Supplements I recommend as a doctor (and the ones I don’t)
412 segments
Supplements feel like an easy win for
better sleep, more energy, or just
living longer, but many don't actually
work, and some can even be risky for
your health. So, let's break down which
supplements I think you should skip,
try, or buy. Whenever I'm deciding
whether to take a supplement at all, I'm
always asking myself three simple
questions that you can ask yourself,
too. Number one, why do I need it? Am I
trying to help with a symptom or am I
trying to prevent something down the
line? Number two, how will I even know
whether it's working? Can I track my
symptom or is there a simple blood test
that I can do to measure its impact? And
number three, if I'm going to take it,
what is the best quality supplement I
can get? With this in mind, let's move
to our first supplement. Multivitamins.
These are the classic just in case
supplement like a nutritional insurance
policy to cover your bases, but for most
people, they don't seem to do much. Big
studies haven't shown any benefit for
living longer or protecting against
major diseases like heart disease. And
my big issue with multivitamins is the
false sense of reassurance you get. I
took my multivitamin today, so I don't
really need to worry about my diet. And
this is not the way we should be
thinking. And in some people like
smokers or those with precancerous
conditions, high doses of certain
vitamins that you find in multivitz like
vitamin B6 have actually been linked to
a slightly higher risk of cancer. So
these aren't harmless across the board,
especially in large amounts. There are a
few cases where they might be
beneficial, like if you're recovering
from surgery, you have a very limited
diet or you're older at risk of
deficiencies, but even then, I would say
you're usually better off with targeted
supplements and adding more
nutrient-dense foods to your overall
meals. My verdict, I would say skip
unless you've been advised to take one
and focus on real nutrients which are in
whole foods first. Creatine monohydrate.
Most people know creatine for sports
performance because it helps your body
produce quick energy when you're doing
short intense bursts of activity like
lifting weights or sprinting. There are
also some endurance benefits as well.
And there's also exciting research on
brain health too, especially in older
adults who tend to have lower levels.
It's really wellstudied. It's got a good
safety profile with minimal side
effects. And the usual dose is anywhere
between 3 to 5 grams of creatine
monohydrate daily. Again, you don't need
it to be healthy. Your body naturally
makes creatine. And you can also get
some extra sources from meat and fish.
My verdict is this is a try,
particularly if you exercise regularly.
There is emerging evidence that vegans
and vegetarians could also benefit from
having this because you don't get it
from your diet and older adults to
protect their brains. NMN, NAD+, and
other brain boosters. On the topic of
brain health, I've seen a lot of
supplements with big price tags and bold
claims. NMN is one of those supplements
that sounds exciting on paper, and it's
a type of vitamin B3 that helps your
body make NAD+, which drops as we age.
But all these claims you see on labels
are based on theoretical mechanisms or
studies in mice. There is no solid
evidence behind them in human trials and
we have no idea what it does long term.
My verdict, it's a big skip. Magnesium
is another one I see everywhere, often
cited as a sleep fix. And look, it is
essential. It's involved in everything
from muscle and nerve function to blood
pressure regulation. But the research on
supplements, it's kind of weak. There
are some small benefits in older adults
and in people who train super hard, but
not enough to make a strong
recommendation across the board. It's
safe in general, but high doses can
cause diarrhea, gastric upset, cramps,
and it can also interact with
medications like antibiotics,
osteoporosis drugs. So, please check
with your physician if you are taking
any medications long term. For most
people, the best way to start is getting
more magnesium richch foods in your
diet. And adults need generally around
300 to 400 milligrams per day, which is
really achievable from four to five
portions of foods like a handful of nuts
and seeds, particularly pumpkin and
almonds. Cooked greens, particularly
things like kale and spinach, wonderful
sources. Edomame beans, even black beans
have got magnesium in. and whole grains.
I know grains get a bit of a hard time
because they're carbohydrate dense, but
they also contain nutrients,
particularly things like quinoa, which
is a pseudo grain. My verdict is try if
you're training really hard, if you're
older, or if you struggle to get these
kind of foods in your diet, but I would
optimize your meals first. A lot of
people think about iron when they're
feeling a bit tired, getting heavy
periods, or eating mostly plant-based.
And again, iron is essential. We need it
to make healthy red blood cells that
carry oxygen around the body. But if you
don't have an actual deficiency, taking
iron supplements has no proven benefit.
And it's actually one that you want to
be really careful with because too much
iron in the body can irritate the gut
and it can potentially increase
oxidative stress over time, which leads
to raised inflammation levels. If you're
concerned about iron deficiency, the
best thing to do is get your iron levels
checked. There are lots of reasons
outside of iron deficiency that lead to
tiredness. And before rushing to the
supplement aisle, I would also encourage
you to eat more iron rich foods. Things
like seafood, particularly mackerel,
sardines, a little bit of red meat if
you eat it. Lentils and beans are also
good sources of iron. Tofu, and here's a
little trick. If you are plant-based in
particular, you want to pair these foods
with something that is high in vitamin
C, something like green leafy vegetables
that also have iron, peppers or lemon
juice, because that also increases the
absorption of iron into the bloodstream.
My verdict, skip unless you've been
diagnosed with low iron or anemia after
a blood test, and it's not something to
top up with for the sake of it.
Probiotics are having a real moment.
They are everywhere promising to fix
your gut, improve your immunity, or just
make you feel better. But most gut
experts that we have talked to agree
that popping a probiotic every day
probably won't do much. We actually
don't know what a healthy gut bacterial
population looks like because it's so
personal and most supplements only offer
a handful of these bacterial species.
whilst your gut naturally has hundreds
of different microbes. In some cases,
however, if you've just taken
antibiotics or you've been diagnosed
with a gut issue like IBS, certain
probiotic strains might help, but it's
best to use them with advice from a
registered nutrition professional or a
physician. If you want to look after
your gut daily, it's actually much more
helpful to think about other things in
your lifestyle. For example, stress. You
can help digestion with belly breathing
before eating meals. Feeding the
microbes that you already have with
specific types of fibers called
prebiotics. These you get from foods
like whole grains, beans, and nuts, plus
fermented foods. Things like natural
yogurts, keir, or sauerkrauts and
kimchi. My verdict on probiotics, try if
recommended for a specific issue, but I
don't think it's worth it for most
people as a daily supplement. focus on
this stuff instead. Green powders. Look,
getting your greens in without having to
chop any vegetables sounds pretty ideal.
It's not a new idea either. Drying fruit
and vegetables has been around forever.
It can help actually preserve nutrients
like vitamin C and folate. But when it
comes to tangible benefits like
improving immunity, digestion, or energy
that a lot of these green powder brands
are promising, the evidence is pretty
weak or I would say non-existent. My
real issue is actually quality. A lot of
these powders don't tell you what's
actually inside or how much. Some add
sweeteners and flavorings that are not
great for your gut at all. Particularly
if you're having one of these powders
every single day. And when you turn
plants into powder, you lose more than
just water. you lose fiber, texture, and
how everything works synergistically
together, which is what makes whole
plants so beneficial themselves in the
first place. That said, a good green
powder can actually come in handy if
you're traveling or you're busy, you're
struggling to get fresh produce in every
single day. Just make sure you do some
research. Look for companies that use
freeze drying or gentle processing and
are really transparent about the
ingredients that they put into their
powder and don't have any additives. It
should also taste like it works. Pretty
disgusting. My preference, however, is
if you have a blender and 30 seconds,
you're honestly better off making a
quick smoothie with some nutrient-dense
frozen ingredients. Frozen spinach,
frozen berries, probiotic Greek yogurt,
bit of nut butter, some raw honey,
splash of water.
[Music]
This is far cheaper. It gives you fiber
and the whole orchestra of nutrients,
not just a faded tune. It's good. My
verdict for green powders, try, but only
a good one as a backup. A lot of people,
even in sunny countries, are low on
vitamin D. We spend most of our time
indoors, missing out on sunlight, which
is our main source of vitamin D. And
it's pretty hard to get enough from food
alone. And vitamin D acts more like a
hormone than a true vitamin. It helps
regulate hundreds of processes in your
body. So, if your levels are low, a
supplement can definitely help. It's
been linked to stronger bones, fewer
fractures, and possibly fewer infections
as well. But it's not magic. The
benefits mainly show up when you correct
a deficiency, which is why I think a
blood test is the only real way to know
whether you'll benefit from
supplementation. It's also worth
mentioning that if you have darker skin,
melanin blocks UV, so you make less
vitamin D. So, if you're older and you
don't get outside much, or you have
darker complexion like myself, it's
definitely something to get tested. If
your levels are low, I recommend taking
anywhere between 400 IU to 2,000 IU per
day, and that's vitamin D3 with vitamin
K2. Be wary of higher doses without
testing your level because more isn't
necessarily better and it can actually
be harmful. It is still worth adding
some food sources of vitamin D to your
diet like sardines, eggs, mushrooms that
have been exposed to sunlight and things
like salmon as well. Every little adds
up. My verdict for vitamin D, buy and
test your vitamin D levels if you can.
Omega3. Now, the best evidence we have
is for heart health, but there may be
some extra benefits for brain, mood, and
even inflammatory conditions. Now, if
you're eating oily fish two to three
times a week, like salmon, sardines,
mackerel, anchovies, you're probably
okay. But if not, I would say a
supplement is probably worth it.
However, there's debate around how much
omega-3 is beneficial. Most people aim
for around 250 to 500 mg of EPA and DHA
every day. But if you're after specific
benefits, closer to 1 to two grams is
probably better. If you can test your
levels with an omega-3 index blood test,
ideally you want it over 8% for heart
and brain health benefits. And one other
thing to watch out for is not all fish
oils are good quality. Some can be
oxidized, rancid, and not contain what
they say. So, look for third-party
testing on the brand's website. If
you're vegan or vegetarian, I actually
highly recommend you take an omega-3
supplement, and you can get them sourced
from algae sources as well, but you do
need to consume enough to get a high
level of EPA and DHA. My verdict is, oh,
it's a buy as it's hard to get over a
gram of EPA and DHA from food alone.
Protein powders. Now, the more I've
looked into the research on protein, the
more I'm convinced that many of us could
do with a little bit more, especially as
we get older. Protein powders can be a
handy topup, especially if you're busy,
training a lot, or just not eating
enough to meet your needs. There's good
evidence that they can help build muscle
and maintain it, especially alongside
strength training. That said, a lot of
protein powders are ultrarocessed. They
contain artificial sweeteners, gums,
emulsifies, and the quality can be all
over the place. Certainly not something
that I would recommend you consume every
single day. So, if you do use them, flip
the pack or tub over and read the label.
Always look for third-p partyy testing
that's on the brand's website. That is
your best bet for avoiding contaminants
like heavy metals that plague lots of
protein powders. But really, the
healthiest way I believe is to get
protein through whole foods. It could be
protein snacks like Greek yogurt with
berries, nuts and seeds, particularly
peanuts, pistachios, and things like
shelled hemp seeds, which are really
high in protein. You could also try
snacks like boiled eggs and hummus as a
way to just bump up that protein number.
And some of my favorite plant-based
sources of protein are edomame, tempeh,
and of course, tofu. Poultry, fish, and
lean red meat are obviously good sources
as well. So, my verdict is try protein
powders when you can't get enough from
food. Use them as a top up, not as your
main protein source. We've covered a lot
of supplements. The list could go on,
but what I'm really excited about are
the potential for whole food
supplements. Instead of isolated
nutrients, you're getting a full
spectrum of things like fiber, healthy
fats, proteins, and polyphenols all
working together for your gut, your
heart, and your brain. It's sort of like
using the full tool kit instead of just
one screwdriver. So, for example, for
energy and focus, you've got cacao. It's
my go-to. It's full of flavonol that
help with blood flow to the brain. It
tastes delicious. It also has a
prebiotic effect, which is great for
your gut health, and it's a source of
protein as well. I use this in lots of
different recipes. Specifically for gut
health, I'm always looking for flax seed
and psyllium husk. They give you tons of
fiber and there's evidence that it can
improve digestion, feed your gut
microbiome, and even reduce cholesterol
as well. For inflammation and joint
health, turmeric, as well as other
spices, work gently but powerfully,
especially when you pair it with black
pepper. for immunity and antioxidant
support. Frozen or freeze-dried berries
like bilbury, black currants are packed
with these plant chemicals called
polyphenols and vitamin C. And these are
fantastic at not just reducing
inflammation but also supporting your
gut microbes as well. For sleep,
something that I get asked about a lot,
instead of relying on supplements or
even food, I think habits matter the
most. Stick to a regular bedtime. Keep
your room cool and dark. Cut off
caffeine before 11:00 a.m. Eat an
earlier dinner and remove digital
devices at least a couple of hours
before bed. If you do that consistently,
it will be better than any sleep
supplement and even some medications as
well. If you think we've missed out on
any supplements, let us know in the
comments. And the best thing about whole
foods, in my opinion, is that they slip
into your day without you even noticing.
Like these three high protein breakfast
recipes that I swear by. They're
absolutely delicious and they're so easy
to make whilst packing in over 30 g of
protein per serve.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video discusses the effectiveness and potential risks of various popular supplements, offering guidance on whether to skip, try, or buy them. It emphasizes asking three key questions before taking any supplement: why is it needed, how will its effectiveness be measured, and what is the best quality option available. The video provides specific advice on multivitamins, creatine monohydrate, NMN, magnesium, iron, probiotics, green powders, vitamin D, omega-3s, and protein powders. It concludes by highlighting the benefits of whole food supplements and emphasizing lifestyle habits for sleep over supplements.
Videos recently processed by our community