52

um you know you think about that show

119:54

The Biggest Loser which I hate uh you

119:56

know where severely obese people are

119:58

made to sort of compete and gring

120:00

horrific forms of exercise then we're

120:02

like okay Jabba we forgive you now you

120:05

know what I mean we use this kind of

120:06

stigmatizing ways of

120:07

thinking cheating is a bit more

120:10

subtle because I kept thinking I'm

120:12

cheating as I do this and I was like

120:13

well that's really weird if I if I had a

120:15

heart problem and I took statins I would

120:17

not think I was cheating right I said

120:18

why is that and I think it's partly so

120:21

people put in a huge amount of effort to

120:22

be thin right loads of women watching

120:25

this and it's disproportionately women

120:27

will suffer some privation and

120:30

deprivation in their life because they

120:31

are really trying to be thin and then

120:34

they hear a this [ __ ] just injects

120:36

himself once a week and he gets to be

120:38

thin like me it's like they feel the way

120:40

I imagine cyclists do when they look at

120:42

Lance Armstrong right and the only way

120:44

out of those that negative conversation

120:48

where we turn on each other like rats in

120:49

a sack is to realize

120:52

oh there is a sin and there are people

120:54

who are cheating but it's not Oprah it's

120:57

not someone who Jeff Parker that guy I

121:00

mentioned who you know didn't want to

121:02

die young it's the food industry that

121:04

[ __ ] all of us that's why we're in

121:06

that race right that's why you're

121:07

starving yourself that's why we feel

121:09

we're

121:10

Sinners okay well we can collectively

121:13

come together and challenge that shared

121:14

opponent if we want but if we're just

121:16

going to get into look it's very hard in

121:19

this age of social media Madness to not

121:22

have every conversation turn into a

121:24

toxic conversation and it's not

121:25

surprising that something is charged as

121:27

a debate about a zenic and weight has

121:30

become so toxic so quickly but again we

121:34

don't have to do that that the toxicity

121:36

isn't going to get us out of this right

121:37

we're in a shared crisis everyone

121:39

watching has someone they love who is on

121:41

course to Die Young because of the

121:43

problems associated with obesity because

121:45

obesity is so widespread in this Society

121:48

in a very recent amount of time look at

121:50

a picture of a beach in Britain

121:52

in 1975 not a million years ago everyone

121:56

is thin by our standards right this

121:58

happened in the blink of an eye in human

122:00

terms right again we don't have to

122:03

tolerate that part of it is also we

122:05

don't like when people lose weight some

122:06

of us because it shines the light on us

122:09

and I think about someone like Adele who

122:12

dropped a ton of weight very quickly and

122:14

the shocking thing when she when she

122:16

dropped that photo I think it was at

122:17

like a birthday party because she went

122:19

from like being you know a certain way

122:21

to then dropping weight very quickly so

122:23

we because we don't see Adele's private

122:24

life life much it was just this the

122:26

selfie she dropped and if you look

122:28

online at the reaction people were

122:30

betrayed they felt betrayed by Adele's

122:33

weight loss not because they're they're

122:35

assuming she used a zenic or anything

122:37

the fact she's now

122:38

not the way she was in terms of her

122:41

weight people were like almost angry

122:43

about it and the same happened with

122:44

Rebel Wilson When Rebel Wilson dropped a

122:46

ton of weight because in her book she

122:47

talks about you know she wanted to

122:50

increase her chance of having a kid so

122:52

her doctor advised her to lose lose the

122:53

we people were Ang like almost angry

122:56

that they lost someone they could maybe

122:59

relate to or that made them feel a

123:00

certain way about themselves which I

123:02

find to be really interesting that we

123:04

actually don't like it when

123:06

someone loses way we've got to

123:09

understand where that's coming from

123:10

obviously I don't support anyone being

123:13

cruel to people online and it's good for

123:15

both ad Del and Rebel Wilson that

123:16

they've improved their

123:17

health um but I think where it comes

123:21

from and a lot of these things that can

123:22

seem a little bit odd that that are kind

123:24

of said we've got to realize how much

123:28

shame people are soaking up on this

123:29

issue you know if you have a BMI higher

123:32

than 35 and you're a woman 45% of women

123:35

in that position get insulted every

123:37

single day in public every day right so

123:40

you're walking through the world

123:42

constantly being made to feel there's

123:43

something wrong with you being treated

123:45

like [ __ ] um and I can see how people in

123:48

that position develop a sort of

123:50

parasocial relationship with Rebel

123:51

Wilson or Adele like oh look we can look

123:54

to Adele and they feel trapped they feel

123:56

they can't lose weight and then they see

123:58

Adele and Rebel Wilson and they're just

124:00

like oh two brute [ __ ] you you know I

124:02

get it now it's not the right response I

124:05

would want to talk to them more about

124:06

okay what we want to think deeper about

124:09

this but I can see where it comes from

124:11

and I can see why some people look at me

124:13

and go you [ __ ] right I totally get it

124:17

I suspect I would have felt that anger

124:18

were I not me looking at me right so I

124:20

get where the anger this comes from from

124:23

the moment we're born in this culture we

124:26

are primed to be overweight and we are

124:29

primed to feel tremendous amounts of

124:31

Shame about being overweight right and

124:35

anything that comes along and brings up

124:37

those stories and forces us to think to

124:39

them brings them to the surface like

124:40

these new weight loss

124:43

drugs just leeches out of all of us so

124:48

many negative and angry and hurt

124:50

feelings and I felt it myself

124:52

right I felt so much self-doubt all the

124:55

way through this I still feel self-doubt

124:57

about it I still have days where I

124:58

wonder am I doing completely the wrong

125:02

thing so I do think we have to

125:04

understand where it's coming from and

125:05

not just sort of know you're not doing

125:07

this you're always interested in

125:08

understanding where people come from but

125:09

it's tempting to just condemn people and

125:13

go look at this bad behavior and I'm

125:14

always more interested when people are

125:15

behaving badly and it is cruel to say to

125:18

Adele you [ __ ] you betrayed us uh I

125:21

mean I would never say anything about to

125:22

Adell anyway because I love Adell but I

125:24

saw her in Vegas she's incredible but

125:26

um I do think we always have to try to

125:29

understand and it comes from a place of

125:30

profound pain and that's not a pain that

125:32

those people deserved right that and

125:34

that's a pain they should never have

125:35

been subjected to but one of the really

125:37

surprising things you talk about in your

125:39

book is the relationship that a zek has

125:40

on addiction and I couldn't quite figure

125:43

out why there'd be any impact on

125:45

addiction if we start taking AE drugs

125:47

you talk about the how it eases the food

125:49

chatter in our brains and the sort of

125:50

food cravings we have but then there's a

125:52

lot of research you go into that shows

125:55

um a zenek and these kinds of drugs can

125:57

actually have an impact on our um

125:59

addiction to things like cocaine and

126:01

alcohol so this is much disputed and

126:03

there are serious scientists on both

126:05

sides but I found it mindblowing and

126:08

totally fascinating so for

126:11

example woman called Elizabeth yog who's

126:13

a professor at the University of

126:15

gothenberg in Sweden has done some of

126:17

the pioneering work on this I

126:18

interviewed her a

126:19

lot they get a loot of rats and they put

126:21

them in a cage and they give them loads

126:24

of alcohol and rats will like alcohol

126:26

and they get hammered like the rest of

126:27

us and they wobble about and they love

126:29

it right so they put them in this cage

126:30

for a while they've got plenty of

126:31

alcohol they get drunk over many weeks

126:34

and then once it starts to resemble like

126:36

a dive bar in vas they do an

126:38

intervention they come along and they

126:40

inject them with gp1 Agonist the exact

126:42

drug you've got in front of you stide um

126:45

and then they watch and what they

126:46

discovered what professor yog and her

126:48

colleagues discovered is afterwards the

126:50

rats drink about 60% less than they did

126:53

before and the Rats who drank most

126:55

heavily are the ones who cut back on

126:56

their drinking the most like whoa what's

126:58

going on there but then they thought

127:00

okay maybe it's because alcohol's got a

127:02

caloric content it's like they want the

127:04

calories less right so then there were

127:06

experiments done with drugs that don't

127:08

contain any calories so Professor

127:10

Patricia grigson who's at Penn State

127:12

University gets rats heavily using

127:15

heroin and fenil gives them a GP Agonist

127:18

again finds the same thing 50% reduction

127:21

ction in the rats using the her self

127:23

administering the the heroin and the

127:25

fenil Then Greg stanard who I mentioned

127:27

before who's at Florida State University

127:29

does it with cocaine in it was mice not

127:31

rats for him again 50% reduction in them

127:34

using cocaine we don't know why again it

127:37

come some of the theories come back to

127:39

that question about the reward system

127:41

could it be dampening the reward system

127:43

one of the things a lot of the

127:44

scientists find fascinating is these

127:46

drugs appear to have what they call SEL

127:49

activity so SEL activity is where

127:52

the drug makes you want less of the Big

127:54

Mac but not less of a salad right so it

127:57

seems to it doesn't just generally

127:58

dampen you don't just not eat at all

128:01

some people do with malnutrition as a

128:02

risk but most people don't right so

128:05

given that it's some of them argue again

128:09

it's highly speculative at this point it

128:12

seems to be activating downgrading your

128:15

desire for things that are bad for you

128:17

but not things that are good for you

128:18

right I'm thinking how can that be that

128:20

seems so weird let's I'm Elton John

128:22

right and I get my pleasure from playing

128:24

music how can it know to tell me to eat

128:27

fewer Jam sandwiches but not to engage

128:29

in jamming right how can it do that and

128:31

they kept saying we don't know there

128:34

does seem to be a mechanism that does

128:35

that we're trying to explore it so

128:38

obviously hugely encouraging results in

128:40

animal studies with uh addiction so now

128:44

there's lots of experiments going on

128:45

with giving these drugs to humans to see

128:47

if they reduce addiction there there's

128:49

been a huge amount of anecdotal evidence

128:51

interview to a nurse in Canada called

128:52

Tracy who had a bad relationship breakup

128:55

and just became completely addicted to

128:57

shopping she would just obsessively buy

128:59

books she'd never read clothes she'd

129:01

never wear she was doing a lot of um

129:03

skin

129:04

picking um and obsessive eating she goes

129:07

on as mpic and all these addictions like

129:09

disappeared so there's now this debate

129:11

okay is it going to have this effect

129:13

more widely the early research is kind

129:15

of mixed so there's only very very small

129:18

studies on humans so far uh it found

129:20

that it reduce smoking but only if you

129:23

pair it with a nicotine patch they found

129:26

that it does reduce alcohol consumption

129:28

but only if you were a heavy drinker at

129:30

the start so we're going to know a lot

129:32

more we're going to get a lot of results

129:34

actually this year and definitely a lot

129:35

next year but it's a very promising so

129:38

some people argue so the most extreme I

129:40

want to stress this is

129:42

speculative the biggest cheerleaders for

129:44

the drug would say actually we haven't

129:46

found a drug that causes appetite

129:48

regulation what we found is a drug that

129:50

boosts self-control across the board

129:52

right now that's very contested I'm

129:55

always conscious you know of the

129:57

overselling of drugs

129:59

generally we want to be careful about it

130:01

but it's a possible scenario and the

130:02

animal research is mind-blowing and

130:04

really is highly highly exciting and you

130:07

don't normally see this right there's no

130:09

other drug that I'm aware of pretty sure

130:11

there isn't um that just reduces

130:13

addiction across the board in animal

130:15

studies right it's remarkable I mean

130:18

there's a debate about whether you can

130:19

even call it Addiction in animals but

130:20

you know what I mean heavy compulsive

130:22

use what impact has zek had on your

130:25

weight loss Journey how much have you

130:26

lost I me I just lost a huge amount of

130:28

weight so I lost three stone across a

130:30

year and actually it was even more

130:32

dramatic was the percentage of body fat

130:33

that I lost so at the start I was 33%

130:36

body fat I remember the day Josh my

130:38

trainer measured that and it sort of

130:40

looked winced as he saw it and um I said

130:43

oh God if you if I was a sandwich you

130:44

wouldn't want to eat me I later looked

130:46

up whales at only 35% body fat so it

130:48

started disconcerting so I went from 33%

130:51

body fat to 22% body fat so it's a

130:53

really dramatic fall and did you

130:54

increase your dose yeah so everyone

130:57

starts at 0.25 milligram partly because

130:59

the most common side effect by far is

131:01

nausea right almost everyone feels

131:04

nauseous a bit when they start taking it

131:06

for some people the nausea is unbearable

131:08

I interviewed someone called Sunny

131:09

Newton in Vermont who said you know it

131:11

felt like an alien had entered her body

131:12

and was thrashing and trying to get out

131:15

yeah a significant minority experienced

131:17

such extreme nausea they just have to

131:18

stop for me the nausea has now totally

131:20

gone away way um and Carell laru one of

131:23

the scientists who worked on there said

131:24

look when it comes to nausea you've got

131:26

a level with people there are two kinds

131:27

of drugs there are drugs that have side

131:30

effects and there are drugs that don't

131:31

work right and he's right about that but

131:33

yeah the nausey is pretty bad but but

131:36

for me it's all gone away now I really

131:38

do admire Oprah I've um watched her

131:40

she's kind of like a role model of mine

131:42

for how she's kind of conducted herself

131:43

throughout her career and as you say

131:44

she's a friend of yours and she's I

131:46

think recently come out and admitted to

131:48

using as zc she's talked about how she

131:50

struggled with with weight for her life

131:53

um andna zek has been a bit of a Magic

131:55

Bullet it seems for her in her weight

131:57

loss Journey um you know her as a person

132:00

I've not been paying enough attention to

132:02

her describing her decision to know why

132:05

she decided to take a zek verses I don't

132:08

know some other form of dieting has she

132:10

explained that yeah she talks about it

132:12

very movingly um she talked about an

132:14

interview with People magazine and then

132:15

a brilliant special for ABC I think

132:19

um I mean nobody has publicly tortured

132:22

themselves with diets more than Oprah

132:24

there's this famous clip that you've

132:25

probably seen where she comes on stage

132:28

on her show and she's Wheeling a a huge

132:32

bucket of fat and that's the amount of

132:34

fat she'd lost on this diet and she

132:35

describes very movingly in this special

132:37

she says it much better than I can how

132:39

she had starved herself to get that

132:41

right and you think about so she had

132:44

tried all the

132:47

extreme diet and exercise options that

132:49

were available and they'd always yyo

132:51

back for the reasons that we talked

132:52

about

132:53

before so and you know and she had to

132:55

have a knee operation I'm not giving

132:57

away anything she's she's disclosed this

132:59

you she had to have a knee operation and

133:01

she was very worried about her

133:03

health and so for those reasons she's

133:05

made this this Choice there are lots of

133:08

reasons to be worried about these drugs

133:09

but I have found it very

133:11

hard when you talk to people who really

133:15

struggled with this like that guy Jeff

133:18

Parker I mentioned before in San

133:19

Francisco like Oprah people who've made

133:22

the decision to do it and seen the

133:23

benefits of the weight loss staggering

133:26

benefits whatever the other arguments

133:28

are I've NE I don't want to argue

133:30

against them right if if you are taking

133:34

these drugs and experiencing an enormous

133:35

Improvement in your in your health as

133:38

they both have and as lots of other

133:40

people have then that's been the right

133:41

choice for you now that won't be right

133:42

for everyone I met people who really

133:44

regretted taking the drugs for all sorts

133:46

of reasons including many of the

133:47

terrible side effects and

133:49

risks but I think we have to be truthful

133:52

to the complexity of these drugs right I

133:54

mean one of the reasons it's called

133:55

Magic pill the book is because there's

133:58

three different ways you could think

133:59

about this as magic loads of people who

134:01

take the drug go this is Magic right so

134:03

the first form of magic is obvious it

134:06

seems to solve a problem so quickly so

134:08

effectively that you're like whoa It's

134:10

like a miracle right that's one way the

134:13

second way is it could be magic like a

134:17

conjures illusion right it could be like

134:19

a magic trick it seems to solve the

134:21

problem but doesn't or sets up and

134:23

trains something else or the Third Way

134:25

is think about almost every fable about

134:27

magic is you get what you want but then

134:30

you get what you want in a way you

134:32

didn't quite expect you you make a wish

134:34

with the genie and you get what you want

134:35

but the wish doesn't quite work out how

134:37

you thought most famous story about

134:38

magic is Fantasia you know the magic can

134:41

spiral away from you so I think one of

134:43

the things we're still trying to figure

134:44

out is what kind of magic is this is it

134:46

a magic solution is it a magic trick or

134:49

is it a magic solution that's going to

134:50

spiral in all sorts of unpredictable

134:53

directions I have to say when you know

134:54

when you were holding that pen looking

134:55

at me I got weird like you were doing

134:58

slightly judgmental Dragon's Den eyes

135:00

and I was like I was like [ __ ] how do I

135:01

persuade him to invest in me right so

135:03

funny I I was you I was thinking I was

135:06

thinking I was having a conversation

135:08

with myself and I staring at thinking

135:10

God this would be easier than going

135:12

because after you leave here I I haven't

135:14

eaten yet today I'm going to have my

135:15

lunch and then I'm going to go to the

135:16

gym for about an hour and a half and

135:18

much of the reason why I go to the gym

135:19

is to try and stay in shape you know I

135:21

want to keep my I want to keep my belly

135:22

fat off I want to keep my muscles strong

135:24

I want to be strong I want to look good

135:25

that's the that's the reasons I go to

135:27

the gym also the positive consequence of

135:31

me going to the gym later on after this

135:32

conversation is it will make my brain

135:34

feel really good yeah now as I was

135:36

looking down at the pen I was

135:37

thinking I could take this and then the

135:40

belly fat you know would wouldn't be

135:42

there but then I would lose the positive

135:44

upside of the exercise that I'm going to

135:46

get from going to the gym as well so I

135:47

was wondering to myself are people going

135:49

to exercise less and is there a

135:51

consequence to us not ex not exercising

135:53

as much um to our mental health and our

135:56

feelings of you know happiness and all

135:58

the things that exercise does for us

136:00

yeah the answer to both your questions

136:01

is yes people will exercise less and it

136:03

will have negative effects so we know I

136:06

want to add to that the point that I

136:07

alluded to earlier on people are getting

136:08

more and more sedentary we're living in

136:10

like a Vision Pro headset don't need to

136:12

move World well you know what I mean so

136:16

we're going to be able to inject to keep

136:17

the weight down but we're we're still

136:19

going to be moving less and there's a

136:20

lot of upside to moving and exercise

136:22

yeah so we know that there's there are

136:25

enormous benefits to exercise which

136:27

exist quite separate to the question of

136:29

weight loss right if you exercise for

136:31

270 hours a year you add three years

136:34

onto your life even if it doesn't cause

136:35

weight loss right so that benefits in

136:38

terms of preventing disease slowing down

136:41

aging mental health are just enormous

136:43

from exercise and I think you've gone to

136:45

a really important drawback which is

136:48

yeah if you can get the benefit in the

136:50

short ter medium-term just from a

136:53

jab but that calculation you were

136:55

thinking through as you were holding the

136:56

pen in the slightly Sinister Dragon Den

136:58

way um is a calculation lots of people

137:01

were going to make and there's um

137:02

there's a lot of things I'm not sure

137:04

about in these drugs but there's a few

137:05

bits of advice which I am very sure

137:07

about if you are not overweight or obese

137:10

you definitely shouldn't take these

137:12

drugs right you are incurring all the

137:14

risks for none of the benefits so that

137:17

I'm certain of and there are lots of

137:18

people who are not overweight or obese

137:20

who are taking the drugs to be super

137:21

thin my friend Elise lonen who used to

137:23

be the chief content officer at goop

137:25

said she won't even go out for dinner in

137:27

LA with people we know now because no

137:29

one eats anything like why did we come

137:31

out for dinner you're all starving she

137:33

says you know dieting is out elimination

137:34

is in the way she put it so I'm

137:36

confident about that I'm also fairly

137:39

confident although slightly less but

137:41

fairly confident if your BMI is higher

137:44

than

137:45

35 or your body fat percentage is very

137:47

very

137:49

high and you're not someone with thyroid

137:52

cancer in your family and you're not

137:53

trying to get

137:55

pregnant I would recommend taking the

137:57

drugs I think for you the balance of

138:00

risk and and assuming you've tried diet

138:03

and it didn't work I think for you the

138:05

balance of risk is is more towards the

138:07

benefits of taking the drug I'm not as

138:09

confident about that but I'm pretty the

138:11

people I love who have BMI higher than

138:13

35 who are in that position I have

138:14

recommended the drug to them for people

138:16

between with a BMI between 27 and 35 I

138:20

think it's much more or um you've got to

138:22

just go down the list of the benefits

138:24

and drawbacks um and really think it

138:26

through for yourself and reasonable

138:28

people will reach completely different

138:29

conclusions it's going to be quite

138:31

interesting to see that people who do

138:32

decide to do exercise and they change

138:35

their diet and they've start running

138:36

marathons when they lose weight every

138:39

everybody is going to say no you didn't

138:41

that's so funny everyone's going to say

138:42

it was impc if some celebrity now drops

138:44

I don't know three stone or four stone

138:46

and they did it you know in the gym and

138:48

with a diet change no one is going to

138:50

believe them no one that's very funny

138:53

and I think think certainly yeah I think

138:54

you're right there I had thought of that

138:56

you wouldn't believe them of course you

138:57

wouldn't believe them no you're right

138:59

one of the big rebuttal that I see

139:01

online is that because people are now

139:03

taking these drugs people like you are

139:04

taking them to lose weight diabetics

139:07

can't get their hands on these drugs

139:08

anymore and I saw some articles that

139:09

said the um the drugs have been in such

139:12

high demand that diabetics who really

139:14

really need them to save their lives now

139:16

can't get access to them I think those

139:18

people have a really good point and I

139:20

interviewed some of them for the book

139:21

and it was a very painful conversation I

139:24

think the solution is what we should

139:25

have done right from the start and what

139:26

we should do now is what we did in

139:27

Britain with the covid vacine so we

139:29

should um ration the drug and the people

139:32

with the greatest need should be given

139:33

it first and everyone

139:36

agrees severely obese people and

139:38

diabetics together would be the people

139:40

who most need the drug and they should

139:42

be given it first people like me who've

139:45

got heart disease in my family but were

139:46

not hugely obese would probably be

139:48

around the middle and you know people

139:50

who don't have heart disease and are

139:52

just sort of overweight would be at the

139:53

bottom we didn't have that system what

139:55

we had unfortunately because the

139:56

government didn't set up that system was

139:58

a scramble which meant that you know

140:01

some diabetics didn't get the drug they

140:03

needed had to go on insulin earlier

140:05

which poses a real threat to their

140:06

health that's awful and I feel a bit

140:09

ashamed about it because of course if

140:10

people like me hadn't hadn't all

140:13

together bought it that wouldn't have

140:15

happened in practice for me

140:17

personally I was worried about my own

140:19

heart risk you know I mean year older

140:21

than my granddad was when he died um but

140:24

that's not much of an excuse and when I

140:26

met the diabetics in that position like

140:27

for example a guy called zami Jalil who

140:30

was exactly in that position he could as

140:32

a musician 41 couldn't get the the ASM

140:36

pick he needed for his diabetes for his

140:37

type two

140:39

diabetes I felt um ashamed you know

140:42

clearly his need was

140:45

greater Yan thank you thank you for a

140:48

few things I think it's worth saying

140:49

that the first time you came on my

140:51

podcast I had basically no listeners you

140:53

were like a tiny little baby podcaster I

140:55

remember it really clearly you came to

140:56

my flat I showed up at your flat in

140:58

London I'd read your book lost

140:59

connections I was so fascinated by it so

141:01

I reached out to you and asked you if

141:02

you'd come on and you said yes when I

141:04

was when no one was listening to the

141:05

podcast I don't I wasn't even videoing

141:06

it back then um and it was an incredible

141:09

conversation the audio was terrible

141:11

there was Lo we had loads of issues and

141:12

stuff like that but you were one of the

141:13

first people to really give me a chance

141:14

so it's so wonderful that that we can

141:16

still stay in touch and that I get to

141:18

cover your work still to this day so

141:19

thank you for giving me a chance back in

141:21

the day I really appreciate it oh my

141:22

pleasure and thank you for writing this

141:24

book because one of the the most sort of

141:26

popular things that our audience have

141:27

been seeking to understand is a zmek

141:30

we've seen that in all the data and the

141:31

way that you approach this even though

141:33

you are someone that's taking it so it's

141:35

easy to see how you would be biased in

141:37

various ways to defend it or whatever

141:39

that's not the approach you take and in

141:40

the book magic pill you're able to be

141:43

incredibly nuanced and how you look at

141:45

the pros and the cons in a way that I

141:47

was not expecting from someone who is

141:49

taking it themselves and I think that's

141:50

really important because you're right

141:51

you finished the book and in a weird way

141:55

you you have more information but I can

141:59

understand how the decision Still

142:00

Remains with the individual and I think

142:03

that's really what any book on this

142:05

subject should should aim to achieve it

142:06

should kind of not have a dog in the

142:08

fight but present you both sides of the

142:11

trade-off so that you can make a

142:12

decision for yourself and that's what

142:13

you do so skillfully and the real thing

142:15

you know as an author that you've taught

142:16

me over the years is you're just

142:18

remarkably good at writing and it's

142:21

really your your storytelling is

142:23

phenomenal it's influenced me profoundly

142:25

as an author myself and uh whenever I

142:28

read a book now I often wish that they

142:30

had written it like one of your books

142:32

because you take a you take a concept

142:33

that's difficult and widely discussed

142:36

and you take us on a journey and that

142:38

journey is so much more enjoyable than

142:40

just reading like a science book so I

142:42

recommend everybody to go and get magic

142:43

pill right now it's um it's obviously a

142:45

huge point of conversation at the moment

142:46

these these magic pills um and this is

142:49

the book to read on it magic pill the

142:51

extraordinary benefits and disturbing

142:52

risks of the new weight loss drugs it's

142:55

due to be released on the 2nd of May

142:57

2024 so we're a couple of days away from

143:00

that now and um yeah I would just highly

143:03

highly recommend this book thank you so

143:04

much Johan oh I'm really touched by that

143:06

Stephen thank you so much I almost

143:08

forgot we have a tradition on this

143:09

podcast oh yes the question what is the

143:11

question who who posed this question I'm

143:13

not going to tell you who who this is

143:15

but the question that's been left for

143:16

you is it's a really interesting one

143:21

why

143:21

should

143:23

Humanity continue to exist so as you

143:27

know I've been writing for God 12 years

143:30

now 13 years a book about a series of

143:32

crimes that have been happening in Las

143:33

Vegas I'm not allowed to talk about but

143:34

it will come out next year and I promise

143:35

we'll finally talk about it I think

143:36

you're just saying this so you can hang

143:37

out in Vegas every time I see you say

143:39

You're Just in Vegas writing a book I'm

143:41

like where's the book your hand yeah

143:43

there are people many people in Vegas

143:44

have said to me yeah your book's been a

143:46

long time [ __ ] coming but so um I

143:50

know two people called Rob banghart and

143:52

Paul

143:53

Vino who um a lot of people won't know

143:56

but there's many thousands of homeless

143:58

people who live in the drainage tunnels

143:59

beneath Las

144:01

Vegas and Rob and Paul used to live in

144:03

the

144:04

tunnels and Rob lived in a particular

144:07

set of tunnels that I know very well and

144:08

have spent a lot of time

144:10

in and in

144:13

2017 so Rob was known as hobo Santa he

144:16

would steal things and give them to

144:17

people and um he was also a kind of

144:21

low-level dealer very low-level and

144:23

there was a a group of uh rival Cuban

144:25

dealers who didn't like him and one day

144:28

in

144:29

2017 they hit him in the head with an

144:31

axe split his skull open dragged him

144:33

onto the railway tracks and left him

144:35

there for a train to run him over but

144:37

fortunately someone spotted him pulled

144:40

him off the tracks and he survived and

144:41

he in the next six months as he

144:43

recovered he um turned his life around

144:49

and he began to volunt here for a group

144:51

that my friend Paul runs uh called shine

144:53

a light which is a group of people

144:55

overwhelmingly people who used to live

144:56

in the tunnels who managed to get out

144:58

turn their lives around who now help the

145:00

people who are still down there they

145:01

give them loads of practical things from

145:04

tampons to flashlights and they most

145:06

importantly give them support when they

145:08

want to leave and I've got lots of

145:09

people out and every month get people

145:11

out of the tunnels and I've seen them do

145:13

it with some people I really love who

145:14

were down

145:15

there and one

145:17

day few years ago I was I was with Rob

145:22

and

145:23

um

145:25

um so one day a few years ago I was with

145:28

Rob when he got word that uh a friend of

145:32

his from the tunnels called picket had

145:33

died he' ODed in in the tunnel they used

145:36

to live in so we went straight down

145:38

there and um picket stuff was still

145:41

there they'd taken away his

145:43

body and we bumped into a woman who also

145:46

lives down there and whenever Rob goes

145:48

to the tunnels even in a situation like

145:49

that he always BRS supplies you know

145:51

food and stuff and he said to

145:54

her who's in the tunnel over there and

145:57

she said oh you don't want to go there

145:58

and he said why and she named some

146:00

people and he said no I'll go there I'll

146:02

give them some stuff and he went and

146:03

gave them some stuff anyway I didn't

146:04

really think about it very much I was

146:05

thinking about pick it and what

146:07

happened and a few days later I said to

146:09

Rob what did she mean when she said you

146:11

don't want to go there and he said oh

146:13

it's just these guys and I said what

146:15

guys he said oh well they're the guys

146:17

who hit me in the head with an axe

146:18

they're the guys who tried to kill me

146:22

and I saidwell why did you go and help

146:24

them and he said because they're human

146:27

beings and they're suffering and they

146:28

need

146:30

help and

146:33

um I thought a lot about

146:37

Rob every day him and

146:40

Paul go back into those tunnels you know

146:42

they could do anything they could leave

146:43

and do a million things right they're

146:45

incredibly intelligent and talented

146:47

people every day they go back and they

146:49

help the people who got left behind and

146:52

they make no money doing it and they

146:54

don't have great lives doing it in any

146:56

material sense and I've say to them why

146:59

do you do it and they just they say

147:02

because it's the right thing to

147:03

do and if you said to me why should

147:06

human beings continue to exist I could

147:07

give you a load of abstract answers I

147:08

could talk to you about philosophy and I

147:10

could talk to you about art and I just

147:12

say come and meet Rob and

147:15

Paul there why humans should continue to

147:17

exist

147:21

thank you cheers Stephen

147:26

[Music]

Interactive Summary

The video features a discussion with journalist and author Johan Hari about his new book, 'Magic Pill', which examines the extraordinary benefits and potential risks of weight loss drugs like Ozempic (semaglutide). Hari explains his personal journey of taking the drug to address his weight and health issues, detailing both the physical and psychological effects. The conversation covers how these drugs function by influencing satiety and the brain, their potential role in treating addiction, and the '12 big risks' associated with them, including muscle mass loss, potential mental health impacts, and the unknown long-term consequences. Throughout the discussion, Hari remains deeply conflicted about whether these drugs are a 'magic solution' to an artificial problem or a dangerous shortcut that ignores deeper societal and environmental causes of obesity, such as the ubiquity of ultra-processed food.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts