MacBook Neo Long Term Review - Why Would Anyone Buy This?
278 segments
So, this MacBook absolutely blew up the
laptop market when it came out a few
months ago, but it did have some
compromises and get some complaints. Uh
one of them, strangely enough, that it
was too cheap. Now, I've been using my
MacBook Neo every day for the last few
months, and here is what the everyday
experience is actually like. So, first
up, something that is really important
to me for my tech devices, especially
ones that cost a fair bit of money, is
the build quality. Particularly laptops,
because I am constantly, you know,
interacting with it every single day,
unlike something like a, you know,
monitor, for example, that just sits on
my desk and I never really touch it.
With a laptop, like I'm just constantly
moving it around, you know, opening and
closing the screen, using the built-in
keyboard and trackpad. And at this, you
know, $500 to $600 US dollar price
range, that is usually where a pretty
massive compromise is made in the form
of, you know, a plastic chassis that
squeaks and bends and just feels really
cheap. But not the Neo. And
interestingly enough, when I compared it
to the most expensive MacBook lineup
currently available, which is the M5 Pro
and Max MacBook Pros, build quality
feels identical, which is crazy to me,
because, you know, this is 500 bucks,
and this is like four times more
expensive. But what is often not
mentioned is what effect such good build
quality means for the future. You know,
when I get into year two of Neo
ownership or three or four, with the
more plasticky, cheap laptops, um the
plastic on mine would always discolor
and go dull where my palms would rest on
the chassis when typing. Uh also, over
time, it just gets more squeaky and
wobbly, and scratches show up really
easily, or things just straight up
break, like the ports or the screen
hinges or something like that. Now, I've
only been using my Neo for a few months,
which is still too early to show any
kind of long-term wear and tear, but I
know it's going to age really well
because this is my M1 MacBook Air. Now,
it is 6 years old at this point, you
know, pretty similar build quality to
the Neo, and it still looks and feels
almost brand new even 6 years later.
Now, in terms of everyday performance of
the Neo, I find most videos on this
subject tend to get a little too nerdy
and show, you know, graphs or benchmarks
or complicated workflows. And let's be
honest, this is tech you should, right?
If you're watching this video, you're
probably more knowledgeable about tech
than the average person. But, it is
still important to not forget that the
average person is who the Neo is aimed
at. Like, you know, the type of person
who doesn't even know what RAM is or has
never used Photoshop in their life, for
example. Like my mom, for example. Like
imagine asking your mom, who might be in
her 50s or 60s or whatever, uh how she
feels about the screen being LCD and not
OLED or only having 8 GB of RAM. She's
going to have no idea what you're
talking about. And this is the point I'm
trying to make, right? Like the average
person will just walk into an Apple
Store, say, you know, I need a basic and
affordable laptop for XYZ,
>> [music]
>> what can you recommend? And then they're
happy with the price of the Neo and they
just get that. And the Neo does this so
well. Like it's not flashy. In fact,
it's actually a really basic laptop, but
I can watch movies with the built-in
speakers and have a pretty decent
listening experience. and the mic works
well for video calls. Actually, it's an
upgrade over some previous MacBooks. The
screen isn't some fancy OLED like super
high refresh rate thing, but it still
looks bright and colorful and more
importantly has a super sharp
resolution. So, text and UI elements
look incredible. For battery life, I've
been getting about 8 to 10 hours of
normal use as well. And everyday
performance is really good, too. In
fact, side by side with the more
powerful and also much more expensive M5
MacBook Air.
I really struggled to tell the
difference when doing those everyday
tasks, you know, stuff like web
browsing, watching YouTube videos,
multitasking. Sure, exporting videos or
editing photos, etc. is going to be
snappier on the more powerful laptop,
but that is not something that 95% of
people do regularly. But, this is where
I'll get into some of the commonly
mentioned complaints about the Neo. It's
pretty obvious that Apple had to make
some compromises to get the price of the
Neo so low, but I think these
compromises have been made in areas
where it's not really an issue for the
average Neo user. For example, the 256
GB SSD, now my preference is for 512 GB,
but I have been using 256 GB SSD
MacBooks for, you know, six, I think
maybe even eight years at this point,
and it is fairly easy to manage. I just
keep all of my large files on an
inexpensive external drive, and then I
just use iCloud or some other cloud
service to store all of my other stuff.
I typically have around 50 to 70 GB free
after this, and I do have to regularly
clean up my downloads folder or, you
know, delete movies and TV shows that
I've finished watching just to keep
space free on the SSD. Now, if you're
looking for something that will take
care of all this for you and more, you
can check out an app called CleanMyMac,
and big thanks to CleanMyMac for
supporting my channel and sponsoring
this section of the video. Now,
CleanMyMac has many features, but the
most powerful is something called Smart
Care. With just a few clicks, Smart Care
initiates a thorough scan of your system
and takes care of everything from
cleaning up junk files to enhancing
performance. It'll show you the results
in a neat dashboard and allow you to
take action by simply clicking the run
button. Now, I personally love the
cleanup feature because I have had
issues in the past where my Mac's SSD
has filled up almost entirely, and it
can often be hard to pinpoint where this
issue is coming from using macOS's
built-in storage manager. Using
clean-up, I can not only free up
invisible junk like deleted user
profiles, outdated caches, and broken
login items, but take it a step further
with the my clutter feature to easily
find large unnecessary files or
duplicate files. On top of that,
CleanMyMac comes with a built-in
protection feature designed to safeguard
your Mac by detecting and addressing a
wide range of threats and
vulnerabilities like malware, even in
USB drives and email attachments. So,
use the link in the description and
download CleanMyMac today and get 10%
off using code created10 at the
checkout. Okay, getting back into the
compromises of the Neo, another one I
hear about is the ports. Now, the Neo
does have much slower USB 3 and USB 2
ports versus Thunderbolt on the other
Apple Silicon MacBooks. And this doesn't
really seem to be an issue in my
opinion, like the average Neo user is
not using super fast SSDs or really
expensive 5K resolution monitors that
require those faster ports. There's also
no Touch ID, uh but I've seen a lot of
comments from Neo owners on my videos
saying that they don't really care about
Touch ID. So, it seems again it's just
not really a big deal. Another criticism
I regularly hear apart from the 256 GB
SSD is too small, is that 8 GB of RAM is
not enough and that because of this the
Neo will be e-waste in 2 to 3 years. And
to answer that question, I'll go all the
way back to the M1 MacBook Air where
people said the exact same thing. And
yet, here we are 6 years later and the
M1 Air is working perfectly. In fact,
it's working so well that a lot of M1
Air owners see no point in upgrading.
And I think the Neo is the exact same.
Like it all boiled down to what I was
doing on the Neo, right? So, web
browsing, watching YouTube videos,
emails, Word documents, maybe editing
the occasional holiday photo, etc. These
tasks are not going to be significantly
more demanding in 5 years time. In fact,
to give you an idea of RAM usage on the
Neo, here's a pretty typical usage
scenario for me. Now, I have about 20
browser tabs open in Chrome, uh about 10
in Safari for about 30 total active
tabs, the Mail app, Notion, Excel,
ChatGPT, and Spotify. You might look
straight away at the memory used figure
and think, "Oh, well, he's, you know,
maxing out his RAM already." But, macOS
is designed to try and use all available
RAM at all times for best performance.
Now, the best indicator of RAM usage is
actually the memory pressure chart in
the bottom left corner. Now, this ranges
from green, which means good, uh you
know, you're not using that much,
yellow, which means the available RAM is
being mostly utilized, and red, which
means, yeah, you need more RAM. You can
see the memory pressure right now is
just barely yellow. In fact, if I close
a few Chrome browser tabs, and I go back
to green, my workflow on the Neo doesn't
really get more intensive than this. So,
8 GB is fine for me, and I don't really
see that changing anytime soon. Now,
yes, if you're a white-collar
professional who needs, you know, 15
different apps open and 70 browser tabs
while doing a Teams call, for example,
uh this is not the laptop for you. That
will bring the Neo to its knees. But,
you know, for everyone else, it is
perfectly fine. So, after months of
using the Neo, what are my overall
thoughts? Well, first of all, I'm
actually really surprised that Apple
entered this budget laptop market. Their
cheapest laptop for years has always
been the MacBook Air at around the
$1,000 price point. So, to come in with
a MacBook, half the price is a pretty
big move in my opinion. And they didn't
really compromise on the overall MacBook
experience, either, even though it's
half the price. You know, I get great
battery life, the keyboard and trackpad
feel really nice, significantly nicer
than the competition at this price
range, and just everyday performance is
fast and snappy, and that build quality
is just chef's kiss. It's literally a
single piece of aluminum. You know, show
me any other laptop around the same
price that would give me an equivalent
experience. It doesn't exist. And I
would know that because I've really
tried to find one. Now, if you are
considering buying a Neo, I actually
made a video going into more detail on
some of the things I mentioned here,
including talking about that $100 SSD
and Touch ID upgrade, and if it's worth
it or not. And you can find it here, or
I'll also link it down in the
description somewhere.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video details the long-term, everyday experience of using the budget-friendly MacBook Neo. The author examines its impressive build quality, which rivals significantly more expensive models, and addresses common concerns regarding hardware specifications like RAM and storage. Despite some inevitable compromises required to achieve its lower price point, the author concludes that the Neo remains an excellent choice for the average user, offering a premium MacBook experience that holds up well for standard daily tasks.
Videos recently processed by our community