The REAL Reason Doctors DON'T Prescribe Creatine
656 segments
And when we start getting the the brain
benefits up at this end,
>> Right.
>> what are those brain benefits that they
were recorded in the studies? Is it I'm
going to feel like I slept or is it
something more internal?
>> You likely won't feel anything.
>> Oh, okay.
>> However, when you get to task the next
day, so for example, you're up all
night, you take a high dose creatine,
then you have to go write the final or
the midterm or you can't remember. It's
those things when your memory and and
and doing puzzles or basic task.
Or what about a Stroop test?
>> What's a Stroop test?
>> So, I'm going to get you to do this. I
apologize in advance.
>> Uh-huh.
>> It's one of the most fatiguing things
that you can do and it was one of the
most robust studies to show the efficacy
behind creatine. So, all I simply want
you to do is you can see that there's
words and then corresponding letters,
but you'll notice that the color is
incorrect. So, up here you would see,
you know, you have red, blue, green,
blue, black, but the Stroop test is now
looking at the bottom part.
>> Okay.
>> So, I've tried it. I can only get the
line two without making a mistake.
>> Okay.
>> Okay, so I want you to do this
out loud, but as fast as possible.
>> And am I reading the words or the color?
>> You're reading the color.
>> Okay, so the first one's green, yeah?
>> Uh, yes.
>> Okay, fine.
You want to do it as fast as possible?
>> as possible. Okay, so let's see how you
do.
>> Gosh, this is confusing already. I hit
the second one and I got it wrong in my
head.
>> Depends how much creatine you took.
>> [laughter]
>> I don't think I had creatine today.
>> Okay.
>> Okay.
Green, red, yellow, green, blue, black,
orange, red,
blue,
green, blue, pink, black, gray, yellow,
red, blue, green,
>> [clears throat]
>> black.
>> There you go, see?
>> The study that they did, get this, they
had to do this for 90 straight minutes.
>> Oh, wow.
>> So, you can imagine how fatiguing that
is for someone studying for the MCAT for
medical school or, you know, midterms
being sleep deprived. And you're not
sleep deprived and you struggled, and
you got slower. Now you have to do this
for 90 minutes. And in this classic
study, they gave 20 g of creatine before
they did the test and then after, and it
really improved their ability with speed
and cognition there. So, it's just a
simple example to show, "Wow, our brain
is seeing one thing. We got to maintain
memory and cognition, and creatine can
help maintain some of those factors."
So, you won't feel anything, but
performance of activities like that come
into play.
>> Do you remember how much it improved
their performance on the Stroop test?
>> I would have to get the graph, but it
did prove statistically significant,
yeah.
>> What else is there for me to know about
the impact that creatine can have on the
brain? You know, I think as a
>> [clears throat]
>> as a podcaster who sometimes sits here
for many, many hours interviewing people
on a range of subjects, I'm always
trying to find if there's any way that I
can perform better mentally.
>> Yeah. So, it doesn't boost the brain. It
likely just brings those levels back up
to normal levels before stress, and it
might give you a little bit more. So,
there's been populations, Alzheimer's
disease, clinical depression, uh
concussion. When those populations are
evident, one of the biggest
factors is that they have reduced
creatine in their brain. So, maybe
supplementation can get through the
blood-brain barrier. The brain says, "I
need help." And that's why you see some
improvements there as well. So, I like
to think of the brain that creatine can
act as a safety net. Um and it certainly
won't cause any detrimental effects, but
it's always good to have that because
you never know when I give you a Stroop
test. Like, I'm going to find you
tomorrow, give you this, and say,
"You're going to be practicing all
night. Will you perform better?" But
that's just an example of something that
we go through on a daily basis. If
someone's working on Wall Street or
whichever it is, a really high-stress
demand, uh you know, stuck in traffic
for 2 hours, these all add up, and it's
a cascade of stressors that
unfortunately most people go through.
And now that we have a nutrient that is
being made in the brain, but during
times of stress, it likely needs a
little bit of help.
>> For the last couple of years, I've been
working on something that I realized
every podcaster listening to this, but
actually probably every creator
listening to this might just need
Podcasting is difficult for many
reasons, and one of them is that these
hosting platforms don't give you much
information. And also, because they're
so fragmented, you kind of have to go
through every single platform, uploading
it to YouTube, and then taking the same
big old video file and uploading it to
Spotify's platform. It takes huge
amounts of time, and that friction means
most of us don't do it. That is the
problem we set out to solve, and so we
built something called Flight Cast,
which you can find at flightcast.com.
And today, Flight Cast is also one of
our show sponsors. And some of the
world's biggest podcasters are now using
our platform to run their shows, because
it gives you an edge. It saves you time.
It gives you analytics most people won't
typically get. It allows you to use AI
to be more informed on your show. And it
has growth tools that other hosting
platforms don't have. So, podcasters
that are using Flight Cast have this
unfair advantage. So, go to
flightcast.com/doac
now.
Of all the things I thought would ever
turn up on my desk, a red light
toothbrush was not one of them. Here we
are. This is made by our sponsor Bon
Charge, and you'll probably know of
their red light face mask and their
infrared sauna blanket, because I use
them religiously and I've spoken about
them on this podcast before. But, their
toothbrush is new to me. I was sent one
of these a few weeks ago, and ever since
then I've been using it religiously
because I love their products. And this
is the first toothbrush that combines
both red light and near infrared light
with sonic cleaning at the same time.
The same red light technology that's
used for skin and inflammation is now
built into a device you already know so
well. And I'm using it at least two
times a day at the moment to clean my
teeth. It's great for your gums, for
stimulating gum circulation, and for
soreness. And the best part is, it's not
an extra thing to add to your routine.
It just replaces your current
toothbrush. If you give it a try, you'll
get 20% off at boncharge.com/doac.
And also, you'll get free shipping and a
1-year warranty. That's
bondcharge.com/doac.
>> What about inflammation in the body? So,
what is inflammation? And is there a
link between creatine supplementation
and inflammation?
>> There is. So, unfortunately, I'm 49. So,
at the age of 40, I have this systemic
inflammation that went up. And we all
know this because around the age of 30,
you know, you can work out and nothing
hurts and then all of a sudden you wake
up one day when you're in your 40s and
50s and things hurt. So, systemic
inflammation is happening all the time
and unfortunately, it accelerates aging.
We're more sore more often and it can
lead to a lot of arthritis or or joint
pain and things like that. Creatine does
have anti-inflammatory effects, but a
big distinction. Creatine is [snorts]
not like acetaminophen or ibuprofen
which directly as a drug effect blocks
that, but it has been shown to decrease
markers of inflammation specifically
during long duration exercise. So, this
is an important distinction. Weight
training is too acute.
But when you do Ironman, triathlon,
things like that, those individuals who
took creatine 20 g a day for 5 days
beforehand, they had reductions in
inflammation markers. So, that might
allow that individual to recover
quicker, not get ill, and then perform
more optimally. From a weight training
perspective, we see that it decreases
markers of muscle damage. So, it has
these anti-inflammatory and
anti-catabolic effects as well.
>> Interesting.
>> Yeah.
>> And what about people that have
neurodegenerative disorders?
>> Yes, so Alzheimer's is is the area we're
really starting to focus on and a couple
single arm studies came out last year by
Matt Taylor and Aaron Smith showing that
20 g a day for 8 weeks did increase
brain creatine levels in Alzheimer's
patients and it seemed to improve
measures of memory and cognition there
as well. So, again, using the same
mechanisms. It decreases inflammation,
it maintains brain bioenergetics, and it
might actually have a neuroprotection
effect as well. There's evidence in cell
cultures and in rodents that there's
some lines there, but in humans we're
still in a in the infancy. But if it can
have any benefit to any neurological
disease, it's huge and there's a lot of
hope, especially around Alzheimer's.
>> There was an 8-week trial on Alzheimer's
patients that also showed modest muscle
gains and a 1.9 kg increase in hand grip
strength.
Which is a key predictor of survival in
dementia patients. And which was a
landmark study of 20 Alzheimer's
patients found that taking 20 g of
creatine daily for 8 weeks increased
brain creatine levels by 11% and
significantly improved the cognitive
test scores they showed as the Journal
of Psychiatry and Brain Science.
>> And that one's really exciting and I
think more future studies will come out.
The limitation with those is that there
was no placebo to compare to, but again,
it's just showing that yes, creatine can
be used as an effective adjunct, yeah.
>> And because there is impact on our
brain, is there impact on our mental
health with creatine?
>> Excellent point. So, the best lines of
evidence here come from clinical
depression and anxiety. The group out of
Utah in the United States have clearly
shown that creatine in addition to other
therapies. So, this is important.
Creatine by itself has never been shown
to be a standalone, but with SSRIs or
cognitive behavioral therapy or
methamphetamine use in populations under
medical supervision, the addition of
creatine seemed to improve symptoms and
it's likely going back to all the ones
we've already talked about where it
improves bioenergetics, it improves
neuro transmission or neuromodulation,
but it also in animals has been shown to
improve a protein called BDNF. So, this
protein is involved in brain plasticity.
So, there's a whole bunch of emerging
evidence and hope that creatine one day
will be used as a treatment in the
toolbox for a lot of these clinical
issues. PTSD also comes to my mind.
>> There was a study in Gatorade Sports
Science Institute which PubMed published
that said it a study of over 200,000
adults found that those who consumed the
least amount of creatine in their daily
diet had the highest rates of depressive
symptoms.
>> Yes, that's correct. And the common
denominators those with clinical
depression and anxiety, when you measure
their baseline creatine stores very
similar to concussion or Alzheimer's,
they're reduced. So, therefore,
obviously, this
condition or series of conditions is
causing a disruption at the brain
bioenergetic level and creatine levels
are decreasing.
>> There's another impairment that said in
a clinical trial of women with major
depression adding 5 g of creatine to
their daily antidepressant
>> Yes.
>> doubled their remission rate over 8
weeks.
>> That's correct, yes. And that uh group
is from uh Perica Renshaw's group out of
Utah. Uh they do great work. Our hope,
and I'm collaborating uh with some
colleagues now to look at creatine as a
standalone treatment versus placebo,
could it have some beneficial effects
there? So, that's very exciting to come
out.
>> If I don't want to be supplementing with
creatine, is there what are the foods
that I can eat that are high in creatine
naturally?
>> They're primarily uh animal-based, so
seafood and red meat. Um you know,
herring is going to have one of the
highest concentrations, uh salmon,
uh as well as beef. Uh very small
amounts in milk and dairy, so you'd have
to drink all the the milk in the Jersey
cow to get a sufficient amount. So, uh
it definitely comes down to animal-based
flesh, yeah.
>> There's some other studies that I that I
love that I I think I've had you talk
about before. One of them was um young
athletes who took 5 g of creatine daily
slept an average of 1 hour longer
>> Yes.
>> on training days.
>> Yeah, we did that study a few years ago
in uh uh young biological females who
were healthy, and on the days that they
trained and took creatine,
this is interesting because they
actually slept an hour longer uh
compared to the placebo. So, this is a
very interesting fact. So, creatine, you
know, we now know it has brain
bioenergetics, and there's two
arguments. If it's making the brain
recover, wouldn't you need less sleep,
right? Now, in this study, it showed
that improved, so maybe these
individuals trained at a higher capacity
and allowed the brain to have more
homeostasis to come back. So, this is an
a study that needs to be replicated in
males as well to see can creatine
improve sleep quantity, and if it is, I
think that's a game changer. I think
everybody on the planet would raise
their hand and say, "Hey, I need more
sleep."
>> Is there anything else we haven't
covered as it relates to creatine?
>> You know, the expected gains versus the
hype gains. I think there's evidence
there that creatine can have a
an effect. I I think it's getting
overhyped, especially around the brain
for what it can do. It's one tool in the
toolbox and I think it's one of those
things that I'd like to show or, you
know, talk about for sure, yeah.
>> Well, what do you mean by that?
>> So, if you think of the toolbox when it
comes to a plan, whenever you need to go
fix things, you simply say, "Where's my
toolbox?" You can't do anything without
a plan. And the way I like to preface
this is the most popular tool in
anybody's toolbox is the hammer. Now,
from a lifestyle perspective, what do
you think the hammer represents? What
would you decide that the hammer
represents?
>> Um as in like a
>> Is it weight training? Is it cardio? Is
it creatine? Is it protein? Is it sleep?
>> Sleep.
>> Okay. So, I say weight training is going
to be the hammer.
>> Okay.
>> Okay.
Now, what about the screwdriver? Always
need a screwdriver.
>> Creatine.
>> No, I think aerobic training or sleep
comes way before creatine.
>> Okay.
>> But most people say, "Hey, I can fix a
lot of things with that." Now, remember,
we have a nice big toolbox.
I like to think of creatine as the
multifactorial wrench or screwdriver.
Because creatine has profound benefits
for muscle, a little bit for bone, of
course brain and other areas of the
body. So, you can hit something with
this.
You can open it up and fix something
with this. It's heavy. You can also pull
out the measuring tape. Your argument,
sleep. This could be protein, whichever
it is. So, when you put all these things
in your toolbox, you're now having a
greater comprehensive plan to improve
health.
>> So, you said weight training was the
hammer.
>> Hammer. I like to consider if you were
to choose one modality of exercise,
weight training is a little bit superior
to cardio. You get pretty much all the
same benefits of cardiovascular
exercise, and then you get more with
obviously an increase in lean tissue
mass and performance. Weight training if
done effectively can actually improve
mitochondrial health. You can actually
improve VO2 max if done correctly,
and you don't need a lot of it. So, I
think we've switched from just doing
cardio to now incorporating weight
training to be effective.
>> So, weight training.
>> Yes.
>> What are the sort of misconceptions
about
weight training, and why are you so
positive about it?
>> Yeah, I think one of the biggest myths
is that you always need to lift heavy to
put on muscle mass.
And world-renowned [clears throat]
researchers in this area have clearly
shown now that lighter weights if
performed to a lot of effort almost to
fatigue, if done correctly, you can get
the same increases in muscle mass as
then compared to lifting heavy weights.
However, if your goal is just to get
stronger, lifting heavy is always there.
So, I think this is a cool thing for
people. Some days if you have a little
bit of soreness or you don't have a lot
of energy, you can lift lighter weights
but just to fatigue. Whereas other days
you come in Monday, you've had your
coffee, whichever it is, you're ready to
go, you can lift heavy. So, I think
there's not one concrete way. There's a
little bit of variety here as well.
>> And why are you putting it above
cardiovascular work?
>> Yeah, I think the benefits there is that
cardiovascular exercise will make you
live longer and and
and healthier. But the downfall with
cardiovascular exercise, it doesn't
stimulate strength or the
musculoskeletal system as much as we
we'd hope. So, improving muscle mass and
that is very difficult to do with
cardio. Maybe sprint interval training
will do that, but the cool thing with
weight training is you get
cardiovascular benefits, but you also
get those profound musculoskeletal
benefits. So, if I was to tell anybody
if there's one form of exercise to do,
it's weight training, but you've got to
do cardio as well. So, do both.
>> And if I just do weight training, what
am I missing from not doing cardio
training?
>> Yeah, if you do weight training
improperly where you're lifting heavy
heavy weight with low repetitions all
the time, you're likely going to
jeopardize capillary density or
mitochondrial health. These are things
that sort of move blood flow to and from
your muscles. You could decrease VO2 max
or a fitness parameter for metabolic
health fitness. So, at the end of the
day, everybody should be doing both.
But, if you only have time to do weight
training or cardio, you still benefit
cuz the majority of the population
doesn't do any.
>> And how how much how often do you think?
>> It's amazing that it's a small amount.
So, let's just do cardio. Most countries
will say 150 minutes of physical
activity at a moderate level over a
week.
I'm okay with that. I'd like it to be
higher. I'd also like the intensity to
be a bit higher. So, when you tell an
average individual 150 minutes a week,
most people say, "Well, I'm going to do
70." Or, "I'm going to do 30." "I'm
going to hold the couch down and watch
Netflix." So, we're given 150 and we
say, you know, if you can do 21 minutes
or 22 minutes a day for 7 days a week,
that's going to be a brisk walk or
whichever. We'd like to be at a higher
intensity if possible.
Now, when it comes to weight training,
this might be surprising, but 2 days a
week or more is all you basically need.
And you can do a whole body routine. So,
you don't need to go in there and just
do chest and biceps Monday and then legs
Tuesday. You can, but if you say I want
to do whole body of training Monday,
Wednesday, Friday, that is great as
well. So, a little bit of volume or
frequency goes a long way, especially as
we get older. That's the key.
>> Why especially as we get older?
>> Well, based on this graph here, it's
clearly showing a detrimental effect.
So, if you can see here, you know, you
have muscle mass on the the x-axis or
the y-axis, and then you're having all
the catastrophic effects as we get
older. So, unfortunately, you know, 20
and 30 looks great.
>> When you're 20 and 40 years old.
>> When you're 20 and 40 years old or all
the way from 22 40, you can see great.
That's probably the area that you're
going to have the most muscle.
>> Yeah.
>> But, look what happens 40, age 60, 80,
and if you live to be 100.
It's catastrophic. You're losing muscle
mass at an accelerated rate. On average
is about 1% per year after the age of
40.
>> Even if you're training?
>> So, if you're training, you're
maintaining that. So, this is the
average sedentary inactive population.
You lose strength at about 1. or 1 to 3%
even faster. Now,
if we were to maintain resistance
training, that muscle mass would
plateau.
So, I can't stress this enough. Although
we focus on creatine, if you were to
choose one thing to do today is
exercise. And the only form of exercise
that really maintains muscle is
weight-bearing or resistance training.
And if that's the case, you're going to
have way more muscle later on in life.
So, you can pick up the grandkids. You
can walk those stairs. You can do more
functionality things later on in life.
>> Can you not just do I don't know, 60
years old start training then?
>> You can absolutely and you get profound
benefits. You can be 80 or 100 and you
still get benefits. It's never too late
to start.
But one of the things we've already
talked about is if you do weight
training and add in a little bit of
creatine,
it gets a bit higher. If you added in
protein, it gets even higher. So, again,
nutrition, you know, if exercise is
king, the queen is going to be
nutrition. They go hand in hand all
throughout lifespan. You got to have
both.
>> And on the subject of protein, you're
saying that can when combined with
creatine, it's a
force multiplier.
>> It's it's a force multiplier when it
comes to performance and lean tissue
mass. So, there's been a few studies
when you combine a high-quality protein
with creatine, they have been shown to
increase lean tissue mass and muscle
performance a little bit more than each
alone, yeah.
>> Does the average person get protein
through their diet?
>> You know, I think nowadays we do and and
I think this is overhyped as well. I
think if you're getting about 1.2 to 1.6
g per kilogram. So, you know, if you're
70 kg, that's going to be on average
about 84 to about 115 g of protein. I
think we're so conscious now of the
health benefits of protein that most
people are. I think if you're training
really intensely five, six days a week
and you take a gram per pound, that's
probably the max. But a lot of times
when you take an excess protein, it
doesn't go to your body area that you're
probably hoping. It doesn't all go to
your muscle. It's used for other things
like hormones and blood cells, things
like that. But I think nowadays most
people are likely getting enough
protein. The question is, are they
getting enough high-quality protein? So
vegans and vegetarians can definitely
get enough protein. They might just need
to eat a little bit more to get all
those essential amino acids, which we
need.
>> If you love the Darvis CEO brand and you
watch this channel, please do me a huge
favor. Become part of the 15% of the
viewers on this channel that have hit
the subscribe button. It helps us
tremendously and the bigger the channel
gets, the bigger the guests.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The transcript provides a detailed overview of the potential brain and physiological benefits of creatine supplementation, particularly when dealing with stressors like sleep deprivation or mental fatigue. It explains that while creatine is not a cognitive 'booster,' it serves as a 'safety net' for brain bioenergetics. The conversation also explores creatine's anti-inflammatory properties, its promising role as an adjunct therapy for neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's and mental health issues, and emphasizes the importance of weight training and proper protein intake as foundational pillars for long-term health and preventing age-related muscle loss.
Videos recently processed by our community