HomeVideos

Michael Pollan: How To Change Your Mind | E158

Now Playing

Michael Pollan: How To Change Your Mind | E158

Transcript

1958 segments

0:00

Depression, anxiety, addiction, mental

0:03

disorders that involve a rigidity of

0:05

thought. What psychedelics appear to do

0:08

is break those habits of thought. What

0:10

is the cost of this though? It's a great

0:12

question.

0:13

One of the 100 most influential people

0:15

in the world.

0:16

Please welcome Michael Pollan. You've

0:19

written six New York Times bestsellers

0:21

and they're on such a diverse range of

0:24

topics. Two of the topics I've worked on

0:26

have turned into movements. I was

0:28

writing a piece on the meat industry and

0:31

how [ __ ] up it is and it led to this

0:33

movement to try to reform agriculture.

0:36

Then I got into psychedelics.

0:39

They're much better than the results for

0:41

antidepressants when they came on the

0:42

scene and we're talking about potential

0:45

cures not simply symptoms. There are

0:48

risks with this and we don't talk about

0:50

them nearly enough and people are going

0:52

to get hurt.

0:54

One of the immersive journalistic

0:55

pursuits you embarked on was this topic

0:57

of caffeine. It allows us to function

0:59

better. It allows us to work harder,

1:01

longer. You're feeling the clearing of

1:04

the mental fog.

1:05

I can tell you the cost of doing heroin

1:06

every day, but no one can seem to tell

1:07

me the cost of having three cups of

1:09

coffee a day. If you really want to

1:11

understand your relationship to this

1:12

drug, you have to

1:15

So without further ado, I'm Steven

1:17

Bartlett and this is the Diary of a CEO

1:19

USA edition. I hope nobody's listening.

1:22

But if you are,

1:24

then please keep this to yourself.

1:26

[Music]

1:32

Michael, I have to say it's a real a

1:35

huge honor to speak to you. When I

1:37

departed from my company and I started

1:39

investigating what I was interested in,

1:40

one of the things alongside DJing and

1:42

this podcast and many others was

1:43

psychedelics. I was so compelled by

1:47

um this apparent and I didn't have

1:49

confirmation this apparent increase in

1:50

mental health disorders in my country.

1:52

Mhm. In the UK, as you know, as I know

1:54

you've talked about many times, it's the

1:55

suicide is the single biggest killer of

1:57

men under the age of 45. And I thought

2:00

that the most sort of fulfilling thing I

2:02

could do with the next chapter of my

2:03

life was start a company in that space.

2:05

That's how I came to the psychedelics

2:07

industry. That's how I came to actually

2:08

work in the psychedelics industry. And

2:10

when I arrived in that industry, people

2:11

said your name over and over and over

2:13

again. And they told me and I'm not

2:15

blowing smoke up your ass, they told me

2:17

that I had to It was like I wasn't

2:19

allowed in the industry until I'd read

2:20

your book, right? Um

2:23

How to change your mind. It was that

2:24

much of a pivotal book for my colleagues

2:26

at the time.

2:27

You've written six New York Times

2:29

bestsellers.

2:30

And they're on such a diverse a range of

2:33

topics. To be so successful in such a

2:35

diverse range of topics in writing, my

2:39

first question to you that I wanted to

2:41

ask is

2:42

as you look back on your life and your

2:43

career,

2:44

why were you successful?

2:47

What was it about you that made you

2:49

successful?

2:50

I think finding the right topics. I I

2:52

had a nose for topics that most people

2:55

weren't paying attention to. I I felt

2:57

very lucky. I was writing in these

2:58

uncompetitive spaces. Nobody was writing

3:00

about psychedelics except, you know, the

3:02

small handful of people within the

3:04

psychedelic community who write these

3:06

books for one another that nobody else

3:08

reads and they and

3:10

So I had I've I I I remember thinking

3:13

the whole time I was writing that book

3:14

is like, where is everybody? Am I making

3:16

a mistake here investing so much in

3:17

this? Um no one else is writing about

3:19

it. And the same was true with food.

3:20

There was very when I started writing

3:21

about food and agriculture, very little

3:23

being written. So

3:25

a willingness to go into places that

3:27

other people, you know, weren't working

3:29

in. I don't like writing in competitive

3:31

environments. I'm not fast enough.

3:34

Um so that was one thing.

3:36

Um

3:37

I think there's something about the way

3:40

I structure stories. So I don't start on

3:43

page one with all the answers. And if

3:45

you read the first page of anything I've

3:47

written, I'm kind of an idiot on page

3:49

one. Um I've got questions. I don't have

3:51

answers.

3:52

And so my books are kind of detective

3:54

stories or, you know, I I just tell

3:57

about the process of my figuring things

3:59

out and going to this person and

4:01

learning this and having this experience

4:03

and learning that.

4:04

And I think that readers don't like to

4:06

be lectured at and um and I don't do

4:09

that. I I take them along on the

4:11

journey. When when I think about

4:13

starting a business, one of the pieces

4:14

of advice that I would and I think a lot

4:16

of entrepreneurs would give a young

4:17

aspiring entrepreneur is to not pursue

4:19

something that you're not genuinely

4:21

interested about because Oh yeah, well

4:23

without question. I mean that I write

4:25

about things that I'm passionate about.

4:27

Um curiosity is the driver and

4:31

cultivating Curiosity doesn't

4:33

necessarily come naturally to everybody.

4:35

It's a muscle you have to cultivate and

4:38

you have to see the world in terms of

4:40

questions rather than answers

4:42

cuz questions are always more

4:43

interesting than answers. Uh so I do

4:46

cultivate that. When I see something

4:48

happening, I remember when I first read

4:50

a little article in the New York Times

4:52

saying they were giving psilocybin to

4:53

cancer patients to help them deal with

4:55

their fear of death. I'm like, what's

4:57

that about? Why would you do that? Why

4:59

would you ever want to take a trip when

5:01

you got a terminal diagnosis? I don't

5:03

think I would want to do that. You know,

5:05

I just had all these questions and the

5:06

only way to answer them was to do

5:08

reporting. Was to go interview the

5:10

patients and interview the doctors

5:13

and satisfy my curiosity. So without

5:16

question, I I can't write about things

5:18

I'm not interested in. I mean, I get,

5:20

you know, and you can as you can

5:22

imagine, editors are always coming to

5:23

me, we'd like an article on this or a

5:24

book on this and I'm like,

5:26

I don't feel it. So yeah, so you do have

5:29

to you do have to care about it. I mean,

5:31

writing a book is such a long journey

5:33

with so many twists and turns and um so

5:36

if you if you don't have some

5:38

deep-seated drive

5:41

to understand something, to tell a

5:42

story,

5:44

you're going to you good chance you're

5:46

going to sink along the way. And you

5:48

really do

5:49

go all the way. That's something that

5:51

you're

5:51

Well, immersion is a big part of my work

5:54

and I think and I think that's another

5:57

that's been another key thing. I can I

6:00

you know, I've been thinking about this

6:01

a lot recently um

6:03

but I can trace the moment where I was

6:07

first exposed to the kind of journalism

6:09

that I think of myself as doing. And

6:11

that was when I was 13, my parents gave

6:13

me a a book called Paper Lion. It's a

6:16

book of sports writing. It was about

6:17

football by a writer named George

6:19

Plimpton.

6:21

He was a literary person but a sports

6:23

writer too and loved sports writing and

6:25

um

6:27

he was kind of bored with how sports

6:28

writing was done then, which is, you

6:30

know, it's that cynical cigar-chomping

6:33

guy on the sidelines with the hat who's

6:35

just been there, done that, seen it all,

6:38

has no sense of wonder or excitement

6:40

anymore.

6:41

And he thought there's a way to reinvent

6:43

this form. And he and what he did was he

6:46

persuaded uh the Detroit Lions, American

6:50

football team, to let him um train with

6:53

them over the summer, summer training

6:55

camp, and then start in a exhibition

6:58

game at the beginning of the season

7:00

as quarterback.

7:02

So this guy had never played

7:03

professional sports at all.

7:05

Um was not an athlete and there he was

7:08

um facing this line of giant guys coming

7:11

at him.

7:12

And he could write about football in a

7:15

way that no sports writer could but

7:17

neither any football player could

7:20

because they had been doing it since

7:21

they were 10 or six

7:23

and they no longer saw it freshly. It

7:26

was a job.

7:27

But he had this incredible sense of

7:29

wonder and humor cuz he's a fish out of

7:32

water and it opened up all these funny

7:34

narrative possibilities.

7:36

And I realized that book just sat with

7:40

me. I loved that book. So when I started

7:42

writing,

7:44

I forget which book it was in. Um

7:47

I real I think it was my second book. It

7:49

was a book about architecture and then I

7:50

realized I couldn't write this book

7:52

unless I built something myself.

7:54

And so finding how to put my finding the

7:57

way to put myself in the story

7:59

is uh been key for me. And with

8:03

agriculture, you know, I bought a cow

8:05

and followed him through the food

8:06

system. Wait, you you bought a cow?

8:09

I did. I I I was writing a piece uh that

8:12

became a chapter in The Omnivore's

8:13

Dilemma

8:14

on the meat industry and how [ __ ] up

8:17

it is and um

8:19

and feed lots and and the drugs they

8:21

give the animals.

8:22

And that was my assignment from the New

8:24

York Times and I found this uh and I was

8:27

going to do the piece in terms of I was

8:29

going to follow one animal through the

8:30

whole system from insemination to

8:32

slaughter.

8:33

And

8:34

um this was a piece called Power Steer

8:36

that was published in the New York Times

8:39

uh and you it's on my website if you

8:40

want to um check it out for free.

8:43

But along the way, one of the ranchers

8:45

said, "If you really want to understand

8:46

our business, you should buy one of

8:48

these animals." And I thought

8:50

immediately, this is a great idea.

8:53

Because it's going to do two things.

8:55

It's going to give me a character, even

8:56

though it's an animal,

8:58

um which, you know, having an animal

9:00

hero in a piece is always a good thing.

9:02

And it's going to give me a different

9:04

kind of access when I get to the feed

9:06

lot and the slaughterhouse cuz I own

9:08

this animal. I'm not just a journalist.

9:12

And so I I picked out this animal,

9:14

number 534.

9:16

Um and I followed him and I you know, I

9:19

I met him on the ranch where he was born

9:21

and then I had a reunion with him in the

9:23

feed lot where he ended up, you know,

9:25

several months later.

9:26

I'm super intrigued by what happened to

9:28

this cow.

9:28

Oh yeah, well.

9:31

Were you emotionally attached to it at

9:32

all when that when it got, you know,

9:33

reached its end end of its days? I was a

9:35

little. I didn't They wouldn't

9:38

Something happened. So I had to publish

9:40

the piece before he was slaughtered.

9:41

Right. He was slau uh they wanted to

9:44

publish the piece. I handed it in in

9:45

February. They wanted to publish it in

9:47

March and he wasn't going to get

9:47

slaughtered till June. I wanted to wait

9:50

because I still had very good access cuz

9:52

nobody knew I was writing an exposé on

9:54

the on the meat industry. I was just

9:55

some goofball following the life of this

9:58

cow.

9:59

And um but when the piece came out, the

10:02

slaughterhouse is like, "We're not doing

10:04

business with Pollan anymore."

10:06

And uh so I was hoping to retrieve the

10:08

steaks and eat them or or try to eat

10:10

them and see what I thought about it.

10:12

And um but they wouldn't they wouldn't

10:14

play anymore.

10:15

Um

10:17

And it's interesting when this piece

10:18

came out,

10:20

there was a whole explosion in the

10:23

American media of people who wanted to

10:25

save the cow cuz they knew he hadn't

10:27

been killed yet.

10:28

And I had people I had someone in

10:31

write me

10:32

a movie producer in Beverly Hills wrote

10:35

and say, "I want to buy your your 534."

10:39

And I said, "What are you going to do

10:40

with it?" I'm going to put it on my

10:41

front lawn.

10:42

And

10:44

I was like,

10:45

"You know,

10:47

saving one animal is not going to fix

10:49

the food system." And everybody thought

10:51

that way. There was even a telethon on a

10:53

vegan radio station in New Jersey. They

10:56

were raising money and they would pay me

10:57

anything I wanted for this animal.

11:00

And I'm like, "This is not This is

11:03

this is not how you change the meat

11:04

system by like having this poster boy

11:07

steer."

11:08

And they actually likened it to the

11:10

underground railroad, that saving one

11:13

slave was worth it. I was like, "That's

11:16

interesting." Um

11:19

And so I did not sell it.

11:22

And it went through the process and

11:23

somebody ate it. But it wasn't me.

11:26

There's something

11:27

sort of telling about that about the

11:28

human condition where we believe that

11:30

one sort of surface-level act of

11:33

apparent, probably virtue signaling, but

11:35

apparent goodness is

11:37

is enough or that we don't really care

11:40

about the systemic No. Systems are hard

11:42

to deal with, right? We're we're we

11:44

evolved to deal with individuals and

11:45

stories of individuals. And that's why

11:47

this story was powerful cuz it was about

11:49

an individual cow.

11:50

But what matters is the system. This you

11:53

know, I I I chose it because it was

11:55

representative of the system. It was a

11:56

very typical animal going through a

11:58

typical start out on grass kind of

12:02

idyllic situation in in

12:04

South Dakota, move on to this horrible

12:07

feedlot where they stand in their own

12:08

manure all day and eat corn which makes

12:10

them sick and they have to take drugs.

12:13

And then they go through this

12:14

slaughterhouse process.

12:17

Which I described even though I didn't

12:18

get to witness. But I think we have

12:21

trouble dealing with systems.

12:23

And so we we we always have the poster

12:25

child, you know? I mean, you look how

12:27

you know, look at all the nonprofits how

12:29

they advertise, right? There's one

12:31

animal or there's one child that you're

12:32

going to save with your donation. And I

12:36

just think it's a limitation of our

12:37

imaginations. That's what I was thinking

12:39

of a very recent example of that which

12:41

is the tragic death of George Floyd and

12:43

how that sparked people around the

12:45

world, specifically on Instagram posting

12:47

a black tile.

12:48

As a black male, I looked at that and

12:51

thought this is like the easy thing to

12:53

do, right? But it doesn't solve the

12:54

systemic issues of sort of race and race

12:57

relations and discrimination. But like

12:59

we can all do the like virtue signaling

13:01

socially hashtag whatever black tile.

13:04

But again, the the complexity of the

13:06

system below it that's kind of caught

13:07

might be the cause of some of these

13:08

things is just

13:10

Does anybody really care to deal with

13:11

that? You know, it's like I think it's

13:13

just overwhelming to people. And

13:16

you know, I don't I mean, it is virtue

13:18

signaling. I mean, all over Berkeley

13:20

where I live, people still have Black

13:22

Lives Matter signs in their windows, you

13:24

know, everywhere. Like when are they

13:26

going to take them down?

13:27

Are they ever going to take them down?

13:30

I understand the value of expressing

13:33

that point of view, but there's so much

13:36

more that needs to be done. What does

13:38

need to be done when we're thinking

13:38

about sort of rewiring systems?

13:41

Is it education? Is it political? Is it

13:45

I tend to think it's about law.

13:47

I think you can't legislate morality,

13:51

but you can change laws and make certain

13:54

kinds of

13:55

activity discrimination illegal. Um

14:00

You know, we're approaching it in

14:02

America at the level of everyone's soul.

14:05

We're trying to reform everyone's soul

14:07

with anti-racism campaigns and things

14:09

like that. We'll see if it works.

14:11

I tend to think it doesn't work.

14:13

And one of the things that I've been

14:15

very discouraged by is the collapse in

14:17

support for Black Lives Matter, which

14:19

had majority support after that George

14:21

Floyd summer. And now it doesn't. It's

14:23

been

14:23

politicized, right?

14:25

Yeah, and and it's been fought against

14:26

by Republicans. And

14:29

but I also think

14:32

shaming people is not the way to get

14:35

them to change.

14:36

And there was a lot of that. And and I

14:40

see a lot of this on college campuses. I

14:42

see a lot of this throughout the

14:43

culture. I understand the instinct. Um

14:46

but I think you get I think you invite a

14:48

backlash.

14:49

Um

14:50

That's not the best way to get people to

14:52

change. And I think in fact it can have

14:54

the opposite effect. I think

14:56

from what I've observed specifically

14:57

around this issue of Black Lives Matter,

14:58

that shame that I saw in the wake of

15:01

George Floyd's death only resulted in

15:02

this kind of like apparent social

15:05

compliance, not change. Like, "Okay, now

15:07

I have to pretend to be this person."

15:10

And that like compliance again is not

15:11

what we're looking for. I did a big

15:13

tweet thread about how I felt white

15:15

people were being shamed into either

15:16

speaking out, saying something profound

15:19

or or other. When really

15:22

for me it was actually

15:23

the least natural reaction to to the

15:26

scenes that I saw in that video of

15:28

George Floyd's death would be

15:30

doing a tweet or posting. I even I spent

15:34

weeks like processing it and then I was

15:36

being shamed. Steve, why aren't you

15:37

speaking up about black people? And I

15:39

just thought, you know, like

15:41

I you know, and all of that again it

15:43

made me

15:44

it made it didn't bring me closer to

15:47

waving the flags. It just made me feel

15:49

like

15:50

I don't know, kind of disillusioned by

15:52

it all.

15:53

So you're right, shamed Yeah, there was

15:54

a lot pressure to immediately express

15:57

your solidarity Yeah. with Black Lives

16:00

Matter. And and if you didn't, there was

16:02

something wrong.

16:03

Yeah. Yeah. I I definitely saw a lot of

16:05

that.

16:06

Um

16:08

I don't know. I just think we need I

16:10

think our politics has to be organized

16:12

around

16:13

more positive emotions. I mean, make

16:15

people feel really good about social

16:16

change, about um

16:19

And I think, you know, really concrete.

16:21

I think the way we hire people needs to

16:23

change. I think the way we promote

16:24

people needs to change. I think I think

16:26

that there's certain still certain kinds

16:28

of discrimination that have to be

16:29

outlawed.

16:30

Um

16:32

I mean, the biggest thing going on at

16:34

the same time of Black Lives Matter is

16:36

taking away the ability of African

16:38

Americans to vote.

16:39

You know, voter suppression. That is so

16:41

concrete and you need those votes in

16:44

order to change things. And so while

16:47

we're working on, you know, our souls,

16:50

we're losing the franchise, which

16:53

you know, the Civil Rights Movement has

16:55

fought long and hard.

16:57

Um it's we're going backwards.

16:59

So um

17:01

I think it's I think we should consider

17:04

whether this politics is working or not.

17:06

Um

17:07

I would suggest it might not be.

17:09

I would agree. Um we we started talking

17:11

about the the topic of like immersive

17:12

journalism. One of the

17:15

one of the sort of immersive

17:17

journalistic pursuits you embarked on

17:19

was this topic of caffeine. Which I

17:21

found it really really interesting

17:23

because I believe there's a cost to

17:25

everything in life just generally. And

17:27

the cost is always harder to see. And

17:29

with caffeine in the culture,

17:30

specifically in business, and even I

17:32

could see it sort of taking hold in my

17:33

own life. This topic of caffeine, I'm

17:35

like, people never talk about the cost

17:37

of it as if it's the super drug. We take

17:39

it, it just sends us up.

17:40

There's no free lunch. Exactly, right?

17:42

So I and I started thinking, with

17:44

anxiety on the rise, is there is there a

17:46

risk that this sort of tampering with

17:48

our um

17:50

our emotional state is going to ruin the

17:55

system that regulates us naturally and

17:57

make us go up, okay, fine, when we take

18:00

caffeine, but then the down, like every

18:02

other drug, like heroin and cocaine, is

18:04

going to be

18:05

equally

18:07

destructive?

18:08

Yeah, I mean,

18:10

I you know, you're talking about the law

18:12

of compensation, I think is what Ralph

18:15

Waldo Emerson called it.

18:17

And that that there is there's always

18:19

some compensating thing. There is no

18:21

free lunch. And

18:23

and that was a real issue as people were

18:24

trying to understand how caffeine worked

18:26

because it seemed to be a free lunch.

18:28

Here was something with zero calories

18:30

that gave you more energy.

18:32

Caffeine works by blocking the action of

18:35

a

18:36

neurotransmitter or neuromodulator,

18:38

technically, called adenosine. It's a

18:41

chemical that we all have in our bodies

18:43

that

18:44

over the course of the day the levels

18:46

rise. And it um

18:49

plugs into a certain receptor in the

18:51

brain. It's all over the brain. I think

18:52

it's other parts of the body, too.

18:54

And adenosine is your body's signal to

18:58

slow down, get ready for sleep. It

19:00

builds sleep pressure. Um

19:04

And what caffeine does is it fits

19:07

exactly in the same receptor and and

19:09

hijacks it. Basically blocks the

19:11

adenosine from getting to that receptor.

19:13

So the adenosine is still in your body,

19:15

but it's not acting on your brain cuz it

19:17

can't get into those receptors.

19:20

When the caffeine leaves your system,

19:22

which takes a while to do,

19:24

all that adenosine that's been building

19:26

up,

19:28

comes in. And so you're more tired than

19:29

you were before. So you have this kind

19:31

of rebound exhaustion. So you're really

19:34

borrowing that energy from the future

19:37

rather than creating new energy out of

19:39

nothing.

19:41

It's still very useful under certain

19:43

circumstances. I'm not a critic of

19:45

caffeine.

19:47

It's it might be my favorite drug.

19:49

Um

19:49

And And tried a whole bunch. Um

19:52

and it was immersive journalism in that

19:55

in this case I had to stop doing

19:57

something rather than doing something.

19:59

So in How to Change Your Mind, I tried

20:01

LSD and psilocybin and 5-MeO-DMT and all

20:03

these things that were really scary and

20:05

hard

20:06

for me, but this was harder. Giving up

20:08

caffeine for 3 months

20:10

um

20:11

really was a stretch.

20:13

And but it was a really interesting

20:14

experiment and it taught me that there's

20:17

a great value in giving things up

20:19

temporarily

20:21

just to understand your relationship to

20:23

them, understand your dependence on

20:24

them. What was hardest about it?

20:26

Well, there was the withdrawal, which

20:28

took a few days and was very unpleasant.

20:31

I felt like kind of muzzy-headed. I felt

20:33

like this veil had fallen between me and

20:35

reality.

20:36

Uh things seemed less fresh, less

20:39

immediate. Um I didn't have headache the

20:42

headaches that some people report and I

20:44

didn't have the flu-like symptoms, but I

20:46

didn't feel myself.

20:48

And uh I was sluggish. I couldn't

20:50

concentrate. I couldn't write for the

20:51

first week. Um I just I I I I said in

20:55

the book I felt like an unsharpened

20:57

pencil. I just didn't have it. You know,

20:59

it takes a certain amount of ego

21:02

strength to launch into a writing

21:04

project uh or launch into it every day.

21:08

And I just didn't have it. And uh so I

21:10

was like uh I don't know I don't know if

21:12

I can do this for 3 months.

21:14

After the first week or so, I found my

21:16

way back that I could work, but I still

21:19

didn't feel myself. And and it began to

21:21

occur to me that how curious is that

21:23

because

21:24

what does that say if if I feel more

21:27

normal on this drug than off this drug

21:29

cuz I'm I'm through the withdrawal

21:31

period.

21:33

But I came to see that my my normal

21:35

default consciousness was caffeinated

21:38

consciousness as it is for a great many

21:40

of us. I mean, 90% of people on Earth

21:42

have a daily relationship with caffeine

21:44

whether it's in um

21:46

tea, coffee, soda, chocolate. Um it's in

21:49

a lot of things. You know, you you meet

21:51

people who say I I can't talk to you

21:53

until I've had a cup of coffee. I you

21:54

know, I I'm not civil. I can only read

21:56

the paper. You know, people who just

21:57

don't enter into social relations till

21:59

they have a cup of coffee. The reason is

22:01

they're going through withdrawal and

22:02

they're cranky and they know it. The

22:04

amount of people probably in this room

22:06

now there's probably I don't know 12

22:07

people in this building and of them I

22:10

think probably 12 of them have had that

22:12

drug today. Yeah. With the society as

22:15

you've said people saying I can't

22:16

function I can't have a conversation

22:17

till I've had a cup What is the cost of

22:19

this though? Because it

22:21

I can tell you the cost of doing heroin

22:22

every day. Or pretty much Yeah, this is

22:25

subtler. Even sugar I can tell you the

22:26

cost of doing sugar having you know,

22:28

huge amounts of sugar every day. But no

22:30

one can seem to tell me the cost of

22:31

having three cups of coffee a day. Yeah.

22:34

Well,

22:35

the costs

22:37

I mean, if it it depends on how it

22:39

agrees with you. I mean, for some people

22:41

on three cups a day they get pretty

22:42

jittery. Um and

22:45

it passes over from this very positive

22:47

feeling to this nervous feeling and

22:49

that's that's a cost.

22:51

Um I think the larger cost is to our

22:54

identity as animals. We were designed I

22:57

think to have rhythms as animals do that

23:01

you know, you wake up when the sun comes

23:02

up and you start going to sleep when it

23:04

gets dark and that we were tied into

23:07

these natural cycles

23:09

dictated by the light. Um

23:11

and it broke that connection. It broke

23:14

that temporal connection. And so there

23:17

may be some cost as species and we

23:19

struggle with sleep and sleep is a huge

23:22

deal and sleep is a you know,

23:24

you need sleep to be healthy and sane.

23:26

You need it for your mental health and

23:28

coffee does damage your sleep.

23:32

Now, I put a little asterisk next to

23:35

that because if you can stop drinking it

23:38

after that morning cup, you're going to

23:40

have very little in your system when you

23:42

go to sleep. But

23:44

a cup of coffee you drink at noon,

23:47

a quarter of that caffeine will still be

23:49

circulating at midnight. So it takes a

23:51

while to get out of your system.

23:53

Most of the caffeine researchers I

23:55

interviewed do not drink

23:57

coffee or tea.

23:59

Interesting.

24:00

I mean, these are people who understand

24:01

sleep and the importance of sleep. And

24:03

one of the benefits I didn't mention one

24:05

of the benefits of being off coffee is I

24:07

slept like a teenager. It was fantastic.

24:09

I had some great sleeps. My sort of

24:11

logical mind when it when it understands

24:13

how other drugs impact us and the

24:14

withdrawals and how they impact our

24:16

rhythms our natural rhythms. Even think

24:18

like testosterone if you take too much

24:19

of it your body stops producing it. If

24:21

you do if you have too many sleeping

24:23

pills, your body struggles to sleep

24:25

without them. So I I reflect on coffee

24:27

and go

24:28

surely

24:30

I'm an idiot so don't take this as a

24:31

truth. Surely um if I have coffee every

24:34

day, I'm going to struggle to like

24:36

self-regulate

24:38

um my ups and downs and I and if my if

24:40

I'm forcing my body to go up, then my

24:42

body will come down even further than it

24:45

would ordinarily. Or you'll take

24:46

something else to make it come down. Yes

24:48

and then I'll have to take a sleeping

24:49

pill or alcohol. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.

24:51

So no, people do get into these cycles

24:53

of of coffee and alcohol uh or tea and

24:56

alcohol. Um

24:57

So yeah, there I think there's always a

24:59

cost, but I would say

25:02

historically there have been the

25:04

benefits have outweighed

25:06

the costs of I mean, compared to other

25:08

drugs

25:09

um

25:10

I think that uh we've gained a lot. And

25:12

there's the whole social aspect of

25:14

coffee. I mean, the coffeehouse scene in

25:15

London was just so vibrant and you know,

25:19

the the

25:21

um the insurance in Lloyd's of London

25:22

began in a coffeehouse and the the

25:24

London Stock Exchange began in a

25:25

coffeehouse and

25:27

um

25:28

you know, English literature was changed

25:30

by the rhythms of conversation in the

25:32

coffeehouse and it was this place where

25:34

the classes could mix in a in a way they

25:36

couldn't in the tavern or anywhere else.

25:39

And you know, you can make a case and I

25:41

try to in the book that the

25:42

Enlightenment and the Age of Reason owed

25:44

a lot to caffeine.

25:46

So I think it had really positive effect

25:48

in that it got people who were

25:50

enibriated on alcohol all the time to

25:52

think clearly.

25:54

Um and that was a big deal cuz I don't

25:56

think people realize how much alcohol

25:58

people drank um prior to 1650. It was

26:02

the safest thing you could drink because

26:04

the water was contaminated with disease

26:06

and people understood that. That's how

26:08

you got plague was you know, using the

26:10

wrong water pump and things like that.

26:13

Um alcohol the fermentation process and

26:15

the alcohol itself disinfected water to

26:18

some extent, but not as effectively as

26:21

boiling it.

26:22

And coffee and tea the first time we

26:24

boiled water to drink.

26:26

Um so the the the countries that

26:28

embraced coffee and tea suddenly their

26:30

public health was much improved. They

26:32

had much lower rates of disease. So that

26:34

was also a boon. So there are a lot of

26:36

positives. You talk about the reason why

26:38

why coffee is addictive anyway from a

26:39

pollination perspective which I found

26:41

really No one's ever said that before.

26:43

Yeah, so that was a one of the

26:45

interesting um bits of research that I

26:47

came across. Um so like a lot of drugs

26:50

that plants produce, it begins its life

26:52

as a pesticide. Um most of these

26:55

alkaloids that we think are so great

26:57

whether it's cocaine or um

27:00

uh caffeine or

27:02

um oh god, there's so many of them and

27:04

they're not occurring to me right now.

27:06

Plants evolved these as chemicals that

27:09

would um kill insects or discourage

27:12

insects from eating them.

27:14

And then we found that they had

27:16

interesting effects on our brains if you

27:17

got the dose right. And um so caffeine

27:20

was designed

27:21

it kills insects at high doses. It also

27:24

stops other plants from germinating

27:26

nearby. So it you get more habitat if

27:29

you if you if your leaves contain

27:31

caffeine and and they drop. Um

27:34

but the cleverness of plants is such

27:37

that some of them figured out that a

27:39

really low dose of caffeine in their

27:41

nectar

27:43

would attract bees.

27:44

And the uh the orange the citrus family

27:47

does this reliably. So they've

27:49

repurposed this pesticide as an

27:51

attractant cuz you don't put pesticide

27:53

in your nectar. That's where you attract

27:54

insects.

27:55

And um it turns out bees really like

27:58

caffeine

27:59

and they will go preferentially to

28:01

flowers that offer them caffeine. We

28:03

don't know if they get a buzz.

28:05

Um

28:06

but they do prefer it. And it does for

28:10

them what it does for us. It improves

28:12

their memory. They're more likely to go

28:14

back to the flower that gave them

28:16

caffeine than any other flower and

28:17

remember where it was. They will also

28:20

work harder as um so they become better

28:23

workers basically. So the plants are

28:25

manipulating the bees to do their

28:27

bidding. We knew that, but in a much

28:29

deeper way than we understood by

28:31

essentially, you know, drugging them.

28:33

And then humans came along and just got

28:34

humans yeah. Yeah. But but the curious

28:37

thing is why should a pesticide have

28:40

these mental effects for us?

28:42

And the theory I advance in the book is

28:46

that if you're a plant and you're and

28:49

you're bothered by pests,

28:51

the best strategy is not to kill the

28:53

pest. Because if you do that, if you

28:55

just put out a lethal chemical, um

28:59

you're going to kill

29:01

a bunch of the pests, but the resistant

29:04

members and there are always some

29:05

mutations that give resistance, they're

29:08

going to explode. Their population will

29:10

explode and you will and your tool will

29:12

be gone. It won't work anymore.

29:14

But if you merely discombobulate

29:18

your

29:19

predator, your pest, confuse it, which

29:23

psychedelics and other drugs do, uh make

29:26

it lose its appetite, which most drugs

29:29

do, um

29:30

you're much better off cuz it won't it

29:33

it won't have this kind of selective

29:34

pressure. Interesting. So I got this

29:37

insight from my cat Frank who

29:40

um had a real issue with catnip. I I had

29:43

a catnip plant in my garden and my

29:45

garden was fenced.

29:47

And every night when I was going to out

29:49

to the garden to pick something for

29:50

dinner, Frank would follow me

29:53

and look up at me, and he wanted to be

29:55

shown where the catnip was. And I would

29:57

show him to the catnip, and he would

30:00

roll in it and get really stoned. And um

30:04

and then forget where he had seen the

30:06

catnip. And he had to be reminded every

30:08

single day. This is an intelligent cat.

30:10

Like, where was that plant?

30:12

The plant had drugged him so that he

30:15

would lose track of where it was.

30:17

Oh, wow. So, I thought that was a pretty

30:19

clever plant. Certainly more clever than

30:21

Frank was.

30:22

Speaking of clever plants, then.

30:26

Transition, yes.

30:27

wasn't bad, was it?

30:29

Um

30:30

I on the topic of psychedelics, which is

30:31

I referenced at the start,

30:33

when I first heard about the concept of

30:35

psychedelics, I, like you cuz I've heard

30:37

you talk about your initial sort of

30:39

perception of them, was terrified by the

30:42

thought of losing my consciousness. I

30:44

also thought as you know, you talked

30:45

about cancer anxiety in your writing and

30:48

how patients with suffering with cancer,

30:50

I think the last thing I'd want to do is

30:51

trip if I had cancer. But also, another

30:53

point that you made in in a talk you you

30:55

gave was I saw myself as a very logical,

30:59

scientific, physical person, and I

31:01

thought that I couldn't be that and Mhm.

31:04

spiritual or whatever however you want

31:06

to describe it or really anything I

31:07

couldn't think or feel.

31:09

Tell me about your journey then from

31:11

going from that place

31:13

to psychedelics. I I I I know you it's

31:14

well well documented in um the journey

31:17

you've taken, but I but I really want to

31:18

understand how your perception shifted

31:20

and where it sits today as a spiritual

31:23

Yeah. individual.

31:24

So, I did see myself as a very

31:27

materialist uh in my philosophy. Um

31:30

I thought that the laws of nature we

31:32

knew explained everything and anything

31:34

else was supernatural, you know? And I'd

31:37

talk to a lot of people who'd done

31:39

psychedelics and had this big spiritual

31:40

experience. And so, I was curious about

31:43

it cuz I did I I said somewhere that I

31:45

thought I was kind of spiritually

31:46

[ __ ] I just It was a part of myself

31:48

I hadn't developed.

31:49

And I but I did have this misconception

31:51

that uh to be spiritual is to believe in

31:54

supernatural things. Yeah. Okay. And

31:56

that's kind of a scientific view. It's

31:58

an assumption, you know, scientists

31:59

assume this about spiritual people.

32:02

I had a couple big experiences on

32:04

psilocybin at the as I was uh

32:07

researching the book, more immersive

32:09

journalism. And um Nice excuse. Uh I

32:12

know I you know, I did feel

32:14

I was curious to try these things, but I

32:16

also felt compelled. I think my readers

32:19

expect me to do stuff, you know, that

32:21

I'm writing about and not just be on the

32:22

sidelines. And so, I did feel some real

32:25

pressure to do it. But I was I did these

32:27

conversations with volunteers in these

32:29

studies and individuals who had, you

32:31

know,

32:32

amazing experiences that completely

32:34

changed their attitude toward death. I

32:36

mean, people who who lost their fear of

32:38

death after one 4-hour experience on

32:41

psilocybin. I mean, how does that

32:43

happen? You I mean, you you have to be

32:44

curious about that.

32:46

Um Psilocybin being the active

32:47

ingredient in magic

32:48

In in magic mushrooms, yeah. Um but in

32:50

these trials, they get it in a pill

32:51

form. It's kind of purified, but it's

32:53

the same same drug exactly.

32:55

Um

32:56

So, I had a couple really interesting

32:58

experiences um that reset my

33:01

understanding of what spiritual meant.

33:04

Um and

33:07

my experiences had to do with powerful

33:09

connection to something bigger than me

33:12

that I felt.

33:13

Um specifically for me, it was the

33:16

plants in my garden

33:18

that I mean, I'm a gardener. I've been

33:19

writing about plants one way or another

33:21

for a long time.

33:22

And

33:23

I've always admired plants and I think,

33:26

you know, as we were talking about the

33:27

the the the citrus plants with the

33:29

caffeine, I think they're really

33:31

intelligent um in a very different way

33:33

than we are.

33:35

But it was that was kind of an

33:36

intellectual conceit. I didn't feel them

33:39

as

33:41

um

33:41

conscious beings.

33:43

And during this trip I did, I was in my

33:46

garden and all the plants were like

33:48

talking to me. I mean, not literally

33:50

talking to me, but they were returning

33:51

my gaze. They were present. They had uh

33:55

sentience. Um and it was and they were

33:58

very benign. They They liked me.

34:02

I took care of them, you know, what do

34:03

you I fertilized them.

34:05

Um

34:05

but it was a very powerful connection to

34:08

nature that I hadn't felt before. Most

34:10

of us when we walk through the natural

34:11

world, we we sort of feel we're sort of

34:14

part of nature, but we're sort of not

34:15

part of nature. We're all alienated from

34:17

nature. That's our human thing. And it's

34:20

our human arrogance, actually, but um

34:22

uh but it's also a failure of

34:24

imagination to see ourselves as animals.

34:26

And but that's what we are.

34:28

Um we're a little different. And in

34:30

their ways in which we have transcended

34:32

nature or think we have. But anyway,

34:35

I felt more one creature among many than

34:39

I had ever felt in my life. I was just

34:40

another creature in the garden. And and

34:43

it was kind of liberating. It was this

34:44

wonderful feeling. It was It was a great

34:46

moment. So, I had that experience, and

34:48

then I had another experience of

34:51

uh you know, what people call ego death

34:53

of, you know, total ego dissolution on a

34:55

high dose psilocybin, a guided

34:58

psilocybin trip. It's not something you

35:00

want to try on your own.

35:01

And um

35:03

uh I saw myself kind of explode in a

35:06

cloud of Post-it notes, blue Post-it

35:08

notes, and then they fell to the ground,

35:09

and there I was this

35:11

this um pool of paint on the ground. And

35:14

that was me, but I was observing it from

35:16

this new perspective that was completely

35:18

untroubled by what should have been a

35:21

catastrophe. And it was fine. This is

35:24

how things are. And then having no ego

35:26

anymore,

35:27

I had no walls, and I just merged into

35:30

this piece of music that the guide was

35:32

playing, this Bach unaccompanied cello

35:34

suite.

35:35

That was

35:37

undescribably beautiful. And I but there

35:39

was no subject-object relationship. I

35:41

just became the music. I just joined it.

35:44

It was the most profound experience

35:46

listening to music I'd ever had.

35:48

So, I came out of these experiences like

35:51

rethinking what is spiritual mean.

35:54

And I came to understand it. It means

35:56

having a profound connection with

35:57

something larger than you.

35:59

Um it's a kind of love.

36:01

It's um

36:03

it could, you know, some people have it

36:05

with the universe. I had it with the

36:07

plants in my garden uh and this piece of

36:10

music. Um

36:11

And that um

36:15

that sense of profound connection,

36:18

that's what I think of as spiritual now.

36:20

Um and there's nothing um

36:23

there's nothing supernatural about it.

36:24

You could say, well, your plants weren't

36:25

really conscious,

36:27

but they are sentient beings. And

36:31

we're the first culture in history

36:32

that's forgotten that. You know, our

36:34

scientific worldview has given us this

36:37

incredible blind spot about the

36:38

sentience all around us, you know, going

36:41

back to Descartes

36:42

um

36:43

who, you know, thought that we were the

36:45

only thinking creature and and no other

36:48

creature felt pain or had consciousness.

36:51

Um

36:52

And most of us still sort of believe

36:53

that, I think, even though we're

36:54

learning that sentience goes way down.

36:57

Um

36:58

and that I just read a paper saying that

37:00

insects may have consciousness.

37:02

Wrap your head around that. Um

37:05

Christ. Yeah.

37:06

Think about all the Well, there there

37:08

are a lot of ethical There are a lot of

37:09

ethical implications. Um

37:11

So, so my point is though that

37:15

the perception that you're surrounded by

37:17

sentient beings is not supernatural. We

37:21

are.

37:22

And what the um psychedelics are

37:26

removing is this is this filter that's

37:28

allowed us to see things in this very

37:30

narrow, materialist, scientific

37:32

worldview. Paper was published uh just

37:35

this week

37:36

by the group at Johns Hopkins. Roland

37:39

Griffith was the author. He's the guy I

37:41

was just telling you about who studies

37:42

both caffeine and psilocybin.

37:44

And they they did a big uh observational

37:47

study of people who've had a psychedelic

37:48

experience to see if their uh how their

37:52

beliefs changed. And they And the thing

37:53

they looked at was really interesting.

37:55

They looked at attribution of

37:57

consciousness to other beings.

37:59

Um and it went up dramatically.

38:03

Um so, people who

38:05

I think normally 13% of people think

38:07

plants have some consciousness, it went

38:09

up to like 58%. And that was the most

38:11

dramatic gain, but everything did. I

38:13

mean, people attributing consciousness

38:14

to animals, to cats and dogs, to

38:16

insects,

38:17

uh it all went up. Now, you might think,

38:19

okay, psychedelics increases your

38:21

magical thinking, but they also checked,

38:24

did you believe in the Loch Ness Monster

38:26

and a bunch of other kind of magical

38:29

nature things?

38:30

Um and they didn't. There was no change

38:33

there.

38:33

But this attribution of consciousness

38:35

went way up across the board.

38:37

And so, what does that tell us? Well,

38:40

every traditional culture has believed

38:42

that there are many species that are

38:43

conscious, that are sentient.

38:45

Um

38:46

and that um this is something we've

38:48

unlearned.

38:50

And I think you one way to interpret is

38:52

psychedelics

38:54

um

38:56

you know, unlearns the unlearning,

38:58

basically, and and allows us to see

39:02

something that all children see and most

39:04

traditional people see,

39:06

which is the fact that we're not the

39:08

only thinking

39:10

being.

39:11

Um So,

39:13

that's a that's a spiritual question,

39:14

too.

39:15

I my first real experience with a

39:17

psychedelic was San Pedro. Uh-huh. You

39:19

know the cactus? Yeah, I have. Really

39:20

interesting experience. So, I drunk this

39:22

drink um with my partner, and we

39:25

you? Peru. Okay. So, I don't think it

39:27

grows that well in England. No. No,

39:29

yeah. You can grow it out here. Yeah,

39:31

well, yeah, I yeah, I I have I've heard,

39:33

but I but it was a really interesting

39:34

experience. I first two two three hours,

39:37

the guy the shaman takes us to a to a

39:38

cave cuz it's raining, and nothing. I'm

39:41

sat there for three hours, nothing.

39:43

I leave the cave and I go back out into

39:45

the hills, the beautiful sort of grassy

39:47

hills with trees and everything. And the

39:49

minute I got outside, I think within 2

39:51

minutes, I was convinced and I've said

39:52

it to my team before, I was convinced

39:55

that me and the plants

39:57

were the same thing and really that they

39:59

were like they were like looking at me.

40:01

Mhm. I was looking at them and they were

40:03

like looking at me and it was the first

40:04

time I felt like I had, as you describe

40:05

it,

40:06

a almost human relationship, even with

40:09

the the grassy hills, but it was really

40:10

these plants in front of me. It was like

40:12

they were an audience now. Were they the

40:14

cactus? Or not? They were just they were

40:16

just these these these tall plants and

40:18

it felt like they were like looking at

40:20

me and trying to tell me something and

40:22

you're right, the experience I had was I

40:23

totally

40:25

didn't matter in the same way that I'd

40:27

mattered 3 hours ago. My all sort of

40:29

sense of self-importance had had gone

40:32

and I was just as important as this this

40:33

little plant.

40:34

Mhm. And it was and as you describe it,

40:36

it was we were the same thing and I was

40:37

in awe of that that feeling.

40:39

Obviously, you don't forget the feeling.

40:42

You don't forget the memory, but you

40:44

almost you lose the feeling a little

40:46

bit. You do. I think you do. I think you

40:48

go back to baseline to some extent, not

40:50

completely.

40:52

Um

40:52

I can

40:54

I don't know. I find that I can

40:57

return to some of those ways of

40:59

thinking. So, my involvement with

41:02

psychedelics led to a meditation

41:03

practice.

41:04

And um

41:06

I think psychedelics are very good for

41:07

starting a meditation practice.

41:09

Um

41:10

I could never do it. You know, I was I

41:12

was just a very frustrated meditator

41:15

before that when I tried and um

41:18

but I'd had certain kind of paths of

41:21

consciousness laid down during the

41:22

psychedelic experience that I could get

41:24

on again.

41:25

Not so much the peak experience, you

41:27

know, the fireworks. Um

41:29

and that's what people end up talking

41:31

about or writing about, but a lot of the

41:32

psychedelic experience is this long

41:35

tail, this long denouement.

41:37

Uh as you're coming down, you're

41:39

regaining control over what you're

41:41

thinking about, you can direct your

41:43

attention here or there, yet you're not

41:45

distractible. You are really

41:47

in a zone.

41:49

And

41:50

that state is a meditative state and

41:54

having laid down those tracks, you can

41:56

get back to them, I think. Um with work

41:58

and sometimes it's a matter of thinking

42:00

about an image I saw on a psychedelic

42:01

trip that helps me get there.

42:03

Um

42:05

So,

42:07

I think that's one way you keep it

42:08

alive.

42:10

Um because psychedelics aren't a

42:11

practice. You just you can't do it that

42:13

often. You don't want to do it that

42:14

often. It it takes a toll. It's hard

42:16

work. Um and and that's one of the

42:18

reasons that I think they're not

42:19

habit-forming and they're not is that

42:21

after a big psychedelic trip,

42:24

you're not saying when can I do it

42:25

again, you're saying do I ever have to

42:26

do it again? And um cuz it's it's hard

42:29

work and it can be overwhelming.

42:31

But

42:33

there is a residue that stays with you.

42:36

And some people I've, you know, really

42:37

have seen their lives turned around and

42:39

they have a big

42:40

uh you know, they take away a lot.

42:42

Um I I for me it's been subtler things

42:45

like that, but I I I can use meditation

42:47

to kind of

42:49

nurture that flame.

42:51

One of the as you you talked there about

42:52

people's lives turning around after a

42:54

psychedelic experience. Obviously, the

42:56

the studies that have been done on

42:58

psilocybin and many other psychedelic

43:01

compounds

43:02

um

43:03

are pretty profound when you read about

43:05

them. The the impact of one dose, one

43:08

trip in the right set and setting on

43:10

things like treatment-resistant

43:11

depression are really like almost hard

43:13

to believe. Yeah. And um

43:17

and I think we should take them with a

43:18

grain of salt. I mean, I think that one

43:20

of the things to understand, they're

43:22

very impressive results. They're much

43:23

better than the results for

43:25

antidepressants when they when they came

43:26

on the scene. They were approved with

43:28

like marginal utility. I think they they

43:31

scored like two percentage points better

43:33

than placebos.

43:35

You know, but it doesn't take a lot to

43:37

get a drug approved. Um here you're

43:39

seeing substantial sustained changes in

43:42

people, um which is great. But it's

43:44

important to understand the early

43:45

studies on any drug tend to be more

43:48

positive than they are later.

43:50

Part of the reason is that that the

43:52

researchers are optimizing everything.

43:55

They have very trained well-trained

43:56

guides. They they can exclude anyone

43:59

who's too depressed or

44:02

has some other problems. So, they're

44:03

they're you know, they're they're not

44:05

giving it to thousands of people,

44:06

they're giving it to hundreds of people.

44:08

So, I think we could expect as we get to

44:10

phase three and then introduction that

44:13

the effects won't be quite as good as

44:14

they've been. But so far, they've been

44:16

like two-thirds of people in most of

44:18

these trials, whether it's MDMA for

44:20

trauma or psilocybin for depression or

44:23

addiction,

44:24

have um you know, lost their diagnosis.

44:27

And that's pretty extraordinary. And

44:29

we're talking about potential cures, not

44:32

simply symptoms, dealing with symptoms.

44:35

Um so, it's very exciting research. I

44:37

think I'm a little concerned about the

44:39

kind of irrational exuberance that's

44:41

surrounding the space. There's all this

44:43

investment money. There's there's more

44:44

capital than there are good ideas, I I

44:47

would say. That's my reading of the

44:48

situation. Um

44:50

and people are going to get hurt, you

44:52

know. So, I I just see a bubble here

44:54

that concerns me, but there is something

44:56

real here. Um

44:59

and I just hope we can be careful about

45:01

how we, you know, that we don't uh build

45:03

up people's expectations, especially

45:05

people with mental illness that they

45:07

think they've got a cure. It doesn't

45:08

work for everybody.

45:10

And and some people have really hard

45:12

experiences on psychedelics.

45:15

That tends to be the case with that sort

45:16

of bubble that you described tends to be

45:17

the case with all new industries, the

45:20

internet, cryptocurrencies,

45:21

psychedelics. They have this euphoria

45:23

bubble and then there's a a flattening

45:25

where the the true value emerges over

45:27

time. Especially on Silicon Valley,

45:29

which is some like some

45:30

fashion-conscious money. Um And cuz I've

45:33

seen this, you know, having worked in

45:35

the food space, uh agriculture, there

45:38

was I remember this moment in 2008 or

45:40

so, uh where all the Silicon Valley

45:42

people were investing in ethanol. They

45:44

thought this was the green this green

45:45

energy. This is turning corn into fuel.

45:48

And it was clear to anybody close to the

45:50

situation that in fact it took more

45:52

energy to make ethanol than you got out

45:54

of it. It was just a way to get rid of a

45:56

surplus of corn on the part of the

45:58

farmers and the government.

46:00

But everybody jumped in. Bill Gates, um

46:02

you know, the the Sand Hill Road crowd

46:05

and um and you could watch this and then

46:07

they very quickly realized, oh, this

46:09

isn't such a good business. And and then

46:11

then they got into food and they got

46:12

into mock meats and that's where they

46:14

are now. They're in the food industry as

46:16

well as psychedelics and they're going

46:17

to be very disappointed at the returns

46:19

in the food industry, which like if

46:20

you're lucky you're two or three

46:21

percent. Um it doesn't scale like

46:24

software.

46:25

Some of the evidence in these clinical

46:26

trials does show the efficacy of the

46:28

psychedelics psychedelic compounds. And

46:30

one of the questions I had and I know

46:31

that, you know, you've done a huge

46:32

amount of research on this is if

46:34

psychedelics are effective, even in some

46:36

cases, what does that say about the

46:38

causes of these It's a great question.

46:42

Yeah.

46:42

The honest, complete answer is we don't

46:44

know, but the best theory that that I've

46:47

come across is that if you look at the

46:50

different disorders that psychedelics

46:53

appears to be effective in treating,

46:56

depression, anxiety,

46:58

uh obsessive-compulsive disorder,

47:00

addiction, all of these are mental

47:03

disorders that involve a kind of

47:05

rigidity of thought.

47:08

People stuck in loops of rumination, um

47:11

inflexible thinking. They need this drug

47:14

to get through the day. Um

47:17

they have this narrative in their head

47:18

that they're a bad person, that nothing

47:20

is working in their life or they have

47:23

anxiety and they replay loops about, you

47:26

know, what makes them anxious. Um

47:29

what psychedelics appear to do, what

47:31

psilocybin appears to do is break those

47:34

habits of thought.

47:36

It's it's kind of a solvent. Um and so

47:39

that it uh shakes things up in a way

47:42

that makes the brain more plastic, more

47:44

able

47:46

to learn new patterns. Because this is

47:48

essentially people stuck in old

47:49

patterns.

47:51

And so, I think that this is probably

47:54

its contribution. The most beautiful

47:55

metaphor of this that I I I heard from a

47:58

a neuroscientist,

48:00

he said, I I think of I think think of

48:02

your mind as a hill covered in snow

48:05

and uh it would have been a mountain

48:07

except he was from Holland and they

48:09

don't have mountains. Um and your

48:11

thoughts are um sleds going down the

48:14

hill.

48:15

After a while, your thoughts are going

48:16

to keep getting drawn at like attractors

48:19

into the same grooves and it's going to

48:21

be very hard to get down the hill

48:22

without falling into those grooves.

48:25

Think of the psychedelic experience as a

48:26

fresh snowfall filling the grooves

48:30

allowing you to take any path you want

48:31

down the hill.

48:32

Um so, I think it has to do with

48:36

habitual thinking.

48:37

Rigid brains, stuck brains, uh brains

48:40

that have too much order

48:42

and need to be disordered a bit.

48:44

Um

48:46

So, you know, this all remains to be

48:48

proven. There's actually a

48:50

a group at uh Mass General at Harvard

48:53

that is looking at the whole question of

48:56

rumination and psychedelics and seeing

48:58

if that is indeed the common

48:59

denominator. Cuz we think of all these

49:01

diagnoses as

49:03

actual real things, but they're really

49:06

conventions of the psychiatry industry.

49:09

And if you read the DSM, the

49:11

the whole encyclopedia of diagnoses,

49:13

every 5 years they throw out a bunch,

49:15

they add a bunch. They don't really know

49:16

what they're doing. So, I remember

49:18

asking a psychiatrist, I said, isn't it

49:20

a little weird that this same drug works

49:22

on these five different things, you

49:24

know, addiction and obsession? And he

49:25

said, well, how do you know they're

49:26

different things?

49:28

Maybe they're all different symptoms of

49:29

the same brain, same kind of brain.

49:32

And so, you know,

49:35

I mean, if you if you think about it,

49:36

anxiety is is worry about the future.

49:39

Depression is really a being a victim of

49:41

the past, but it's a similar mental

49:44

construct. And psychedelics appears to

49:47

weaken it. I read that that in that sort

49:49

of analogy of the hill and I and it

49:52

really stayed with me. That hill with

49:54

the snow, this idea that our trauma or

49:55

whatever it might be, our past

49:57

experiences have created these grooves

49:58

which we just you know, slide down every

50:00

single day and over and over again. And

50:02

you talked about previously how um

50:04

that's why there might be a case for

50:06

doing psychedelics later in life.

50:07

Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, I I do feel I

50:10

mean, as life goes on, we become more

50:11

creatures of habit. I mean, it's just a

50:13

given.

50:14

It's about learning. We learn what

50:16

works. We learn the algorithms that get

50:18

us through the day, get us through a

50:19

fight with our spouse, get us through

50:22

negotiating with our children, whatever

50:24

it is. We have these algorithms, they're

50:25

handy, they work, they save us time. And

50:28

we are efficient creatures.

50:30

Um

50:31

But but habits blind you to reality. You

50:35

know, they they they you're one step

50:37

removed from experience. You're you're

50:40

saying, "Okay, that's the situation. I'm

50:41

going to play this tape." And you don't

50:44

you lose your sense of wonder. And

50:47

that's so important and and awe. You

50:50

know, awe is one of the most important

50:52

emotions and as we get older, you know,

50:54

kids are have this awe experience every

50:56

day, every minute, you know, it could be

50:58

a cookie, it could be walk down the

51:00

street. I mean, it's just incredible.

51:03

And the reason is that it's all new to

51:04

them and they haven't formed these

51:06

habits.

51:07

Um

51:08

And as we get older, I think that's

51:11

where the value of psychedelics is

51:13

really important because they are

51:15

reliable awe inducers

51:18

and that they

51:20

make you see things freshly. And

51:23

you know, I talk in the book about

51:25

this very common psychedelic insight

51:29

that love is the most important thing in

51:31

the world.

51:32

And we laugh and it sounds like a

51:34

Hallmark card and such a cliche, but

51:36

what is a cliche? It's just it's a truth

51:38

that's been overused and and and we

51:41

protect ourselves with the sense of

51:43

irony and banality, but love is the most

51:45

important thing in the world. So,

51:46

there's truth to that. And that the line

51:50

between banality and profundity is very

51:52

fine. And um and so you know, you're

51:56

always hearing people who have

51:57

psychedelic experiences and they come to

51:58

you with this revelation of the obvious.

52:01

Um but we need to be reminded of the

52:02

obvious.

52:04

Do you think there's another way to to

52:05

remain fresh in the mind other than

52:07

needing to do a psychedelic trip?

52:09

Because I I even relate I'm 29, but I

52:11

relate to me getting stuck in the same

52:14

patterns of thought which can diverge

52:16

into like a bitterness or like they can

52:18

So, you know, some of the some of my

52:19

patterns and habits result in happiness

52:21

and fulfillment and feelings of

52:22

contentment. And then others can result

52:24

in like bitterness and resentment and

52:26

other negative things. So, I'd love to

52:27

be able to do some a fresh fall of snow

52:30

on some of those.

52:31

Yes, I know. I know and without using

52:33

psychedelics.

52:35

I mean

52:37

learning something new, doing something

52:39

new is incredibly

52:42

revitalizing. Travel is. I mean, think

52:44

of think of like how

52:46

when you travel somewhere, you're in a

52:48

new country, you've never been there.

52:51

All your algorithms fail. Like you know

52:56

the menu is has full of unexpected

52:59

things.

53:00

Walking down the street, you don't see

53:01

the same brand names you see everywhere.

53:03

You You're So, your senses are are are

53:06

really working hard cuz you're taking in

53:09

lots of new information. That's why it's

53:11

so exhausting, but it's it's so

53:12

wonderful, too. So, I think travel is

53:14

one thing. I think learning a new skill.

53:17

You know, I think that for me, that's

53:20

really important. It's what I love about

53:22

journalism. You know, I get paid as an

53:23

adult to learn whole new fields. You

53:25

know, I'm I'm getting paid now to learn

53:27

about neuroscience and consciousness.

53:29

It's so great. Um

53:32

but you know and and some jobs don't

53:34

allow you to do that. That is in the

53:36

nature of journalism. It's in the nature

53:37

of what you do. You get to talk to

53:39

anybody you want.

53:39

say before I get I ask the question, I

53:41

was thinking I I was thinking if I was

53:42

to answer it myself, it's this. This cuz

53:44

when I walk away from these

53:45

conversations, I it's almost like

53:48

sometimes a psychedelic trip or it just

53:50

a a real shaking of what I thought to be

53:52

true.

53:52

Yeah. And it and it yeah. Oh, I get that

53:55

after I do an interview. I you know, I I

53:57

I I I came from an interview with this

53:59

neuroscientist and I was like so

54:01

exciting like to think about I hadn't

54:03

thought about things that way. And um

54:06

So, I think putting in your yourself in

54:09

situations where there's a lot of new

54:11

information and you're out of your

54:12

comfort zone. The comfort zone is the

54:14

problem, right? And um if you can put

54:17

yourself in a situation and and and also

54:22

you know, we we tend to gravitate to

54:23

what we do well. Yeah. We get reward for

54:26

that, but you know, try working on

54:28

something you don't do well. You know.

54:30

I was just thinking then about how when

54:31

people get older, they tend to go on

54:32

holidays to the same places.

54:34

Yes. When people are young, they go to

54:35

somewhere new.

54:36

They don't Yeah, they don't want to

54:37

repeat themselves. No, it's true. I

54:39

know, it's So, I found this

54:41

at this phase of life,

54:44

the psychedelic experience was really

54:46

valuable for that reason. Um that it did

54:49

cause me to rethink things, have new

54:51

perspectives.

54:53

Um and have this wonderful feeling of

54:56

awe and be reminded of these things. How

54:58

much I love plants. How much I love

55:00

love. Um relationships. I mean, the

55:02

sense of gratitude um that I I I've I

55:05

mean, this is a very common emotion for

55:07

me in after in a psychedelic trip is

55:10

gratitude for

55:11

my parents and my son and and my wife

55:14

and and um

55:17

you know, I mean, we're

55:18

we don't we don't spend nearly enough

55:20

time expressing gratitude for what we

55:21

have. We take it for granted.

55:23

And undermining the taken for granted, I

55:26

think is the most important thing that

55:28

they do.

55:29

Breath work. Something I've heard you

55:31

talk about as well.

55:32

Yeah, so breath work is a

55:34

non-pharmacological

55:37

mode of changing consciousness. It was

55:41

developed by Stan Grof, a Czech

55:43

psychiatrist who who worked in the

55:45

States for many years.

55:46

him as well? I assume for your book.

55:50

Stan's wonderful and I interviewed him

55:53

for How to Change Your Mind and Um so,

55:55

when LSD was banned in 1970,

55:59

he want he was having such good luck

56:01

with it and really believed that there

56:03

were these new you know high super

56:06

highways to the unconscious that he

56:08

wanted to figure out another way to

56:09

induce this state. And so, he studied

56:12

yogic breathing and all these

56:14

other traditional cultures that had

56:17

these trance induced trance. And it's a

56:20

pattern of breathing that you do

56:22

accompanied by usually rhythmic drumming

56:26

that for I think about 2/3 of people

56:29

will put you in a trance state that's

56:31

very much like a psychedelic state. It

56:32

was it was really eerie how it works.

56:36

Um

56:36

you basically

56:39

find yourself losing control of your

56:41

limbs. I mean, it's very physical. Yes,

56:44

you're on your back and you're dancing

56:45

and you're

56:47

and you're breathing this very unnatural

56:49

pattern of a strong exhalation,

56:53

stronger exhalation than inhalation,

56:54

very fast. I think you're

56:56

hyperventilating. I think that's what

56:58

you're doing.

56:58

Basically, yeah. And um

57:01

and I think that that probably, we don't

57:03

know this yet, but that probably is

57:06

reducing blood flow to the brain or

57:08

oxygen to the brain.

57:10

And one of the curious things about

57:12

psychedelics is not that they're

57:14

increasing brain function, but they're

57:16

decreasing it in certain important areas

57:18

including something called the default

57:20

mode network.

57:21

Uh which is the center of the brain

57:23

that's very

57:24

uh very important control center of the

57:26

brain that is involved with your sense

57:28

of self time travel into the past, into

57:32

the future,

57:33

uh the narrative self, the story you

57:35

tell yourself about your life, how you

57:36

fit everything into the story of who you

57:38

are. It's I it's if the if the ego had

57:40

an address, it would be the default mode

57:41

network.

57:43

It may be that starving that of oxygen

57:46

gets us similar effect that psychedelics

57:48

do.

57:49

Um but psychedelics

57:51

that's one of the mysteries. It's like

57:53

we think of all this extra consciousness

57:55

we get from psychedelics or expanded

57:57

consciousness, but it may be that it's

58:00

closing down certain things which allow

58:02

other things to happen. I did breath

58:04

work with um with my partner in my

58:06

girlfriend in Bali. She's training as a

58:08

breath work practitioner.

58:09

So, how did it go?

58:11

So, again, walked in super skeptical.

58:13

This guy starts telling me a bunch of

58:14

reasons why it's going to you know, the

58:16

sort of physiological reasons why it

58:17

works.

58:19

It was about 13 minute 20 minute

58:20

session.

58:21

I mean, 10 minute I didn't even notice.

58:23

I only noticed on photos after that I

58:26

was laying on my back, but my hands were

58:27

in the air. So, and I didn't even I did

58:29

not put my hands in the

58:30

Yeah, it's involuntary.

58:31

Yeah, and they were in the air for 15

58:32

minutes and it didn't hurt my muscles.

58:35

And the other thing was I

58:38

I went to the strange emotional place

58:40

where I felt huge amount of gratitude

58:42

for certain people in my life and I

58:43

actually felt the need to like apologize

58:45

for recent behavior that I'd carried

58:47

out. It just Mhm. Um It was a very

58:50

emotional experience as it is for I know

58:52

a lot of people, but it was just really

58:53

compelled me the thought that doing

58:55

something with my breathing could

58:56

have such a profound impact. And then it

58:58

got me thinking about my day-to-day

59:00

breathing which is part of the

59:02

the education about how we breathe so

59:04

shallowly.

59:05

Right.

59:05

And especially when I'm anxious, if I'm

59:07

ever anxious and I think about it, I'm

59:09

I'm I'm breathing Yeah, very shallow.

59:12

20% of what I usually breathe. So, one

59:14

of my ways now of if I do feel anxious

59:16

of counteracting that from that breath

59:17

work session

59:19

is taking 7 second inhalation, holding

59:22

it and then 7 second out. And honestly,

59:23

doing that for 20 seconds or 30 seconds

59:26

completely seems to flush out any

59:28

feelings of anxiousness.

59:29

There's a bunch of really interesting

59:31

breathing exercises. There's one that

59:33

Andrew Weil does called

59:35

4-3-7

59:38

4-3-8

59:39

and it involves

59:41

certain amount of I'm not going to

59:42

remember it right now, but certain

59:43

amount of inhalation, hold your breath,

59:47

and then exhale for longer than you

59:49

inhaled. And it's it's remarkable. I've

59:53

done it before going on stage and things

59:55

like that. It just lowers your stress

59:56

level very quickly. And I'm guessing it

59:59

lowers your blood pressure. There's a

60:00

lot we don't know about breath. I mean,

60:02

breath is amazing and

60:06

I think you can do a lot to fiddle with

60:08

your consciousness using breath. It

60:10

genuinely, of all the things that people

60:11

have prescribed or told me

60:14

the simplest thing that I've I've I've

60:16

sort of implemented in my own life when

60:17

in situations where I'm feeling stressed

60:19

before going on stage as well, before my

60:20

tour I used to do it in the the green

60:21

room, or when I'm feeling anxious or

60:23

over

60:24

diverging into sort of like overthinking

60:26

is just focusing on my breath.

60:28

My next question to you, my last

60:29

question really is is about what's next

60:31

for you. As a as a tremendously

60:33

successful author that's written about

60:34

such a diverse range of topics

60:37

I mean, I think the first question when

60:38

you walked in the door was what are you

60:39

writing about next? Yeah. It's going to

60:42

be something of deep interest. You're

60:43

going to immerse yourself. You're going

60:44

to buy a cow again, like

60:46

I don't know what I'm going to do for

60:48

this this topic. So, I'm researching

60:50

consciousness, the science and

60:51

philosophy and literature of

60:53

consciousness.

60:55

You know, one of the things that

60:56

psychedelics does is raise questions

60:58

about consciousness. You know, I talked

61:00

to you at the beginning about questions

61:02

are more interesting than answers.

61:04

It's kind of amazing that we're

61:05

conscious. I mean, you know

61:08

we could do all this stuff

61:09

automatically, but we're not. We have

61:11

this space in our heads where we see

61:13

things. We we assume other people have

61:15

consciousness too, but we can't be sure.

61:18

And

61:20

and how does 3 lb of tofu in your you

61:24

know, between your ears

61:26

produce

61:28

an experience of subjectivity, of

61:31

quality.

61:32

It's it's it's one of the greatest

61:34

mysteries left.

61:36

So, I'm going to explore all of it and

61:38

see where it takes me. You know, again,

61:40

I don't know where I'm going,

61:41

but that's the that's the exciting part

61:43

of

61:44

writing. Quick one. We bring in eight

61:47

people a month to watch these

61:48

conversations live here in the studio

61:50

when we're here in the UK and when we're

61:52

in LA.

61:53

If you want to be one of those people,

61:54

all you've got to do is hit subscribe.

61:57

You know, you said at the start that

61:58

your job is to answer questions. What is

62:00

the question that you're trying to

62:02

answer in your next project? Is it just

62:05

what consciousness is?

62:07

Yeah, what is consciousness?

62:08

There there is a couple questions under

62:10

that though. Why do we have it? Do we

62:12

What do we need it for? What does it

62:14

allow us to do?

62:15

Who

62:17

else has it? You know, if you you know,

62:20

do the insects have consciousness? Do

62:22

the plants have There are people who

62:23

believe plants are conscious. Are they?

62:26

How do you define consciousness? There's

62:27

so many subsidiary questions you have to

62:29

answer to get to the bottom of it. Um

62:32

and I think it has a lot of this

62:34

question of who else has consciousness

62:36

has a lot of political or environmental

62:38

implications.

62:40

I think that one of the reasons we got

62:42

into such trouble with the environment

62:44

is the scientific worldview for all its

62:46

power

62:47

has blinded us to the self the interests

62:51

of other creatures. And

62:54

one of the

62:57

you know, you look at Native American

62:58

culture and there's this sense that

62:59

everything is alive, everything has a

63:01

spirit to it. Um

63:04

that keeps you from doing something to

63:06

certain things to those others, right? I

63:08

mean, that that you're violating

63:09

spirits. We don't have that feeling. I

63:11

mean

63:12

our worldview allows us to see nature as

63:15

something for us to exploit

63:17

rather as our relatives as Native

63:20

Americans would describe it. So so

63:22

getting consciousness right means

63:24

getting a lot of things right. Um so,

63:27

wish me good luck.

63:28

No, I do. I'm sure you're going to do an

63:29

unbelievable job on that because you you

63:31

always have on your on your on your work

63:33

and all the books you've written take a

63:35

a different approach and I think that

63:37

yeah, you you highlighted how that comes

63:39

from a place starts with a from a place

63:40

of naivety and curiosity. I'm definitely

63:43

naive. I mean, cuz I have to learn

63:45

neuroscience for this a lot of it and

63:47

and that's a struggle for me. And some

63:49

of these theories are really

63:50

mathematical and that's really a

63:52

struggle for me.

63:53

Um but you know, that's that's the job

63:56

is finding the good explainers who can

63:58

help me to explain it and make it I get

64:01

a lot of satisfaction from taking a

64:03

subject that people think might be very

64:04

dry and difficult and and helping people

64:07

make sense of it. You know that there's

64:09

a tradition on this podcast where the

64:10

previous guest writes a question for the

64:11

next guest. They don't know who they're

64:12

writing it for. The question is

64:15

as you've juggled your life, work,

64:17

relationships, friendships, and

64:18

self-time, what things have been key to

64:20

building your resilience?

64:24

Doing new things

64:26

including taking psychedelics, which has

64:29

definitely

64:31

affected me and and

64:33

contributed to my resilience.

64:35

But I I think it's seeking out new

64:37

projects and um

64:41

doing things that break you out of

64:43

habitual ways of thinking and responding

64:45

to things.

64:47

Habit is wonderful, it's very efficient,

64:49

but it's deadening too.

64:51

So, I'm often thinking and I am a

64:54

creature of habit. I have like a whole

64:56

routine every day to get myself to the

64:58

desk to write, but

65:00

but breaking it is is I think breaking

65:03

habits I would say would be an important

65:05

one. You've spoken to that throughout

65:06

this conversation, so that's a beautiful

65:07

ending. This this idea of leaving your

65:09

comfort zones as well. Thank you. Thank

65:11

you for all the work you're doing. It's

65:12

really inspiring to me that an author

65:14

could be so powerful.

65:16

And I I hope we can have another

65:17

conversation again once your your book

65:19

about consciousness is out because I'm

65:20

sure it'll be a good conversation.

65:21

to that. It's been a great pleasure

65:22

talking to you. Thank you, Michael.

65:24

Thank you.

65:26

I had a few words to say about one of my

65:27

sponsors on this podcast. As the seasons

65:29

have begun to change, so has my diet.

65:31

And

65:32

right now, I'm just going to be

65:33

completely honest with you. I'm starting

65:35

to think a lot about slimming down a

65:38

little bit because over the last couple

65:39

of probably the last four or five

65:41

months, my diet has been pretty bad.

65:43

And it's started to show a little bit.

65:45

Really over the last two months. I go to

65:46

the gym about 80% of the time. So, I

65:48

track it with 10 of my friends in a

65:50

WhatsApp group and this tracker online

65:52

that we all use together. And so, one of

65:53

the things I'm doing now to reduce my

65:55

calorie intake and trying to get back to

65:57

being nutritionally complete in all I

65:58

eat is I'm having the Huel protein

66:02

shake. Thank you, Huel, for making a

66:03

product that I actually like. The salted

66:05

caramel is my favorite. I've got the

66:06

banana one here, which is the one my

66:07

girlfriend likes, but for me, salted

66:10

caramel is

66:11

the one.

66:14

[Music]

Interactive Summary

In this conversation, Michael Pollan, renowned author and journalist, discusses his immersive approach to writing, his exploration of psychedelics, and the role of curiosity in his career. He examines the concept of 'rigidity of thought' in mental health, the potential of psychedelics to disrupt these habits, and the importance of nature and consciousness. Pollan also touches on his investigation into caffeine as a societal drug, the physiological effects of breathwork, and his upcoming work focusing on the mystery of human consciousness.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts