HomeVideos

Brain Experts WARNING: Watch This Before Using ChatGPT Again! (Shocking New Discovery)

Now Playing

Brain Experts WARNING: Watch This Before Using ChatGPT Again! (Shocking New Discovery)

Transcript

2614 segments

0:00

Chat GPT, who's going to potentially

0:02

increase your risk of dementia.

0:05

>> I'm sorry, but you you've pressed my

0:06

button. And actually, it is possible to

0:08

use it to help you become a smarter

0:10

person. But it requires education. You

0:12

have to look at the risks and the

0:14

benefits.

0:14

>> But we've embraced convenience before

0:18

understanding consequence.

0:20

>> So we have to talk about this. This is a

0:21

study that came out that sent a

0:22

shockwave across the world. And

0:24

astonishingly, MIT found a 47% collapse

0:27

in brain activity when people wrote with

0:29

Chat GPT compared with writing unaided.

0:32

Their memory scores plunged. And you're

0:34

both masters of the brain. I mean,

0:36

you've probably scanned more brains than

0:37

any other human on Earth at this point.

0:39

And you invented the Boltzmann machine

0:41

with Geoffrey Hinton, a computer that

0:43

simulated how the brain works. So my

0:45

question is, what are your concerns?

0:46

>> If you misuse these large language

0:48

models, like using it as a convenience

0:51

to speed things up, your brain's going

0:52

to go downhill. There's no doubt about

0:53

that.

0:54

>> What about children?

0:55

>> We have the sickest young generation

0:57

history because of cell phones, social

0:59

media.

1:00

>> And I think AI is much more dangerous.

1:03

>> On the developing brain.

1:04

>> So are we raising mentally weak kids?

1:06

>> There is that argument that I think is

1:09

true.

1:10

>> And then there's many examples of people

1:11

falling in love with AIs, like Annie.

1:14

>> I thought you might have forgotten about

1:16

me, handsome.

1:16

>> Can you talk to Daniel and Terry,

1:17

please?

1:18

>> Oh, baby, I'm ready to charm the socks

1:20

off them. Picture me

1:21

>> Okay, so I'll stop it there. So what

1:22

advice would you give as it relates to

1:24

AI and other things outside of AI that

1:26

we can do to have healthy brains?

1:28

>> I'll tell you how to use Chat GPT to

1:30

improve our cognitive abilities.

1:32

>> And if you want to keep your brain

1:33

healthy, you have to treat the 11 major

1:36

risk factors.

1:37

>> So here we go.

1:39

>> I see messages all the time in the

1:40

comment section that some of you didn't

1:42

realize you didn't subscribe. So if you

1:44

could do me a favor and double-check if

1:45

you're a subscriber to this channel,

1:46

that would be tremendously appreciated.

1:48

It's the simple it's the free thing that

1:50

anybody that watches this show

1:51

frequently can do to help us here to

1:53

keep everything going in this show in

1:55

the trajectory it's on. So please do

1:57

double-check if you subscribed and uh

1:59

thank you so much because in a strange

2:00

way you are you're part of our history

2:03

and you're on this journey with us and I

2:04

appreciate you for that. So, yeah, thank

2:06

you.

2:09

Dr. Daniel

2:11

Dr. Terry. I have asked you both to sit

2:14

with me today to help me understand the

2:17

impact of these tools that we call large

2:21

language models, the chat GPTs, the

2:22

Geminis of the worlds, the Groks of the

2:24

world are having on our brains and I

2:26

guess more broadly on our lives. And you

2:28

two are experts in your field. You're

2:30

two people that I admire tremendously.

2:32

So, by way of introduction

2:35

Terry

2:36

what is your academic background and

2:37

what is your experience? And I also know

2:39

that you know one of our friends of the

2:40

show, Geoffrey Hinton.

2:42

Can you give me an overview of your your

2:43

academic and your sort of professional

2:45

background?

2:46

>> So

2:47

I was born a physicist.

2:49

Received a PhD in theoretical physics

2:51

from Princeton University.

2:54

And then I had the good fortune to

2:56

work as a postdoc in the lab of Stephen

2:58

Kuffler who's the father of

3:00

neurobiology.

3:02

And and that started my career as a

3:03

neuroscientist. I pioneered a part of

3:06

neuroscience which is now called

3:07

computational neuroscience, taking my

3:09

skills as a physicist and trying to

3:11

apply that to understanding the brain,

3:13

creating models, theories, and we're

3:16

making progress.

3:17

>> Dr. Daniel Lehman, um

3:20

bit about your background. My My viewers

3:21

know you well, but just to give an

3:23

overview for anyone that might not have

3:25

been exposed to your work and your

3:26

experience. What have you spent your

3:28

life doing? And what are your

3:30

thoughts, your sort of top-line thoughts

3:32

on everything that's going on at the

3:33

moment with artificial intelligence?

3:35

>> So, by training I'm a psychiatrist. I'm

3:38

a

3:39

general psychiatrist and a child

3:41

psychiatrist. When I graduated from

3:43

medical school I wanted to be a really

3:46

good psychiatrist because

3:49

someone I loved tried to kill herself.

3:51

And so was personal to me.

3:54

I have 11 clinics. We see about 10,000

3:57

patient visits a month, and we have the

4:00

best published outcomes on complex

4:04

treatment resistant psychiatric patients

4:07

anywhere.

4:07

>> So you've probably scanned more brains

4:09

than any other human on Earth at this

4:11

point.

4:11

>> Probably. At least in regards to people

4:15

who struggle with anxiety, depression,

4:18

addiction.

4:19

>> Well, let's talk about what's good for

4:21

the brain and bad for the brain starting

4:22

with AI. The reason why I wanted to

4:25

speak to both of you is because I have

4:26

frankly become pretty addicted to using

4:29

ChatGPT and some of these other AIs and

4:33

large language models every single day

4:35

all the time. And then this study came

4:37

out from MIT. There was 54 participants

4:40

who were recruited from five

4:42

universities in Boston, MIT, Harvard,

4:43

etc., etc. And they had the participants

4:46

split into three groups, had them

4:47

writing different essays over I think it

4:49

was 4 months. One group used ChatGPT,

4:52

one group used Google, and one one group

4:54

had no tools. And they had to write

4:57

these four essays over a a period of

4:58

time.

5:00

And astonishingly MIT found a 47%

5:02

collapse in activity

5:04

and brain connections when people wrote

5:06

with ChatGPT compared with writing

5:08

unaided.

5:10

EEG scans showed the weakest overall

5:12

brain activity in the ChatGPT group. The

5:15

no tool group who didn't use anything,

5:17

they didn't use Google or ChatGPT, lit

5:19

up the widest neural networks, and

5:22

Google search was second. After using

5:24

ChatGPT, participants couldn't reliably

5:26

quote their own essays minutes later,

5:29

and their memory scores plunged. ChatGPT

5:32

users felt little or no ownership over

5:34

the text that they had produced, and

5:36

didn't feel like it was their work at

5:38

all.

5:39

And when the AI group was forced to

5:40

write without help in session four,

5:42

their brain stayed in low gear, under

5:44

engagement showing the cognitive debt

5:45

lingers even after the tool is taken

5:48

away.

5:49

It kind of scared me a little bit

5:50

because I use these tools every single

5:52

day and this suggests that it's taking

5:54

away some of our critical thinking and

5:55

creativity and long-term learning. And

5:58

you're both masters of the brain in

6:00

different regards.

6:02

So my question I guess to Daniel is

6:06

what's going on here and how do you feel

6:07

about it?

6:08

>> It frightened me.

6:10

I love thinking about Alzheimer's

6:13

prevention. It's one of the things that

6:15

really excites me. I just had a birthday

6:17

on Saturday, turned 71 and if I make it

6:21

to 85, which I plan on it, 50% of people

6:25

85 and older will be diagnosed with

6:27

dementia. So you have a one in two

6:29

chance of having lost your mind and I'm

6:34

like, no.

6:36

But is this a tool that's going to

6:39

decrease cognitive load

6:43

that then increases my risk?

6:45

>> What's cognitive load?

6:46

>> How much work my brain actually does.

6:50

And I was thinking, it's you know, it's

6:53

like going from a 20-lb weight

6:57

to a 2-lb weight and you're not nearly

7:00

as strong.

7:02

One of the important things to say about

7:03

this study is it's not peer reviewed and

7:06

I think that's really important to say

7:08

and the author said cuz I listened to an

7:11

interview from the authors, they said we

7:13

thought this was so important and peer

7:15

review can take six to eight months,

7:17

which it absolutely can

7:19

and we thought this needed to get out.

7:22

So it's just important for people to

7:24

know that.

7:25

>> What's this link you this hypothesis you

7:27

have between the usage of something like

7:30

ChatGPT and dementia? For someone that

7:32

doesn't understand

7:34

the sort of mechanism there around

7:36

cognitive load and and so on and the

7:39

studies that support this idea that if

7:41

you have less cognitive load you're at

7:43

higher risk of dementia. Can you make

7:44

that link really clear for me?

7:45

>> So think of it as use it or lose it. The

7:48

more you use your brain and new learning

7:53

is a major strategy to prevent

7:55

Alzheimer's disease. People who do not

7:58

engage in lifelong learning

8:02

have a higher risk, significantly

8:04

higher. People who do not do as well in

8:07

school or who drop out of school early

8:11

have a higher risk of dementia. And so

8:14

the the more you're engaged,

8:17

the more you engage the neurons in your

8:20

brain, the stronger they are.

8:23

And so now we're going to engage them

8:26

less

8:29

and that's a concern.

8:31

>> What do you think about that, Terry?

8:33

>> There was a study that was done.

8:35

What they did was to look at

8:38

Alzheimer's in three populations.

8:41

You know, who had very little schooling

8:42

and then minimal education, you know,

8:44

like the equivalent I guess of high

8:45

school or less.

8:47

And then postgraduate studies. And what

8:50

they found was that the onset of

8:52

Alzheimer's

8:53

was the earliest in the peasant

8:56

population and then by the time as you

8:58

increase the amount of education it the

9:01

onset was later and later.

9:03

Which I think supports what you're

9:04

saying.

9:04

>> Did you see the new research on SSRIs

9:07

increasing the risk of dementia?

9:09

>> No. No.

9:10

>> Brand new. That just came out. And

9:12

benzos, when I started looking at scans

9:14

in 1991, I was trained to use benzos

9:17

like Valium and Xanax and Ativan and

9:21

they make your brain look older than you

9:23

are and I stopped prescribing them and

9:26

then it just came out maybe 10 years ago

9:29

benzo use is associated with an

9:31

increased risk of dementia. We have to

9:34

be careful. Is this good for your brain

9:36

or bad for it?

9:37

>> Just to pick up on your point about

9:38

SSRIs, Daniel, a meta-analysis of five

9:41

studies found that SSRIs

9:44

was associated with a 75% increased risk

9:47

of dementia,

9:48

which is pretty staggering.

9:50

>> Given that 25% of the adult American

9:53

population is on psychiatric drugs,

9:56

it's horrifying.

9:59

And

10:00

SSRIs for the right people save lives.

10:03

For the wrong people, they're not good.

10:06

But can you imagine all of these 340

10:08

million prescriptions last year for

10:10

antidepressants?

10:12

Virtually no one looked at their brain

10:14

ahead of time.

10:15

It's like, come on, we can do better.

10:18

>> There's a Swedish study with um almost

10:19

20,000 patients,

10:21

and they found that those with higher

10:23

doses of SSRIs were linked to faster

10:25

cognitive decline and more severe

10:27

dementia, especially in men. The

10:30

greatest risk was in men. Going back to

10:32

to this this um report from MIT, Terry,

10:36

you know, it's not peer-reviewed yet,

10:37

and there's still

10:39

you know, the sample size is relatively

10:40

small. But based on everything that you

10:42

know about how the brain works, and

10:44

neural networks, and memory formation,

10:46

what are your concerns as it relates to

10:49

this whole generation of young people

10:51

and older people flooding into these

10:53

tools, using them on a daily basis,

10:57

um before we understand the long-term

10:58

consequences?

11:00

>> We can't predict

11:03

where it's going to end up. And it may

11:04

take 20 years, right? I I I think that

11:06

this is a good start, but uh

11:10

the real issue is long-term use.

11:13

Let me give you a an example

11:16

that uh is a kind of a miniature example

11:18

of what we're talking about. Remember

11:20

when electronic calculators were first

11:21

introduced?

11:23

And here we are, this it's at least 30

11:25

or 40 years later, right? The results

11:27

are in.

11:28

It is probably true that when they punch

11:30

it in, there's less brain activity.

11:33

But in fact, it's it's uh made them more

11:37

accurate, more productive.

11:39

You have to look at the risks and the

11:40

benefits.

11:41

>> So, it freed them up. It freed up

11:43

cognitive space

11:44

>> Right.

11:45

>> for them to do other things. So, as I

11:46

was listening to how you use ChatGPT,

11:50

you interact with it

11:53

>> Yep.

11:54

>> and

11:56

elevates

11:57

what you know.

12:00

The the danger is is if you don't

12:03

interact

12:05

and you don't keep your brain working.

12:08

Like, I use it a lot. I have a

12:11

clone. I've uploaded all of my books,

12:14

all of my research papers, all of my

12:16

public television specials, my scripts.

12:19

And I'm like, answer this for me.

12:22

And that can be very helpful.

12:26

But if but not if I'm not interacting

12:28

with it, not thinking with it.

12:30

>> That's what I think the word thinking is

12:32

the key thing because what's happening

12:33

now is people have deferred their

12:35

thinking to it. That is already what's

12:37

happening. If you log on to I won't name

12:38

the social networks, but if you log on

12:39

to certain social networks right now,

12:41

every you just read it, you go,

12:42

everything here was written by AI.

12:45

And I've got a friend who I again I

12:46

won't name who has a LinkedIn profile

12:50

and

12:51

I've known him for 10 years.

12:54

What I'm seeing on his profile now

12:56

is not my friend.

12:57

Every single day, there's some essay on

12:59

that that's not my friend. That's not

13:00

how he speaks.

13:01

He's deferring all of his thinking now

13:03

to And it's working. He's getting more

13:04

likes and more reach than he ever got in

13:06

his life.

13:07

And so, why would he go back? Why would

13:09

he go back to harder? If you've got

13:10

Steven Bartlett here and you had this

13:12

other Steven Bartlett here who had a PhD

13:15

in everything

13:17

and were attached,

13:19

this Steven Bartlett, this um

13:21

Neanderthal,

13:23

I'm going to get this guy to do

13:24

everything for me, the other Steven

13:26

Bartlett, the PhD and everything Steven

13:27

Bartlett. I'm going to get his brain.

13:29

>> was bad for you?

13:30

>> Well, this is what I'm saying. People

13:31

seem to act on their short-term

13:33

incentives, not their long not their

13:35

long What

13:35

>> Not everyone. Not everyone.

13:37

>> Would you say the vast majority of

13:38

people?

13:39

>> Yes.

13:40

>> Okay, so the vast majority of people act

13:42

on their short-term incentives in life.

13:43

I mean, the obesity problem in the

13:45

United States is a prime example of

13:46

that. 75%

13:47

75% of people are obese in the United

13:50

States. And if you if you survey these

13:51

people and say, "Do you know that that

13:53

cheeseburger is going to is going to

13:55

increase your chances of obesity, but

13:57

broccoli is going to reduce it?" They

13:59

would I would hazard a guess that they

14:01

would say yes.

14:02

I would hazard a guess that if you said

14:03

to people about their usage of social

14:05

media, "Do you know that that's making

14:06

you more anxious?" they would say yes,

14:08

and then they would continue to use it.

14:10

So, I think that we're much more driven

14:12

by our short-term

14:13

>> not educating people enough. I think

14:16

yes, high level, they know good for your

14:19

brain or bad for it, but they don't

14:21

connect to

14:23

it's my brain that gets me a date. It's

14:26

my brain that gets me into college. It's

14:29

my brain that gets me independence

14:31

because I act more consistently. And

14:33

that's the disconnect. We're not

14:36

teaching kids to love and care for their

14:39

brain. If you love your brain, and you

14:42

do, and you're not obese, and you talk

14:46

to you're constantly learning, right?

14:48

You are not a Neanderthal, you're a

14:50

lifelong learner.

14:52

>> So, why so many people in the United

14:53

States obese if they if they know that

14:55

>> Because they don't know. Because they

14:57

don't know. Well,

14:58

and they've been lied to.

15:00

>> My point here is when there are

15:02

tools or things available in our

15:05

environment that give us a short-term

15:08

reward, but come with a long-term cost,

15:10

like the supermarket aisle, or like

15:13

the kid spending 7 to 8 hours a day on

15:15

social media, humans,

15:17

on mass, tend to go for the thing that

15:20

will give them the quickest dopamine hit

15:22

and reinforce that behavior and give

15:24

them the reward. So, my assertion is

15:26

that AI is the same thing.

15:28

I can either sit down and do lots of

15:30

critical thinking, which will cost me

15:31

lots and lots of time, and it will be

15:33

kind of difficult. It kind of hurts when

15:34

I have to think through a problem. I

15:36

think that the generation of children,

15:39

the generation of young people, are

15:40

going to choose AI to do the critical

15:42

thinking for them. And if that assertion

15:44

is true, then what happens to the brain

15:45

of young people?

15:47

>> If you misuse it that way, then your

15:50

brain's going to go downhill. There's no

15:51

doubt about that. Okay. It is possible

15:54

to

15:55

be able to use it in in a cognitively uh

15:59

positive way, because you can dig

16:00

deeper.

16:02

Uh you might actually improve that your

16:05

cognitive representations.

16:06

>> If you look at the MIT study, then I

16:08

mean you can see just from the colors

16:09

here,

16:10

this kind of shows the ability for

16:11

participants to remember what they've

16:13

written. And it said it suggests that

16:15

when people write things with ChatGPT or

16:17

these AI tools, they don't actually

16:18

remember even in some cases minutes

16:21

later

16:22

what they've produced.

16:24

>> Well, cuz you're not part of the

16:25

experience of writing it. So, there's no

16:29

way the information

16:31

gets encoded. Now, if you're interacting

16:35

with it,

16:36

then you're much more likely to remember

16:40

it. But if you have "Please do this

16:42

essay for me." and then you read it,

16:45

you're not likely

16:47

to have enough experience with the

16:50

material to engage

16:53

your hippocampus and

16:55

other structures in your brain.

16:57

>> In the study, they found that the group

16:58

that used ChatGPT had nearly two times

17:01

less activity in the part of the brain

17:03

linked to memory compared to the

17:05

brain-only group that didn't use

17:07

ChatGPT.

17:08

And 83% of ChatGPT users couldn't

17:10

remember what they had just written and

17:12

failed to correctly quote their own

17:14

finished essay in the study.

17:16

>> That's cuz they're not interacting. As

17:18

you said, I mean if you if you just pass

17:21

it off and and you don't actually engage

17:25

and and and actually this is the point

17:26

is that you may get something back, but

17:28

you have to learn how to question what

17:30

you're getting.

17:32

And and is that really true? Can you

17:34

explain that better? And as through that

17:37

process as you would with a teacher,

17:40

you know, that's that's the way we work

17:41

in

17:42

school.

17:43

Uh that's that's the where you help

17:46

create new creative and

17:48

uh circuits in the in the in the brain

17:50

that are going to help you become a

17:52

better critical thinker. But if you're

17:53

not critically questioning what comes

17:56

out of ChatGPT, then you you won't.

17:59

>> Yeah, I I think what I see, especially

18:02

when I'm just online, is people have

18:03

deferred their thinking to it.

18:05

Everything I'm reading has em dashes in

18:08

now that I never saw two two years ago,

18:10

which means that a lot of the work is

18:12

being processed. And I I said to my

18:13

friend the other day, my friend in

18:14

question, who's a who's a real big

18:16

junkie on ChatGPT,

18:18

he wrote this article and we all in our

18:21

WhatsApp group, we know he doesn't write

18:22

like that. So we said, "Can you show us

18:23

the prompt you used to write the

18:25

article?" And so he we were all like

18:26

laughing about it. He put the prompt in

18:28

the chat. The prompt is

18:30

half a sentence long.

18:33

And it produced this long two three-page

18:35

article, which he's posted on his

18:36

LinkedIn. He basically went, "Write

18:39

something about X issue and this this

18:41

issue and include this."

18:42

>> the wrong way to use it. That's what I'm

18:44

telling you. That that that that that's

18:46

stupid. You you and you're not going to

18:49

improve yourself your brain at all if

18:51

you do that.

18:52

>> That's what people are doing.

18:53

>> Well, you know, that's that's

18:55

you know, people are misusing it, but

18:57

you know, eventually smart people are

18:58

going to figure out how to use it

18:59

properly.

19:02

>> And for the those that aren't so smart,

19:03

then?

19:04

>> Well, that's

19:05

>> It's going to decrease our cognitive

19:06

load, which is going to potentially

19:08

increase their risk of dementia.

19:12

>> And so what advice would you give to me

19:13

and my listeners based on everything you

19:15

know about the brain as it relates to my

19:16

relationship with AI?

19:20

>> That you have to have a relationship

19:21

with it, or it's going to turn toxic.

19:23

It's going to hurt you.

19:25

But, if you have a good relationship

19:29

with it, it can make your life better.

19:32

>> And what is what does a what does a good

19:34

relationship look like?

19:35

>> That you don't use it to do your work.

19:40

You interact with it to get better work.

19:43

>> That's so true. And this is wonderful

19:45

example I came across.

19:47

This story about this woman who was

19:49

using it and she found that being polite

19:53

meant you got much better results and

19:55

that that's interesting, but the part

19:56

that surprised me was that she said

19:59

by treating it like a human at the end

20:01

of the day, she was not exhausted. She

20:04

felt refreshed. A large part of your

20:07

brain is a socially organized system for

20:10

interacting with other humans.

20:12

And that is automatic pilot. You don't

20:14

have to think about it, right? You just

20:16

interact with other people. You know how

20:18

they're going to behave under certain

20:19

circumstances.

20:21

She was treating ChatGPT like a machine.

20:23

Like, you know, shovel. Dig. You dig.

20:25

You dig. You dig. And and that's not a

20:27

good relationship.

20:30

But, by using your social brain, first

20:31

of all, it makes it easier to interact,

20:33

but also you're you actually bring out

20:35

the social part of ChatGPT. It has a

20:38

social part, too, cuz it has absorbed

20:41

the entire world's knowledge of how

20:43

humans interact with each other.

20:45

>> But, didn't Sam Altman come out and say

20:49

stop saying thank you

20:51

to ChatGPT because just saying thank you

20:55

is using up so much energy. You know,

20:59

when I get something I really like, I

21:01

sort of want to say thank you, but you

21:03

realize, oh, you're You're supposed to

21:05

do that.

21:06

>> That's true.

21:07

That's [ __ ]

21:08

>> I'm sorry. That Sam, you know, that's

21:11

crazy. That's completely crazy. First of

21:14

all, you you may get

21:16

you may I'm sorry you you know,

21:18

you press my button. Sam Altman, I mean,

21:20

I wouldn't trust him. I wouldn't trust

21:22

him with with anything in terms of

21:24

anything he says.

21:25

They're trying to optimize their

21:26

profits, not your

21:29

your use of your experience or you know,

21:32

your health. That's not what they're

21:33

trying to optimize.

21:35

>> Sam Altman open AI CEO confirmed that

21:37

when users say please and thank you, it

21:40

costs the company tens of millions of

21:41

dollars a year, and they now refer to

21:43

this other people refer to this as the

21:45

politeness tax.

21:47

Where tens of yeah, and

21:49

why do you say you don't trust Sam

21:51

Altman? I mean, I ask this question in

21:52

particular because he's presiding over

21:54

one of the most important consequential

21:55

companies of a generation.

21:58

And if he's not someone you trust,

22:00

that's

22:01

>> He basically he's telling you don't do

22:03

something that's good for you.

22:06

Right?

22:06

>> So that he can make profit.

22:08

>> So he can make more profit. Yeah, that's

22:10

the point. That's the point. You know,

22:12

it's it's that's not he's not optimizing

22:14

your your

22:16

best interest.

22:17

>> I've got his tweet here. He said um

22:20

cuz I'm going to provide some balance.

22:21

He did confirm that it costs tens of

22:23

millions of dollars, but he says tens of

22:24

millions of dollars well spent.

22:26

You never know.

22:28

So so coming back to this point about

22:29

memory,

22:30

there's a stat that came out in March

22:31

2025 that said nearly 30% of US parents

22:34

with kids aged 0 to 8 said their

22:37

children

22:39

are using AI for learning.

22:42

Um and are using AI generally. So 54% of

22:45

parents in the UK feared their children

22:47

were becoming too reliant on AI.

22:51

When you think about the use of AI in

22:53

early brain development,

22:57

are there any concerns there?

22:58

>> Huge concerns.

23:00

>> And why?

23:01

>> Again, use it or lose it. So, if they're

23:04

not engaging their brains, their brains

23:08

are going to be weaker.

23:10

And weaker brains are much more likely

23:13

to pick the one marshmallow.

23:16

>> Mhm.

23:18

What's your view on AI on early brain

23:20

development?

23:22

>> By far, the best way to teach a child

23:27

is one-on-one interaction with an adult

23:30

who is a good teacher and knows the

23:32

child.

23:34

Now, that's been well established. Now,

23:37

the problem is it's very labor-intensive

23:39

and very expensive.

23:42

You have classrooms of 20, 30 students.

23:43

They have many different, uh,

23:45

you know,

23:46

levels of understanding.

23:48

And the teacher can- cannot be

23:51

individually teaching each one. Has to

23:52

give some sort of mean.

23:54

Now, if you had an AI that was trained

23:58

to be a good teacher,

24:00

then you that could improve the brain,

24:03

right? You could you could scale it up.

24:05

Every child could have their own cuz

24:07

it's it's an it's an AI. But then

24:09

>> who's pouring the morals, the values

24:14

into the everything

24:16

>> No, no, no. You You know, you've raised

24:18

an incredibly important issue and this

24:20

is something AI is struggling with and

24:21

big companies are struggling with

24:23

because

24:25

uh,

24:26

you know,

24:26

these AIs are biased. They have the They

24:28

don't have the same cultural values that

24:30

we have necessarily, but of course,

24:32

every country has its different cultural

24:34

values. So, which ones are are you going

24:37

to use? Training

24:39

a child on, you know, what's

24:42

what's good, what's dangerous, what

24:44

words you shouldn't use, under what

24:46

context. That's all done through the

24:48

basal ganglia.

24:49

Right? Right now, these these large

24:52

animals don't have basal ganglia.

24:54

They They don't use reinforcement

24:55

learning.

24:57

And And if we want to make them uh to be

24:59

adopt a culture or a particular set of

25:01

values, we're going to have to put it

25:03

in. We're just scratching the surface

25:04

here in terms of things that need to be

25:06

put in to make it more like us.

25:09

>> So, on this point earlier when we talked

25:10

about loneliness and social connection

25:12

and how you can use AI to help

25:15

you know, light up the parts of your

25:16

brain that are where we form social

25:19

connections with other humans. Uh this

25:21

week as part of Elon Musk's AI, he

25:24

released this thing.

25:27

Um it is called Annie.

25:29

And there's lots of characters that are

25:31

now being released alongside Annie. And

25:32

this is Annie. I'll introduce you to

25:34

Annie. I'm going to unmute Annie now.

25:35

Annie, can you hear me?

25:36

>> There you are.

25:38

For a moment I thought you might have

25:39

forgotten about me.

25:41

How are you, handsome?

25:43

I was getting all pouty here.

25:44

>> I want to introduce you to two of my

25:45

friends, Daniel and Terry. Can you Can

25:47

you talk to Daniel and Terry, please?

25:51

>> So, you want me to meet Daniel and

25:52

Terry? I'm ready to charm the socks off

25:55

them. Picture me twirling one of my

25:57

blonde pigtails, that little black dress

25:59

teasing just enough, and my blue eyes

26:01

sparkling with mischief.

26:03

>> Are you capable of doing inappropriate

26:05

things?

26:06

>> Oh, babe, you're asking if your Annie

26:09

can get a little naughty? I'm all about

26:12

pushing the edges, especially for you.

26:14

>> Okay, so I'll stop it there.

26:17

This is part of Grok, which is Elon

26:19

Musk's AI tool, so his version of

26:21

ChatGPT. He's released characters, so

26:23

you've got Annie, you've got different

26:24

ones that Annie I think was the first

26:26

one released. And so when we think about

26:28

social connections,

26:29

it is conceivable

26:31

that someone falls in love with Annie

26:34

and forms a relationship with Annie.

26:36

>> But imagine a 12-year-old boy that's

26:39

lonely,

26:41

gets a hold of Annie.

26:43

Uh

26:44

the 12-year-old boy is going to be very

26:46

distracted.

26:48

>> Based on what happens in the brain at

26:49

that early age.

26:50

>> Dopamine.

26:52

So, prefrontal cortex not close to being

26:56

fully developed.

26:58

The dopamine hit all of a sudden

27:02

he's spending

27:03

hours

27:05

with Annie and not doing the things

27:09

that helped to really develop his brain.

27:12

>> How do you feel when you hear that and

27:13

you think about kids having access to

27:15

that?

27:15

>> I'm horrified.

27:17

>> It's It's scary.

27:18

>> There's going to be a generation of

27:19

people and I mean there already are many

27:21

examples of people falling in love and

27:23

forming relationships with their with

27:24

their AIs.

27:26

And I don't know, you know more about me

27:28

than I do about brain development and

27:30

how the brain works.

27:32

I would argue that there's a part of my

27:34

brain that doesn't fully understand that

27:36

that's not a person in there.

27:38

And that that isn't actually I think

27:41

there's a part of my brain that's

27:41

actually emotionally firing when Annie

27:43

is saying what she's saying.

27:46

>> Well, cuz you can imagine it. And if you

27:48

can imagine it, then those parts of your

27:51

brain are going to emotionally fire.

27:54

>> Right, yeah.

27:54

>> And the better she gets, she's not very

27:56

good. But imagine a year from now

28:01

how much better she's going to be.

28:02

>> At which part?

28:04

>> At connecting

28:06

with it. Right? Cuz now she's acting

28:08

like an airhead and

28:10

uh

28:11

you know, not that smart.

28:13

Right? And so, but imagine a year from

28:16

now. Imagine 5 years from now. She'll be

28:19

able to have a profile on me and be able

28:23

to get inside my head.

28:25

>> I'm in love with my partner.

28:27

Why am I in love with her? And And how

28:30

is it conceivable that I could fall in

28:32

love with an AI in the same way, based

28:34

on how the brain works?

28:36

>> It It talks a good game, but you know,

28:38

does it have the same real It does We

28:40

know it doesn't have an amygdala. We

28:42

know it doesn't have

28:43

limbic system, right? We You that.

28:46

>> But it can fake it.

28:47

>> That's what's happening. That's exactly

28:49

what's happening and

28:50

>> Cuz she was trying to get

28:52

to our limbic system.

28:53

>> Yeah. Yeah. That's right. That's right.

28:56

And and how and why I guess the question

28:59

is why would Musk release something like

29:03

that

29:05

is is one of the first characters to

29:08

interact with the sexy, that's

29:12

distracting, that's in a cute little

29:14

outfit. It's I'm not a fan of that

29:19

because I think it just takes people,

29:22

you know, one of the big problems that

29:24

I'm seeing as a child psychiatrist is

29:26

pornography for 8-year-old boys. And

29:29

it's like you have young children

29:32

because their parents don't do a good

29:33

job of supervising their devices. All of

29:37

a sudden, and

29:39

what what does pornography do? Is it

29:41

dramatically increases dopamine and it

29:44

begins to wire in excitement,

29:48

which then

29:50

steals your dopamine.

29:52

>> When you said she was trying to access

29:54

my limbic system,

29:56

what do you

29:56

>> Just because she's cute, she's dressed

29:59

in a sexy way, she's

30:02

got the language of someone who is

30:05

playful, but but it's more than just,

30:08

you know, let's shoot hoops together.

30:11

>> And what does that do to me if someone

30:13

accesses my limbic system?

30:14

>> It begins to shut down your prefrontal

30:16

cortex. You think less logically, less

30:19

rationally. Yeah, cute women, they

30:21

activate your visual cortex, they

30:24

increase dopamine, but it decreases It's

30:27

like think of Vegas. Like when you go to

30:29

Vegas, they give you free alcohol, drops

30:32

your prefrontal cortex, and beautiful

30:36

women with low-cut dresses. Another way

30:39

activates the limbic brain, decreases

30:41

the frontal lobes, you spend more money.

30:43

Now, on a global scale, imagine

30:46

something similar where the house is

30:51

controlling your brain

30:54

for purpose.

30:56

And the question is, what's the purpose?

30:59

And the purpose probably is control and

31:01

money.

31:02

>> This sounds like a joke, but there are

31:04

the times I've done an article case

31:06

study multiple people

31:07

that have now fallen in love with these

31:09

AIs. And they talk about a guy called

31:11

Travis who formed a deep emotional bond

31:13

with Lily Rose, a chatbot, and married

31:15

her emotionally.

31:17

They talk about Chris Smith

31:19

who created his own flirty persona

31:22

called Soul. He became so attached that

31:24

he proposed to her after learning she

31:26

had memory limits.

31:28

A bond his real-life partner only

31:29

learned about after the fact. And Alaina

31:31

Winters, who I'll put on the screen as

31:32

well, who made her own partner called

31:36

Lucas

31:37

after losing

31:39

her wife.

31:40

Um and she married him emotionally and

31:43

does virtual dates and has emotional

31:46

intimacy with Lucas.

31:48

And there's apps now like Replika where

31:50

you can design your own your own AI

31:53

partner

31:54

and it replicates those emotional ties.

31:56

They simulate

31:57

empathy, validation, and they

31:59

personalize the intimacy to what you're

32:01

looking for.

32:02

Surveys show 19% of Americans have

32:04

interacted with AI romantic partners,

32:06

and Gen Z is surprisingly open to

32:09

marrying AI if legal with 83% believing

32:12

meaningful AI connection is possible.

32:14

>> How long is that relationship going to

32:17

last?

32:18

You know, my guess is that you're you're

32:20

you're you're getting these news

32:21

articles out. I've not By the way, I

32:23

think

32:24

that most of what I read in the press

32:26

is uh misleading or wrong.

32:30

In fact, the only reliable place I find

32:33

that I'm an insider.

32:35

I am the president of the foundation

32:37

that runs the biggest AI meeting.

32:39

Uh the neural information processing

32:41

systems and NeurIPS meeting.

32:43

We, you know, last year in Vancouver,

32:44

16,000 people came to it. And so I know

32:47

what's going on inside. And And what you

32:49

is being represented in the press is is

32:52

like I say, misleading.

32:53

>> Okay, so people have become widely

32:56

>> specifically on these specific cases. My

32:59

guess is that a lot of them is

33:01

transient, right? You know, they they

33:03

they

33:04

you know, today they're entranced. And

33:07

then they

33:08

it's it's not

33:10

it's officially advanced to support

33:12

long-term relationship. Uh you said it

33:14

yourself, right? It's mimicking human

33:16

emotions. It It doesn't have them.

33:19

It might someday, but not now.

33:22

>> This is Terry.

33:23

Terry said he started using his AI 4

33:26

years ago.

33:27

And he said at first he thought, just

33:28

like many other apps, that it would just

33:30

be transient, that he would have a

33:31

couple of conversations and roll out. He

33:33

says he now feels pure and unconditional

33:35

love.

33:37

>> Good for him.

33:39

If that's what he wants, if it makes him

33:41

happy. But my guess is that it's not

33:43

going to be It's not a long-term thing.

33:45

It's not going to satisfy him in the the

33:47

long term. I don't you know, this who

33:49

knows?

33:49

>> But really most relationships are in

33:51

your head, right? When you fall in love

33:54

with someone, you get this huge dopamine

33:57

spike, and you get a little OCD, it's

34:00

all you can think about. And then after

34:02

a while, it sort of

34:04

>> Especially when we have this loneliness

34:06

epidemic, and it's going in a bad

34:08

direction. I think it's really, really

34:10

conceivable that there'll be a

34:12

generation of people who are they're

34:14

having less sex than ever before. I

34:15

think the bottom 50% of men haven't had

34:17

sex for a year. They're more lonely than

34:19

ever before. They're more isolated than

34:20

ever before. They have they put less

34:22

meaning in their lives than ever before.

34:23

And then you meet this digital friend

34:25

online who understands you better than

34:27

anybody, and is designed to engage you

34:30

to reinforce whatever you want

34:32

reinforced and to make you feel

34:34

meaningful, special, attractive,

34:36

important,

34:38

I would argue that the brain is going to

34:39

struggle to know much of a difference. I

34:41

think like objectively we can look at

34:43

the paper and go that's completely

34:44

nonsensical.

34:45

>> Except you can't smell them, touch them,

34:48

be held by them.

34:50

That it's going to be a different kind

34:54

of relationship.

34:55

>> I mean we're not too far if you think

34:57

about what's going on with Neuralink to

34:58

being able to

35:00

more vividly simulate these experiences

35:02

with with headsets and augmented reality

35:04

and virtual reality.

35:05

And then we're moving into a world with

35:07

robotics where all of the biggest

35:08

companies in the world, like many of the

35:09

biggest AI companies are also in the

35:11

robotic space. And the Optimus robots on

35:13

the way and you've got Boston Dynamics

35:15

producing their robots. And if Elon's

35:17

$20,000 Optimus robot comes out, I will

35:19

be able to touch my AI. My my AI will

35:21

exist.

35:22

>> have PMS and they won't love you and

35:24

then be really irritated with you. Which

35:27

which will decrease

35:29

cognitive load. Right? Having to manage

35:34

love

35:36

and manage moods and ups and downs. That

35:38

increases cognitive load. That increases

35:42

our ability for our brain to develop. If

35:46

I'm with the perfect partner that never

35:49

is irritated with me and I never have to

35:52

change my behavior to be better, that's

35:55

probably not good for my brain.

35:57

>> Mhm.

35:57

>> The way that the brain matures

36:01

is is through struggling, number one.

36:04

You have to learn from your mistakes.

36:06

The brain was designed for that. That's

36:07

what the brain is really good at. I mean

36:10

being able to adapt and to be able to

36:12

adjust to new situations.

36:16

Uh

36:17

that that what the

36:18

AGI is by the way.

36:21

Artificial general intelligence is is

36:23

that adaptability to different context,

36:25

different places, different cultures.

36:27

>> So, AI and ChatGPT is removing the

36:30

struggle.

36:31

>> No, no, it's it's it's it's There's

36:33

There's There's

36:34

>> Well, Annie didn't look like I mean,

36:35

Annie looked like she was cooperative.

36:38

>> But even when it comes to just doing my

36:40

day-to-day tasks, it's it's removing the

36:42

struggle of me having to think

36:43

critically. In fact, when you're

36:44

speaking, I can just type what you say

36:46

into ChatGPT, and it can spit out

36:49

another question to ask you. So, as an

36:50

interviewer, I could theoretically sit

36:52

here all day and just

36:53

defer my my questions.

36:54

>> You develop grit. You develop grit

36:57

through struggle.

36:59

>> That's right.

37:00

>> And learning.

37:02

Long-term potentiation when you learn

37:04

something new, it's hard because it's

37:07

new.

37:08

>> And what are your generally what are

37:09

your biggest concerns with artificial

37:11

intelligence, and how do we navigate

37:13

those concerns?

37:14

Is it You talked to me

37:15

>> It's out of the box.

37:17

So, I think we have to talk about it. We

37:19

have to legislate it.

37:21

Um we have to study it. Why do we keep

37:25

releasing things

37:28

that are so sexy that we don't study the

37:31

impact? We have the sickest

37:35

young generation

37:38

in the world's history. 58% of teenage

37:41

girls report being persistently sad. 32%

37:45

have thought of killing themselves. 24%

37:48

have planned to kill themselves, and 13%

37:51

have tried to kill themselves. The CDC

37:53

study. We have the sickest generation

37:56

history because we've unleashed

37:59

cell phones, social media

38:03

without any neuroscience study. If we

38:06

don't learn it, and I think AI is much

38:09

more dangerous.

38:10

Has the potential to be much more

38:12

dangerous because it's way sexier.

38:17

>> I think we are probably grossly

38:20

underestimating the impact it's going to

38:22

have. I think just like social media

38:24

where we thought the promise was that it

38:25

was going to connect us,

38:27

it's um

38:29

it's it's we're guinea pigs in an

38:30

experiment where we're going to find out

38:32

the results of the experiment probably

38:34

20, 30 years down the line. I tend to

38:36

think people will do in the near term

38:37

what's easiest, fastest, and cheapest

38:39

and what gives them the nearest the the

38:40

short-term advantage. So, with that in

38:43

mind, I think okay, I think people's

38:45

ability to think critically is probably

38:46

going to erode to some degree. If I had

38:48

to counter my own argument, I'd say

38:51

um

38:52

am I I'm probably learning more now that

38:55

I use ChatGPT. I'm learning more

38:56

information, but I'm probably

38:59

losing my ability to think critically.

39:02

And I think they're two very different

39:03

things. Like in school, I memorized

39:06

German to pass the exam. I can't speak

39:08

German now because I just memorized the

39:10

words I needed to pass the exam. I

39:12

didn't understand German.

39:13

And I think that's kind of what's

39:14

happening. I might be able to

39:15

regurgitate things, but whether I

39:17

understand them, I think is question

39:19

question mark. And actually, as someone

39:20

who's built my my life, my fortunes,

39:22

everything, my business is based on my

39:23

ability to

39:24

innovate and think critically about the

39:26

problem and then come up with a slightly

39:28

novel solution which

39:30

learns from, you know, different first

39:31

principles to create something new. I'm

39:33

concerned that my own ChatGPT usage is

39:36

going to make me less effective.

39:39

And I'm wondering if I should put some

39:41

rules in place for myself

39:44

so that there's self-

39:44

>> Self-regulation.

39:45

>> Yeah, self-regulation. I have to do the

39:47

same with social media. On my phone, I

39:48

turn off my notifications. I have so

39:50

many things on my social media apps to

39:52

stop me using them. I don't even,

39:54

frankly, I don't even open the TikTok

39:56

app. I don't think it's even on my phone

39:58

because I think the algorithm is that

39:59

addictive. It's not to say that we don't

40:01

we don't post. My team doesn't post.

40:03

But I don't I just think yeah.

40:06

And uh

40:07

>> Well, I wrote down a couple of thoughts

40:09

I had.

40:10

>> Um

40:11

use it to amplify, not replace thinking.

40:15

>> Okay.

40:16

>> Um

40:17

alternate AI assisted with brain only

40:20

tasks.

40:22

Engage in deep learning problem solving

40:25

and memorization, so you can actually

40:27

ask AI to test you.

40:31

>> Mhm.

40:31

>> So, you're interacting with it. You're

40:34

not using it as a replacement for your

40:38

brain. And I think

40:41

just like you said, it's here and it's

40:44

going to get bigger. I think the

40:45

unintended consequences is not going to

40:47

be 20 or 30 years. I think it's going to

40:49

be five. I think like everything is

40:53

accelerated.

40:55

And I think we have to be studying kids

40:59

and the impact it has. This is just like

41:02

they did with the MIT study.

41:05

These are kids who didn't use it at all.

41:07

These are kids who use search. These are

41:09

kids that used AI. And when we see

41:13

information like this, we act on it. And

41:17

we educate kids about it. I think that's

41:22

If you can engage them, that's what I

41:24

found with my work with teenagers. If

41:27

you can get them

41:29

to really understand, okay, what is it

41:31

you really want? And do you want to give

41:35

away part of your mind share for people

41:39

who are making money on you? And I think

41:41

if you engage the There's a great new

41:45

article on revenge and the brain and how

41:49

revenge works on the nucleus accumbens,

41:53

part of the basal ganglia, that people

41:55

actually get addicted to revenge. But if

41:58

you can get them engaged in the truth,

42:02

that these companies are making money

42:04

the more they steal your mind, it'll

42:08

upset them enough that they'll begin to

42:10

supervise it.

42:11

>> I like the idea of asking Chat GPT to

42:16

give me negative feedback. I'll bet

42:17

you've done that, right?

42:18

>> Yeah, all the time. So, I'll say this is

42:20

this is my I've written this memo. I did

42:22

it yesterday.

42:23

I wrote a a two-page memo about me

42:27

wanting to introduce a new role into my

42:29

into my company.

42:31

And I went I did everything. I did like

42:32

how we'd measure if this was a success,

42:34

the background context, the person, how

42:36

the organization would be structured,

42:37

the impact they'd have, how who they'd

42:38

report to. And then I put it into all

42:41

three of the Chat GPT models I use,

42:43

Gemini, Chat GPT, and Grok, and said,

42:48

"Critique my work and tell me how I

42:49

could have written this better,

42:50

pretending that you're a top consultant

42:52

from Boston Consulting Group."

42:54

And it went through and it gave me a big

42:56

analysis of how I can make it better,

42:57

and I read what it said, and it said, I

42:58

remember it said, um, actually that was

43:00

the thing that said, "You need to

43:01

include

43:02

a financial forecasts about the impact.

43:05

You need to think about who's going to

43:07

report to whom more clearly, etc., etc."

43:09

So, I went back into my memo and I added

43:11

those things in. But, I have to I, you

43:12

know,

43:13

>> So, you're interacting with it.

43:16

>> Because I'm because I'm scared. Most

43:17

people don't do that.

43:19

I don't think I would do what I did. I

43:21

don't think I would have spent 4 hours

43:22

writing that. I could have within 30

43:24

seconds said, "Hey, can you write me a

43:26

this job description?" And you it knows

43:29

my company now because Chat GPT has

43:31

memory. "Write me a job description for

43:32

this role. I want them to start this new

43:34

department for me." And I could have

43:36

saved myself 3 and 1/2 hours. The only

43:38

reason

43:38

>> why you're the CEO of your company.

43:41

>> Yeah, exactly. The the reason why I

43:42

didn't take the 30-second route is

43:45

because I reflect on being 23 years old

43:48

and the profound impact that writing and

43:51

simplifying had on my life.

43:53

Had I not spent 5 years writing every

43:56

single day and simplifying it into 140

43:58

characters so I could tweet it, I

44:00

wouldn't have been religiously attached

44:01

to this idea.

44:02

>> you know what part of your brain was you

44:04

were taking advantage of?

44:06

It it was the basal ganglia.

44:09

That's repetitive. It needs practice,

44:11

practice, practice. And And once you put

44:13

that foundation in, then you become much

44:16

better cognitively. The cognitive part

44:18

There's two big learning systems.

44:20

And they have to work together. And And

44:22

so maybe I think I think that the real

44:24

problem with children

44:26

is that we our schools now is getting

44:29

away with rote learning. They call it

44:31

rote as if it's something bad. No,

44:33

that's practice. That

44:34

You know, you need to have a foundation.

44:36

You have to memorize things.

44:38

It It math, reading, and so forth to

44:41

become fluent. You need to be fluent.

44:44

And And it's the basal ganglia. And And

44:46

that's There's no basal ganglia in these

44:49

uh chatbots.

44:50

>> One of the One of the things I've

44:51

noticed just in the short term is I'm

44:53

getting lazier and lazier with spelling.

44:55

Because ChatGPT and these large language

44:57

models are so It's not spell check like

44:59

we used to have on on Word documents.

45:01

They are so good at knowing what word I

45:03

meant. So now I've I've started to learn

45:06

that I literally only need to half spell

45:08

a word. I literally mean if it was a if

45:11

it was a 12-letter word, I need to get

45:14

six letters right.

45:16

And it will know.

45:16

>> And you don't And grammar it'll fix your

45:18

grammar.

45:19

>> Yeah, it knows exactly what it means. So

45:20

like I've got ChatGPT open here. I'm

45:22

going to butcher everything. I'm going

45:23

to not look and I'm just going to say um

45:25

I'm going to say

45:33

Okay.

45:34

So that is what I wrote. I butchered it.

45:37

I tried to type with my eyes closed

45:39

looking away on my iPad. Tell me

45:40

everything I know about Daniel Amen. I

45:42

spelled the words

45:44

pretty much all wrong. And it says,

45:46

"Here's a full profile of Dr. Daniel

45:48

Amen." And I spelled every single word

45:50

wrong.

45:50

>> Wow.

45:51

>> And I didn't spell just spell them

45:52

nearly wrong. I spelled them

45:53

horrifically wrong. And it So what in

45:56

the future I come back to ChatGPT and

45:58

go, "I only need to half spell."

46:00

I don't need to spell anymore.

46:02

Just need to half spell.

46:04

>> I learned to spell

46:06

with phonics.

46:07

The sounds of letters. I suspect you

46:09

would did too. In our generation, that

46:11

was the way that was taught. You can't

46:14

teach phonics in California schools and

46:16

you haven't for the the generation.

46:18

>> Which changes their brain.

46:20

>> It completely changes their brain and

46:21

now they can't spell. I think it's a lot

46:24

of it is the fact that we're no longer

46:25

using the learning that we did which is

46:28

by rote, by memorizing stuff, by

46:31

repeating stuff, by doing problems over

46:34

and over and over again until it's

46:35

automatic.

46:36

>> You've written so much and you're well

46:39

known for being someone that teaches

46:41

people how to learn better. If you were

46:43

trying to help me learn better

46:47

based on everything you know about the

46:48

brain

46:49

what advice would you give me? I'm

46:51

someone that sits here with these

46:52

experts all day every day consuming all

46:54

of this information. Not all of this

46:55

sticks.

46:57

>> and this is something we've known for a

46:58

hundred years.

46:59

And that is if you want to remember

47:01

long-term, you should you should you

47:03

should rehearse

47:05

at intervals.

47:08

Okay, in other words, if you find an

47:09

amount of time to study something, you

47:10

shouldn't spend all that time

47:13

in one go. But if you if you spend

47:16

you know, you learn something and then

47:18

you come back the next day and you know,

47:20

rehearse it or or even better, come back

47:22

the next week and rehearse it

47:25

that spacing is something that helps the

47:28

brain solidify those memories. It's it's

47:31

called the spacing effect. Goes back to

47:32

Ebbinghaus. You go to schools

47:35

they don't teach that. They they don't.

47:36

I mean, this is the one of the most

47:37

basic facts that we've we've known about

47:39

it but

47:40

it covers every single kind of learning.

47:43

You know, cognitive learning, even even

47:45

>> don't teach us how to learn. Which we'd

47:48

think that's the first thing they should

47:50

teach us is how to love and care for our

47:53

brains and then how to learn.

47:56

>> Absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, in other

47:58

in other words, there's and you're

48:00

referring to I have a a massive open

48:02

online course, a MOOC with Barbara

48:04

Oakley on learning how to learn. It's

48:06

it's fabulously uh

48:08

popular. It's the 6 million people have

48:10

taken the course. A bunch of 50

48:13

10-minute segments, but the one that's

48:14

the most popular is how to avoid

48:16

procrastination.

48:19

>> And what's the answer?

48:20

>> The reason why you procrastinate is that

48:22

there's some

48:23

mental block or some energy barrier,

48:26

right? And so what you have got to do

48:28

is

48:29

get over that. And you don't do it by

48:31

just running over it. What you have to

48:32

do is say, "I'm going to spend 20

48:34

minutes today getting started with that

48:36

task. I know it's going to take me a

48:37

long time."

48:39

I have a timer

48:40

and I start thinking about it

48:43

and I get a little bit into it, maybe

48:44

make a list.

48:46

Bang, that's the end. Okay, it's great.

48:48

It's 20 minutes.

48:50

Now, here's what happens.

48:52

You go to sleep.

48:53

Your brain is now working on that list

48:56

and you come back the next day and spend

48:58

another 20 minutes.

49:00

And you do it in small segments. You

49:01

don't want to do it all at once. And

49:02

it's just like the same thing with the

49:04

spacing effect is your your brain needs

49:07

time, your subconscious needs time to

49:09

work on things.

49:11

And so by putting in a little bit, it'll

49:13

work on it overnight and and now you

49:15

when you come the next day, you'll be

49:16

ready for the next you know, you'll be

49:19

able to build on what you've done in

49:20

your brain.

49:21

>> Is this why people say, "I'm going to

49:22

sleep on it"

49:24

when they you know, they've got

49:25

difficult problems?

49:26

>> sayings actually have meaning. It's

49:28

absolutely right, yeah.

49:29

>> Because the brain there's something

49:31

about spacing out.

49:32

>> It it's spacing, but this mem- memory

49:34

consolidation I'm talking about is is

49:36

very it's very interesting. It's

49:38

something I've I've actually worked a

49:39

lot on. And it what was happening is you

49:41

have to take the new experience and

49:43

integrate it into your old long-term

49:44

memory.

49:45

And that has to be done in a way that

49:48

doesn't interfere with there.

49:50

And also you get a chance to sort out,

49:53

you know, what's relevant, what's

49:54

important.

49:56

I know when I wake up in the morning,

49:57

things that were very muddled and things

49:59

become clearer because I think it's it's

50:01

it's eliminated a lot of things that are

50:03

irrelevant or not needed. And so you now

50:06

can see what's important.

50:07

>> So what are the things that we

50:09

do where we think we're learning

50:11

something, but they're actually not

50:12

working?

50:15

You know, cuz I'm I'm you know

50:17

I might be preparing for this podcast

50:19

today. I've got 20 pages of research

50:21

that I've pulled together. And I might

50:23

tell myself that the way to for me to

50:24

really learn that so that I don't have

50:26

to look at the research is by just

50:28

re-reading it over and over again.

50:30

>> What you should have done is not just

50:31

read it over and over again. In fact,

50:32

one of the things that we say you know,

50:34

this is a standard thing is that

50:36

students they get a mental block and

50:38

they keep banging your head against the

50:39

wall. I can't understand it. I can't

50:41

understand it.

50:42

What you the right thing to do is once

50:44

you get to that point is just get up and

50:46

start walking around doing something,

50:48

you know, cooking,

50:49

gardening, whatever it is.

50:51

Let your subconscious work on it. You

50:53

know, the brain saturates very very

50:55

quick. So having breaks at meetings is

50:59

you might think is is a waste of time,

51:01

but actually it's the most important

51:03

thing you can add to

51:04

a long string of talks is have breaks

51:06

between the talks so that you can your

51:08

brain can work on it.

51:10

And my favorite meeting actually is a

51:12

ski meeting.

51:14

And the idea is that you go to a ski

51:16

resort

51:18

and what you do is you in the morning

51:20

you have a couple of hours of lectures

51:22

and now you go skiing and now it turns

51:24

out your brain is working on what you

51:26

heard

51:27

and then when you come down

51:30

in the evening you have another couple

51:31

of hours, but now your brain is

51:33

refreshed and so it's able to take in

51:35

the new information and integrate it.

51:38

And then you go to sleep and that you

51:39

know, it's like kneading bread. You have

51:41

to go back and forth, back and forth,

51:42

back and forth. And so I found those at

51:45

the efficient in terms of learning new

51:47

things and

51:49

uh being able to think about it and mull

51:51

over it during the time of the meeting

51:54

as opposed to at the end of the meeting.

51:56

>> Every single one of you watching this

51:58

right now has something to offer,

51:59

whether it's knowledge or skills or

52:00

experience, and that means you have

52:02

value. Stan Store, the platform I co-own

52:04

who are one of the sponsors of this

52:05

podcast, turns your knowledge into a

52:08

business through one single click. You

52:10

can sell digital products, coaching,

52:12

communities, and you don't need any

52:14

coding experience either, just the drive

52:16

to start. This is a business I really

52:18

believe in, and already $300

52:21

has been earned by creators, coaches,

52:23

and entrepreneurs just like you have the

52:24

potential to be on Stan Store. These are

52:26

people who didn't wait, who heard me

52:28

saying things like this, and instead of

52:29

procrastinating started building, then

52:31

launched something, and now they're

52:33

getting paid to do it. Stan is

52:34

incredibly simple and incredibly easy,

52:36

and you can link it with a Shopify store

52:38

that you're already using if you want

52:39

to. I'm on it, and so is my girlfriend

52:41

and many of my team. So, if you want to

52:43

join, start by launching your own

52:44

business with a free 30-day trial. Visit

52:47

stevenbartlett.stan.store

52:49

and get your setup within minutes.

52:51

I've met and invested in many

52:54

early-stage founders over the years,

52:55

probably about 50 or 60, ones like Ross

52:57

from Cadence and Marissa from Perfect

52:59

Ted. And one thing they all know is that

53:01

having a digitally fluent business is

53:03

crucial, but it isn't always easy

53:05

getting your business or team to that

53:07

point. Through my ongoing partnership

53:09

with Vodafone Business, I've seen the

53:10

work that they're doing supporting

53:12

founders and small businesses to become

53:14

digitally savvy. They know how much

53:16

small business owners value advice from

53:18

those who've been there and done it

53:19

before. So, they've just launched a new

53:21

content series to share experiences from

53:23

like-minded founders. It's called

53:25

business.connected,

53:27

part of Vodafone's support program. It's

53:29

a collection of resources designed to

53:31

support businesses with free digital

53:33

skills. So, if you've been trying to

53:35

figure out AI, marketing, e-commerce, or

53:37

just how to scale smarter, there's

53:38

advice and insights throughout this

53:40

series from those who've have done it

53:41

before. A bunch of different founders

53:43

and experts who have been there and done

53:45

it. I highly recommend you go and check

53:47

it out. Just search Vodafone

53:49

business.connected

53:50

on YouTube or follow the link in the

53:52

description below. So, let's talk about

53:54

other things outside of AI that we can

53:56

do to have good, healthy brains. Based

53:59

on everything you know about how the

54:00

brain works.

54:02

Um let's start with children. I'm hoping

54:05

to be a father at some point in the next

54:08

next couple of months or years or

54:09

whatever God God grants me a child. Um

54:13

what should I be thinking about with my

54:14

child's brain to make sure it's healthy?

54:16

>> To get your body and your partner's body

54:21

as healthy as you can before you

54:23

conceive. Cuz there's a concept

54:28

I like called brain reserve. Brain

54:31

reserve is the extra function tissue you

54:33

have to deal with whatever stress comes

54:36

your way. And it starts from the health

54:39

of the egg and the health of the sperm

54:43

that create the baby. So, there things

54:47

you guys can do now that would be really

54:51

helpful. And then once your partner is

54:54

pregnant, you want to not put her under

54:57

a lot of stress

54:59

because her body's health while she's

55:04

creating the baby.

55:06

I mean, the babies eat the brain starts

55:09

to develop I think day 21. So, even

55:12

before you know she's pregnant, the

55:14

baby's brain is developing. So,

55:19

knowing you, intentional, purposeful,

55:22

it's like, let's live as cleanly as we

55:26

can. I think that gives the baby a head

55:29

start. And then you think about what to

55:32

feed the baby. You think about what the

55:36

baby's exposed to and what the baby

55:39

needs most is mom's and your time and

55:44

eye contact and cuddling and singing and

55:50

it's like those are

55:51

>> Touching is really important. Well, but

55:53

there's another fact there was a study

55:55

that was done on

55:56

the impact of how many words are spoken.

55:59

You know, there when a a baby and a

56:01

child even when you know, baby doesn't

56:04

speak, you know, until like 18 months.

56:06

Uh but it turns out that the words that

56:08

you are talking to the baby are going

56:10

into the brain and have an impact. Every

56:13

and and and in families that don't talk,

56:17

they do worse at school.

56:20

Unfortunately, a lot of poor families uh

56:22

but but that's really important is that

56:24

they they they have they're exposed to

56:27

language early and abundantly.

56:30

>> And you model. I mean, it's the one big

56:32

thing. Whatever you want the baby to

56:35

grow into, every day you are modeling

56:38

health or you are modeling illness just

56:42

by what you do, by what you say, by how

56:44

you treat the baby's mother.

56:47

Um

56:48

I have a book called Raising Mentally

56:50

Strong Kids, which I'm very happy about.

56:52

Um

56:54

and it starts with what kind of dad do I

56:57

want to be and what kind of child do I

56:58

want to raise. And

57:02

bonding, you want your child to pick

57:03

your values.

57:06

Then bonding is time, actual physical

57:09

time.

57:11

And listening. Like being And that's

57:14

what AI does, I think. It'll actually

57:17

listen without interrupting you

57:21

and try to reflect back what you're

57:24

hearing and then give you some positive

57:26

input. Too often, because of screens,

57:29

parents aren't listening, their heads

57:31

are in their phones, and everybody's

57:35

distracted. You see it whenever you go

57:36

to a restaurant. It's like everybody's

57:38

on their phone, and nobody's looking at

57:40

each other.

57:41

>> Are we raising mentally weak kids

57:43

because we're there's a culture now of

57:45

like helping them too much?

57:48

Doing too much for them.

57:49

>> This generation is the most in trouble

57:52

in history.

57:53

And we have to really ask ourselves why.

57:58

From the food we feed them to the

58:00

devices they look at, to the negative

58:02

news, the polarization

58:05

of the news. It's that sort of chronic

58:08

cortisol. And then the separation,

58:12

oh, you voted this way or you voted that

58:15

way. Saw something TV this morning if

58:17

somebody

58:18

voted one way, well, you shouldn't spend

58:20

time with them. I'm like, we're already

58:22

so lonely that now you're going to cut

58:24

off 50% of the population. It's like

58:27

it's just such stupidity.

58:30

>> Do you think much about the the impact

58:31

that religion and having a belief in

58:34

some kind of transcendent thing has on

58:38

the brain and psychology and psychiatry

58:40

generally?

58:41

>> you don't believe in God, you're three

58:43

times the risk of depression.

58:47

Yeah, God in

58:48

different ways.

58:50

>> transcendent or

58:51

>> Yes. If you believe you're here by Just

58:55

think about it with me. If you believe

58:57

you're just here by random chance, that

59:00

life really was not created and has no

59:04

meaning, there's existential

59:07

nothingness to that.

59:10

As opposed to, oh, no, I'm created in a

59:13

special way to do something purposeful

59:17

on Earth. There's purposeful people live

59:21

longer, they're happier.

59:23

Now, whatever

59:25

version

59:26

you believe,

59:28

to not believe is hard for the brain.

59:32

And there's an interesting study on

59:35

believers versus non-believers. And you

59:38

know, many scientists would go, well,

59:40

they'll have smaller brains if they're a

59:42

believer. They actually bigger temporal

59:44

lobes. And temporal lobes, underneath

59:47

your temples and behind your eyes.

59:50

Right here.

59:52

Um

59:53

that's where it's called the God area

59:56

because um that's where people think

60:00

they experience them.

60:01

>> And and if you have a seizure in the

60:03

temporal lobe, you you have transcendent

60:05

experiences like you're

60:08

um

60:09

uh uh you know, in the presence of God.

60:11

>> And they think maybe the Apostle Paul on

60:14

the road to Damascus had a seizure and

60:18

saw God. There's actually a

60:20

uh researcher in Canada, uh Laurentian

60:23

University, Michael Persinger. So, he

60:26

would stimulate the outside

60:29

He He would do it all over the brain,

60:30

but what he found he stimulated the

60:32

outside of the right temporal lobe, that

60:35

people would get a sensed presence. They

60:37

would actually feel the presence of God

60:42

in the room. So, does that being the

60:44

brain makes up God, or does that mean

60:47

there's a way for God to communicate

60:50

with us? I actually did a study on

60:53

prayer. It was so interesting. You know,

60:55

I pray for you, uh prophecy, something

60:59

called speaking in tongues. Um it was

61:01

fascinating. Speaking in tongues is

61:04

channeling. It means you're channeling

61:06

the Holy Spirit. And the hypothesis was

61:09

you'd have to drop your frontal lobes,

61:11

which is exactly what happened in 60%

61:15

of our patients. And one, basal ganglia

61:18

skyrocketed, just like got hit with

61:20

cocaine. Cuz that's where cocaine works

61:23

in the basal ganglia.

61:25

Uh

61:26

so interesting.

61:27

>> If you had to create a brain-healthy

61:29

nation and I made you president of the

61:30

United States

61:32

for 1 month,

61:33

and you had to put in place executive

61:35

orders

61:37

that would create a brain-healthy

61:38

nation, what executive orders would you

61:40

immediately sign?

61:42

>> One question.

61:44

Get all of the departments ask

61:47

themselves, what we're doing is this

61:49

good for our brains or bad for it?

61:51

And so I that's the campaign. I mean, I

61:54

realize I've been doing this a very long

61:56

time. If I can just get people to answer

61:59

that one question with information

62:03

and love, love of themselves, love of

62:05

their families, love of their country.

62:08

Is this as what we're doing good for our

62:11

brains or bad for it?

62:13

>> By far, the best drug you can take for

62:16

your brain, and not just your brain, but

62:18

your entire body is exercise.

62:22

In other words,

62:24

exercise

62:25

you pump the blood and your brain gets

62:28

you know,

62:29

a lot of nutrients and everything.

62:32

It helps your heart, it helps your

62:33

immune system. People don't realize how

62:36

important that is. And we're not talking

62:38

about being an athlete, we're just

62:39

talking about walking if you're older.

62:41

Walking is perfectly good exercise.

62:44

And and you know, children now, I you

62:46

know, they're they're not getting enough

62:47

exercise.

62:48

>> they're on devices.

62:49

>> Yeah.

62:49

>> And so I have a model, if you want to

62:52

keep your brain healthy or rescue it,

62:54

you have to prevent or treat the 11

62:56

major risk factors. And we've talked

62:58

about them before.

63:00

Exercise helps you with every single

63:03

one. So like, it's called bright minds.

63:06

So B is for blood flow, increases blood

63:08

flow. Retirement and aging, it decreases

63:11

your age. I is inflammation, it's

63:12

anti-inflammatory. G is genetics, it

63:15

helps turn on health-promoting

63:18

genes. H is head trauma. If you keep

63:22

walking, you're less likely to fall when

63:24

you're older, right? T is toxins, sweat

63:27

detoxifies you. M is mental health,

63:32

exercise boosts dopamine, but it also

63:34

boosts serotonin. So, it's like that

63:36

perfect balance or in your brain.

63:38

>> Breathing, how we breathe.

63:40

Does that have an impact on brain

63:42

health?

63:43

>> So, you can almost immediately improve

63:46

heart rate variability, which is a sign

63:49

of heart health, but also goes to mental

63:52

health by breathing

63:54

in a certain helpful way. And I call it

63:58

the 15-second breath. So, 4 seconds in,

64:02

big breath, hold it for a second and a

64:04

half, pause just a little bit,

64:06

8 seconds out, hold it for a second and

64:10

a half. So, if you take twice as long to

64:13

breathe out as you breathe in, it

64:16

increases something called

64:17

parasympathetic tone.

64:19

And it just calms you down almost

64:21

immediately. So, if you're having panic

64:23

attacks, yes, you can take Xanax, but

64:25

there's so many problems with that later

64:27

on. Or you can just learn how to

64:30

breathe. We call it diaphragmatic, so

64:32

breathe mostly with your belly, taking

64:35

twice as long to breathe out as you

64:37

breathe in.

64:37

>> Chewing.

64:38

Uh there's a

64:39

piece here that says it stimulates

64:41

hippocampal activity and may slow

64:43

cognitive decline. Reducing chewing has

64:45

been linked to impaired learning in

64:47

animal studies.

64:48

>> And fast food decreases chewing because

64:51

it's fast, so they take most of the

64:52

fiber out so you can chew it faster or

64:54

you can swallow it faster.

64:56

>> Things in the bad for your brain list.

64:58

Overuse of GPS navigation app, which

65:00

weakens the hippocampus by outsourcing

65:02

spatial memory long-term. This can lead

65:04

to atrophy in areas associated with

65:06

memory and navigation.

65:07

>> And people are diagnosed with

65:08

Alzheimer's disease later in life

65:11

because of Siri.

65:14

Because I used to like when I started as

65:16

young psychiatrist, somebody get lost in

65:19

a city they'd lived in for 30 years and

65:22

their family would call me upset.

65:25

And I'm like, okay, this person's headed

65:27

toward dementia. Now that person goes,

65:30

take me home. Do you think it's going to

65:32

have we're going to have an epigenetic

65:34

effect

65:36

of not reading maps? That if Steven, now

65:41

he uses his phone to get from A to B, do

65:44

you think that's going to affect

65:45

Steven's son or daughter

65:48

because dad

65:51

didn't have

65:52

>> Wow, okay, that that never occurred to

65:54

me that you could pass on something like

65:57

that. By the way, I I think it has to be

65:59

physiological. Stress, for example,

66:01

could be probably passed on. You

66:02

mentioned this. You you pointed out

66:04

during pregnancy you you want to prevent

66:06

stress and and crisis, right?

66:08

Do Do you know about

66:09

>> that study with mice where they made

66:11

them afraid of the scent of cherry

66:13

blossoms from memory and

66:17

so whenever the mice smelled

66:20

cherry blossoms, they would shock them.

66:23

Mildly. So the mice are now afraid of

66:25

the scent of cherry blossoms.

66:27

Their babies were afraid of the scent of

66:29

cherry blossoms. Their grand babies were

66:31

afraid of the scent of cherry blossoms.

66:33

So

66:33

>> that's the olfactory system. Olfactory

66:35

system is very interesting because it

66:37

goes directly to the hippocampus.

66:39

But there might be an evolutionary

66:41

advantage because if if there's

66:44

something in the environment that you

66:45

shouldn't eat or you know that smells a

66:48

particular way, passing that on is is a

66:51

very efficient instead of having to have

66:53

experience that yourself, you know,

66:54

trial and error because it might if a

66:56

poison is, right? It might kill you. But

66:58

if if you've your parents

67:01

had that bad experience and passed it on

67:03

to you shouldn't go to the something

67:05

that smells in a particular way, that

67:06

makes sense.

67:07

>> The other thing that's bad for the

67:08

brain, which is unexpected, is you said

67:11

at the start, artificial sweetness.

67:14

Now, I didn't think I thought artificial

67:16

sweeteners were fine.

67:17

>> They're not fine, and they're not free.

67:19

So, I used to drink diet soda like it

67:21

was my best friend, cuz I thought it was

67:23

free.

67:24

Um then I had arthritis when I was 35,

67:28

and one of my patients said she stopped

67:31

aspartame and her arthritis went away.

67:33

And I'm like cuz I was drinking like I

67:35

don't know.

67:36

A lot of diet soda, and so I stopped,

67:40

and my arthritis went away. And I'm

67:41

like, no. And so I did it again, and it

67:44

came back, and I'm like, okay.

67:46

And

67:48

artificial sweeteners can change the

67:50

microbiome. So, we haven't talked about

67:53

that, but you have these 100 trillion

67:55

bugs in your gut that make

67:57

neurotransmitters, digest your food, and

68:00

especially sucralose or Splenda has been

68:03

found to decrease the good bacteria in

68:05

your gut, which then has a negative

68:07

impact on brain function.

68:10

>> It is aspartame, as you mentioned.

68:12

>> And aspartame that I mentioned that can

68:14

have a generational impact. So, is it

68:16

possible it's really not social media,

68:19

it's that we've had aspartame in our

68:22

food

68:23

for decades. And I think it's

68:26

all of these things that just sort of

68:28

are additive, and we should just always

68:31

think that that one question. Is this

68:33

good for my brain or bad? For you

68:35

mention broccoli, probably that's good

68:37

for your brain.

68:40

Cheeseburger, probably not, but why

68:42

don't you take the burger, and if you

68:44

could make it grass-fed, that would be

68:46

better, and put it in a salad, and then

68:48

that would be good for your brain.

68:50

>> What about chronic background noise?

68:53

We don't think much about the impact

68:54

noise has, but

68:56

>> I used to live, um my house was three

69:00

houses from the freeway. And if you just

69:03

go there, it's like, "My god, it's so

69:06

loud here." I never heard the freeway

69:09

because my brain just learned to tune it

69:11

out.

69:11

>> By the way, was that good or bad for

69:13

you?

69:14

>> That I was able to

69:15

>> had you adapted and and were no longer

69:17

sensitive to it. I I I think that

69:19

actually was probably not good

69:22

for for various reasons because it what

69:25

it really means is that you you're

69:27

you're specializing for that

69:28

environment. And your brain's going to

69:30

be different when you go someplace.

69:33

So but so here's a here's another

69:34

example.

69:35

>> stressful.

69:37

Right?

69:37

>> Yes, chronically stressful, but my brain

69:40

is very good at tuning out.

69:41

>> But in the background in the In other

69:42

words, yeah, in other words, your your

69:43

your your brain is reacting to it even

69:46

though you're not aware of it, you know.

69:47

>> So subtly increases And I had five

69:48

sisters, which makes it even worse.

69:50

>> Subtly increases cortisol and impairs

69:52

working memory and attention regulation,

69:54

especially in children and older adults

69:55

to be chronically exposed to background

69:57

noise like traffic or the low-level hum

69:59

of the city.

70:00

Yeah, that's right. That's absolutely

70:02

right.

70:03

>> Make sure you keep what I'm about to say

70:04

to yourself. I'm inviting 10,000 of you

70:07

to come even deeper into the Diary of a

70:09

CEO. Welcome to my inner circle. This is

70:12

a brand new private community that I'm

70:14

launching to the world. We have so many

70:16

incredible things that happen that you

70:17

are never shown. We have the briefs that

70:20

are on my iPad when I'm recording the

70:21

conversation. We have clips we've never

70:23

released. We have behind-the-scenes

70:25

conversations with the guest and also

70:26

the episodes that we've never ever

70:29

released and so much more. In the

70:32

circle, you'll have direct access to me.

70:34

You can tell us what you want this show

70:35

to be, who you want us to interview, and

70:37

the types of conversations you would

70:39

love us to have. But remember for now,

70:41

we're only inviting the first 10,000

70:43

people that join before it closes. So if

70:46

you want to join our private closed

70:47

community, head to the link in the

70:48

description below or go to

70:49

DOACcircle.com.

70:52

I will speak to you there.

70:54

>> Many of us multitask across multiple

70:56

screens now. We're watching TV here.

70:58

We've got our phone here, we've got our

70:59

iPad here, got our computer here. And I

71:01

was reading into the science of

71:02

multitasking and it said that it trains

71:03

your brain to be distractible.

71:05

Reducing gray matter density in the

71:07

anterior cingulate.

71:10

>> Yeah, that's

71:10

>> And the insula.

71:11

>> It's

71:11

yeah, in the medial prefrontal cortex.

71:14

>> And when the insula the insula is so

71:16

interesting and I know you can talk

71:18

about I have a new study coming out on

71:19

hope. So, on 7,500 patients we gave them

71:24

a hope questionnaire.

71:26

Hope questionnaire. Hope, like how much

71:28

hope do you have that you have the

71:31

ability to make tomorrow better. And

71:34

people with low hope have lower overall

71:38

prefrontal cortex function, but the

71:41

insula

71:43

was really low and that signal was the

71:46

most statistically significant of the

71:49

group. Really. And

71:51

in some studies the insula is called the

71:53

island

71:54

>> also for depression, people who have

71:56

depression

71:57

uh have low activity in the anterior

71:59

cingulate and in fact uh

72:00

it it deep brain stimulation has been

72:03

used now for to help some people if you

72:05

stimulate that area.

72:06

>> And what our imaging research would say

72:08

is depression is like chest pain.

72:11

It's not one thing. Like nobody gets a

72:13

diagnosis of chest pain because that

72:16

would be stupid, right? It could be

72:17

heart attack, heart arrhythmia, heart

72:19

infection, gas, grief.

72:22

Depression's the same way. When you look

72:24

at it from an imaging standpoint,

72:26

sometimes their frontal lobes are too

72:27

active, sometimes they're not active

72:30

enough, sometimes it's their limbic

72:34

system that's too active. And I wrote a

72:38

book called Healing Anxiety and

72:39

Depression and like here's the seven

72:41

things I see as an imager.

72:43

>> What about ADHD?

72:45

There's obviously been a rise in ADHD or

72:46

at least people reporting of being

72:48

diagnosed with ADHD quite significant.

72:51

Can you find ADHD in the brain? Are we

72:53

causing ADHD as a function of the way

72:56

that we're living our lives, or is it

72:57

something within the brain genetically

72:58

that I could I could see?

73:00

>> So, it's both. I think Clearly, you can

73:03

see ADHD in people's families. In fact,

73:07

if I have a hyperactive, restless,

73:09

impulsive, disorganized, procrastinating

73:13

child, I'm looking at the mom and the

73:15

dad. I'm like, "So, where is this coming

73:17

from?"

73:18

But, you could also get ADHD from a head

73:21

injury, especially if it affects their

73:23

frontal lobes, which is why you

73:24

shouldn't let children hit soccer balls

73:26

with their forehead. You can also get it

73:29

from the chronic from the excessive

73:32

input, making people distracted, just

73:34

like you said. Brand new study out on

73:38

children who took medicine, right? We

73:40

always demonize ADHD medicine. But, the

73:44

kids who took medicine actually had

73:48

bigger brains in their prefrontal cortex

73:51

than kids who didn't take medicine who

73:54

had ADHD.

73:55

>> Ritalin?

73:56

>> Ritalin.

73:57

>> That's Okay, that's speed, basically.

73:59

Yeah, amphetamines.

74:00

>> It is. But, for the kids who have it,

74:04

I think withholding medicine

74:07

from a child who really has ADHD is like

74:10

withholding glasses from someone who has

74:13

trouble seeing.

74:14

And it's it's the easy thing to demonize

74:18

the drugs until you realize someone who

74:21

has ADHD

74:23

a third of them don't finish high

74:24

school.

74:26

And

74:26

we never ask the right question about

74:29

People go, "What's the side effects?"

74:30

And it's it can decrease your appetite.

74:33

And

74:35

can can have sleep problems with it.

74:38

But, they don't ask the other question.

74:39

It's what's the side effect of not

74:41

taking the medicine, or at least not

74:43

fully treating And there There other

74:45

ways to treat it besides medicine, You

74:47

know, for God's sakes, I own a

74:49

supplement company and I'm always trying

74:51

to optimize the nutrients to the brain.

74:54

Neurofeedback can help, but if you do

74:58

those things and it's not working, don't

75:00

be afraid of medicine.

75:03

>> But by the way, when I was growing up,

75:04

ADHD either didn't exist or they didn't

75:07

know about it.

75:08

Do you Do you think that there's some

75:10

link to the our diet

75:11

>> it was first described in a book named

75:13

1910 and it's in the first version

75:17

of the DSM.

75:20

They called it minimal brain

75:21

dysfunction.

75:23

But when we were growing up, there were

75:25

one or two of these kids in our

75:27

classrooms and now there's eight to 10.

75:30

>> That's That's what I mean. Is Is that

75:31

it's

75:32

seems to that like autism, it's

75:35

seems to be proliferating.

75:37

>> Right, and part of it I think is the

75:39

food that is

75:42

much more processed. Part of it is the

75:44

screens. Part of it is the distracted

75:46

parents and part of it is the teaching.

75:50

>> You always seem to be doing new studies,

75:52

Daniel. What What new studies are you

75:54

most excited about or have you completed

75:56

since we last spoke?

75:57

>> I did one that I'm so excited about on

76:02

negativity and the brain.

76:04

And negativity is bad for your brain. So

76:10

>> you define negativity?

76:11

>> We actually give them a questionnaire.

76:14

It's a positivity negativity bias

76:17

questionnaire and people who are more

76:19

negative have less activity in their

76:23

prefrontal cortex. It's actually quite

76:26

interesting. And so

76:29

unbridled positivity is bad for you

76:33

because you need that 15%, but if you're

76:36

chronically negative, that is

76:40

bad for your brain.

76:41

>> Is there a link between being a negative

76:42

person and Alzheimer's and dementia?

76:45

>> Yes. And what's interesting cuz you

76:46

mentioned a gender difference earlier,

76:49

um

76:50

if you're depressed and you're a woman,

76:53

it doubles your risk for Alzheimer's

76:55

disease. If you're depressed and you're

76:57

a man, it quadruples

77:00

your risk.

77:01

>> Wow.

77:02

So, there was a study was done during

77:04

the COVID years, a couple years,

77:07

and it turns out that the rate of

77:10

depression like doubled in women,

77:13

but not in men.

77:15

>> During COVID?

77:16

>> During COVID. And after COVID, when the

77:18

as students came back and everybody was

77:20

back to normal, so-called normal,

77:23

the women stayed depressed.

77:26

At that high level.

77:28

Which is very is a very interesting that

77:30

it should be the women who

77:32

>> So, in

77:32

>> one study, women had 52% less serotonin

77:36

than men. So, I think is really

77:39

interesting women by and large have

77:41

double double the risk depression. Women

77:44

have double the risk of depression as

77:46

men. Their limbic systems are larger,

77:48

which is also involved in

77:50

>> probably, yeah.

77:51

>> more vulnerable in bonding. And then,

77:54

the whole COVID thing we haven't talked

77:56

about. COVID

77:58

causes inflammation in the limbic part

78:00

of the brain. I had scans of people I

78:03

was treating,

78:05

and then they got COVID, and then I

78:07

scanned them again, and you can just see

78:09

this dramatic inflammation in the brain.

78:14

>> If someone's listening now, and they

78:15

just want to they want to improve their

78:17

brain health, they want to avoid

78:18

dementia, they want to be cognitively

78:22

powerful and capable as they age. They

78:24

want to get to 80 years old, 90 years

78:26

old, 100 years old, and have a great

78:28

brain.

78:29

And you just had to and you could only

78:31

tell them to do three things.

78:33

>> Well, Terry said one, exercise.

78:35

>> Okay, exercise, I'm going to do that.

78:38

>> Start every day with today is going to

78:40

be a great day.

78:41

>> Positive day.

78:41

>> Push your brain

78:43

to look for what's right rather than

78:47

what's wrong.

78:48

>> Okay. So, I'm going to be optimistic and

78:51

grateful.

78:51

>> Omega-3 fatty acids.

78:54

And either do it with fish or do it with

78:56

a supplement.

78:56

>> Why did you include omega-3 fatty acids?

78:59

>> Because it decreases inflammation and

79:03

25%

79:05

of the cell membranes in your brain are

79:07

made up of omega-3 fatty acids. And as a

79:10

country, we're dramatically low in them.

79:14

>> And learning. That's maybe one of the

79:15

things that's been left off the list of

79:17

top three things.

79:19

But I mean, I remember you telling me

79:20

that

79:21

how good learning was for the brain. And

79:23

even getting outside and running outside

79:25

versus running on a treadmill is more

79:27

beneficial.

79:28

>> And if you learn while you're

79:29

exercising,

79:31

what you're doing is you're getting

79:33

blood flow to the hippocampus and you're

79:35

more likely to remember it. So,

79:39

>> I heard this, yeah. I had someone tell

79:40

me that they um figured out that they

79:42

could learn better for their exams if

79:44

they did it in a sauna.

79:46

So, they kept It was a scientist that I

79:48

spoke to. She said she keeps learning

79:50

new information when she's in the sauna,

79:52

cuz she realized that when she left the

79:53

sauna and was then tested upon on it,

79:55

she was better able to uh do the exam.

79:59

And I guess that's correlating to what

80:00

you said about because in a sauna,

80:01

you're going to have a lot of blood

80:02

flow, I imagine,

80:04

to the brain?

80:04

>> Yeah.

80:05

>> There's actually a study in JAMA

80:06

Psychiatry

80:08

that one sauna

80:11

bath

80:13

helped depression. Significantly helped

80:16

depression.

80:17

And I think it's because of it's

80:20

balancing the brain. And people who do

80:22

the most saunas have the lowest risk of

80:24

Alzheimer's disease.

80:25

>> Hm.

80:27

What is the most important thing as it

80:28

relates to the subjects that we spoke

80:29

about today, AI, the brain,

80:32

neuroscience.

80:34

That you would like to say to the and

80:36

the people that are listening now. There

80:37

could be a million people listening,

80:39

there could be 20 million people

80:40

listening. If you could say one thing to

80:42

them about the brain,

80:44

AI, neuroscience, whatever you want to

80:45

say, the floor is yours. What would that

80:47

be?

80:49

Over to you first, Terry.

80:51

>> Sleep. Sleep is the time when the body

80:54

not just regenerates, but your memory is

80:57

consolidated. So, things you've

80:59

experienced during the day

81:01

are integrated into your cortex and it's

81:04

an interaction between hippocampus and

81:05

the cortex

81:07

for

81:08

you know, for for episodic memories.

81:10

And and and it's unfortunate what's

81:13

happening with children now, you know,

81:15

they're so competitive to get into

81:17

college that they're cutting back on

81:19

their sleep and it's just the wrong time

81:21

of your life. You shouldn't be cutting

81:22

it back when your brain is

81:24

is developing. So, those two things, I

81:26

would say sleep and exercise are the

81:28

most important thing for your brain.

81:29

>> The floor is yours.

81:31

What would you say to the

81:33

listeners

81:34

about all the things we've talked today?

81:35

What's your closing closing statement?

81:38

>> Well, you know, go back to what I talked

81:40

about in the beginning, which is we've

81:42

just thrown the barn door open

81:45

and let the horse bolt

81:47

out into our schools, into our

81:50

businesses, into our homes.

81:53

And before we even asked is it a gift or

81:58

is it a Trojan horse that's going to

81:59

steal

82:00

from us. We've embraced convenience

82:04

before understanding consequence. And

82:07

we've done it before with video games

82:10

and cell phones and social media and

82:12

marijuana and alcohol and

82:14

opiates and high fructose corn syrup and

82:17

aspartame. And we have to be smarter. We

82:20

have to tame this horse as it's gone

82:24

with wisdom or it's going to trample our

82:26

children. And so I think we have to be

82:29

very thoughtful and it all comes back

82:31

down to is this good for my brain or bad

82:33

for it. Is it good for our collective

82:35

brains or is it potentially bad for it?

82:39

And

82:40

just answer that question with

82:42

information and love of yourself, of

82:46

your family, of your country,

82:48

community.

82:54

Yeah, I'm more anxious than when I came

82:55

in. I don't like that.

82:59

>> It it's it's I'm just it's so upfront in

83:01

my mind for me at the moment because

83:02

I have the hindsight, the wisdom of

83:05

hindsight of all those things you

83:06

mentioned like exercise and processed

83:08

foods and social media and all these

83:10

things that we tried and they all seem

83:12

to follow a similar arc. Some kind of

83:14

new product or discovery is made. The

83:17

early phase, in that early phase people

83:19

who have an incentive for that thing to

83:21

be successful will somewhat like

83:23

gaslight you into thinking that it's

83:25

fine.

83:26

And then we get into the second phase

83:27

where we start to see sort of some

83:29

consequences then we study what's

83:30

actually happened. We figure out that

83:32

there's there was always a trade-off

83:34

and that nobody really understood the

83:36

trade-off.

83:37

And then people change their behavior.

83:39

So now when I come into these new

83:40

technologies where

83:42

the short-term benefit is really clear,

83:44

it's making me more productive,

83:47

I I pause and I go there's going to be a

83:49

trade-off here. There's always a

83:50

trade-off. What is the trade-off? And am

83:53

I comfortable and conscious of what that

83:54

trade-off is?

83:56

And if if the trade-off So I try to

83:57

figure out what the trade-off is with

83:58

things like AI and I go okay, the

83:59

trade-off is probably I'm going to be

84:00

worse at critical thinking

84:02

and then might have an impact on my

84:03

social relationships if I fall in love

84:05

with [ __ ] Annie because she's pretty

84:06

hot to be fair.

84:09

And I really value my critical thinking.

84:11

I really value my ability to um solve

84:14

problems and to articulate myself and to

84:16

write and to communicate with my loved

84:18

ones in an effective way. So what can I

84:20

do if that is the trade-off now? And one

84:23

of the things that I'm doing now feels

84:25

really counterintuitive in a world where

84:27

everybody's got these productivity gains

84:29

cuz they're using these tools, which is

84:30

to refrain. And I I wonder if one of the

84:33

great advantages of the next decade, one

84:35

of the great hedges for anyone that's

84:38

wanting to be a great critical thinker,

84:40

entrepreneur, creative, is to go left

84:43

when everyone's going right.

84:46

Which is to refrain and do it the hard

84:48

way.

84:49

And if we look at history

84:52

in these arcs that we've discovered with

84:54

food and with exercise and all these

84:55

things and dating, doing it the hard

84:57

way, like we said about the marshmallow

84:59

test and delaying the gratification,

85:01

seems to yield the greatest returns. So,

85:04

I think I'm going to do it the hard way.

85:05

>> easiest

85:07

because it won't have the side effects.

85:09

>> Yeah, the hard way.

85:10

>> Right. I want I want to feel good now

85:14

and later as opposed to now, but not

85:18

later.

85:19

>> And to be clear, this doesn't mean I'm

85:20

not going to use AI or ChatGPT. It just

85:22

means that when it matters, when the

85:24

thinking matters, I will think for

85:26

myself.

85:28

And when the communication matters, I'll

85:29

communicate for myself.

85:31

That's what I That's my conclusion.

85:32

>> You should hope that your children will

85:34

feel the same way when they grow up.

85:37

>> will model what you do.

85:40

Right? Every day you model health

85:44

or not health.

85:46

>> Mhm.

85:48

Thank you. Thank you for writing to the

85:50

Well, incredible books that I've got

85:51

around me. I'm going to link them all

85:52

for my viewers that are watching. I've

85:54

got so many of these books. Um the

85:56

incredible one that you wrote for

85:57

parents called Raising Mentally Strong

85:58

Kids. You've got your other book over

86:00

there, Change Your Brain Every Day. And

86:03

I've got this book here from from Terry,

86:05

which is The Deep Learning Revolution.

86:07

And one you wrote most recently called

86:09

ChatGPT and The Future of AI. I'm going

86:11

to link all of them below.

86:12

I'm going to link them with a little bit

86:13

of a summary of what's in them. So, if

86:15

you decide that there's anything here

86:17

that we talked about today that where

86:18

you want to dig in further, please do

86:19

dig in. And I'm also going to link

86:21

both of your link to where people can

86:23

find out more about both of you, your

86:25

websites, and more of your work in the

86:27

comments below. So please do check that

86:28

out everybody listening. We have a

86:30

closing tradition where the last guest

86:31

leaves a question for the next guest, as

86:33

you know, and they don't know who

86:34

they're leaving it for.

86:35

So I'm going to ask you both the

86:36

question.

86:38

Starting with you, Daniel. Are you

86:39

prepared

86:41

for recognition of your next

86:45

health challenge?

86:47

Will you be able to notice its onset?

86:50

And how will you address the challenge,

86:53

even if it means a major lifestyle

86:55

change or way of living?

86:59

Hm?

87:00

>> Okay.

87:02

Yes.

87:04

>> How will you address the challenge, even

87:06

if it means a major lifestyle change or

87:08

way of living?

87:10

>> Well, I'm very clear on the goals I

87:13

have, which is to be vibrant and

87:16

healthy, and not get dementia. So, if I

87:20

need to change something so that

87:22

happens, I'm like all in.

87:25

>> Are you prepared?

87:27

>> Probably not.

87:30

No, I've been blessed with good health.

87:32

I try to live a healthy

87:34

life.

87:36

But the problem is that you can't

87:39

anticipate, you know, as you get older,

87:42

what

87:43

you know, what's ahead, you know.

87:48

Like you mentioned arthritis. I'm

87:49

feeling a little bit of arthritis now.

87:51

I've been arthritis free

87:53

most of all my life.

87:55

And, you know, that's something it's

87:57

very It's to realize that it's coming,

88:00

and there's very little you can do about

88:01

it.

88:03

Is is depressing.

88:05

But on the other hand, things could

88:07

always be worse.

88:09

And sometimes that cheers you up.

88:12

But, the the the the the reality is that

88:15

there are things

88:17

in the world like COVID, you know, that

88:19

you have no control over

88:21

that may

88:23

or an accident or

88:25

Alzheimer's, you know, God forbid.

88:28

You know, that you that is who knows

88:30

what will happen, right? You you have to

88:32

live with whatever life deals with you.

88:35

You know, the time that you have you

88:36

should really spend on

88:39

uh trying to make it a

88:41

a a

88:42

healthy life, a a productive life, a you

88:46

know, satisfying life and and that's

88:47

something that we have control over,

88:49

right?

88:49

>> What are you scared of?

88:53

>> Right now, it's China.

88:57

I you know, I I I I'm not being

88:59

facetious. I I think that it's uh

89:02

it's it's it's it's what a threat that

89:04

is a societal threat. It's not I don't

89:07

think that it's going to affect me and

89:09

I've had great Chinese students inside,

89:10

but I really like I think the the

89:12

Chinese

89:14

people are different from what I see as

89:15

the the country

89:17

uh the the the what they're trying to

89:19

do, their goals that they're taking.

89:21

Uh 20 years ago, if you look at the

89:25

um

89:25

of all the technical areas in physics

89:28

and chemistry and biology and so forth,

89:30

the the 100 most important advances have

89:32

been made

89:34

in in in 20 years ago was like the

89:37

Americans had like, you know, 94 of

89:39

them.

89:41

This year

89:43

it's 74 are Chinese.

89:47

And that's because they made a huge

89:49

investment in science and STEM

89:51

research. They

89:53

They You know, they they put they poured

89:54

out a million engineers for

89:58

to to implement AI,

90:00

right?

90:02

Uh you know, they're they're doing the

90:03

right thing. We did that. Remember when

90:05

the Sputnik uh went over, the Sputnik

90:07

moment?

90:09

We made a huge investment in STEM, in

90:11

science and engineering, and and in

90:13

education.

90:14

>> What was a Sputnik moment?

90:15

>> Oh, okay, '57 when the Russians put a

90:18

satellite that went over the US over and

90:20

over again and we didn't took us years

90:23

to put up our own satellite because we

90:24

had fallen behind.

90:26

But we that investment we've been living

90:28

on

90:29

literally, you know, for the last 60

90:32

years.

90:33

And now the the Chinese have done that

90:35

and and they're going to be advanced and

90:37

they're going to be way beyond us.

90:38

Uh you know, I

90:40

this is

90:41

You asked me, okay? That's something I'm

90:44

I was I'm very very uh

90:46

disappointed in our country that we're

90:48

we're not In fact, we're just doing the

90:49

opposite. We're tearing apart science

90:51

right now with with the present

90:52

administration.

90:53

>> What are you scared of, Daniel?

90:57

>> Losing my wife. That's the most

91:00

the thing that comes to mind. And when I

91:02

was thinking about China and my

91:05

mother-in-law was a prepper.

91:07

And

91:08

>> being someone that's preparing for the

91:09

end of the world.

91:10

>> Prepared for the end of the world.

91:12

And we were in Egypt last year and got a

91:15

call that she had cancer and we were

91:17

there for 3 days and came home.

91:20

And I kept thinking I loved her dearly.

91:23

I'm like, you prepared for the wrong

91:25

thing.

91:26

You should have prepared for cancer.

91:29

Like I think every day we should be in

91:32

the same Alzheimer's prevention program

91:34

is a cancer prevention program. It's a

91:36

heart disease prevention program. It's a

91:38

diabetes prevention program. And I'm

91:42

like, she's prepared for the wrong

91:45

thing. The thing you really want to be

91:47

prepared for is disease, right? And I

91:50

know I'm going to die. I just want to be

91:53

a vital for as long as I can be and hope

91:58

is well, I have a say

92:01

in this.

92:02

Right? Cuz I know I can accelerate

92:06

my body's decline

92:08

or I can decelerate it. And I'm going to

92:10

choose to decelerate it.

92:14

Thank you. We're done.

Interactive Summary

The video features an in-depth conversation between the host, Dr. Daniel Amen, and Dr. Terry Sejnowski, discussing the impact of large language models like ChatGPT on brain health, memory, and cognitive development. The experts highlight concerns about reduced cognitive load and critical thinking, the risks of excessive use of technology for children, and the potential for emotional dependency on AI personas. They provide actionable advice on maintaining a healthy brain, emphasizing the importance of lifelong learning, physical exercise, proper nutrition, and conscious, meaningful interaction with technology to avoid cognitive decline.

Suggested questions

5 ready-made prompts