HomeVideos

The Science & Treatment of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) | Huberman Lab Essentials

Now Playing

The Science & Treatment of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) | Huberman Lab Essentials

Transcript

852 segments

0:00

Welcome to Huberman Lab Essentials,

0:02

where we revisit past episodes for the

0:04

most potent and actionable science-based

0:06

tools for mental health, physical

0:08

health, and performance.

0:11

I'm Andrew Huberman and I'm a professor

0:13

of neurobiology and opthalmology at

0:15

Stanford School of Medicine. Today we

0:18

are talking about obsessivempulsive

0:20

disorder or OCD. First of all, as the

0:22

name suggests, OCD includes thoughts or

0:26

obsessions and compulsions which are

0:28

actions. The obsessions and the

0:30

compulsions are often linked. In fact,

0:32

most of the time the obsessions and the

0:34

compulsions are linked such that the

0:36

compulsion, the behavior is designed to

0:39

relieve the obsession. However, one of

0:42

the hallmark themes of

0:43

obsessivecompulsive disorder is that the

0:45

obsessions are intrusive. People don't

0:48

want to have them. They don't enjoy

0:50

having them. They just seem to pop into

0:52

people's minds and they seem to pop into

0:53

their mind recurrently. And the

0:56

compulsions unlike other sorts of

0:59

behaviors provide brief relief to the

1:02

obsession but then very quickly

1:04

reinforce or strengthen the obsession.

1:07

OCD is extremely common. In fact,

1:11

current estimates are that anywhere from

1:14

2.5% to as high as three or even 4% of

1:18

people suffer from true OCD. That is an

1:21

astonishingly high number. Another thing

1:23

to point out is that OCD is currently

1:26

listed as number seven in terms of the

1:28

most debilitating illnesses. Not just

1:31

mental illnesses or disorders, but all

1:34

types of illnesses, including things

1:35

like asthma and cancer, etc. So, you can

1:38

imagine with that standing at number

1:41

seven that it is both extremely common

1:44

and extremely debilitating. And as a

1:46

consequence, it's now realized that many

1:49

hours, days, weeks, months, or even

1:51

years of work performance or showing up

1:54

at work of relational interactions

1:57

really suffer as a consequence of people

1:59

having OCD. With recurrent intrusive

2:01

thoughts happening at very high

2:03

frequency or even at moderate frequency,

2:05

people are spending a lot of time

2:06

thinking about this stuff and they're

2:08

thinking about the behaviors they need

2:09

to engage in and then engaging in the

2:11

behaviors which, as I mentioned before,

2:12

just serve to strengthen the

2:13

compulsions. And so they're not actually

2:15

doing the other things that make us

2:17

functional human beings like commuting

2:18

to work or doing homework or doing work

2:21

or listening when people are talking or

2:23

interacting or sports or working out.

2:24

All the things that make for a rich

2:26

quality life are taken over by OCD in

2:29

many cases. Another thing you'll soon

2:31

learn is that sadly a lot of the

2:33

obsessions and compulsions in OCD often

2:36

relate to taboo topics. And that's

2:38

because the general categories of OCD

2:40

fall into three different bins. checking

2:44

obsessions and compulsions, repetition

2:46

obsessions and compulsions, and order

2:49

obsessions and compulsions. The checking

2:50

ones are somewhat obvious, checking the

2:52

stove or checking the locks. Repetition

2:55

obsessions and compulsions obviously can

2:57

dovetail with the the checking ones, but

3:00

those tend to be things like counting

3:01

off of a certain number of numbers like

3:04

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 6 5 4 3 2 1. People

3:07

perform that repeatedly, repeatedly

3:09

repeatedly or feel that they have to. So

3:12

we have checking, we have repetition,

3:13

and then there's order. Order often

3:16

times is thought of as putting

3:19

cleanliness or making sure everything is

3:21

aligned and perfect and orderly. And

3:24

often times that is the case. But there

3:26

are other forms of order that people

3:27

with OCD can focus on in a obsessive and

3:31

compulsive way. Things like

3:32

incompleteness, the idea that one can't

3:35

walk away from something or stop doing

3:37

something because something's not right

3:39

or complete in that picture. It could be

3:41

the way the table is set. It could be

3:43

the way that something's written on a

3:45

page. It could be an email. It can also

3:47

be in terms of symmetry that everything

3:49

be aligned and symmetric in some way.

3:51

This could be uh seen perhaps in young

3:53

kids. This is one example that I read in

3:55

the literature of children that need to

3:57

arrange their stuffed animals in exact

4:00

same order every day and in a particular

4:02

order uh to the point where if you were

4:05

to move the little stuffed frog over

4:07

next to the stuffed rabbit that the

4:08

child will have a an anxiety reaction to

4:11

that and feel literally compelled driven

4:14

to fix that maybe even multiple times

4:17

over and over again. And then the other

4:19

aspect of order which is a little bit

4:21

less than intuitive is this notion of

4:23

disgust. This idea that something is

4:25

contaminated. So we often think about

4:27

OCD and handwashing behavior in response

4:30

to people feeling that something is

4:32

contaminated, a space, a towel, etc. or

4:35

even simply somebody else's hand and so

4:37

they're unwilling to shake somebody's

4:38

hand. You can imagine how these

4:41

different bins of obsessions and

4:42

compulsions, checking, repetition, and

4:44

order could be extremely debilitating

4:46

depending on how severe they are and how

4:48

many different domains of life they show

4:50

up in. And I know I've said it multiple

4:52

times now, but I'm going to say it many

4:54

times throughout this episode in a

4:56

somewhat obsessive, but I believe

4:58

justified way that every time that one

5:02

engages in the compulsion related to the

5:04

obsession, the obsession simply becomes

5:06

stronger. So you can imagine what a what

5:08

a powerful and debilitating loop that

5:10

really is. So let's drill a little bit

5:12

deeper into how the obsessions and

5:14

compulsions relate to one another. If we

5:16

were to draw a line between the

5:17

obsessions and the compulsions, that

5:19

line could be described as anxiety. Now,

5:23

we need to define what anxiety is. And

5:26

to be quite honest, most of psychology

5:28

and science can't agree on exactly what

5:31

anxiety is. Typically the way we think

5:33

about fear is that it's a heightened

5:35

state of autonomic arousal. So increased

5:37

heart rate, increased breathing,

5:39

sweating etc. in response to an

5:41

immediate and present threat or

5:43

perceived threat. Whereas anxiety

5:45

generally speaking in the scientific

5:47

literature relates to the same sorts of

5:50

thought patterns and somatic bodily

5:53

responses, heart rate, breathing, etc.

5:55

But without a clear and present danger

5:58

being in the environment or right there.

6:01

So that's the way that we're going to

6:02

talk about anxiety. Now, and anxiety is

6:04

really what binds the obsessions and

6:06

compulsions such that someone will have

6:08

an intrusive thought. Some people are

6:10

probably wondering if there's a genetic

6:12

component to OCD. And indeed, there is.

6:15

Although the nature of it isn't exactly

6:17

clear, based on twin studies where

6:20

researchers have examined identical

6:22

twins, fraternal twins, even identical

6:24

twins that share the same sack in

6:26

uterero, the what we call monocorionic,

6:28

so sitting in the same little bag during

6:30

pregnancy or in different little bags,

6:32

you can see different levels of what's

6:34

called genetic concordance. But if we

6:36

were to just sort of cut a cut a broad

6:38

swath through all of the genetic data,

6:40

it's fair to say that about 40 to 50% of

6:43

OCD cases are have some genetic

6:45

component, some mutation or some

6:47

inherited aspect that's genetic and that

6:49

one could point to if they got their

6:50

genome mapped. Now, while that's

6:52

interesting, I don't think it's terribly

6:54

useful for most people. First of all,

6:56

you can't really control your genes. It

6:57

can't pick who your parents were, as

6:59

they say. So, just know that there is a

7:01

genetic component in about half of

7:03

people with OCD, but not always. Now, as

7:06

is typical for this podcast, I want to

7:08

focus on some of the neural mechanisms

7:11

and chemical systems in the brain and

7:12

body that generate obsessivempulsive

7:15

disorder. So, let's take a step back and

7:17

look at the neural circuitry. What's

7:19

going on in the brain and body of people

7:21

with OCD? Why the intrusive recurrent

7:24

thoughts? Many studies, we can fairly

7:27

say dozens, if not hundreds of studies

7:29

have now identified a particular circuit

7:32

or loop of brain areas that are

7:34

interconnected and very active in

7:36

obsessivempulsive disorder.

7:39

That loop includes the cortex which is

7:43

kind of the outer shell of the the human

7:45

brain, the lumpy stuff as it sometimes

7:48

appears if the skull is removed. And it

7:51

involves an area called the stryatum

7:52

which is involved in action selection

7:54

and holding back action. The cortex and

7:56

the strriatam are in this intricate back

7:59

and forth talk. It's really loops of

8:01

connection. There's a third element in

8:03

this cortico strriatal loop as it's

8:06

called and that's the phalamus. Now, the

8:08

thealamus is not a structure I've talked

8:09

a lot about before on this podcast, but

8:11

it's one of my favorite structures to

8:13

think about and teach about in neuro

8:15

anatomy, which I teach uh back at

8:17

Stanford and have taught for many years

8:18

elsewhere. Because the phalamus is this

8:21

incredible egg-like structure in the

8:23

center of your brain that has different

8:25

channels through it. Channels for

8:27

relaying visual information or auditory

8:30

information or touch information from

8:33

your environment up into your cortex and

8:36

as a consequence making certain things

8:38

that are happening to you and around you

8:40

apparent to you, making you aware of

8:42

them, making you perceive them and

8:44

suppressing others. At the same time,

8:47

your phalamus is surrounded by a kind of

8:50

a shell, something called the theamic

8:51

reticular nucleus. Again, you don't have

8:53

to remember the names, but the theamic

8:54

reticular nucleus, as I'm going to call

8:56

it, serves as a sort of gate as to which

9:00

information is allowed to pass through

9:01

up to your conscious experience and

9:03

which is not. So, let's zoom out and

9:06

take a look at the circuit that we've

9:07

got and that we now know based on

9:09

neuroiming studies is intimately

9:12

involved in generating obsessions and

9:13

compulsions in OCD. We have a cortex or

9:16

neoortex which is involved in perception

9:19

and understanding of what's happening.

9:21

We have the strriatam and basil ganglia

9:23

which are involved in generating

9:24

behaviors go and suppressing behaviors

9:27

no go. And we have the phalamus which

9:30

collects all of our sensory experience

9:31

in parallel hearing touch smell etc. Not

9:35

so much smell through the phalamus I

9:36

should mention but the other sensor

9:38

senses that is and then that phalamus is

9:41

encased by the phalamic reticular

9:44

nucleus which serves as a kind of a a

9:46

guard saying you can pass through and

9:47

you can pass through but you you you

9:49

can't pass through up to conscious

9:51

understanding and perception. So that

9:53

loop this corticostriothamic

9:56

loop corticostriolamic loop is the

9:59

circuit thought to underly OCD and

10:02

dysfunction in that circuit is what's

10:04

thought to underly OCD. How do we know

10:07

that this circuit is involved in OCD?

10:09

Well, there we can look to some really

10:11

interesting studies that involve

10:14

bringing human subjects into the

10:15

laboratory and generating their

10:17

obsessions and compulsions and then

10:19

imaging their brain using any variety of

10:21

techniques that we talked about before.

10:23

So, what they do typically is bring

10:24

subjects into the laboratory who have a

10:28

obsession about germs and contamination

10:30

and a compulsion to hand wash. And they

10:33

give these people, believe it or not, a

10:36

sweaty towel that contains the sweat and

10:39

the odor and the liquid basically from

10:43

somebody else's hands. In fact, they'll

10:45

sometimes have someone wipe their own

10:47

sweat off the back of their neck and put

10:49

it on the towel and then they'll put it

10:50

in front of the person, which as you can

10:52

imagine for someone with OCD is

10:54

incredibly anxietyprovoking

10:56

and almost always evokes these

10:58

obsessions about, oh, this is really uh

11:01

this is really bad. This is really bad.

11:03

I need to I need to clean. I need to

11:04

clean. I need to clean. Now, they're

11:05

doing all this while someone is in a

11:07

brain scanner or while they're being

11:09

imaged for posetronom tomography. And

11:11

then they can also look at the patterns

11:12

of activation in the brain while the

11:15

person is doing hand washing. Although

11:17

sometimes the apparati associated with

11:19

these imaging studies make it hard to do

11:20

a lot of movement. They can do these

11:22

sorts of studies. They have done these

11:24

sorts of studies in many subjects using

11:27

different variations of what I just

11:28

described. And lo and behold, what

11:31

lights up? And when I say lights up,

11:32

what what sorts of brain regions are

11:36

more metabolically active, more blood

11:37

flow, more neural activity? Well, it's

11:39

this particular corticostrial phalamic

11:42

loop. In addition to that, some of the

11:45

drug treatments that are effective in

11:47

some, and I want to emphasize some

11:48

individuals at suppressing obsessions

11:51

and/or compulsions, such as the

11:53

selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors

11:55

or SSRIs, which we'll talk about in a

11:57

little bit. When people take those

11:59

drugs, they see not just a suppression

12:01

of the obsession and compulsion, but

12:05

also a suppression of these particular

12:07

neural circuits. They become less

12:09

active. Now, I want to emphasize and

12:11

telegraph a little bit of what's coming

12:13

later. These drugs like SSRIs do not

12:15

work for everybody with OCD. And as many

12:18

of you know, they carry other certain

12:19

problems and side effects for many but

12:21

not all individuals. That collection of

12:25

studies of data, fMRI, PET scanning in

12:28

humans, the treatment with SSRIs really

12:30

points squarely to the fact that the

12:31

cortical stridthalamic loop is likely to

12:34

be the basis of OCD. Now, of course,

12:37

other circuits could also be involved,

12:39

but the cortical stridthalamic circuit

12:42

seems to be the main circuit generating

12:44

OCD- like behavior. But as you'll next

12:47

learn when thinking about the various

12:49

behavioral treatments and drug

12:50

treatments and holistic treatments for

12:52

OCD, what you'll notice is that each one

12:55

taps into a different component of this

12:57

corticostrial theamic loop. By

12:59

understanding the underlying mechanism,

13:01

why certain drugs and behavioral

13:03

treatments work and don't work will

13:05

become immediately apparent. And in

13:07

thinking about that, in knowing that,

13:10

you'll be able to make excellent

13:11

choices, I believe, in terms of what

13:13

sorts of treatments you pursue, what

13:15

sorts of treatments you abandon, and

13:17

most importantly, the order, the

13:19

sequence that you pursue and apply those

13:22

treatments. Before we go any further,

13:23

I'd like to give people a little bit of

13:25

a window into what a diagnosis for OCD

13:28

would look like. give you a sense of the

13:30

sorts of questions that a clinician

13:32

would ask to determine whether or not

13:34

somebody has OCD or not. The most

13:38

commonly used test of OCD or for OCD I

13:42

should say is called the Yale Brown

13:43

obsessivempulsive scale and this is uh

13:46

you know scientists love acronyms as do

13:48

the military and it's the Y box the Y-bs

13:53

the Y box. Before the clinician would

13:55

proceed with any kind of direct

13:57

questions, they would very clearly

13:58

define what obsessions and compulsions

14:00

are. And here I'm actually reading from

14:01

the Ybox. So, quote, "Obsessions are

14:04

unwelcome and distressing ideas,

14:05

thoughts, images, or impulses that

14:07

repeatedly enter your mind. They may

14:08

seem to occur against your will. They

14:10

may be repugnant to you. You may

14:12

recognize them as senseless, and they

14:13

may not fit your personality."

14:16

Then there are compulsions. Quote,

14:17

"Compulsions, on the other hand, are

14:19

behaviors or acts that you feel driven

14:20

to perform, although you may recognize

14:22

them as senseless or excessive. At

14:24

times, you may try to resist doing them,

14:26

but this may prove difficult. You may

14:28

experience anxiety that does not

14:30

diminish until the behavior is

14:31

completed. Now, there are tremendous

14:32

number of questions on the Y box. So,

14:35

I'm just going to highlight a few of the

14:36

general categories.

14:38

Typically, the person will fill out a

14:40

checklist. So they will designate

14:43

whether or not currently or in the past

14:45

they have for instance aggressive

14:48

obsessions. Fear that one might harm

14:50

themselves. Fear that one might harm

14:52

others. Fear that they'll steal things.

14:53

Fear that they will act on unwanted

14:55

impulses currently or in the past or

14:58

both. That's one category. The other one

15:00

are contamination obsessions. So

15:01

concerned with dirt or germs, bothered

15:03

by sticky substances or residues, etc.,

15:05

etc. So a bunch of different categories

15:08

that include for instance sexual

15:09

obsessions, what are called saving

15:11

obsessions, even moral obsessions,

15:14

right? Excess concern with right or

15:15

wrong or morality, concerned with

15:17

sacrilege and blasphemy, obsession with

15:20

need for symmetry and exactness. Again,

15:22

all of these questions being answered as

15:24

either present in the past or not

15:25

present in the past, present currently

15:27

or not present currently. And then the

15:29

the test generally

15:32

transitions over to questions about

15:35

target symptoms. They really try and get

15:36

people to identify if they have

15:38

obsessions. What are their exact

15:40

obsessions? Now, this turns out to be

15:41

really important because as we talk

15:43

about some of the therapies that really

15:44

work, I'll just give away a little bit

15:47

of why they work best in certain cases

15:50

and why they don't work as well in other

15:52

cases. It turns out that it becomes very

15:55

important for the clinician and the

15:56

patient to not just identify the

15:59

obsessions and the compulsions generally

16:01

in a kind of a generic or top contour

16:03

way but to really encourage or even

16:06

force the patient to define very

16:09

precisely what the biggest most

16:11

catastrophic fear is. what the obsession

16:14

really relates to that turns out to be

16:16

very important in disrupting this

16:18

corticostrialamic

16:20

loop and getting relief from symptoms

16:22

one way or the other. So the Yale Brown

16:25

obsessivempulsive scale, this Y box

16:27

again is very extensive. It goes on for

16:30

dozens of pages actually and has all

16:32

these different categories. not so much

16:34

designed to just pinpoint what people

16:37

obsess about or what they feel compelled

16:40

to do, but to also try and identify what

16:43

is the fear that's driving all this.

16:45

Right? In the way that we've set this up

16:47

thus far, we've been talking about

16:48

obsessions and compulsions as kind of

16:50

existing in a vacuum. You're obsessed

16:52

about germs and you're compelled to wash

16:54

your hands. Obsessed about germs,

16:56

compelled to wash your hands. Or

16:57

obsessed about symmetry, compelled to

16:58

put right angles on everything. Or

17:00

obsessed about counting and therefore

17:02

counting, etc. The deeper layer to all

17:04

that is what is the fear exactly if one

17:08

were to not perform the compulsion

17:11

meaning what is the fear that's driving

17:13

the obsession. So that brings us to a

17:16

very powerful category of treatments

17:19

that I should say does not work in

17:21

everybody with OCD but works in many

17:24

people with OCD and really speaks to the

17:28

underlying neural circuitry that

17:30

generates OCD and how to interrupt it.

17:32

and that is the treatment of cognitive

17:34

behavioral therapy and in particular

17:37

exposurebased cognitive behavioral

17:39

therapy. Cognitive behavioral therapy

17:41

and exposure therapy in the context of

17:44

OCD most often involves trying to get

17:47

people to tolerate not relieve their

17:50

anxiety. This is extremely important and

17:53

I realize there's variation to this

17:55

depending on the style of cognitive

17:57

behavioral therapy, the style of

17:58

exposure therapy, but almost across the

18:01

board. The goal again is to get people

18:04

to feel the anxiety that normally they

18:07

are able to at least partially relieve

18:09

however briefly by engaging in the

18:11

compulsion. So if we think back to that

18:14

circuit of corticostrial falamic, what's

18:17

going on here? Where is CBT intervening?

18:20

Well, as you recall, the cortex is

18:21

involved in conscious perception. The

18:23

phalamus and that the phalamic reticular

18:25

nucleus are involved in the passage of

18:28

certain types of experience up to our

18:30

conscious perception, not others. And

18:32

the stridum is involved in this go no-go

18:34

type behavior. When OCD is really

18:38

expressing itself in its fullness,

18:41

people feel an anxiety around a

18:42

particular thought and they either have

18:45

a go, for instance, wash hands or a

18:48

no-go, do not turn left type reaction.

18:52

By having people progressively in a kind

18:54

of hierarchical way reveal their precise

18:58

source of anxiety, their utmost fear in

19:00

this context,

19:02

what happens is they feel enormous

19:04

amounts of autonomic arousal. Now in the

19:07

context of anxiety treatment or other

19:09

types of treatments, the goal would be

19:11

to teach people to dampen to lessen

19:13

their anxiety through breathing

19:14

techniques or through visualization

19:17

techniques or through self-t talk or

19:18

through social support. any of the

19:20

number of things that are well known to

19:21

help people self-regulate their own

19:23

anxiety. Here, it's the opposite. What

19:25

they're trying to get the patient to do

19:27

is to really feel the anxiety at its

19:30

maximum, but then do the exact opposite

19:32

of whatever the normal compulsion is.

19:34

So, if normally the compulsion is to

19:36

wash one's hands, then the idea is to

19:38

suppress handashing while being in the

19:40

experience of the utmost anxiety. Now, I

19:42

want to be very clear. This is not the

19:44

sort of thing you want to do on your

19:45

own. This is not the sort of thing you

19:46

want to do for a friend. This is done by

19:48

trained licensed psychologists and

19:51

psychiatrists because the goal again is

19:54

to bring the person right up close to

19:56

the thing that they fear the most and

19:58

then to interrupt the circuit. What's

20:01

happening is the person is feeling

20:02

compelled to act act to relieve the

20:04

anxiety and through a progressive type

20:07

of exposure, right? You don't throw

20:09

people in the deep end in this kind of

20:10

therapy right off the bat. you gradually

20:13

ratchet them toward or move them toward

20:15

the discussion of exactly what they fear

20:17

the most and then eventually move them

20:18

toward the interruption of the

20:20

compulsion as they're feeling this

20:22

extremely elevated anxiety. Of course,

20:24

within the context of a supportive

20:26

clinical setting, but in doing that,

20:28

what you are teaching people is that the

20:31

anxiety can exist without the need to

20:34

engage in the compulsion. So, I'd like

20:35

to just briefly summarize the key

20:37

elements of cognitive behavioral therapy

20:39

and exposure therapy and how they can be

20:42

combined with drug treatments that are

20:44

very effective. Much of what I'm going

20:46

to talk about next relates to the data

20:49

and indeed the practice of an incredible

20:53

research scientist and clinician. So,

20:56

this is Helen Blair Simpson or I should

20:58

say Dr. Dr. Helen Blair Simpson because

21:00

she is indeed an MD medical doctor and a

21:02

PhD research scientist at Columbia

21:04

University School of Medicine and one of

21:08

the world's foremost experts if not the

21:10

expert I would put her in a category of

21:12

maybe just one to three people who is

21:16

most knowledgeable about the mechanisms

21:18

of OCD is actively researching OCD in

21:21

humans trying to find new treatments

21:24

trying to unveil new mechanisms and

21:26

expand on our current understanding. and

21:28

who also treats OCD quite actively in

21:31

her own clinic. She describes that the

21:33

key procedures are exposures of course

21:36

done in person and with the actual thing

21:39

that evokes the obsessions and

21:41

compulsions. And the goal of course then

21:44

is to gradually and progressively

21:46

increase the level of anxiety but then

21:48

to intervene in so-called ritual

21:50

prevention to prevent the person from

21:52

engaging in the compulsion. Typically,

21:54

this is done through two planning

21:56

sessions with the patient. So,

21:59

describing to the patient what will

22:00

happen and when it will happen and how

22:02

long it will happen so that they're not

22:03

just thrown into this out of the blue.

22:06

And then 15 exposure sessions done twice

22:10

a week or more. So, the one thing to

22:12

really understand about cognitive

22:13

behavioral therapy is that it can take

22:14

some period of time, several or more

22:16

weeks, as many as 10 or 12 weeks. In

22:19

addition, Dr. Dr. Blair Simpson and

22:21

others have explored what are the best

22:23

treatments for patients with OCD by

22:26

comparing cognitive behavioral therapy

22:28

alone, placebo, so essentially no

22:31

intervention or something that takes an

22:34

equivalent amount of time but is not

22:36

thought to be effective in treatment as

22:39

well as

22:41

selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.

22:43

Placebo did not reduce the obsessions or

22:46

compulsions to any significant degree.

22:48

However, cognitive behavioral therapy

22:51

had a dramatic effect in reducing the

22:55

obsessions and compulsions such that by

22:57

four weeks that score that in this case

23:00

ranged from 8 to 28 dropped all the way

23:02

from 25 down to about 11. So there's a

23:06

huge drop in the severity of the

23:08

symptoms. Now what's really interesting

23:10

is that when you look at the effects of

23:12

SSRIs in the treatment of OCD symptoms,

23:16

they had a significant effect in

23:18

reducing the symptoms of OCD, but the

23:22

severity of their symptoms was still

23:23

much greater than those receiving

23:26

cognitive behavioral therapy alone. So

23:28

what happens when you combine them?

23:30

Well, they explored that as well. and

23:31

the combination of cognitive behavioral

23:33

therapy and the SSRIs together did not

23:37

lead to any further decrease in OCD

23:40

symptoms. This points to the idea that

23:42

cognitive behavioral therapy is the most

23:44

effective treatment. And again, when I

23:46

say cognitive behavioral therapy now,

23:47

I'm still referring to cognitive

23:48

behavioral/exposure

23:50

therapy done in the way that I detailed

23:52

before, twice a week for 12 weeks or

23:53

more. So for those of you that have

23:55

sought treatment and you're taking a

23:57

SSRI or if you're thinking about

23:59

treatment and you're prescribed an SSRI,

24:01

the ideal scenario really would be to

24:02

combine the drug treatment with

24:04

cognitive behavioral therapy or in some

24:06

cases maybe cognitive behavioral therapy

24:07

alone. Although that's a decision that

24:08

you really have to make with the close

24:12

advice and oversight of of a licensed uh

24:15

physician because of course these are

24:16

prescription drugs and anytime you're

24:18

going to add or remove a prescription

24:20

drug or change dosage, you really want

24:21

to do that in close discussion with and

24:24

on the advice of your physician. I don't

24:25

just say that to protect me. I say that

24:27

to protect you and because it's just the

24:28

right thing to do. So, what I'm about to

24:30

tell you next is most certainly going to

24:31

come as a big surprise, which is that

24:34

despite the fact that the selective

24:36

serotonin reuptake inhibitors can be

24:38

effective in reducing the symptoms of

24:39

OCD, at least somewhat, and certainly

24:42

more than placebo, there is very little,

24:45

if any, evidence that the serotonin

24:47

system is disrupted in OCD. And I have

24:49

to point out that this is a somewhat

24:52

consistent theme in the field of

24:53

psychiatry. that is a given drug can be

24:57

very effective or even partially

24:58

effective in reducing symptoms or in

25:01

changing the overall landscape of a

25:03

psychiatric disorder or illness and yet

25:07

there is very little if any evidence

25:09

that that particular system is what's

25:11

causal for OCD or anxiety or depression

25:15

etc. Now earlier we were talking about

25:18

not reducing anxiety but learning

25:20

anxiety tolerance in order to deal with

25:23

and treat OCD in the context of

25:25

cognitive behavioral therapies. That

25:28

doesn't necessarily rule out cannabis as

25:29

a candidate for the treatment of OCD.

25:33

And in fact this has been explored. A

25:34

study from Dr. Blair Simpson herself

25:38

looked at this. This was a fairly

25:40

smallcale study. So first of all I'll

25:41

give you the title and again we'll

25:42

provide a link. This is entitled acute

25:44

effects of canabonoids on symptoms of

25:46

obsessivempulsive disorder a human

25:48

laboratory study. I'm just reading from

25:50

their conclusions here. The data

25:51

suggests that smoked cannabis whether

25:52

containing primarily THC or CBD has

25:56

little acute impact meaning immediate

25:58

impact on OCD symptoms

26:00

and yield smaller reductions in anxiety

26:03

compared to placebo. So they did not see

26:05

a a when I say a positive effect I mean

26:08

a um a meerative effect an effect in

26:11

reducing symptoms of OCD from cannabis

26:13

or or CBD. Another treatment that's

26:16

becoming somewhat common or at least

26:18

people are commonly excited about is

26:20

transcranial magnetic stimulation. So

26:22

this is the use of a magnetic coil. This

26:25

is completely non-invasive placed on one

26:28

portion of the skull and one can direct

26:31

magnetic

26:33

energy toward particular areas of the

26:35

brain to either suppress or nowadays you

26:37

can also activate particular brain

26:39

regions. There are some interesting data

26:41

showing that if TMS is applied to areas

26:43

of the brain involved in the generation

26:45

of motor action, so the so-called motor

26:48

areas or supplementary motor areas as

26:50

they're called, while people think about

26:53

or have intrusive thoughts, we know that

26:56

the TMS coil can interrupt the motor

26:59

behaviors, the compulsive behaviors, and

27:02

at least in a small cohort of studies

27:04

and a small number of patients within

27:06

those studies, this has been shown to be

27:09

effective. Not just while the coil is on

27:11

the head, of course, but act after the

27:13

study has been performed or the

27:14

treatment's been performed in reducing

27:17

OCD symptoms by disrupting the tendency

27:20

for the compulsive behavior to be so

27:23

automatic. Right now, I don't think it's

27:26

fair to say that TMS is a magic bullet

27:28

either. I think there's a lot of

27:29

excitement about TMS. And in particular,

27:32

I really want to nail this point home.

27:34

In particular, there's excitement about

27:36

the combination of TMS with drug

27:39

treatments or the combination of TMS

27:42

with cognitive behavioral therapy. I

27:44

realize that a number of listeners of

27:45

this podcast are probably interested in

27:48

the non-typical or holistic treatments

27:51

for OCD. Dr. Blair Simpson's lab has at

27:54

least one study exploring the role of

27:57

mindfulness meditation for the treatment

28:00

of OCD. there the data are a little bit

28:04

um complicated and I should mention that

28:07

good things are happening at least in

28:09

the United States probably elsewhere as

28:11

well but good things are happening in

28:13

terms of the exploration of things like

28:16

meditation and other let's call them

28:18

non-traditional or holistic forms of of

28:20

treatment for psychiatric disorders

28:22

because of the division of complimentary

28:24

health that's now been launched by the

28:26

national institutes of health. So

28:27

whereas before people would think about

28:30

uh meditation or yoga nidra or even CBD

28:34

supplementation for that matter as kind

28:37

of fringe maybe or kind of woo or

28:39

non-traditional at the very least the

28:41

national institutes of health in the

28:43

United States has now devoted an entire

28:45

division right an entire institute

28:48

purely for the exploration of things

28:50

like breathing practices meditation etc.

28:52

So there's a cancer institute, there's a

28:54

hearing and deafness institute, there's

28:55

a vision institute and now there's this

28:58

complimentary health institute which I

28:59

think is a wonderful addition to the

29:02

more traditional aspects of medicine. I

29:05

think uh no possible useful treatment

29:07

should be overlooked or unressearched in

29:10

my opinion provided that can be done

29:11

safely. Turns out that mindfulness

29:13

meditation can be useful in the

29:15

treatment of OCD, but mainly by way of

29:18

how it impacts the focus on and the

29:21

ability to engage in cognitive

29:24

behavioral therapies. So, it's very

29:26

unlikely, at least by my read of the

29:27

data, to be a direct effect of

29:30

meditation on relieving the symptoms.

29:32

Rather, it seems that meditation is

29:33

increasing focus on things like

29:36

cognitive behavioral therapy homework

29:38

and to not focus on other things and

29:40

therefore indirectly improving the

29:42

symptoms of OCD. Now, somewhat

29:44

surprisingly, at least to me, there have

29:45

also been a fairly large number of

29:47

studies exploring how neutrauticals, as

29:50

they're sometimes called, supplements

29:52

that are available over the counter can

29:54

impact the treatment of

29:55

obsessivempulsive disorder. One compound

29:57

that I like to focus on is inositol. And

30:00

here I'm referring specifically to

30:02

myoininoitol because it comes in several

30:04

forms. And it does appear that 900

30:07

milligrams of inositol can improve sleep

30:10

and can reduce anxiety perhaps when

30:12

taken at that dosage or higher dosages.

30:14

So I think there's a great future for

30:15

these neutrauticals meaning I think more

30:17

systematic exploration in particular of

30:19

lower dosages in the context of of OCD

30:22

treatment and as we saw before for the

30:25

SSRIs and other prescription drug

30:27

treatments. I think there really needs

30:29

to be an exploration of these

30:30

neutrauticals in combination with

30:32

behavioral therapies and who knows maybe

30:34

with brain machine interface like

30:35

cranial magnetic stimulation as well.

30:38

What I've tried to provide is an

30:39

opportunity to really drill deep into

30:41

the neural circuitry and an

30:42

understanding of where OCD comes from

30:44

and also to give you a sense of how the

30:47

individual behavioral and drug

30:49

treatments work and perhaps don't work

30:51

so that you can really make the best

30:52

informed choices. again highlighting the

30:54

fact that OCD is an extremely common

30:58

extremely common and yet extremely

30:59

debilitating condition and one that I

31:02

hope that if any of you have or that you

31:04

know people that have it that you'll

31:05

both gain sympathy and understanding for

31:08

what they're dealing with perhaps as a

31:10

consequence of some of the information

31:11

presented today and maybe help them

31:14

direct their treatment find better

31:16

treatment and of course apply those

31:18

treatments for some relief. In closing,

31:21

I'd like to thank you for this in-depth

31:23

discussion about the mechanisms and

31:25

various treatments for obsessivempulsive

31:28

disorder and some of the related

31:29

disorders. And as always, thank you for

31:32

your interest in science.

Interactive Summary

Loading summary...