HomeVideos

The Biology Of Why Men Isolate

Now Playing

The Biology Of Why Men Isolate

Transcript

419 segments

0:00

So, I don't know if you guys have seen

0:01

these memes where, you know, there's uh

0:03

some kind of comic where a woman is

0:05

getting complimented slashharassed on

0:07

her appearance and then someone does a

0:09

gender swap and then dudes are like,

0:10

"Yeah, this would be great. I'd be

0:12

totally fine with this." So, today we're

0:14

going to talk a little bit about

0:15

compliments. We're going to dig into the

0:16

science of what kind of attention men

0:19

receive, what kind of attention women

0:22

receive. And the really interesting

0:23

thing about this is as we look at

0:25

compliments, we will uncover some very

0:29

crucial mechanisms that are driving the

0:31

loneliness epidemic and may explain why

0:34

the loneliness epidemic is statistically

0:37

what appears to be worse for men than

0:39

women. And it turns out that there are

0:42

some aspects of biology, specifically

0:44

the effect of estrogen and testosterone

0:47

on oxytocin. So oxytocin is a bonding

0:51

hormone facilitates the connection

0:53

between human beings. And it turns out

0:56

that estrogen facilitates oxytocin's

1:00

action. So facilitates the formation of

1:02

bonds, whereas testosterone inhibits it,

1:05

especially under periods of stress. And

1:07

so this is kind of a weird video because

1:09

we're going to start with compliments

1:10

and we're going to sort of move on to

1:11

loneliness. So let's get started with

1:13

compliments. First thing to understand,

1:15

women receive about 75% of all

1:18

compliments. men receive about 25%. The

1:20

earliest research on this started in the

1:22

80s and then studies through about 2008,

1:25

which is the last study that I looked

1:26

at. It basically maintained this ratio.

1:28

So, first reason why compliments are

1:30

core memories for dudes, they don't

1:32

receive them much. So, here's what's

1:34

really interesting. It's not just the

1:35

quantity of compliments, it is also the

1:38

type of compliment. So, 75% of

1:40

compliments that women receive are on

1:43

their appearance. Um, interestingly

1:45

enough, the majority of compliments that

1:47

women receive on their appearance are

1:48

from other women. And the majority of

1:51

compliments that men receive are on

1:53

their performance. But complimenting

1:55

people in today's world is a little bit

1:57

tricky because if I compliment a woman

1:59

on her appearance, will this be

2:02

perceived as unwanted attention or

2:04

sexual harassment? Because I certainly

2:05

don't want to do that. But on the flip

2:07

side, how do I express appreciation for

2:10

someone even if I'm not interested in in

2:12

them in a romantic way? Or how do I

2:14

express appreciation for them if they if

2:16

I am interested in them in a romantic

2:19

way? And then we get to dudes

2:20

complimenting other dudes. So this is a

2:22

great example of this from a research

2:23

paper where one guy's like, "Hey, I like

2:25

your shirt." And the other dude's like,

2:26

"Nice. I like your face." So we're going

2:29

to talk a little bit about how to

2:31

compliment people and also how to

2:33

receive compliments. So let's get into

2:35

the type of compliments and figure out

2:37

which ones are appropriate and not

2:38

appropriate. First thing is we can

2:40

compliment someone's appearance. So 75%

2:42

of the compliments that women receive

2:44

are on their appearance. The majority of

2:47

appearance-based compliments received by

2:50

women are given by women. Right? So

2:52

women compliment their appear other

2:54

women's appearance all the time. Second

2:56

thing is the majority of compliments

2:57

that men receive are based on their

3:00

performance. Okay? So about 70% of

3:03

compliments that uh men receive are on

3:05

their performance. Once you enter a work

3:08

setting, 68% of compliments that women

3:11

receive are on their performance. Right?

3:13

So it used to be about 75% were on their

3:15

appearance. In the work setting, they

3:17

get complimented on their performance a

3:19

lot more. That's a good shift. 98% of

3:23

compliments that men receive in the

3:25

workplace are based on their

3:26

performance. So rule number one, if you

3:30

are working with someone, you want to

3:32

complement their per performance, not

3:34

their appearance, unless it's a female

3:35

to female relationship where arguably

3:37

you can still get away with that, but

3:39

generally speaking, don't compliment

3:41

people's appearance in the workplace.

3:43

Second thing, if you are going to

3:45

compliment someone's appearance, a good

3:48

way to do it is to take an article of

3:51

their clothing or their hairstyle, one

3:53

attribute of their appearance, and tie

3:55

it to them specifically. For example,

3:58

Dr. K, you're rocking that hoodie. So,

4:02

we're not saying they're pretty. We're

4:03

not objectifying a part of them. We are

4:05

actually usually referring to an object

4:08

that they have and tying it to them,

4:11

making it special about them. The way

4:13

that you are pulling off that outfit is

4:16

awesome. You're really knocking that

4:18

outfit out of the park. You're really

4:20

rocking that hairstyle. You're really

4:22

like that that beer gut is absolutely

4:25

enviable, bro. Okay, so if we want to

4:28

compliment appearance, don't just call

4:29

someone hot unless you're trying to

4:31

indicate romantic interest. You can

4:33

still appreciate someone's appearance

4:35

without making it threatening or sexual.

4:38

Third thing is men especially like this.

4:40

You can comment on someone's

4:41

possessions. Super safe way to give a

4:44

compliment. That's an awesome truck. I

4:46

love that grill. That's an epic mouse

4:48

pad. I really like that pen. You can

4:50

compliment someone's stuff and it tends

4:52

to be pretty safe. Next thing that we

4:53

got to talk about cuz we got to do

4:55

social rehab for the internet is how to

4:57

receive compliments. Generally speaking,

4:59

the best thing to do is to appreciate

5:02

someone giving you a compliment. This is

5:04

kind of like parrying a compliment where

5:05

it's like someone sends a compliment

5:07

your way and then you knock it back by

5:09

sending one of your own. And I love this

5:11

in in video games because there's this

5:12

parry mechanic, right, which is one

5:14

attack is countered by another attack.

5:17

But we don't want to parry compliments.

5:19

What we want to do is appreciate them.

5:21

So a lot of times what happens is we

5:22

feel really embarrassed when someone

5:24

notices something nice about us. And

5:27

then what we do is we have to reverse

5:28

uno them. I really like your hair. Oh,

5:30

well, I really like your hair. I feel

5:32

really uncomfortable receiving that

5:34

compliment. So, I sort of reject it and

5:36

turn the tables on to you. Instead, what

5:38

you can do is appreciate their

5:40

compliment. This is the right way to

5:42

receive their positive energy and give

5:44

positive energy back. Oh, I really love

5:47

the way that you, you know, you're

5:48

rocking that sweater. And then you can

5:50

appreciate that by saying, "Yeah, I

5:52

actually like looked at three or four of

5:53

them. I wasn't sure which one to get.

5:55

Thank you so much for noticing. Right?

5:57

You can say something like that. You can

5:59

appreciate. Thank you for noticing. I

6:01

appreciate you noticing. Thank you.

6:03

Thanks. Thanks a lot. Thanks, bro. Okay?

6:05

So, you can just appreciate it. That's

6:07

really good. Next thing is that if you

6:09

do feel embarrassed, that's actually

6:11

totally fine. So, here's the cool thing.

6:13

If someone compliments you and you feel

6:15

embarrassed, that is their way of

6:19

knowing that the compliment worked,

6:21

right? You're not confused. You're not

6:24

upset. They tickled you. They tickled

6:27

your emotions in a really nice way. So,

6:29

you feel better about that. Now, this

6:31

becomes really important because, you

6:33

know, there are tweets like this one

6:34

where people will say, "Yeah, 50% of the

6:36

loneliness epidemic is because dudes are

6:38

completely uninvested in social

6:41

interaction." And many of us as men are

6:43

not taught how to compliment people. But

6:46

the broader question still remains that

6:49

why is it that men receive so few

6:50

compliments? Why is it that when we

6:53

receive a compliment, it feels like a

6:55

core memory? And why is it that it is so

6:58

hard for people to connect? But it turns

7:01

out that biology has a huge part to play

7:04

here. Relationships have never been

7:06

easy. Anytime you interact with someone,

7:08

you're dealing with their unique soup of

7:11

emotions, expectations, and even

7:13

traumatic baggage. And the fact that

7:15

we're all texting now and dating apps

7:17

are a thing is not making things easier.

7:20

That's why we developed a coaching

7:21

program to help our community with

7:23

modern relationship problems. Working

7:25

with a coach can help you build skills

7:27

like setting boundaries, communicating

7:30

effectively, and navigating conflict.

7:32

So, if y'all are struggling with your

7:33

relationships, check out the link in the

7:35

description below.

7:37

So, from a big picture standpoint, I

7:39

want you all to think about this. When

7:40

we see a systemic effect, right? So if

7:44

all men, not all men, but if a lot of

7:47

men, if a majority of men or a

7:49

significant minority of men struggle in

7:52

forming relationships, chances are there

7:55

is a systemic reason. It is not

7:57

individual responsibility. There is

7:59

something going on with the way that men

8:01

are conditioned, our biology that

8:03

results in this thing. And unless we

8:05

understand those systemic factors, we

8:08

can't place the responsibility on an

8:11

individual dude to solve a systemsbased

8:14

problem. What I think a lot of people

8:16

don't realize is how hard it is for men

8:19

to form bonds. How we're biologically

8:23

impaired literally at forming bonds,

8:26

especially we're when we're under

8:28

stress. So this is a really fascinating

8:30

study. In their analysis of gender

8:32

differences in coping, Lucknow at Al

8:34

found that the largest difference arose

8:36

on seeking and using social support and

8:39

combined significance of their effect

8:41

was significant beyond the p value of

8:43

this is an astronomical p value. Y'all,

8:45

of the 26 studies that tested gender

8:47

differences, one study showed no

8:49

difference and 25 favored women. This is

8:52

really important to understand. When

8:54

women are under periods of stress, they

8:56

cope with that stress by forming bonds.

8:59

But the question is why right? So what

9:01

is different about women as compared to

9:04

men? And this is what's really

9:05

fascinating. So estrogen actually

9:08

induces oxytocin transcription. So what

9:12

does this mean? This means that when we

9:13

have estrogen floating around, it

9:15

actually causes us to create oxytocin

9:18

and has a synergistic effect with

9:21

oxytocin. And oxytocin is our bonding

9:24

hormone. So what we see is that the

9:26

female sex hormone is directly

9:28

responsible for the formation of bonds

9:31

and for the drive to form bonds. Whereas

9:35

if we look at testosterone, the higher

9:37

our testosterone levels are, this has an

9:40

inhibiting effect on oxytocin. When men

9:43

are under periods of stress, we actually

9:45

don't respond by forming bonds with

9:48

other people. We actually see a

9:50

hyperarousal. So we tend to be problem

9:53

solvers. We tend to focus on solutions.

9:56

We also bear that burden by ourselves.

9:59

It's not just the effect of estrogen and

10:01

testosterone and oxytocin. The brains of

10:03

men and women when we're faced with

10:05

stress also behave differently. So the

10:08

hypothesis that stress responses in men

10:10

may be primarily characterized as fight

10:12

or flight is supported by the

10:14

observation that RPFC right prefrontal

10:16

cortex activation and left orbital

10:18

frontal cortex activation with stress is

10:21

predominantly observed in the male

10:23

brain. What this research basically

10:25

shows us is that when we are under

10:27

periods of stress men and women respond

10:29

differently based on the hormones in our

10:32

body. Okay. So when women are under high

10:34

levels of stress, they tend to tend and

10:37

befriend. Estrogen mediates an increase

10:39

in oxytocin production and also acts

10:42

synergistically with oxytocin, allowing

10:45

us to form bonds with other people.

10:47

Hence that paper that we looked at

10:48

earlier where 25 out of the 26 studies

10:51

that we looked at, women tend to cope by

10:53

forming social bonds. Now the problem is

10:55

that testosterone has the absolute

10:57

opposite effect. When men are under

10:59

periods of stress, they engage in a

11:02

fight orflight response where

11:03

testosterone increases, cortisol

11:06

increases, and this actually blunts the

11:08

effect of oxytocin, which results in men

11:11

isolating. And this is a biological

11:14

effect. Now, this is where I think a lot

11:16

of people will jump to saying like,

11:17

okay, like men just need to change,

11:19

right? This is where like the subjective

11:21

experience of men doesn't matter. men

11:23

need to compliment each other more,

11:24

which I totally agree with, by the way,

11:26

which is why we taught y'all how to

11:27

compliment. Okay? But I I I want to

11:29

point this out because I think in if you

11:31

guys want to fix your gender dynamics,

11:34

both with your own gender and the

11:36

opposite gender, with the gender that

11:37

you're attracted to, I don't care. If

11:39

you want to improve your relationships

11:41

with the people around you, you must

11:43

understand their experience of the

11:46

world. The biggest mistake that I see

11:48

right now is we are judging other

11:50

people. Men are judging women. Women are

11:53

judging men based on our experience. So

11:56

when we see a woman receiving lots of

11:59

compliments, we think to ourselves, I am

12:01

starved for compliments. This is

12:03

amazing. I don't understand why this

12:05

person is complaining. And when men say

12:07

this kind of stuff like, I would love

12:08

this. I don't think they understand the

12:11

experience of a woman in today's world.

12:13

Okay, so let's look at some scary

12:15

statistics. The first two items, cat

12:17

calls, whistles, and stairs, and

12:19

unwanted sexual attention were reported

12:21

to be experienced once a month by 32 and

12:24

40% of the sample. Strikingly, 31%

12:27

reported experiencing cat calls,

12:28

whistles, or stares from strangers every

12:31

few days or more. Over one-third of

12:33

participants reported hearing offensive

12:36

sexual jokes, or sexist remarks from

12:38

strangers once a month. In addition, 36

12:41

reported being the victim of unwanted

12:42

touching or stroking once a month. So, I

12:46

think this is where like what a lot of

12:47

dudes I think miss about women's

12:49

experiences are the frequency. So, if

12:52

you think that the amount of uh

12:54

attention that women receive is okay,

12:56

we'll get to why you think like other

12:58

reasons because you're so starved, but

12:59

if you think it's okay, I think the

13:01

thing that people are usually missing

13:02

here is the frequency. So, I want you,

13:05

if you're a dude, I want you to imagine

13:07

someone that you're not attracted to.

13:09

And what would the effect on your

13:11

psychology be if from every few days to

13:14

once a month this person stroked you,

13:16

made sexual advances, stared at you,

13:19

touched you in ways that you don't want,

13:21

and you're like, "Okay, I can handle it

13:23

once." But imagine if this happened

13:25

every few days to one month. What effect

13:27

would that have on your psychology? On

13:29

the flip side, if you're a woman who

13:31

thinks that men can just form bonds, I

13:34

want y'all to really appreciate how

13:36

difficult this is for us biologically.

13:38

It is easy for you to form bonds. It is

13:41

natural for you to form bonds because

13:43

based on the estrogen levels in your

13:45

body and the oxytocin levels in your

13:47

body, what feels natural to you, what

13:50

feels intuitive to you is to bond with

13:53

somebody else. Whereas we are actually

13:55

wired in the opposite way. What feels

13:58

natural to us is to isolate. And this is

14:01

where like I'm going to avoid a pitfall

14:03

because this is the point where a lot of

14:05

people may be drawing what I would call

14:06

a false equivalency because here I am

14:09

talking about female sexual harassment

14:11

and here I am talking about male

14:12

loneliness and I'm not saying that these

14:14

two are equivalent in any way, shape or

14:16

form. My point is that we take for

14:19

granted based on our own biology. Right?

14:23

So like my favorite example of this is

14:25

parents who have never experienced

14:27

depression who tell their children to

14:29

just get out of bed. But if y'all have

14:32

never experienced depression, you have

14:34

been moving through air your whole life,

14:36

which I know sounds weird. So when I get

14:38

up and I walk around, I literally move

14:40

through air. There is no resistance for

14:43

me to get up and walk to the door. When

14:46

I have patients who have depression,

14:48

walking to the door feels like moving

14:51

through mud. feels like walking through

14:54

molasses.

14:55

There is a fundamental subjective

14:58

experience that makes it so hard to just

15:01

get out of bed and walk to the door. It

15:04

literally feels like a profound amount

15:06

of resistance. And unless you understand

15:08

that this is the experience of men when

15:11

it comes to loneliness, their natural

15:13

inclination, their biology is telling

15:15

them to isolate. Their biology is

15:18

telling them to handle things on their

15:20

own. Their biology is literally telling

15:22

them to fight or to run away. Don't tend

15:25

and befriend. And until we understand

15:27

that, we will never understand why

15:30

compliments are core memories for dudes.

Interactive Summary

This video discusses the science behind compliments, gender differences in receiving and giving them, and how this connects to the loneliness epidemic, particularly among men. It highlights that women receive more compliments, primarily on appearance, while men receive fewer, mostly on performance. Biologically, estrogen facilitates oxytocin's bonding action, while testosterone inhibits it, especially under stress, leading women to tend and befriend, and men to isolate or engage in fight or flight responses. The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding these biological and experiential differences to improve social dynamics and relationships, noting that men often lack social investment while women frequently experience unwanted attention, making both experiences valid but different.

Suggested questions

8 ready-made prompts