The Most Misdiagnosed Condition In Mental Health
614 segments
Today we're going to talk about one of
the most misdiagnosed conditions,
cognitive disengagement syndrome, which
used to be known as sluggish cognitive
tempo. Now, the reason that these are so
misdiagnosed is because many people who
have these things get diagnosed with ADD
or ADHD. And these conditions are sort
of characterized by an internal
drifting. So, people have difficulty
paying attention because they daydream
too much. They have difficulty
completing tasks because they have a lot
of difficulty getting started. They have
difficulty with motivation. So these are
conditions that are characterized by
sluggishness overall and hypoactivity.
The reason they get misdiagnosed for
ADHD is because they create a lot of the
same symptoms on the surface. So if we
look at an ADHD kid, this kid has
difficulty paying attention, right? So,
if they're in school, the teacher is
talking and they're easily distracted.
They're paying attention to what
somebody is is moving their leg over
there. There's a bird that flies out the
window. So, they're unable to sustain
focus because their mind is going in a
thousand different directions. Cognitive
disengagement syndrome is an inability
to maintain focus, but for an opposite
reason. Whereas the ADHD kid is highly
distractable by things outside of them.
The kid with cognitive disengagement
syndrome is highly distractable by a
thing inside of them. So their mind
tends to drift, their mind tends to
wander, they get described as very
spacey. And so I want y'all to
understand this is like kind of the same
problem. Right? So in both cases I can't
pay attention to the teacher. But the
mechanism for why I can't pay attention
is actually the exact opposite. One is
externalized and associated with
hyperactivity and one is internalized
and associated with hypoactivity.
Another key feature of cognitive
disengagement syndrome is hypoactivity.
So when we look at ADD or ADHD, the H in
ADHD is hyperactivity. So these kids
tend to be very very active. They're
restless. They move around a lot. They
have difficulty sitting still. They get
excited easily. They run around a lot.
Whereas someone with cognitive
disengagement syndrome is hypoactive.
They have difficulty moving around. It's
hard to get out of bed. It's hard to get
up and start doing things. We'll get
into this a little bit more, but they
also just have a basic motivational
block. Okay. So, in both cases, we see
the same result, which is like in ADHD,
people have difficulty completing tasks,
right? And so, when we look at ADHD, why
do they have difficulty completing
tasks? Well, they have difficulty
getting started. They have difficulty
staying on task. But the reason they
have difficulty getting started is
because they're too distracted. It's
hard for me to sit and focus on this
because I'm thinking about this,
thinking about this, thinking about
this. In cognitive disengagement
syndrome, it's actually the opposite. I
have difficulty getting started, but
that's because my mind is so wandering
away that it's hard for me to focus on
this in terms of sustained focus and
task completion. Once again, ADHD has
distractions, right? So I start to work,
I work for 15 minutes and then my mind
wanders away, starts thinking about
this, thinking about that. And in
cognitive disengagement syndrome, the
mind sort of drifts away from the task
and and flows into sort of a daydreaming
kind of state. And so the three key
features of cognitive disengagement
syndrome are daydreaming, mental
confusion, and hypoactivity.
Now, even though this looks like ADHD on
the outside, it's really important to
understand the mechanism on the inside
because, as we'll discover, there are
actually several things that are
different about these people's brains
and physiology
that lead us in a different direction
for treatment. So, a lot of times
what'll happen with these people is
they'll get diagnosed with ADD or ADHD.
They'll get started on treatment and
they'll get a very suboptimal response.
And that's because we're not targeting
the right ideology. So if you think
about ADHD, it is hyperactivity. So our
treatments are designed to slow things
down. So even when we give someone a
stimulant medication, what the stimulant
medication is stimulating is the breaks
in their brain, right? So we have this
the frontal loes which restrain our
impulses, calm down our emotions,
actually suppress sensory input that
distracts us. Right? So in ADHD, we're
increasing the strength of the brakes
because the mind gets easily distracted
and runs in a in a bunch of directions.
You can think about stimulant medication
like a leash that is on an animal and
the animal runs this way and we yank it
back. Runs this way, we yank it back.
Okay. Hey y'all, if you're interested in
applying some of the principles that we
share to actually create change in your
life, check out Dr. K's Guide to Mental
Health. And if you kind of tunnel down,
okay, why aren't you motivated? And
they're like, well, there's no point.
And if you get underneath there's no
point, what you ultimately find is
hopelessness. So what the yogis
discovered is that what we call
motivation, they actually called a
concentrated mind. What's the difference
between someone who actually does stuff
and someone who just tries to do stuff?
So check out the link in the bio and
start your journey today. The challenge
is that in sluggish cognitive tempo or
cognitive disengagement syndrome, the
problem is not that the dog is running
in a thousand directions. The problem is
that the dog is sitting still and
refuses to move. So, we actually need a
different set of treatments. Some of
them overlap with ADHD treatment.
There's some overlap here to kind of get
the dog moving. Okay? And you can sort
of use a leash to do that, right? Like
you can yank on a dog to try to get it
to move. And so, stimulants do work a
little bit, but it's important to
understand how cognitive disengagement
syndrome is different because that'll
give us an idea of how we actually
address the problem. So the first thing
that we're going to talk about is
internalization versus externalization.
So if you look at human beings, some
human beings are more externally
oriented, right? So I pay attention to
stimuli around me. I get excited by
sight, smells, sounds, etc. What we tend
to find with cognitive disengagement
syndrome is that these are people who
are highly internalizing. So if you sort
of literally look at where their
attention goes, what are they focused
on? they are focused on things inside of
themselves. So daydreaming is a good
example of this. The other really
interesting thing is that people with
cognitive disengagement syndrome who
have a high level of internalization are
also way more prone to depression,
anxiety and social difficulties. So
often times what happens with these
people is they get diagnosed with ADHD,
autism plus ADHD. And why is that?
That's because they appear to have some
of the social difficulties that are
consistent with autism. So, they have
difficulty with social relationships.
They have difficulty engaging in social
behaviors. People who have cognitive
disengagement syndrome have been shown
to be more shy, more introspective and
internally focused when it comes to
social situations. And I don't know if
you guys sort of know this like you know
picture like kind of classic picture of
someone with autism but they are so in
their own head that they have difficulty
engaging with other people. People on
the autism spectrum will also be very
anxious about social situations. And so
both of these things sort of overlap
with this idea of cognitive
disengagement syndrome but the mechanism
is different. So in one case it's the
autism spectrum but in cognitive
disengagement syndrome what tends to
happen is I'm highly internalized
which means first my feelings of anxiety
are really really intense because I'm
looking inward right so if we think
about where does anxiety exist it exists
within us and since I'm so drifty and
internally focused when when someone may
experience let's say a certain amount of
anxiety if I'm zoomed in internally that
anxiety will feel way stronger. We also
see there's a lot of evidence of social
problems with people with cognitive
disengagement syndrome, which once again
has to do with an internal s uh an
internalizing behavior, a sense of
shyness. But what these people really
experience is that when they're in
social situations, their mind will start
to wander. Their mind will drift, right?
They don't get distracted by something
in the environment and that's why they
can't pay attention. their mind
literally like floats away from a a
social situation and then that cascades
into problems over time. So socially
they're considered spacey. It's hard to
have a conversation with them. If you're
like playing a game with them, they'll
like forget that it's their turn. And so
this will start to create further
problems, right? Because now is a a
human child realizes people don't like
to spend time with me. They realize, oh
my god, I should be paying attention.
that starts to create an additional
anxiety because now you realize, now you
know that you're not very good socially.
So, cognitive disengagement syndrome has
these features that kind of look like
ADHD, difficulty paying attention, but
it's heavily internalizing. So, I tend
to daydream. I can't get myself
motivated to start. And since I'm
internalizing, I have difficulty in
social situations because I'm hyper
sensitive to my anxiety. I have
difficulty sort of paying attention to
the conversation because I'm internally
preoccupied. So the most natural
question is okay, what do we do about
it? And this is what is sort of scary
about cognitive disengagement syndrome
is that if you go to a provider and you
describe these symptoms, you are likely
to get diagnosed with ADHD. And what I
found working with these people is that
ADHD treatment doesn't work great. So
this is where sometimes people would
come to me. I'd get referrals from other
psychiatrists who have ADHD patients for
whom treatment is not working. So they'd
send them to me to do the alternative
medicine stuff. And when I assessed
these people, what I really noticed is
their hypoactivity. So a sluggishness of
the mind, a sluggishness of the body.
And this is what we're going to target
with cognitive disengagement syndrome.
So the first thing is that if we look at
studies on medications on cognitive
disengagement syndrome, what we find is
that atamoxitine is more effective than
methylenadate. So we have to understand
a bit about adamoxitine and
methylenadate. So methylenadate is a
stimulant medication and what that means
is it stimulates the brain but it
stimulates the brain in a very specific
way. It stimulates the brakes in our
brain. So we have this part of our brain
called the frontal loes and the frontal
loes are basically what provide the
leash to other parts of our brain. So
when I have an impulse to get distracted
my frontal loes are like no no no we're
going to focus on this this thing over
here. We're going to do our homework.
We're not going to look at short form
content on the internet. The other thing
that the frontal loes do, so they allow
us to reduce distractions, they also
pull the leash on our emotions. So
oftentimes people with ADHD will feel
emotionally disregulated, but once we
give them stimulants, their brain is
able to restrain their emotions. So it
kind of tones down our emotions. But
methylenadate doesn't work as well in
cognitive disengagement syndrome as it
does in ADHD. And that's because the
problem in cognitive disengagement
syndrome is fundamentally different. It
is not hyperactivity of the brain. It is
hypoactivity of the brain. So this is so
the studies show that there's this
medication called adamoxitine which
works better. And adamoxitine is
interesting because it is actually more
noradinurgically
active. Now what does that mean? So we
have epinephrine and norepinephrine
which is epinephrine is also adrenaline.
We have another uh uh hormone called
noradrenaline. These are adrenaline is
what wakes us up, right? Activates us,
allows us to respond to danger. And so
it's really interesting that when we
have all of this hypoactivity, what
works better is something that
stimulates our noradinergic system, our
adrenaline system, right? Gives our
activation a boost. And that seems to
work better because what we're shooting
for is not restraining an a hyperactive
mind. That's what stimulants do. We are
boosting a hypoactive mind. So when I
work with these people, medications have
a role. Executive function training
absolutely has a role. This is a shared
thing with ADHD where we're training our
mind to sustain its attention, focus on
one thing. We talk about a lot of these
things um in Dr. K's guide to ADHD and
doing stuff. We teach people how to set
appropriate goals, get organized. We
sort of address the executive function
there. what I'm going to focus on for
this video. And and just to be clear,
this is this doesn't mean that that
stuff isn't important. This is a thing
that separates
cognitive disengagement syndrome for
ADHD. And that is focusing on your
hypoactivity. So what we find in people
who have cognitive disengagement
syndrome is sort of what I would like to
call a functional hypoactivity. So their
body and brain's ability to rise to the
challenge is impaired. So for most of us
if we're neurotypical we sort of you
know are active throughout the day and
then we calm down in the evening and
we'll get more to that. So most of us if
we're neurotypical when we're faced with
challenges our body and our brain
respond right so basically when we're
like sitting and trying to do a test our
body and our brain are like oh my god
it's a test let's go into hyperactive
mode right so we engage with the world
around us there are times where we are
calm and there are times where we are
engaged and what we see in cognitive
disengagement syndrome is sort of a
failure of that system that even in a
test we'll continue to to daydream there
is no difference between trying to do
your homework and taking your final
exam. Our brain sort of responds
hypoactively in both of those
situations. So, this is where there's
some really interesting research on
motivation and hormones. And so, this is
a study that basically found that people
who are highly motivated, not a study,
several studies have shown this. People
who are highly motivated have a cortisol
system that adapts to our circumstances.
And people who have low quality
motivation basically have a cortisol
system that is unresponsive. So cortisol
is our basic stress hormone. I kind of
view it as an analog of adrenaline and
noradrenaline. All three of these
hormones work together. So when
adrenaline is malfunctioning often times
cortisol will malfunction. The two are
really connected. So these people with
cognitive disengagement syndrome almost
have like a functional adrenal
insufficiency which means that their
cortisol system doesn't activate in the
right way. Okay. So, how do we fix this?
What I tend to find with when I work
with these patients is that they're
under a state of chronic stress. They're
under a state of sort of chronically
elevated cortisol. So, this means that
they're always falling behind. They feel
lazy. We kind of get this message of
like, am I trying? They like try they
try to try hard, but it's difficult for
them to actually try hard, right? When
they when their mind tells them, hey
man, it's time to like kick it into
gear, their body sluggishly responds. So
as they fall further behind in life, as
they have social difficulties, their
chronic level of stress elevates. Once
our stress level is chronically
elevated, we lose our cortisol's
responsive state. Okay? So this is
basically what happens. Like if you
think about, okay, I need to focus on a
test, but if I'm chronically stressed
out, that becomes my baseline. And once
chronically elevated stress becomes my
baseline, then there's no way for me to
do more. And even scarier than that, I
start to run ragged. So these people
feel incredibly frayed to me. Like
they're they're falling apart at the
edges. You know, the seams are kind of
coming apart. They're right on the verge
of like collapsing and splitting open
and everything's on the verge of falling
apart all the time. So when I work with
these people, there are a couple of
really important things that I do. And
basically what we're going to try to do
is restore that cortisol rhythm. Okay?
Okay. Now I'm not doing cortisol
salivary cortisol tests on all my
patients. This is sort of the functional
work of a psychiatrist. Okay. So first
thing that has been associated with
cognitive disengagement syndrome is
sleepiness. So one of the key things
that we really need to do is focus on
going to sleep at the right time and
waking up at the right time. So often
times the people that I work with who
have these problems have really bad
sleep hygiene. They stay awake because
they're kind of sluggish throughout the
day. They haven't done enough during the
day. So, they kind of stay awake at
night hoping that they'll kind of work,
you know, at some point. Maybe I'll get
that second wind. I really need to do
all this kind of stuff. They have really
bad like sleep time, uh, bedtime
procrastination. So, we have a whole
video about, you know, key principles of
restoring your sleep cycle, which I
would strongly recommend y'all check
out. The other problem that these people
have with their sleep is that since they
feel so sluggish during the day, they
will often time have times have high
levels of caffeine intake, which sort of
stimulates you some, but then makes it
hard for you to sleep. So going to bed
on time and falling asleep is a really,
really, really important part. And this
is the other key thing. Waking up
usually around dawn can be incredibly
helpful. So go to bed around dusk, wake
up around dawn. Now, there are all kinds
of real life problems that happen if you
try to do this. I'm just telling y'all,
if we're talking about an ideal
situation for restoring your sleep
schedule, this is what it is. Social
life becomes a mess. Sometimes job and
work and things like that become hard.
So I I get that. Okay. So, restoring
your sleep schedule is a huge part of
it. And the reason it's a huge part of
it is because we want to restore that
fluctuation in cortisol. We want a nice
healthy cortisol that rises in the
morning and then calms down in the
evening. And we can use sleep to kind of
get that back into into the right
rhythm. The other thing that is very
helpful for these people is robust
aerobic exercise, usually early in the
morning. So remember that your body is
kind of sluggish and this is what's so
challenging is that robust aerobic
exercise. So highintensity interval
training I think is fantastic for this
is exactly what you need to activate
your physiology and then once you are
absolutely wiped and absolutely
exhausted you will then deactivate your
physiology. So you'll kind of have this
energetic crash which is exactly what we
want. We want an energy spike and an
energy crash instead of this chronic
level of stress where we're sort of
trying to focus all day but it's never
really working. Okay, so this is really
challenging because if you have
cognitive disengagement syndrome,
there's a really good chance that
physical exercise will feel incredibly
hard to you. But that's actually what
you need. The next thing that we want to
talk about is sort of this weird
energetic stuff. So when I work with
with people who, you know, have
cognitive disengagement syndrome,
they're referred by psychiatrists.
Treatments don't seem to be working very
well. So I I kind of look at them and I
look at their sluggishness and I say,
"Okay, your chi or your prana, your
vital life energy appears to be
sluggishly moving." So there's like some
limited evidence of this stuff, but I've
seen a large clinical benefit. This is
the work that I was doing at Harvard. I
was trying to develop energy- based
protocols, Bronnam and Chiang protocols
for particular mental illnesses and was
developing those protocols, was studying
them, but then I started doing this.
Okay, so this is where there are a
couple of practices, revitalizing
practices, energetic practices. Um, yoga
and taichi tend to work really well. So,
what I would recommend is like you wake
up, you know, around dawn, you're going
to feel like crap. Do whatever amount of
exercise you can manage for about 20 to
30 minutes. You know, you can go through
your morning routine and then maybe in
the evening or in the morning if you can
swing it doing 20 to 30 minutes of yoga
or ta chi and then 20 to 30 minutes of
pranayam or chiong. I'll share with
y'all a key pranayam that I teach to
people who have problems with their
energy levels and that is called
bastrika pranayam. So bustria pranayam
is bellows breath. Okay. And so what we
want to do is breathe like a set of
bellows at a blacksmith. So we want
strong rapid inhalations with
contraction of the diaphragm followed by
strong rapid exhalations with the
diaphragm pushing the air out. Okay? So
I want you all to kind of focus on your
stomach and when we inhale we're going
to push our stomach out. And when we
exhale I want you to imagine your naval
your belly button contracting towards
your spine. Okay? And then we want to
breathe in such a way through our nose
ideally where it makes a sound. So pasta
kind of goes like this. [snorts]
[snorts]
[snorts]
[cough and laughter]
Uh one cycle is about 10 rounds of
breath. And what you really want to do
is like rapid cycles, right? So I'm
feeling a little bit dizzy. I'm feeling
a little bit activated. I'm feeling a
little bit lightheaded. Which is exactly
what we want to do. So you can do brown
fast rapid inhalation [snorts]
and not without without moving the
shoulders
and like pull yank the air in and throw
the air out. And you can do something as
simple as three rounds of 10 breaths
each along with your yogic practice. And
that will sort of energize and
revitalize you. So, when it comes to
cognitive disengagement syndrome, if
you're someone who feels like you're a
neurode divergent doomer, key thing is
to balance your energy levels. Allow
yourself to rest when it's time to rest
and allow yourself to wake up when it's
time to wake up. Now, this is going to
feel absolutely like an uphill climb,
right? But any situation where we are
deconditioned, if I haven't exercised
for 5 years and I start jogging, it's
going to feel terrible. But that is the
process of your brain and your body
reconditioning. And as always when it
comes to diagnosis, really good idea to
work with a professional. If you guys
want more resources on structured
meditation practices or things like
executive function, goal setting,
sustaining your attention, check out Dr.
K's guide.
[music]
You know,
the
>> [music]
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video explores Cognitive Disengagement Syndrome (formerly known as Sluggish Cognitive Tempo), a condition often misdiagnosed as ADHD. While both manifest as difficulties in task completion and focus, the underlying mechanisms are opposite: ADHD involves external hyper-distractibility, whereas Cognitive Disengagement Syndrome is characterized by internal, mental drift (daydreaming), hypoactivity, and mental confusion. The speaker explains that because the root cause is a hypoactive mind rather than a hyperactive one, standard ADHD treatments like stimulants may yield suboptimal results. He suggests a holistic approach focusing on restoring healthy cortisol rhythms through proper sleep hygiene, early morning high-intensity aerobic exercise, and specific energetic practices like Bhastrika Pranayama to activate the body and mind.
Videos recently processed by our community