HomeVideos

Margin Call Scandal Explained Like You're 5

Now Playing

Margin Call Scandal Explained Like You're 5

Transcript

418 segments

0:00

September 2008, Peter drops [music] a

0:02

bomb.

0:03

Jesus, we're screwed.

0:05

$1.2 trillion in assets would be worth

0:08

zero in no time.

0:10

This is [music] the story of the

0:11

greatest financial collapse and how it

0:14

unravels within 24 hours.

0:19

An elevator opens on the 42nd floor of a

0:21

Midtown Manhattan skyscraper. Four HR

0:24

people [music] step out carrying file

0:26

boxes. Everyone on the trading floor

0:28

knows what that means. They split up,

0:31

each with a list, [music]

0:32

each hunting specific names.

0:35

Eric Dale.

0:36

Eric Dale was the head of risk

0:38

management. [music]

0:39

19 years at the firm. The guy whose

0:42

entire job was to measure how much

0:43

danger the company was in.

0:45

Minutes later, he's in a glass

0:47

conference room. Everyone on the floor

0:49

watching through the walls. The firm is

0:51

offering 6 months severance

0:53

>> [music]

0:53

>> at half salary. You have until tomorrow

0:56

to accept or the offer is revoked. What

0:59

about my current work?

1:00

I'm in the middle of something

1:01

important. The firm has a transition

1:03

plan. We appreciate your concern.

1:06

They [music] didn't. They didn't even

1:08

know what he was working on. They cut

1:10

his email, his phone, his building

1:11

access.

1:12

But as Eric packed his desk, [music] a

1:14

young analyst named Peter Sullivan was

1:16

waiting outside. Peter had a PhD in

1:19

propulsion engineering from MIT, an

1:21

actual rocket scientist. But the money

1:23

on Wall Street was better. So here he

1:26

was.

1:27

I just wanted [music] to say thank you.

1:29

You were the one person here who

1:30

actually

1:32

don't

1:33

here.

1:34

Eric reached into his box and pulled out

1:36

a USB [music] drive.

1:38

I was close to something.

1:40

They wouldn't let me finish.

1:42

Take a look.

1:43

Be careful.

1:45

The elevator doors closed. Peter stared

1:47

at the drive in his hand. He had no idea

1:50

he was holding a detonator.

1:51

To understand why this tiny USB drive

1:54

was about to bring down the global

1:55

economy, you need to

1:57

the lie that built it. It started with

1:59

[music] a simple, irresistible question.

2:02

Why rent when you can own?

2:04

And America said, "Yeah, why the hell

2:07

not?"

2:09

Banks were handing out mortgages like

2:10

Halloween candy. A strawberry picker

2:13

earning $15,000 a year

2:14

>> [music]

2:14

>> got approved for a $720,000

2:17

home loan.

2:18

A stripper in Las Vegas bought five

2:20

investment properties. They called these

2:22

ninja loans. No income, no job, [music]

2:26

no assets, no worries. You still got

2:29

your loans approved. The banks giving

2:31

out these garbage loans didn't care

2:32

whether people paid them back because

2:34

they weren't keeping the loans. They

2:36

were selling them to other buyers.

2:39

Wall Street had invented a magic trick.

2:41

They took thousands of these toxic

2:43

mortgages, bundled them together into a

2:45

single financial [music] product, and

2:47

called it a mortgage-backed security.

2:50

Think of it like a sausage. Each

2:52

individual ingredient might be

2:54

questionable, but once you grind it all

2:56

together, slap a nice label on it, and

2:59

this bundle of subprime mortgages,

3:01

AAA, safe as US Treasury bonds. But half

3:06

these borrowers don't have jobs. Half of

3:08

them do.

3:09

Glass half full, my friend. AAA. Next,

3:13

pension funds bought them. Retirement

3:15

accounts bought them. Banks in Iceland,

3:17

Ireland, and [music] Germany bought

3:18

them.

3:19

Everybody was feasting on these

3:20

sausages,

3:21

but nobody wanted to look at what was

3:23

actually inside.

3:26

10:17 p.m.

3:29

The floor was empty. Just Peter.

3:31

Just the hum of servers and the glow of

3:33

monitors. [music]

3:34

He'd been working on the file that Eric

3:36

handed over, a risk analysis on the

3:38

firm's mortgage-backed securities, the

3:41

sausages. [music]

3:42

He was testing what would happen if the

3:44

market got volatile.

3:45

Peter ran the model again.

3:47

Same result. [music]

3:48

His hands went cold.

3:51

"Hey, can you guys come look at this?

3:53

Inside his computer, they discover this

3:56

massive 60% [music] discount to the

3:58

intrinsic value on Incogni. Just

4:01

kidding.

4:02

Let's be real for a second.

4:05

Have you ever Googled yourself and felt

4:07

exposed?

4:09

Your home address, phone number, and

4:11

even your SSN are sold behind your back

4:14

by data brokers.

4:15

It's a goldmine for scammers crafting

4:17

fishing attacks or identity theft in

4:19

your name. And once it happens,

4:21

>> [music]

4:21

>> it would take months, even years, to fix

4:24

the financial and reputational damage. I

4:26

signed up for Incogni in minutes, and

4:28

they immediately [music] started

4:29

contacting data brokers to get my

4:31

information removed. They handle all the

4:33

legal back and forth for you.

4:35

But the real deal is the custom [music]

4:37

removal feature on their unlimited and

4:39

family unlimited plans.

4:41

If you find your info [music] on a

4:42

specific sketchy site, you just point

4:45

Incogni's agents to that URL, and they

4:48

manually [music] remove it for you.

4:50

Go to incogni.com/crayoncapital

4:53

and use code crayoncapital for 60% off.

4:55

They can't harm you if they can't find

4:57

you.

4:58

That's incogni.com/crayoncapital.

4:59

[music]

5:01

Code crayoncapital for 60% off.

5:04

Link in the description.

5:07

Now, back to the real finding. [music]

5:08

His colleagues gathered. They use a

5:10

model called VAR, value at risk. That's

5:14

how a bank measures danger.

5:16

Think of it as a weather forecast for

5:18

money. It looks at decades of market

5:20

history and says, "99 days out of 100,

5:23

[music] the worst you'll lose is $50

5:25

million.

5:26

So, relax. You're covered."

5:29

But here's the fatal flaw.

5:31

That model only tells you about the 99

5:33

normal days. It says nothing about the

5:36

1% outlier that destroys you.

5:39

Peter realized the hurricane was already

5:41

here. The losses, sitting on the firm's

5:43

books, had already blown past anything

5:45

the model thought was possible. [music]

5:47

11:44 p.m. Sam Rogers, the head of

5:51

trading,

5:51

>> [music]

5:51

>> arrived. He looked at the model for 3

5:54

full minutes.

5:55

You're certain?

5:57

If you're wrong, you never work [music]

5:58

again.

5:59

If you're right, none of us do.

6:02

Within minutes, the 42nd floor

6:04

transforms. The vacuum of the night is

6:06

sucked out as the C-suite executives

6:08

descend. Sarah Robertson,

6:10

>> [music]

6:10

>> the chief risk officer, and Sam's boss,

6:13

Jared Cohen, the head of capital

6:14

markets.

6:16

Sarah, how did we miss [music] this?

6:18

Our math was based on independence. We

6:21

assumed if one guy in Ohio defaulted, it

6:23

wouldn't [music] affect a guy in

6:24

Florida. But the bubble tied them

6:26

together. It's a perfect correlation.

6:29

When one tile falls, the whole floor

6:31

goes.

6:32

Suddenly, a corporate helicopter sliced

6:34

through the Manhattan skyline, landed on

6:36

the roof. John Tuld, CEO, late 50s.

6:41

Hadn't been in this building in 2

6:43

[music] years. Someone tell me the

6:45

problem.

6:46

He looked down the table.

6:48

Actually, I'd like to hear from the

6:50

young man who found this.

6:51

>> [music]

6:52

>> Mr. Sullivan?

6:53

How old are you?

6:55

27, sir.

6:56

Please, call [music] me John.

6:58

Now, speak to me as you might to a

7:00

golden retriever or a small child. It

7:02

wasn't brains that brought me to this

7:04

seat, I can assure you.

7:05

>> [music]

7:06

>> Sir,

7:07

for the last few years, we've been

7:09

making a lot of money packaging

7:10

mortgages into tradable securities.

7:13

But because [music] these take a month

7:14

to package, we have to hold them on our

7:16

books for a long time. And why is that a

7:18

problem? Because they're just mortgages.

7:20

[music]

7:21

We felt safe borrowing massive amounts

7:23

of money to buy them. We've pushed our

7:25

leverage to the limit.

7:26

>> [music]

7:27

>> We are currently holding 1.2 trillion

7:29

dollars in these assets.

7:31

And I'm guessing the math your bosses

7:32

did in the past to doesn't quite work

7:34

anymore.

7:35

>> [music]

7:36

>> It's worse, sir. The math hasn't worked

7:38

for 2 weeks.

7:39

The historical volatility we used to

7:42

predict the future has already been

7:44

shattered by what happened over the last

7:45

10 days.

7:47

>> [music]

7:47

>> What does your model say that means for

7:49

us?

7:50

If the value of these assets [music]

7:51

drops by just 25% while they are still

7:54

on our books, that loss would be greater

7:57

than the value of this entire [music]

7:58

company.

8:00

So, what you're telling me, Mr.

8:02

Sullivan, is that the music is about to

8:04

stop and we are left holding the biggest

8:07

bag of stinking [ __ ] in the history of

8:09

capitalism.

8:12

Sell it all.

8:13

Today.

8:15

You're talking about $1 trillion of

8:17

paper, John. [music]

8:18

Who the hell are we selling this to?

8:20

The same people we've been selling to

8:22

for the last 2 years.

8:24

And whoever else will buy it.

8:26

If we do this, we will kill the market

8:28

for years.

8:30

Maybe forever.

8:32

I understand.

8:33

And you're selling something you know

8:35

has no value.

8:36

>> [music]

8:36

>> To people who trust us?

8:38

We are selling

8:40

to willing buyers at the current market

8:42

price so that we may survive.

8:45

You'll never sell anything to any of

8:46

these people again.

8:48

I understand.

8:50

Do you?

8:51

Do you?

8:53

This is it.

8:55

Sam.

8:57

Then Tuld turned to Sarah Robertson, the

8:59

chief risk officer.

9:01

He pulled her aside.

9:02

Private room, just the two of them.

9:06

You filtered warnings about this over a

9:07

year ago.

9:08

John, I was told in no uncertain terms

9:11

it doesn't matter. The board needs

9:13

someone to point to.

9:14

The SEC, the media, they'll want a name,

9:18

a face.

9:19

Someone had to take the fall and the

9:21

people who gave the orders never do.

9:24

The firm didn't care about Sarah's

9:25

feelings. They had a few hours until the

9:27

market opened and unloaded $1 trillion

9:30

in worthless paper onto an unsuspecting

9:32

world.

9:35

7:30 a.m.

9:38

33 traders file onto the floor. It's

9:40

dead silent. These are the golden boys

9:43

of Wall Street, usually loud and

9:45

arrogant. Today, they look like they're

9:47

walking toward an electric chair.

9:49

Sam Rogers stands [music] at the front.

9:51

He's been their mentor for decades. He's

9:54

the guy who taught them that in this

9:55

business, your word is your bond.

9:58

Today, we are liquidating our entire

10:00

mortgage portfolio.

10:02

Every single cent

10:04

you have until the closing bell to move

10:06

it all. If you hit your targets, you'll

10:08

each receive a $1.4 [music] million

10:10

bonus.

10:12

And the great betrayal begins.

10:14

The traders sit down and pick up their

10:15

phones. They're calling their best

10:17

friends,

10:18

>> [music]

10:18

>> their college roommates, the people who

10:20

trust them most. Hey Marcus. Yeah, it's

10:23

Will.

10:24

Listen, I've got some risk over here I

10:26

need to move. My [music] loss is your

10:28

gain today, buddy. I'll give you a

10:30

discount, 96 cents on the dollar.

10:33

Marcus, on the other end, [music] thinks

10:35

he's getting a deal. He trusts Will. He

10:38

buys $100 million of worthless sausage.

10:41

By 10:00 a.m., the secret starts to

10:43

leak.

10:44

The street realizes this isn't a normal

10:46

trade. It's a liquidation.

10:49

The buyers start to panic. The phone

10:51

calls get uglier.

10:53

Will, I'm looking at these numbers. This

10:55

stuff is toxic.

10:57

Why the hell are you selling this to me?

10:59

I'm just following orders, Leo. Do you

11:01

want the remaining 30-year mixed or not?

11:04

I'm at 85 cents now.

11:06

The price doesn't stop at 85. It craters

11:09

to 73,

11:10

>> [music]

11:10

>> then 64.

11:11

By 3:54 p.m., they just finished their

11:14

last call.

11:16

They've sold nearly all of it and saved

11:18

the firm.

11:19

>> [music]

11:20

>> Now,

11:21

Margin Call is a movie. The characters

11:23

are fictional. The firm doesn't have a

11:25

real name.

11:26

But the crisis it's based on,

11:29

every bit of that was real.

11:31

This exact scenario played out across

11:33

every major bank on Wall Street in

11:35

September [music] 2008.

11:37

In the 2 years that follow, the weather

11:39

forecast hits the real world.

11:42

Suddenly, mortgage rates double.

11:44

Pensions,

11:45

>> [music]

11:45

>> packed with those AAA sausages, lose 40%

11:48

of their value.

11:50

In total, 6 million families lost their

11:52

homes as $11 trillion in wealth simply

11:55

evaporated. Neighborhoods turned into

11:57

[music] ghost towns where welcome mats

11:59

were replaced by foreclosure signs.

12:02

The government tried to step in. They

12:03

signed a $700 billion check to rescue

12:06

the banks.

12:08

Yep, you heard it right. They bail out

12:10

the institutions [music] that built the

12:11

bomb, and back at the firm, the lights

12:14

were off.

12:15

The trading floor was a graveyard.

12:17

Everyone was laid off.

12:20

Except Sam Rogers.

12:22

He found John Tuld in the executive

12:23

dining room, calmly eating a steak while

12:26

the world outside burned.

12:28

>> [music]

12:28

>> I want out, John.

12:30

I'm done.

12:31

Sit down, Sam. You'll get your bonus,

12:34

but I need you for another 24 months.

12:37

If I'd spent 40 years digging ditches,

12:39

>> [music]

12:39

>> at least there'd be some holes in the

12:40

ground to show for it.

12:42

Stop feeling sorry for yourself.

12:44

It's just money, Sam. [music]

12:46

It's made up. Pieces of paper with

12:48

pictures on them so we don't kill each

12:50

other for food.

12:52

1637

12:53

>> [music]

12:54

>> 1857

12:55

1929

12:57

2000 [music]

12:58

It's the same thing over and over.

13:01

We can't stop it.

13:03

We just react. [music]

13:04

And the percentages of winners and

13:06

losers,

13:07

they stay exactly the same. Happy [ __ ]

13:10

and sad sacks, fat cats and starving

13:12

[music] dogs.

13:13

Anyone else would have done exactly what

13:15

we did today.

13:17

You really believe [music] that? That

13:18

it's all just a cycle?

13:20

No right, no wrong, just reaction.

13:24

Mhm.

13:28

I'll stay. not because of your speech,

13:31

because I need the money.

Interactive Summary

The video recounts the intense, 24-hour period during the 2008 financial crisis within a major Wall Street firm. It details how an analyst discovers that the company's mortgage-backed securities, which were deemed safe and AAA-rated, are actually toxic assets that threaten the firm's survival. Faced with imminent collapse, the leadership team orchestrates a desperate plan to liquidate these assets, knowingly selling them to unsuspecting buyers to save themselves. The narrative highlights the moral bankruptcy of the situation, the subsequent global economic devastation, and the cynical justification that such crises are merely inevitable cycles of human nature.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts