HomeVideos

Here’s Why China is MAD About Venezuela | China Decode

Now Playing

Here’s Why China is MAD About Venezuela | China Decode

Transcript

845 segments

0:00

Venezuela is not Taiwan in terms of

0:02

China's core interests. It is a

0:04

important strategic foothold uh for

0:06

China in Latin America. I mean, it was

0:09

described as an all-weather strategic

0:10

partnership back in 2023. So, this was a

0:13

critical relationship that has, I think,

0:15

been [music] weakened with the Trump

0:17

administration's move.

0:20

[music]

0:22

Welcome to China Decode. I'm Alice Han

0:25

>> and I'm James King. In today's episode

0:27

of China Decode, we're discussing how

0:30

China will respond to Trump's takeover

0:32

of Venezuela, a turning point in the

0:34

electric vehicle race, and China's

0:36

luxury food boom. That's all coming up.

0:39

But first, let's do a quick check-in

0:41

with how the Chinese markets are

0:42

starting the week. On Monday, the

0:44

Shanghai Asshare index rose 1.4% on its

0:47

first trading day of the year. The

0:49

Hangshare index rose less than 0.1%

0:53

hovering near a 7-week high. Oil

0:56

companies Petrochina and China National

0:58

Offshore Oil Corporation both fell more

1:00

than 3% due to their ties to Venezuela.

1:04

And Miniax, a Shanghai based AI company

1:06

backed by both Alibaba and Tencent, is

1:09

expected to begin trading on the Hong

1:11

Kong stock exchange within the week at

1:14

an IPO valuation of $6.5 billion. All

1:18

right, let's get right into it. China

1:21

just watched the US pull off a lightning

1:23

strike and takeover in Venezuela,

1:26

removing the leader Nicholas Maduro and

1:29

threatening to take some control over

1:31

the nation's oil industry. Now, this

1:34

happened just hours after Beijing's top

1:36

envoy was sitting with Maduro himself.

1:39

Now, this timing could be accidental or

1:42

it could be the opposite. But for China,

1:44

Venezuela isn't just an ideological

1:46

ally. It is a significant energy

1:48

supplier, a major data, a strategic

1:51

foothold in Latin America and a test

1:53

case for pushing against US dominance in

1:57

the Western Hemisphere. A day after the

1:59

US operation, the Chinese Foreign

2:00

Ministry declared itself quote unquote

2:03

deeply shocked and strongly condemned

2:06

the flagrant use of force by the United

2:08

States against a sovereign state. So the

2:11

real question now isn't so much whether

2:13

China is angry, it's how it will

2:15

respond. Will Beijing swallow the loss

2:18

and play the long game? Or does Trump's

2:20

move force China to harden its posture

2:23

elsewhere from Latin America to Taiwan

2:26

or even the South China Sea? What

2:28

happens next could tell us a lot about

2:29

the shape of US China relations in 2026?

2:33

James, I'm very excited to be talking

2:35

about this for the first episode of the

2:37

year. I want to hear your takes before I

2:39

dive into mine. What's what's your view

2:41

on this?

2:41

>> Well, Alice, I mean, you know, when it

2:43

rains, it pours.

2:45

um the the new year starting off like

2:47

this. Uh there really couldn't be a

2:50

bigger geopolitical question for China

2:53

than how it reacts to this. And I think

2:55

you framed it perfectly. Is it going to

2:58

play the long game or are we going to

3:00

see some retaliation

3:03

uh pretty much straight off potentially

3:05

even military retaliation? Now, I'm not

3:08

going to duck the question. I'm going to

3:10

go straight in there. Um, of course, we

3:12

can't know the answer. Such things are

3:16

among China's most closely guarded

3:18

secrets. I think that we will not see a

3:22

military retaliation from China on

3:25

Taiwan or in the South China Sea, at

3:28

least not in the short term. I think

3:30

that what you framed as China playing

3:33

the long game is a much more uh likely

3:36

scenario. And the reason I think that is

3:39

because Taiwan considerations

3:42

are in the background of China's

3:44

reaction to this. Venezuela is a long

3:46

way from China. It's a long way from

3:49

Taiwan. But just let me try and sketch

3:52

out why I think Taiwan and and and

3:55

China's reaction to Taiwan is crucial in

3:58

this geopolitical shadow play that we're

4:00

watching. I think that the way in which

4:03

the US framed its move on Venezuela as

4:08

part of its uh attempts to shore up its

4:11

backyard to concentrate on what both

4:14

Trump and Marco Rubio described as the

4:17

Western Hemisphere. I think that that

4:20

may give China a ray of hope or at least

4:24

cause to wait and see whether the US is

4:28

really serious about concentrating its

4:31

geopolitical attention onto the Western

4:33

Hemisphere, which of course doesn't

4:36

include Taiwan or China, and thereby

4:40

move away or shift the focus of its

4:43

geopolitical reach away from China's

4:47

sphere of influence.

4:49

And so I think if that does turn out to

4:51

be the case, we may well see China

4:55

taking a longer view on this and

4:58

although yes, some of China's

5:00

condemnations um have been fairly

5:03

strong, I also think that uh other

5:07

statements by the Chinese so far give

5:10

the sense that China is really waiting

5:13

uh to see. The two pieces of reasoning

5:16

that I advanced to support my point of

5:19

view is that the national security

5:22

strategy which the US released in

5:25

December last year identifies the

5:28

western hemisphere as the vital interest

5:31

of the US and it drops language from the

5:34

Biden presidency that identified China

5:38

as America's most consequential

5:41

geopolitical challenge. Um, it also

5:45

doesn't even mention great power

5:47

competition at all with China and it

5:51

also downgrades the status of Taiwan.

5:55

Um, in the past under Biden, it used to

5:58

say that the US was opposed to a shift

6:01

in the status quo of Taiwan. But the new

6:05

uh national security strategy unveiled

6:07

in December last year in the US says

6:10

that it quote does not support a change

6:13

in the status quo of Taiwan. This is

6:15

seen as a clear downgrading of the

6:18

importance and sensitivity of the Taiwan

6:20

question. So my response is I think that

6:24

China is hopefully waiting to see the US

6:28

redefine its geopolitical focus to its

6:32

own backyard i.e. Latin America and in

6:35

this case Venezuela in particular and

6:37

thereby shift away from Taiwan and those

6:41

contentious areas the South China Sea

6:43

and China itself. And if that happens,

6:46

it will give China breathing space to

6:49

advance its biggest priority in terms of

6:52

geopolitics. But this is really hard to

6:56

call at the moment, Alice. I'm really

6:57

interested in your take on it. So, how

6:59

do you see it?

7:00

>> Well, very quickly on the geopolitical

7:02

front before I talk about some of the

7:04

economic consequences which are worth

7:06

delving into as well. uh is is it's

7:09

interesting that uh you know we talk a

7:11

lot about the the Trump's approach is

7:13

the Roosevelt crawler into the Monroe

7:15

Doctrine. Uh to borrow another Roosevelt

7:17

analogy uh I think China's approach to

7:20

this after seeing what happened in

7:23

Venezuela is going to be uh to speak

7:25

softly and carry a big stick. And what I

7:27

mean by that is on one hand it will

7:30

continue I think to pursue some kind of

7:32

trade day to to try to soften some of

7:36

the edges the rough edges in the

7:38

relationship. Uh I think that they were

7:40

heartened by the national security

7:42

strategy document that you referred to

7:44

James not being an attack a direct

7:46

attack on China as it had been in

7:48

previous administrations. But at the

7:49

same time you know massively uh

7:52

increasing its investments uh and

7:54

deployment of its military capabilities.

7:57

We saw that in in full display a couple

7:59

months ago at the September parade. So I

8:02

think we'll have a two sort of two-track

8:04

approach to this relationship and

8:05

towards China's geopolitical strategy.

8:07

But it it is worth mentioning, James,

8:09

that even although Venezuela is not

8:12

Taiwan in terms of China's core

8:13

interests, it is a important strategic

8:16

foothold uh for China in Latin America.

8:19

I mean, it was described as an

8:21

all-weather strategic partnership back

8:22

in 2023. That's sort of the second tier

8:25

in terms of what we think about uh in

8:27

terms of friendships that China has with

8:29

the rest of the world. So, this was a

8:31

critical relationship that has I think

8:33

been weakened with the Trump

8:35

administration's move. And we if we

8:37

think about the economic implications as

8:39

well, it's not so much about oil because

8:42

only about 5% of China's seaborn crude

8:45

imports come from Venezuela. It's more

8:47

about uh the debt that's outstanding. So

8:50

we have still by some estimates around

8:52

$10 billion if not more of debt

8:54

outstanding that Venezuela owes to

8:56

China. And a lot of that traditionally

8:58

from Chavez onwards to Maduro was in the

9:01

form of loan for oil deals. that I think

9:04

is going to be subject to debate whether

9:06

or not Chinese creditors are going to

9:07

get a haircut or they're going to have

9:10

to miss a lot of the debt that's owed

9:12

because fundamentally uh Venezuela I

9:14

think is going to have to listen to the

9:16

Americans uh at least in the short term

9:19

in terms of some of these debt

9:20

restructuring and and oil developments

9:22

in the region. So I think for from

9:24

China's vantage point this is a net loss

9:27

certainly but I agree with you James if

9:29

we broaden it out I don't think this

9:32

materially increases China's uh designs

9:35

to invade or blockade Taiwan I think if

9:38

if I'm in Beijing watching this I would

9:41

tread carefully because the Trump

9:43

administration has shown that it has the

9:45

military muscle to fight in areas that

9:47

it deems to be in its national core

9:49

interests which in in this

9:51

administration is about the western

9:52

hemisphere. So, if I'm Xi Jinping

9:55

sitting in Beijing, I'm going to sit

9:56

tight a little bit and see what the

9:59

Trump administration is going to do uh

10:01

in its second half of a lame duck

10:04

presidency because remember, we have the

10:06

midterms coming up. A lot can change

10:08

domestically that can also transform and

10:11

alter Trump's uh geopolitical strategy.

10:13

>> Absolutely. I think uh one of the one of

10:16

the first indicators that we're going to

10:17

get of the trajectory of China US

10:20

relations after uh this move in

10:23

Venezuela is whether or not uh Trump's

10:26

meeting with Cining which is supposed to

10:29

take place in April actually goes ahead.

10:32

Um if we start seeing that you know that

10:35

meeting is called off or or people are

10:37

talking about rescheduling a meeting

10:39

then I think it will be a sign that

10:41

things are going badly wrong uh in the

10:44

US China relationship perhaps partly

10:46

because of these tensions and losses

10:49

that China is going to suffer over

10:51

Venezuela. But if China gets a sense

10:53

that there is something to play for on

10:56

its crucial priority of Taiwan i.e. a

10:58

softening of the US position on Taiwan,

11:01

then I would expect China to be pushing

11:04

full steam ahead for that meeting to go

11:06

ahead.

11:06

>> Yeah, I agree. I think that will be the

11:08

next litmus test uh in April if the two

11:11

presidents meet and whether or not

11:12

Taiwan is on the table, so to speak. And

11:15

I'm sure that the Chinese will be

11:17

testing the Americans to see to what

11:19

extent uh the Trump administration is

11:21

willing to sacrifice uh blood and

11:23

treasure for a Taiwan campaign, which at

11:26

least to my mind when we when I think

11:28

about the Trump uh clan and the people

11:30

around Trump, I mean, including frankly

11:33

uh Rubio as Secretary of State, it

11:35

doesn't seem to be a top priority. I

11:38

think that the focus in this

11:39

administration is very much on Latin

11:41

America, on defending the Western

11:43

Hemisphere as opposed to uh being

11:45

embroiled in conflicts overseas. I

11:47

wanted to talk a little bit about some

11:49

of the economic implications for some of

11:51

the players in China because, you know,

11:52

we've heard on Monday that the NFRA, the

11:56

National Financial Regulatory

11:57

Administration, is telling the banks

11:59

that it needs to release its exposure to

12:01

Venezuela. It's still unclear when I was

12:03

digging into the data to the extent to

12:05

which the policy banks and banks uh in

12:07

China are exposed to Venezuelan debt.

12:10

When I look at the numbers since 2007,

12:13

uh you have over hundred billion in

12:16

loans that were lent to Venezuela uh to

12:20

help with infrastructure, to help with

12:21

oil. What's your take on this? Uh have

12:24

you been following this, James? Yeah, I

12:26

mean I I used to write a lot about China

12:29

Venezuela because Venezuela was the

12:31

poster child of the Belt and Road

12:34

initiative um launched by China around

12:37

2012 in Latin America. It was the number

12:40

one borrower um among Latin American

12:43

countries from China and China was

12:46

building all kinds of infrastructure in

12:48

Venezuela. There were factories,

12:50

railways, roads. It really was a

12:53

showcase of what China could do and

12:56

China wanted to show the whole region.

12:58

And I remember back in the days of

13:00

former President Hugo Chavez in

13:02

Venezuela talking about the alliances

13:05

between China and Venezuela as like a

13:08

great wall of friendship that obviously

13:12

we were supposed to read in would sort

13:14

of keep the Americans out. And so as you

13:17

rightly say Alice, Venezuela has been

13:20

really crucial for China. but less so

13:22

recently. And as you've already sketched

13:25

out, I think if we boil it down to uh

13:28

brass tax, I think China stands to lose

13:32

about 10 billion US uh in loans that are

13:36

not repaid if the deal doesn't go to its

13:39

advantage. And also there's a potential

13:42

that it could lose around 2 billion in

13:45

terms of investment that was intended by

13:49

Chinese companies in the Venezuelan oil

13:51

sector that may now not go ahead. Those

13:54

are big numbers but they're not

13:56

catastrophic. Um, China is lent more

13:58

than$2 trillion US dollars as part of

14:02

its uh, belt and road initiative um,

14:04

according to aid data a US consultancy

14:08

over the last 10 or more years. So 10

14:11

billion it's a large number but it's not

14:14

catastrophic in terms of the general

14:17

reach of China's uh, development lending

14:19

around the world.

14:20

>> Yeah, I'm going to agree with that. I

14:21

think that the bigger implication is the

14:23

geostrategic one for China and Latin

14:25

America. And when we broaden it out to

14:27

China's allies or partners, you know, I

14:29

I feel very much that the access of ill

14:31

will has been weakened. Iran has been

14:33

weakened substantially by Israel over

14:35

the last few years. This is yet another

14:37

I think ally and partner for China that

14:40

has been weakened uh under this

14:41

administration. So, we'll have to see uh

14:43

what happens uh in 2026 with with the

14:46

rest of the players. Okay, we'll be back

14:48

with more after a quick break and stay

14:50

with us.

14:53

[music]

14:56

Welcome back. Tesla has just lost its

14:58

crown. The company sales fell 16% at the

15:02

end of 2025, hit hard by the roll back

15:04

of US EV tax credits. And for the first

15:07

time, China's BYD has overtaken Tesla as

15:11

the world's top electric car maker. It's

15:13

a sharp turn for a company that once

15:15

aimed to dominate global auto sales and

15:18

is now betting its future on

15:19

self-driving tech and robots. James,

15:22

let's go right into it. I have a lot of

15:24

opinions, but I want to get your take on

15:26

why BYD has over finally overtaken uh

15:30

Elon Musk's Tesla. It's not been a good

15:32

year for Elon Musk 2025, I have to say.

15:35

>> Yeah, I mean uh this is one of the great

15:38

corporate rivalries of our time. I mean,

15:41

it's rather like the Coca-Cola versus

15:43

Pepsi, Apple versus Microsoft,

15:46

McDonald's versus Burger King, but this

15:49

time it has an extra twist because this

15:52

is an American high-tech champion versus

15:55

a Chinese high-tech champion. And the

15:59

bare facts are that Tesla has lost its

16:02

global sales crown to BYD, the Chinese

16:06

uh car maker after almost a decade as

16:09

the world's bestselling EV brand. This

16:12

is because both BYYD's numbers were up

16:16

very sharply in 2025. They got a 28%

16:19

increase in global sales and Tesla sales

16:22

were down 8.6%

16:24

uh for the year. Of course, Tesla's

16:27

sales are down partly because of tax

16:30

changes in the US which removed an

16:32

incentive for American consumers to buy

16:36

uh Tesla cars. But more generally, I

16:39

think, and this is where I think the

16:40

main story is, BYD is steamrolling into

16:45

markets all over the world. um here in

16:48

Europe and I've actually driven one of

16:51

the BYD cars as it came off the first

16:55

shipment to Australia. There was a

16:57

massive ship transporter and about 5,000

17:01

BYD cars came off the ship and I I drove

17:04

one in 2024 in Bremen and I have to say

17:09

it took me a while to understand how to

17:11

use it. There were so many kind of

17:13

gadgets and dials and the car was

17:15

talking to me in German which I speak

17:18

very poorly. But after I got going, I

17:20

have to say it was a very smooth ride.

17:23

So, it's a piece of high technology. But

17:25

I think the crucial point is that the

17:28

BYD car that I was driving, which was

17:30

the Dolphin Surf, cost about 22 uh

17:36

23,000.

17:38

That's almost half the cost of the Tesla

17:42

Model 3. And I have to say the cars are

17:45

are, you know, comparable in terms of

17:48

their technology and their look. And I

17:50

think that fact lies behind why BYYD has

17:54

managed to record a million sales of

17:58

vehicles outside China uh last year.

18:01

That's up an incredible 150% from 2024.

18:07

So, I think Tesla is being beaten by a

18:10

cheaper car that looks kind of almost as

18:13

good and is technologically either on a

18:16

par with Tesla or even slightly better.

18:18

What's your opinion, Alice?

18:20

>> Well, at the risk of being contrarian,

18:22

James, I'm going to take the other side

18:23

of it and say that BYD may have peaked

18:27

and some of these EV players may have

18:28

peaked at least domestically in China.

18:30

You know, just to give people a sense of

18:32

the numbers, BYD sold 2.26 26 million uh

18:36

electric vehicles this year. Uh Tesla

18:38

sold 1.63 million. So that's quite a big

18:41

delta uh between the two players. But a

18:44

lot of it, James, I mean to your point

18:47

uh still is a domestic driven story. I

18:49

think the majority of EVs sold by BYD

18:52

still consumed by Chinese consumers.

18:55

That trend that in the last few years

18:57

has shifted. We're seeing more that are

18:58

going out. Um but we can also discuss

19:01

whether or not that is going to be an

19:03

ongoing trajectory given some of the

19:04

trade uh barriers that countries like

19:06

the EU uh for instance are putting on

19:08

China. But when I look at the domestic

19:11

outlook, what's interesting to me is

19:13

that the government just in the last

19:15

week or so has announced that it's going

19:17

to get rid of some of the tax waiver for

19:20

the purchase tax on EVs. So originally

19:23

there should be a 10% purchase tax.

19:26

There was a full 100% exemption of that

19:28

for a couple of years. As of this year,

19:30

it's going to be a 50% exemption. So,

19:32

effectively a 5% purchase tax on all

19:34

EVs. That could have a material impact

19:37

on whether or not you as a Chinese

19:38

consumer are going to buy a new vehicle.

19:41

But on the flip side, they've announced

19:43

uh at the end of December that they're

19:44

going to put in $ 8.9 billion ultra-long

19:47

special treasury bond issuance program

19:50

to fund tradein of EVs uh and subsidies.

19:54

So it could be that we could see after

19:57

March at the NPC meeting that there is

20:00

some more support uh for for existing EV

20:03

consumers trading in their old vehicles

20:05

and buying new ones. But you know we're

20:07

also seeing an economy that's still

20:09

trapped in some kind of deflation.

20:11

Consumers are not spending as much as

20:12

they the government wants them to. So

20:15

I'm still a little bit skeptical about

20:16

the growth trajectory domestically uh in

20:20

terms of demand for EVs. Uh, and then

20:22

when we factor in some of the headwinds

20:25

globally to Chinese EV providers, I'm a

20:28

little bit worried. Yes, I mean BYD has

20:31

a superior product. I was just in a BYD

20:34

vehicle uh a couple days ago in Sydney,

20:36

Australia. I'm seeing more of them on

20:38

the streets for sure, but I I I worry a

20:41

little bit about how this will be

20:42

perceived by foreign governments uh as

20:44

an influx of of cheap Chinese EVs. So,

20:48

I'm a bit skeptical. I'm holding my

20:50

breath to see if we're going to see

20:52

major legislation from countries around

20:54

the world to try to limit the amount of

20:57

Chinese electric vehicles cuz remember

20:59

autos is a huge political issue not just

21:02

an economic issue for a lot of countries

21:04

around the world. So I think this will

21:06

be an interesting thing to track

21:07

obviously when we think about the

21:09

broader Chinese uh overcapacity issue

21:12

and China's export engine. But one last

21:15

thing that I wanted to add which I

21:16

thought was super interesting again tied

21:18

to Elon Musk is that he tweeted a couple

21:21

days ago that uh China's silver export

21:24

controls are not good that because

21:27

silver is uh needed in many industrial

21:29

processes and I think people forget that

21:31

given that silver is a precious metal

21:33

but it is used it is used in cars for

21:35

instance in electric vehicles in solar

21:37

panels uh in AI data centers uh and you

21:41

know we've seen the creation of these

21:43

export controls to restrict the global

21:46

supply uh more recently of rare earths.

21:48

Silver has been added to that list. I

21:50

think this is important and worth

21:51

tracking because this also could have a

21:54

material impact on Tesla for instance on

21:56

other automakers because silver is still

21:59

an important input in into some of these

22:01

processes. And when I think about some

22:04

of the levers that China will use in

22:05

2026 when it is unhappy with say the

22:08

Venezuela policy with Trump's tariff

22:10

policy, I think people should expect

22:13

more of these precious metals, critical

22:16

minerals, intermediary inputs being

22:19

added to some kind of export control

22:21

list and weaponized by China.

22:23

>> I think that's really interesting.

22:25

Alice, I just want to mention one thing.

22:27

You you you uh raised the issue of

22:29

protectionism.

22:31

countries here in Europe or elsewhere in

22:34

the world may see these Chinese EVs

22:37

steamrolling into their markets and

22:39

displacing sales of, you know, valued uh

22:43

um domestic brands. And so I definitely

22:46

think that protectionist pressures will

22:48

rise, but I don't know whether here in

22:51

Europe anyway, the Europeans will

22:53

actually get it together to have the

22:55

unity to push forward, you know, uh,

22:58

greater tariffs or other other forms of

23:01

protectionism against the influx of

23:04

these Chinese cars. And just one other

23:07

really fascinating aspect that lies in

23:10

the future that is that BYD is planning

23:13

on bringing its so-called flash charging

23:16

batteries to Europe sometime this year.

23:20

Now these flash chargers can charge uh a

23:25

car within 5 minutes. That means that

23:28

they will significantly reduce the

23:30

amount of time it takes to charge your

23:32

EV. Uh the one I drove um in Germany, I

23:37

almost missed my plane on the way back

23:39

to the UK because the charger that we

23:43

found was so slow that uh you know, we

23:46

were standing there literally biting our

23:48

nails looking at the clock wondering if

23:50

we had the charge to get us to the

23:52

airport. That will be a thing of the

23:53

past when you can just draw up alongside

23:56

a flash charger that will charge your

23:58

car within 5 minutes. Now Tesla does not

24:01

have that technology. It is bringing out

24:04

technology, but it will be slower than

24:06

the five minute charge. What I've been

24:09

able to read online says that the next

24:11

Tesla supercharger will charge a battery

24:14

to within a range of 200 miles within 15

24:19

minutes. So China is ahead yet again in

24:22

this crucial aspect of the whole EV

24:24

market.

24:25

>> Very interesting. All right, let's take

24:27

one last quick break and stay with us.

24:29

>> [music]

24:33

>> Welcome back. China is now exporting

24:36

more than electronics and EVs. It is

24:38

exporting luxury food. From caviar to

24:41

fuagra, truffles to macadamia nuts,

24:44

China has quietly become a global

24:46

heavyweight in high-end agriculture,

24:49

supplying its growing domestic appetite

24:51

and increasingly reshaping markets

24:53

overseas. Now backed by provincial

24:56

governments and years of investment,

24:58

China now dominates global caviar

25:00

production. A shift that's turning what

25:02

were once niche European delicacies into

25:05

another front in China's expanding trade

25:08

power. I mean this is a topic close to

25:11

my heart given that I I do love food.

25:13

James

25:14

>> and you're a tremendous cook as well

25:16

which is credentials that I definitely

25:17

don't have. So um I think your take's

25:20

going to be more in instructive but I

25:22

would just start by saying how wrong I

25:24

have been in my thinking on this topic.

25:28

Um I never imagined that China would

25:31

leap to the global for forefront of

25:34

luxury food. Um I I just thought that um

25:39

markets such as caviar, fuagua,

25:41

macadamia nuts, black truffles, matcha

25:43

tea would remain the domain largely of

25:47

premium foreign brands in China. They

25:50

have a kind of a cache. Let's say the

25:52

brand is French or Australian or

25:54

Japanese or or Russian or Iranian when

25:58

it comes to caviar. But nope. uh in this

26:01

area too it seems that China has risen

26:04

to the forefront and is now dominating

26:07

uh not only the market inside China but

26:10

globally too. I just never imagined that

26:13

that would happen. The Financial Times

26:14

has got a really good piece on this

26:16

phenomenon. Um, and it turns out that

26:18

the caviar example uh goes right back to

26:22

the late 1990s when some aquaculture

26:26

scientists decided that you could uh use

26:30

um sturgeon to breed. Um, and it would

26:33

take about 7 to 10 years for a sturgeon

26:36

to mature, produce eggs, and then you

26:39

would uh take those eggs to a breeding

26:41

center and then the young sturgeon would

26:44

would uh would grow. And that's how this

26:48

uh market has developed. So since that

26:51

time when China produced almost no

26:54

sturgeon to 2024,

26:56

China produced 43%

26:59

of the global total. I just find that

27:02

extraordinary. But uh tell me Alice h

27:04

how are you seeing this whole topic?

27:06

Well, firstly I have to preface this

27:08

with the fact that you know when I I

27:11

love European food and I think there's

27:14

something special about uh you know

27:17

Parmesan coming from the region of Italy

27:20

um Hmon Burka coming from Spain there's

27:23

something that is unique about those

27:25

flavors and the artisal nature of how

27:28

that developed and when I mentioned this

27:30

topic to a couple of Europeans uh

27:32

European friends of mine I think they

27:34

were uh very upset by this because they

27:37

their immediate reaction was well it's

27:38

never going to taste as good as what we

27:41

produce here in Europe. But I think that

27:43

that defeats the purpose and I think

27:45

that that is not seeing this for what it

27:47

is which is that China is trying to

27:51

create more agricultural products. It is

27:53

trying to develop more high technology

27:55

and agricultural development aspects I

27:57

think which will both appear in the

27:59

5-year plan in March. And this is all

28:01

part of she's broader strategy to have

28:04

on the one hand agricultural

28:05

self-sufficiency but also develop

28:07

agricultural critical technologies that

28:10

can be developed domestically but also

28:12

potentially exported around the rest of

28:15

the world. I'm thinking particularly of

28:16

global south countries like Africa where

28:18

it would be particularly germanine and

28:20

and of use. So when I think about this,

28:23

I think about it more in the context of

28:25

of China, you know, using its export

28:28

engine and manufacturing engine to the

28:31

food realm. And I think that there will

28:33

be a degree of nationalism whereby

28:35

Chinese people will think, well, I don't

28:37

need to get caviar from Eastern Europe

28:39

or Russia. I don't need to get truffles

28:41

from Italy. These truffles domestically

28:44

have a a good enough terois, you know,

28:47

to borrow a wine term and and we want to

28:49

support domestic producers. So, I can

28:51

see that as a trend domestically with

28:53

within China. I'm not so sure if this is

28:56

going to be an attractor proposition for

28:59

foreigners, but you know, if you're cost

29:02

conscious, uh, you know, and you're

29:04

looking to get something that is half

29:06

the price, say, of a European premium

29:08

good, maybe you go for the Chinese one.

29:11

But I think it'll be harder sell

29:13

globally. I do think this will do very

29:15

well domestically for all the reasons I

29:17

mentioned. And and and just to drive

29:19

home a personal story, so I was

29:21

traveling in Eunan last year and Eunan

29:24

some people may know has the most

29:26

biodiverse uh range of mushrooms in the

29:29

world. Uh most of the world's actually

29:31

porchini mushrooms come from China, come

29:35

from Euran specifically. Uh and China

29:37

accounts for a third of the world's

29:39

truffles and exports went up 60% since

29:42

last year. I actually went to an

29:45

Italian's factory in Junan and he was

29:48

producing porchini mushrooms, portoella

29:50

mushrooms, uh truffles which he was

29:53

selling in powdered form or dried form

29:55

to the European market. Uh and

29:58

apparently Europe does not have enough

30:01

uh uh porchini mushrooms to make all

30:03

those risotto sachets. So in some ways,

30:06

China is part of this global industry

30:09

because it has the ability to produce on

30:12

mass and at scale. Uh and so I think

30:14

that there will be areas like this dried

30:16

mushroom powder that I'm talking about

30:18

where China is already being globally

30:20

accepted. And I don't think people

30:21

actually even realize that. And one last

30:23

fun fact I have about this is that

30:25

apparently people in China don't like

30:27

the taste of truffles. So it's a very

30:29

easy cell to to cultivate that

30:31

domestically in your and then sell it to

30:33

the rest of the world because it's not

30:34

seen as delicacy uh in China which I

30:37

thought was quite interesting

30:38

comparative advantage at play. But super

30:40

interesting story and I'm glad FT

30:42

covered it because I think it shows uh

30:45

so many aspects of what's happening in

30:47

China in terms of taste changing in

30:49

terms of domestic alternatives to

30:51

foreign products uh and in terms of

30:53

China trying to compete at at a global

30:56

scale with some of these premium goods.

30:58

>> Yeah. And you mentioned Yunan there,

31:00

which I'm really glad because I I think

31:02

that sometimes maybe people outside

31:04

China when they think of China, they've

31:06

seen all the pictures of the factories

31:08

and the big cities and the smog and the

31:11

pollution. But a a province like Yunan,

31:14

which is right on the southwest uh uh

31:17

sort of bottom corner of China on the

31:19

map, bordering Myanmar, is honestly one

31:22

of the most beautiful places anywhere in

31:24

the world. And you mentioned terowa. I

31:26

would have thought that Yunan tera is

31:29

superior to to many parts of the world.

31:32

The biobiodiversity is absolutely off

31:34

the charts. And uh in the financial

31:37

times story that I'm quoting from,

31:39

there's a quote here from uh one of the

31:42

growers there who says there's a joke

31:44

that whatever expensive fruit exists in

31:47

the world, Yunan will import it,

31:50

research it, cultivate it, and bring

31:53

down the price. So, I think that that

31:56

sort of um sums up uh this trend, but uh

32:00

we really shouldn't underestimate some

32:02

of the natural underpinnings that China

32:05

has to grow this stuff and to grow

32:07

really high quality uh uh food.

32:09

>> Well, I guess we're going to have to try

32:11

Chinese caviar next time we're in town.

32:12

I think you're going to China very soon,

32:14

James. So, you're going to have to try

32:16

some for me.

32:17

>> I have to admit, I don't like caviar.

32:19

[laughter]

32:21

>> Do you like truffles, James? Listen,

32:23

Alice, I I come from North Yorkshire,

32:25

which is a very set to bottom place. I

32:27

don't think I've ever had a truffle in

32:29

my life. What about you?

32:30

>> I am very partial to truffles. I mean, I

32:32

was in Southwest France uh a couple

32:34

months ago, and they and they have a

32:36

particular white truffle that's quite

32:38

unique there. Um so, I I am partial to

32:40

them. But James, we're going to have to

32:42

change that uh for 2026. We're going to

32:44

have to get you eating caviar and

32:45

truffles. [laughter]

32:47

>> Okay.

32:48

>> Living the high life. All right, James,

32:49

it is prediction time and we're going to

32:51

make our first predictions for 2026. Uh

32:54

I'm going to do something a bit left

32:56

field because I think uh this is going

32:59

to come up in a couple weeks. You know,

33:02

when we see on Jan 20 the economic

33:05

readout in China, I think the economic

33:08

uh trajectory of China is still going to

33:10

be a topline issue uh for investors and

33:12

the and the rest of the world in 2026.

33:15

But I want to take it to a prediction

33:17

that I feel fairly strongly about, which

33:19

is on the currency side. I think we're

33:22

going to see an appreciation of the CNY,

33:24

a slight appreciation by at least 10%. I

33:26

think I feel comfortable about the

33:28

currency ending at 6.8 to 6.9 uh by the

33:32

end of the year. Uh primarily because I

33:35

think the Trump administration is going

33:37

to elect uh a fairly doubbish uh Fed

33:41

chair. It could well be Kevin Hasset.

33:43

And in that case, uh, when we factor in

33:45

the interest rate differentials between

33:47

the Fed and the PBOC and the fact that

33:50

China isn't going to intervene, I think

33:52

strongly to to defend the currency, I

33:55

think we could see uh the currency go up

33:57

and strengthen uh against the dollar to

34:00

around 6.8 to 6.9 uh by the end of the

34:02

year. And that is materially important

34:04

because it obviously impacts US China

34:07

trade talks, negotiations. Trump isn't a

34:09

fan of a weak CNY. He wants to see a

34:12

weak dollar and I think this could be an

34:14

era in which there is some degree of of

34:16

compromise between China and the US. But

34:19

James, what's your prediction for 2026?

34:21

>> I'm going to go back to what we were

34:23

talking about at the top, Alice. I think

34:25

that China will swallow its pride,

34:29

swallow its humiliation, suffer its

34:32

losses with regard to Venezuela, and I

34:35

think it will play the long game. And I

34:37

think the Trump C meeting in April will

34:40

go ahead and both sides will try to gain

34:44

whatever advantage they can in other

34:46

areas uh effectively putting aside what

34:50

China is currently condemning as uh as

34:53

this unlawful move by the United States

34:56

in Venezuela.

34:58

>> Okay, so watch the space. We're going to

35:00

wait for a Trump meeting in April.

35:01

That'll be exciting. All right, that's

35:03

all for this episode. Thank you so much

35:05

for listening to China Decode. Make sure

35:07

to follow us wherever you get your

35:09

podcast so you don't miss an episode.

35:12

And talk to you again next week.

35:23

[music]

Interactive Summary

This episode of "China Decode" covers three significant developments. Firstly, the US takeover in Venezuela sparked a "deeply shocked" reaction from China, prompting a discussion on whether Beijing will play a long game or adopt a harder stance, especially given Venezuela's strategic importance and China's substantial investments there. Secondly, China's BYD has surpassed Tesla as the world's leading electric vehicle manufacturer, attributed to its aggressive pricing and technological advancements, though it faces challenges from domestic tax changes and global protectionism. Lastly, China is emerging as a global leader in luxury food exports, from caviar to truffles, leveraging government support and agricultural innovation to dominate markets traditionally held by European producers.

Suggested questions

6 ready-made prompts