HomeVideos

The Anti-Woke Expert: “We Are Witnessing The Fall Of The UK & The USA!” - Konstantin Kisin

Now Playing

The Anti-Woke Expert: “We Are Witnessing The Fall Of The UK & The USA!” - Konstantin Kisin

Transcript

3248 segments

0:00

one of the terrible things about

0:01

wokeness is that we're at risk of

0:03

destroying the very thing that we now

0:04

enjoy freedom because other countries

0:07

see that as weakness and they capitalize

0:08

on it how do you prove that threat is

0:10

real because this has already happened

0:12

and we'll get into this in more detail

0:14

Conant kiss is the sharp wited saturnist

0:16

podcast host and social commentator

0:18

unafraid to discuss some of the most

0:20

controversial topics and challenging

0:22

questions that Society is struggling

0:23

with ideology is a very bad thing

0:26

because the moment you buy into a

0:27

prepackaged set of ideas about what

0:29

you're supposed to believe you can very

0:31

quickly find yourself not interested in

0:32

the truth for example the ideology of

0:34

wokeness creates a very simplistic and

0:36

frankly ridiculous way of looking at

0:38

people not as individuals but as groups

0:41

with a hierarchy of Oppression and

0:42

promotion of victimhood which is what

0:44

makes them so dangerous because when you

0:46

teach people to be victims you actually

0:48

cause them to suffer in real life we're

0:51

weakening ourselves and now we censor

0:53

everything political labeling is a

0:54

weapon people use against their

0:56

opponents and political correctness is

0:58

preventing you from expressing a descent

1:00

opinion you can't say that that's hate

1:01

speech but as we spend more time arguing

1:03

about trivial issues instead of real

1:05

stuff that matters the dominant

1:07

civilization becomes more divided

1:09

especially from the inside and other

1:10

countries get to make a play for that

1:12

dominant position and it will mean that

1:13

the values of the west human rights

1:15

equality of treat and freedom of speech

1:17

those values will not be considered

1:18

values at all they don't want to hold

1:20

hands and sink Bay and I'm convinced

1:22

that the geopolitics we have seen in the

1:24

last many years would not be happening

1:26

if we were not signaling weakness in the

1:28

division is there a way to stop the

1:30

division here's what you

1:33

do question if you could sit at a table

1:36

with any four guests from the D CEO who

1:39

would you choose here's a challenge for

1:41

the entire D CEO Community if we hit 10

1:45

million subscribers by the end of

1:47

2024 you will get to pick four guests

1:50

for your dream conversation and you can

1:52

make it weird or you can make it

1:53

wonderful and here is the best part

1:56

3,000 of you that subscribe will be

1:58

invited to join this conversation live

2:01

in person and for free subscribe now and

2:05

let's make this happen

2:10

together

2:12

Constantine who are you and what do you

2:15

do and I have to add to that why did you

2:17

do

2:18

it my history is I was born in the late

2:22

Soviet Union and I grew up in that

2:24

Society watched the collapse as a young

2:26

man young boy actually um and then saw

2:30

the craziness of the emergence of modern

2:32

Russia which was an experience unlike

2:34

any other really it was pretty insane

2:36

what happened um and then there was a

2:39

very very brief window in my family's

2:41

time when we went from being very poor

2:44

when I was born to being very rich to

2:46

being very poor in the space of like 10

2:48

years and in the 5year period when my

2:51

family did have money they sent me to

2:53

boarding school in the UK and that's how

2:55

I I ended up here and then fast forward

2:58

a bunch of years um I started a podcast

3:01

with another

3:02

comedian called Francis Foster called

3:05

trigonometry we're about to hit a

3:07

million subscribers today which is

3:09

pretty exciting yeah and the reason I do

3:12

what I do is um I have a different

3:15

perspective to most people uh most

3:17

people who were born here grew up here

3:19

who take what we have here as a given

3:21

they take it for granted in my opinion

3:23

many people I've seen that the world is

3:25

not like this everywhere I've seen also

3:28

that societies don't necessarily last

3:31

forever uh cultures don't necessarily

3:33

last forever civilizations don't

3:34

necessarily last forever so the reason I

3:37

do what I do is I'm trying to remind

3:40

people in the west how privileged and

3:43

truly lucky we are to live in the

3:45

society and we've talked you know in the

3:48

last 10 years in particular so much

3:49

about different forms of privilege you

3:51

know male privilege White Privilege the

3:54

one form of privilege that we don't ever

3:56

talk about for some reason is Western

3:57

privilege and actually I believe that's

3:59

the one that we really should be talking

4:01

about and should be talking about from a

4:03

position of gratitude uh because we are

4:06

incredibly lucky to live uh in the west

4:10

uh and because we don't know that I

4:13

believe we're at risk of destroying the

4:15

very things that we now

4:16

enjoy an immigrants love letter to the

4:19

West is the title of your book it's I

4:20

love this title um for a variety of

4:24

reasons the word love is really

4:26

intentional why did you include the word

4:28

love

4:30

because how I feel you know um when

4:31

you've come to a place from outside it's

4:34

easier to see what makes it special uh

4:37

and so I'm incredibly grateful for the

4:39

opportunities that people like me enjoy

4:42

but actually all of us enjoy the freedom

4:44

to make of your life what you will the

4:46

freedom to speak your mind at least

4:47

until recently the freedom to pursue

4:50

things the freedom you know one of the

4:52

bedrocks of our societies is capitalism

4:54

now capitalism is based on the idea of

4:56

private property private property

4:58

doesn't really exist in most of the rest

5:00

of the world if you are a billionaire

5:03

even in Russia um you might be a

5:05

billionaire today but if you cross vad

5:07

Putin or whoever else might be in charge

5:09

you will go to prison and have all your

5:11

assets taken away from you and that's

5:13

what happened to Mel horovsky Jack ma in

5:15

China he made some comments about like

5:18

banking regulations it wasn't even

5:19

particularly controversial stuff and

5:21

then he disappears for a year and comes

5:23

back with you know completely different

5:24

set of opinions all of a sudden and

5:26

loses most of his money so we have the

5:29

luxury in in the west to do what we want

5:33

far more than any human beings have ever

5:35

had in the history of humanity and I

5:37

love that I love that freedom and I love

5:39

the the opportunities that I've had to

5:42

build my own life build my family's life

5:44

to give my son now opportunities that he

5:46

never would have enjoyed in a billion

5:48

years in another country so what is the

5:50

threat because you love the UK it's all

5:52

going great you know um what is the

5:55

threat that you see on the horizon and

5:56

how do you prove that threat is real if

5:59

you look at history and I'm no historian

6:01

but if you read interesting people about

6:03

history most civilizations are not

6:05

destroyed from the outside they're

6:07

destroyed through suicide uh through

6:09

cultural suicide and I think one of the

6:12

big threats I've been raising the alarm

6:14

on for a long time is what people talk

6:16

about as wo culture or Progressive you

6:18

know rampant progressivism whatever you

6:20

want to call it but at the heart of it

6:22

is the idea that we are bad our society

6:26

is bad it's based our history is bad

6:28

it's based on you know slavery and

6:30

colonialism and exploitation and

6:32

imperialism and all of this stuff and

6:34

how do you prove that well there's

6:36

several ways to think about it the first

6:38

one is if you thought your Society was

6:41

bad why would you defend it why would

6:44

you teach its values to your children

6:46

why would you want it to persevere and

6:49

continue to exist if you look

6:51

geopolitically in the last many years as

6:53

I've been predicting now for a long time

6:55

look at what happened in Ukraine look at

6:58

uh what happened in Afghanistan with the

7:00

withdrawal of American forces look at

7:02

what China is now doing in terms of how

7:04

muscular it's becoming about Taiwan as

7:07

the West loses confidence as the West

7:09

becomes more divided as the West becomes

7:10

more distracted as we spend more time

7:13

you know it's a tried thing to say but

7:14

as we spend more time arguing about what

7:16

a woman is instead of real stuff that

7:18

matters other people around the world

7:20

see that as weakness and they capitalize

7:23

on it and I'm convinced that the things

7:25

we have seen in terms of geopolitics in

7:27

the last many years would not be

7:29

happening happen if we were not

7:30

signaling weakness and division you

7:33

politically Affiliated at all do do you

7:36

consider yourself to be on the left or

7:37

the right or neither or well here's how

7:40

I think about it right uh my interest is

7:45

in our society

7:48

thriving our culture thriving our

7:50

culture doing better and uh I don't

7:53

think the right or the left is always

7:56

right it's contextual right there are

7:58

times when you want higher taxes and

8:01

more government spending there are times

8:03

when you want lower taxes and less

8:05

government spending there are times when

8:07

you need more immigration you know after

8:10

World War II Britain Australia Canada

8:13

many countries wanted more immigrants to

8:15

come because they needed to rebuild

8:17

their society uh there are times when

8:19

you need less immigration and so I think

8:22

it's about where you are in the moment

8:24

as opposed to these rigid ideological

8:27

positions like you know I am Pro

8:29

immigration I'm anti-immigration I think

8:31

both of those are pretty misguided

8:33

positions what you want is to be in the

8:36

right place at the right time so I don't

8:39

know if you've noticed this but it seems

8:41

to me like political labeling is now

8:43

mostly a weapon that people use against

8:45

their opponents right like if I don't

8:47

agree with you it's convenient for me to

8:49

label you as a member of the opposite

8:52

tribe so if I'm on the right well you're

8:54

a communist if I'm on the left well

8:56

you're far right and and this is how we

8:58

have conversation now um I have some

9:01

positions that are currently considered

9:03

rightwing I have some positions that are

9:05

currently considered leftwing and you

9:07

know I just one of the things I really

9:09

learned from my history and my family's

9:11

history and I talk about this in the

9:12

book as you know is that ideology is a

9:15

very bad thing always and so the moment

9:18

you buy into a prepackaged set of ideas

9:21

about what you're supposed to believe

9:23

you very quickly find yourself having to

9:25

believe things that you don't actually

9:27

agree with so that you get to stay in

9:29

the tribe mhm I don't care about the

9:32

tribe I care about the truth there's a

9:35

quote you um you referenced which uh I

9:38

actually sent to my friends earlier on

9:39

and I was talking to them um it is I

9:42

have no interest whatsoever in the false

9:43

dichotomy of right versus left if there

9:45

is one thing my Soviet childhood taught

9:47

me it's that subscribing to someone

9:49

else's ideology will always inevit

9:51

inevitably mean having to suspend your

9:53

own judgment about right and wrong to

9:55

appease your tribe which is on chapter

9:57

one of your book on page 21 and it

9:59

really

10:00

um you know as a podcaster when you

10:03

really want you're genuinely curious and

10:05

you want to interview lots of people

10:06

from lots of backgrounds the the great

10:08

thing about doing this job is I have to

10:10

teach myself to always look at the other

10:13

side so if you represent one side my job

10:15

in many respects is to try and

10:16

understand the other side so we can talk

10:17

about the other side as well to like

10:18

represent the other side and um that's

10:21

been really useful for me because it's

10:22

stopped me falling into the Trap of like

10:24

conforming with a tribe and also as you

10:26

say like when you talk about the right

10:28

and left thing being a label and a

10:30

weapon that people will use it's the

10:32

same when a journalist wants to write

10:33

about me what they'll do is they'll find

10:35

the most right-wing person that's ever

10:37

been on my podcast and they'll say he

10:38

interviews people like yes insert name

10:41

insert name yeah as if to say I am those

10:44

two people yes or in our case with

10:47

trigonometry what happens is we are

10:49

people who started our show because we

10:51

were pushing back against the woke

10:53

Progressive Dogma in our comedy industry

10:55

at the time and so a lot of our early

10:58

guests were exploring ing perspectives

11:00

that were not ours we were two remain

11:02

voters and when the remain when the

11:05

brexit vote happened we were really

11:07

confused because we were part of that

11:09

kind of elitist Metropolitan you know I

11:12

don't know anyone who voted brexit kind

11:14

of thing but my perspective was I found

11:18

it odd that people were saying well you

11:19

know the reason people voted for brexit

11:21

is because half the country is racist

11:23

and I was like I mean come on that

11:25

that's just factually incorrect we both

11:27

know that uh that's not to say the big

11:29

people don't exist and that doesn't mean

11:31

that some brex of Voters weren't racist

11:33

but to explain a complex phenomenon like

11:36

that by a simplistic explanation of that

11:39

just wasn't accurate so we had a lot of

11:41

people who were Pro brexit on the show

11:44

to understand where they're coming from

11:45

well one of the things that happens is

11:48

if you talk to a lot of people from one

11:49

side then the people from the other side

11:51

say what you just said well he's talk to

11:53

this this and this I won't go on his

11:55

show right and then they use that

11:58

against you to say well you only talk to

12:01

these people and like I'm like we've

12:03

we've invited your Owen Joneses and your

12:04

Ash sakas and all the others and Ash

12:06

should come on soon and and we've had

12:08

lots of people from different

12:09

perspectives but if I'm writing an

12:11

article about you or if I want to tweet

12:13

something about you it's very easy to

12:15

use what is wokeism as far as you see it

12:18

because the word kind of sounds like a

12:20

compliment it was initially it was a

12:22

self- compliment initially so wokeness

12:24

came along really in around 2014 and

12:27

there if you are interested we can talk

12:29

about why it does around that time

12:31

because it's a very interesting thing

12:32

that I actually think speaks to the

12:34

moment we're in more broadly um but it

12:36

was initially used by uh people

12:39

particularly kind of black lives matter

12:41

and racial activists in America about

12:44

themselves and what they were saying is

12:46

we are awakened to certain realizations

12:50

realizations like what they call

12:52

intersectionality which is the idea that

12:55

you know different racial and sexual and

12:58

other groups and Society are treated

13:00

differently um and we're now awake to

13:03

this that's what wokeness meant and now

13:05

we are aware these systemic forces that

13:07

are disadvantaging certain groups and

13:10

now we're going to pursue activism

13:12

that's designed to address you know

13:13

white privilege male privilege and all

13:15

of this other stuff but very quickly

13:18

what happened is a lot of people looked

13:20

at some of the ways these people were

13:22

behaving and other people around them

13:24

were behaving and started making fun of

13:26

it which is what often happens and so

13:28

now the word work is kind of an insult

13:30

that's being used to say these people

13:32

are somewhat detached from reality and

13:34

they're obsessed about trivial issues um

13:38

that don't actually have much bearing on

13:39

reality they're not interested in facts

13:41

they're interested in narratives and so

13:42

on um but if you're asking me what woke

13:45

culture really is it's a combination of

13:48

things first and foremost it's the

13:51

promotion and celebration of

13:53

victimhood first and foremost then you

13:56

take that victimhood and you say

13:58

different groups are differently

14:00

victimized some groups are victimized so

14:03

black people ethnic minorities women U

14:06

and by the way of course there's a

14:07

kernel truth to all these things right

14:10

uh certain groups

14:11

are disadvantaged in society or perhaps

14:15

a better way of saying is generally

14:17

speaking have worse outcomes than others

14:19

and that you know we can explore why

14:20

that is in in more detail um but what we

14:24

then do is we build a a hierarchy of

14:26

Oppression some groups are more

14:28

oppressed than others which makes them

14:30

better morally Superior to others and

14:32

there are some other groups that are

14:34

suspect because they're doing better so

14:37

this ideology kind of says the way to

14:38

work out who is oppressed and who is the

14:42

oppressor because if you have the

14:43

oppressed you have to have someone who's

14:45

oppressing them we can't say you know

14:47

different groups do different in society

14:49

for all sorts of different reasons if

14:52

someone is not doing as well as someone

14:53

else that's because they've been

14:54

oppressed right uh and then you work out

14:57

this hierarchy you know white people are

14:58

the evil at the top uh you throw in some

15:01

other successful minorities you know for

15:03

example uh in the UK and in

15:05

America uh Asians from the Far East

15:08

Chinese Koreans Japanese they do very

15:11

well right so they are now seen as part

15:13

of the kind of more the oppressor groups

15:16

that's why in American colleges for

15:17

example they're discriminated against in

15:20

admissions because they do better than

15:22

Hispanics and and blacks right so uh

15:26

it's essentially a way of creating a

15:28

very very simplistic and frankly

15:30

ridiculous way of looking at people not

15:33

as individuals you know Steven

15:34

Constantin but as groups black white

15:38

russian Jewish whatever way you want to

15:39

look at it and it's this generalized

15:42

thing and one of the reasons it's so

15:44

destructive is it's asking all the wrong

15:46

questions it's it's asking the question

15:48

of why do why why are people struggling

15:51

right but it doesn't ask it from the

15:52

right perspective the real you know

15:54

poverty is the norm the real question is

15:56

what creates Prosperity what creates

15:58

success uccess what creates uh

16:00

successful outcomes for different groups

16:02

and if you just focus on you know what

16:04

happened to a certain group 200 years

16:06

ago you're really not going to get to

16:08

the answer of how to uplift people in in

16:10

the present moment so it's the elevation

16:12

of victimhood it's Obsession about

16:15

racial and sexual and gender Dynamics um

16:19

and it's the promotion of a kind of

16:21

anti-western anti- white anti-male

16:24

ideology uh that I believe is very very

16:27

dangerous to actually the very great

16:30

societies that we've created which are

16:31

based on the idea that you know I have

16:34

some issues with multiculturalism but a

16:36

multiracial society I think is a very

16:38

healthy thing provided we are not

16:40

encouraged to see each other as members

16:42

of separate and divided tribes but that

16:46

is exactly what this ideology does what

16:49

is the harm of victimhood and how does

16:52

how is that like really showing up in

16:54

people's everyday lives from an

16:55

individual standpoint and so I really

16:58

want to know like the how victimhood is

17:00

becoming self harm so if I choose to

17:02

adopt a victimhood mindset how does that

17:04

hurt me Steven well oh I mean there's a

17:07

hundred different ways but one of the

17:09

the thing things we know from psychology

17:11

is what they call perception is

17:12

projection I don't know if you're

17:13

familiar with this idea okay you've had

17:15

Jordan Peterson on the show right so one

17:17

of the things he talks about is you

17:19

cannot see unless you have a hierarchy

17:22

of value in your mind right there is an

17:25

almost unlimited number of things I

17:27

could be looking at in this room there's

17:29

a bunch of books behind you there's

17:30

cameras in the room your producers over

17:32

there there's a wall there's lights

17:33

there's all kinds of things but I'm

17:35

looking at you why because in this

17:37

moment you're the most important thing

17:39

that's happening to me in this room

17:41

right our

17:42

conversation however if I walk into this

17:45

room and I am triggered by

17:47

books right I wouldn't be able to focus

17:50

on you I would be be a only be able to

17:52

focus on what's behind you right now

17:54

let's say you walk around thinking that

17:57

because of your racial background

17:59

everyone's out to get you well what are

18:01

you going to see out in the world you're

18:04

going to see people look at you funny

18:05

now people look at you funny for all

18:07

sorts of different reasons people look

18:08

at me funny people look at women funny

18:10

people look at men funny for all sorts

18:11

of different reasons you might walk past

18:14

the police officer and you might think

18:15

well I know that my racial background

18:18

makes me a victim of police brutality

18:21

therefore I'm going to be on edge what

18:23

does that mean well if a police officer

18:24

says something to me to you you might

18:26

interpret it differently than you might

18:28

have done as if you were just a normal

18:30

guy right and on and on it goes so you

18:34

bring your perceptual filters into every

18:37

situation and therefore the outcomes

18:39

that you experience are predetermined to

18:42

a very significant part not by the other

18:45

people but by your own expectations and

18:48

so when you teach people to be victims

18:50

you make them victims you actually cause

18:53

them to suffer in real life and the

18:55

people who need to be resilient and

18:57

strong and to be taught that you may be

19:01

mistreated sometimes by different people

19:04

but you have the capacity to overcome

19:06

that you have the capacity to make that

19:08

you can be whoever you want you live in

19:10

a free Society where no one can stop you

19:12

the people who need that message the

19:14

most are the people who are actually

19:16

victims the people who actually suffer

19:18

discrimination the people who actually

19:20

come from difficult backgrounds they

19:23

need that message more than anyone it

19:25

reminded me of that video I saw you do

19:28

or feat in where you talk about the scar

19:30

experiment which

19:33

um made it very real for anyone that

19:35

hasn't seen that video what was that

19:37

experiment basically what they did is

19:39

they took a bunch of people I think it

19:40

was mostly women some men and they said

19:43

to them what we're doing today so they

19:45

set the frame what we're doing today is

19:47

we are doing an experiment to find out

19:49

how people with uh facial disfigurements

19:52

are treated in society and they put

19:55

scarring on their face in front of a mow

19:57

so they could see that they had some

19:58

really serious facial disfigurements and

20:01

as they were leaving the

20:04

room they said you know what we just

20:06

need to touch touch that scar up a

20:08

little bit more and they removed the

20:09

scarring so these people went into what

20:12

was set up as a job interview thinking

20:15

they had scars on their face but the

20:17

scarring had been removed without their

20:19

knowledge and when they walked into

20:21

those interviews when they came out they

20:22

were asked a bunch of questions and what

20:24

people found was they had massively

20:26

increased levels of

20:29

discrimination for their facial

20:31

disfigurements they reported specific

20:33

comments that the interviews had made

20:35

about their face even though they had no

20:38

scaring at all they brought their

20:40

expectation in with them and they came

20:42

out with the result that they were

20:43

looking for so they believed they were

20:45

discriminated against yeah so I I read

20:48

about something called stereotype threat

20:51

um which talks about how if you remind a

20:54

group of people whether that's black

20:55

people or women or whoever it might be

20:58

about a stereotype um or factor that

21:00

relates to a stereotype before they do a

21:02

test then they perform worse than the

21:03

test and and I guess I don't know if

21:05

this is a Counterpoint to this but so if

21:06

I'm a black person and there's a

21:08

stereotype that black people aren't good

21:09

at maths just by asking someone on a

21:12

test to fill in their ethnicity before

21:14

they do the math test drops their scores

21:16

on the math test right which I I believe

21:18

is the Crux of the experiment and this

21:21

this kind of proves

21:23

that I guess it's a few things I guess

21:25

it's someone believing that they are as

21:28

a disadvantage causes a disadvantage in

21:30

performance but it also highlights if

21:33

that's like an innate thing it also

21:35

points to the power of these these

21:37

stereotypes totally but it's not the

21:39

power of the stereotypes it's the power

21:41

of the brainwashing right because what

21:44

what that what when someone says to you

21:46

there's The Stereotype it's not just the

21:48

stereotype alone it's also the fact that

21:50

they've told you that reinforces it for

21:52

you right because you might be aware of

21:54

the stereotype of a peripheral level but

21:56

you're like no I'm good at mass and

21:57

that's it but it's when other people

21:58

come in and tell you stuff that's when

22:01

that social proof is also reinforcing it

22:03

sometimes they tell you it in a

22:04

well-meaning way yeah yeah but that

22:06

doesn't change it right but you're not

22:08

saying we shouldn't tell people at all

22:10

well I I don't know that the stereotype

22:13

that black people aren't good at math is

22:14

true I I think what we should tell

22:16

people is you can be whatever the hell

22:18

you want uh and you might be terrible at

22:21

math that's okay you might be good at

22:23

some other things but the thing you

22:24

should really do is do your best and

22:26

find out the result you get I asked this

22:29

question I flashback when I was 18 years

22:30

old and I was thinking of starting my

22:32

first business and I discovered that

22:34

there's this special like loan or Grant

22:36

you could get if you were black and as I

22:39

sat there I remember being sat there on

22:41

Facebook typing out this post which I

22:42

never posted where I basically was like

22:45

this seeing that this exists has made me

22:49

feel like I'm at a disadvantage the

22:52

existence of this thing but it's

22:54

well-meaning like they wanted to give

22:56

grants to people that were black but

22:58

part of me if you read between the lines

23:01

of what that says it says because you

23:02

are black you have a disadvantage right

23:04

and then when I sort of overlap that

23:06

with what I know about stereotype

23:07

threats I'm like did the existence of

23:09

that grant program make me more hopeful

23:12

and self-elaboration

23:28

they are incredibly well-meaning they're

23:31

incredibly well- meaning which is what

23:32

makes them so dangerous because um I

23:34

always forget this quote but there's a

23:36

there's a wonderful quote about this

23:37

which is that a tyranny exercised for

23:39

your own good is much worse than a

23:42

tyranny that's exercised out of pure

23:43

evil because at least the evil person

23:45

knows they're being evil but when

23:47

someone is trying to help you by being

23:49

tyrannical towards you I mean this is a

23:51

different context but the point is the

23:52

same when someone is doing something to

23:55

you because they think they're try

23:56

they're helping they are not held back

23:59

by their conscience at all mhm and so

24:01

they will do whatever the hell they

24:03

think is the right thing in order to

24:05

help you what might be a good way of

24:08

helping people who who come from

24:10

backgrounds where there is less

24:12

entrepreneurial success and maybe that

24:14

is the case I don't know what the

24:15

statistics are is you know creating a

24:17

school of black business Excellence

24:19

right like here's here's 10 guys like

24:22

you who come in and talk about how you

24:24

were great and here's some tips and

24:25

here's what you do and here's what I did

24:27

inspiration right now look I don't buy

24:30

personally into this idea that like

24:32

there's this Narrative of you can't be

24:34

what you can't see I think that's one of

24:36

the most pernicious and dangerous ideas

24:38

that we've seen in recent years um but

24:40

to the extent that there are people who

24:42

who need someone who looks like them

24:44

maybe that's that's the way that you do

24:46

it um there is a great writer American

24:49

writer called Thomas soul I don't know

24:50

if you're familiar with his work not

24:52

brother if you read his stuff you will

24:54

you will be hooked one of the things he

24:57

talks about uh is the fact that um over

25:01

the last 30 40 years we have replaced

25:04

things that work with things that sound

25:06

good and so much of what we now do in

25:09

our society is things that sound good

25:12

like that program but don't actually

25:14

help anyone they don't actually work

25:16

very well um and when we talked about

25:19

why wokeness really takes off in 2014

25:22

one of the reasons I believe and there's

25:23

a lot of evidence for this and you can

25:25

look this up and even maybe flash up

25:26

some graphs about this when social media

25:28

comes

25:30

along that's when this stuff really

25:32

takes off because social media is

25:34

completely detached from The Real World

25:36

and social media because of that

25:38

promotes things that sound good that

25:41

make us feel good about how Progressive

25:43

we are virtuous virtuous but don't

25:46

actually achieve anything because in the

25:48

isolated context of Twitter or Facebook

25:50

or whatever you don't have the feedback

25:53

mechanism of Smashing your head on the

25:54

floor if you walk the wrong way or

25:56

whatever whatever it is right um so we

25:59

do a lot of things in our society now uh

26:03

that practically don't get the results

26:06

that we'd like them to get but they make

26:08

us feel incredibly good about how

26:09

Progressive like the black tile the

26:12

black tile during the BLM movement right

26:14

there was the everyone posted a black

26:15

tole on Tuesday right right right and

26:17

then if you didn't post the black tile

26:18

you're attacked for being racist yeah

26:20

yeah I just thought Instagram was broken

26:21

for a

26:23

day no I remember doing a post at the

26:25

time saying that I thought this was

26:26

ridiculous like and really the the the

26:28

part of it that was ridiculous was um

26:30

attacking people that hadn't done it uh

26:33

which exists under this assumption that

26:35

the normal thing to to do the normal

26:37

response to seeing a horrific video

26:39

where someone is suffocated to death is

26:41

to take to social media and post about

26:44

it like in fact that's the most unhuman

26:46

unnatural response to seeing something

26:48

which is quite troubling yeah um but The

26:50

Virtuous thing to do obviously that CL

26:51

the likes would be to fall in line and

26:54

if you look at that Stephen not to get

26:55

you know too far into the weeds of it

26:57

but one of the respons respers to that

26:59

terrible uh killing of George Floyd was

27:02

that a lot of people decided to take a

27:05

lot of understandable frustrations out

27:07

on policing and the police more broadly

27:10

and what happened is that a lot of the

27:12

police pulled back in several cities in

27:14

America and a lot of black people have

27:17

been killed as a result because there's

27:18

less police to actually keep the peace

27:20

and protect people from criminals so

27:22

that was another example of where an

27:25

understandable emotional reaction gets

27:27

converted into very bad action that's

27:29

counterproductive for the very community

27:30

that in that instance we were trying to

27:32

protect you said something a second ago

27:34

you said you don't believe that you need

27:35

to see it to believe it yeah like I

27:39

believe that and it speaks to a broader

27:41

thing which is I I I think that you and

27:43

I having spoken to you beforehand and

27:45

you know we have big podcasts and

27:47

whatever you and I probably have a

27:49

better understanding and more similar

27:50

values around certain things then we

27:52

would do people of our own background

27:55

and that's because people aren't just

27:57

these stupid super icial things right so

28:00

when we talk about you need to see

28:02

someone like you succeed I'm like well I

28:06

didn't I didn't need to look at someone

28:08

who looked like me to be successful I

28:10

saw people in America doing podcasts

28:12

about the similar talking about stuff

28:14

that I wanted to talk about I was like

28:16

oh great maybe I can try that and then I

28:18

did you know and I think teaching people

28:21

that is going to open the doors for way

28:24

more people from Minority backgrounds

28:26

than teaching them that there's this one

28:27

guy

28:28

who looks like them that's been

28:30

successful I just I don't see it that

28:32

way I think the truth of of modern

28:34

Western society and this is why where we

28:36

started the conversation why we're so

28:37

lucky is that if you're talented if

28:39

you're driven if you're willing to work

28:41

on yourself if you're willing to read

28:43

and grow and and and have a goget a

28:45

mindset the world's your Royster it

28:47

doesn't matter what your skin color is

28:49

it's interesting because I I reflect on

28:52

when I started in business and for

28:54

whatever reason I had a lot of Role

28:56

Models All Around the World you know

28:58

whether it was Sir Richard Branson

29:00

studying his story or other people but I

29:03

I you two look incredibly similar I've

29:05

met him he's we're very very different

29:06

but you know he's a very very kind man

29:08

um but Jamal Edwards who was a young

29:11

black man probably the most famous young

29:13

black business person in the UK I was

29:15

obsessed with because there was

29:17

something about him and his story that

29:19

killed my excuses and it kills your

29:23

victimhood MH which is if someone who

29:25

was a young black man who is walk up

29:28

that ladder you're trying to walk up and

29:30

they don't come from money and they had

29:32

a job in I think Top Shop normal dude

29:34

didn't have like a you know incredible

29:36

education Oxford you go I've got no

29:38

excuse right and that's and that that

29:41

part of it I've always rated which is if

29:43

someone like you is walked in those

29:44

footsteps before it helps kill your

29:45

excuses and it gives you no reason sure

29:47

but think about what that meant for you

29:49

though what you're talking about is

29:50

undoing the brand the brainwashing that

29:52

already existed yeah right yeah yeah

29:55

yeah yeah yeah so it's not that like you

29:58

you needed a black person you needed

30:00

someone who you could look at and say oh

30:02

no no all this stuff I've been

30:03

brainwashed into thinking isn't true but

30:06

on the point of brainwashing yeah it is

30:08

objectively true that if I I think if

30:10

you if you look at studies where they

30:11

take someone with a name that is

30:14

associated with a certain race and they

30:16

like sent a thousand emails for a job

30:19

application you're much more likely to

30:20

get the job if you're called John yes

30:22

than like lante sure or

30:26

Constantine like you're called Steven

30:28

yeah yeah my parents nailed it they

30:30

probably nailed it but we we could slice

30:33

this a billion different ways yeah you

30:36

could say look I'm 5'9 barely right if

30:39

you look at the CEOs CEOs of the top

30:41

Fortune 500 companies they're all over

30:43

six foot basically um the tallest

30:46

president presidential candidate in

30:48

America almost always win wins like

30:51

height heightism height discrimination

30:54

is massive especially against men what

30:57

am I going to do well I'm gonna complain

30:58

about that I'm gonna sit there and go oh

31:00

I'm 5'9 it's not going to change

31:02

anything right so the only thing the

31:04

only option I have is do I take this and

31:08

run with it do I make it a strength of

31:10

some kind do I compensate for it

31:12

elsewhere MH or do I wallow in my

31:15

victimhood those are the choices man

31:18

yeah no one's going to make you grow can

31:20

you acknowledge that the brainwashing

31:21

exists that it's in in part objectively

31:25

true sure but it's also not a not reason

31:28

enough to become a victim sure okay but

31:30

that's all I'm saying myself my point is

31:32

that look of course different people are

31:36

treated differently and it's different

31:38

in different ways right like for example

31:39

I'm a first generation immigrant in this

31:41

country some people will see that as a

31:45

Bad Thing other people will see that as

31:47

a good thing right there are tradeoffs

31:49

to everything right being an outsider is

31:52

often bad but sometimes good so the only

31:55

thing that you can do is play the cards

31:56

that life has D you

31:58

right and so going i' I've been dealt

32:01

you could look people are free to do

32:03

whatever they want with their life if

32:05

you want to sit there and say you've

32:06

been dealt a bad hand of cards I'll

32:07

agree with you I mean fine you have but

32:10

it's not going to help you it's not

32:12

going to help you and what I want for

32:13

people is to thrive I want them to

32:15

thrive I want them to create the life

32:17

that they want and I know for a fact you

32:20

know I've been the son of very wealthy

32:22

people I've slept in a park in Edinburgh

32:25

for weeks because I couldn't afford Ren

32:28

the only person that is going to change

32:30

your life is you no one's coming to save

32:32

you no one's coming to rescue you no one

32:34

the Cavalry isn't coming it's just you

32:37

and you have the opportunity to take the

32:40

cards you've been dealt with and convert

32:41

them into the best possible outcome and

32:43

for some people having a job is

32:46

incredible taking the life that they've

32:48

been given and just having a job that

32:50

they can hold down and provide for their

32:52

family that in itself is a massive

32:53

achievement for others the sky is the

32:55

limit but you only get this one set of

32:59

cards and you only get to play it once

33:01

do you want to sit there and complain

33:04

that you were born with the wrong

33:05

genitals or the wrong skin color or

33:07

whatever or do you want to just play the

33:09

hand to the best of your ability that's

33:10

the choice it's interesting because you

33:12

said you want to help them Thrive yeah

33:14

and I think if you asked some of those

33:16

people they'd say they also want to

33:17

thrive and maybe they see the victimhood

33:20

as their path to thriving you know what

33:23

I mean that's just a cop out man that

33:24

like identity like because if I if I

33:27

become a victim then I have this group

33:29

of people and then they're going to be

33:30

nice to me and we're going to reinforce

33:31

each other and we you too me you know

33:34

like sure but it's not going to actually

33:36

help you it makes you feel good makes

33:38

you feel understood and everyone gets

33:41

does it make your life

33:43

better does it do you earn more money

33:45

does is your business more successful

33:47

well if you're like a diversity

33:49

consultant it does right but for

33:51

everyone else does it make your life

33:54

better first of all it makes you feel

33:56

awful right and we've all been there

33:58

we've all felt victims in certain

34:00

different situations because we've all

34:01

been victimized in in one way or another

34:03

you know whether it's a traumatic

34:05

childhood or things happen to you you

34:06

know uh all kinds of things happen to

34:08

people but ultimately you go talk to any

34:12

any good therapist or psychologists

34:14

they're not going to say to you yeah

34:15

yeah oh yeah you're really oppressed

34:17

yeah they're going to say this this is

34:20

your opportunity to grow this is your

34:21

opportunity to overcome yes we accept

34:23

that the things that happened to you

34:24

were wrong and bad and whatever but it's

34:26

acceptance and then you move on that's

34:28

how life Works do you think there's

34:29

differences in Generations as it relates

34:31

to this attitude what are you seeing

34:32

when it comes to like generation Zed as

34:34

they call them and how does that vary

34:36

from

34:37

Millennials some of the stuff that I we

34:39

have genz people working for us at

34:41

trigonometry and I'm like some of the

34:43

things about them are incredible young

34:45

people are always amazing because

34:47

they've had the benefit of learning

34:50

stuff like knowing stuff that we had to

34:52

learn right like I had to learn this

34:55

they just get given it on YouTube or

34:56

whatever they can watch a video

34:58

and like for 10 minutes and no stuff

35:00

that it took me 20 years to unpack right

35:03

um on the one hand on the other hand

35:05

this is a generalization you can't

35:07

generalize about people but my

35:09

experience is in the workplace for

35:12

example they they think about their role

35:16

in in such a disproportionately

35:18

grandiose way comp like we had I

35:21

remember Francis and I my co and try I

35:23

used to help him run a comedy club and

35:26

there were people who would who would

35:28

they literally just came in to help out

35:29

they were effectively doing an unpaid

35:31

internship and they'd like pipe up in

35:34

meetings and be like I think we should

35:35

do it like this like for my generation

35:38

you know the idea that I'd like say

35:40

anything in that meeting would have been

35:42

completely Preposterous you know what I

35:43

mean but look um every generation has

35:46

its own challenges I don't envy jenzi

35:47

because they grew up with phones from

35:49

day one and we are starting to to

35:53

realize I think probably 20 years from

35:54

now we will look at phones like we look

35:56

at tobacco companies 30 or 40 years ago

35:59

like the fact that young people were

36:00

given smartphones from the age of 3 four

36:03

5 six or whatever that was just kind of

36:05

Cruelty really I think and we're

36:07

starting to find that out so uh it's

36:10

look it's very easy always to to slag

36:12

off young people um I we need them we

36:15

need them to be the best versions of

36:17

themselves so I'm always thinking about

36:19

encouraging and lifting them up and

36:20

mentoring and and all of that certainly

36:22

the people that I know from that

36:23

generation but they do face unique

36:25

challenges and and kind of smacking some

36:28

of that self-centeredness out of them is

36:30

part of it you hopeful for

36:32

them I'm very torn about this more

36:35

generally as well I'm someone who's

36:36

incredibly optimistic

36:40

personally as I look out of the world

36:42

today I'm not optimistic about the world

36:45

I am optimistic personally so it's a

36:48

it's a very weird thing I think that as

36:51

I say I think gen Z they've had some

36:54

really difficult things imposed on them

36:55

by their parents and of structure and

36:58

discipline imposed on them by their

37:00

parents on the other hand they have

37:02

tremendous opportunities too so I guess

37:04

it just remains to be

37:06

seen you're not optimistic about the

37:08

world definitely not definitely why well

37:13

we started talking about I think the

37:15

West undermining itself um whether you

37:18

think the West is good or bad is kind of

37:20

irrelevant for this part of

37:21

it when the the the the civilization

37:25

that is

37:26

dominant which is us there's six great

37:28

civilizations in the world today Western

37:31

Civilization who are the descendants of

37:33

the Western Roman Empire Eastern

37:35

Christian civilization who had descended

37:37

from Byzantium the Eastern Christian

37:40

Romans Empire so that's the center of

37:42

that Civilization is Russia now uh the

37:44

two Islamic civilizations the Arabs and

37:47

the Persians Persians Iran China and

37:49

India the Chinese and the Indians

37:52

right Western Civilization has been

37:54

dominant around the world for many many

37:57

centuries now

38:00

when the dominant civilization becomes

38:04

weakened especially from the inside

38:05

whichever one that is what that opens up

38:08

is what Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping

38:11

and others are now talking about this is

38:13

what they mean when they talk about the

38:14

multi-polar world what they mean is they

38:18

get to

38:19

play they get to make a play for that

38:22

dominant position they don't no one

38:24

wants to No One Vladimir putins and the

38:26

XI Jin p don't want to sing you know

38:28

hold hands and sing Kumbaya that's not

38:30

what they're into they want to be the

38:33

dominant Force like America has been for

38:34

a very long time and so when when the

38:38

king of the H Hill gets weaker and

38:40

signals weakness to others what happens

38:42

is conflict that's what happens so even

38:46

if you don't think Western values are

38:48

good values which I happen to think they

38:50

are for reasons we can get into the fact

38:53

that we are increasing the level of

38:55

conflict around the world by signaling

38:57

weakness I think is a bad thing right so

39:00

Ukraine is a very good example of that

39:03

whether Taiwan happens as some people

39:05

are predicting or we don't know it's not

39:07

a good thing if you look at what

39:08

happened in Israel the reason Hamas felt

39:11

comfortable to attack Israel on October

39:12

7th is he did is the Iranians who back

39:15

Hamas feel comfortable in challenging

39:18

Israel because Israel is America's Ally

39:20

in the Middle East right so there is

39:22

this great game being played and and it

39:25

is about throwing the West up its

39:27

pedestal

39:28

so even if you weren't comfortable with

39:31

the West's dominance the fact that it is

39:34

likely coming to an end is a bad thing

39:36

for the world in the interim because it

39:38

means there's more conflict uh and

39:40

there's more violence uh and there's

39:42

more strife and there's more Discord and

39:44

just to be clear the reason why it's

39:45

coming to an end in your view is because

39:47

of the internal Division and the

39:48

internal

39:50

conflict that's part of it look it's a

39:53

look the the the the rise and decline of

39:55

civilizations is a very complicated

39:57

thing part of it is economic right but

40:00

even if you look at our economic

40:01

problems um the biggest problem that

40:03

Western countries face is our level of

40:05

debt right look at debt as a societal

40:09

issue national debt what does that mean

40:12

well one of the things it means is we've

40:14

we've broken the intergenerational

40:16

conflict uh intergenerational contract

40:19

between your generation your children's

40:21

generation and the generation before

40:23

yours and mine right effectively our

40:26

parents are unwilling to sacrifice for

40:29

their grandchildren that's what debt

40:32

means because what we're doing is we're

40:34

borrowing from the future right we are

40:36

operating at more than 100% GDP debt at

40:39

the moment and we're increasing it all

40:41

the time because we're running deficits

40:42

America is borrowing like crazy what

40:45

does that mean you and I are not going

40:46

to be even you and I are not going to be

40:47

paying it off our children will right is

40:51

that the behavior of people who feel

40:52

like they're one that they're United

40:54

that they're looking after the Next

40:55

Generation look at

40:58

GDP per capita I mean one of the reasons

41:00

uh we have uh levels of mass immigration

41:03

that we do today politicians will tell

41:04

you we need Mass immigration to boost

41:06

our economy and they're only half Ling

41:09

um they're they're telling you that

41:11

because it's true in order that they can

41:13

pretend our GDP is growing we need to

41:16

bring in more people but our GDP per

41:17

capita is falling and has been for some

41:20

time so the Gen Z generation are going

41:23

to be poorer than you and

41:25

I is that a reflection of a society that

41:27

is cohesive is reflection of a society

41:30

that feels like it's one that we're

41:32

looking after the Next Generation which

41:33

is our first Duty as people right U so

41:37

even our economic problems which are

41:38

significant in my opinion are partly

41:41

because of the cultural malays that we

41:43

experience and then everything flows

41:45

from that as we talked about at the

41:46

beginning if you brainwash people for

41:48

decades now to think that their society

41:50

is bad and wrong and evil well they're

41:52

not going to be willing to advance its

41:54

interest they're not going to be able to

41:55

go and fight and defend it in war it's

41:57

Etc we're weakening ourselves who's

41:59

doing the

42:00

brainwashing a lot of it has been

42:02

happening in Academia since the 60s so

42:05

Educators uh who were uh being

42:08

encouraged and funded and supported by

42:10

my boys from the Soviet Union at the

42:12

time to demoralize the West they

42:14

encouraged a lot of these marxists and

42:16

one of the things we haven't yet touched

42:17

on is um the ideology of wokeness is

42:20

really a new form of Marxism it's a kind

42:22

of race Marxism I know this sounds like

42:24

very abstract and crazy I don't know if

42:25

it does to you but maybe to many people

42:26

in your audience so perhaps I can lay it

42:28

out a little bit can you explain what

42:30

Marxism is well sure so Marxism was an

42:32

ideology created obviously by KL marks

42:34

and Angel who who funded him and

42:37

assisted him and the idea was very

42:39

simple uh the idea was that the way to

42:42

understand human society is through the

42:44

lens of Oppression we we've talked about

42:47

this before right there are some people

42:49

who are the oppressors and some people

42:51

who are oppressed who are the oppressors

42:53

in Marx's original idea the oppressors

42:55

were the Bourgeois the cap the people

42:57

who owned what he called the means of

42:59

production the factories the the capital

43:02

the stock like you are you are now a

43:04

member of the Bourgeois a capitalist you

43:07

own a business right and what he said

43:09

was that you are oppressing your

43:11

producer and everyone who works for you

43:13

because you take their labor and you

43:15

profit from it without giving them back

43:17

the right amount of value in exchange um

43:20

and by the way just like with a lot of

43:22

these other ideas it was true in the

43:25

sense that Marxism really is a reaction

43:28

to the rampant abuse that was caused by

43:32

the Industrial Revolution in which you

43:34

know you had people sleeping in

43:35

factories and chimney sweeps that were

43:38

12 years old up chimneys you know dying

43:40

all of that right so as with all of

43:43

these ideas there is a kernel of truth

43:45

but what he said and you know the people

43:47

who really practiced this idea the most

43:49

were the Soviets and the Chinese

43:50

Communist is well how do you solve this

43:52

problem oh very simple you got to take

43:55

from the oppressors and you got to give

43:56

to the oppressor

43:57

from each according to his ability to

43:59

each according to his needs however the

44:01

problem is it turns out that communism

44:04

is effectively a great idea at the

44:06

family level like your family is a

44:08

communist Society so is mine like I go

44:11

out to work I earn money we spend it

44:14

together on the needs of my wife my

44:15

children blah blah blah that's communism

44:17

right we share what one productive

44:19

person produces other people do other

44:21

jobs they may not be paid as well blah

44:22

blah

44:23

blah the level of society doesn't really

44:27

work because people are self-interested

44:29

and to make them not self-interested to

44:32

make them all give up everything for the

44:33

needs of the state and other other

44:35

people you have to use a lot of force

44:37

right which is why you have to kill 50

44:39

million people in Russia 50 million

44:42

people in China to even make it happen

44:45

now what happened was you got to

44:48

remember this is very important people

44:49

forget this when the Soviet Union was

44:51

created it was not designed to be a

44:54

Countrywide phenomenon the communist

44:57

belied that the only rightly by the way

44:59

that the only way communism would work

45:01

is if you made everyone in the world

45:03

communist because if you made everyone

45:05

communist then no one could look at over

45:07

the border and look at these evil

45:09

capitalists having a great life everyone

45:11

would be equally poor and then they'd be

45:13

happy that was the idea right um and so

45:16

the idea of the the Russian

45:19

Revolution wasn't about making Russia

45:21

Communists communist it was about making

45:24

the world communist it was the world

45:27

Revolution that's why the Soviet Union

45:29

the the the the symbolism of the Soviet

45:30

Union it never had anything to do with

45:33

Russia or the Soviet Union on the flag

45:35

it had the globe and the hammer and

45:37

sickle the point was this ideology was

45:40

meant to spread to the entire world the

45:43

problem was that when people saw what

45:44

was actually happening in the Soviet

45:46

Union they really didn't want that and

45:48

most of all people in Western societies

45:50

including the working class who was

45:52

supposed to be the oppressed and to

45:53

overthrow their oppressive people they

45:55

didn't want that they just wanted to

45:57

have a nice life and to have a house and

45:58

to blah blah blah um and so the Marxist

46:02

in the west they very quickly realized

46:04

that this wasn't going to work Western

46:06

workingclass people were not going to

46:08

overthrow the existing regime and have a

46:10

a Soviet style Revolution where they

46:12

slaughter all the bouris and the

46:14

capitalist so they had to find a

46:16

different way to approach it which is

46:18

why they invented this form of race

46:20

Marxism they said no no no you're not no

46:23

you're not really oppressed cuz you're

46:24

working class and you don't have Capital

46:26

the reason you you're oppressed is

46:28

you're a man you're gay you're black

46:29

you're this you're that and that really

46:33

landed with people particularly

46:34

multiethnic societies like ours where we

46:36

have a lot of people from Minority

46:38

backgrounds um it coincided with the

46:41

sexual Revolution I know you've had my

46:42

friend Lis Perry on the show yeah uh I

46:45

don't know if you talked about this but

46:46

the pill basically changes the

46:47

relationship between men and women women

46:49

are liberated so now a lot of this stuff

46:52

also happens and so what happened in the

46:53

60s is a lot of Educators in Academia

46:56

started teaching these ideas to students

46:59

and then you have successive generations

47:01

of people who are now essentially

47:03

trained to think that our societies were

47:06

bad uh what they were was about

47:08

oppression racism bigotry imperialism uh

47:12

colonialism slavery Etc uh which all of

47:16

these things have a kernel of Truth and

47:18

that kernel of Truth is used to tell

47:20

gigantic lies and cuz I because often

47:24

when we we talk about this division

47:25

that's happening internally Within West

47:27

we think of it as the other side of

47:29

doing it but a second ago you really

47:31

pointed at forces far a field are

47:34

tinkering and actually there was a story

47:36

this week I think or last week where a

47:38

podcaster has been I think like arrested

47:41

and had her channels deleted because it

47:42

turns out I didn't go deep into the

47:44

story she hasn't been arrested but yes

47:46

perhaps I can just summarize it quickly

47:48

so there was a company in America called

47:50

tenant media who were given $10 million

47:53

in a very short period of time so I'm

47:54

sure it would have been more by a

47:56

Russian today

47:58

Affiliated uh influencers and various

48:01

nefarious actors from Russia effectively

48:05

to uh disseminate certain types of

48:07

information through right-wing

48:09

influences in America and this has been

48:11

happening for decades there's a guy

48:13

called Yuri basmanov if you're not

48:15

familiar with him this guy's going to

48:16

blow your mind you should look him up he

48:18

was a Soviet Defector uh in the 80s who

48:21

came uh from the Soviet Union to India

48:24

to Canada ended up in America he gave

48:26

series of lectures which people can

48:28

watch on YouTube about what the Soviet

48:31

intelligence Services were actually

48:33

focusing on because during the Cold War

48:37

you might not remember this but you know

48:39

people thought about Soviet spies as

48:41

like stealing microfilms of American

48:43

nuclear installations and all of this

48:45

stuff actually what he said was almost

48:47

all of their resources were used on what

48:49

he called

48:50

demoralization and demoralization is the

48:52

process whereby you divide Society and

48:57

you activate nefarious forces within

49:00

that Society against the society so you

49:02

encourage forces that are destabilizing

49:04

this is one thing that people don't

49:06

understand about Russian misinformation

49:08

disinformation influence operations Etc

49:11

they're not designed to get a specific

49:13

person elected this is how British

49:15

people and Americans think they're like

49:17

you know well I invest $10 million to

49:19

get this outcome it's not what they do

49:22

what they want is to create a cacophony

49:25

of Lies so that you don't know what to

49:27

believe anymore is this true is that

49:28

true and so they were they are and were

49:31

and have always been paying people in

49:33

the west or using people in the west to

49:36

seow Discord to divide people against

49:38

each other to say uh the Soviet Union by

49:41

the way was very active in in funding

49:43

militant uh African-American groups uh

49:47

in the 60s and 70s and 80s in America

49:49

and in fact whenever people would say to

49:52

uh the Soviets well look you're like

49:54

starving millions of people and putting

49:55

them in gags by would say well what

49:57

about black people in America they're

49:59

you don't treat them well right so who

50:00

are you to tell us about all of this

50:02

stuff so by the way this isn't like um a

50:07

unique thing like America does this too

50:08

America Funds liberal organizations in

50:11

Russia to get Russian liberals to act in

50:15

their interest this is what all

50:17

civilizations do I'm just saying maybe

50:19

we should protect our civilization from

50:21

this foreign influence so yes uh foreign

50:24

forces are at play but you can't like no

50:28

I I don't know I imagine there's no

50:29

amount of money that people could give

50:31

you to spread Russian propaganda on this

50:33

show there's no amount of money that

50:35

people could give me to spread Russian

50:36

propaganda or Chinese propaganda on my

50:38

show what they do is they find people

50:41

who already agree with them and then

50:43

they amplify their voice using money and

50:46

influence and say look we'll we'll we'll

50:48

give you you know we'll give you $10

50:49

million and you can come to this great

50:51

conference we'll we'll give you an

50:52

opportunity to interview this guy who's

50:54

close to Vladimir Putin or or this guy

50:56

who who says this or that person or this

50:58

person and they they just take the

51:01

forces within our society that already

51:04

destabilizing and they amplify them so

51:06

this podcaster in the United States it

51:07

was tenant media is that one podcast or

51:09

is that a network of podcasts so what

51:11

happened is they had a network of

51:13

podcasters underneath them who is

51:16

according to the indictment they were

51:17

all being used so they didn't know they

51:18

were being paid by Russia okay U they

51:21

were just all being used and never now

51:23

and again again we don't know the full

51:24

details but it would be like hey have

51:26

you seen this new story like the

51:28

ukrainians might have been involved in

51:29

the terrorist attack in Russia maybe you

51:31

should cover it and one of them did

51:33

stuff like that okay and they weren't

51:35

necessarily picking a side were they no

51:37

they were picking a side oh so they were

51:39

Pro Trump or Pro Cala or well they were

51:41

mostly right-wing influences uh but the

51:44

person in question whose name is Lauren

51:46

Chen she actually started agitating

51:49

people against Donald Trump at one point

51:51

which is my point they are not trying to

51:54

get a particular person elected they are

51:56

trying to make you go who do I vote

51:59

what's going like just to to confuse

52:01

everybody to the point that they don't

52:02

know what to believe and they don't know

52:04

what to think and they don't know what

52:05

to do looks like it's working that's my

52:08

point which is why we need in the west

52:12

to have a very clear idea of who we are

52:14

where we're going how we got here what

52:15

makes our society successful where we've

52:18

come from and to reject the lies about

52:20

our history because this is why uh both

52:22

the crazy left and the crazy right want

52:24

to revise our history

52:27

so that we don't know who we are anymore

52:29

so that we can't say well actually

52:31

Britain is a great country and has done

52:33

incredible things for the world right uh

52:36

you know Britain is the country that has

52:38

the first modern Parliament it's a

52:40

country that spread democracy around it

52:41

it's a country that actually the first

52:43

Empire in history that ended slavery it

52:46

ended

52:47

slavery it didn't invent it it ended it

52:49

slavery was the norm and then the

52:51

British came along practiced slavery

52:53

just like everybody else and a terrible

52:54

thing it was and then they spent a

52:56

tremendous amount of blood money and

52:58

treasure to end slavery not only within

53:00

the British Empire they spent a huge

53:03

amount of diplomatic military and

53:04

financial Capital to for to force other

53:07

countries to end slavery in those

53:09

countries as well right but that's not

53:11

what you're being taught in school right

53:13

now is it no and and that's the problem

53:16

because if you think of your society as

53:18

based on these terrible things well why

53:20

would you want its values to persevere

53:22

and continue in the future it may be

53:25

wonder if there there is any hope or any

53:27

solution to this because immediately as

53:29

I was thinking is there a way to stop

53:31

the division and most of the division

53:33

actually happens on the internet now

53:34

it's not like we're out on the streets

53:36

and the way the algorithms work is they

53:38

reinforce an opinion so you get

53:40

literally like coins at the casino for

53:42

saying something where a big group of

53:44

people clap and Nuance is like the enemy

53:47

of social media growth I think like if

53:49

you if like if you express a solution to

53:51

a problem as complex and nuanced who the

53:54

[ __ ] who the [ __ ] wants to hear a

53:56

complex Nuance like really that that I

53:58

think there's much more reward for me to

53:59

say this is bad yes or this is amazingly

54:02

good and if you're in either of those

54:03

camps you know exactly who's clapping

54:05

yes whereas in the middle as we've kind

54:08

of you probably experienced it a lot as

54:09

a

54:10

podcaster um like you don't get the

54:13

support the full support of either side

54:16

maybe maybe the middle exists I don't

54:17

know well the center is the place of

54:19

greatest tension it always is because

54:21

you're getting fire from both sides uh

54:24

and picking a tribe is always much more

54:26

comfortable and more convenient but this

54:27

is where I think actually the beauty of

54:29

the internet is too

54:31

like 20 years ago you and I both would

54:36

have had some kind of rich

54:38

funer not me or you but someone who

54:40

actually had loads of money who would be

54:42

funding this and telling you what you

54:44

supposed to talk

54:45

about I don't have to give a [ __ ] what

54:48

anyone thinks there is an audience out

54:51

there for the nuanced balanced here's

54:53

the thing I think about this but also

54:55

about this take

54:57

and you know look yes absolutely uh you

55:00

know if you're Andrew Tay you're going

55:01

to get a bigger audience saying what

55:03

you're saying or the equivalent of of

55:05

the left whatever that looks like uh

55:08

then I might but yeah I'm very happy

55:10

with a million subscribers on YouTube

55:11

I'm very happy that 60,000 people read

55:13

my substacks every week and that's

55:15

growing too there is a market out there

55:18

for everybody and then ultimately I

55:20

think it comes down to is who are you

55:23

and who do you want to be I didn't get

55:26

into this to be the richest or the most

55:29

successful podcaster in the world I got

55:31

into this because I wanted to promote

55:34

critical thinking I wanted to promote

55:36

the truth and the pursuit of truth I

55:38

don't claim to know the truth but I'm

55:39

trying to find out what it is um and I

55:42

wanted people in the west to remember

55:44

what they have to be grateful for it to

55:47

defend it uh to stand up for the values

55:49

that made these societ is great you said

55:51

a second ago that we've we need to

55:53

remember who we are um if we are going

55:55

to be successful as society and one of

55:57

the things that did sort of anchor Us in

55:59

values was religion yes and I'm um I I

56:03

was born to a very religious Christian

56:06

family um went to church a lot when we

56:08

were younger um my mother's still

56:11

extremely religious my father is

56:13

religious as well I believe I still

56:15

think he's religious and at about 18 or

56:17

19 years old I discovered Like Richard

56:19

Dawkins books and had this like

56:21

existential crisis for two

56:22

[Music]

56:23

years and then after the existential

56:25

crisis which lasted two years and me

56:27

like you know really trying to find the

56:29

answers I kind of was just at piece with

56:31

it and I would class myself now as being

56:33

agnostic yeah but in the last six months

56:36

I classed myself as being

56:39

agnostic but you're by curious now my

56:43

Curious yeah it's like you're God

56:45

curious you can always feel me going

56:47

back to the beginning again but much of

56:49

that I think is what you described which

56:50

is because we've become more

56:52

individualistic more lonely all these

56:54

kinds of things we're now searching for

56:56

purpose again yes and for for values

56:58

that are anchored in something yes um I

57:01

wondered what your take was on the

57:02

impact that us becoming a more atheist

57:04

Society has had on all these things look

57:06

I an agnostic myself um I that's not to

57:10

say that I think you know I'm not a

57:12

materialist in the sense that like this

57:14

is it right it's definitely not it and I

57:17

know that experientially I know that

57:18

there are ways that human beings connect

57:21

that are Way Beyond you know the things

57:23

that we can see with our eyes and hear

57:24

with our ears uh there are powerful

57:27

forces in this world that are spiritual

57:29

in nature these are not things I can

57:31

prove and I have no intention of trying

57:33

but they exist

57:36

um but there's no question that the the

57:40

the decline of religion has meant that

57:43

people are lacking meaning and lacking

57:45

purpose and lacking guidance and lacking

57:46

discipline and lacking a set of rails in

57:49

which to live their lives

57:51

um the the hope is that from that comes

57:55

something else um you know there have

57:58

been many great religions throughout

57:59

history there's no reason to say that

58:01

the ones we currently have are the last

58:03

ones we're ever going to have um God

58:06

knows what AI is going to do to our

58:08

sense of who we are and what our purpose

58:10

is and what our mission is um and also

58:13

you

58:14

know there is purpose to be found in

58:17

other things you you know if if you are

58:20

fortunate enough like me to become a

58:22

father at some point that really changes

58:24

your perspective on so many different

58:26

things and and gives you a sense of

58:28

meaning and purpose I'm sure your work

58:29

is very meaningful to you um but yes at

58:33

a societal level uh uh the death of

58:36

religion is has been very impactful in

58:38

that way for sure do you think we'd be

58:40

better if we went back to being more

58:43

religious as a society forgive me but

58:45

that's a stupid question because you

58:46

can't go back really no you can't go

58:49

back to anything the part of the reason

58:52

we are less religious is the the

58:53

material circumstances of our lives have

58:55

changed very dramatically

58:58

um and you can't put the toothpaste back

59:01

in the tube you can go forward and

59:04

that's what I'm alluding to uh I don't

59:06

think the the religious age is over I

59:08

mean human beings clearly have a

59:10

religious Instinct that has lasted

59:12

through Through the Ages and usually

59:15

religion has been there to explain to us

59:18

the things that we do not understand I

59:20

think that with a lot of the

59:22

technological breakthroughs that we're

59:23

about to see there's going to be a whole

59:25

range of things that I don't even know

59:27

what they are that we we're not going to

59:29

understand exactly and the spiritual

59:31

attitude we take to those things may be

59:33

different yet again we'll find out or a

59:36

lot of people will go to religion but I

59:38

don't think they're going to go to like

59:40

the 960s version of it do you know what

59:43

I mean yeah and I I think I think about

59:46

I read some work that said that a lot of

59:48

young Western men in particular were

59:49

choosing Islam obviously we've seen

59:52

people like Andrew Tate as well make the

59:53

decision but that there was this rise in

59:55

Young Western men deciding to come out

59:58

or convert to Islam that makes sense

60:01

that makes a lot of sense why uh because

60:04

a Islam is a religion that offers

60:07

particularly men quite a lot of the

60:10

things that they really

60:12

want right discipline

60:16

structure uh reward mhm uh

60:19

Community

60:21

um the I mean one of the things about

60:23

Islam when you contrast it against

60:26

Christianity and and Western values

60:28

today's Western values more broadly is

60:30

Islam like very few other things is is

60:33

one of the ideologies that still allows

60:35

men to be strong and confident right in

60:38

modern Western Society what is a man

60:40

supposed to be look at your adverts look

60:43

at your movies look at everything man's

60:45

supposed to be this PA

60:47

pathetic weak uh you second to his

60:53

strong female counterpart right uh men

60:56

are supposed to step back and make space

60:58

and all of this Islam says no no no

61:00

you're you're the man that's always

61:02

going to be appealing to men who who

61:04

increasingly feel particularly younger

61:05

men who in many ways they've got the

61:08

short end of the stick while being told

61:11

that they are privileged and blah blah

61:12

blah blah blah like young men are not in

61:14

positions of privilege in in our society

61:16

now they do worse in education they do

61:19

worse in all sorts of other things and

61:20

at the same time they're being demonized

61:22

right it's very natural that their

61:24

response to that is going to be things

61:27

like that and you know people often talk

61:29

about Andrew Tay as a very problematic

61:31

figure which certainly is but to me the

61:36

blame he's to me is the symptom of a of

61:39

of a much bigger underlying wider

61:42

problem like my

61:44

generation's version of that was Jordan

61:46

Peterson who I thought was a very

61:47

constructive force and still is I had

61:49

the privilege of touring with him in

61:50

America this year and was incredible and

61:54

he's a very positive constructive person

61:56

but the more you try to prevent men from

61:59

being men the more you're going to get

62:01

the backlash and I think people joining

62:03

Islam following these hyper masculine

62:06

influences going to like one of the

62:09

reasons if you notice loads of guys are

62:11

like now into going to the gym and being

62:13

like not just going to the gym to like

62:15

be healthy but like they're buff right

62:18

because that's one of the very few

62:19

acceptable ways for men to be men in

62:22

modern society right because the things

62:25

that we conven would associate with

62:26

masculinity you know strength confidence

62:29

aggression dominance Etc they're kind of

62:32

looked down upon for guys nowadays right

62:35

um and so well at least I can go to the

62:37

gym and I can look buff right it's so

62:39

true I was just thinking about the

62:40

people my father might have looked up to

62:42

he's from Coventry and when I from my

62:45

memory of his idols they were like rock

62:47

stars in bands yeah they were like

62:49

skinny like probably smoked some weed

62:51

they all had long hair my dad had long

62:52

hair as well like this down to his

62:54

shoulders when I saw some old photos of

62:55

him and I imagine his version of like

62:57

the Andrew Tate was that I know the lead

63:00

singer of like the Beatles or whatever

63:01

yeah or his favorite rock band but

63:03

you're right all of our people we look

63:05

up to in society they probably do

63:07

Brazilian jiu-jitsu right they go to the

63:09

gym yeah there's some they fight in some

63:12

way yeah boxing UFC whatever and it's

63:15

much you know because I think that's one

63:16

of the reasons that the UFC is crushing

63:18

it as hard as it is I mean Dana why is a

63:20

brilliant business guy and it's a great

63:22

product and it's fascinating but I think

63:24

one of the reasons there such an

63:25

obsession with combat sports nowadays is

63:29

that it's like well at least I can see

63:31

like men being men type of thing do you

63:32

know what I mean cuz nowhere else am I

63:34

going to get that I think that's it's

63:35

undoubtedly to me a kind of like

63:38

misplace misplaced masculinity or maybe

63:40

it's not misplaced it's just like the

63:42

one place you can actually see it you

63:43

know and you're allowed to celebrate

63:46

masculinity in that way the the hyper

63:48

masculinity it's a very interesting

63:50

moment that we're in is is there a

63:52

solution that you can see to the issues

63:54

that men are facing in the sort of

63:56

modern world where suicide rates are

63:58

through the roof loneliness depression

64:01

look the solution for men is always

64:02

going to be the same uh which is to be

64:04

better to do better to work harder to

64:06

learn skills to grow to develop uh to

64:10

look for mentors to look for guidance uh

64:12

and to do things it's always going to be

64:14

the way like no like I said no one's

64:16

coming to save you and this is uh this

64:18

is why victimhood that we talked about

64:20

earlier it's especially bad for men CU

64:23

you know we feel sorry for women we

64:25

don't really feel sorry for men right so

64:28

if a woman is a victim everyone wants to

64:30

like go and help her and support her and

64:31

it's natural and understandable there's

64:33

a very good evolutionary reasons for

64:35

this I think um which is men are

64:38

biologically disposable basically um you

64:41

know if you have a tribe of 10 men 10

64:43

women you send the men off to war one

64:46

comes back you can replenish the tribe

64:49

and that's a one very lucky dude if if

64:51

you do it the other way around and you

64:52

send the women off to war you're screwed

64:55

right and so um men are kind of

64:58

disposable we didn't evolve to feel

64:59

sorry for them and so for guys again

65:02

like you just got to do stuff and be

65:04

better and yes you've been dealt a bad

65:05

hand you have compared to the previous

65:08

generations where like men were in

65:09

charge and all of that you're going to

65:11

have to find a way and wokeism um and

65:15

sort of I guess political correctness

65:17

and Council culture and all these things

65:19

are much of the weapons that are used to

65:22

put men in those situations you would

65:23

argue yeah uh but you know I I think

65:27

with I always worry when we have these

65:29

conversations that um to say that

65:32

men young men especially younger than me

65:35

I think have a bad deal is often like

65:38

people try and immediately shove you in

65:40

some kind of box like you're some men's

65:41

rights blah blah blah I just think

65:43

that's an observable fact and the reason

65:45

I think it's important is um that men

65:48

and women need to work together mhm men

65:52

and women have had to work together for

65:54

the entire history of human existence

65:56

one of the terrible things about

65:57

wokeness is that it creates these

65:59

divisions between men and women you know

66:01

men are this women are that and you see

66:03

the the the response to that from the

66:06

aggressive masculine side now or women

66:08

are all this and women are all that

66:10

actually the thing that men and women

66:12

really need more than anything is each

66:14

other they need to work together that

66:16

operates at the level of your

66:18

relationship with your girlfriend my

66:19

wife but broader Society too like we

66:21

have different skill sets we are

66:23

naturally inclined to towards different

66:25

things we have to find ways to work

66:27

together better um and so when one side

66:31

suffers there was a time when women were

66:33

treated very badly a lot of them that

66:36

wasn't good uh treating men badly isn't

66:39

going to work out well either what you

66:41

really need is finding ways for men and

66:43

women to be healthy together in

66:45

relationships um and so that's I think

66:47

important to say that that's the

66:49

objective if that's the goal if that's

66:51

the objective that we're holding up then

66:53

the question is how do we get there and

66:55

and question the answer to that is not

66:57

to point fingers at the other sex and

67:00

say they are this and they are that but

67:02

to go well men are naturally aggressive

67:06

and dominant and Status seeking and all

67:08

of this stuff and let's find ways to

67:10

channel that into effective things like

67:12

we need guys to like stand on

67:14

construction sites and Hammer [ __ ] into

67:16

the ground and all of that um and we

67:19

need women to do other things that are

67:20

more natural to them I mean look once

67:22

you have a kid and you start taking them

67:24

to like Nursery you find find out that

67:26

you know there is no gender equality in

67:28

a kindergarten it's like mostly women

67:30

that run that place and that's the way

67:31

it should be and that's that's makes

67:32

sense so um we have different

67:35

inclinations different skill sets it's

67:37

not to say there aren't exceptions of of

67:39

course there are right but generally

67:41

speaking we need to work together that's

67:43

the point yeah I think even um

67:45

mentioning that there might be

67:47

biological differences in male and

67:48

female is where people like the you know

67:50

those that are looking for

67:53

watery they come out in but I think

67:56

anyone in their private relationship can

67:58

very clearly State the differences

68:00

between men and women and as you say

68:01

they're not sweeping and there are

68:03

exceptions but how beneficial I don't

68:06

know anything about you we've just met

68:09

but I

68:10

imagine your girlfriend's Been

68:12

instrumental in your life would that be

68:13

fair to say of course I wouldn't be

68:15

anywhere near where I am without my wife

68:17

like and we both reap the benefits of

68:20

that I'm sure that's the case with you

68:22

that's how it's supposed to work on an

68:24

individual level and at the level of

68:26

society holding each other up filling in

68:28

gaps like the first time I remember you

68:30

know something when I was young when I

68:31

was about 20 like full of testosterone I

68:34

remember watching my mom resolve a

68:37

conflict with a joke and a smile and to

68:40

me it was like magic I was like whoa you

68:43

can do that and then I that was a

68:46

helpful thing for me to learn you know

68:48

but in my masculine boarding school kind

68:51

of environment you'd never do that right

68:53

it was all about who can like win and

68:55

fight and dominate and whatever we're

68:57

useful to each other we can learn from

68:59

each other that's the attitude that we

69:01

should have towards each other and the

69:02

other sex I love the what the term you

69:04

use there when you said hold me up

69:06

because that's exactly what my partner

69:07

does for me right and I think she'd

69:09

probably say the other the same for her

69:11

sure which I think it goes to your point

69:12

about what it should be this s Mutual we

69:14

fill in the blanks in each other's maps

69:17

of the world in emotional states there's

69:20

certain emotional states that I find

69:22

very hard to get out of my wife can come

69:23

in and be like boom boom boom done and

69:25

vice versa right and they're not the

69:27

same we've been told the lie that men

69:29

and women are the same what about

69:31

problematic men like Harvey Weinstein

69:34

and stuff like yeah terrible of course

69:35

the the whole me too movement exposed

69:37

this wave of like I someone on my

69:39

podcast said it was at the

69:40

neuroscientist America he said um we've

69:42

called men out but we need to make sure

69:44

we call them back in if that kind of

69:46

makes sense well I think the mistake we

69:48

made was we called Mana instead of

69:50

calling toxic Mana in the same way that

69:54

people who are itical of women now they

69:58

will point to certain female traits or

70:00

certain female people who behave in ways

70:03

that are very toxic and they will

70:05

broaden and generalize from that onto

70:07

all women right Harvey Weinstein does

70:10

not represent me in fact throughout

70:13

history people like him would have

70:15

actually been dealt with by Good Men and

70:18

prevented from acting in that way right

70:20

I guess the argument is that it is all

70:22

men because you're having those

70:24

conversations in your group chat and

70:26

you're not not checking your uh your

70:29

friend or your I don't know Harvey's

70:31

friends didn't check him what kind of

70:33

group chats are you reading this is what

70:35

the this is what I see online as like

70:37

right but that makes absolutely zero

70:39

sense this is this is the thing is like

70:41

if you want to generalize about an

70:43

entire group of people generally

70:45

speaking we think that's a bad thing to

70:47

do like if you were to do that about

70:50

pakistanis people wouldn't be be into

70:52

that right if if I was to do that about

70:54

black people nobody would be into that

70:56

but the moment it's men suddenly that's

70:58

that's totally cool now now we're going

71:00

to do this doesn't make any sense free

71:03

speech is at the heart of this right

71:04

because we're talking about social media

71:05

platforms the ability to express ideas

71:07

and not be scared um free speech has

71:10

been on a bit of a journey over the even

71:14

the last 10 years I think if you just

71:15

looked at where we were 10 years ago and

71:17

then five years ago and then the

71:18

pandemic and then now it feels like all

71:21

four of those moments were in a

71:22

different place what what's your

71:23

observation of that story AR Free Speech

71:27

well it's all very contextual right and

71:28

depends where you are uh what you do and

71:31

what your opinions are um one thing

71:34

people forget give you one brief example

71:36

right because people a lot of people

71:37

make free speech a political issue they

71:39

say well this side cares about it

71:41

because they want to say their stuff and

71:42

this side doesn't care about it because

71:44

blah blah blah right during the pandemic

71:47

when the vaccine came out in America the

71:50

person who was pushing the vaccine was

71:51

Donald

71:53

Trump and people who were opponent oon

71:55

of his on the left said I'm not taking

71:57

Trump's vaccine blah blah blah blah blah

71:59

blah blah right the moment the

72:01

presidency changed suddenly you couldn't

72:04

criticize the vaccine right and suddenly

72:07

you know you wanted to kill people if

72:08

you had some reservations about some

72:11

things about it right so free speech

72:13

usually and always has been really uh is

72:16

a weapon that people like to use against

72:18

the other side which is why you need

72:20

people in the middle to to kind of be

72:22

the referee and say guys I don't care

72:25

which one of you is in power now we

72:26

always need free speech so that we can

72:28

criticize the people in power not the

72:30

right or the left but the people in

72:32

power whoever that is now from about

72:36

2014 onwards particularly I think there

72:39

was a lot of restriction of speech uh

72:42

from the left from the progressive left

72:44

um and that was part of wokeness and by

72:47

the way just for for your uh your

72:49

audience I think it might be helpful I

72:51

always say this because people don't

72:53

know this where the term political

72:55

correctness comes from people think

72:57

political correctness is you know let's

72:59

be let's not be mean to people let's not

73:01

offend minorities let's not make

73:03

offensive jokes blah blah blah never had

73:05

anything to do with that political

73:07

correctness was invented in the Soviet

73:09

Union by Communists so that they could

73:12

say to critics of the Communist Regime

73:15

well comrade what you're saying may be

73:17

factually correct but it's Politically

73:19

Incorrect and therefore you should shut

73:21

up in other words it's inconvenient to

73:23

the party line of the the day and that's

73:26

how political correctness is used always

73:29

it's about preventing you from

73:31

expressing a dissenting opinion um so

73:34

from 2016 onwards you saw lots of that

73:37

uh especially on social media because uh

73:41

the kind of progressive left had a lock

73:43

on all of those institutions Facebook

73:46

Twitter uh Instagram we can go down the

73:49

full list they panded I'm not saying the

73:51

people who ran them were themselves

73:53

necessarily work but they p Ed and

73:55

appeased that Fringe who said you can't

73:58

say that that's hate speech you can't

73:59

say that that's and during the pandemic

74:02

we saw real restrictions on it I

74:05

understand why the pandemic killed a

74:07

hell of a lot of people there was a hell

74:09

of a lot of lies being told by people of

74:11

all different sides um I was

74:13

uncomfortable with the level of

74:15

censorship we saw though I thought that

74:17

a lot of very reasonable things were

74:18

prevented from being talked about one of

74:21

them was where the virus came from we

74:23

now know with almost certainly it came

74:26

from a lab in China due to almost

74:28

certainly gain of function research um

74:30

Matt Ridley for example he he in the

74:33

House of Lords in the UK so he's not

74:34

some Fringe random guy wrote a whole

74:36

book with a Chinese scientist Alina Chan

74:38

I think her name is uh we've had him on

74:40

the show to talk about this if you'd

74:42

said that on social media in the early

74:43

days of the pandemic you would have been

74:45

banned now we know that's almost

74:47

certainly what happened and it's really

74:49

important where the virus came from for

74:51

obvious reasons which is if it came from

74:52

a lab where these people were messing

74:54

around with viruses don't we want to

74:56

know that because could happen again

74:59

might right um so free the Restriction

75:02

of free speech is dangerous for all

75:05

sorts of reasons um and then Elon Musk

75:08

bought Twitter and I think since then

75:10

we've seen that you know um a friend of

75:13

mine's um very fond of saying that zero

75:17

is a special number and what he means by

75:20

that is when you control every single

75:22

media Outlet in the world m of that type

75:25

social media you are able to censor

75:28

everything but the moment one of those

75:30

Outlets is not controlled by you

75:33

censorship becomes pointless because

75:36

people can go to the other platform and

75:38

see the things for themselves right

75:40

which is one of the reasons Mark

75:41

Zuckerberg has come out recently and

75:42

said that they were wrong to ban Donald

75:44

Trump from Facebook and Instagram and

75:47

they were wrong to suppress the hunter

75:49

Biden laptop story and all of that kind

75:51

of stuff and that they wouldn't do so

75:52

again because now now that there is a

75:56

platform where that censorship is not

75:57

happening he looks kind of bad in this

76:00

whole thing right um so I think Elon

76:03

buying Twitter and opening up the range

76:05

of conversations has had some very

76:08

positive effect it's also had some

76:10

negative effect undoubtedly uh and that

76:13

is a thing that you know I think a great

76:15

engineer like Elon will hopefully

76:17

fine-tune over time um what is the

76:20

negatives of well look the amount of

76:22

horrific [ __ ] that people say on there

76:24

now is is increased exponentially

76:26

undoubtedly right and the answer to that

76:30

might not be that they need to be banned

76:33

or censored it might be what he said

76:35

originally he talked about freedom of

76:37

speech but not freedom of reach like you

76:39

know maybe you know my view as someone

76:42

from a Jewish background is I don't want

76:45

people being banned from social media

76:46

for being anti-semitic but should they

76:48

be promoted actively on social media for

76:51

being anti-semitic should we flood the

76:54

internet with that Maybe not maybe like

76:56

they can say what they want but maybe it

76:58

shouldn't be to the broadest possible

77:00

audience or what whatever it looks like

77:02

right like I don't think we want a space

77:05

where people are encouraged to be

77:07

hateful and it sometimes does feel like

77:09

that on social media one of the big

77:11

problems is of course anonymity right

77:13

it's like that windscreen effect in the

77:15

car you get in your car someone has cut

77:18

you up in traffic the the things you do

77:21

and say are not the things you would say

77:23

to someone face to face MH and if you

77:25

have complete online anonymity it

77:27

encourages people to be the the worst

77:28

version of themselves um how you resolve

77:32

that we don't know it's a complicated

77:33

problem I mean social media is a giant

77:35

conundrum um personally I am still

77:39

despite all that horrible [ __ ] on the

77:41

side of like the opening up is good we

77:43

don't want people being banned for

77:45

expressing the wrong opinion about you

77:47

know the pandemic the vaccine the

77:49

whatever unless they're really being

77:52

nefarious um there's a balance to be

77:54

found we haven't found it yet when you

77:57

look at all solutions as just having

77:58

tradeoffs yeah I think it makes a lot

78:00

easier to accept that we'll never be

78:01

happy with this and if you arrive at

78:03

that position then um then that's a

78:06

Thomas Soul line by the way oh was

78:07

actually yeah man you would love his

78:09

books I promise you I've written his

78:10

name down so I'm going to have to have

78:11

to dig in um and everything you said I I

78:16

have seen so I've seen a rise in

78:19

commentary that I think has really been

78:21

beneficial and I've also seen the nword

78:24

more times on my timeline than like I

78:26

ever would have seen before or like

78:28

horrific stuff um so the idea of freedom

78:30

of speech but not freedom of reach might

78:33

be the best solution and look it's a

78:35

terrible thing to say but maybe maybe

78:39

maybe you know the trade-off of a free

78:41

Society is some people are going to say

78:43

things you and I both really don't like

78:45

you know uh the question is should they

78:47

be front and center of the biggest

78:50

social media platform in the world maybe

78:52

not but as I say I think these are it's

78:54

a technical issue uh and as you say

78:57

there are trade-offs to to both ways of

78:59

handling it uh I believe that social

79:01

media is a very new thing we will find

79:03

the solution it's going to take some

79:04

time I just hope it doesn't break our

79:06

brains in in the meantime are you if we

79:09

look forward 5 10 20 years do you think

79:12

the West will still be

79:15

dominant I think in that timeline yes

79:18

because the accumulated Advantage we

79:20

have is very

79:21

significant um

79:24

but you know that thing about how did

79:26

something end gradually and then

79:28

suddenly H we're not on a good

79:30

trajectory and you know when we talk

79:32

about you know the decline of the West

79:34

people imagined like you know and then

79:36

one day everybody died this is not what

79:38

I'm talking about but have you been to

79:40

Rome yes yeah have you been to Athens no

79:44

okay well they're the same thing you

79:45

walk out of the the tube station in

79:47

central Rome and you see this Coliseum

79:50

and it's incredible and you think what

79:52

an amazing civilization then you look

79:54

around and there's Italians and they're

79:55

wonderful people and they have a great

79:57

time and whatever but those are not the

79:58

same thing the Roman Empire in Italy are

80:01

not the same thing um great

80:03

civilizations come to an end um and the

80:06

and they come to an end when they decide

80:08

they are no longer willing to fight for

80:10

their future and what does that mean in

80:11

reality if it comes to an end as in if

80:13

the West becomes you know secondary to

80:16

China or Russia what does that mean for

80:18

for me and you decline in living

80:20

standards uh we are going to be dictated

80:23

to by other countries in the way that we

80:25

currently dictate to them uh what they

80:28

should do what they shouldn't do where

80:30

they can have their power centers where

80:31

they can't um it will mean that our our

80:35

children are not as prosperous and not

80:37

as free as as you and I have been um and

80:41

it will mean that the values of the West

80:43

which are ironically the things that

80:45

woke people care about so much human

80:47

rights equality of treatment all of

80:49

those those things will will fall to the

80:51

way side because you know in Russia or

80:53

China the attitude to gay people or

80:56

ethnic minorities is nothing like what

80:59

we have here and so that's what I keep

81:01

trying to say to people like look I

81:03

agree with you when when you say we know

81:05

we need to treat people of different

81:06

backgrounds equally and we need to be

81:08

fair and we need to be kind to people if

81:10

that's what you care about the thing you

81:12

should really really do is do everything

81:14

you possibly can to save the West

81:16

because the moment the West is not

81:18

dominant those values will not be

81:19

considered values at all what could I do

81:22

to save the West okay remove the podcast

81:24

okay Stephen before the podcast what

81:27

could I do as an individual listening to

81:29

this to save the West teach your

81:31

children how lucky they are take them

81:34

abroad show them the rest of the world

81:37

show them what people live like in poor

81:39

countries around the world and remind

81:41

them how fortunate they are and then

81:42

explain to them where it all comes from

81:44

and it comes from the fact that we have

81:47

developed designed invented found the

81:50

magic formula for Human Society at least

81:52

the best one that humans have invented

81:54

so far freedom of expression freedom of

81:56

research freedom of speech capitalism uh

81:59

private property the rule of law um and

82:03

the idea that uh you know we talked

82:05

about religion I think it comes largely

82:07

from Christianity that we we all have

82:09

dignity by virtue of Being Human um uh

82:13

those are the things that have driven

82:14

our society to the tremendous success we

82:16

have to the technological progress

82:18

people don't realize that but you know

82:20

without freedom freedom of research

82:21

freedom of expression you don't have the

82:23

technological progress that we we have

82:25

and then you don't have the dominance

82:26

that we enjoy because our dominance is

82:29

almost entirely based on the

82:30

technological progress we're not the

82:32

most populist civilization in the world

82:34

we don't have the largest number of

82:35

people um we are prosperous because of

82:38

our technological advantages and they

82:39

come from the incredible opportunities

82:42

that people have to research things to

82:45

make things and then to profit from them

82:47

in a way that they don't have in other

82:48

societies uh teach your children that

82:51

their society is great teach them that

82:53

they live in one of the best places in

82:55

the history of the world uh that all the

82:57

[ __ ] they''re being taught at school

82:58

is not true uh inoculate them against

83:01

these ideas my parents had to do this

83:02

with me when I was growing up in the

83:04

Soviet Union they before my first day at

83:06

school they said two things first do not

83:09

ever discuss anything we talk about in

83:11

the home at school because we'll all be

83:13

in trouble and two they're going to

83:15

teach you this this this is this this is

83:17

not true that's fine you don't have to

83:19

you don't have to argue with your

83:20

teacher just know that it's not true

83:22

here's why it's not true if you have any

83:24

questions talk to us you have to

83:26

inoculate your children against this

83:27

stuff and then they will be good

83:28

citizens then they will create things of

83:30

value to the society and they will

83:32

spread that message to others I was

83:34

thinking about you telling the story of

83:35

uh going to school and your parents

83:36

basically saying don't say that because

83:38

we'll be in trouble and and then I had a

83:40

little Flash in my head of some of the

83:41

recent headlines around people talking

83:43

on social media um and being arrested

83:45

for it now I know there's a big spectrum

83:48

of things people have been arrested for

83:49

for saying on social media but there are

83:51

some absurd things as well which make

83:53

everyone I think should give everyone

83:54

cause for concern yeah um but we don't

83:57

think of our society as one where we

83:58

could get in trouble for something we

84:00

tweet well the assumption that most

84:02

people make is well you probably got

84:04

arrested because you said something

84:05

horrific yeah um

84:08

and I understand why they make that

84:10

assumption but it's not always true uh a

84:12

lot of uh gender critical feminists for

84:15

example women who are concerned about

84:17

the invasion of women Spaces by trans

84:19

activists they've had issues with the

84:21

police uh there was a girl called

84:22

Chelsea Russell I don't know if you're

84:24

familiar with this case but she um she

84:27

post her friend was killed in a car

84:29

crash and she posted the lyrics of his

84:31

favorite song on her Instagram and

84:33

contain the nword uh it's a rap song uh

84:36

and she was prosecuted and found guilty

84:38

of a hate crime um and she I think it

84:41

took several years for her to win an

84:42

appeal against this but before that she

84:44

was like tagged she had a curfew lots of

84:48

lots of other things so because you put

84:49

rap lyrics in her Instagram by yeah

84:51

Chelsea Russell look her up um so when

84:54

you restrict what people can say in this

84:56

way you inevitably stray into areas that

85:00

for some reason currently are

85:01

controversial like the trans thing for

85:03

example uh and you punish people for

85:06

expressing you know sometimes not very

85:08

articulately but not everyone is

85:10

articulate sometimes people have honest

85:12

feelings and by the way you know should

85:13

it be illegal to be a dick I I don't

85:16

think so otherwise there' be hell a lot

85:18

of people getting arrested you know um

85:21

and I just think we should always h on

85:23

the side of freedom um we should always

85:25

ear on the side of allowing people to

85:27

express themselves even if what they say

85:28

we really don't like I mean that's what

85:30

our society is built on can I ask you a

85:32

question then do you think someone who

85:34

um says a racial slur online should be

85:38

arrested personally I don't know MH no

85:42

there is a context in which that might

85:44

be the case like if you're saying all

85:46

these nword should be killed that's a

85:48

different thing because you're inciting

85:49

violence but look I've been racially

85:52

abused in my life it's not pleasant but

85:54

like nothing happens do you know what I

85:57

mean yeah I don't think if someone just

85:59

said a racial slur they should be locked

86:01

in jail right um but obviously there

86:04

will be social consequences regardless

86:06

they're not going to be able to get a

86:07

great job for example like if you walked

86:08

into a pub and you you started you know

86:11

going off about some racial group most

86:12

people probably like be like who's that

86:14

dick and you know the landlord might ask

86:16

you to leave yeah that's normal societal

86:18

reaction your friends might stop being

86:20

friends with you that's perfectly

86:22

reasonable but do we need to criminalize

86:24

that behavior gosh slippery slope that

86:26

is I I think so I think so and and I

86:28

think the most important thing is if you

86:30

look around at countries in the world

86:32

where people are prevented from saying

86:34

things that other people don't like

86:36

where people are prevented from making

86:37

jokes that other people don't like those

86:40

are not the sort of societies that we

86:41

would want to live on our

86:43

emulate do you think this election which

86:45

is coming up in the US between Trump and

86:48

Kamala do you think it

86:50

matters every election matters in the

86:52

United States because it's the most

86:53

powerful country in the world and it's

86:55

the leader of the western world and also

86:57

because the gap between those two

86:59

candidates is so vast the Gap in terms

87:02

of their political views and in terms of

87:04

what they would do with the country in

87:06

terms of their perspectives their

87:07

attitudes yes I think is very important

87:09

do you for the woke um the eradication

87:13

of the sort of woke virus that you you

87:16

speak of um do you think one candidate

87:19

is more likely to achieve that than the

87:21

other it's very hard to say because k

87:24

has said a lot of things that are woke

87:26

um and she certainly would allow that

87:30

side to flourish more then again if

87:32

Donald Trump gets elected does that

87:34

provoke even more of a work backlash

87:36

because um you know the woke narrative

87:39

is America's racist and homophobic and

87:41

sexism whatever and when Donald Trump

87:43

gets elected that kind of reinforces

87:45

their ideas about reality and they

87:46

double down so I don't know the reality

87:49

I'm much more concerned about the war in

87:52

Ukraine I think that that needs to be

87:55

resolved um I have a lot of family in

87:57

Ukraine I really care about what happens

88:00

there your wife is Ukrainian my wife's

88:02

Ukrainian my mother's Ukrainian I spent

88:04

my Summers as a kid on my granddad's

88:07

Farm in Ukraine my grandmother 95 years

88:09

old still alive lives 100 kilometers

88:11

from the front line can't leave she

88:13

lived through the Nazi occupation and

88:16

now this um but more importantly for the

88:19

West I think it's a real test of uh the

88:22

West's resolve and that issue needs to

88:25

be resolved by someone I have said from

88:28

day one Ukraine would have to give

88:30

something away for long-term security

88:32

because there's no winning this war

88:34

which candidate is more likely to end

88:36

the

88:37

war well carela I look there's two ways

88:40

to play this right and both of them have

88:42

merits one way is you give the

88:45

ukrainians way more support than we're

88:46

currently doing so they can actually

88:48

make advances that's one way to handle

88:51

it the other way is you accept Where We

88:53

Are and you say to Putin you've got two

88:56

choices my friend one is we do a deal

89:00

that's fair to you and that's fair to

89:01

the ukrainians and the most important

89:03

thing is that the ukrainians get

89:05

long-term security that means because

89:08

you remember in 2014 this has already

89:11

happened Russia already bit a piece off

89:14

Ukraine in

89:15

2014 and but even at that point Ukraine

89:19

had security guarantees from Western

89:20

countries which were not executed on

89:23

right they were not on we promised them

89:25

safety and we didn't give them safety so

89:27

the most important thing in this outcome

89:29

is that there's a physical barrier

89:31

between Ukraine and Russia so that this

89:33

can't happen again so either that's

89:34

membership of NATO not going to happen

89:37

or more likely some kind of Korean style

89:39

demilitarize Zone with peacekeeping

89:41

troops on the border

89:44

right if you don't want to do that

89:46

Vladimir then we will give you cran

89:50

everything that's the threat that's the

89:52

deal you have to do

89:55

out of the two candidates I think Donald

89:57

Trump is probably more likely to get

89:59

that outcome

90:01

uh it's not to say I like everything

90:03

about Donald

90:04

Trump but on that particular issue I

90:07

think he would be the the candidate I

90:09

would put more faith in to sort it

90:11

out for all the businesses and

90:13

entrepreneurs out there listening you

90:14

know how challenging it can be to reach

90:16

the right people especially when it

90:17

comes to B2B marketing that's why I'm

90:19

excited to share that LinkedIn ads who

90:21

sponsor this podcast have the solution

90:22

for you in B2B you're not just doing

90:24

business with one person you're dealing

90:26

with buyer groups who are teams of

90:28

people making decisions together

90:30

LinkedIn ads allows you to reach a vast

90:33

Professional Network of over a billion

90:34

members including a 100 million decision

90:37

makers and 10 million cwe Executives who

90:40

make up these buying groups you can

90:42

precisely Target them by job title

90:44

industry company and more with LinkedIn

90:46

ads targeting and measurement tools

90:48

built specifically for B2B you'll be

90:50

able to drive results and build

90:51

meaningful relationships it's no wonder

90:53

linked to is the highest returning paid

90:55

social platform to help you get started

90:57

LinkedIn ads have kindly offered a $100

91:00

credit to launch your first campaign so

91:02

go to linkedin.com doac 24 to claim your

91:05

credit that's linkedin.com doac 24 terms

91:09

and conditions apply what have you

91:11

changed your mind about that mattered

91:15

interesting I think one of the things

91:16

I've changed my mind most about is

91:18

business as trigonometry has become more

91:21

successful and we start to employ people

91:23

um I've understood things that I didn't

91:25

really used to understand about taxes

91:27

and incentives and stuff like that I

91:29

mean I don't know if you know this but

91:31

Britain more millionaires are leaving

91:32

the UK than any other country in the

91:34

world at the moment really yeah yeah and

91:37

that's because we have a very bad

91:38

business environment we keep talking

91:40

about you know we need to raise taxes on

91:41

the rich and whatever what I never

91:43

really understood is a a tremendous

91:45

amount of wealth is created by business

91:47

people and when you tax them what

91:49

happens is they stay rich but they stop

91:53

employing as many people they stop

91:55

giving jobs to other people uh and so I

91:57

never really understood wealth creation

91:59

very well before it's really interesting

92:01

yeah it's a big topic of conversation at

92:03

the moment in both the US and the UK

92:04

that like capital gains tax and cor

92:06

Corporation tax um and you know it's a

92:10

raging conversation in society which is

92:11

we just need to tax like the rich and

92:13

the business people more and then one

92:15

side says no don't do that because we're

92:17

creating wealth and opportunities and

92:19

jobs and the other side says no you're

92:21

buying a private jet and a and a yacht

92:24

yeah I think in the UK it's particularly

92:26

bad because there's a kind of attitude

92:28

to money here that's that's a little bit

92:31

class warfish in a way you know what I

92:33

mean and and for good reasons probably

92:36

because you know this country had a

92:39

landed gentry these were people who were

92:41

Rich because they were Rich because

92:42

their dad was rich basically right um

92:45

and so we when we think of wealthy

92:47

people we don't think of successful

92:48

people we think of privileged people um

92:51

but most people who have money are not

92:55

like that most people have have money

92:56

because they've created things that are

92:58

of value to other people but we get

93:00

those two things confused quite often uh

93:02

and most people I know who are wealthy

93:05

and successful they don't buy private

93:07

jets they pour all their money that they

93:09

have into bigger better you know hiring

93:13

more people you know when we have more

93:15

money the trigonometry we hire another

93:17

person because we want there's more [ __ ]

93:19

for us to do that we want to do that

93:20

we're not yet doing um then the on other

93:23

things you know I used to be incredibly

93:25

libertarian on drug

93:26

policy I used to think that you know

93:29

people should be take what you know

93:30

freed to take whatever drugs they want I

93:32

still think that about certain drugs but

93:34

I also think there are certain drugs

93:36

that are just so incredibly addictive

93:39

particularly to people who are already

93:40

vulnerable that they shouldn't be

93:42

criminalized I think for taking them I

93:43

think they should be given help they

93:45

should be this should be treated as a

93:46

mental health issue um but I I've become

93:49

slightly less Le less Affair about it uh

93:53

I think

93:54

and then with everything else I've just

93:58

that point you made earlier which is

93:59

Thomas Soul thing about there are no

94:02

Solutions only tradeoffs every time I

94:04

look at any issue I just realize that

94:07

most of the things that we argue about

94:09

are unsolved because they're difficult

94:10

to solve and there's very difficult

94:13

things on on both sides of the argument

94:16

and quite often we look at things from

94:19

an ideological perspective and that

94:21

ruins things take an America they

94:23

they're obsessed politically about

94:24

abortion right you know these people

94:26

argue that people women should be

94:28

allowed and the very good reasons to

94:30

argue that these people argue what the

94:31

sanctity of human life which I think is

94:33

a very good valid reason

94:36

too and we can have those arguments and

94:38

we're going to stay exactly where we'

94:39

stayed for however many

94:41

decades there are countries in the world

94:44

Hungary for example where they have a

94:45

very right-wing government who didn't

94:47

want to make abortion a political issue

94:50

what they did instead is they made

94:51

Family a political issue they encouraged

94:53

people people to have families

94:55

financially they give people all kinds

94:56

of tax breaks and help them get on the

94:58

housing ladder if they have kids and

95:00

they've hared the number of abortions in

95:02

half without Banning abortion right so

95:05

that's a practical solution to an issue

95:07

that is not going to get resolved by

95:09

people arguing about it from an

95:10

ideological position and I just think

95:13

there's so many like tricks like that

95:15

that can be found if we're willing to be

95:18

interested in pragmatism instead of

95:20

ideology it's interesting because when

95:22

you use the abortion example I go you

95:25

know I think a for a lot of people in

95:26

politics this abortion subject is like a

95:28

political weapon now yeah and the I

95:31

think often the same about the Border I

95:33

think if I was trying to get you to vote

95:35

for me and I was um I need to represent

95:40

a bunch of things and if those things

95:41

scare the [ __ ] out of you or create

95:44

create some kind of disgust they're

95:45

probably going to work sure so if I say

95:48

there's rapists coming across the border

95:49

who are taking our daughters or you know

95:51

and they're sending that from mental

95:52

institutions M and they're coming for

95:54

your daughter and I'll stop it it's like

95:56

a compelling now you know sure and also

95:58

I heard Trump talk recently about some

96:00

of the the abortion subjects and talking

96:02

about ripping live babies out that at

96:04

nine months and and I just think God

96:06

that language is so tempting well

96:09

they're trying to win votes having said

96:11

that Trump is is actually very moderate

96:13

by Republican standards on the abortion

96:15

issue he's actually getting the tagged

96:16

from his own side for it um look I think

96:19

on immigration we talked before about

96:22

how different levels of immigration are

96:24

appropriate to different times America

96:26

in particular has a very rich history of

96:28

welcoming people from all over the world

96:31

uh the problem that both Britain and

96:34

America and other European countries

96:35

have is illegal immigration there is no

96:37

reason that should be happening there's

96:39

there's literally zero reason that

96:40

people should be walking into this

96:42

country um without being checked without

96:44

knowing who they are um and there it's

96:48

happening on a vast scale and I give you

96:50

an example this is just anecdotal of

96:51

course but it's representative a big

96:53

issue when I was in last time I was in

96:55

LA all the taxi drivers the lift drivers

97:00

in LA are Armenian okay yeah Armenians

97:04

speak Russian Armenians know that

97:06

Constantine is a Russian name so I'd get

97:08

in the lift they' be oh Constantine

97:10

start speaking Russian to me none of

97:12

them know who I am so we get chatting

97:14

whatever basically the ones that came to

97:17

America in the 80s and 90s they all came

97:20

by applying for Reves or following the

97:21

rules the guys have come since then

97:23

they've all come through the southern

97:25

border really yeah it's not Mexicans

97:27

fleeing cartel oppression mostly it's

97:30

people from all over the world um and

97:32

this guy was telling me was like oh yeah

97:34

yeah yeah I brought my cousins over I

97:35

brought my my dad over he's 883s in a

97:37

wheelchair no problem we're just got him

97:40

over what's the harm what's the harm

97:44

yeah of illegal immigration of him

97:45

coming over and taking that job as a

97:47

lift driver there's no harm of him

97:49

coming over and taking that job as a

97:50

lift driver other than there's lots of

97:52

people who are following the law and

97:54

applying and not coming in because that

97:57

person has jumped a queue you can't have

97:59

people coming in

98:00

illegally you it's against the law it's

98:03

like saying what's the harm of someone

98:05

committing a crime well the harm is

98:07

they're breaking the law right first and

98:08

foremost secondly people break the law

98:12

on purpose the reason they break the law

98:14

is that we probably wouldn't LED them in

98:15

otherwise so that means we've thought

98:18

about what kind of immigration system we

98:20

want to have we've voted for people who

98:22

put in the laws that we wanted I mean

98:24

this idealized version of reality but

98:26

you get what I'm going with this um and

98:29

then we say well we want these people to

98:31

come in but we don't want everyone to

98:33

come in we want only these people

98:34

because they have the right skills the

98:36

right qualifications the right whatever

98:38

and what's happening is we're not

98:40

letting them in some of them and we're

98:41

letting people in that we never wanted

98:43

in the country in the first place then a

98:45

lot of them are coming for example this

98:47

country I don't know the latest figures

98:49

but under the conservatives we were

98:51

spending 8 million pound a day

98:54

every day in Britain on housing for

98:57

illegal immigrants who were coming over

98:59

from other countries right why should

99:01

the British taxpayer be spending 8

99:03

million pound a day to put people up in

99:06

hotels what's the rationale for that I'm

99:09

open to hearing it I still don't know if

99:13

I'm clear on the harm that that if lots

99:16

of people like that cab driver came in

99:18

through the southern border I know it

99:20

breaks the law yes um I want to get

99:23

really clear on the the do you want a

99:27

large population of people whose First

99:29

Act of coming to your countries to break

99:30

the law How likely do you think those

99:33

people are to pay taxes to contribute to

99:36

society more

99:37

broadly less likely than someone who was

99:40

from that country yeah so it would the

99:42

har is and especially less likely so to

99:45

than someone who would have come legally

99:46

by applying for a Visa and getting that

99:48

visa and getting a job so if they all

99:51

abided by the law and paid taxes would

99:53

there be no other harm well we were

99:55

getting to the harm so the harm is not

99:58

all of them are like the lift driver and

100:00

we have no way of sorting them one from

100:02

the other right so when you have large

100:04

levels of illegal immigration one of the

100:06

things that happen is nefarious actors

100:08

abuse that so people come in who are uh

100:13

some of them are criminals some of them

100:14

are terrorists some of them are just

100:16

violent you know Abdula zidi who threw

100:18

acid over that woman and her children

100:20

recently in the UK he was an illegal

100:22

immigrant he came in here on a lry he

100:25

was supposed to have been deported twice

100:26

and then suddenly decided you know what

100:28

I'm a Christian he converted and then we

100:31

we let him stay and then he attacked the

100:33

woman and two children withd are people

100:35

crossing the borders more statistically

100:38

committing crime than people who are

100:40

there legally we don't know interesting

100:43

because we don't know how many of those

100:44

people there are people will say well

100:46

you know actually immigrants commit

100:48

crime or how do you know how do you know

100:50

how many illegal immigrants there are h

100:53

this is what I always think cuz I I

100:54

watched all of the commentary around the

100:56

elections and I watch every debate and I

100:57

know it's on tonight and I watch

100:59

everything and I always hear about like

101:02

the acid attack yeah now that's horrific

101:04

it makes me get get goosebumps when I

101:06

think about it but there's also acid

101:09

attacks going on from people that were

101:10

born here so I'm trying to really

101:13

understand if I'm being brainwashed by

101:15

like an extreme oh my God it's awful in

101:16

that emotional feeling you get when you

101:17

hear that story or statistically there's

101:20

significance here and that's why I as

101:22

the question I'm is this an anomaly

101:24

which is being used to like look over

101:26

here or is it the the norm that illegal

101:29

immigrants are criminals sure but why

101:33

would we take the risk of having people

101:36

come here who are deliberately breaking

101:38

the law does that is that a signal of

101:42

good intent on their part do you know

101:43

what part of it is is I go oh God if I

101:47

was in you know inert country yeah I'd

101:51

give it a go my was bad I'd give it a

101:54

[ __ ] go wouldn't you sure well I'm a

101:56

first generation England yeah yeah I was

101:57

born in Botswana yeah oh were you I yeah

101:59

yeah I was born in Botswana so my half

102:02

of my siblings were born in Manchester

102:03

but me and the youngest were born in

102:05

Botswana my mom's Nigerian so and I

102:06

think if I was in Botswana and I heard

102:08

this like Disneyland of the UK portrayed

102:11

to me on a TV whatever I'd give it a

102:12

shot I interviewed Francis inani yeah oh

102:14

did you amazing guy yeah amazing guy I

102:18

speak to him on WhatsApp sometimes and

102:19

hearing his story that he was in was it

102:21

Cameroon and he Walked Out Of Africa

102:25

swam to like tried swimming got a boat

102:28

tried climbing the walls etc for years

102:30

and years walked through the desert and

102:32

then makes his way to to I think it

102:33

Spain and then gets to France becomes

102:35

the greatest of all time in UFC you go I

102:38

I wouldn't agree with that noones is the

102:41

greatest he's the greatest of all time I

102:42

meant to say the heavyweight champion of

102:43

the world of the world he's incredible

102:45

fighter just the most incredible Story

102:46

the fact that that fight has didn't

102:48

happen is the worst it's just a crime

102:51

yeah anyway your point is

102:53

you would do it yes and you're a a

102:57

valuable member of our society that we

102:58

need sure uh but what the point I'm

103:01

trying to make to you is first and

103:03

foremost people act like that's the

103:06

choice right either we let Francis and

103:07

Ghana drown in the

103:09

Mediterranean or we let him in illegally

103:12

that's not what I'm advocating for this

103:13

is where a lot of this conversation

103:15

breaks down the actual solution to this

103:17

like with the abortion thing that we

103:18

talked about there are practical

103:19

solutions to this that actually make

103:21

sense what you do is you set set up

103:23

Refugee processing centers in the local

103:25

areas where there are conflicts where

103:28

there's all sorts of turmoil going on

103:30

people can apply there and then be

103:32

selected or not selected based on their

103:34

circumstances because you like you said

103:37

there are no Solutions only tradeoffs we

103:39

can't let everyone in the world who is

103:41

poorer than us into our country can we

103:44

no can we agree on that yeah I'm not I'm

103:46

not I know you're I'm just saying I'm

103:48

just taking you through the argument I'm

103:49

not saying you're saying that so that

103:52

means we have to limit number of people

103:53

we allow in is that fair yes okay

103:56

therefore we then have to choose who we

103:57

let in is that fair yeah okay therefore

103:59

illegal immigrations unacceptable does

104:01

that make sense yeah okay because if we

104:04

want to help people from poor parts of

104:06

the world where they're being mistreated

104:07

and oppressed we have to get them to

104:10

form an orderly line in those areas give

104:13

them an opportunity to apply for Asylum

104:16

then pick the ones that we think are the

104:17

most likely to not be terrorists not be

104:19

criminals they have a genuine case that

104:22

they need our help that they're most

104:23

likely to contribute to our society if

104:25

they break out of the queue and Run and

104:28

Jump the wall and get in yeah do you

104:30

have empathy for them of course and can

104:33

you blame them no no it's and I think

104:37

this is the kind of nuance and issue

104:38

which some people sometimes don't

104:39

highlight which is and I mean if you

104:41

think about what's happened on the

104:42

streets of the UK recently it's been

104:45

attacking them like going to the hotels

104:48

where they they've been put trying to

104:50

burn the hotels burning down Asylum

104:51

centers and hotels is moronic and people

104:54

shouldn't do it and they should go to

104:55

prison for doing it and people can't see

104:58

the difference no they can't you know I

104:59

mean it's like you stole my job yes well

105:04

yes and I don't think I I I think sadly

105:07

what happens is when people lived in

105:09

deprived communities where they don't

105:11

have jobs and it's not because someone

105:12

stole them it's just because those

105:13

communities were de-industrialized or

105:15

whatever they get deprived and people

105:17

lash out U and it's terrible and it

105:20

shouldn't happen and they always look

105:21

for escape go and that scape is always

105:23

going to be somebody like that that does

105:25

not mean that we should have an open

105:28

border for illegal immigration right so

105:31

the question is can we let everybody in

105:34

that would want to come here the answer

105:35

is no as we agree that means we have to

105:37

be selective that means we have to

105:39

choose who comes and who doesn't that

105:41

means we are going to have to reject

105:42

some people we can still have empathy

105:45

for them and understanding for them but

105:47

it's like you have a front door in your

105:49

house and there are thousands of

105:51

homeless people in London

105:53

what if one of them broke into your

105:54

house and started stealing stuff to sell

105:59

you would have empathy wouldn't you not

106:02

a lot judging by your face but you would

106:04

have some okay let me try and add some

106:05

more color to this analogy what if I

106:07

needed people in my house to make it

106:09

function and um okay good analogy so

106:13

let's say you need someone to build you

106:14

an extension like I need like a cleaner

106:16

a chef you need a you need a cleaner you

106:18

need a chef and you need someone to

106:20

build an extension so you need a bunch

106:22

of people yeah

106:24

and you put out a job advert right and

106:27

some people reply and you're like cool

106:29

I'll pay you this much you come in you

106:31

sort out my extension you do my cleaning

106:33

you do my cooking blah blah blah

106:35

okay they're turn scheduled to turn up

106:37

on Monday and then on Sunday a bunch of

106:39

people break into your

106:42

house and start doing all that stuff you

106:44

don't know who they are you don't know

106:45

what their qualifications are they break

106:47

down the front door and walk in mhm

106:50

would would you be cool with that no

106:53

right so in the same way that we have a

106:55

front door on our houses because we want

106:56

to decide who comes in and out of our

106:58

houses we have a front door on our

107:01

countries I agree I think illegal

107:02

immigration for all the reasons you've

107:04

said is not is not acceptable and um the

107:06

part that I where I get pulled a little

107:10

bit is where I see the illegal

107:12

immigrants being demonized whereas what

107:15

nothing to do with them yeah which is

107:16

what but it's almost impossible and

107:18

there's so many issues in society like

107:20

this where if you talk about the issue

107:22

and really talk about the issue there

107:25

will be some important conversation

107:27

happening here then you'll have some

107:28

people come to the issue and see it as

107:30

an opportunity to Fan The Embers and the

107:34

people that fan The Embers cause people

107:35

Downstream to misunderstand the issue

107:37

and then start wars below so the point

107:40

the conversation we're having about

107:41

immigration is a I think is a productive

107:43

conversation but then if if someone you

107:46

know uses that as a as a way to get into

107:49

Power by saying that someone is coming

107:51

to rape your children or they're

107:53

stealing from you or all these things

107:55

they've taken your job they're the

107:56

reason you're unemployed you know

107:58

they're the reason she she broke up with

107:59

you because you don't have a job now the

108:01

illegals um that then causes all of this

108:03

horrible Division and fighting below and

108:05

lots of like people get caught in the

108:06

crossfire that were just getting on with

108:08

their lives and good people 100% And

108:10

that's that's why it's so so unfortunate

108:12

we can't well we can we're doing it now

108:16

I think you and I I don't know what you

108:18

actually think but certainly in terms of

108:19

your arguments you're putting to me

108:21

you're coming from a different place and

108:23

I think we've got to the place that we

108:25

understand that I'm not anti-immigrant

108:27

yeah uh and I'm actually Pro immigration

108:30

in the sense that um well I'm I'm not

108:33

pro or anti-immigration sense it depends

108:35

on the time that you're in but generally

108:37

speaking I think when you choose the

108:39

people who come when they're culturally

108:41

a good fit for that society when they're

108:43

driven and talented and ambitious and

108:45

blah blah blah blah blah that is going

108:47

to be hugely beneficial to your country

108:50

um and I am for having legal immigration

108:54

at the level that is beneficial to our

108:55

society which is not zero legal

108:57

immigration I think can be very

108:59

conducive so not anti-immigrant

109:01

otherwise I'd have to be anti- me um but

109:04

at the same time I think illegal

109:05

immigration it just shouldn't be

109:06

happening yeah we agree and that's quite

109:09

rare actually the the the ability to say

109:11

that immigrants aren't bad people

109:13

they're not the the bad ones necessarily

109:15

they're not the ones to to demonize um

109:17

although of course there's exceptions

109:19

and that um legal immigration's good

109:22

legal legal immigration's bad well again

109:24

legal immigration can be good yeah right

109:27

uh if it's very large numbers of people

109:30

in a very short period of time that

109:32

becomes very difficult to digest for the

109:34

whole society and then then tensions

109:36

arise of the kind that you're talking

109:37

about so my view is you want to bring in

109:40

the right number of people you want to

109:42

make sure that they're able to integrate

109:44

make themselves at home learn the

109:45

language adapt and then you can bring

109:47

more people if that's what your Society

109:48

needs at that time what's the most

109:50

important thing we didn't talk about

109:51

that we should have talked about

109:54

hm it's a good question uh tradeoff

109:57

denialism

109:59

interesting tradeoff

110:01

denialism tradeoff denialism is people

110:03

who deny the very thing that we've been

110:05

discussing most of this conversation

110:06

which is you can't solve every problem

110:10

you can choose which tradeoff you get

110:13

and in a lot of our conversations we

110:15

talk about them as if there are no

110:18

trade-offs climate change which I talked

110:20

about in my Ox speech is a very good

110:21

example of this people say the planet's

110:23

about to burn therefore we must do

110:26

everything that we possibly can the

110:28

problem is that when you do the things

110:30

that they're suggesting you do a

110:31

terrible amount of damage to people you

110:33

make people poor especially in the third

110:35

world in the poor parts of the world um

110:38

and in our countries too um you know the

110:42

reason that people are living longer and

110:45

healthier lives is because we burn

110:47

fossil fuels in 1947 the average life

110:50

expectancy in India was 32

110:53

32 that's mostly because Jesus I just

110:55

turned 32 yeah so on average you would

110:59

have died by

111:01

now mostly in in infancy actually a lot

111:04

of it was infant mortality today it's

111:07

71 why because they're burning a hell of

111:10

a lot of f fossil fuels and getting

111:12

richer as a result right energy is what

111:15

makes our societies run it's why we are

111:17

living longer eating better all of that

111:20

when you pursue this idea called Net

111:23

Zero which is when we Outsource our own

111:25

emissions to other countries so we can

111:26

pretend that we're green we actually

111:28

create more CO2 around the world because

111:31

we're we're Outsourcing manufacturing to

111:34

other countries where they make things

111:35

dirtier and then we're shipping them

111:37

back MH right um that doesn't make the

111:41

world better it makes us feel better but

111:43

if your thing is well you know climate

111:46

change is the only thing that M it's the

111:47

only variable that we're optimizing for

111:49

then you do a lot of damage and it's the

111:51

same with almost everything else that do

111:53

so what's the solution with the climate

111:55

change challenge what how would you

111:56

approach it if we and presumably you

111:58

believe in the idea that in global

112:00

warming and climate change I guess yeah

112:02

well the world is warming and there

112:05

human beings do contribute to that as

112:06

far as I understand um it's not nearly

112:09

the catastrophe that we're being told

112:10

that it is not even remotely the

112:12

catastrophe that we're being told that

112:13

it is for a number of reasons one of

112:15

them is when the climate gets warmer

112:16

it's actually much better for human

112:18

beings within a certain range uh we it's

112:21

beneficial to Human Society we know that

112:23

from history um doesn't mean that we

112:26

want run away climate change mhm but

112:29

more people die from the cold than die

112:31

from warm from warm weather and from

112:33

warm weather related events one of the

112:35

things that we actually know is that far

112:38

fewer people are dying from climate

112:40

related disasters every year and that's

112:43

because our technology and coping with

112:45

them is getting better uh my view is

112:47

answer is technological uh we've got to

112:49

use way more nuclear power than we use

112:51

because it's carbon neutral to not

112:53

entirely but it's you need a lot less of

112:55

it uh you build a power station and

112:57

basically then it kind of runs itself

112:59

there's nuclear waste we'll find a

113:00

solution to that but the solution is

113:02

very simple we have to find a way to

113:04

make energy cheaper that's clean it's

113:06

really interesting actually I was just

113:07

thinking as you're speaking about the

113:08

call that Trump had with um Elon where

113:12

Trump's making his point about climate

113:13

change and then elon's kind of saying

113:15

well actually like climate change is a

113:18

real thing and okay it's we're not going

113:20

to the planet isn't going to burn in 5

113:21

years or 10 years but you know in with

113:23

within sort of a medium time Horizon we

113:25

do need to get carbon levels down and I

113:28

was just thinking as you was speaking I

113:29

was thinking God if if Elon wasn't

113:30

running

113:31

Tesla I think that the right who I think

113:34

have now kind of adopted Elon in some

113:35

respects would think about climate

113:37

change very very differently I think the

113:39

right do think about it very differently

113:41

I think climate is quite unpopular on

113:43

the right but but his presence there

113:46

means that people are openminded open

113:48

minded subject and look the the answer

113:50

to that issue like with every other

113:52

issue is to think about as a pragmatic

113:53

issue not as a religious issue which is

113:55

increasingly what it's become people

113:57

gluing themselves to roads and throwing

113:59

soup on paintings is not going to stop

114:01

climate change is my point we have a

114:04

closing tradition on this podcast where

114:05

the last guest leaves a question for the

114:06

next guest not knowing who they're

114:07

leaving it for and the question that's

114:09

been left for you oh in the D I didn't

114:12

know that

114:13

is what is one unfulfilled dream in your

114:18

life huh it's a good question

114:23

to have a large

114:24

family oh interesting so you've got one

114:27

child yeah and we'll probably squeeze

114:28

another ey if we're lucky but apart from

114:31

that that that will that will remain

114:33

unfulfilled I

114:34

suspect interesting yeah thank you so

114:37

much thank you so much for the work that

114:38

you do your your podcast has an absolute

114:40

cult trigonometry an absolute cult so

114:43

many my team members are really really

114:44

big fans of the show and I've watched so

114:46

many episodes predominantly clips that

114:48

I've seen and then I've got drawn in and

114:50

then TR tried to find the longer form

114:51

episode but it's um it's an

114:54

important uh last refuge for sense and I

114:59

and I really respect people like you

115:01

because I do think that you do a really

115:03

good job of navigating complex issues in

115:07

a way where I still have faith in your

115:12

process I still believe that you when

115:14

you approach these issues you're not

115:16

doing it because you're ideologically

115:18

contaminated in some way you're still

115:20

trying to approach them despite the

115:22

tempt and the external pressure with the

115:24

intention of pursuing truth and truth to

115:26

the to the means of making things better

115:28

and those are the people that I really

115:29

warmed to because it's difficult I

115:32

appreciate that man I feel seen as they

115:34

say oh good no but I that's that's the

115:36

goal you know uh it's one of the things

115:38

that we're very proud of is that as we

115:41

discussed in the main conversation you

115:42

know it's very very easy to make lots of

115:45

money and get lots of attention by

115:47

appealing to people's base instincts and

115:49

worst instincts to by pretending to have

115:52

more extreme views that you have um and

115:55

we've really done our best we are all

115:57

susceptible to it uh but we've really

116:00

done our best to operate from that place

116:03

bad faith changes everything and so does

116:06

good faith when you act in bad faith it

116:08

changes everything like this

116:09

conversation if you were acting in bad

116:11

faith we wouldn't have had the

116:12

conversation we would have had good

116:14

faith changes everything as well and

116:15

that's what we try to do it's what

116:17

you're clearly doing so anyway thank you

116:19

for having me and enjoy the hate you're

116:20

going to get it's okay thank you so

116:25

[Music]

116:29

much every single time you eat you have

116:32

an opportunity to improve your health

116:34

and that's why I love Zoe because Zoe

116:36

helps me to make the smartest food

116:38

choices for me and my body and as you

116:41

guys will know by now Zoe is a sponsor

116:43

of this podcast and I'm an investor in

116:44

the company and if you haven't tried Zoe

116:46

I highly recommend you do because Zoe

116:48

combines My Health Data with Zoe's

116:50

worldclass science and using those two

116:53

things Zoe guides me to Better Health

116:56

every single time I make a food choice

116:57

and eat which means that I have more

116:59

energy better sleep better mood and I'm

117:01

less hungry and the most important thing

117:03

is Zoe actually works it's backed by

117:05

their recent clinical trial something

117:07

called the method study which is the

117:09

gold standard of scientific research I

117:11

started Zoe just over a year ago now and

117:13

I've been able to track my progress week

117:16

after week so I can learn how to be even

117:18

smarter the following week and if you

117:19

haven't joined Zoe yet I'm giving you

117:21

10% off when you join Zoe now just use

117:24

the code ce10 at checkout isn't this

117:29

cool every single conversation I have

117:30

here on the Diary of a CEO at the very

117:32

end of it you'll know I asked the guest

117:35

to leave a question in the Diary of a

117:37

CEO and what we've done is we've turned

117:40

every single question written in the

117:42

Diary of a CEO into these conversation

117:45

cards that you can play at home so

117:47

you've got every guest we've ever had

117:50

their question and on the back back of

117:52

it if you scan that QR code you get to

117:55

watch the person who answered that

117:58

question we're finally revealing all of

118:01

the questions and the people that

118:04

answered the question the brand new

118:06

version 2 updated conversation cards are

118:09

out right now at Theon conversation

118:12

cards.com they've sold out twice

118:14

instantaneously so if you are interested

118:15

in getting hold of some limited edition

118:17

conversation cards I really really

118:19

recommend acting quickly

118:22

oh

118:24

[Music]

Interactive Summary

This episode features Konstantin Kisin, a podcaster and social commentator, discussing the dangers of modern ideological movements like 'wokeness' and their impact on Western civilization. Kisin argues that Western societies are at risk of self-destruction due to internal division, cultural suicide, and the rejection of foundational values. He emphasizes the importance of objective truth, the danger of victimhood mindsets, and the need for individuals to take personal responsibility to thrive. Kisin also addresses topics such as the influence of foreign propaganda in destabilizing Western nations, the importance of free speech, and the role of religion and traditional values in providing social structure.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts