HomeVideos

Divorce Expert: Slippage Is Tearing Marriages Apart! If Kids Are Your Priority You’ll Divorce!

Now Playing

Divorce Expert: Slippage Is Tearing Marriages Apart! If Kids Are Your Priority You’ll Divorce!

Transcript

4639 segments

0:00

Every single marriage ends in death or

0:01

divorce, but it ends. But the majority

0:04

of them end because of slippage. And

0:06

what does slippage mean?

0:07

Slippage is

0:08

James Ston is back.

0:10

The world's leading divorce lawyer

0:12

with over two decades of experience. He

0:14

offers practical nononsense advice for

0:16

maintaining healthy relationships.

0:17

We live in a society that presumes

0:20

marriage is a good idea. You're about to

0:22

do something incredibly dangerous that

0:25

fails so much of the time. And I think

0:27

it has almost nothing to do with love.

0:29

But if you get married, here's what I

0:31

will tell you. Have you talked about a

0:32

prenup? Getting married without one is a

0:35

fairly risky activity. But the truth is

0:37

is having a child with someone is the

0:40

most risky activity in relationships.

0:42

There's so much stuff a person can do to

0:44

torture you if they have a kid with you.

0:46

And what I'll tell you is the people who

0:48

are obsessed with their children stop

0:50

paying attention to their partner. Which

0:51

leads you right to my office.

0:53

Okay. So, if you were to give me one

0:55

piece of advice to prevent me and my

0:56

partner ever ending up in your

0:57

consultation room,

0:58

if there's a core message to my approach

1:00

to relationships, it is that'd be the

1:03

only advice I'd ever give to anybody.

1:05

James, if you think about the divorces

1:07

you've seen in court, was there ever a

1:08

case that broke your heart?

1:10

Yeah. It was a case that I won that I

1:12

should have lost. I remember looking at

1:15

the judge and thinking like, you're

1:16

letting this happen.

1:18

She's going to lose because she's poor

1:20

and she can't afford a lawyer. And he's

1:22

going to win because he can afford a

1:23

lawyer that knows how to put a document

1:25

into evidence. And there's something

1:26

really wrong about that.

1:30

[Music]

1:33

This has always blown my mind a little

1:35

bit. 53% of you that listen to the show

1:38

regularly haven't yet subscribe to the

1:40

show. So, could I ask you for a favor

1:42

before we start? If you like the show

1:43

and you like what we do here and you

1:44

want to support us, the free simple way

1:46

that you can do just that is by hitting

1:47

the subscribe button. And my commitment

1:49

to you is if you do that, then I'll do

1:51

everything in my power, me and my team,

1:53

to make sure that this show is better

1:54

for you every single week. We'll listen

1:56

to your feedback. We'll find the guests

1:58

that you want me to speak to and we'll

2:00

continue to do what we do. Thank you so

2:01

much.

2:05

James,

2:07

our last conversation, I think, did

2:09

almost 10 million downloads and views

2:11

across platforms. And I can't imagine

2:13

the amount of messages you get on a

2:16

daily, weekly, monthly basis from people

2:18

that are interested in the subject of

2:20

divorce, but also the sort of

2:21

interconnected subjects of love and and

2:23

marriage and all of these things.

2:26

When people contact you, what do they

2:28

typically say?

2:30

You're absolutely right. Right. I mean,

2:31

the number of people that contacted me

2:33

after our conversation exponentially

2:36

increased. It also very much broadened

2:38

the pallet of things people contacted me

2:40

about. So, a lot of a lot of my prior

2:42

work, a lot of my writing prior to our

2:44

first conversation was very much tied to

2:47

just relationship issues, divorce

2:50

related issues. So, I would get a lot of

2:51

messages from people saying, "I'm going

2:53

through a terrible divorce. I'm dealing

2:54

with this situation. you know, even

2:56

though you can't represent me because

2:58

I'm in a different state or a different

2:59

country, could you give me some general

3:01

advice? Um, so people would reach out

3:03

with very specific to my career topics.

3:07

I got a lot of people talking to me

3:10

about the conversation we had about our

3:13

dogs and about loss and about the nature

3:17

of um you know aging and endings and

3:22

whether it's the ending of a marriage or

3:24

the ending of a dog's life or our own

3:26

lives and how the loss of our pets you

3:29

know brings us more sharply into focus

3:32

about the mortality of everything around

3:34

us. So, um yeah, I mostly get people

3:37

saying, "Oh, you you gave voice to

3:42

something that I'd felt and um it it was

3:46

meaningful to me to do that." And I I

3:48

try to write people back and just say,

3:50

you know, very briefly like, "I'm so

3:51

glad that something in my perspective

3:53

resonated with you."

3:56

If there was one message that you could

3:58

give to everyone that messages you. So,

4:01

one singular message. It was a broadcast

4:03

message and you had to send it to

4:04

everybody that's messaged you about all

4:06

of these interconnected subjects. But

4:07

you could only say a couple of

4:08

sentences. And you think it's the couple

4:10

of sentences that would most serve all

4:12

of them in one go regardless of what

4:14

their issues are because it's a

4:15

fundamental message about love and

4:17

marriage and divorce and all these

4:18

things. What would that message be?

4:21

I mean, I've always said that I think

4:22

the core truth I've learned in my life

4:24

is that the hard thing to do and the

4:26

right thing to do are usually the same

4:28

thing. So, I would I would often

4:30

challenge anybody who reaches out to me

4:32

about anything that that they're

4:33

struggling with, I would say to them

4:35

that what is the hard thing to do in

4:37

this situation because that's probably

4:38

the right thing to do.

4:40

The the other thing I would say is that

4:42

although I really appreciate that

4:45

someone would reach out to me in the

4:47

hopes that I could give them some

4:48

answer, I I pretty strongly believe that

4:52

the only zen you find on mountain tops

4:55

is the zen you brought up there. And and

4:58

so I think a lot of a lot of the truth

5:01

we know when we hear someone say it out

5:05

loud, it's it resonates in a way, but

5:09

it's because we knew it was true. We

5:10

already knew it was true. Maybe that

5:12

person gave voice to it.

5:13

When you said the thing about Zen and

5:15

Mountaintops.

5:16

Yeah.

5:16

Can you say that again? And what did you

5:18

mean?

5:18

Yeah. I I mean, you know, you can also

5:20

parse it as the only wisdom we find on

5:22

mountain tops is the wisdom that we

5:24

brought up there. You know, there's

5:25

this, you know, there's all of these

5:27

sort of Zen parables of the of the monk

5:29

who like in Batman Begins, you know,

5:31

sort of in his in his flip-flops and

5:33

robes sort of wanders up the mountain

5:35

through the cold trying to find the Zen

5:37

master at the top of the mountain who

5:38

has the wisdom that he can then share

5:40

with him. And and very often like that

5:43

wisdom is inside of all of us. that

5:44

wisdom is something that whether we want

5:47

to call it our gut, whether you want to

5:49

call it your soul, what whatever you

5:51

want to call it, that that the wisdom is

5:53

inside of you and that um we we we want

5:57

I think sometimes to have other people

6:00

validate it for us or say it out loud

6:02

because perhaps we're not as articulate

6:03

about it, but to have someone give voice

6:05

to it gives us the ability to go, okay,

6:08

okay, so it's not just me. And I think

6:10

that's that's what I mean when I say the

6:11

wisdom we find on mountain tops. I I

6:13

think we travel very very far to find a

6:18

joy and a wisdom that's inside all of

6:21

us.

6:23

On that point, I as you were talking

6:25

about it and the reason I was so peeked

6:26

by it is I've got so many friends over

6:28

the years who have been struggling in

6:31

relationships and in their life and in

6:33

their marriages who have thought that

6:35

the answer to all of those problems was

6:37

to basically get on a plane and move

6:39

country or city to go somewhere else.

6:41

Yeah.

6:42

And so when you were saying that I was

6:43

thinking I was thinking back to a

6:45

conversation I had with my friend many

6:46

years ago where he said you know I'm

6:47

going to move to Spain

6:49

and you know his life was in ruins

6:50

really at the time. His relation his

6:51

partner had just cheated on him and was

6:53

pregnant. Um and he thought moving to

6:56

Spain would solve the problems. And I

6:58

remember the conversation with him where

6:59

I said like by the way all the problems

7:00

of buying a plane ticket with you

7:02

like they're going to Spain with you.

7:04

Wherever you go you know there you are.

7:06

And so I had a friend who was a uh a

7:09

hairdresser

7:10

and I remember once talking to him. It

7:13

was while he was cutting my hair and uh

7:16

we got on the topic of you know because

7:18

both of us are are someone that people

7:20

talk to. You know people talk to me

7:22

about their problems in their

7:23

relationship as a function of my work as

7:25

a divorce lawyer. And people sit with

7:27

their hair stylist and they'll talk

7:29

particularly women will talk for a long

7:31

period of time about the things that are

7:32

stressing them out and upsetting them.

7:34

And what he said to me is, you know, um,

7:37

a lot of women in particular come in and

7:40

they say, I I want to cut I want to cut

7:42

it all off. I want to cut it all off. I

7:44

want to cut it very short. I want to cut

7:45

it very different. Like, I want just a

7:47

whole. And he said, you know, there was

7:49

a time early in his career where he

7:51

would give them what they were asking

7:52

for. So, if they came in with super long

7:54

hair and they said, "I want a little

7:55

short, very bob cut, you know, he would

7:57

do it." And then he would get a call

7:59

from them a few days or weeks later

8:01

going, "Oh my god, when can you fix it?

8:03

like what do we do? And he said what he

8:05

started to figure out is what they what

8:06

they're really saying is a very human

8:08

thing which is I don't want to be me

8:10

anymore. Like I don't want to be me

8:12

anymore. Like I can't do it. Like it's

8:14

all too heavy right now. Like can I stop

8:17

being me? Can I look different than me?

8:19

Can I because maybe if I look different

8:20

than me I'll feel different than me and

8:22

maybe I'll do things differently than

8:24

the way I've been doing them. And I

8:26

think that's so human, you know, to to

8:29

say and that's the same thing about okay

8:30

that's I'm just going to move. I'm going

8:31

to move. I'm going to like I'm I'm just

8:33

as guilty of this as anyone. When I've

8:36

had a really stressful, difficult week

8:38

carrying all of my clients chaos and

8:40

stress and there's just bombs falling

8:42

from the sky constantly in my line of

8:43

work. I go, "That's it. I quit. I'm

8:45

done. I'm done. I'm just going to do

8:46

media stuff. I'm just going to write

8:48

books. I'm not practicing law anymore.

8:50

I'm never setting foot in a courtroom

8:51

again. Mic drop. I'm out." And the

8:54

reality is I'm tired. I'm just tired.

8:56

like or okay if it's true that I'm at a

9:00

place where transitioning it then just

9:02

cut back it's you don't have to cut all

9:04

your hair off like you and I said to my

9:06

my friend who's the hairdresser so now

9:08

what do you do you try to talk them out

9:10

of it and he said no he said I I kind of

9:13

play a trick he's like I I do something

9:15

a little different but not so different

9:19

and then I play up in my reaction to it

9:21

like oh I love it like this look at how

9:24

it's so nice I didn't take as much as

9:26

you But I think this is really and he

9:28

said and very often they're thrilled

9:30

like they just go oh yeah this is great

9:32

because it was symbolic like it was a

9:35

symbolic thing for them that no I'm

9:37

going to do something different and I'm

9:39

going to look a little different when I

9:40

look in the mirror and when I look in

9:42

the mirror it's going to remind me to be

9:44

different but that's inside of you like

9:47

I I I mean for me

9:51

we wake up every single day and decide

9:53

to be who we are or to continue being

9:56

who we are. Like and and and one of the

9:59

reason why this is always so present in

10:01

my mind is because as a divorce lawyer,

10:03

people have this very clear image of who

10:06

they are and what their life's going to

10:08

be. And very intentionally, they went

10:09

and put on the white dress and the

10:11

tuxedo and they took the vows and they

10:12

were like, "This is the path. This is

10:14

the path. I'm taking this path and this

10:17

is who I am. I'm Bob's wife or I'm Jen's

10:20

husband and I'm going to be a mom or I'm

10:23

going to be a dad and I'm going to this

10:24

is what I'm going to And then it blows

10:25

up whether it's 5 years later, 10 years

10:28

later, 20 years later, when the kids go

10:29

off to college, whatever it might be.

10:32

And then they're what they're really

10:34

struggling with is wait, who am I?

10:36

Who am I now? Like the barn's burn down.

10:39

What? Like what do I do? Like what? I'm

10:41

not Bob's wife. Then what am I? You

10:43

know, I'm Bob's ex-wife. That's a

10:45

terrible thing to be. I don't want to be

10:47

defined by what I'm not anymore and used

10:49

to be, you know? So what do I who am I

10:51

now? And you know, watching people

10:55

over the course of their divorce

10:58

navigate that is one of the most

11:01

inspirational things in the world

11:03

because people are so much stronger and

11:06

more resilient than they give themselves

11:08

credit for when they're in the crisis of

11:10

it.

11:11

Was there ever a a particular case that

11:15

you think about that broke your heart?

11:18

You're going to try to make me cry

11:19

again, Stephen. This feels unfair. No,

11:21

it's interesting because I I didn't I

11:23

was our conversation last time was so

11:25

interesting because we spoke so matterof

11:27

fact about the the subject of love and

11:29

marriage and then for me to also learn

11:32

at the same time that you are a deeply

11:34

emotional person.

11:35

What is the one case?

11:41

I I've had a few. I mean, one of them I

11:43

wrote about in my book, which was I

11:46

represented I it was a case that I won

11:49

that I should have lost. I was I

11:51

represented a pimp. That's what he did

11:54

for a living. And uh he owned a variety

11:57

of of illegal businesses. Uh he's in

12:00

prison um for a long long time now. But

12:03

uh at the time he had uh very brutally

12:07

abused uh a woman who he had children

12:09

with. And we went to uh fam there was a

12:12

family court proceeding and the lawyer

12:14

on the other side of the of the case,

12:16

the lawyer who represented his um his

12:19

co-parent, his victim if you will, um

12:23

was very inexperienced. She was an

12:25

assigned lawyer, so I was privately paid

12:27

as I am and she was assigned by the

12:30

state. So she was getting, I think at

12:31

the time, $25 an hour, something like

12:33

that versus my 750 an hour. And she was

12:37

quite new as a lawyer. She was right out

12:40

of school. She wasn't quite sure, you

12:41

know, of of what to do and how to do it.

12:43

And I was fairly experienced. And a

12:47

judge who was very impatient, who just

12:49

was in a bad mood that day. I don't know

12:51

what he had for breakfast or what it

12:53

was, but he was an older judge. He'd

12:54

been on the bench for probably too long.

12:56

He retired a few years later. The key

12:58

piece of evidence they had was a

13:00

photograph of the way that my client of

13:02

this woman's face after my client had

13:05

allegedly beat her up quite badly. And

13:08

getting a photograph into evidence is

13:10

very easy, but it requires a very

13:13

specific phrasing. So what you say is,

13:16

"I'd like this to be marked for

13:18

identification." You mark the photo and

13:20

then you hand it to the witness or you

13:22

hand it to the court officer who hands

13:23

it to the witness and you say, "I'm

13:25

showing you what's been marked as

13:27

petitioners one for identification." Do

13:29

you recognize that? Yes. What do you

13:32

recognize it to be? It's a photograph.

13:35

Does that photograph fairly and

13:36

accurately depict your face after he

13:40

beat you up? Or does it accurately

13:42

reflect your face on the date you've

13:44

been discussing? Yes, your honor. I'd

13:46

like it put into evidence. That's it.

13:48

It's easy. Does it fairly and accurately

13:51

depict?

13:53

For whatever reason, most likely lack of

13:55

experience, opposing council,

13:58

I guess, didn't know how to get a

13:59

photograph into evidence. Now normally

14:02

in that situation a judge will be

14:05

helpful like they will just jump in and

14:08

say ma'am is this fairly but this judge

14:11

was just not in the mood and posing

14:14

councel said um I'd like this to be

14:16

marked and then she said could you hand

14:18

to the witness and she said what is that

14:20

a photo of so I did my job I said

14:22

objection she's asking about the

14:24

contents of a document not an evidence

14:27

which is my job

14:29

judge said sustain

14:32

which means

14:33

which means my objection is correct. So

14:35

she said, "Uh, okay. Uh, I'm sorry. Uh,

14:38

who took this photo?" And she said, "I I

14:40

I don't I don't know who took it." She

14:43

says, "Okay, well, what what is it a

14:45

photo of?" Stood up again. Objection,

14:49

asking about the contents of a document,

14:50

not an evidence. And I could see

14:53

opposing council getting flustered

14:55

because she didn't know the words. And

14:58

my internal dialogue

15:00

at that moment was

15:03

just say it like just get it right. Like

15:05

just say just say fair does it fairly

15:07

inaccurately depict is it just say it

15:10

like and and and I I remember looking at

15:12

the judge and thinking like you're

15:14

letting this happen.

15:16

You're letting this happen. Don't let

15:18

this happen. Like she's poor.

15:22

She's poor. That's that's why she's

15:25

going to lose.

15:27

She's going to lose because she's poor

15:28

and she can't afford a lawyer. And he's

15:30

going to win because he can't afford a

15:32

lawyer that knows how to put a document

15:33

into evidence. And there's something

15:35

really wrong about that.

15:37

And the judge didn't the judge just let

15:40

her drown. And she she asked three or

15:42

four more questions that were the wrong

15:44

questions. And then she just said, "Um,

15:47

I I don't I don't know. I don't know

15:49

what to say. I'm sorry." And then she

15:50

just sat down and the case got

15:53

dismissed.

15:55

And we walked out. And as we walked out,

15:59

my client patted me on the back and he

16:03

said, "You know, a good lawyer is better

16:05

than 20 stickup men."

16:08

And I remember thinking,

16:11

"This is this is not a good day. It's

16:14

not a good day." And

16:18

that case that was a long time ago and

16:20

it's it still stayed with me because it

16:23

it was I did my job and I I you know I

16:27

represent my client but I also represent

16:29

the system and I don't always believe in

16:31

my client but I have to believe in the

16:33

system and I have to believe that I am

16:35

not it's not my right to judge people's

16:39

case. It's the judge's right like like I

16:40

believe in this system. I believe in the

16:42

adversarial system, but watching

16:46

someone lose who shouldn't lose

16:50

and winning when you know you shouldn't

16:52

win does not feel good in this line of

16:55

work.

16:56

Would you take that case again? Exact

16:59

same case, exact same person, exact same

17:01

scenario. You're asked to go and do it

17:03

again tomorrow. Same opposition lawyer.

17:06

I would. Yeah. Well, first of all, it's

17:08

many years later and I still know that

17:10

lawyer and she's actually become a

17:11

really good one and I'm really proud of

17:12

that.

17:13

If she was equally inexperienced, the

17:15

same woman, the same circumstances, the

17:17

same victim,

17:20

you know, if I knew it was going to go

17:22

that way, I probably I would turn it

17:24

down. I mean, I turned down a lot of

17:26

cases. I don't actually know if today I

17:29

would represent him anymore. It's a hard

17:31

question for me to answer. I see. I

17:34

think you don't always you don't know in

17:37

the consultation

17:39

and like it's not like this guy came

17:41

into my office and said, "Yeah, I beat

17:43

this woman terribly.

17:45

Will you retain will you represent me?"

17:47

Like that's very different. No one's

17:49

ever done that in my in my office. Like

17:52

he came in and he said, "Yeah, she's

17:53

accusing me of all these horrible

17:55

things. I didn't do any of it."

17:56

But you knew he did.

17:58

In my gut, I think I knew he did. Yeah.

18:00

the more I got to know him. I mean, in a

18:01

consultation, you don't know. Like, in a

18:03

job interview, you don't know what kind

18:04

of employee somebody's going to be. You

18:06

know, sitting across from someone in a

18:08

1-hour consultation, most of the time,

18:10

I'm talking telling them about their

18:12

rights and obligations and how the legal

18:13

process works. Like, I don't really get

18:15

to know them. But throughout the

18:17

process, I started to figure out like,

18:19

yeah, there's this guy did this.

18:20

You said you turned down a lot of cases,

18:23

you know, these days. Yeah.

18:24

What are the kind of cases that you

18:25

would absolutely turn down irrespective

18:27

of remuneration?

18:29

I turn down cases where I feel like the

18:31

person I mean a lot of times I turn down

18:34

cases that I don't think they need me.

18:36

Like I don't think you need to bring a

18:37

gun to a knife fight. Like I think if

18:39

you can do it with a scalpel, don't use

18:41

a chainsaw. And I'm a chainsaw. So like

18:44

don't you don't need me. And so I I I

18:48

I'm very honest with people about you

18:51

don't need me. I'm not the right tool

18:53

for the task. But there are a lot of

18:55

cases I turn down that I think people

18:57

are using. They want to weaponize the

18:59

legal system to punish their ex for

19:02

their transgressions, real and

19:03

perceived. Like they want to their

19:05

spouse was cheating on them and they

19:07

want to just litigate them into

19:09

submission. They want them force them to

19:10

spend a million dollars in council fees

19:12

by making ridiculous motions and by

19:15

minimizing, you know, their access to

19:17

the kids and making them fight for every

19:19

single hour of visitation they get with

19:21

the kids. Like I I'm not interested in

19:23

being a weapon that's used for

19:25

Yeah.

19:26

for that purpose.

19:26

Presumably sometimes your job is to get

19:28

custody of kids essentially all the

19:31

time,

19:31

which means that you're you're basically

19:32

taking children away from

19:34

a parent.

19:36

You can look at it that way.

19:37

It's a harsh way to say it, but

19:39

I've jokingly said that before cuz when

19:40

my kids were little and they would have

19:43

those like, you know, bring your dad to

19:44

school day

19:46

and you know, it was like, "Oh, this is

19:48

my dad. He's a firefighter. And this is

19:50

my dad. that he's a doctor. And I always

19:52

felt like my sons were like, "This is my

19:53

dad. He's the reason why your

19:54

firefighter dad only sees you on

19:56

alternate weekends, you know, and that

19:58

felt a little strange, you know, and

20:00

there were times where actually I my

20:01

kids were in school with people whose

20:03

divorces I had I had handled um you

20:05

know, their their parents. But yeah, I I

20:07

I think um I do have a tremendous impact

20:11

on on people's access to their children,

20:13

both positive and negative. Like I help

20:15

I help people get access to children

20:17

that's being withheld from them. I help

20:19

people um address parental alienation

20:23

and negative gatekeeping, the kinds of

20:25

things that are really becoming much

20:27

more insidious and prevalent in our

20:29

culture where where people are using

20:32

children essentially as weapons against

20:34

their ex who they're mad at. I mean,

20:36

look, breakups on any level are

20:38

difficult, you know, and and there's

20:40

usually hurt feelings and anger in a

20:42

breakup. And I don't think that's

20:43

abnormal. Like I think you lose someone

20:45

whether it's to death or whether it's to

20:47

divorce or just to split up. There's

20:48

some anger, you know, there's

20:50

resentment. Why don't you love me? Why

20:51

don't you love me the way I love you?

20:52

Why don't you want to be with me

20:53

anymore? What does this say about me?

20:55

Does this mean I'm a bad person because

20:56

you don't want to be with me anymore?

20:57

Like this these are really universal

20:59

themes. Like there's almost no one in

21:01

the world in any culture that if you go

21:03

to them breakups that they don't go, you

21:06

know, they get it. Like they get it.

21:08

My friend's going through a breakup at

21:09

the moment. Um he's been with his

21:11

partner for many, many years. And I when

21:13

he sent me the voice note explaining

21:14

like we've been together eight years,

21:16

we've kind of broken up four times, but

21:18

um my the he's being broken up with. So

21:22

he's the he's the sort of victim, per

21:24

se. And

21:25

which is the better one to be

21:26

really? Oh yeah.

21:27

You want someone to break up with you?

21:28

Oh, I mean well here's what I'll say cuz

21:31

I' I'm have something of a PhD in this

21:33

one. I I have to tell you when someone

21:36

has been broken up with there's a

21:38

tremendous amount unless it was by some

21:40

patently awful behavior. you know, like

21:42

they got caught with the girlfriend or

21:44

the boyfriend red-handed, like then it's

21:46

no one's going to give you much

21:47

sympathy. But if someone dumps you,

21:51

like it's not it's not me, it's you.

21:53

Like they just dump you.

21:55

There's a tremendous amount of sympathy.

21:57

Like if somebody call if I called you

21:59

and I said, "Dude, I just got broken up

22:00

with." You'd be like, "Oh me, come on,

22:02

man. Let's let's go out. Let's tough,

22:05

man. We've all been there. Like don't

22:06

tell you know what happened." But when

22:09

you break up with someone,

22:12

there's only so much sympathy people

22:14

will give you because, you know, well,

22:15

we broke up. If you're so upset about

22:18

it, get back. What did you do it for

22:20

then? Like you whereas sometimes, you

22:22

know, you're just the one who called it

22:24

like it's not it wasn't a happy

22:27

relationship. It wasn't like you're sad

22:29

that it had to end, you know, like I

22:31

didn't want to break up. I wanted the

22:33

relationship to stay good and it didn't.

22:37

So, one of us has to be the grown-up and

22:39

say, "Okay, this thing's over now." But

22:42

I think that person actually sometimes

22:43

deserves, you know, just as much

22:45

sympathy as someone who got dumped

22:46

because they're both someone who's

22:49

experiencing a loss of sorts, even if

22:51

it's a loss that it's, you know, I mean,

22:53

it's a terrible metaphor. But if someone

22:55

said to you, "I have lung cancer." You

22:57

would go, "Oh my god, that's horrible."

22:58

Like, "Are you okay?" If someone said,

23:00

"Well, I was a smoker for 50 years and I

23:02

got lung cancer." It's not like YOU GO,

23:03

WELL, WHAT DID YOU THINK? I MEAN now

23:05

it's of course you're still going to go

23:07

oh my god that's terri it's not like you

23:08

deserve it. It's I mean yes is it

23:11

SHOCKING IT'S NOT AS SHOCKING if you've

23:13

been smoking for 50 years but it's still

23:15

quite sad and it's still a journey this

23:17

person's going to have to go through. So

23:18

it's the same thing. It's like I I just

23:20

went through a breakup. Well who's who

23:22

picked who decided to break up with who

23:24

before I tell you if I feel bad for you

23:26

or not. Like I don't think that's a fair

23:27

way to approach a breakup.

23:29

A lot of people want to own the they

23:30

want to own it. They want to say that

23:31

they broke up with them, right? As well

23:32

because that

23:33

it's very popular.

23:34

Well, there's something empowering about

23:35

that.

23:36

Yeah. It was my decision.

23:37

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Or or the like, well,

23:39

I'm glad they did because I I'll tell

23:41

you the truth, I was about to I was

23:42

about to break up with that person, you

23:43

know. Yeah. That's very common. I think

23:45

that's a pride thing, though, because,

23:47

you know, there's something about the

23:50

rejection

23:52

of it's over, you know, a great example

23:54

of this for me, which is is very um it's

23:58

always vexed me professionally. So, a

24:00

lot of people um I've handled a lot of

24:03

divorces where someone

24:05

uh breaks up with in a heterosexual

24:08

marriage because they are coming out as

24:11

gay or lesbian. Okay? So, they end the

24:14

relationship. So, in in the heterosexual

24:16

example, man and a woman are married to

24:18

each other for a period of time and the

24:20

man says, "I'm ending things with you

24:22

because I'm gay. I've realized that I'm

24:25

gay and I'd like to live my life as a

24:26

gay man.

24:30

my thinking as someone who's never had

24:32

that happen to me. My thinking, and

24:35

perhaps it's naive, like my experience

24:37

has taught me that maybe I'm just

24:38

strange, which I kind of knew, but this

24:40

is another example of it. If if a woman

24:44

broke up with me

24:47

and said, "I'm breaking up with you

24:50

because I'd like another man better than

24:53

you." That's very hard to swallow. It's

24:56

like I want one like you but better than

24:58

you. Whereas if she said I'm leaving you

25:01

cuz I'd like to go be with a woman now.

25:03

It's like well I mean I don't I don't

25:06

have that. Like I can't give you that.

25:08

It's not like I want someone who's a

25:10

better dancer. I want someone who's

25:11

funnier. I want someone who has

25:13

different parts than you. And okay. I

25:16

mean that feels a little less like a

25:18

reject. You're not rejecting me

25:20

necessarily. You're rejecting my entire

25:22

sort of gender. you're you're basically

25:24

saying this isn't who I want. The

25:26

opposite actually happens. It it it

25:29

those are some of the most brutal and

25:31

vitriolic awful divorces you could

25:34

possibly imagine. And they've actually

25:36

gotten worse over the span of my career

25:38

because over the 25 years span of my

25:40

career, when I started,

25:43

when someone said, "Okay, my husband is

25:45

leaving because he's gay and now he's

25:47

going to live as a gay man." it was

25:50

actually okay to then say, "Yeah, and

25:52

he's a pervert and a horrible human

25:54

being." And because there was just such

25:57

a widespread homophobia at the time. I

25:59

mean, you know, Will and Grace, like

26:00

Will couldn't even kiss his boyfriend on

26:02

TV. He couldn't really even have a

26:03

boyfriend. It was like so, you know,

26:05

young young people today have no idea

26:08

how in my lifetime that that has changed

26:11

so much. Not to say there isn't still

26:12

homophobia, not that there's still not

26:14

heteronormativity, but the reality has

26:17

changed tremendously. the boots on the

26:19

ground reality. Now, if your spouse

26:22

leaves you for a if if I was married and

26:26

my spouse left me for a woman and I'm

26:30

upset about it, I'm opening myself to an

26:33

accusation of being homophobic.

26:36

And and the truth is like, no, whoever

26:39

she's leaving me for, it's really

26:41

upsetting. or whoever she's been

26:42

sleeping with, male, female, anything.

26:44

It's upsetting because they're with

26:46

another person. So, I I think there is

26:49

in that phenomenon of people's breakups,

26:52

the sense of like, well, I was going to

26:53

break up with them anyway, is like a

26:56

pride thing. I think I think there is a

26:58

tremendous amount of um of stuff that we

27:02

carry around when it comes to those

27:04

breakups. I've always wondered what

27:05

heartbreak actually is because I I I

27:08

flip between thinking okay it's like you

27:10

mentioned the word rejection is it a

27:11

blow to our self-esteem is it the loss

27:14

of a future that we had like built in

27:16

our head

27:17

because yes

27:18

if you can understand what it is I was

27:19

thinking about how do I give my friend

27:20

advice on it then I then I know what the

27:22

advice should be or the support should

27:24

be because if it's a loss of this future

27:26

then okay I you know I know I'll say

27:28

this if it's his self-esteem okay I'll

27:30

boost his self-esteem.

27:31

Yeah. So, I think it's all of those

27:33

things, but I I think it's it's it's an

27:36

ending. And I think that endings are

27:37

hard. I think that saying to

27:41

what I always try to do when I have

27:42

friends going through a breakup and even

27:44

with clients is that, you know, every

27:47

beginning is born of some other

27:50

beginning's end.

27:52

So, we talked about this the last time

27:53

we sat down together where I said that,

27:55

you know, I only got Cabba because

27:58

Buster died,

27:59

which is your dog's.

28:00

Yeah. my my dog that passed away 13 14

28:03

years ago and my dog that's now 13 years

28:05

old and and one one I only got one

28:09

because the other died and I love both

28:11

of those dogs so much but if I'm being

28:14

honest I guess I have to say I'm glad

28:17

that I lost Buster so that I could have

28:20

Cabba that that sounds terrible because

28:23

I don't mean it like oh I'm glad that he

28:25

but death like that ending was part of

28:27

life just and it made room for the

28:29

beginning of the next thing and what I

28:31

always try to focus my clients on is

28:34

that this relationship is ending and

28:38

that's there's there has to be honoring

28:41

that, mourning that, feeling that,

28:44

seeing it as the transition that it is,

28:47

grieving the loss of it, but also

28:49

realizing that every ending is the

28:52

beginning of the next thing. And and

28:53

there has to be an ending for the next

28:56

thing to come and for the next beginning

28:58

to happen. And I have now watched that

29:01

cycle for so thousands of clients over a

29:05

span of 25 years where where their life

29:08

is ending. Who they I was this person's

29:11

husband. I was this person's wife. I was

29:14

a dad who lived with his kids full-time

29:17

that had them every Thanksgiving. Not

29:18

every other Thanksgiving. That I had

29:20

them every Christmas Eve, not alternate

29:23

years. On in even years they're with me.

29:25

In odd years they're with her. Like what

29:26

are you talking about? like this is who

29:28

I am. Who I'm dying, like who I am is

29:32

dying. And I don't know who I'll be

29:35

next. And

29:38

when you're in that, right? And when

29:40

it's your first divorce, it's not mine,

29:42

but it's yours. You know, it's very hard

29:45

to see like just just like when

29:48

someone dies, you know, when when Buster

29:51

died, I I said it last time. I I said,

29:54

"I will never do this again. I will

29:57

never love anything like this ever

29:58

again. I'll never let my heart be broken

30:00

like this again. I'll never open myself

30:02

up like this again. Ever. Never. This is

30:05

the worst pain. Why would I ever do

30:07

this? Loving anything is stupid. It's

30:10

insane. You're opening yourself up to

30:12

the inevitability of loss. And yet

30:18

Cabba was the such a joy. And now

30:22

I'm near the end of that. And and what

30:25

do you do?

30:26

Well, I I like to believe that now I'm

30:30

not saying that's not going to be as

30:31

painful when it happens. It will be. But

30:35

I no longer believe the world is ending.

30:37

Like I understand that like the beauty

30:40

of who he is was born of the emptiness

30:44

that had to be created by the loss of

30:46

Buster. Like I I understand that now.

30:49

And so I like I said, will I do it

30:53

again? There's going to be a period of

30:54

time where I'll say, "No way." And same

30:56

thing with love. Like people get

30:57

divorced. I had a client last week say

31:00

to me, they're they're right kind of in

31:02

the middle of their divorce. And I said,

31:05

you know, 86% of people are remarried

31:07

within 5 years of their divorce. And

31:10

they said, "Uh, oh, I am never doing

31:12

that. Are you kidding? I am never doing

31:14

this again." And every time they say

31:16

that, I laugh cuz I think to myself, I'm

31:18

like, "You're so wrong." And I get it.

31:21

Like, you don't see it right now. Like

31:22

right now I know you think that's true

31:25

like but you will love again and you

31:27

will when you love again like you will

31:30

feel it and you will be in it and you

31:32

will go a and this one's perfect and

31:36

this is great. Like I've done divorces

31:37

for people that spent a million dollars

31:39

in council fees and went through

31:41

absolute hell and and when they're about

31:43

to get remarried I go you know we should

31:45

do your prenup so you don't ever have to

31:47

do that again. Like I'll do it for free

31:49

if you want. like let's just do and they

31:51

go no no no no this this is real this is

31:55

real and I sit there and I think like oh

31:57

my god you've just you've learned

31:59

nothing at all like you that was real

32:01

too until it wasn't like but but this is

32:04

you know perhaps you know love is a

32:06

delusion brought on by an adequate

32:08

lighting I don't know but there's

32:09

there's something in us that you know

32:13

feels that pain and then there's

32:14

something in us that forgets that pain

32:16

and I think that that you know that's a

32:18

good thing that's a good cycle

32:19

I think life is a game you can't win and

32:22

so you play it to the utmost. To love

32:25

anything is insane because you are

32:27

accepting that you're going to lose it.

32:29

It's a quote you said. You think life is

32:32

a game you can't win.

32:34

Yeah. I don't think there's any winning.

32:36

You die.

32:38

Like that's the only truth. The only the

32:41

you know it

32:43

every story you know starts the same.

32:47

You were born. Like every Wikipedia page

32:50

starts the same. They were born. And

32:53

every Wikipedia page will end exactly

32:55

the same. They died. That's it.

32:58

Everything that happens in between is

33:00

your life. But those are the only two

33:02

inevitabilities. Those are the only two

33:04

real things for certain. So I I look at

33:07

it as it's a game you can't win.

33:10

Meaning

33:12

if you pursue money like your money will

33:15

eventually be useless. The things you

33:17

accumulate with it will be useless.

33:18

Every car you own, someone else will

33:20

either own it someday or it'll get to

33:22

the scrap junkyard someday or it'll

33:24

you'll give it to somebody. Like it's

33:26

all your material possessions will be

33:27

utterly meaningless. Like we all went

33:28

through this when the COVID lockdowns

33:30

first started. Everybody was like, you

33:31

know, I've got all this money and I've

33:33

got all these travel vouchers. And

33:34

they're like, yeah, you can't go

33:35

anywhere now. And it's like, oh, okay.

33:36

Well, what do I the, you know, you

33:38

started to see the limitations of

33:39

things. Have the power go out in your

33:41

house sometime. And it'll remind you

33:43

that like, oh, wait, yeah, like

33:45

everything I have, I just have like this

33:47

much of a grip on it. All you got to do

33:49

is just take that away and it's gone.

33:50

And that's that's it, you know? And it's

33:52

the same thing with our health. It's the

33:54

same thing with, you know, everything

33:56

like everything is totally fine and

33:59

wonderful and then you have a terrible

34:00

splitting headache and then the only

34:02

thing that matters is that headache, you

34:04

know, and then that headache goes away

34:07

and for like a day you go, I don't have

34:10

that headache anymore. But did you wake

34:12

up today and go, I don't have a

34:14

headache. Oh, and the power's on. Isn't

34:16

that great? You know, and I don't have

34:18

cancer. Isn't that good? You know, no,

34:20

you don't. you walk around going like,

34:22

"Ah, you know, I really why aren't why

34:23

aren't my page views where they're at or

34:25

what happened with this and why did that

34:27

person be so nasty to me?" Like we get

34:29

caught up in all this stuff when in fact

34:31

the only thing that you know again if

34:33

you keep you know uh uh Epictatis the

34:35

stoic philosopher said like keep death

34:38

and everything horrible in your line of

34:40

sight sort of momento mori because

34:43

nothing will bother you that much if you

34:45

have that there. So I think life is a

34:47

game that look we're playing it. We're

34:50

doing our thing. Love is but all love

34:51

all relationships end. Every single

34:54

marriage ends in death or divorce but it

34:55

ends. Every relationship ends. Your

34:58

child you will hopefully predesce your

35:00

child but your child will die someday.

35:02

That's the nature of it. So we have

35:05

created a culture where we really try

35:08

not to talk about that. We really try to

35:10

just keep that out of our gaze. Let's

35:12

not talk about it. Our only depictions

35:14

of death are preposterous.

35:18

They're like the person in the deathbed

35:20

being like I loved you all

35:23

and then just beautiful, you know,

35:25

beautifully die. Death doesn't look like

35:27

that. If you ever spent time with people

35:30

on their deathbed, I I I was a hospice

35:32

volunteer for many many years and I

35:34

spent a lot of time with people who were

35:36

dying, actively dying. And I have to

35:38

tell you, like you hang out with someone

35:40

who's it's it's it's not pretty. It

35:44

doesn't smell good. It doesn't sound

35:46

good. But it's real. It's natural. It's

35:48

okay. It's where it's all going. And and

35:50

the reason why I say this is not to be

35:52

morbid. It's that we're doing ourselves

35:54

a tremendous disservice by not

35:56

acknowledging this. Because I can tell

35:58

you how many families when I was a

36:00

hospice volunteer when their family

36:03

member, their loved one would die would

36:06

say to me, "It's not that they died,

36:07

it's that they died terribly. They died

36:10

without dignity." And I would say to

36:12

them, "No, they they died like everyone

36:13

dies." Like it's okay. Like they just

36:16

because it wasn't like on TV where you,

36:19

you know, like sort of fade out and say

36:21

a few final words and then fade out.

36:22

LIKE NO ONE VERY FEW IF anyone dies that

36:25

way. It's not how it works. So, we're

36:28

not doing anyone like this is the part I

36:31

don't understand is that we don't want

36:34

to talk about divorce, you know, we

36:37

don't want to talk about death. We don't

36:39

want to talk about endings cuz I think

36:41

there's something in our brain that says

36:43

if we talk about it, we're going to make

36:44

it happen. And if we don't talk about

36:46

it, we'll prevent it from happening. And

36:48

that seems to me insane because this

36:52

these are things that are absolutely

36:55

inevitable when it comes to death and

36:58

highly likely when it comes to divorce.

37:01

So why not bring them back into the

37:04

discourse? And I'll tell you the truth.

37:05

I think one of the reasons why

37:09

my conversations have become something

37:11

people are interested in is because I

37:14

think we're all fascinated by this but

37:15

we don't want to talk about it over

37:17

dinner conversation and we don't want to

37:19

you know but but we know it's important

37:21

something in us knows this is important

37:24

like this is something that needs to be

37:25

talked about and thought about.

37:28

You did your thesis,

37:30

your master's thesis on the subject of

37:32

death titled

37:33

Well, you do your research

37:34

on metaphor and mortality, the semantics

37:35

of death and dying.

37:36

Yeah.

37:37

Why would you write your thesis on the

37:38

subject of death?

37:39

Well, it was a different life. So, I

37:41

this is before I went to law school. I I

37:44

had gotten out of I got out of college

37:45

with a degree in psychology and I

37:48

decided I wanted to um I was a hospice

37:51

volunteer. I I um

37:53

why

37:56

I have to ask my therapist that

37:57

question. I I I can give you the answer.

38:00

So I when I was quite young uh I think I

38:05

was about six or seven years old, my

38:08

mother was diagnosed with a very rare

38:10

form of cancer called leoyio saroma.

38:13

It's a soft tissue saroma

38:16

and it's it's very rare. I was way too

38:19

young to understand what was going on. I

38:21

I just I remember my mother crying, the

38:23

sound of my mother crying in the

38:25

bathroom and running the sink so I

38:27

wouldn't hear her crying, but I I knew

38:30

she was crying. I didn't really

38:32

understand what death was. Like I

38:33

understood that my gerbil had died, but

38:36

I I grew up Catholic, so I remember like

38:39

you got to go to heaven and that sounded

38:41

pretty good because it was like a really

38:42

nice place apparently.

38:44

And I remember hearing my mother talking

38:47

on the phone to her sister and talking

38:50

about the fact that she had six months.

38:53

And I remember my sister who's six years

38:55

older than me explaining to me that mom

38:58

was sick and she wasn't going to get

39:00

better. And I remember being so young

39:03

that I didn't really understand what

39:04

that meant, but it was scary and

39:06

everyone was very upset.

39:09

And then my mom didn't die. What had

39:12

happened is depending on how you looked

39:14

at it either it was a miracle or it was

39:17

science and that is that the tumors had

39:20

encapsulated itself meaning that the the

39:22

immune system had essentially closed up

39:24

around it so it didn't metastasize or

39:26

spread in any way they went in they did

39:28

surgery memorial slunketing cancer

39:30

center and uh she was fine she was well

39:34

and then five or six years later it came

39:36

back and again I got told your mom has

39:40

six months to live At that point, I was

39:42

like old enough to understand what that

39:44

meant. And I was terrified by it. I was

39:47

saddened by it. And once again, she had

39:50

surgery. She had all kinds of procedures

39:53

and things that had to happen to deal

39:55

with it. But once again, she just

39:57

miraculously sort of ducked a bullet and

39:59

she made it. And three years later, it

40:02

came back again.

40:04

And then they said, "Your, you know,

40:05

your mom has six months to live." And I

40:07

remember by that point thinking, "Yeah,

40:10

you you don't know how many times we've

40:12

had this conversation. Like, I don't

40:13

believe you anymore." Like, and and it's

40:15

okay. Like, I'm not afraid because I'm

40:17

not like it's not going to happen. I

40:19

know that something's going to happen

40:20

and it'll work out. And it did. Once

40:22

again, she had surgery again. She had

40:24

seven surgeries over the course of my

40:27

into my 20s. And every single time the

40:30

prognosis was bad and every single time

40:33

they kind of took more pieces of her

40:35

unfortunately because the type of cancer

40:37

this is sometimes gets into other

40:38

organs. And so they had to take you know

40:42

they had to take her ovaries forced her

40:43

into menopause in her 30s. Then they had

40:45

to take they had to change the way her

40:47

they had to do a bowel resection. They

40:48

had to do all kinds of awful things. And

40:51

uh and it changed her. It was a painful

40:53

life for my mom. It was very hard. And I

40:57

remember

40:58

though from a very young age being

41:00

forced to think about death, being

41:02

forced to sort of see death as something

41:04

that was just there and that it was part

41:06

of things and that there was no way

41:08

around it. And it it just became

41:11

familiar. It became sort of this

41:15

person in our home, you know, this

41:17

possibility that was always there.

41:20

And I remember every time I would get

41:23

the call that my mom's cancer had come

41:26

back, there would be some part of me

41:29

that thought, "Oh, is this the phone

41:31

call?" Like, "Is this the one where this

41:33

time she's going to die? Like, is this

41:35

the one?" And most of the time it

41:37

wasn't.

41:39

And 10 Yeah. 10 years ago,

41:44

um, once again, she had a recurrence.

41:48

She was supposed to have a very complex

41:49

surgery. My dad and I sat in the waiting

41:52

room. My parents were married for 50

41:54

years. And uh we sat in the waiting

41:57

room. It was supposed to be an 8-hour

41:58

surgery because it was very complicated.

42:00

And the doctor came into the waiting

42:02

room a half an hour into the surgery and

42:05

said, you know, we opened her up. It's

42:07

like a bomb went off. There's nothing we

42:10

can do. We're going to close her up and

42:12

put her on hospice.

42:14

And um she passed away eight years ago

42:18

after you know she was on hospice for

42:20

over a year. Um and she died with us all

42:22

around her.

42:24

And there was something

42:27

about the reality that we had been able

42:30

to talk about death for so long that

42:33

there was a tremendous peace there. Like

42:36

there was a tremendous sense of well

42:38

this was going to happen. You know this

42:40

was part of our life. you know that this

42:43

was what was going to happen and she had

42:44

a tremendous piece about her because it

42:47

had been part of her life for so long.

42:50

So when I was in my late teens, I think

42:52

my mom had had three or four rounds of

42:53

this this cancer thing. I just remember

42:57

thinking

42:58

I I have to confront this. I have to

43:01

spend time around death. You know, I

43:03

again I'm strange. You know, I was

43:05

always afraid of spiders. I didn't like

43:07

spiders when I was a kid. So when I went

43:09

off to college, I bought a tarantula and

43:12

I put it in a glass terrarium next to my

43:14

bed so that every morning I would wake

43:16

up and there was just this giant spider

43:18

sitting there next to me and I'm not

43:19

afraid of spiders anymore. And it it got

43:22

rid of that very quickly. And so I

43:24

thought, you know, this is something

43:25

that's been around me all the time and

43:27

it's something I'm not quite at peace

43:29

with, so I'm going to confront it. And I

43:31

went and did a hospice volunteer

43:33

training. And I remember I, you know, it

43:35

was a weird thing for like a 20-year-old

43:36

to do. I had just gotten out of college.

43:39

I was 21. And uh I think I was the only

43:42

person under 60 who was in this

43:43

volunteer training. And hospice

43:45

training. Hospice volunteer training I

43:47

would recommend to anyone

43:49

because they do things like they make

43:51

you write your eulogy.

43:52

Your own eulogy.

43:53

Your own eulogy. Yeah. Yeah. They make

43:55

you write your own eulogy. Like and it

43:57

can either be if you died right now,

43:59

what would the eulogy be? Um or if you

44:03

died in your idealized future, what

44:04

would it be? Um, they make you write

44:06

your own obituary. Like they make you

44:09

confront the reality of thinking about

44:11

death and and thinking about your own

44:13

death and death of the people around

44:15

you. And then after you've been through

44:19

the training, they assign you families.

44:23

And

44:25

I intended initially just to do it as

44:27

sort of a part-time thing in the summer

44:29

after I'd graduated college. I was

44:31

working as a waiter and I had a lot of

44:32

time during the day because at night I

44:34

was I was waiting tables and um I got

44:38

assigned to a bunch of families one at a

44:40

time and and I I loved it. It was the

44:43

most

44:45

it was the most it was the most

44:47

life-changing thing I've ever done. Like

44:49

it it it uh there is something about

44:52

when you're a hospice volunteer and

44:54

you're just brought into a home and

44:56

you're just there to be of service. like

44:58

you're just if they want to talk, we'll

45:00

talk. If you want me to help do the

45:03

dishes so that you can hang out with

45:04

your loved one, that's great. I'll do

45:06

that. Like I I did yard work. And a lot

45:09

of times like people cuz caring for

45:11

someone who's terminally ill in your

45:13

home is hard. And and like things like I

45:15

want to run out to the store and get a

45:16

few things myself. Like that's hard

45:18

because you don't want to leave this

45:19

person alone. So a lot of times I was

45:22

just there to sort of be relief just to

45:24

sit with someone. And um and and every

45:28

time I would walk out of a hospice

45:32

home, I felt like

45:36

I don't know. I felt like a Zen monk. I

45:38

felt like like I could hear the rain.

45:41

Like I just felt like

45:43

I'm alive.

45:45

Like I'm like that that's not happening

45:48

to me yet. Like I'm not there yet. Like

45:50

that's not that's not someone I love in

45:52

that bed. Like I I have love for this

45:54

person. and I want to be there for them.

45:55

I'm here of service, but that's not my

45:57

father. That's not my brother. That's

45:58

not me. It will be someday. And one day

46:01

it was. One day it was my mother. But it

46:04

wasn't me. And I have to tell you,

46:06

there's something about going through

46:07

that experience when you're in your 20s,

46:10

when you're so self-centered, and you're

46:11

supposed to be. You're kind of supposed

46:13

to be self-centered in your 20s. You're

46:14

supposed to say like, "All right, what

46:15

am I going to do with this life? What am

46:17

I going to do with these hands? What am

46:18

I?" But there is something about at that

46:20

stage in life to be told whatever you do

46:23

with these hands, whatever you do with

46:25

all this, that's where it's going to

46:26

end. That's where it's going to end.

46:28

Best case scenario, best case scenario,

46:31

it's going to be in your own home with

46:32

your family around you. Worst case

46:34

scenario, it's going to be on the street

46:36

somewhere prematurely, you know. So, I

46:39

was fascinated with death. And I I

46:42

decided I was going to go to graduate

46:44

school and I was going to study than I

46:47

was going to study death and dying. But

46:48

there really aren't any programs in

46:50

that. So I went to New York University's

46:51

Department of Culture and Communication

46:54

and I found um uh Neil Postman, Dr. Neil

46:57

Postman, who was going to be my because

47:00

NYU of back then and still gives you a

47:04

lot of opportunities to kind of create

47:05

your own curriculum. As long as it's

47:06

something serious, you know,

47:08

academically serious, and as long as you

47:09

can put together like an amalgam of

47:11

classes from different disciplines,

47:13

they'll let you put together something

47:15

very individualized. And so I put

47:17

together a a study about our the

47:21

cultural approaches we have to death and

47:23

dying. And my master's degree thesis was

47:26

called the semantics of mortality or or

47:29

I'm sorry metaphor and mortality the

47:31

semantics of death and dying. And it was

47:33

published in a journal called etc um

47:36

which is the journal of general

47:37

semantics. And it what I did is I

47:40

studied the words we use to talk about

47:42

death and what they reflect on how we

47:45

think about death. So like you know I

47:49

remember when I was a kid and our our

47:51

dog when I was a child had to be um had

47:54

to be euthanized. I remember the doctor

47:56

saying we're going to put him to sleep.

47:57

And I remember thinking no you're not.

47:59

He's going to die. He's not going to

48:01

sleep. Like I'm going to go to sleep

48:03

later. Like he's not going to go to

48:05

sleep. He's going to go to death. like

48:07

why are you calling it that? And I

48:09

understood why obviously as an adult

48:10

like it's a in a primitive culture

48:13

someone it's an eternal sleep. It looks

48:15

like I mean you're asleep you look like

48:16

your dad you know I've held a mirror

48:18

under something be like all right and I

48:21

will I understand where these med like

48:23

doctors I I explored doctors talking

48:26

about we lost the patient like what what

48:29

you don't know where he is like no you

48:31

you know what room he's in no we lost

48:33

the battle the battle against death

48:35

you're definitely going to lose that

48:36

battle like that's they death's record

48:39

is amazing death always wins like so if

48:43

you're setting it up for that battle.

48:45

Like that's a that's a bad battle.

48:48

We just don't want to confront it

48:49

though, do we? That's the essence of why

48:50

we use the words like pass on, pass,

48:52

which is fascinating to me because it is

48:54

the only certainty we have and we act as

48:59

if we are certain it's something bad

49:03

when in fact absolutely no one can say

49:06

with certainty what it is and what

49:08

happens except that it's inevitable.

49:10

Having spoke to so many people in their

49:12

final days, weeks and months and final

49:14

minutes, I'm really compelled to

49:16

understand what I can learn from them

49:18

about how I should be living my life

49:20

based on the types of things they then

49:22

say to you, focus on prioritize.

49:25

Yeah, that's it's that is true. Like you

49:28

can learn a tremendous amount from that.

49:30

And here's what I will tell you. I

49:31

learned they don't talk about death.

49:35

Like you go through this hospice

49:36

training where they're they're they're

49:38

very much preparing you to talk with

49:40

people about their fear about their

49:41

death or their imminence of their death

49:43

and all people really want to talk about

49:46

is their grandkids, their kids, their

49:49

wife, their husband, what they did for a

49:52

living and what they liked about it.

49:53

Like most of the time people talk about

49:55

like the things that made them happy.

49:58

Like I I spent a lot of time just

50:00

listening to people tell me about tell

50:02

me happy stories about their life.

50:05

telling me moments that and it made a

50:07

lot of sense to me. Like it made a lot

50:09

of sense to me. Like if I said to you

50:11

right now like what are five moments in

50:14

your life where you just felt loved and

50:17

happy like you could stop and close your

50:20

eyes and and and there'd be like and and

50:23

what a comfort it would be like to have

50:24

those. And every once in a while like

50:27

when you're in that moment you go I'm in

50:30

one of those right now. like I'm gonna

50:32

remember this moment, you know, and but

50:35

most of the time you don't like most of

50:37

the time it just happens and then you

50:39

look back and you go, "God, I remember

50:40

that kiss, you know, or remember that,

50:43

you know, that meal or remember that and

50:46

and you don't see it when it's

50:47

happening." And that for me is is what I

50:50

really learned from doing hospice work

50:52

was that like all these people wanted to

50:55

tell me about was, you know, when they

50:58

were alive, like really alive, not

51:01

laying in a bed dying. Like they want to

51:03

talk about like, yeah, I did this or I

51:05

saw that. And, you know, I I learned it

51:08

in my mom's passing. I remember my last

51:10

day with my mom before she became so ill

51:13

that she was not mobile and and not not

51:15

really functional to have a discussion

51:16

with. I just remember we just sat there

51:19

and I told her about like how great my

51:21

sons were doing, her grandchildren, how

51:23

great they were doing and and I talked

51:25

about how happy I was and like just how

51:28

great life is and how great I feel. And

51:31

I just remember like she just was I

51:34

remember thinking like, "Oh, that's what

51:36

I would want." Like I would want to know

51:37

that like, "Yeah, you did it. Like you

51:40

did great. Like look at look at all this

51:42

stuff that's here because of you, you

51:44

know?" And to me, like that that's what

51:47

hospice work very much taught me was it

51:49

it it taught me that that um no one's

51:53

really going to care that much about you

51:55

know some of this stuff that seems so

51:58

important. Like it's just not

52:01

that important. like like the people

52:04

talked about their kids, they talked

52:06

about their grandkids, they talked

52:07

about, you know, the love of their life

52:10

or if they if they had survived that

52:13

love and and they, you know, they talked

52:15

about how like, oh, maybe, you know,

52:17

maybe I'm going to get to see them

52:18

again, you know, and and it's very funny

52:21

because I I remember

52:24

I remember talking to someone a few

52:26

years ago and saying something about,

52:28

"Oh, you know, I wish my mom had been

52:30

alive to see me do you know this thing

52:33

and they said oh I I you know I I bet

52:36

she's seeing it like I bet she's seeing

52:38

it from you know cuz this person was

52:39

religious and I remember thinking you

52:41

know I don't believe that but I really

52:43

hope I'm wrong

52:45

like I really hope I'm wrong that would

52:47

be amazing like that'd be wonderful it'd

52:48

be beautiful you know so I I think

52:51

hospice for me the reason why I I got

52:53

into the hospice work the reason why my

52:55

research interests became death related

52:59

um was that that Uh, I just think life

53:02

is better when you have those things in

53:06

front of you. When you when you remind

53:08

yourself of the inevitability of

53:09

endings.

53:11

We're just the imagination of ourselves.

53:13

Those are words that you said. You said

53:16

we're just the imagination of ourselves.

53:17

There's nothing to be afraid of.

53:18

Everything's connected. We're just in

53:20

one state of being now and then we'll be

53:22

in a different state of being. There's

53:24

probably a benevolent force out there.

53:25

That was something that came to me as a

53:28

function of of of um of my my

53:31

experiences with psychedelics very early

53:33

in my life is um was that realization

53:36

was the realization that everything is

53:38

connected and that there is some

53:40

benevolent something underneath all of

53:42

it and that there's nothing to be afraid

53:44

of. And I think some of that was a

53:46

function of course of of growing up in

53:48

an environment where you couldn't deny

53:50

death where it was sort of always

53:51

present. And perhaps that was on my mind

53:54

at that stage in my life when when I had

53:57

those profound experiences. But um

54:00

that's stayed with me. That's never gone

54:01

away. That's been very um very much a

54:04

part of my view of things that that um

54:09

that perhaps we are just one

54:11

consciousness experience itself

54:13

subjectively and that we we are just you

54:16

know I heard what was it Pete Holmes the

54:18

comedian recently talking about how you

54:20

know people say that like oh we came

54:22

from nothing I don't believe in God I

54:24

believe in nothing and you know he has

54:26

this whole bit about him he's like

54:27

really so like instead of believing in

54:30

God which is something that you can't

54:31

touch can't prove, can't photograph, and

54:33

science can't prove or disprove. You

54:35

believe in nothing, which is something

54:36

you can't see, touch, feel, science

54:38

can't prove or disprove. Like, so if

54:40

you're nothing just spontaneously, you

54:42

know, creates everything, that's pretty

54:44

impressive. Nothing in the scheme of

54:45

things. So I think I think that I am

54:48

very much a believer in the fact I like

54:50

to believe whatever the name of it is

54:53

whatever we want to call it having spent

54:56

a lot of time with hospice patients and

54:57

having thought a lot about death

55:00

I I'd like to think that we you know we

55:04

are drops of water and that when we die

55:06

we return to the sea that we just merge

55:08

with our creator again. And I'm not I'm

55:12

not really worried that Jim stops

55:14

existing like cuz I don't remember what

55:19

I was before Jim. So I have no reason to

55:22

think it was something terrible and I

55:25

don't know what I'll be after I'm Jim.

55:27

But I have no reason to think it's going

55:28

to be something terrible. It could just

55:30

as easily be it's going to be something

55:32

fantastic and that I'm going to get

55:34

there and go, "What? What? Why didn't I

55:36

get here sooner?" you know, and if there

55:38

was a god, then he might greet me and be

55:39

like, "Yeah, why are you guys so fixated

55:41

on not getting here? It's awesome." You

55:43

know, like that temporary thing, like

55:45

there's a reason why as an organism

55:47

you're supposed to just there's all

55:49

these things that'll kill you. Like it's

55:51

supposed to be that that happens sooner

55:52

rather than later. But like that's it's

55:54

a very uncomfortable thought. Like it's

55:58

an uncomfortable thought that like this

56:00

might be hell or this might be the part

56:04

that we should be afraid of. Like this

56:07

might be the part that's really hard.

56:10

Like maybe what's before it and what's

56:11

after it's really the easy part and

56:14

what's happening here is what's

56:16

challenging. Like when someone dies.

56:20

I've always thought to myself like when

56:22

someone dies like the people who suffer

56:24

are the living. Like the person who's

56:27

passed they're gone now. That's why I

56:29

never believed in the death penalty

56:31

because they were like we're going to

56:32

punish this person by they're going to

56:34

die. I'm like, well, my grandmother

56:36

died. I I didn't like to think that it

56:37

was a punishment. Like, put them in a

56:40

box, feed them terrible food. That that

56:43

sounds like a punishment, you know,

56:44

like, you know, make them watch bad TV.

56:46

I don't know, something. But death,

56:49

like, death to me doesn't I don't like

56:50

to think of death as a punishment. I I I

56:53

I'm enjoying this ride and I'm enjoying

56:56

this body and I'm enjoying all of this,

56:58

but I'm not terrified of that. I'm

57:00

genuinely curious. I'm genuinely

57:03

curious. And when the time comes, I want

57:06

to face it with open with, you know,

57:08

clean hands and an open heart.

57:10

Where does acceptance play in dealing

57:14

with an ending? Like how important is it

57:16

to accept? And when you when you meet

57:18

your clients as a divorce lawyer now, is

57:22

part of the suffering the resistance to

57:25

accept the situation?

57:26

Yes. even if it you it wasn't your fault

57:28

because you know this is sometimes

57:30

people conflate this idea of acceptance

57:32

with like you know justification I'm not

57:35

saying justification I'm saying accept

57:36

this is the situation you find yourself

57:38

in

57:38

yeah I I think that's very very astute

57:41

and very real I think there's a step

57:44

before acceptance there's a number of

57:46

steps before acceptance but but the

57:47

first one is acknowledgement like I

57:50

think you have to acknowledge that

57:51

something is happening before you can

57:54

start because acceptance has to do with

57:55

adjusting your emotional state and

57:57

reaction to it. Changing the level of

57:59

tension in your body about it. You know,

58:01

like every time I've ever gone to the

58:03

dentist, you know, there's this part of

58:05

me it's like, "Oh, here it comes. Oh

58:06

god, here it comes. This is going to

58:07

hurt. Here it comes." You know, and it's

58:08

like I'm ready. I'm bracing. I'm

58:10

bracing. And And I have to remind myself

58:12

like, "Wait, stop. Don't do that."

58:15

Yeah. Stop. Soften. Soften. Soften over

58:18

and over. Soften. It's one of the

58:20

reasons I love Brazilian jiu-jitsu

58:22

because when you're a white belt in

58:23

Brazilian jiu-jitsu, everything is like

58:26

resisting everything, you know, trying

58:27

to stop everything and and then you you

58:30

start to learn like, oh, no, no, no,

58:32

like soften, like yield, like just, you

58:34

know, protect the neck, move the hand.

58:36

Okay, go ahead. Try and choke me. Like,

58:38

you're not going to do it. Like, and and

58:40

there's something about that like not

58:43

trying to resist the thing, but

58:45

trust what you were saying there about

58:47

trust. trust in how natural something

58:49

is. But it's acknowledging first, okay,

58:52

here is the reality of my situation.

58:54

This marriage is ending. Like there

58:56

there's a there's a a a

58:59

Zen parable or saying I heard many years

59:03

ago, which is

59:05

if you don't learn to find joy in the

59:07

snow, you will have less joy in your

59:11

life and precisely the same amount of

59:13

snow.

59:17

reality is reality. Like I I broke my

59:21

favorite teacup. I can be happy about

59:24

that. I can be angry about that. I can

59:27

be sad about that. Either way, my teacup

59:29

is gone. It's gone. That's it. Like, and

59:32

so I think that the acceptance piece

59:37

first requires, okay, my life is finite.

59:41

My life is finite. My marriage

59:44

is not permanently gifted to me. Love is

59:47

not permanently gifted. It is loaned.

59:50

Whether it's the life of my my life, the

59:53

love of my dog, the love of my romantic

59:56

partner, the love of my children, it is

59:58

on loan to me. It is not permanently

60:00

gifted. So that's just acknowledgment

60:02

first. then it's not pulling from that

60:07

yielding from like it's it's about

60:08

softening softening and realizing that

60:11

okay so now what do I do with this like

60:13

what do I do you know there's something

60:15

about

60:18

my my therapist once said to me we were

60:20

talking about um

60:23

we were talking about like resisting

60:25

change in life I was going through a

60:27

transition in life and and I was having

60:29

a hard time with it and he said you know

60:33

Uh he said you're very curious. He said

60:35

you

60:37

you try to like swim against the current

60:41

and it's not going to work

60:44

or you just let go and let yourself go

60:46

with the current and that's not going to

60:48

work. So you try to like I'm going to be

60:51

the ocean and that doesn't work. He's

60:54

like surf.

60:56

He's like surf. He's like surfing is

60:58

kind of the perfect balance. like you're

61:01

not trying to fight the wave. You're

61:04

trying to take it where it's going to

61:05

take you, but you're going to impose

61:08

yourself on the process a little. You're

61:10

going to use technique, patience, you're

61:12

going to use your body, and you're going

61:14

to try to just see because there's an

61:16

element in surfing, just like in

61:18

jiu-jitsu, just like in so many things

61:20

in life, of like yielding, but also

61:23

maintaining an active role, right? And I

61:25

think that is in the demise of a

61:29

relationship or the loss of someone

61:32

because of death or again any transition

61:36

any ending. First it's about

61:38

acknowledging the reality of what we had

61:41

what we were you know what our health

61:43

was whatever it might be and then saying

61:46

okay and now this has changed and I can

61:49

resist it or I can yield to it. I can

61:52

accept that this is what's happened. It

61:53

is snowing. My teacup is broken.

61:55

Whatever it is. And then

61:59

you can see what's next because again,

62:01

we don't know what's next. We don't know

62:03

what that will lead to. Like some of the

62:05

worst things, some of the moments in my

62:07

life where I went, "Oh my god, I'm never

62:09

getting through this gave way to some of

62:11

the greatest moments in my life." Like

62:13

just when the just when the caterpillar

62:15

thought its life was ending, it became a

62:17

butterfly. You know, but it had the

62:20

world had to end. Like imagine being the

62:23

bird in the egg. You know, you've been

62:26

warm and happy. Imagine being in the

62:29

womb. Like you're warm, you're happy,

62:31

everything's being fed to you. It's like

62:33

lovely. You're just buoyant and floating

62:35

around. And now if you're that bird, you

62:38

got to break through a shell and get

62:40

into this cold weird world. You don't

62:42

know how your wings work yet. Or if

62:43

you're a baby, it's like all blood and

62:45

screaming. But you got to do that to get

62:48

to the next thing. And the next thing is

62:50

beautiful. Like the bird only gets to

62:52

fly because it broke through the egg.

62:54

And it only broke through the egg

62:55

because it was brave enough to destroy

62:58

the only world it's ever known. And

63:00

that's how I look at divorce in some

63:02

ways is that divorce is like this whole

63:05

whether I'm the one ending it or my

63:07

partner is the one ending it. Like

63:10

something is ending that I never thought

63:12

was going to end and it's done. And now

63:14

what? I don't know. I don't know what.

63:16

But I have no reason to think it's going

63:18

to be horrifying. It might be incredibly

63:20

beautiful, but it's it's the road ahead

63:22

of me now. And and that to me, there's

63:25

something very beautiful about that

63:27

level of acceptance,

63:28

but the lights are off.

63:30

The lights are off on that road. It's a

63:32

it's a road with no street lamps. And

63:34

that's what the uncertainty of

63:36

Yeah, it's scary.

63:37

It's scary, right? We humans are

63:39

particularly bad with dealing with

63:40

uncertainty. I learned this when I when

63:41

I studied um Uber Labs, which is this

63:43

laboratory they had at Uber to figure

63:45

out how to build the perfect taxi app.

63:46

And they discovered that much of the

63:48

reason why we love Uber is it cuz it

63:49

kills the uncertainty that we used to

63:51

have when we called the taxi on the

63:52

phone and then we had to stand there for

63:54

seven or maybe 17 minutes

63:56

hoping that it was coming. And it's the

63:58

same analogy you might find if you know

64:00

you go to an airport and it says flight

64:01

is delayed. Now flight delayed is much

64:04

worse than flight delayed 2 hours

64:05

because I can work with that.

64:07

But flight delayed

64:09

Yeah.

64:09

with no certainty around how long I'm

64:11

going to be stood in this airport for is

64:13

like mental torture. And it's the same.

64:15

And the truth is there is something I'm

64:17

I'm not look I'm not polyiana about it

64:19

like there is something terribly

64:22

frustrating upsetting difficult about

64:24

your flight being delayed or your flight

64:26

being cancelled for example but I in

64:30

Frankfurt Germany

64:33

I had the I think it's the best meal of

64:36

my entire life at a little tiny

64:38

restaurant.

64:40

I only had that meal because I was

64:43

flying back from Poland and had a stop

64:47

in Frankfurt that was supposed to be for

64:50

one hour and because of snow they

64:52

canceled all the flights to essentially

64:54

to the United States and I was stuck in

64:56

Frankfurt for the night. Now I I

65:00

certainly had a few moments of like are

65:02

you kidding me? Like I have work, I have

65:04

this, I have that. But then something in

65:06

me went, okay, like you can be upset

65:09

about this all you want, man, but it

65:10

ain't gonna make the flights happen and

65:12

you can't walk home from Frankfurt, so

65:15

what are you gonna do? You've not been

65:16

in Frankfurt before. See what happens.

65:20

And I walked around Frankfurt and I

65:22

found this amazing little restaurant and

65:25

it was I think still to this day the

65:27

best meal I've ever had in my life. And

65:29

I've gone back to Frankfurt three times

65:31

just to eat at that restaurant. And I

65:33

the hotel that I found because I was

65:36

like, "All right, I need a room. I need

65:38

to get a room somewhere." Turned out

65:39

became one of my favorite hotels and I

65:41

stayed there several times. So, you

65:43

know, again, if you'd said to me in

65:44

advance, Jim, would it be awful if you

65:48

got stuck in Frankfurt? I would be like,

65:49

"Oh my god, that would be so bad. I have

65:51

a quarter appearance tomorrow and I have

65:53

this to do and I have that to do." My

65:55

life would have been so much poorer if I

65:57

hadn't gotten stuck in Frankfurt. I had

65:59

like four amazing trips and a bunch of

66:02

amazing meals and all these incredible

66:04

experiences because one time my flight

66:07

got cancelled because of snow. And I

66:10

tell you something, I I'm really really

66:12

glad that flight got cancelled. I wasn't

66:14

at the time. At the time it was very

66:15

frustrating. I'd call my assistant in

66:17

the middle of night and be like, "All

66:18

right, you got to cancel all my stuff.

66:19

You got to reset." But the truth is like

66:21

you just don't know. You just don't

66:22

know. You won't know. You won't know

66:24

until you're sitting ideally in a bed

66:27

and there's a hospice volunteer sitting

66:29

next to you and you're telling them all

66:31

about the amazing meal that you had in

66:33

Frankfurt that one time, not you know my

66:36

flight got delayed once.

66:40

You said earlier at the start of this

66:42

conversation, no one intends to end up

66:44

in the consultation room um with a

66:46

divorce lawyer. But I wondered when you

66:48

said that, I thought, do you know what?

66:49

I bet you've met someone in your life

66:51

that did intend to end up there. I

66:54

someone that got married because they

66:57

wanted the divorce.

66:58

Yeah. Yeah. I'm sure I I I have met So,

67:02

I've met people because I'm in in the

67:04

high net worth and ultra high net worth

67:06

space. High net worth we define as like

67:08

10 to a few hundred million and ultra

67:11

high net worth is like 500 million and

67:13

up

67:16

in in those spaces. Yeah. There's a

67:19

there's there certainly are people that

67:21

get married

67:23

to a wealthy person for what will be

67:27

great financial benefit,

67:29

but a lot of them are not planning on

67:32

cashing the chips out necessarily. They

67:34

see it as a possibility,

67:36

but they more often are like, "Oh, no.

67:39

I'd like to ride this ride as long as

67:40

possible because the amount of money I'm

67:43

going to have access to with this person

67:46

is much greater than even if I divorce

67:48

and take some of their things. So, um

67:51

that that is certainly I I would the

67:54

overwhelming majority of people like

67:57

99.999%

67:59

of my of clients I have met in a 25-y

68:02

year career did not mean to get

68:04

divorced. They they they move towards

68:07

divorce and eventually many of them go,

68:09

"Oh yeah, this I saw early on we were

68:12

doomed." But you know, love is so

68:15

intoxicating. We fall in love so fast,

68:17

you know, and we really do like have a

68:20

tendency to in the early days like we we

68:23

tend to just be so forgiving of a

68:24

person. I mean, thank God that passes to

68:26

some degree. Could you imagine like

68:28

that? You know when you first are with

68:30

your romantic partner like they brush up

68:32

against you and it's like electric that

68:34

feeling you know because you we couldn't

68:36

what would we as a world get stuff done

68:38

if we felt like that forever about our

68:40

romantic partner if 10 years into the

68:42

relationship when your partner brushed

68:43

up next to you at the sink you went like

68:45

oh god YOU WOULDN'T GET ANYTHING DONE

68:47

like you wouldn't get anything done you

68:48

we would be a very unproductive world so

68:51

thankfully that fades and changes I I

68:54

hope it never goes completely away for

68:56

for any couple but It becomes

68:59

manageable. You start to see this person

69:01

a little more clearly. Hopefully still

69:03

with tremendous optimism.

69:04

What's the quickest marriage you've ever

69:06

represented?

69:06

Quickest marriage and divorce. Marriage

69:08

72 hours.

69:09

From marriage to divorce.

69:10

From marriage to divorce.

69:12

Yes. Marriage to marriage to anulment in

69:14

that situation. But I've I've seen

69:17

divorces that were 72 hours.

69:19

Were they drunk? What was the

69:20

Yeah, it was in one it was that they

69:22

were drunk. In one it was um I don't

69:27

know how to put it. It was almost like a

69:29

It was almost like a game of chicken

69:31

that went too far. Like they were they

69:33

had just sort of started dating and one

69:36

of them was like, "I bet you wouldn't

69:38

get my name tattooed on you." And

69:39

they're like, "Oh, yeah." And then they

69:40

went and got their name tattooed on each

69:42

other. And then they were like, "Well, I

69:44

bet we I wouldn't I like you, so I'd get

69:46

an engagement ring." And then they went

69:47

and got an engagement ring, and they

69:48

were like, "Oh, yeah. Well, I would I

69:49

you know, would you marry me?" And then

69:50

they got married. And then I think like

69:52

they probably had a great night. Like

69:54

that night was probably that might have

69:56

been some mindbending sex, but then two

69:59

days later they were like, "Wait, you

70:01

know, do you you don't actually want to

70:02

have kids?" Oh, because I do. And like,

70:04

oh, you're you know, like and they

70:05

realize they were just fundamentally

70:06

incompatible people.

70:08

Have you seen any patterns there with

70:09

compatibility then? If if a couple walks

70:11

in and they've been together for I guess

70:14

when you look back at the types of

70:15

people you've represented

70:18

um is there a certain length of

70:21

engagement and boyfriend girlfriend

70:23

phase that is typically conducive with

70:25

it working or not working?

70:26

No, I don't see that pattern. I I'm

70:28

constantly I'm very fixated on pattern

70:31

recognition. So I'm constantly thinking

70:33

I'm always looking at same religion

70:35

different religions or religious versus

70:37

non-religious or older and younger older

70:40

man younger woman younger man older

70:42

woman like what what permutation same

70:44

culture different culture same races

70:46

different races like first generation to

70:49

the US or you know both first generation

70:52

or neither

70:54

um I I don't I don't see those patterns

70:57

I really I I if I did I'd be the first

71:00

to say it you know I don't hesitate hate

71:01

to say stuff, but I I've not seen those

71:04

patterns. I I have found if I was to say

71:08

there was any any pattern, it it it

71:14

really is um

71:16

I I think substance use is probably the

71:19

main thing like that if if one or both

71:21

people are big drinkers or drug users,

71:27

that's usually a good indication that

71:29

the marriage is going to lead to divorce

71:31

because substance use issues tend to get

71:36

worse in either both people, which

71:38

causes all kinds of second order

71:40

effects, or more commonly, one person

71:44

when they have kids or when they reach a

71:47

slightly different stage in life

71:50

scales back on alcohol or drug use and

71:54

the other person has an unhealthy

71:56

relationship with the substances and it

71:59

gets further down and that's the

72:01

direction that it goes in. I had um you

72:02

said something earlier which really piqu

72:04

my interest as well which kind of

72:04

relates to this is you said love is

72:06

loaned and I I immediately thought of a

72:09

friend who who brought me to a

72:10

restaurant one day to basically tell me

72:12

that him and his um wife were being

72:15

divorced and the way they described it

72:17

was quite heartbreaking because

72:20

it seemed like they had a good

72:21

relationship. It's kind of like they got

72:23

busy with their jobs and the kid and

72:26

they forgot to water the plant.

72:28

Yeah.

72:28

It's like the only way I can describe it

72:29

because they were like good people. They

72:31

didn't really appear to argue at all.

72:33

They had this kid. They're both CEOs.

72:35

She's a CEO. He's a CEO.

72:36

And it's like they like raised the kid

72:38

and forgot to water the relationship.

72:40

Yeah. Yeah. I I've I've always phrased

72:43

that as they lost the plot. Like that

72:46

they were because when you get married,

72:48

you're trying to write a story together

72:50

and sometimes I think you lose the plot.

72:52

Like you know when you're reading

72:54

and like all of a sudden you stop and

72:55

you go, I don't really remember where I

72:58

am in this. like and you got to go back

72:59

a few pages, you know, to like, oh,

73:01

okay, I remember this part. Let me start

73:03

there.

73:04

I think sometimes we lose the plot. And

73:06

I and when we I think that happens in

73:08

every relationship, every long-term

73:09

relationship, I think sometimes you lose

73:10

the plot. Like other things are going on

73:12

at work or you have kids and and kids

73:14

require a tremendous amount of your

73:15

bandwidth. So, I I get it. But I think

73:18

if you lose the plot, that's where it

73:22

it's like hard to it's a it's again

73:25

acknowledgment of it, like awareness,

73:28

truth, being honest, and saying, "Hey, I

73:30

feel like we lost the plot." Like I feel

73:32

like there's, you know, we lost the

73:33

plot. How do we get it back? Like how

73:35

But but the problem is

73:38

when you say to your partner, "Hey, I I

73:41

feel like we kind of lost the plot."

73:44

rather than hearing that as, "Hey, this

73:47

is really important to me. You're really

73:50

important to me. Yeah, work's important.

73:52

Kids important, but you and me, you and

73:55

me, that's really important." Like, it's

73:56

equally, if not more important. So, I

74:00

feel a certain way. I I feel like we've

74:02

lost the plot. And And I'm not saying

74:04

that's your fault. I'm not saying it's

74:05

my fault. I'm saying it's the kids'

74:06

fault. I don't know whose fault it is. I

74:07

don't really care. But I don't want to

74:09

lose the plot because I care about you

74:10

and I and this plot, this story is

74:12

important to me. People don't hear it

74:14

that way. People hear it as we lost the

74:15

plot. Well, what do you want me to do

74:17

about it? Like I, you know, oh, okay, so

74:19

I'll just ignore the kid. What do you

74:20

What What do you want? I'm sorry. I'm

74:22

doing the best I can. And that's like

74:26

that's not the way to hear that. I I

74:28

understand. I think it's very human to

74:29

hear it that way. But I genuinely

74:33

believe that that, you know, yeah, it's

74:35

like you forgot to water the plant.

74:36

Like, and nobody meant to kill the

74:38

plant, but you kill the plant because

74:39

you weren't thinking about the plant.

74:40

And by the way, plant's right there. YOU

74:43

WALK PAST it every single day. You just

74:46

not once thought, "Oh yeah, I got to

74:48

remember to water the plant." And so I

74:50

think it's very easy in marriage, in

74:52

long-term relationships, it's very easy

74:54

to just forget that this is you're

74:58

borrowing this, you know, this is not

75:00

yours. Like this person's not yours.

75:03

This person is loaned to you. And it's,

75:06

by the way, it's the same with death.

75:09

Like this person is loaned to you. They

75:10

could be taken away.

75:12

By divorce or by death, they could be

75:14

taken away. Every marriage will end in

75:16

one of those two things. Death or

75:17

divorce. For sure.

75:18

You've used this word slippage before.

75:20

Yeah.

75:20

When does it happen and what does

75:22

slippage mean?

75:24

I mean, slippage is everyone understands

75:26

slippage, I think. Like it's not like

75:28

you eat cake and then the next day your

75:30

suit doesn't fit. Like you just make

75:32

lots of little choices and those little

75:35

choices add up and all of a sudden your

75:36

suit doesn't fit and you go, "Wait, when

75:38

did that happen?" You know? And I think

75:39

it's the same thing in relationships.

75:40

Like we You know, Ernest Hemingway said

75:43

in um The Sun Also Rises,

75:46

um I I went bankrupt the same way

75:48

anybody does. Very slowly and then all

75:50

at once. And I think that's how that's

75:53

slippage. Like it's just little

75:55

raindrops that eventually become the

75:57

flood. And and I think that's what

75:59

happens in relationships is you you

76:02

start to with good intentions,

76:05

you're focused on other things. Maybe

76:07

you start to go, "Hey, I got this." Like

76:09

cuz you know when you were single,

76:11

finding the one was big. That was big.

76:15

That was a big priority in your life.

76:18

And then you found them. And then

76:19

there's like a whole bunch of just

76:21

high-fiving and celebration. And it's

76:22

like, oh, this is so great. I FOUND THE

76:24

ONE. YOU FOUND YOU WANTED THE ONE, TOO.

76:25

AND YOU FOUND IT. IT'S ME. IS this

76:26

great? And then you go, "All right, we

76:29

got that. Now what other stuff, you

76:31

know, what other stuff can we do?"

76:32

Because now like I'm supercharged. I got

76:34

you. You got me. We're gonna do this

76:36

thing. And you go and what do you do?

76:37

make new life or you make careers or you

76:40

go amazing places LIKE YOU'RE DO IT'S

76:42

NOT ENOUGH IT'S NOT enough to just go we

76:44

got each other and it's so fun and let's

76:45

just tuck in here and just stay together

76:48

you know and I I always laugh with

76:50

friends by the way because I can always

76:52

tell when someone's like in love because

76:54

they put on a couple of pounds you know

76:56

cuz they really do because they're just

76:58

they just go like do I want to like get

77:00

up and go to the gym or do you go want

77:01

like sit on the couch and eat popcorn

77:02

and watch something yeah let's do that

77:04

you know and it's just sort of like you

77:05

know you're just so it's love weight

77:06

it's happy love weight. And I I love

77:09

when I see it on somebody. Like it looks

77:10

good on everybody, you know? Much better

77:14

than like if you believe me, like if you

77:15

look at photos of me from when I had an

77:17

eight pack, it was the most miserable

77:18

time in my life cuz I'm at the gym just

77:20

trying to beat the pain out of me, you

77:22

know? So I I I think it's very very

77:26

normal that people in that heaviness of

77:30

that. Okay. So when that fades and now

77:32

we're like in a sustainable pattern of a

77:34

relationship and you're focusing on

77:36

other things, little tiny things start

77:39

to, you know, and you don't want to make

77:41

a thing of it. You don't want to say

77:43

like, "Oh, by the way, calling a foul

77:44

here, throwing a flag on that play." No,

77:46

you just sort of go like, "Oh, no. It's

77:47

it's just a little thing. It's not a big

77:49

thing. Don't worry about it." And I

77:50

think that's the that is how the process

77:53

begins and it leads right to my office

77:56

someday.

77:57

Jordan Peterson said something to me.

77:58

Jack, have you got my phone? Yeah,

78:00

I just wanted to play you this um 30

78:03

seconds of something he said.

78:05

Everybody keeps telling me I have to

78:06

have a conversation with Jordan

78:07

Peterson. This

78:07

it would be fascinating.

78:08

I imagine two people are telling him the

78:10

same thing, which is

78:11

my friend is um going through some

78:14

difficulties in his relationship and I

78:15

sent him this little clip which I

78:17

honestly I keep this clip saved in my

78:19

phone. I have to send it to so many of

78:20

my male friends.

78:22

But this is what Jordan says and it

78:23

relates to slippage.

78:25

Here's something to understand about

78:27

your marriage. Okay, you are going to

78:29

have to listen to your wife 90 minutes a

78:30

week. Okay, and you might as well just

78:33

get that through your thick skull. Now,

78:36

why? If you listen to her enough, you

78:38

can make peace and you can play. So,

78:40

there's a huge benefit. If you don't

78:43

listen to her, that will accumulate

78:47

and you'll listen to her in divorce

78:48

court.

78:49

Someone sent me that. I don't think it

78:52

was you. Someone sent me that. So, yeah.

78:55

Yeah, I mean I think that's a piece of

78:56

what I'm talking about for sure. It

78:59

feels a little like the advice last time

79:01

I was on I was saying I I found

79:03

offensive which is happy wife, happy

79:04

life. Like I think there's this sense of

79:06

like well what a man has to do is just

79:08

sort of tolerate the like listen I I

79:12

don't think most men like don't want to

79:16

listen to their wife for 90 because that

79:18

impo that seems to me and I know he's

79:20

being hyperblock and I love Jordan's

79:21

work and I I I find him fascinating and

79:23

I really enjoy him but when when someone

79:27

says to me like oh you have to listen to

79:29

your wife for 90 minutes a week like

79:30

that feels like you're going to sit

79:32

there and be like how many more minutes

79:34

do I have to do was for, you know, there

79:36

was a time where you couldn't wait to

79:38

hear her. Like she was interesting and

79:41

she was interested. But do you think the

79:44

women that are listening to this right

79:45

now that have husbands and boyfriends

79:47

Yeah.

79:48

think they their husband and boyfriend

79:50

likes it when they said, "Hey, hey, hey,

79:51

we need to talk about something."

79:53

But see who when in your life has

79:56

someone saying that to you been a

79:58

precursor to something good? Hey, we

80:00

need to talk about something THAT THAT

80:01

NEVER THAT'S LIKE, you know, is this

80:03

siren A GOOD SIREN? WHEN is this siren

80:05

ever good? Like there's certain phrases

80:08

we really need to have a conversation.

80:10

That is not a good entry point. And

80:13

that's not because it means there's

80:14

something wrong. But before you get to

80:17

that, like how many women,

80:20

you know, would say that that, you know,

80:22

in the interaction with their spouse,

80:25

like they don't want like a let's have a

80:27

90 minutes in the penalty box where you

80:29

have to listen to me talk to you. Like

80:30

that seems terrible. You know, the the

80:32

thought of of of having to do that as

80:36

like a practice sounds sort of like, all

80:38

right, well, if I endure that for 90

80:40

minutes, the the bonus is I get sex or

80:42

something like, and that seems crazy to

80:44

me.

80:44

As a divorce lawyer,

80:45

if you think about the divorces you've

80:47

um seen in court and you've sort of

80:49

consult consulted on, etc., Do you

80:52

believe that if that couple had spent 90

80:54

minutes a week, sat down openly being

80:57

honest with each other, they would have

80:58

ended up in your consultation room?

81:02

I think if they'd made a practice like

81:04

that as something deliberate, I I mean,

81:06

maybe it would make a difference. I I

81:08

think what's more important than the the

81:11

structure of a ritual and the the time I

81:14

I have a better practice than that. I

81:17

have um so I have a chapter in the book

81:20

called hit send now where I talk about

81:24

sharing with your partner kind of

81:26

promptly when something has rattled you

81:29

the wrong way without saying we need to

81:31

talk like just giving like and I I

81:33

suggest people do it via email so that

81:35

it's like you can say to your partner

81:38

like hey listen like I want you to

81:39

reflect on this like you don't have to

81:41

answer right away you don't have to be

81:42

defensive and also you can be careful

81:44

about how you parse it because not

81:46

everybody's is very sure-footed in their

81:47

speech, right? So, sometimes people if

81:49

you just try to do it face to face,

81:50

sometimes it's not going to come out

81:51

clearly. So, if you're writing, you can

81:53

edit it. You can be careful with it. But

81:55

I I genuinely think sometimes people

81:59

just need to check in in a relationship.

82:03

And by the way, you have to if you want

82:05

that, you also have to be willing to

82:07

accept that in your direction, right? So

82:11

I have a friend I have a a friend who

82:13

read my book and he was a friend who

82:15

actually then read my book and he said

82:17

that he and his wife go for a walk once

82:20

a week and they make a deliberate

82:24

practice during that walk of sharing

82:26

with each other one or two or three

82:29

things that the person

82:32

didn't do perfectly in the relationship

82:35

that week. and they hear it with love.

82:38

Like they deliberately from the

82:39

beginning go, we're hearing this with

82:40

love. We're hearing this as a practice.

82:42

It's a deliberate practice because our

82:44

goal is to have a great relationship and

82:47

keep it great. So, we're going to hear

82:49

it that way. We're not going to hear it

82:50

as a criticism. We're going to hear it

82:51

as I love this relationship enough to be

82:53

honest with you. I want you to have, you

82:55

know, I'd rather you have an

82:57

uncomfortable truth than a comfortable

82:58

lie. I'd rather not have resentment

83:00

buildup. And then they always finish

83:03

that walk with three things that the

83:06

person did that made them feel loved or

83:08

feel good or what. And that's so you're

83:10

ending on that positive note. And they

83:12

said they've never had a week where they

83:14

didn't come up with something.

83:15

That happy wife, happy life phrase.

83:18

There must be a reason why it became

83:20

cliche, why it became popular. Well, it

83:23

became popular because I think so many

83:24

people were willing to accept the

83:26

unbelievably ridiculous model of

83:28

relationships that's led us to a 56%

83:30

divorce rate and probably another 20 or

83:32

30% staying together unbelievably

83:35

miserable but not wanting to give up

83:36

half their stuff. So yeah, like every

83:39

misery loves company. Like everybody is

83:41

sitting around going like, "Well,

83:42

listen, women are like that. You got to

83:45

spend 90 minutes with them. Happy wife,

83:47

happy life." Like and I I just I just

83:49

don't accept that. I don't accept that

83:51

it has to be awful.

83:54

Why is it not happy husband, happy wife,

83:56

though?

83:57

Well, in reality, it is. I think in

84:00

reality, it's happy husband and happy

84:03

wife equals happy marriage. Like,

84:05

but why did it come into culture that

84:07

that way rounded?

84:08

Because I think there's there's a

84:11

Well, I mean, my personal opinion on

84:12

this is I think men are probably easier

84:14

to please in some ways. Like,

84:16

okay,

84:17

you know, I think men are either hungry

84:18

or horny. So, like either feed us or

84:21

have sex with us. And that's kind of

84:22

we're most of the time pretty happy.

84:24

Like I don't I don't we're not you know

84:27

like which curtains should we pick out

84:28

for the house? Like we're not that

84:30

caught up in I don't know a lot of guys

84:31

caught up in that. Like when it came to

84:33

weddings like most of the guys I know

84:35

weren't when they were young men going

84:36

like what is my wedding going to be

84:38

like? I can't here's what I'm going to

84:39

do. Like it was very like is there a DJ

84:41

or a band and what will the bar have and

84:43

that's kind of what they were into. And

84:45

everything else was like cool babe

84:46

whatever you like. Like I'm excited to

84:48

see you excited. That's what matters to

84:50

me.

84:50

So men are simple.

84:51

I think men are quite simple. Yeah. And

84:53

I think women, and by the way, this is

84:54

not a criticism of men and it's not a

84:57

criticism of women. And again, it's a

84:58

generalization. I understand that. But

85:00

like women, I think, thank God, women

85:04

are much more nuanced in my experience.

85:07

It's like they they notice more

85:09

sometimes or different things like

85:11

they're like I I think men and women

85:13

bring different things to and again not

85:14

every man not every woman but like I

85:16

genuinely believe that we bring

85:18

different gifts to relationships and and

85:20

when we embrace that and by the way that

85:22

polarity when we're dating is the

85:26

greatest thing in the world. But of

85:28

course it gets challenging because this

85:31

person's not just your sexual partner

85:33

and romantic partner. They're your

85:35

roommate. They're your co-parent.

85:36

They're your travel partner. Share a

85:38

bathroom with them. Like you got like

85:40

this is a whole another thing when you

85:42

get married. The French have a saying

85:43

that you know marriage turns a lover

85:45

into a relative.

85:48

And and the truth is like not any of

85:50

like your you know your lover you have

85:53

this sort of you know it's why affairs

85:55

are so intoxicating and wonderful

85:57

because you just get the best parts.

85:59

You don't have to you don't have to you

86:01

know pick up this person's socks. You

86:03

don't have to listen to the fight they

86:04

got in with their cousin, you know. You

86:06

don't have to be like, I got to spend 90

86:08

minutes with them, you know. You can

86:09

actually, you're just getting the good

86:11

stuff, the passion, the sex, the, you

86:14

know, which again, you you can have you

86:17

we can do relationships however we

86:19

decide we want to do them. That's what's

86:20

cool about it is the two people in it is

86:23

what matters. And I think even before

86:25

social media, we were very much about,

86:28

well, how is everybody else doing it?

86:30

Because I I guess that's the right way

86:31

to do it. And so, yeah, happy wife,

86:34

happy life. It was like, listen, just

86:37

here, you know, like just just make her

86:39

happy because then she'll shut up and

86:40

you can just watch football. Like, and

86:42

it I I I mean, look, that never appealed

86:44

to me. That was never interesting to me.

86:47

I I think a lot of people absolutely buy

86:50

into that model of relationships.

86:53

What's more interesting to me than

86:56

people who've just given up, right?

86:58

people who've just said like, "Yeah, I

87:00

know the hard thing to do and the right

87:01

thing to do are the same thing, but I'm

87:02

just going to do the easy thing."

87:03

Because it's like, h what's more

87:05

interesting to me is that I think

87:07

sometimes people screw up their

87:08

relationships with completely good

87:11

intentions. And the the example I I I

87:14

give in my book about this is sex.

87:18

I think most people who've been in a

87:20

long-term relationship will say, "Yeah,

87:24

you know, the sex has become kind of

87:25

predictable." like it's become kind of

87:27

it's not as novel, you know,

87:30

and I think that happens for the

87:33

absolute best of intentions. And it

87:36

would be really lovely if we just

87:37

acknowledged that because here's why it

87:40

happens, right? You get with a person,

87:42

you're first dating, first time you, you

87:45

know, you get sexual with the person,

87:47

you throw every trick you've got at that

87:49

person, right? You do all the things

87:51

that you think they're going to like to

87:52

see what are they going to like, right?

87:54

Do they like the same stuff that other

87:56

people liked or do they like something

87:57

different or they you know what do they

87:58

do they like the same things you like

87:59

and you throw everything at it and and

88:01

and you start okay they don't like that

88:03

okay this they really like oh they make

88:04

really nice noises when I do that okay

88:06

and you start to and then what do you do

88:09

you start to get more efficient like oh

88:11

I know she doesn't like that so I'm not

88:12

going to do that but I know she likes

88:13

this so I'm going to do that a whole lot

88:15

right and she does I hope the same thing

88:17

she does the he loves it when I do this

88:18

and the sound that comes out of him when

88:20

I do that I say what do you do you play

88:22

the greatest hits you play the greatest

88:24

hits cuz why not? And by the way,

88:25

there's only so many hours in the day

88:26

and we got some stuff we got to get to.

88:28

So, let's really throw the greatest hits

88:30

at each other and we're going to have a

88:31

great time. Well, what did you just do?

88:34

You were trying to make each other

88:35

really happy and be a really good lover

88:36

to each other. But what did you just do?

88:38

You just created a routine. You just

88:40

created a routine. And here's the other

88:42

thing about humans, which we all know if

88:43

you've ever had a sexual partner for

88:44

more than six months.

88:46

Then you've noticed the patterns. And by

88:49

the way, you're thrilled with them

88:51

because you're doing the greatest hits.

88:52

Like I went to see spring scene to hear

88:53

Born to Run. That's what I'm there to

88:55

see. Like I I love it. Do the greatest

88:57

hits.

88:59

But then if they do something different,

89:01

there is some part of you that goes,

89:02

"What was that? Where did that come

89:03

from? That was we don't usually do that

89:05

or we don't do it in that order." And by

89:06

the way, sometimes that's exciting,

89:07

right? Sometimes it's like, "Yeah, let's

89:09

have sex in the laundry room. What? We

89:10

got a bed right over there." Yeah, we

89:11

always do it over there. Let's do it in

89:12

the laundry room. Like I don't know.

89:14

That's fun, right? It's fun to do

89:15

something different. Well, we get to a

89:17

place where now when we do something

89:19

different, we start to feel like we're

89:20

gonna have to have a conversation about

89:21

it because it's like, well, why did you

89:23

do that? That's a strange or sometimes

89:26

people go, why did they do that

89:28

different thing? Are they like, is it

89:29

they're watching porn? Are they cheating

89:31

on me? Where did they get that idea

89:32

from? Is that something that they want

89:34

and they want to start doing that? Is

89:35

that part of the greatest hits and I

89:36

didn't realize it? Do they not like what

89:38

I've been doing? And we start to

89:39

sabotage again with good intentions from

89:43

day one. All you wanted was to make your

89:45

partner happy and they wanted to make

89:47

you happy and look what you did. You

89:49

made a routine. So, the only way out of

89:52

that spiral

89:54

is to call it to talk about it. Call it

89:56

out to say, "Hey, you know, it feels

89:58

like things are kind of in like we're in

90:00

a you know, is there anything I could do

90:01

different or you might want different?"

90:03

And I think there's lots of ways to have

90:05

that conversation.

90:07

How do we not have that conversation?

90:08

Like, what's the worst way to have that

90:09

conversation?

90:10

The worst way to have that conversation

90:11

say, "How come you don't do this

90:12

anymore? or you used to do it all the

90:14

time or you know I've never we why won't

90:15

you ever let me this or why don't you

90:17

ever try that that's the worst way to do

90:20

it

90:20

blame

90:21

blame and also it's on you yeah why did

90:24

you do or also that it's like because

90:26

immediately the person's reaction to

90:28

that is going to be well here's why you

90:30

know because of this well because you

90:32

this you know well how come you never do

90:34

this like and it it turns into that and

90:37

I think there's a million other ways to

90:39

do it all of which are better the The

90:42

best one in my opinion, but I'm a lawyer

90:45

and I'm dishonest a lot of the time is,

90:47

you know, manipulation. I think that

90:49

there's very positive man. I manipulate

90:51

people's emotional state for a living,

90:53

right? Like that's my job is to make the

90:54

other side scared, my client feels safe,

90:56

the judge feel good about my client, bad

90:58

about the other side. So like I I try to

91:00

use my powers for good. And I think

91:02

here's a great way to use that power for

91:04

good. I think if there's something going

91:07

on in bed that you want to try or do and

91:10

you don't want to have the clinical

91:12

convers like you don't want to call an

91:13

audible in the middle of sex and just

91:15

start doing something different and have

91:16

your partner go what the heck was that?

91:18

I think a great one is oh my god the

91:21

dream I had about you last night. It

91:24

just you don't even want to know wait

91:26

what what was the dream? What what was

91:28

the dream that you had? No. No. I don't

91:29

even I don't know. It's cuz I had dairy

91:30

before bed or something. I don't know. I

91:32

I had the dirtiest dream about you. You

91:35

tell me what human being, male, female,

91:37

gay, straight, anybody isn't going to

91:39

go, "No, for real, what? What was I

91:41

doing? What were you doing? What was

91:42

it?" Then you tell them, you tell them

91:44

the thing that you'd be interested in

91:45

doing. And they go,

91:47

"It was you and your brother." And

91:49

okay,

91:51

if that's something you're looking for,

91:52

I don't know how to get I'm very

91:54

persuasive. I couldn't get you. I

91:55

couldn't give you an entry point for

91:56

that one. But if it's something that you

91:58

wanted to do, you say, "Yeah, I had this

92:00

dream and this is what happened." And

92:01

your partner may react as, "Oh, really?

92:04

Like you would like that?" And then you

92:06

can go, "Yeah, no. I mean, I don't know.

92:08

I just it was in my brain, so I don't

92:10

know. Like, it seemed weird to me, too."

92:12

And then you can back out of it without

92:13

it being a thing. Or you can go, "I

92:16

don't know. Maybe." Because if their

92:17

reaction is, "Oh, yeah. Would is that

92:18

something you'd want to do?" Be like, "I

92:20

don't know. Maybe it is subconsciously

92:22

or we tried sometimes."

92:23

How many times do people end up in

92:25

divorce court because the lights went

92:27

out in the bedroom?

92:29

I mean, how many would admit it? Or how

92:31

many is it really the case? Well,

92:32

because here's what I'll tell you. I

92:34

would say a good at least 80% of the

92:37

people that end up at my office,

92:38

infidelity was a piece of it. So, that

92:41

tells me that sex is a big piece, you

92:44

know, because most people who are in

92:45

genuinely satisfying sexual

92:47

relationships with their partner aren't

92:48

looking to have other sexual

92:50

relationships. Some people are just

92:52

addicted to sex, though. And I say this

92:54

because I got some friends who people

92:56

always think I'm like projecting and I'm

92:58

like secretly talking about myself, but

92:59

I'm actually not. I've met a wide

93:02

spectrum of individuals and their

93:03

relationship with sex varies wildly.

93:05

Some people I just think are going to

93:06

cheat forever regardless of who they're

93:08

with because they have some like trauma

93:10

related to the chase in sex. And then

93:13

some people are kind of, you know, don't

93:15

have sex at all. So on the on the end

93:17

where you've got that almost sex

93:18

addiction behavior, um I'm just

93:21

wondering if if uh I guess I guess the

93:24

question there the broader question was

93:26

about how many how much is the lights

93:28

going out in the bedroom? Does it relate

93:30

to people ending up in divorce court?

93:31

Well, I remember listening to your

93:33

conversation with Gad and uh and and him

93:36

you you asking him flat out like, "So

93:38

how much of the motivation is sex?" like

93:40

and and I think his answer was ab like a

93:43

tremendous amount of evolutionary

93:44

biology is tied to sex. Like a

93:46

tremendous amount of our motivation is

93:47

born of sex. It's about sex, food, and

93:50

not becoming food. That's like our three

93:52

primary motivators. So I think sex is

93:55

incredibly important. I also think sex

93:56

is constantly thrown into our line of

93:59

sight. So I think you can't discount

94:01

that. I mean, I think sex is on social

94:03

media on like the the amount of sex that

94:06

is put in our face constantly now is

94:11

shocking. It's shocking. I mean, compare

94:13

it. Do your grandfather has not seen as

94:15

many breasts in one lifetime as you'd

94:19

see in one visit to Instagram. Like, I

94:22

mean, there is just so much cleavage

94:23

going on. It's you just can't even. So,

94:26

I think fundamentally, like, of course,

94:27

it's being thrown in our life,

94:29

advertising everywhere. It's surrounded.

94:30

We live in a sex saturated environment.

94:32

How long have you been a divorce lawyer?

94:33

25 years.

94:34

So since that time, things like only

94:37

fans have emerged and pornography has

94:39

been become commonplace. I imagine at

94:41

the start of your career, the term

94:42

pornography probably wasn't used much in

94:44

divorce.

94:44

Hardly ever. Hardly ever.

94:46

Is it used now?

94:47

It's everywhere now. It's everywhere.

94:49

There's a lot of unique things that have

94:51

I've watched evolve in my career. um the

94:53

proliferation of revenge porn, the

94:56

number of people that have concerns

94:58

about audio, video, photographs of them,

95:02

you know, because every I mean, the

95:03

proliferation of it is also a function

95:04

of the fact that everyone has a video

95:05

camera and everyone has a has a has a a

95:08

camera, a sophisticated camera in their

95:11

hand, you know. So, there's a tremendous

95:14

amount of concern about, you know, this

95:16

person has images of me, photos of me,

95:18

tremendous amounts of um, you know,

95:21

cheating has gotten much much easier

95:24

than it used to be. I mean, the idea of

95:26

like connecting with a potential sexual

95:28

partner and also having conversations

95:30

with people we have absolutely no

95:31

business having conversations with and

95:32

having neutral entry points to get into.

95:35

So, like, you know, it used to be like

95:36

maybe you see the attractive soccer mom

95:38

at the your kid's soccer practice and

95:40

she's married and you're married, but

95:42

like if you saddled up next to her and

95:43

started talking, you're having a

95:45

conversation with a group full of

95:47

people. And if you called her on the

95:48

phone at the house, that would be weird,

95:49

right? But if you like message her or

95:51

you add her on Facebook, it's not weird

95:53

cuz our kids are on the same soccer

95:54

thing and maybe there's a Facebook group

95:56

for the soccer parents and then she

95:58

posts a picture of herself when she was

95:59

on vacation and you say, "Oh, where did

96:01

you guys stay? We were thinking about

96:02

going to Jamaica." And then she says,

96:03

"Oh, this." and you go, "Oh, you know,"

96:05

and suddenly we're having a conversation

96:06

and it's private. Nobody else is there.

96:08

We're alone in a room. So, I think it's

96:11

pretty, you know, it's become very

96:15

conducive to cheating. And it's also

96:18

become a way for there to be a

96:20

tremendous amount of evidence of

96:21

cheating that accidentally lands in the

96:23

hands of your partner. So, like I can't

96:25

tell you how many times like I know he's

96:27

passed now Steve Jobs, but like divorce

96:30

lawyers owe him a tremendous debt of

96:32

gratitude for the amount of business he

96:33

sent our way because Apple's integration

96:35

of its devices makes it incredibly

96:39

common that the text message from your

96:41

lover comes up on your kid's iPad

96:44

because you didn't realize you logged

96:45

into the same Apple ID and it comes up

96:47

on the iMessage and now your spouse is

96:49

looking at the the the text about how

96:50

great the sex was yesterday. And like I

96:53

I I'm not being funny. That's like a

96:56

once a week thing that happens in

96:58

divorce lawyers offices. And and I know

97:00

it wasn't intentional. I know he wasn't

97:02

like I'm going to mess up some

97:03

marriages. But the truth is is it, you

97:05

know, it creates an easier opportunity

97:07

for people to cheat because people can

97:09

clandestinely communicate in ways that

97:11

they used to not. And they have these

97:12

neutral entry points that lead to

97:13

something negative. And it's become

97:16

something where you get caught because

97:19

there's a tremendous evidentary trail

97:20

now. So I I think these are all, you

97:24

know, these are all factors that have

97:25

made it harder. But again, porn only

97:30

fans, like all those kinds of things.

97:32

These are just more sort of outlets for

97:35

the same, you know, it's it's like, you

97:38

know, there's a thousand restaurants and

97:39

there's only one menu, you know, and and

97:42

that's all this is is is it's all the

97:44

same stuff just in different

97:45

permutations. Like a divorce lawyer 50

97:48

years ago was dealing with some of the

97:50

exact same things. It's different

97:51

technologies. It's different, you know,

97:53

manifestations of the of the issue, but

97:56

it's it's all just heartbreak. It's all

97:58

just males and females that tried to

98:01

make it work and somehow it came apart.

98:04

Do you think marriages are good for

98:07

love? And like what's your view on

98:08

marriages? I I've been thinking

98:09

I think marriage and love have very

98:10

little to do with each other.

98:12

I'm fine with getting married. My issue

98:14

is the wedding. I'm not a big fan of

98:16

weddings. I think I don't know where

98:18

this tradition of weddings came from,

98:19

but getting like hundreds of people in a

98:21

room and doing this whole the big gaps,

98:23

the amount of time you have to wait, the

98:26

waiting three hours to be fed, the the

98:29

length of it, the fact that it's so

98:31

stressful and it causes some of my

98:33

friends I've watched like 12 to 24

98:35

months of stress and agony and

98:37

arguments, but it's like one day

98:39

and I just go I don't know.

98:41

But have you ever been to a wedding that

98:42

was non-traditional?

98:44

Yeah. I like my

98:45

and that you go, "Oh, that's cool."

98:47

It was like a party.

98:48

Yeah. And it's like them

98:49

and they took all the out.

98:50

Cuz I have to say something like I see

98:52

I'm the opposite, which is I don't

98:54

really believe in the legal institution

98:55

of marriage. I think it has almost

98:57

nothing to do with love. I think it's

98:58

largely performative. I think if people

99:00

were madly in love, they're madly in

99:01

love and they could either marry or not

99:02

get married and it's not going to change

99:03

anything except the legal status of

99:05

things.

99:06

But so I

99:08

I love But I love weddings. Oh, I love

99:10

weddings. I love them. I get mistied at

99:12

every wedding. My son just got engaged.

99:13

I can't wait. Like, it's going to be so

99:15

because I think that I think there's

99:17

something so fun about like a big group

99:20

of people all getting together and

99:22

having a party over something as noble

99:24

as two people finding each other in a

99:26

world of 8 billion people. And like I

99:28

think there's something about like a

99:29

group of people all getting up and going

99:31

like we're going to be cheering for you

99:32

and we're going to be here for you. And

99:34

like I love good food and I love like I

99:37

love being with people. Like I I think

99:39

if I think if the the first time

99:41

everybody you love is in one room as

99:43

your funeral, you're an idiot. Like I

99:45

think there's something really

99:46

beautiful. Like I I have to tell you I

99:48

um you know I got divorced many years

99:49

ago.

99:51

But I have amazing photos of my mom from

99:54

my wedding cuz it's like how many times

99:57

in your life do you put on like a fancy

99:58

dress and have your hair done and all

100:00

that stuff? And my mom lost her hair so

100:02

many times because of chemo and all

100:04

those other things. and when she passed

100:05

like she was so sick for so many years

100:07

and I was so afraid when she died that

100:09

that's how I would remember her is in

100:11

that bed sick and I have to tell you I

100:14

look at those pictures of my mom from

100:15

that wedding smiling so big and you know

100:18

with and it I'm so glad I have those

100:21

photos I'm so glad and I wouldn't have

100:22

had them if we hadn't had this stupid

100:24

party you know and I remember

100:26

deliberately saying to the DJ cuz I was

100:29

what 22 yeah I was 22 I remember saying

100:32

to the DJ do not play that stupid

100:33

chicken dance thing. Do not play that.

100:35

Like, we're not doing that stupid thing.

100:37

We're not happening. And I don't know

100:40

when it happened, but my mom must have

100:42

like gone to him and been like, "Play

100:44

the chicken dance." And he was like,

100:45

"I'm not supposed to play the chicken

100:46

dance." And she was like, "Yeah, but

100:47

you're playing the chicken dance." She

100:48

They played the chicken dance. And I

100:50

tell you something, I I will have that

100:52

memory of my mother with that doing that

100:53

stupid chicken dance in my head until I

100:55

die. And it I'm really glad I have it.

100:58

Like, I'm really glad it's there. So, I

100:59

tell you, like I I think weddings are a

101:03

blast. And I think if you're in love

101:05

with somebody and you love them so much

101:06

that you're like, "All right, we're

101:07

going to do our thing, dude. Go have a

101:09

wedding. Don't get married. Don't get

101:11

married. Have a wedding." Because

101:13

getting married and having a wedding

101:14

that you don't have anything to do with

101:15

the When have you ever gone to a wedding

101:18

and at the end of the wedding said, "Um,

101:19

I just need to see the paperwork. Could

101:21

Could you just show me the marriage

101:22

license now? I just need to make sure

101:24

before I give you the gift and before I

101:25

leave, I just want to make sure

101:26

everything was notorized properly." No.

101:28

No one did you didn't see wedding. You

101:31

don't I've never saw my parents'

101:32

marriage license. They could have made

101:33

the whole thing up. I don't know. But

101:34

have the party. Have the party. Why not

101:37

have the party? And don't have somebody

101:38

else's party. You just described

101:40

somebody else's party where you wait for

101:41

3 hours. SCREW THAT. WHY would you even

101:44

have the sit down dinner portion? The

101:45

pastor derves is the best part. So just

101:47

do that. You can do it however you want.

101:50

Like if there's a core message to my

101:52

book and to my approach to relationships

101:54

is you get to do it however you want.

101:58

You know what almost all the people in

102:00

my office have in common? They all tried

102:02

to do it a particular way that somebody

102:04

told them that's how they're supposed to

102:06

do it and it didn't work and it's got a

102:09

terrible track record. Like like the way

102:11

that most people do it fails 56% of the

102:16

time. So do it different. YOU GOT PLENTY

102:18

of room to do it different. And the only

102:21

two people that are qualified to decide

102:24

how to do it really are the two of you

102:26

out of eight billion choices. You picked

102:28

each other. throw whatever party you

102:30

want to. If your friends love you,

102:33

they're going to love that party. AND

102:35

EVEN IF THEY DON'T LOVE IT, THEY'RE

102:36

gonna go like, you know what, that was

102:37

them. That was very them. You know, it's

102:40

great. And this is really what me and my

102:42

partner kind of decided on. We talked

102:44

about having like a wedding or whatever.

102:46

And I was like, you know what I'd love

102:47

to do? And this is really inspired by

102:48

seeing so many of my friends planning

102:50

their weddings and looking very

102:51

miserable in the process and having to

102:53

basically cut back on things they loved

102:55

in their life because they're saving.

102:57

They're saving for the wedding in two

102:58

years time. So, they can't go out on

103:00

Friday evening. They they're going to

103:01

have to cut back date night because

103:02

they've got this wedding in two years

103:03

time.

103:04

Great. Great start to a marriage.

103:05

And I and I just always think to myself,

103:07

why don't you take say if it's 100k,

103:09

let's say, that you're spending on the

103:11

wedding or if it's 10k, why don't you

103:12

just divide it in 10 and have 10 mini

103:15

parties,

103:16

right?

103:16

And invite lots of, you know, and then

103:17

you get all these memories

103:18

and you know the answer to that question

103:20

because who's that wedding for? It's not

103:22

for them. It's not for them. It's for

103:25

the audience. And the more this is this

103:27

is why we're driving a 100 miles an hour

103:30

towards a brick wall in our culture

103:32

because we are now doing it for the

103:35

audience. We're not doing it for us

103:37

anymore. And we have to live in our

103:39

skin. We have to live in our own lives.

103:41

We have to live in our own

103:42

relationships. So what we're doing for

103:44

the audience because it looks good for

103:46

the audience. Like this is why we've

103:48

become a culture with white teeth and

103:50

rotting gums because we don't actually

103:54

care what it is. is we care what it

103:56

looks like. That's why so many people

103:58

that three weeks ago were # blessed #

104:02

bestwife ever are in my office having a

104:04

consultation and are having an affair

104:06

and are have because underneath that

104:09

that air of and by the way how many

104:11

celebrities how many celebrities are

104:14

denying I have I have celebrity clients

104:16

who their their press releases their

104:19

interviews they're talking about how

104:20

happy they are. They're in my office.

104:22

were actively negotiating the

104:24

dissolution of their relationship. They

104:26

haven't lived together because they

104:28

lived in their separate homes on

104:29

separate coasts for the last year and a

104:31

half, but they show up for each other at

104:33

the red carpet and they do their thing

104:35

and then they part ways and don't talk

104:36

to each other. But why why are we

104:39

selling? Because we're selling a dream

104:40

to people. We're selling a dream. And

104:42

see what's interesting to me is I

104:44

actually think reality is prettier than

104:47

the dream. And so if why would you start

104:50

your relationship

104:52

with a a a an homage to fakeness or to

104:57

someone else's vision of things? Why not

104:59

start it with an authentic expression of

105:01

who you are to each other and how much

105:04

you mean to each other and like then the

105:06

paperwork, whatever. The paperwork's the

105:08

paperwork.

105:11

Do you have celebrity clients who are

105:14

literally in fake relationships?

105:16

Yeah, 100%. 100%. I have celebrity

105:18

clients that are in fake relationships.

105:20

I have celebrity clients that are in

105:23

financial arrangement fake

105:24

relationships.

105:25

I had this big conversation with my

105:26

friends the other day because you know

105:28

there's a couple of like big celebrity

105:30

names who've broken up um that we're

105:32

aware of and I went back through their

105:34

Instagram.

105:35

Oh yeah.

105:36

Just to see the way that they portrayed

105:37

their relation because whenever you see

105:39

a celebrity relationship it's like

105:41

perfect perfect over.

105:42

Yeah.

105:43

Well they do what I they do what I call

105:45

the Rosie O'Donnell, right? Because

105:47

Rosie O'Donnell

105:49

for years there were rumors that she was

105:51

a lesbian and she did this whole thing

105:53

about how she had a crush on Tom Cruz

105:55

and she's not a lesbian and she has a

105:56

crush on Tom Cruz and she's not a

105:58

lesbian and d and then finally one day

106:00

she's like of course I'm a lesbian.

106:01

Everyone knows I'm a lesbian. Everyone's

106:02

known that for years. And I felt like

106:04

it's like you just gas lit the whole

106:06

culture. Like and that's all celebrities

106:08

do is they just gaslight us about their

106:10

relationships. Like they they just do

106:11

the like oh we're so in love. We're so

106:13

all these vicious rumors started by

106:14

people that hate us. And meanwhile,

106:16

yeah, the whole thing's eroded. But see,

106:18

that's not a celebrity alone phenomenon.

106:21

Like, what's great about celebrities is

106:23

they have enough distance between them

106:25

that they can hide that because most of

106:28

them own a home in Miami, own a home in

106:30

LA, own a home in New York, and then

106:32

they have some place in Europe usually

106:34

or Italy. Like, they have enough room to

106:37

lose each other and to be okay with it

106:39

and just be like, "Yeah, we're living

106:40

our lives." They just have to be careful

106:42

about not being seen out with other

106:43

people.

106:45

I I always wonder if the public

106:48

portrayal of a perfect relationship

106:50

correlates to a bad one, if you know

106:52

what I mean. Like I think the people

106:53

that would sit on Valentine's Day,

106:56

sprinkle the rose petals, then they'd

106:58

get their puppy and their husband, and

107:00

then they'd say, "Right, can you take

107:01

that photo?" They're probably taking 20

107:03

or 30 photos. For me, in my head, I go,

107:05

people that like publicly portray a

107:07

perfect relationship. Is it is that like

107:08

a a cloak of the insecurity or is it

107:12

I think so. I mean, I think that that

107:14

and again, this is a function largely of

107:16

social media, but I think there is um

107:20

but we all sort of it works and that's

107:22

why I I think people keep doing it,

107:24

right? Is like it's there's a bad reward

107:26

system at play here. But like I I so I

107:29

live in Manhattan and I live um right

107:33

near and my office is right near the

107:35

vessel and the vessel is this amazing

107:37

beautiful sculpture in in Manhattan in

107:39

uh in in the West Chelsea and my office

107:41

actually overlooks the vessel. It's

107:43

beautiful in the Hudson Yards area. And

107:45

so people, tourists from all over come

107:47

to take a picture by the vessel.

107:49

And so every time I'm walking to and

107:51

from the office, I pass the vessel. And

107:54

I there are always at least a hundred

107:56

people taking pictures by the vessel.

107:58

And I find it absolutely hilarious

108:02

because one of the things you see all

108:03

the time, and it's usually women, but

108:06

men sometimes are guilty of it, is the

108:09

photo of the person pretending that

108:12

they're not having their photo taken.

108:13

So, it's like they're just sort of

108:15

standing there like this or like they

108:17

look over this way and their friend is

108:18

taking the picture from over here. And I

108:20

think to myself, when you post that,

108:23

yeah,

108:24

what are who took that picture? Or is it

108:26

are we to believe that the paparazzi

108:28

were following you? Like you're you're

108:30

just a regular person like there's like

108:32

so clearly you set this up. But here's

108:34

the thing like the thing about us as

108:36

humans is I don't know that we look at

108:38

that photo and go what is what is that?

108:41

Like I mean look at like high we just

108:44

like look at high fashion photos in like

108:46

any magazine Vogue L things like that.

108:49

Look at the position of people's bodies

108:52

like oh that seriously pause this

108:54

whatever you're doing and look do that

108:56

like

108:57

then pause it

108:58

bizarre no one sits you know again

109:00

visually looks good I get it maybe it

109:03

makes the clothes look a certain way no

109:05

one sits like that

109:06

so the thing of like the rose petals and

109:09

the

109:10

like who does that really if they're

109:12

doing it are they doing it because they

109:14

think that's what you're supposed to do

109:15

cuz they saw it right all those rose

109:18

petals All those performative, we're

109:20

madly in love. Look at how in love we

109:21

are. Look guys, quick. Look at how love

109:23

look at how in love we are. It's shower

109:25

sex. It's It looks good, but all you're

109:28

really doing is just putting on a show.

109:30

And that show leads you right to my

109:32

office.

109:32

And the reason we like the show is

109:34

because we want to believe in the fairy

109:36

tale. We because if we see it in my

109:38

favorite celebrity couple, then it

109:40

almost keeps the hope alive. For me, it

109:43

it's it's the the antidote for the

109:46

statistics around divorce. It's the

109:48

antidote for the heartbreak I saw in my

109:50

home. It's the antidote for the misery I

109:52

see around me. Is look,

109:53

fairy tales exist just like Disney. And

109:56

that's why we want it.

109:57

I get that. And I think I understand why

110:00

we do that. But I think it's also like

110:03

pornography.

110:04

It's an it's a I don't want to say an

110:07

idealized version. It's a stylized

110:09

version of something people actually are

110:12

doing. But if you start to to think your

110:16

sex life is inferior because it doesn't

110:20

look like pornography,

110:22

you're you're modeling it against

110:24

something that's very unnatural and not

110:26

real and that is not indicative of what

110:29

actual sex looks like or feels like or

110:32

or how it works logistically or how

110:35

bodies work logistically. So you're

110:38

you're we're we're getting educated the

110:40

wrong ways. And it's again not to tie

110:43

you know go from like marriage to sex to

110:44

death but it's the same problem I had in

110:47

my master's thesis. It really was like

110:49

we convince what we always we shield

110:52

people from death. We hide it from

110:55

people. Like if someone if I said my

110:58

grandmother's dying I want to take my

110:59

kids to sea. You'd be like what kind of

111:02

sick bastard are you? Like if you said

111:04

oh I'm I'm going to walk around the

111:06

graveyard or I'm You don't talk about

111:08

death. You don't talk about these. Why?

111:11

Why? If these are things that are

111:13

important, if these are milestone things

111:15

in our lives, not talking about it is

111:18

not going to prevent it from happening.

111:20

So, why not talk about honestly like

111:23

what's really going on? Like I have to

111:24

tell you, you ever, you know, again, the

111:26

antidote to some of this stuff is to say

111:28

like, "Who took that picture? That's

111:29

weird." Like you didn't know they were

111:31

taking it. Oh, cuz you were looking in

111:32

the other direction. Like, why not just

111:34

start saying like, "Yeah, I'm not going

111:35

to be full of shit." I remember many

111:38

years ago. I remember like waking up in

111:40

New York City and my ex-girlfriend from

111:42

many years ago was like pissed off at me

111:45

because it was Valentine's Day and I

111:47

hadn't text her and like um told said

111:50

happy birthday to her, but I was in New

111:51

York so I was in a different time zone.

111:52

So it was 6:00 a.m. where I was where I

111:53

was. I hadn't even woken up yet. and

111:55

she'd sent me a screenshot of another

111:58

couple who were like with the with the,

112:00

you know, the rose petals and the roses

112:02

and stuff and she was infuriating

112:04

herself

112:06

based on an Instagram post she'd seen of

112:08

another couple and I was being attacked

112:10

because I wasn't meeting that standard.

112:12

Yeah. And this is why I I think we are

112:14

living in a moment where there is more

112:16

comparison than ever.

112:18

You must see that in your office, right?

112:19

I see it in my office constantly. I see

112:21

it in life constantly. But it's not

112:23

just, by the way, it's not just in the

112:25

relationship thing, though. Cuz of

112:28

course, people post their greatest hits.

112:29

People are constantly flaunting their

112:31

relationship and showing everyone their

112:33

relationship. But it's not even just

112:35

your relationship with your significant

112:36

other. It's your relationship with

112:38

yourself. If I see one more person

112:40

posting their workout routine, their

112:42

their sauna and cold plunge, the diet

112:44

routine of the, you know, their

112:46

hashtagbeast mode. If I see one more

112:48

person posting how their parenting

112:50

routine and the wonderful intricate

112:52

snacks that they make for their

112:53

children, like all day long there is an

112:56

idealized stylized version of every

112:58

single aspect of our life that is so

113:00

much better than the gag reel that we're

113:02

living.

113:04

and we're watching it and we're

113:06

comparing ourselves to it and our

113:08

partner to it and we're going, "How come

113:10

my partner doesn't look like that? They

113:12

don't look like that." Like all these

113:14

videos of the person like getting up in

113:16

THE MORNING, WHO SET up the camera? Did

113:18

someone set up a camera? Like, and and I

113:20

really feel sometimes like I'm the crazy

113:24

person going, "Guys, do you not see

113:27

this? Like, do you not see this? Do you

113:28

not see that this is what's making you

113:30

unhappy? You're unhappy with yourself.

113:33

You're unhappy with your partner. You're

113:34

unhappy with your relationship with your

113:36

partner because you're comparing it to

113:37

fiction. And and and because it's on

113:40

your phone instead of on the movie

113:43

screen, you think it's real. Sometimes

113:46

comparison can wake us up to things that

113:48

we needed to know, though. And I think

113:49

your the story of you going to the theme

113:52

park that day, which I was reading

113:53

about, and seeing that couple who

113:56

were pretty idyllic

113:58

Yeah.

113:58

highlighted to you that maybe this

114:00

wasn't the right. They just had their

114:01

20th wedding anniversary last week.

114:03

Yeah. Yeah.

114:04

What happened? So, you were at a theme

114:05

park with them.

114:06

So, I was with my ex-wife and our young

114:09

kids, and these were college friends of

114:12

ours because we were college

114:13

sweethearts, my ex-wife and I. And we

114:16

were at a theme park with them, with our

114:18

all young kids. And, you know, my

114:22

ex-wife's a lovely person. I think she'd

114:24

say nice things about me, too. I'm a

114:26

nice place to visit, but you wouldn't

114:27

want to live there. Um, I think she'd

114:29

tell you I'm a spectacular ex-husband.

114:30

and have have leave a lot to be desired

114:33

as a husband. Probably fair comment. And

114:35

I would say that, you know, there's a

114:37

lot of people I love that I wouldn't

114:38

want to be married to, and she's one of

114:39

them. Um, she's very happily remarried

114:41

for a long time to a great guy. And we

114:43

were at this theme park with them, and

114:45

they'd been married for roughly the same

114:47

number of years that we were at the

114:48

time. And I remember the kids wanted to

114:51

go on some ride, and it was like the

114:53

permutations of seating. It was like

114:55

three and three. And they had two kids.

114:56

So, we were like, "Okay, I'll sit with

114:58

these two kids. You sit with these two

115:00

kids." and they said, "Great. We're

115:02

going to just hold hands and go for a

115:03

walk."

115:05

And they like held hands and they

115:07

started walking away. And I remember

115:09

looking at them and thinking, "Well,

115:11

they really like each other." Like, like

115:14

they really like each other. And I

115:16

remember thinking like, I don't feel

115:18

that way about her. Like, I love her,

115:21

but I don't feel that way about her. And

115:24

it just it wasn't like, and then I went

115:26

home and we got divorced. we together

115:28

for some more time. But I remember when

115:31

we decided to divorce,

115:35

we had some very honest conversations

115:36

with each other about the marriage and

115:38

about when we'd felt, you know, we were

115:40

very good at postgaming it because we

115:41

stayed friends.

115:43

And I said to her, you know, I remember

115:45

this moment when we were at the theme

115:47

park with and and she goes, "Oh my god,

115:50

I remember that exact same moment." And

115:52

I said, "Yeah." And I thought like they

115:54

went off and were holding hands and I

115:55

remember thinking like I don't love her

115:58

like that. And she was like, "Jim, I'm

116:00

not making this up. I thought the exact

116:01

same thing." She's like, "I remember

116:03

seeing it and thinking like, yeah, like

116:05

I don't like if they took our kids on

116:07

this ride, we wouldn't be holding hands

116:09

walking through the park." And

116:12

why?

116:13

We just didn't have that between us.

116:15

What is that?

116:16

I don't know. That's magic. I don't

116:18

know. That thing. That thing. that magic

116:20

part that nobody can really explain. I

116:23

don't know. It's the thing. It's the

116:24

reason why I've never been homophobic

116:26

because I I happen to be heterosexual,

116:29

but I couldn't explain why. Like, I

116:31

don't know if it's a combination of

116:32

biology, cultural pressure. I have no

116:34

idea. I just know what sparks something

116:37

in me is what sparks something in me.

116:39

And I don't think I have a right to say

116:41

to another adult who has those feelings

116:43

about another adult that they have that

116:45

they're wrong and I'm right or

116:46

something. I I genuinely just feel like

116:48

I don't know there's something magical

116:49

about love. I mean there's something

116:50

magical about romantic attraction and

116:53

the feeling of like deep connection to

116:55

each other. I mean I've known th that

116:57

couple now for the entire 28 years or

117:00

that they've been married and they are

117:03

legit super into each other but they are

117:06

the least performative people you'd ever

117:08

meet. They're very they're very focused

117:11

on each other. Like they really like

117:13

each other. like he

117:15

she refers to him as her boyfriend.

117:18

They've been married for 28 years. They

117:19

have two kids that are like adults now.

117:21

And they she'll be like, "Oh, well, my

117:23

boyfriend's coming home next week from,

117:25

you know, work trip." And and like she

117:26

means her husband, but like she refers

117:28

to him as that. And like he refers to

117:31

her as my girl. Like he's like, "Yeah,

117:33

well my girl and I were going to go do

117:34

this." And I'm always like, "Dude, like

117:36

how are 28 years of marriage and that's

117:38

how you guys feel about each other?"

117:39

Like, and it's legit. It's not like a

117:41

thing. It's like legit. I don't know. If

117:44

I knew that, man, I'd find a way to tell

117:46

people to do it and bottle it. Like, I

117:48

don't know. I'll tell you what it is.

117:49

It's beautiful. It's beautiful. It's fun

117:52

to even be around. Like, it's fun to be

117:54

It when you're not in a challenging

117:57

marriage, being around that is like the

118:00

warmest, most wonderful place. It's not

118:02

surprising to me that their their two

118:04

sons are like two of the most amazing

118:06

young men I've ever met.

118:08

How do they argue?

118:09

I think they I've never watched them

118:11

argue, I imagine. And so I imagine one

118:12

answer would be privately.

118:14

But um

118:16

from what I understand because I have

118:18

tried to reverse engineer a little bit

118:20

with them like what is it? Because I've

118:22

talked about them enough in media now

118:23

that they know I'm like I always text

118:24

them like hey I talked about you. Um and

118:27

when the the the book they were like oh

118:28

you know I was like hey pa whatever you

118:30

know and they they thought it was quite

118:31

funny. I I think they play fair like

118:35

they um I don't know they never lost the

118:37

plot. They seem to really

118:40

they I hope this comes out the right

118:42

way. They love their sons. They really

118:45

love their sons. They're two amazing

118:46

parents, but it seems to me like they

118:49

both they view each other as the most

118:51

important thing. And she's always

118:53

looking out for his happiness and he's

118:55

always looking out for hers. And it's an

118:57

equal measure. Like I think she is very

119:00

focused on him and what will make him

119:03

happy and he's very focused on her and

119:06

what will make her happy and they both

119:09

take tremendous joy in each other's joy

119:12

and I think they both feel and they have

119:14

I will say they have been through some

119:17

things like she had metastatic breast

119:19

cancer at one point she had all kinds of

119:22

and they they weathered that storm they

119:24

weathered that storm with grace humor

119:27

and even deeper connection. And I again

119:30

I I I don't know if it's partly luck

119:33

that they like just hit the lottery with

119:35

each other, but I I think some of it is

119:38

just that they they pay attention like

119:41

it's important to them.

119:43

You're in a relationship, but you're not

119:45

married anymore. You were married

119:46

previously.

119:47

Will you ever get married again?

119:49

I've said before that I don't think

119:51

marriage is important to me. I I don't

119:56

marriage from where I'm sitting is a

120:00

contract that was written by the state

120:03

that is supposed to define

120:06

in some general way what this

120:09

relationship is and create a set of

120:10

rules that govern it. And if you do a

120:12

prenup, you can change that set of

120:15

rules, but you're still saying, you

120:18

know, I really want to get the

120:19

government involved in this situation. I

120:21

I have no part of me that in my

120:25

relationship goes, "We really need to

120:27

get the government involved in this." I

120:30

just don't. That's just not in me. And I

120:32

And it's not only not in me, it's just

120:35

seems absurd to me.

120:37

Marriage seems absurd.

120:41

To me, mar I understand why people get

120:44

married. I think I understand it better

120:46

than most people, but I it just to me

120:49

doesn't make any sense. Why do they get

120:51

married?

120:53

I think we need a lot more time. I think

120:55

it's cultural pressure. Okay.

120:56

I think it's performative.

120:58

I think it's because we live in a

121:00

society, if not a world, that presumes

121:04

marriage is a good idea. I think that

121:06

that is tied to medieval institutions.

121:10

It's tied to things that are way before

121:13

us. And it's tied to partly land

121:16

ownership. It's partly tied to religious

121:18

concepts. It's partly, you know, what

121:19

Freud talks about in civilization. It's

121:21

discontents. It's so we're not all

121:23

killing each other over mates. It's

121:25

it's, you know, we've structured society

121:27

around this idea of turning pair bonds,

121:29

which by the way is a very healthy

121:32

permutation with which to raise

121:34

children. And it's very it's fits our

121:36

biology quite nicely, you know, in terms

121:39

of the amount of time that a child's in

121:41

gestation versus, you know, but I I I

121:44

think we've just we're just like running

121:46

a program that it was here before us and

121:50

that we've been taught is how it's

121:52

supposed to be. This is what you do.

121:54

Like again, ask the question,

121:57

you think it's a bad idea, don't you?

121:58

Getting married.

121:59

Yeah.

122:00

I think it's an incredibly bad idea. I

122:01

think it's an incredibly dangerous idea.

122:03

I I don't think it's a bad idea. I think

122:05

it's a dangerous idea. There's a

122:07

difference between those two things.

122:07

Like skydiving is a dangerous idea. I'm

122:09

not saying it's a bad idea, but it's a

122:11

dangerous idea. It It depends on how

122:13

much joy you place on that thing, right?

122:16

Like for me, the joy of jumping out of a

122:18

plane as compared to the danger of

122:20

jumping out of a plane precludes me from

122:22

jumping out of planes. Maybe I'm missing

122:24

out on something. That's okay. I'll live

122:26

with it. There's lots of cool stuff to

122:27

do. I haven't gotten bored yet. Marriage

122:30

is kind of the same thing. Like I think

122:32

marriage is again like because turn

122:36

around the question which is we know

122:41

facts facts marriage is overwhelmingly

122:44

unsuccessful.

122:46

It is way more dangerous than skydiving.

122:49

Yes you die from the skydiving but the

122:51

chances of a catastrophic skydiving

122:53

incident is like 0.00003

122:56

and a one where you die is 0.00001.

123:00

It's like very limited the chances of

123:02

dying from skydiving. Whereas the

123:04

chances of divorce again 56% divorce

123:07

rate. How many stay together who are

123:09

unhappy and they just stay together

123:10

because they don't give up half their

123:11

stuff or for religious reasons or

123:13

whatever. This is a technology with an

123:15

unbelievably bad failure rate.

123:17

And more people die from marriage or

123:19

skydiving.

123:19

Well, I think more people wish they were

123:21

dead from marriage than star skydiving.

123:23

I think most people's sense of self,

123:25

many people's sense of self dies as part

123:27

of an unhappy marriage. Like it's not a

123:29

question of will you die. It's that

123:32

you're alive and not living your life in

123:34

a way that's enjoyable or in a way

123:36

that's authentic to who you are. And I

123:38

think a lot of people are doing that as

123:40

a function of the choice that they made

123:41

of marriage. And again, I'm not saying

123:43

don't get married. But what I'm saying

123:46

is when someone says, "I'm getting

123:48

married." Why is it impolite to say why?

123:53

Why? You're about to do something

123:56

incredibly dangerous that fails so much

123:59

of the time. Why not just say why? I'd

124:02

like to I'm not saying why would you do

124:04

that? It's stupid. I'm saying why? Cuz

124:07

most people's answer doesn't make any

124:09

sense.

124:11

Well, because you know I don't want to

124:13

be alone. Wait, you have to get married

124:16

to not be alone? Join a church group. I

124:18

don't know. Join a baking squad. Join a

124:20

softball team. You won't be alone. What

124:22

does that mean? Well, I want to have,

124:24

you know, regular sex. Okay. I don't

124:27

know that getting married is the

124:28

solution to that. Like, it's not a

124:30

guarantee of regular sex. Like, that's

124:32

not, you know, so if if the question,

124:34

first of all, you're not even allowed to

124:36

ask the question why. If anything, if

124:39

you don't say, "Oh my god, that's so

124:40

great. You have intimacy issues."

124:43

People say for the kids, you know, it's

124:44

good for the kids. And

124:45

which kids? The kids you've already had

124:47

or the kids you're going to have. You're

124:48

saying, "We're getting married so that

124:49

we can." And by the way, again, okay,

124:52

you're saying society it's good for I

124:54

mean, I think what you're saying is it's

124:56

good for a a mother and a father in a

124:59

household with children together, right?

125:01

So, the polarity of male and female,

125:03

again, I I know a lot of samesex couples

125:05

that have raised very successful, happy

125:06

children. So, maybe you're saying a two

125:08

parent family is a good thing, that it

125:09

doesn't have to be male and female,

125:11

whatever. Okay, that's all true. What

125:12

does a marriage license have to do with

125:14

that? What does the government getting

125:15

involved have to do with that?

125:16

It gives me security.

125:17

What What's security? Security. You're

125:19

saying something that fails 56% of the

125:21

time makes you feel like you get

125:22

security. That's a really weird sense of

125:24

security. If I said to you, "I've got an

125:26

airbag in my car that doesn't deploy 70%

125:29

of the time." Would you drive around

125:30

feeling safe? Or would you go like,

125:32

"This is a lottery I don't want to

125:34

participate in. I'm just going to strap

125:36

myself in and do something else cuz I'm

125:38

not going to rely on this 30% airbag."

125:43

You wouldn't have a job.

125:44

Well, that's that's main reason. I don't

125:46

know. I mean, listen, I I've been saying

125:49

for years that I think I have tremendous

125:51

job security, and it makes me very happy

125:54

on one level, and it makes me very sad

125:55

at another level, that I have such job

125:57

security. I think I think I don't think

126:00

we're getting better at this. I think

126:02

we're getting worse at it. And I I don't

126:04

think by the time I retire, which isn't

126:06

that far away, like I I I don't think

126:09

we're going to get so good at it that

126:11

I'm going to be out of a job.

126:12

As an entrepreneur, I'm always looking

126:14

for ways to connect and to create. And

126:16

that's why I decided to launch the

126:18

conversation cards. I turned to Shopify

126:20

who also sponsored this podcast. And

126:22

Shopify made it so easy to set up an

126:25

online store and reach all of you no

126:27

matter where you are in the world. I

126:29

remember the challenges we faced when we

126:31

first launched the DEO conversation

126:32

cards, managing inventory, ensuring a

126:34

seamless checkout process, and reaching

126:36

our audience. Shopify stepped in and

126:38

made everything so straightforward and

126:40

efficient. It was like having an entire

126:42

team of experts by our side, allowing us

126:45

to focus on creating content and

126:46

connecting with you. What I love about

126:48

Shopify is no matter how big you intend

126:50

to grow your business, they give you

126:51

everything you need to take control and

126:54

take your business to the next level.

126:55

And to say thank you for listening to

126:57

this podcast, we're giving you a trial,

126:58

which is just $1 a month, and you can

127:00

sign up by going to shopify.com/bartlet.

127:04

The link is in the description below.

127:06

More and more people are getting

127:07

prenups. said to me that a lot of people

127:08

contact you these days asking for you to

127:10

help with prenups. One of the

127:12

interesting things we were talking about

127:13

before we started filming was

127:14

it's really uncomfortable to turn to

127:16

your partner and ask them for prenup.

127:18

I know a lot of people say that and I

127:21

think it's a question of how you enter

127:22

the conversation again. like, you know,

127:24

I I guess cuz I get paid to talk and I'm

127:27

used to talking sometimes about

127:28

difficult things with a judge or or

127:30

revealing, you know, things that are

127:32

hard to reveal about someone and trying

127:34

to make sure that they're not viewed

127:35

negatively even though they might have

127:37

behaved negatively. So, I think prenup,

127:39

it's all about how you bring up the

127:40

conversation and and my preferred entry

127:44

point for a prenup when I talk to

127:45

someone is every single person who gets

127:47

married has a prenup.

127:49

It's either written by the government or

127:51

it's written by the two people who love

127:53

each other more than the other 8 billion

127:54

people in the world. I personally think

127:58

that the two people in a marriage are

128:01

better qualified to create the rule set

128:03

of their marriage than politicians they

128:06

don't know. Especially when you consider

128:08

the nature of politicians. They won a

128:11

popularity contest. They managed to

128:13

offend as few people as possible and

128:16

they change constantly. So, you're

128:19

signing up for the most legally

128:21

significant thing you're ever going to

128:23

do other than die

128:25

with a rule set that no one ever

128:28

explains to you in advance and that can

128:30

be changed

128:32

by by people who don't know you based on

128:36

who won a popularity contest. Okay, that

128:39

seems smart to you. or or do the two of

128:43

you decide what the rules are going to

128:45

be and then starting from the beginning

128:49

which is where you are if you're doing a

128:50

prenup because you're about to get

128:51

married. Okay, then you live your life

128:54

in accordance with that rule set

128:56

together and when one of you is

128:57

deviating from it or when a red flag

128:59

goes up like you go, "Hey, how come

129:01

you're doing it that way? Remember we

129:02

have that rule set." And so I I like

129:04

that. I think prenups I think prenups

129:06

even having a conversation about a

129:09

prenup I think is a very healthy

129:12

exercise for a couple. I cannot tell you

129:15

how many people since our first

129:17

conversation have stopped me on the

129:19

streets of New York City and said, "I

129:22

got into the coolest conversation with

129:24

my girlfriend about prenups and marriage

129:26

after I saw you and Stephen talking."

129:28

I've had I've had probably like two

129:31

people a week say that to me. It's it's

129:33

a very I always say to these people I'm

129:35

like you do weird stuff in bed. Like

129:37

you're watching Diary of a CEO in bed.

129:39

It's like

129:40

it's you know there's other stuff like

129:42

I'm not great on the shower thing but in

129:44

bed you don't you know it's I like

129:46

Stephen too but that's not the time.

129:47

Maybe it is.

129:48

But they I guess it is. Anytime's a good

129:50

time.

129:50

Please don't.

129:50

But they know I'm not trying to hurt

129:52

your

129:53

I know you broke 7 million. I don't want

129:54

to screw it up. But I I I I do think

129:57

that there is um there is something to

130:01

this conversation. And I do think

130:02

sometimes like, you know, look, you're

130:04

you're in a relationship, you've had a

130:05

hard conversation with your partner.

130:07

Yeah.

130:08

And when you're in it,

130:10

it's not fun and you kind of go like,

130:12

how are we ever going to get out of

130:13

this? Is this how it's going to be now?

130:14

Like we're just we have this feeling and

130:16

it's like awkward and it's weird. And

130:18

then you make it through it. And then

130:20

the next morning you wake up and maybe

130:22

things are still a little weird or

130:23

something, but like oh yeah. And then

130:25

like I like to believe that then there's

130:28

this feeling of like, oh, hey, we did

130:29

that thing. Like that thing was a little

130:31

weird. It was a little hard. We lost the

130:32

plot, but then we got it back and we're

130:34

still here.

130:34

Look at us.

130:35

Yeah. Look at us. Like, yay, go us. You

130:37

know,

130:38

I think there's real value in that. I

130:40

think that again, the hard thing to do

130:42

and the right thing to do are usually

130:43

the same thing. It's hard to talk about

130:47

when this ends. It's actually the thing

130:49

I'm proud of most in my relationship is

130:51

exactly what you just described there.

130:52

I'm not proud of our relationship being

130:55

perfect because it's not. I'm proud of

130:57

how imperfect it is and how we

130:59

continually resolve the conflict with

131:01

without coming out the other side

131:02

resenting each other. We come out the

131:04

other side proud of each other. We're

131:05

like, you know that meme where I think

131:07

it was the Hot Ones meme where they're

131:08

like, "Look at us. Who would have

131:09

thought?"

131:09

And that's like the thing that my

131:11

girlfriend turns to me and says

131:12

continually is, "I'm so proud

131:14

of

131:16

how much we've got through

131:18

because she she refers to it like the

131:20

roots have got even longer." And going

131:23

back to your conversation about prenups,

131:24

it reminds me of what we were talking

131:25

about before we started recording. This

131:27

idea that people don't want to confront

131:28

it because you tried to get a stand at a

131:31

wedding convention as a divorce lawyer.

131:33

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I So I want

131:36

to say one thing about what you said

131:38

before that because I I your verbiage is

131:40

very interesting to me because you said,

131:42

you know, in my relationship, you know,

131:44

we're not it's not perfect, but I'm

131:46

proud of X, Y, and Z. And I have to tell

131:48

you, like I I don't know, that sounds

131:50

pretty perfect. Like I think that things

131:53

are imperfect like and that's that's

131:56

perfect. Like I there's no such thing as

131:59

a perfect relationship like that ever.

132:02

And that's perfect. Like it's perfect.

132:03

Like it I I genuinely believe we're

132:06

perfect. Like I think we're all flawed

132:09

and we're perfect like because we're

132:11

authentic. We're real. So So I I I think

132:13

that's a really important if people if

132:17

perfection is the standard we will all

132:19

fall short. I think the reality is that

132:22

we are all perfectly imperfect. And

132:24

that's really beautiful.

132:25

But yes, the the the wedding so so in in

132:28

in the United States, I don't know in

132:30

the UK, but in the United States, we

132:31

have these things. They're called

132:32

wedding bizaars or wedding expos or

132:34

wedding fairs. And it somebody came up

132:36

with this and it's a brilliant business

132:38

move, which is you rent a gigantic hall

132:40

or a small hall depending on where some

132:42

of them are done at like giant

132:43

convention centers. And you know, people

132:46

who are associated with the wedding

132:48

industrial complex, you know, they pay

132:51

to have a booth. So there's

132:53

photographers, there's bakers, there's

132:55

and and you know, every table has like

132:58

something. The photographers have

132:59

different pictures. The cake people

133:01

might have like little samples of cake.

133:03

You know, there's all the little grab

133:05

bags and things that people give out as

133:06

wedding gifts. There's, you know, uh

133:08

different uh travel things related to

133:10

your honeymoon and where you might go.

133:12

There's different web websites for, you

133:14

know, your registry. Like, there's so

133:16

many wedding related, wedding adjacent

133:19

businesses. This is a multi-billion

133:22

dollar industry. So, I reached out to

133:25

like four or five different smaller and

133:29

bigger wedding expos. And I said in

133:31

summon substance, I'd like to get a

133:34

table. And they said, great,

133:35

photographer, baker. What do you do? And

133:37

I said, "Well, I'm a lawyer and I I do

133:39

divorce and family law, but it's just

133:41

going to be themed around prenups. It's

133:44

not going to be in any way negative

133:46

about marriage. It's going to be, you

133:48

know, just a congratulations on your

133:49

engagement. Have you talked about a

133:51

prenup?" And then I'll have brochures

133:53

and things and you can, you know, make

133:55

sure that they pass muster, that I don't

133:57

say anything that would be offensive to

133:58

anyone. I don't want anyone to be

133:59

uncomfortable, any other vendors to be

134:01

uncomfortable. But there's literally

134:02

hundreds of vendors at this thing. So

134:04

there's no reason

134:06

Not one wedding expo would rent a table

134:10

to me. They refused my money. They would

134:13

not take it. They would not take it. No

134:15

matter how flowery I said I'd make the

134:18

language, no matter how respectful to

134:20

the institution of marriage I said I

134:21

would be, they would not let me buy a

134:25

table. They wouldn't take my money. And

134:27

those tables are not cheap. It's

134:29

thousands of dollars to get a table at

134:30

Wedding Expo. They would not take my

134:32

money. Even though almost 60% of people

134:34

end in divorce and it's like a almost an

134:37

inevitability, the probability is

134:39

yeah,

134:39

there's going to be a conversation about

134:41

how we separate.

134:42

As I've said before, every single

134:44

marriage ends. It ends in death or

134:45

divorce. The majority of them end in

134:47

divorce. The majority of them end in

134:50

divorce. Why wouldn't you allow me to

134:52

have a table that just says

134:55

if you'd like to have a prenup here? I'm

134:57

not even trying to sell a prenup on you

134:59

like you're getting engaged. You need a

135:01

prenup. It's just have you talked about

135:03

a prenup and information about that pre?

135:06

They would not even let me in the room

135:07

and I because because it shatters the

135:10

illusion. It's reality. They don't like

135:13

reality. They don't see reality

135:16

as what it is. Which I think, by the

135:17

way, is quite romantic. I think there's

135:19

something very nice about talking to

135:22

your partner about, you know what, I'm

135:24

afraid of losing you.

135:27

I don't want to lose you to death, even

135:29

though I know someday I have to. But I

135:31

don't want to lose you to divorce

135:33

either. But man, almost 60% of marriages

135:36

end in divorce. And if we got divorced,

135:38

like what would we be? Like I hope we

135:41

wouldn't hate each other. Like I hope

135:42

I'd still love you and care about you or

135:44

I'd still want you to be well. Even if

135:46

you left me, I wouldn't hate you. Like I

135:49

don't have one exgirlfriend

135:51

that I go, "Man, I hate that person."

135:53

Like, I wish all of them joy. I hope

135:55

they're all happy. like our our chapter

135:58

together ended, but I wish all of them

136:00

joy.

136:01

People don't like to go into things

136:03

without optimism, though. And the the

136:06

conversation around should we get a

136:08

prenup almost sounds like I think we're

136:10

going to break up someday.

136:12

I think you can hear it that way, but I

136:14

don't think it has to be that. I agree

136:16

with you about the optimism. I think

136:17

people would prefer to look at the

136:19

bright side of things and to be

136:20

optimistic. And I am not suggesting like

136:24

I don't believe in fairy tales. I'm a

136:27

realist. That doesn't mean I get up

136:29

every day just thinking about nothing

136:31

but death and divorce and how miss like

136:32

that's not life is beautiful and life's

136:34

meant to be lived and like what you

136:36

don't want to sit like I'm not going to

136:37

sit at a wedding and be like do you know

136:39

how many percentage of this people are

136:41

going to get divor. I don't view it that

136:42

way. I think it's wonderful.

136:44

But be realistic about things. Like I I

136:48

don't want to get ill, but I have a

136:50

physical every year. I go to the doctor

136:52

every year. Like I like to know what's

136:54

going on. I like to be a realist. I like

136:55

to I don't plan on crashing my car, but

136:58

I like knowing that I have a seat belt

137:00

and an airbag. And by the way, if my

137:03

seat at my my seat belt and airbag

137:06

aren't working, I would like to know in

137:08

advance because I'm driving as if

137:11

they're going to work. If you told me,

137:12

"By the way, Jim, your seatelt and your

137:14

airbag aren't working." I would drive

137:16

very, very, very carefully, right? So, I

137:20

think it's the same thing. Like, just we

137:22

can't have an honest conversation and be

137:24

optimistic. Divorce in the US is very

137:27

different from divorce in the UK. And I

137:29

I actually learned, well, I think it is.

137:30

I learned this from watching

137:33

several things, but one video comes to

137:34

mind from a couple of weeks ago. You'll

137:36

know the case. There's a black actor who

137:38

is currently posting a lot on his social

137:40

media about how his wife is like chasing

137:42

him down for child support.

137:43

Oh yes. Yes. I don't remember his name.

137:45

I'm bad at celebrity names

137:47

unless I represent them.

137:48

But yes, I know who he is.

137:49

And he was he said on a couple of shows,

137:51

but he went on his Instagram and said

137:52

like my wife who I've broken up with who

137:54

like basically doesn't really have a job

137:56

at the moment or is making some money

137:57

from some some Instagram work. Yeah. is

138:00

she's got this like pack of lawyers who

138:02

email me

138:03

and demand to see my bank statements

138:06

because

138:07

I've been doing well lately. I've got a

138:08

couple of new movies and stuff and she

138:10

wants to make sure she gets more money

138:12

for me and the kids based on his

138:14

success. And I never realized it was

138:16

like that. I never realized that.

138:17

Oh yeah. Oh yeah. It's modifiable. It's

138:19

modifiable. Child support, for example,

138:21

is modifiable every 3 years when there's

138:23

a 30% change in income up or down. So,

138:26

if I have a wife and then we have four

138:29

kids and then I break up with her

138:31

and when I break up with her I'm making

138:32

a million dollars a year

138:33

and then I'm making $100 million a year.

138:36

What

138:37

goes up? Child support goes up

138:38

to like what what what are the numbers?

138:40

What

138:40

depends on the percentages in in New

138:41

York? One child is 17%, two is 25, three

138:44

is 29, and four is 31% of your gross

138:47

income

138:48

of my gross income.

138:49

Gross income less FICA 00765 social

138:52

security Medicare. If my gross income is

138:53

a hund00 million.

138:55

So theoretically there are caps on the

138:58

combined parental income

139:00

everywhere.

139:01

Yes, pretty much. But judges have a

139:04

tremendous amount of discretion based on

139:06

a variety of factors including

139:09

things like what was the lifestyle of

139:12

the children during the marriage? What

139:14

are the reasonable needs of the

139:15

children? Like celebrity divorces. I

139:17

will tell you

139:19

there are some legitimate separate needs

139:21

that celebrities, the children of

139:23

celebrities need. Like they, you know,

139:26

security for example.

139:27

What's the biggest child support

139:29

payments you've ever heard of?

139:31

Well, I mean, Diddy had I think it was

139:33

$20,000 a month for a period of time.

139:36

Um, he's kind of a well-known one and it

139:37

was very well publicized. The most I've

139:40

ever had in a case is I had a client who

139:43

got $65,000 a month in child support.

139:46

But it it covered a lot of things. It

139:49

covered a portion of private school

139:52

tuition. It covered a security detail.

139:54

It covered, you know, these were very

139:56

very high net worth, you know, public

139:58

figures.

139:58

What kid needs $65,000 a month?

140:01

Well, the kid doesn't get the money. The

140:02

parent who has primary physical custody

140:04

gets the money

140:04

and they can do with it whatever they

140:05

want. They so they could go spend it in

140:07

Vegas.

140:08

Correct.

140:08

That's that's not fair. You should have

140:09

to provide receipts. Well, what I've

140:11

always said is I mean, first of all, the

140:14

system's complicated enough without

140:15

people having to provide receipts to

140:17

check the math of a person and what

140:18

they're spending the child support on.

140:20

Like, it's already overwhelmed enough

140:21

and it's already difficult enough. Like,

140:23

listen, what you're proposing would

140:25

create a lot of additional work for me,

140:27

so I appreciate it, but it it is from my

140:30

perspective, it is a um it is a

140:33

potentially very dangerous thing. What I

140:36

always tell people is getting married

140:40

without a prenup is a fairly risky

140:43

activity. Having a child with someone

140:48

is a is the most risky activity in

140:51

relationships in terms of of the amount

140:54

of emotional and financial damage a

140:57

person can do to you. Have a kid with

140:58

them. Having a kid with somebody, they

141:01

can weaponize that child. They can

141:02

alienate that child. they can use that

141:05

child's needs to piggy back onto

141:07

financial needs. There's there's so much

141:09

stuff a person can do to torture you if

141:11

they have a kid with you. And there's so

141:13

much legal wrangling and rambling to to

141:16

do. And what I'll tell you is it it

141:20

you know I've had CL I have a client who

141:23

spent somewhere in the realm of $100,000

141:26

in legal fees arguing over whether

141:28

Thanksgiving should begin on Wednesday

141:30

and end on Sunday or whether it would

141:33

begin on Thursday morning and end on

141:35

Thursday evening. Now that person's

141:37

worth, you know, seven or $800 million.

141:41

So h 100red grand to them is not a lot

141:42

of money.

141:44

Most people, myself included, I'd just

141:46

eat turkey another day. Like, it's not

141:49

worth that amount of money, right, to

141:51

have that argument.

141:53

That's why having a kid with someone,

141:57

you're opening up the door to

141:58

potentially tremendous amount of

142:00

battles. Whereas, if you're arguing over

142:03

a $50,000 bank account and you spend

142:06

$30,000 in legal fees, even if you won,

142:08

you only won $20,000. If you lost, you

142:11

lost significant. So it it it forces a

142:14

certain rationality into the

142:15

transaction. Whereas your time with your

142:18

kids,

142:19

people could attribute whatever value

142:20

they want to that. I've had clients who

142:22

fought over minuscule things about

142:24

children that to me would be minuscule

142:27

to them were incredibly important.

142:29

You said that the two big reasons why

142:30

people divorce are infidelity and money.

142:33

Yeah.

142:34

Is it a loss of money, a lack of money,

142:36

the person goes poor?

142:37

Um it's that's a big piece of it. losing

142:39

money, um, ga gambling money or losing

142:42

money unexpectedly, bad business and

142:45

investment decisions. There was a period

142:46

of time where I did a lot of divorces

142:48

because people decided they were going

142:49

to try to be day traders and all of a

142:50

sudden people's, you know, they were

142:52

like borrowing against retirement

142:53

accounts. Yeah, they were learning the

142:55

hard way that that if you short stocks,

142:57

there's almost no limit to how much

142:59

money you can lose. Um,

143:00

crypto divorces,

143:01

crypto's big. I did a couple of cryp

143:03

divorces relate that where crypto became

143:05

very important and whether it was on a

143:06

hard wallet or whether it was I mean

143:08

hiding money with crypto very some years

143:11

ago when crypto was first sort of on the

143:13

scene when when I really should have

143:14

been buying Bitcoin because it was like

143:16

you know $3 or $5. Um there there was a

143:19

period of time where most divorce

143:21

lawyers and most judges did have didn't

143:23

understand what crypto even was. I mean,

143:25

try to explain to a 75year-old judge who

143:27

has an AOL email address what

143:30

cryptocurrency was and the difference

143:31

between Ethereum and Bitcoin like and

143:33

why you're concerned that they might

143:35

have these funds on a hard wallet and

143:38

they're looking at you going like what I

143:40

have I have no idea what this is, you

143:41

know? So, it's tricky. I mean, there's

143:43

these are the things we as a divorce

143:45

lawyer, one of the things that makes it

143:46

a very exciting job is that we're

143:48

constantly

143:49

we're getting an education in all of

143:51

these things. Like I represent I

143:54

remember I represented a surgeon and I

143:56

learned everything about how surgeons

143:58

get paid, how they make money, how they

144:01

hide money, what their expenses might

144:03

be. And so then the next time I did a

144:05

surgeon, I'm like, "Oh, I know this."

144:06

You know, the first time I represented

144:07

someone who owned a hedge fund or was a

144:09

partner in a hedge fund, I had to learn

144:11

about how capital accounts work and how

144:12

people are paid and where you might be

144:14

able to hide money. Have you ever seen

144:15

that where someone's like publicly

144:17

thought to be a billionaire and then you

144:19

look at their bank statements during a

144:20

divorce and you realize that they've

144:22

basically managed to hide everything. So

144:24

they're they're basically broke. It's

144:25

all in someone else's name.

144:26

Well, yeah. There's two permutations of

144:28

that. One is people who are publicly

144:31

incredibly wealthy and then in reality

144:33

they're leveraged to the hilt and broke

144:35

like way broke. Um that happens a lot

144:38

and that happens a lot with celebrities.

144:40

Um, celebrities are very often leveraged

144:42

to the hilt because they had a hit

144:44

record or they had a hit movie or two

144:46

and then they think, "Oh, everything I

144:48

do is going to be like this." And so

144:50

they just go out and buy tons of stuff

144:52

and there's always people who loan you

144:53

money, you know, especially if you're a

144:55

public figure and you have some money,

144:57

right? A couple of million bucks. You

144:58

you can get a couple million more real

145:00

easy. So, and then it just very rapidly

145:02

and they buy everybody else. They have,

145:04

you know, there's always clingers around

145:05

the person, you know, the whole

145:06

entourage that a lot of whom are

145:08

siphoning money off of people. So,

145:10

there's a lot of people that look very

145:12

wealthy and are dead broke. Um, and and

145:15

I have a lot of those.

145:16

How does that play out in court when the

145:17

wife finds out that their partner or the

145:20

husband finds out that their wife was

145:22

they're not happy? They're not happy.

145:25

And and um and it's hard because they

145:28

think they have proof of something. Like

145:31

they they're like, "But look, here's a

145:33

picture of him with a Ferrari." And it's

145:34

like, "Right, I can show you the papers

145:37

that he doesn't he leases that Ferrari.

145:39

like it's this much of a car payment.

145:40

Like I had a guy who had like three

145:42

Bentleys and a couple of you know like

145:45

McLaren. He had crazy cars and yeah it

145:47

was all leveraged to the hilt. It was

145:48

not he didn't own them. You know

145:50

what's the second permutation of that

145:51

you

145:52

the second permutation is when someone

145:56

is is um

145:57

when they've hidden the money.

145:59

Yeah. They I I'm trying to find the

146:00

right adjective that they're enough of a

146:02

sociopath that they're enough of a uh

146:04

they're enough of a malignant narcissist

146:07

or they're enough of a careful planner

146:10

that um they have created structures

146:13

that that make it almost impossible for

146:16

their spouse to get anything in the

146:18

divorce. there the the so some of the

146:20

things that people do in um in the ultra

146:26

high netw worth space

146:28

for generational wealth preservation and

146:31

tax avoidance

146:34

have secondorder effects when they get

146:37

divorced. Right? So a lot of wealthy

146:39

people don't own very much of anything.

146:42

They own companies that own properties

146:46

and they have an interest in a trust for

146:49

the benefit of their great grandchildren

146:52

that owns companies that own properties

146:54

that they then borrow against. Like

146:57

there's their whole structure is a very

147:00

complex and they pay hundreds of

147:02

thousands of dollars to trust and

147:03

estates attorneys and accountants. So

147:05

they pay almost nothing in taxes and so

147:08

that they will have no estate issues.

147:10

They will have intergenerational wealth.

147:11

Well, those things make a lot of sense

147:14

from a wealth preservation and estate

147:17

planning perspective, but they make a

147:19

divorce really complicated because it's

147:22

no longer marital money. It's owned by

147:25

this trust. It's owned by this

147:26

corporation. It's owned by I only have

147:28

this percent interest in this thing,

147:30

which is why we've both benefited from

147:32

the taxation of it. So that's where it

147:35

gets like a little um what I do is is a

147:38

fascinating job because we work with you

147:40

know very very brilliant forensic

147:43

accountants who kind of go in and try to

147:46

recreate whether something was done as a

147:49

fraudulent transfer and contemplation of

147:51

divorce or whether something was done

147:53

for good faith reasons and and and you

147:55

know was done in a way that was designed

147:57

to benefit the marriage as opposed to as

147:59

divorce planning.

148:00

There must be scenarios where someone

148:01

goes into divorce. I I think I'm

148:03

divorcing you, let's say, and I think in

148:05

divorcing you, I'm going to get a big

148:06

payout. But it turns out in divorcing

148:08

you that you get a big payout because

148:09

I've got more money than you.

148:10

Yeah, that happens a lot. That happens a

148:11

lot. I've actually I I I wrote an

148:13

article uh for for one of the women's

148:16

magazines um called The Last Remaining

148:18

Feminist Taboo and it it talks about a

148:21

lot of um female clients who are paying

148:23

alimony to their husbands and and it it

148:26

stings. You know, you you you you can

148:29

have a woman who's like a Bella Abzug

148:32

like Gloria Steinum level feminist and

148:34

when she gets told, you know, that like,

148:37

yeah, you got to pay him alimony,

148:38

they're like, I'm sorry, what? Like, no,

148:41

he's a man. He could work. Like, he can

148:43

work. He's a men get alimony. And you're

148:45

like, no, gender is a construct and sex

148:48

is actually, you know, a construct

148:50

socially. and you're a CFO of a company

148:53

and he's a really cute long-haired

148:55

musician who you married cuz he's like

148:58

fun, you know, like and you earn 4,000

149:02

times what he earns annually. And so you

149:05

have to pay him alimony cuz it's just

149:07

math. It's God's gender blind. It's just

149:09

math. And they're like, "Yeah, no, I am

149:10

not paying alimony. He's a man. He's got

149:12

a strong back. Tell him to get a job."

149:14

By the way, I've had men in that

149:17

situation go, "Yeah, I'm not taking

149:18

alimony."

149:19

Really? They won't take

149:20

they won't take it.

149:21

Alimony is like the

149:22

spousal support.

149:23

Okay. Like what? But but child support

149:25

or

149:25

No, it's for your it's it's to maintain

149:28

the marital lifestyle. It's

149:30

it's in order to rehabilitate your

149:31

earnings so that you can be so for

149:33

example um I marry a woman from the UK

149:37

who's a physician and now she's coming

149:39

to the United States because we're in

149:41

love and she's marrying me and she is

149:43

going to lose her license to practice

149:45

medicine because she's coming to the

149:46

United States and it's a different

149:47

lensure. Okay. So now she moves here in

149:50

reliance on us being married and we're

149:52

married for a couple of years and then

149:54

we divorce. She's going to need because

149:57

I now make a lot more money than her.

149:59

She's going to need some money to get

150:00

her back to a place where she's back to

150:02

her earning capacity.

150:03

So if I marry Taylor Swift and we're

150:05

together for 20 years, do I get half?

150:07

You do not get half usually. No. No.

150:10

It's I mean, first of all, she has too

150:11

many good lawyers, I'd imagine, for you

150:13

to get half. But I you you you would

150:16

certainly I mean there was a

150:18

how much could you get me?

150:19

How much could I get you from Taylor

150:20

Swift? I'd have to know how much Taylor

150:22

Swift has. I also don't think she's

150:23

she's never made it down the aisle yet,

150:24

has she?

150:25

But if I take her down the aisle and

150:26

then we we stay together 20 years and I

150:28

come back say, "James, it's time."

150:30

Here's what I'm going to tell you. I'm

150:31

going to get you as much as possible. I

150:32

can't promise you anything, but I am

150:34

promising you I'm going to get you as

150:36

much as I can. I mean,

150:38

you know, I'd have to know. I'd have to

150:39

know what the finances are. I would have

150:41

to. She has a billion dollars

150:42

in cash.

150:44

Billion dollars in cash acquired during

150:45

the marriage or prior to the marriage.

150:46

During the marriage,

150:47

all acquired during the marriage, you're

150:48

getting half.

150:49

There you go.

150:50

You're getting half. You're getting

150:51

half. Listen, uh uh Adele's ex-husband

150:53

did very well. Um Kelly Clarkson's

150:56

ex-husband did very well. It depends on

150:58

how quite well. Look it up. Look it up.

151:01

It's out there. I don't remember the

151:02

exact numbers, but it's out there. The

151:03

the reality is is those were people she

151:05

had her most successful tour at the time

151:09

during the marriage. She had her most

151:10

successful album at the time during the

151:13

marriage. It's all a question of where

151:14

things land in the trajectory of

151:17

someone's life. If you marry someone

151:19

when they're on the comeup, like Jeff

151:21

Bezos, great example, like largest

151:23

divorce settlement probably paid in

151:25

history was to his ex-wife. Why? Because

151:27

Amazon wasn't a thing when they got

151:30

together, right? So, so, so that was she

151:33

was there for the whole trajectory. If

151:35

he got remarried now, she's not going to

151:38

get half because she wasn't there.

151:40

There's a premarital component to that

151:42

that is significant.

151:43

If you got me 500 million from Taylor

151:45

Swift, then would you take like a

151:47

commission like an hour?

151:48

No, it doesn't work that way. You're

151:49

prohibited from doing that. Yeah. Paid

151:50

by the We get paid by the hour.

151:51

You're prohibited.

151:52

I am an hourly wage earner. Like if I

151:54

worked at McDonald's,

151:55

who who prohibits you?

151:57

The rules. The rules that govern and by

151:59

the way, rightfully so.

152:00

Why? because you otherwise would create

152:03

an incentive for the lawyer to maximize

152:07

recovery for their client rather than

152:09

the recovery that makes sense for their

152:11

client. So like I've had cases where the

152:15

cash payout I get for my client is lower

152:20

because I want to get them more support

152:22

like child support or spousal support or

152:24

I want to get them more of the real

152:25

estate rather than the payout. So really

152:29

what we're supposed to do as lawyers is

152:31

not be invested in the percentage of the

152:34

result. Personal injury lawyers like if

152:36

you slip and fall that's different.

152:38

Last question from me is regarding me

152:40

and my partner. I never want to end up

152:42

in your consultation room.

152:45

We never want to go there.

152:47

If you were to give me one piece of

152:49

advice to prevent and it can't be don't

152:50

get married. Um to prevent me and my

152:52

partner ever ending up in your

152:54

consultation room.

152:55

It wouldn't be don't get married.

152:56

Okay. It would

152:57

What would it be?

152:58

Pay attention. Just pay attention. Right

153:00

now, you're paying attention. Like,

153:02

you're paying attention. She's important

153:04

to you. You're important to her. You're

153:06

interested and you're interesting. You

153:08

know, I I I would say pay attention and

153:10

and pay attention to three things.

153:14

The you, the me, and the we. Because

153:18

those are three different things. Like,

153:20

you be you, cuz you're who she fell in

153:23

love with. And don't let you go too far

153:25

from shore. like you be you. Don't let

153:28

don't let anything in the world don't

153:29

let her don't let the we don't let any

153:31

of it stop you from being you cuz you're

153:34

who she fell in love with and the she

153:38

right who she is. So there's you,

153:39

there's me, there's we. So her, remember

153:42

who she is. Let her be her. Like make

153:44

sure that she takes time to be her. Make

153:46

sure you give space for her to be her

153:48

because that's who you fell in love

153:49

with. And let that person change just

153:51

like you might change sometimes from

153:53

time to time. And if things change too

153:54

much, I'm not saying resist it, but note

153:58

it. Pay attention. Say, "Hey, this is

154:00

going on. Is it is that a good thing? Is

154:02

it a bad thing?" Like, what? You know,

154:03

let's just notice it. Let's just pay

154:04

attention. And then the Wii, like the

154:06

you, the me, and the we. Like, talk

154:08

about, you know, pay attention to the

154:09

Wii. Make sure we're watering the plant.

154:11

Like, make sure that that'd be the only

154:13

advice I'd ever give to anybody. It has

154:14

nothing to do with marriage. It has to

154:16

do with connection. It has to do with

154:18

love. It has to do with there's a reason

154:21

why you found the Wii, right? Like you

154:25

can be you all by yourself and she can

154:27

be her all by herself. But there's value

154:30

in in being we and seeing each other's

154:33

blind spots and and and and and if

154:35

there's value in that, treat it like

154:38

something valuable. Don't let the world

154:40

don't let your own strengths and

154:43

weaknesses don't let anything pull you

154:44

off of that. Pay attention to you, the

154:47

mei, and the wei. And don't be afraid.

154:49

The hard thing to do and the right thing

154:51

to do are usually the same thing. So if

154:53

it's harder to talk about it, it's

154:54

harder to point it out. It's harder to

154:56

say, "Hey, are we okay? Is everything

154:58

good?" Like, you know, if that's harder,

155:00

do that. Lean into that.

155:04

James, we have a closing tradition on

155:05

the podcast where the last guest leaves

155:06

a question for the next guest, not

155:07

knowing who they're leaving it for. The

155:09

question left for you is, what is

155:12

your most controversial opinion?

155:15

Oh god, you're going to be cancelled.

155:19

What is my most controversial opinion? I

155:23

think

155:26

I think I alluded to it my last

155:28

conversation with you. Um,

155:31

I my most controversial opinion is that

155:33

the most important thing in people's

155:35

lives and their greatest accomplishment

155:37

should not be their children.

155:39

That's a real hot like when you say to

155:41

people like I think it's if the if if

155:44

you say the most important thing that

155:46

ever happened, the greatest thing I ever

155:48

accomplished in life was having

155:50

children. I find that very um I find

155:53

that logic very strange because if you

155:56

say the most important greatest thing I

155:58

ever did in my life was having children.

156:00

Well, is then the greatest and most

156:02

important thing your children ever did

156:03

going to be having children and is the

156:05

greatest thing their children ever did

156:06

is having children? Because that's the

156:08

ideology of a virus or a cancer cell.

156:10

Like it's not like growth for the sake

156:12

of growth for the sake of growth. Like I

156:14

I think there has to be a higher nobler

156:16

purpose to life than reproduction. So

156:19

I'm not an antiatalist,

156:21

but I tend to when someone says to me

156:24

like my children are my greatest

156:25

accomplishment, I tend to look at them

156:27

and go like made some interesting

156:29

choices then. I guess

156:30

science and sort of evolution and

156:32

Charles Darwin might argue that that's

156:34

exactly the point of life is

156:36

and it is on the cellular level and for

156:39

squirrels and for pigeons

156:42

and we're monkeys.

156:43

Yeah, but I think we're different than

156:45

monkeys. Like if you've watched like

156:47

we're we're we're very similar in lots

156:48

of ways, but I'd like to think that that

156:51

there's something higher that we're

156:53

called to. And I don't know that

156:56

reproduction should be the highest goal

156:59

of a human being's life. I'm not one of

157:02

these people that thinks like don't have

157:04

children, it's a terrible thing. I have

157:06

kids. I love my kids. Was great having

157:08

kids. Learned a lot about myself in

157:10

having children. Learned a lot about the

157:12

life and the what I love spending time

157:14

with them. I have a great relationship

157:15

with my sons. I look forward to being a

157:17

grandfather. But the truth is like, is

157:20

it the greatest thing I ever

157:21

accomplished in my life? Absolutely not.

157:23

It's it's in the it's in the top of the

157:25

list. It's a wonderful experience I had.

157:28

But it is not the thing. And I think

157:29

that's a very I don't know why that is

157:31

such a controversial opinion. When I say

157:33

that to people, they they look at me

157:35

like I've got lobsters coming out of my

157:37

nose.

157:37

There's definitely two schools of

157:38

thought there. There's the one school of

157:40

thought that you were saying something

157:42

earlier and it really at the start of

157:43

the conversation about how people lose

157:45

their identity when they have children

157:46

and it causes all of this sort of

157:47

psychological dysfunction and who am I

157:49

now? I'm attached to this thing and

157:51

where did my life as an independent

157:52

person go?

157:53

You know that that's kind of the one

157:55

school of thought where

157:57

where you're resisting

157:59

become becoming all about procreation.

158:02

You're resisting becoming just a I'm

158:04

just here to be a mother father. And

158:05

then there's another group of people

158:06

that go absolutely this is me. This is

158:08

my purpose.

158:08

Right. But see, I I think like

158:10

everything like we don't have to treat

158:11

dandruff with decapitation.

158:13

Like I I think you can you cannot reject

158:17

the concept of having children or making

158:19

them a priority. And you can also not

158:22

make your children your entire identity.

158:24

I think that you can just sort of say,

158:26

"Hey, my children are incredibly

158:28

important to me. I love them. They're

158:30

wonderful. Um, but I also have other

158:33

aspects of my life and self and other

158:35

relationships that have value to me and

158:37

I'm not going to let them all be

158:39

sacrificed at the altar of my children.

158:42

Who's more likely to end up in your

158:43

office? Which school of thought?

158:45

People who are obsessed with their

158:47

children.

158:48

I think people who are obsessed with

158:50

their children stop paying attention to

158:52

themselves and to their partner. That's

158:54

been my experience of people who are

158:56

obsessed with their children. I don't

158:57

mean people who are focused on their

158:58

children. When I mean people who make

159:00

their children a high priority in their

159:01

life, I'm talking about people that are

159:03

like obsessed with their children. That

159:04

their children are their this is who I

159:07

am. I am a mother. This is who I am. I

159:11

am a father. Which cuz by the way,

159:13

childhood is a temporary state. Like

159:16

theoretically, you're going to have a

159:19

very close and intimate relationship on

159:21

a day-to-day basis with your spouse a

159:23

lot longer than your children. If it's

159:25

done properly, your children are

159:26

supposed to leave and go start their own

159:29

families and live their own lives.

159:31

Whereas your partner is not supposed to

159:33

in 19 years or 18 years move out.

159:36

They're supposed to stay there. So it's

159:38

kind of smart to also feed. Not again,

159:41

not only feed, also feed that

159:44

relationship. There's no reason why you

159:47

can't simult and by the way sometimes

159:50

being a really good supportive

159:52

person to your co-parent and loving your

159:56

wife and loving your husband is a

159:58

wonderful gift to give to your children.

160:00

It models great relationship behavior to

160:02

them. It it it's showing that you love

160:05

and respect the other person who loves

160:07

them as much as you do. Like there's so

160:09

much good in being a good parent that is

160:13

made up of being a good co-parent, a

160:16

good spouse, a good partner.

160:17

So you think you're more likely to end

160:19

up in your divorce office if you're

160:21

obsessed with your children?

160:22

You make your children your absolute

160:24

number one priority and your spouse

160:26

falls very far down that list. Yes, for

160:29

sure.

160:30

James, thank you.

160:31

Always great to see you. I love our

160:33

conversations because they're, you know,

160:35

you're a divorce lawyer and you, you

160:36

know, your practice, I guess, is dealing

160:38

with divorces, but your width of wi

160:41

wisdom and knowledge and how it all

160:43

intertwines in the most beautiful, wise,

160:46

enlightening way, and just the

160:48

overarching filter of you not being

160:50

afraid to say things that most people

160:52

would wouldn't say, you not being afraid

160:54

to be politically correct provides a a

160:57

message which is so important and quite

160:59

um unfortunately rare, but is so

161:02

everything you say is so

161:06

obvious in the sense that it's common

161:07

sense, but it's common sense that's

161:09

completely uncommon.

161:10

That means a lot to me.

161:12

That's what I found in your book as

161:13

well. I found the same level of brevity

161:15

and wisdom and experience and diversity

161:18

of experience which ties into these

161:20

central ideas. Everyone, if you didn't

161:21

go by the book last time, you have to go

161:22

buy the book. It's called How to Stay in

161:24

Love. Um, and it's my favorite book ever

161:26

written on the subject of love and

161:28

relationships and life, quite frankly.

161:30

So, I think everyone needs to go and get

161:32

the book. I'll link it below. Um, James,

161:34

thank you so much.

161:35

It's great to see you.

161:35

I love our conversations. I hope we have

161:37

many more. So, I really appreciate you.

161:39

Thank you for having me. It's great to

161:40

see you.

161:44

Isn't this cool? Every single

161:47

conversation I have here on the Diary of

161:48

a CEO, at the very end of it, you'll

161:50

know I ask the guest to leave a question

161:53

in the diary of a CEO. And what we've

161:56

done is we've turned every single

161:58

question written in the diary of a CEO

162:00

into these conversation cards that you

162:03

can play at home. So you've got every

162:05

guest we've ever had their question and

162:08

on the back of it, if you scan that QR

162:11

code, you get to watch the person who

162:14

answered that question. We're finally

162:16

revealing all of the questions and the

162:20

people that answered the question. The

162:22

brand new version two updated

162:25

conversation cards are out right now at

162:27

thecon conversationcards.com.

162:29

They've sold out twice instantaneously.

162:31

So if you are interested in getting hold

162:33

of some limited edition conversation

162:35

cards, I really really recommend acting

162:37

quickly.

162:41

[Music]

Interactive Summary

James Sexton, a prominent divorce lawyer with over two decades of experience, shares his professional and philosophical insights on marriage, relationships, and the inevitability of endings. He argues that marriage, while often idealized, is fundamentally dangerous due to its high failure rate and the complex legal and emotional fallout that follows. He emphasizes that relationships require constant attention to three components—the 'you', the 'me', and the 'we'—and advocates for realism, such as the use of prenups, rather than clinging to performative illusions or cultural pressures.

Suggested questions

5 ready-made prompts