Gabor Mate: The Childhood Lie That’s Ruining All Of Our Lives. | E193
3575 segments
Financial stress on the parents
translates into physiological stress in
the children. They didn't inherit
anything in terms of a disease. They're
just reacting to the environment. People
call Dr. Gabor Mate the people whisper,
legendary thinker and best-selling
author.
He's highly sought after for his
expertise on addiction, stress, and
childhood development.
The evidence linking mental illness and
childhood adversity is about as strong
as the evidence linking smoking and lung
cancer. And the average physician
doesn't hear a word about that. It's
astonishing. I can give you the example
of Donald Trump. I mean, his father was
a psychopath.
You are the enemy of the people. Go
ahead.
For him, these were not choices so much
as survival techniques. And that's the
mark of a traumatized child, the denial
of reality.
What do I have to understand about your
earliest years to understand you?
My grandparents were killed in
Auschwitz, and my mother and I barely
survived. And then my mother, to save my
life, gives me to a stranger. The sense
I get is that I'm being rejected and
abandoned cuz I'm not good enough. How
did that rear its ugly head throughout
your life? Any number of ways. See,
trauma, as I define it, is not about
what happens to us. It's about what
happens inside of us as a result of what
happens to us. It's costing us in terms
of our physical health, our
relationship, our mental health, and so
on. How does one go about correcting
that?
It's a multi-layered answer. First of
all,
Before this episode begins, I just want
to say a huge thank you to all of our
new subscribers. 74% of you that watch
this channel didn't subscribe before.
And we're now down to about 71%. So,
that helps us in a number of ways that
are quite hard to explain, but simply,
the bigger the channel gets, the bigger
the guests get. So, if you haven't yet
subscribed to The Diary of a CEO, if I
could have any favors from you, if
you've ever watched this show and
enjoyed it, it's just to to please hit
the subscribe button. Without further
ado, I'm Steven Bartlett, and this is
The Diary of a CEO. I hope nobody's
listening, but if you are, then please
keep this to yourself.
My dear little man,
only after many long months do I take it
in hand, the pen, so that I may briefly
sketch for you the unspeakable horrors
of those times, the details of which I
do not wish you to know.
Those are words that your mother wrote
into her diary in the 1940s during the
Holocaust.
She wrote those words in April of 1945,
3 months after the
Soviet Army expelled the
Nazis from Budapest, where which is
where we lived. So, she was referring to
the previous year and the beginning of
that year, late 1944 and early 1945. And
in those diary entries, she's addressing
many of them to you directly as a baby.
She wrote the diary to me directly
as if it was like a account of my life
addressed to me.
You talk so much in in your in all your
books, um and much of your work about
the importance of that early context.
It's really been I mean, the center
point of all the writing that I've read
recently. And I know, because it's
it's so evident in everything that
you've done, that that's been a key your
own early context has been a key
inspiration for why you've taken such a
an interest in these topics. What was
your early context? What do I have to
understand about your earliest years to
understand you?
So,
it's just a fact about human beings that
the template that forms us will affect
how we see the world, how we understand
ourselves,
how we relate to other people. And um
that early template is our earliest
months, even in utero, already in the
womb, we're being affected by
the environment, but certainly in the
early years when our brain is being
formed and our personality is taking
shape.
And so, that forms our worldview.
Now, my worldview was and my sense of
self was shaped by the fact that
at 2 months of age, when I was 2 months
of age, the German Army occupied
Hungary.
Hungary was the last country in Eastern
Europe where the Jewish population had
not been exterminated, and that was our
turn.
The day after the German Army marched
into Budapest, which was March 19th,
2000 1944, the day after my mother
called the pediatrician to say, "Would
you please come and see Gabor, cuz he's
crying all the time." And the doctor
said, "Of course I'll come, but all my
Jewish Jewish babies are crying."
And so that the fact is that when
mothers are stressed or in pain, the
infant feels all that and takes it
personally, and it becomes part of their
template for how they view the world.
So, that was that year that's when that
year began in which my grandparents were
killed in Auschwitz and my father was
away in forced labor, and my mother and
I barely survived. And
it's a story I've told many times, but
that's when my brain is developing and
that's when I'm forming my sense of
myself.
And then my mother,
to save my life, gives me to a stranger,
and I don't see her for 6 weeks.
The sense I get is that I'm not wanted
and I'm being rejected and abandoned and
cuz I'm not good enough.
That's
how my life began.
So, your mother gives you away for 5 to
6 weeks Yeah. in order to sort of save
you from starvation in in a
ghetto that that she was going to,
right? That's right.
This is after after your grandparents
were killed in Auschwitz by Yeah. the
Nazis. Um how do you know in hindsight
that that that moment of those 6 weeks
created that sense of abandonment in
you?
I I wouldn't say it's just that one that
one moment. Children very much view
themselves
through the interaction with their
parents.
Now, first of all, I had no father cuz
he was gone. Hadn't Hadn't seen him
except very briefly when I was a month
old, but there was no father in the
picture.
My mother was grief-stricken
and full of woe and worry about what's
going to happen to us and just the the
task of surviving each day.
She's not playful with me. She's not
smiling at me very much. She's
worried-looking. She's stressed-looking.
The infant takes everything personally.
That's just the nature of the infant. As
infants, we're narcissists. We think
it's all about us. So, when things are
great, hey, we're great. But when my
mother's unhappy,
it's because she she doesn't want me or
I can't make her happy or I'm
inadequate.
So, that separation from my mother
certainly set a template for some of my
relationship interactions with my spouse
decades later, but the sense of not
being good enough and and and and and
being responsible,
um that was inculcated in me throughout
that whole first year of life.
So much so that in this book, The Myth
of Normal, I I actually talk about a an
experience with the psychedelic
mushrooms
at at the with a therapist. This is not
that long ago, 7 years ago, maybe.
Um
when I'm at least 70 years old, and
I'm in this therapeutic session with the
psilocybin, the the medicine,
and the therapist,
and I know that I'm 70 70 years old, and
I know this is a therapy session, and I
know her name, and I know
who I am in the world, but at the same
time I'm experiencing myself as a
1-year-old baby.
And she's my mother.
And I start crying. Tears coming down to
my my face. And I say, "I'm so sorry I
made your life so difficult."
Now, that was an unconscious memory of
my sense of myself as a 1-year-old, that
I made my mother's life so difficult,
because that's the way the baby
interprets it.
So,
even if your mother loved you, which
mine did infinitely, not that she always
treated me the best way possible, but
she did love me. And um
can you imagine what a great act of love
even giving me to a stranger in the
street would have been for her, you
know?
But, because of her own unhappiness, I
can only conclude that I'm not good
enough.
It's It's my fault.
At At 70 years old, having that
psilocybin experience, coming to that
realization, or having that sort of
um having that response to your
therapist where
they take the role of your mother and
you're a 1-year-old, how does somebody
at 70 years old go about correcting
that?
That sort of interpretation you had of
that traumatic early early event.
Well,
by bringing up to the conscious level.
Then when I notice that sense of guilt
or responsibility in me, I say, "Oh,
that's what it's about." So, it's it's
it's a meaning
See, to trauma, as I define it, is not
about what happens to us. It's about
what happens inside of us as a result of
what happens to us.
And so, the wound in my in trauma means
wound. So, the wound in this case is my
sense of deficiency or not being good
enough, not being worthy enough. Once I
realize that, "Oh, this has got nothing
to do with anything except this
interpretation that I made of my own
experience all those years ago," then
when I notice it, I can no longer
believe it. I don't have to any longer
be a
subject
to that interpretation of myself and the
world. So, awareness is one step It's
not adequate, but it's an essential step
towards um letting go.
That that one um belief that you weren't
good enough, yeah, how did that
rear its ugly head throughout your life?
It um
made me a workaholic physician cuz I had
to keep proving my worth.
And it doesn't matter. Now,
I don't know if you've ever had an
addiction, but the nature of it is that
we're trying to get from the outside
something that only can
arise and fulfill us from the inside.
So,
when you're looking at it from the
outside, it's addictive because you get
it temporarily, but then that internal
emptiness, that hole, never goes away.
So, it has to be filled over and over
and over again, and it can only be done
so temporarily. So, it becomes runaway
addictive. So, then, you know, work
becomes an addiction because I keep
trying to prove my worth.
And doesn't matter how many times,
you know, I I I may show up in a
positive way at the beginning of
someone's life or the end of somebody
else's life or anytime in between,
it never fills that emptiness that my
sense of lack of worthiness creates.
So, that's one way it shows up.
Another way it shows up is if
in my relationship,
I don't feel as satisfied,
my wife doesn't
please me the way I like her to,
um
then I get angry. But what am I getting
angry?
I'm getting angry because it's my sense
of not being good enough. That's being
now revealed.
It it gets uncovered. This this this
this self-accusation.
Um but I get angry at her because her
job isn't to make me not feel that.
You know, we we we get into this
relationship
for all kinds of reasons. Some of them
are conscious, some are not, some are
positive, some are come out of trauma.
Well, in my case,
I want that relationship to prove to me
how good I am.
So, when it isn't proving that, then I
get upset at my partner, you know. Well,
except the gap is inside me, not inside.
It's not coming from her.
So, it shows up
it shows up in my parenting, it it shows
up all over the place.
I mean, I think both of those examples
sound a lot like me, especially the
first one.
Yeah. Um the second one as well, but the
In what sense? In the sense that I I'm
definitely a a workaholic and I thought
in the earlier phases of my life, I like
sacrificed everything in this pursuit of
becoming a millionaire and and having
all this stuff and really getting this
validation. Sacrificed meaningful
connections, everything in the pursuit
of this one thing. Well, part of the
toxicity of the culture that I
talk about in this book is that it
actually rewards that kind of emptiness
or that or that desperate
uh seeking to
to to to fill that emptiness because
because you know, you get rewarded. You
make a lot of money, a lot of people
admire you, uh
you get to feel good about yourself.
Mind you,
my guess is that good feeling is only
temporary, at least if my example is any
uh guide, you know, that that feeling
good cuz somebody from the outside
values you is only a temporary salve for
the
for the wound that's inside.
But the world actually rewards it, you
know, so you're a workaholic doctor,
great, you make more money and all these
people respect you. Meanwhile, you're
hollowing yourself from the from the
inside and you're not available for your
family. You know, so that that's part of
the craziness of this culture. And it's
like the it's like the hedonistic
treadmill in a in a sense because you
just never
enough is never enough, as you say. So,
the last achievement needs to be
surpassed by a greater achievement for
me to get an applaud or a clap. I've
never really made the connection that
the reason why I'm a workaholic is
because
I I'm trying to prove to the world that
I'm enough, but I think that it's
entirely true. Yeah. So, in your case,
like like race and class
in this society of inequality are
certainly traumatic, potentially
traumatic inputs, as I pointed in this
book and and you know, to to to the
degree that it affects people's
physiology,
you know, but also then, I don't know
your family origin or what kind of
relationship you have with your parents,
but there also may have been a sense
like I got with my mom for, you know,
reasons and and and for whatever it
might have happened in your family,
maybe you got the sense as well that
even in your family of origin, you
weren't
good enough somehow. So, So, my mom
would scream at my dad for like 7 hours
a day. And my dad would just sit there.
Okay.
And so, my early memories of like
looking at my mom and dad are this kind
of
violent verbally, not like physically.
This incredibly stressful screaming, one
person screaming at the other. That's
what I remember, but from reading what
you've written in this book and from
what you've said now,
I actually might have learned a
sort of learned to that I was the
problem to some degree. You tuned into
it that way. That's just the whole
point. That's what I mean about kids
being narcissists. The I don't mean that
in the negative sense. I just mean
actually they think it's all about them.
So, if your mother is unhappy,
it's your fault.
You know, and you're not good enough.
So, then you have to go out there and
work to prove yourself to prove to the
world and to yourself that you're good
enough. So, that
going back to your first question about
how these things show up in our lives,
that's how they show up.
And so, at 12 years old, you you
emigrate to Vancouver. Yeah. Um by 28,
you join the medical profession. Yeah.
And you spend the next 32 years,
roughly, working in medical practice.
at 28, I went back to medical school,
actually. I I I took a detour. I was a
high school teacher for
and um
and then I was 27, 28 when I started
medical school. At age 33, I think I
began my medical
career of 32 years. And in those 33
years, what what was your practice? What
did you specialize in? What did you
focus on?
So,
I was a family physician,
which meant I delivered a lot of babies
and I looked after people's problems
from beginning to the end of life.
I also worked in palliative care.
I was the director of a unit at the
hospital which looked after people with
terminal disease.
And I did
that was 22 years or so of my practice,
20 22 years.
And then then I switched
gears altogether and I went to work in
the downtown east side of Vancouver,
British Columbia, which is North North
America's most concentrated area of drug
use. We have more
people coming from anywhere in the world
are shocked by what they see there,
thousands of people in the streets
injecting, selling, using, inhaling
uh ingesting drugs of all kinds and
people are suffer the consequences of
drug use in a society that doesn't
understand drug use, so that punishes it
and excludes it, ostracizes it. So,
people get HIV from dirty needles and
and and hepatitis C. So,
this is the population often they're
homeless. So, that's the population I
worked with for 12 years
till the end of my medical work.
That experience working with patients
that were in palliative care. So, that's
for anybody that doesn't know, that's
patients that are approaching the end of
their life that have terminal illnesses
and that are aware that they're going to
to die.
What did that experience teach you?
It took an acceptance of one's
lack of
lack of omnipotence as a physician cuz
you go into the you want to cure people,
you want to you want people to heal.
And that takes a tremendous acceptance
to say, you know, we've reached the
limit of our knowledge.
And that doesn't mean we can't help
people, but we certainly can't cure
them.
You know,
and so, it taught me how to be with the
inevitable.
And and and when you're working with
people who are
in the process of dying, but I mean, by
the way, who isn't in the process of
dying, you know, but but people whose
time is more limited than the rest of
us,
acceptance, you learn a lot of
acceptance.
It challenges you to do your best
when you know your best isn't going to
be
saving anybody's lives, but it's to help
people live a life of
as little suffering as possible and as
much dignity as possible.
So, it really challenges the best parts
of you to to show up.
Patience, acceptance,
um intuition.
Personally, it taught me a lot to listen
to people.
Interesting enough,
people really want to be heard when
they're dying.
Uh they want to make sense of their
lives.
They want to tell their stories and they
want their stories to be heard.
And so, um I listened a lot. I just sat
by the bedside and I listened.
Um all that.
When you listened, did you
did you hear any themes relating to
regret or things that actually mattered?
Cuz I always imagine in if I was given
such news that my life was coming to an
end and there was an approximate date,
it would be quite a powerful way of
finally realizing what truly matters and
what never did.
You know, people react to their
impending death in different ways. So,
there were some people who just
fought it to the end, you know, didn't
really want to accept it.
But most people
were more along the lines that you
describe
where they really get to see what's
important. And so,
I mentioned this a number of times, it
sounds strange and I don't recommend it,
but I've had patients say to me,
"Doctor, I don't know how to tell you
this and I can't even explain it,
perhaps, but this illness that's going
to take my life is the best thing that
ever happened to me."
And what by meant they meant a couple of
things by it. They meant what you just
said about finding out what's really
important in life. In this book, The
Myth of Normal, I interview a young man
called Bill Pike who wrote a book called
Blessed with a Brain Tumor.
And how
what kind of blessing is that?
So, I said I asked Will, "What's the
blessing?" And he said, "It made me
appreciate every moment.
It meant every time I talked to
somebody, this I knew this might be the
last conversation I'm going to have with
them. So, it better be a human, genuine
interaction."
So, there was that aspect of it.
The other aspect of it was that
again, my view is as I pointed in this
book and in previous works, who gets
sick and who doesn't isn't isn't exactly
accidental. There were certainly
personality patterns based on traumatic
experiences in childhood that make
disease more likely.
And people very often realize that
throughout their lives
they had abandoned who they were. They
lived a life that didn't wasn't
meaningful for them.
And
around death they reconnected with
themselves in an
authentic way and that seemed to be
worth a lot to people.
Again, I don't recommend that way of
going to reconnect with yourself, but
people have certainly I certainly saw
it. So, those are the two big lessons.
After your 33 years in medical practice,
um
you you described that you had a bit of
a you kind of tuned into a creative
calling which was writing. Well, I began
to write when I was a physician. So, my
first book on ADHD after I was diagnosed
with it was published in 1999 now. So,
that was 23 years ago now. So, I began
to write and even before then I wrote
because I wrote columns for newspapers.
But yes, there was a time in my life
where the writing impulse which had been
with me all my life was stifled and and
and and and
stymied.
And so was I cuz I had this frustration.
In fact, I had the sense that there's
something I needed to express.
But I
didn't know what and didn't know how.
And at some point I realized, oh yeah, I
need to write. So, that began before I
finished medical practice, but it
certainly
um
has been essential to my ongoing
unfolding as a human being.
I I was so compelled by that when I when
I read about that because um
I started to really understand the value
of creativity in all of our lives
regardless of whether we have the luxury
of being called an artist or not.
And so, what in your view is the
importance of
Well, you're you're singing my tune here
if I may say that way because um
I quote in this book there's a great
Hungarian-Canadian stress researcher
called Janos Selye, S E L Y E and Selye
is the one who actually coined the word
stress in the sense that we use it
today. And he's the one that showed in
the laboratory how stress diminishes the
immune system and this
disorganizes the hormones and and also
eats the stomach lining and all this
kind of stuff, but
Selye also said and I quote him here,
what is in us must out. What is in us
must out.
That we all have to follow our creative
urges in the way that nature prepared
for us, otherwise we can be hopeless
hopelessly hemmed in by frustration. I'm
paraphrasing it very closely.
So,
we are created in image of God. I mean,
as you know,
what your religious views are, but that
sense that we're created in images of
God means that we are creators cuz the
essence of God is creation.
In fact, we call God the creator and we
call the result of that creation.
If we're created and if we're if we're
offshoots
of that creative dynamic in the
universe, then it means that it's in us
to create. And whatever form that takes,
I mean, you know, you don't want to see
me
do art, you know, unless you
I can do a pretty good stick figure, you
know, but but I'm married to an artist.
Um
So, that creativity doesn't have to take
the form of formal art, but it does have
to take some flow of something that's
inside you that needs to come out.
Otherwise, as Selye says, you get
hopelessly hemmed in by frustration. And
so, in that sense, everybody's got that
creative urge and that may take the form
of social intercourse. It might take the
form of gardening. I don't care.
Communing with nature, uh
athletic expression, I don't care what.
But it but but there's somebody
everybody's got it. And if people don't
realize they have it, it's only cuz life
has hemmed them in and they're too busy.
And sometimes they are trying to make a
living or trying to survive or too
disconnected from themselves.
But it's in all of us and to the extent
that we don't give it expression, we
suffer.
One of the things that really hems it in
is um
is the prospect that we might not be
good at it because we think to express
ourselves creatively we kind of join a
competition of sorts.
And that's that's a trap we can fall
into. So, if I'm going to DJ, I need to
become a good DJ, but in social
comparison or else I don't want to but
but what I've come to learn is in fact
the act of DJing alone in my kitchen at
midnight is is the reward regardless of
outcome or whether there's a crowd
there. It's just me and my dog
listening. That is the expression is the
reward, not the achievement or the medal
that I might get or the
Yeah, not the external. Well, look, I
went through that in the writing of this
book. So, here I am this, you know,
writer who writes about, you know,
trauma and you know, healing and all of
a sudden I'm in a panic cuz I'm writing
a book and I realized that the problem
was that you you talked about
identifying with your work. So, I had
identified with this book. So, the
problem wasn't the book.
Cuz let's say I write the book and it's
not a success. I mean, okay,
big headline in the Sunday Times, book
not a big success. You know,
how big a big deal is that in the
history of the universe?
But if I identify with the book
and it's not going well, then if the
book fails, then I'm failing as a person
which then goes back to my very earliest
concern about not being worth it, you
know? So,
once I disidentified,
once I said, no, this is just a book. It
may be a good book. It may be an
important book. It may be a book that
doesn't hit the mark,
but it's only a book. And how it goes
says nothing about me or my worth.
Once I could decouple that, then I could
confidently and much more comfortably go
back to the writing of it. But I went
through that crisis. Mhm. It seems like
a bit of a paradox that this the the
lack of self-worth would would motivate
someone to to create great things
because they want the approval, but at
the same time make the process so
agonizing because their self-esteem
seems to be on the line. Yeah. Or their
sense of self-worth is on the line.
Well, that dynamic was in me. Once I
realized it, I let go of it, you know?
So, it didn't it didn't dominate me in
the end and
honestly to God by the time I finished
the book,
I'm not just saying this in retrospect.
It's it's a best-seller now in several
countries, but
I actually said to myself and I meant
it,
now I've done the book,
that's what matters.
I've said what was in me to say.
How the world reacts,
I can't control and it doesn't actually
matter at on a fundamental level. It's
not that I don't want this book to be a
success. I mean, success, of course I
want it to sell 10 zillion copies, but
that doesn't define my self-worth or how
I function in the world or how I feel
about myself. Honestly, it does not and
I
I I understood that by the time I
finished working on it.
So, once it's done, it's out there doing
its work or
not doing its work,
but I don't have to hang my own sense of
self on how the book does.
Because at that point that's an outcome
you can't control, right? So, trying to
control that would be
Yeah.
anxiety Uh and Yeah. Oh, yeah, of course
you can't control it, no.
10 years this book
took you to write. Took me to prepare.
It took three took about 3 years to
write, yeah. You describe it as
a calling. Yeah. The myth of normal.
Yeah.
What four words to
to sort of pull people in and to in some
way summarize a 550-odd page book. Why
why those four words? Why that phrase?
Uh can I pause for a moment to find a
quote on my cell phone? 100%.
Yeah. I just
So, this is um
are you familiar with the work of
Eckhart Tolle? Uh Eckhart Tolle, yes.
Okay, yeah. So, Tolle lives in Vancouver
like I do. And
in one of his books he says, the normal
state of mind of most human beings
contains a strong element of what we
would call dysfunction or even madness,
you know? So,
um
in medical um
parlance, normal means healthy and
natural. So, there's a normal range of
blood pressure, normal
temperature.
It's a range. Outside that range there's
no life. There's no health. Either too
high or too low, you're gone.
So, normal means it's it's equivalent
with synonymous with healthy and
natural.
However, we make that same assumption
that
our in society what we used to, what we
call normal, is also healthy and
natural, which is a myth cuz I'm saying
that in this society what we consider to
be normal is neither healthy nor
natural. In fact, it's heart hurtful to
us. So, that we're using the word normal
in in a way that
doesn't apply.
In the narrow medical sense,
it's accurate, but in the broader sense,
that which we used to in this society we
consider normal is just not good for us,
you know? And norm is kind of a
statistic or it's a kind of a
um average. So, if everybody have a dog,
if everybody in London mistreated their
dogs
and if you didn't, then you'd be
abnormal.
You know? So, it's a myth to say that
what is normal is healthy and natural.
That's what I mean by the myth of
normal. That's one one thing I mean. The
other thing I mean is
if we understand that the actual science
of the unity of everything, I'm not
talking about spiritual insight here.
I'm talking about, you know,
physiological science that our
physiology and psychology is very much
affected by our life experiences, being
in utero, childbirth, early childhood,
and throughout the lifetime.
It also follows that illness and health
are not individual attributes. They're
actually manifestations of our
relationships and our situation in the
world and and and our history.
That also means when the circumstances
are abnormal,
you expect people to be sick.
You know, just as if
you gave animals something that wasn't
healthy for them, they'd be sick. That'd
be what you'd expect.
So,
this idea that the people who are ill
either physically or mentally abnormal,
I say no. These are normal responses to
an abnormal set of circumstances.
And
rather than being sort of those abnormal
ones and then the rest of us,
it's really a spectrum
that we're all pretty much all on. It's
one of those three senses.
This idea of normal is is is a myth.
Uh and and it's one that keeps us from
seeing reality.
And we're all abnormal
in some way. Yeah. So, if you maybe
might might maybe my attention is
different, maybe my, you know, my my
interpersonal relationships are
abnormal, but in some way I'm going to
be abnormal. As it relates to
treatments, how do you think that the
medical profession and the psychological
profession would respond differently if
we remove this idea that there is a
normal? Mhm. How would how would our
approaches change to treating people?
Mhm.
Well, that's
it's it's a multi-layered answer. Um
first of all, we would recognize that
our diagnoses are not explanations for
anything.
So, you know,
I've been diagnosed with ADD, you know,
legitimately so. Uh my first book was on
it. Um
but but it
doesn't explain anything.
So,
so I tune out easily, very easily, you
know, and sometimes when I don't often
when I don't want to, but, you know,
unless I'm highly motivated.
So, so you might say this person has
ADD. How do we know? Cuz he tunes out a
lot.
Why does he tune out a lot? He's got
ADD. How do we know he's got ADD? Cuz he
tunes out a lot. So, the the the
So, first of all, we have to understand
that our understanding of normal and
what's outside the normal, they don't
doesn't explain anything.
They they can
they can describe, if you describe my
mental functioning as that of somebody
who's got an automatic tendency to tune
out, you'd be accurate.
So, as a description,
it's helpful. As an explanation as to
why this person isn't behaving, quote
unquote, normally,
it's doesn't explain a thing. No, if you
understood
that I spent my infancy
under very difficult circumstances where
I was very stressed because of all the
stuff I already talked about, and that
tuning out was a normal response
to to those circumstances as a way of
protecting myself from the stress of it
all.
And this is happening when my brain was
developing.
Then you'd understand there's nothing
abnormal about my my tuning out. In
fact, it is the normal response to a set
of abnormal circumstances.
So, that's the first point. And I could
go to the same kind of
dialectic with all manner of physical
and mental diseases, by the way,
so-called.
The
second point is Why do you say
so-called?
Um
Well, look, the disease model is
as long as we understand it's a model,
it's okay.
When we think it's describes reality
fully,
it doesn't. So, um
for example, um
we call we talk about mental illnesses.
And we're assuming that there's a kind
of definite pathology there just as in
rheumatoid arthritis, you can describe
the inflammation of the joints and
the blood levels of certain antibodies
being abnormal and
hormonal levels
being disturbed, you know.
We're making the same assumption in
mental illness. There's no such evidence
in mental illness.
There's no physiological parameters that
you can say somebody's got mental
illness.
There's just been a study
a few months ago of thousands of brain
scans
of people with mental illness diagnoses.
There's nothing diagnostic about them
about the brain scans.
It's not like I can take an x-ray of a
lung and say that this is this lung is
got what we call consolidation or or or
fluid
indicating inflammation.
There's nothing like that in mental
diagnoses. There's no blood test you can
do and so on. So, illness
is a is is a
is a model. I mean, it it might
if somebody's really depressed, um
even suicidal, perhaps, and they might
need pharmacological intervention, which
could really save their lives.
That may be true.
And in that sense, you may say that
they're ill.
As long as we realize that this is a
construct that we're applying here, but
that there is no actual measurement of
that that's at all similar to what we
call physical disease.
But even in physical disease, we make
certain assumptions.
Um
for example, somebody has rheumatoid
arthritis.
Now,
that nothing wrong with that statement
on the face of it, but there's an
assumption there.
The assumption is that there's this
thing called rheumatoid arthritis.
And there's this person called me.
And this person has this thing. Now, you
know, the example I often give. Here's
my cell phone. I'm holding it in my
hand. I have a cell phone. It's not part
of me. It says nothing about me.
It just it's it's a discrete object.
Its nature doesn't depend on my nature.
Nothing.
Is that true about rheumatoid arthritis?
Or is it more true to say, as I found
out, that this is a condition that shows
up in people with certain life
experiences and certain ways of
functioning in the world?
And that because of the
science document the unity of mind and
body and the
impossibility
of separating the activity of our
emotional apparatus from say our immune
system, cuz it's all one
organismic unit,
therefore, the when the immune system
turns against the body, as it does in
the rheumatoid arthritis, the immune
system actually attacks the body,
is that a thing that's got a life of its
own, or is it a process that's happening
inside that person because of certain
aspects of their lives?
Now, if I say it's a thing that happens
to you, then that thing has got a life
of its own. And that's how most doctors
see it. They see somebody with
rheumatoid arthritis, they say, "Okay,
this is the kind you've got. This is
what's going to happen. This is what
This is the only thing we can do is to
is to mitigate the symptoms."
I find that's not true.
I find that the rheumatoid By the Not
just I find it. The science finds it.
That rheumatoid arthritis is very much
related to stress and trauma.
And the more stress there is, the more
likely it is to flare up. And if people
deal with that stress, if they know how
to prevent it, their illness abates.
Which means that it's not a thing that's
separate. It's a process that happens
inside them.
This is a subtle concept, though. I'm
wondering if I'm explaining it clearly
enough.
No, you are. And it's And it's really
making me question how much we
misunderstand the the relationship
between the mind and the immune system.
Yeah. Because
that's the real That's the important
connection to understand if you if you
are to accept all the things you've just
said.
Yeah. Which we don't we don't understand
I don't think typically we understand
that my mind and my immune system have
such a close relationship. Well,
the There's a whole new science that
studies those relationships. It's called
psychoneuroimmunology,
which studies the interlinked unity of
the emotional apparatus of our brain and
body with the immune system, with the
nervous system, and with the hormonal
apparatus.
I mean, it's just so obvious.
I could change your hormonal state in
the split second right now without
touching you. Just by screaming at you
and threatening you.
That would necessarily create a change.
I mean, it's just clear that emotions
are inseparable, you know, and and the
other funny thing is Well, several funny
things.
How do we treat most conditions in
medicine? Right away, inflammations. If
you go to a dermatologist with inflamed
skin,
if you go to a rheumatologist with
inflamed joints,
if you go to a gastroenterologist with
inflamed intestines,
if you go to a respirologist with um
inflamed lungs, uh if you go to a
neurologist with inflamed nervous system
as in multiple sclerosis, they're going
to give you steroids
to settle the inflammation. Now, what
are steroids? They are stress hormones.
And you would think that as physicians,
we would ask ourselves, "Gosh, we're
treating everything with stress
hormones. Does stress maybe have
something to do with this condition?"
And when you look at the scientific
literature, yes, yes, yes, and yes. So,
the
um There's a great Canadian physician,
actually knighted by Queen Victoria, one
of the great medical teachers of all
kinds, Sir William Osler, and he said in
1890 that rheumatoid arthritis is a
stress-driven disease.
The the French uh neurologist
Jean-Martin Charcot, who first described
multiple sclerosis, he said, "This is a
stress-driven condition."
And since then, there's been so much
research.
So,
what what I'm saying is that this this
way of looking at
what we call disease as a process
is so much more accurate scientifically,
actually, in understanding the mind-body
unity. And then, you know, naturally,
when people are traumatized, that has a
huge impact on their physiology. Their
psychological trauma is a huge impact on
their physiology. It's just science.
But it's science that's not taught to
medical teach medical doctors. It's just
for some strange reason. Well,
the average physician never hears a
single lecture about, say, trauma and
its relationship to illness. And yet,
there's studies internationally,
thousands of them,
showing those relationships.
So, there's this strange gap between
science and and medical practice. But it
would it would change medical practice
for the better.
Because what would happen if you went to
a physician and you presented with your
symptom, and they'd they'd say, "Okay,
look, we'll give you such and such
medication to deal with your symptoms.
And then, let's look at your life
in the context that you live it and see
how that the stresses that you may be
taking on, the traumas you may be
carrying might be affecting the
physiology of your body."
Now, they don't have to be all trauma
therapists to do that. They just have to
raise the question
and to start and and to begin the
inquiry. That'll make a huge change to
that person's life and to their disease
process.
And clearly to their kids' lives as
well, because I remember reading in your
book about the the study with the rats.
Yeah. Um and how they Could you tell me
about that study? How the stress study
with the rats and how the parents um
treatment of a child
impacted their stress response and then
also they passed that on, which I
thought was stunning. Yeah, that was a
very interesting study. It was done in
Canada at McGill University.
Um I think maybe sometime in the last 20
years,
early 2000s, I think.
And
they looked at how mother rats
interacted with their infants, their
newborns.
And some and there's a process called
grooming
in which the mother rat licks the
infant around the perineal
perineal or perianal area, you know, on
the genitalia.
This is shortly after birth. These
mother rats just start licking their
infants.
Some mother rats did it in a more
efficient and caring kind of way than
other mother rats.
Those that had the better kind of
caring, the better kind of grooming,
grew to be calmer
and responded to stress in more
functional ways than those little rats
who
as neonates had not been given that same
kind of
efficient and quite as
caring
grooming.
And what they found that in the brains
of those adult rats who had been groomed
one way or the other
as infants, the stress apparatus was
different. Certain receptors for the
stress hormones. So, one of them could
calm themselves more easily than the
other.
What was interesting is you might say,
"Well, so what? That's just genetic. The
calmer mothers passed on their genes to
their infants." No, they didn't. Cuz if
you took the infants of mothers who
groomed beautifully
and put them with mothers who didn't,
and conversely, you took the infant rats
of mothers who
um didn't groom so well, but you put
them with mothers who did,
it changed. It changed the brain and
it's for for the adult. It changed the
brain?
Yeah, it changed the genetic
functioning, not the genes,
but the genetic functioning. This is
called epigenetics, how genes are turned
on and off by the environment.
And then, those mother and those rats
who were groomed well as infants,
doesn't matter
what their original mother was, but
those rats who were groomed well, they
went on to groom their infants
in exactly the way they'd been groomed.
So, this is how we pass on our parenting
stuff
from one generation to the next, both
behaviorally, but also through the
turning on or off of certain genes.
So, in essence, the how nurturing our
parents were has a big impact on our own
ability to handle stress positively or
negatively. Oh, absolutely. And then we
pass that down to our
How stressed our parents were,
how they reacted to our own stresses as
infants, you know,
uh that has everything to do with how
our brains handle stress later on.
And so, some people just don't handle
stress very well. They don't handle
frustration very well.
You should have seen me this morning at
the hotel when the swimming pool didn't
open in time, you know?
But I I was a lot better than I might
have been years ago, you know? Uh
but yeah, our stress response is very
much programmed by our early
developmental experiences.
Speaking about our early experiences,
the first word in this sort of subtitle
of your book is the word trauma. Yeah.
Um it's a word that I've I've talked
about a lot on this podcast and I've,
you know, I've had a lot of people here
that have opened up about their traumas.
How How do you define trauma? I know
society's defined it in its own way, but
how do you define it, the word?
I define it very specifically. Um
it's not something bad that happens to
you. It's not some It's not that way.
You know, I went to this movie last
night and I was traumatized. No, you
weren't. You were just sad or you were
had some emotional pain, but you weren't
traumatized.
Trauma means a wound. That's the literal
meaning of the word. It's a Greek word
for wounding.
So, trauma is a psychological wound that
you sustain.
And um
it behaves like a wound. So, on the one
hand,
a wound, if it's very raw, if you touch
it, it just really hurts. So, if if I
have a wound around not being wanted,
then
or or the belief that I'm not,
then decades later, if anything reminds
me of that, it hurts as much as it did
when I originally incurred the wound.
So, in in one sense, trauma is an
unhealed wound that touched, we get
triggered. That's what triggering means,
by the way. So, an old wound wound
that's
activated or touched. The other thing
that happens to wounds is that they scar
over.
And scar tissue has certain
characteristics. It's thick.
It has no nerve ending, so there's no
feeling in it. So, people traumatized
disconnect from their feelings.
Um scar tissue is rigid. It's not
flexible. So, we lose kind of response
flexibility. So, when something happens,
we tend to react in typical,
stereotypical, predictable,
dysfunctional ways cuz of the rigidity.
And scar tissue doesn't grow like
healthy flesh. So, people who are
traumatized tend to be stuck in
emotional states that characterized
their development when they were
traumatized. So, when somebody says to
you,
"Don't be such a baby."
Uh
doesn't sound very pleasant, but there's
some truth to it. It means that you're
probably reacting according to lines of
some wound that you sustained as an
infant. And now you're you're reacting
as if that wound was happening all over
again. This is what one of my friends in
the trauma world, Peter Levine, calls
the tyranny of the past.
So, something happens in the present
and we react
as if we're back there in the past when
this first happened.
And we're not in the present moment at
all.
And I was I was trying to figure out how
many people um as a percentage of the
population have a
have trauma.
But then I I I you know, I read this
stat that 60% of adults um say that
they've had a sort of a traumatic early
upbringing whatever or traumatic events
from their childhood. But then I
thought, maybe everybody has trauma.
It depends on um how we understand
trauma.
So, if we understand trauma as only the
really terrible things that happen to
people, which do happen to people,
you know,
in the book I talked about
a British friend of mine who was now
living in Canada.
Um they are a yoga teacher and a
meditation teacher
and a psychologist
and an artist, actually.
And they grew up in some orphanage here
in Britain where they were racially
taunted every every morning, you know,
words that are in the book by her
permission, which I'm not going to cite
here publicly.
And that gave her a sense of deficient,
a sense of self that I'm just not good
enough, that I don't belong, and so on.
There's those obvious traumas or the
obvious trauma of being sexually abused.
So,
men who are sexually abused, according
to Canadian study, have triple the rate
of heart attacks as adults,
you know, and all kinds of physiological
reasons. But that should be the case.
So, there's those
self-evident large big T traumas that we
call big T trauma, okay, T with a
capital T, trauma with a capital T.
There's a certain percentage of the
population, much larger than we think,
subject to that. If you include
um
all the known factors such as physical,
sexual, or emotional abuse. Spanking, by
the way, has not been shown to be as
traumatic as
harsher forms of physical abuse.
Spanking, which is still recommended by
so-called experts who shall remain
remain unnamed for the moment. Uh the
death of a parent, violence in the
family, violence parental violence
against each other,
um a parent being jailed,
a parent being mentally ill.
Did I say a parent being addicted? A
rancorous divorce. These are the
identified big traumas, big T traumas.
Not not to mention poverty,
not to mention extreme inequality, um
war, and so on.
But then,
if you remember that trauma is not what
happens to you, but what happens inside
you,
it's the wound. People can be wounded
not just by bad things happening to
them, but small children can be wounded
in loving families
where they don't get their needs met.
I mean, that's obvious in a physical
sense.
If a child doesn't get proper nutrition,
their their body will suffer. Their mind
will suffer.
We we're also creatures with emotional
needs as important as our physical
needs.
So, when the child's emotional needs are
not met, that child is wounded.
That's what we call small t trauma,
which is not the big ticket events such
as I described, but just a child's need
to be loved unconditionally, to be held
when distressed, to be responded to, to
be seen, to be heard, to be allowed
their full range of emotion without them
being stamped on in the name of
so-called discipline. Um
the right to play
creatively,
spontaneously, out there in nature, not
with these damn digital gadgets that
subvert and uh
hijack the child's imagination,
but spontaneous play that's essential
for brain development.
So, what I'm saying is that when these
needs are not for the
unconditional loving attachment
relationship, when those needs are
frustrated, children are also hurt. And
I call that trauma as well because it
shows up later in life as the impact of
painful wounds.
So, trauma in this society, for all
kinds of reasons, is far more common
than we imagine.
From sitting here and speaking to, I
don't know, somewhere over a hundred
different people that come from all
walks of life, but specifically people
that are successful in their industries,
and you talked about, you know,
how um
an anomalous early upbringing can create
sort of abnormality in an adult. A lot
of people I sit here are successful
because of some kind of abnormality, or
at least their interpretation of some
kind of early event that caused them to
have some sort of abnormal belief about
themselves that they're not enough, so
they become a billionaire or a gold
medalist or whatever it might be. Yeah.
One of the things that I thought I could
predict is
I thought I could, if they told me, I
thought after doing a hundred episodes,
if they told me the traumatic event
they'd been through, I could predict the
the outcome in them. Mhm. But there's a
disconnect there because, you know, I'd
sit here with a guest who went through
one of your tall um capital T traumas
like domestic violence.
Yeah.
And
one of them might become incredibly
angry. Yeah. And one of them might
become the most peaceful, loving person
I've ever met. Yeah. And that taught me
that there's this thing in between the
event, which is what you call
interpretation. Yeah.
And I found that really I found that as
that kind of makes it really difficult
to diagnose. Well, now look, so the two
examples you gave, um
that really peaceful person, maybe
really peaceful for genuinely good
reasons such as they found
the milk of human love flowing through
their veins and they've had some
spiritual mm reconciliation with the
world, or they may have lit genuinely
learned compassion for themselves and
others.
But they could also be very nice and
peaceful cuz they're suppressing their
healthy anger.
Because they're actually sitting on
their rage unconsciously,
which is going to show up in the form of
some kind of health manifestation, I
guarantee you, later on. So, you can't
tell from the outside
without asking some questions.
Uh
Or I can give you the example of of a
Donald Trump
who
had a really traumatic childhood. I
mean, his father was a this as described
by his psychologist niece, Mary Trump,
his father Trump's father,
who is Mary's grandfather,
was a psychopath.
And who really uh demeaned and harshly
treated their their children.
So, Trump decides unconsciously
that, by the way, I'm not talking about
his policies here. I'm not this is not a
political debate.
And in the book I point out that his
opponent was also traumatized, uh
Hillary Clinton. So, this is this is a
uh
ecumenical uh view of trauma and
politics. I'm not choosing sides.
I'm just saying that you can see his
trauma in every moment he opens his
mouth.
His grandiosity, his need to make
himself bigger, more powerful,
aggressive, and he has much as said in
his autobiography that the world is a
horrible place, a dog-eat-dog place
where everybody is after you. Everybody
wants your wife and your house and your
wealth, and this is your friends.
Never mind your enemies. That's the
world he lives in. Now, that world that
he lives in reflects his childhood home.
He developed that world view.
He came to it honestly, you might say,
cuz that's the world that he lived in.
And he gets to be really successful in
this crazy world.
You know, financially, although people
question,
you know, was he really as big a success
as he says he was?
But he certainly was successful
politically if by success you mean the
attainment of power.
His brother, on the other hand, Mary
Trump's father, Trump's niece's father,
drank himself to death.
And they were both responses to the same
You can never say it's exactly the same
for two kids, but there was that there
was that toxic home environment. One of
them ends up dead as an alcoholic.
The other ends up at the pinnacle of
power.
Um
And when I look at them both,
I see dysfunction there, significant
dysfunction there.
So, one of them one of those the
consequences of that early upbringing
was it materialized itself as sort of
addiction.
And the other got the same psychological
reinforcement or the thing missing from
power and work and money.
Well, well, well, well, well, Donald
Trump learned that the way to survive is
to be aggressive and harsh and
competitive and to get the other before
they get to you,
which is a faithful reproduction of his
early childhood experiences. So, for him
these were not choices so much as
survival
techniques and uh
when they talk about his
lying,
well,
I don't know when he's lying or when
he's not, but my sense is that often he
actually believes what he's saying.
And actually his biographer or the
person who
co-wrote his
quasi-autobiographical, The Art of the
Deal, this this writer says that he's
never met anybody who's so capable of
believing something that's not true to
be true if he wants it to be true.
Now, that's the mark of a traumatized
child.
You know, a denial of reality.
It is an inauguration, there was a
certain number of people that came to
the
He couldn't stand it that there weren't
as many people there as came to Barack
Obama's
inauguration. There were much smaller
number of people there.
He created this reality where many more
people came to his inauguration.
Now, what age behavior is that?
That's a four-year-old with more kids
came to his party than my party. That
can't be true.
But that's Donald's way of dealing with
reality.
It's not a moral failing as such. That's
how he survived.
And these survival um mechanisms for
then be get to form our personalities.
And
again, in this world, sometimes they pay
off
in certain ways.
Is that is that often the case with
pathological liars? They've learned to
lie as a way to survive.
Oh, absolutely. The the the German
philosopher writer, Nietzsche, Friedrich
Nietzsche, said, "People lie their way
out of reality who have been hurt by
reality."
And so,
I've lied,
you know, like when I had my shopping
addiction,
I lied every day to my wife.
You know, and even afterwards,
when she tried when she stopped trying
to change my behavior,
I said, "Just tell me
if you're going to shop, you're going to
spend another thousand dollars on music,
just tell me."
I still couldn't.
Cuz
I was so ashamed of it.
And so, the lying became like a
a way of survival for me. Defense
against reality.
It's a defense against reality and it's
defense against
um being judged.
You know?
Well, that says something about my
childhood, you know? Nobody's born a
liar. As we say in this book, there are
congenial liars, but there there are no
congenital liars. No one-day-old baby
tells any lies. No one-day-old baby
pretends anything. If we end up
pretending in any way at all to the
extent that we do, it's because we had
to learn that's what we must do to
survive.
You said something at the start when I
gave the example that I have this I sat
with a guest here who went through
domestic abuse.
Yeah. And they are the calmest person.
And then you said, "Well, maybe they're
suppressing it." And in fact,
the minute you said that, it reminded me
of something they said, which is they
they said to me on this podcast that
they had um
angry outbursts all the time.
So, sometimes their child will come up
to them Yeah. um and want to play when
they're working, and they'll snap. Yeah.
And they're trying to they're trying to
deal with that. Yeah. That's what I
meant, that they're sitting on this
mm
crater of
volcanic crater of anger, which
sometimes bursts out of them. So, their
their demeanor is like a really
developed, suppressed
um way of handling rage,
which rage, when they were children, had
they expressed, would have gotten them
into more trouble. So, suppressing it,
repressing it,
became their survival It's all about
survival, you see. So, it became their
survival mechanism. Now,
that person, as long as they keep it
that way, they're
at risk.
They're at risk for
mental health diagnosis like depression.
Cuz what do we what is depression? It
means you're pushing something down.
That's what it means.
What do we push down?
Our natural emotions. Why do we push
them down? Cuz we have to to survive. So
that that person I I I don't know. I
can't prognosticate what's going to
happen to them, but if they don't work
it out,
in general,
they're at risk for some kind of mental
or physical manifestation. That's my
experience.
Quick one. Some of you may know we got a
brand new sponsor on this podcast,
American Express. And you've got a brand
new exclusive offer for a limited which
I can't wait to tell you about. From the
18th of October to the 16th of November,
American Express is offering new card
members a 60,000 point membership reward
as a welcome bonus when you join. When
you spend a minimum of 8,000 pounds
across the first 3 months. This is
simply a thank you for joining American
Express. And for those that don't know,
you can use your American Express
Business Platinum Card points in
exchange for various rewards such as
booking travel, holidays, gift cards,
and so much more. So essentially, you're
rewarded with huge prizes for just using
their card to spend on your usual
purchases. And I've had a look through
at what 60,000 points can get you. So if
you'd like to find out how you can get
your hands on your new American Express
Business Card, then search American
Express Business Platinum Card to find
out more.
Quick one from our longest standing
sponsor, Huel.
I I can't tell you over the last I'd say
over the last really it's been about 2
and 1/2 years. It was really um
post-pandemic how much my health has
become such a huge priority in my life.
Huel has been probably the most
important partner in my health journey
because
I've been in the boardrooms. I've been
to their offices
tens and tens and tens and tens of
times. I've seen how they make their
decisions on nutrition. And that's why
it's such a wonderful thing to be able
to talk to this audience about a brand
and a product that is so unbelievably
linked to my values and the and the the
place I am in my life of valuing the
gym, exercise, movement, my mind, my
breathing, and all of those things, and
most importantly, my nutrition. That is
the role Huel Huel plays. And so every
time I get to read these ads I do it
with such passion because I really
really believe every word I'm saying,
and I absolutely love the brand. So if
you haven't already tried Huel and
you've been resistant to my my
pestering, then give it a go and let me
know how you get on.
You talked about expressing one's
emotions. And something you've talked
about in this book, but also previously,
is this idea that there is such a thing
as healthy anger. Yeah. Um it's one of
the seven A's of your of healing, as you
say. The first being the topic a topic
we've talked about already, which is
acceptance.
Yeah.
Um
the next being awareness.
Well, awareness that we should have put
into this book, but we didn't.
Not into this book. Uh in this book I
put four A's, and uh I left out
awareness, and that was an omission on
my part. Really? Yeah, it was. I'm
sorry, but it was.
So in the book you have authenticity,
anger, acceptance, A- A- A- acceptance
and and agency, yeah. Yeah, and yeah,
acceptance.
Yeah. So
awareness you've said before before this
book that awareness is the starting
point.
Yeah.
I found that to be so true in my life,
but it's not very easy. I feel like
awareness is a is a luxury or a
privilege that is very hard fought.
Yeah. Because you're guessing. Yeah.
You're guessing ba- based on pattern
recognition. So I was guessing 25 years
old I can't get into relationship.
Anytime a girl comes near me, even af-
I've pursued her, I run off. Mhm. And to
figure out why I was doing that, to even
identify the behavior pattern go that's
not helpful. That's not going to lead me
to feeling whole. Yeah.
Um where does that come from? Took 25
years and a lot of like introspection.
But but most people they're living
unaware of the puppet master of trauma
that is driving their life. That's a
really good analogy. It's the trauma
really is like a
a puppet master behind the scenes so in
the unconscious pulling your strings,
and you're not aware of it, you know?
Do you remember Pinocchio? Yeah. So you
remember what
Pinocchio says at the end where he when
he finally becomes a real boy? Yeah,
yeah, yeah. He says, "How foolish I was
when I was a puppet."
And to the extent that we're being
activated by these
unconscious strings that are traumas
pulling behind the scenes,
and we're acting in our lives and we
think we're autonomous free beings, but
we're actually being controlled by
something in the past that we haven't
worked out, we're puppets.
We're actually puppets.
And and and and there's not there's not
much freedom in that.
There's no there's no freedom in it at
all.
So I mean
I suppose the opposite of trauma, if you
want to revisit that question, is is
liberation.
Interesting.
Liberation and and by reconnection. By
reconnection, but liberation from the
from the inexorable power of the
unconscious. Which is like cutting the
strings in a in a way. Kind of brings me
to I there's kind of two ways I want to
go with that. The first question I have
about about trauma and the puppet master
analogy is
do we ever do we ever really cut the
strings? Or do we just kind of learn to
pull against them when they try and tell
us to do something with more force than
they're exerting in the opposite
direction?
Um
that doesn't work very well.
Pushing against it because they're still
reactive. You're still not in charge.
You're just in automatic resistance mode
to something. There's no freedom in that
either.
You know? It's a still a So yeah.
Um
but awareness that you mentioned is huge
because once you're aware that there's
this
See, the thing about these strings may
not fray right away.
But once you're aware that ah
this reaction of mine
it's not about what's going on right
now. There's something old being
activated here. That awareness alone
weakens the it slackens the strings a
bit. Now you're no long- they're no
longer as taut. They're no longer as
automatically um
capable of pulling on you.
So it does have to begin begin with
awareness of them.
Ultimately,
if we realize that this puppet master is
just a desperate little person trying to
get you to survive the only way
he she they knew how when you were small
when they were small, if you make
friends with it,
but we relieve it of its duties,
saying thanks very much, but I can
handle it now.
It it eventually becomes a friend rather
than sort of our
master, you know?
On that first step of just
acknowledging, just understanding that
there is a puppet master that
controlling us, and exactly what strings
that puppet master is is pulling in our
lives, how does one go about
awareness, the process of awareness? Is
that I mean is it introspection, keeping
a diary, therapy? What what is it? Well,
all of that. I mean it all or any. But
even when you ask how you go about it,
what is the it? Well, for you to say how
to go about it, you already must have
some degree of awareness. If you didn't,
you wouldn't even be asking the
question.
So that's the very first step
of realizing that there's something here
to work on. There's something here to
work through. It does not need to be the
way it is. That already is the biggest
step. The Buddha said that that that
to to recognize the source of your
suffering is the first step towards
relieving the suffering. And so
as soon as you ask how you go about it,
you've already taken a huge step. Cuz
cuz a lot of people don't even know that
there's an it.
They just think this is a reality, that
this is life. So real- realizing that
this it doesn't have to be the way it
is, that's already a huge step. Now,
beyond that,
yoga, meditation, um
nature,
um therapy of all kinds, bodywork,
um of all kinds like like like somatic
experiencing or um
or um
craniosacral treatments, or even massage
therapy. Um it's incredible what can be
revealed just through bodywork like
that. Then you all kinds of forms of
therapy, the ones I teach, the ones
other people teach.
Um journaling,
um certain exercises in this book that
we recommend, like
just ask yourself why you have trouble
saying no in life to things you don't
really want to do, and working that
through on a regular basis. So there's a
lots of ways once you open the door.
You know?
I have a chapter on psychedelics here,
which is uh
again, it's not like a panacea or for
everyone, but certainly it's a helpful
modality for a lot of people.
So um
some people may actually benefit from
taking pharmaceutical medications
if their situation is dire enough,
but not as the final answer, but as a
way of getting respite that allow them
to go to work on the real issues
that caused them to be depressed or
anxious or tuning out. You know, so any
and all of these things. A lot of people
don't even want to open those doors,
though.
Because they there's so much pain
associated with maybe going back or
revisiting an early experience that they
just think it's better keep the doors
shut. Yeah.
Um and get get to tomorrow.
That's true.
Um to which I have two answers.
Um one is it's true, it's painful.
Um because
all the pain you didn't want to feel and
you've been running away from through
your compensatory behaviors like like
your addictions are nothing but an
attempt to escape from pain. That's all
they are. That's all they you know,
they're not a disease, they're not
genetic
whatever it is.
Addictions are very simply an attempt to
escape pain.
Which create more pain.
But that's what they are.
And so we get addicted to work, to sex,
to pornography, to gambling, to the
internet, to shopping, to eating, to
power. On that point, I I find it so
fascinating you that when you mentioned
in your previous book that you know, you
classify things like food, Yeah. social
media, Yeah. shopping, Yeah. porn, and
work as types of addiction.
That was That in and of itself was a bit
of a revelation for me because I never
saw work as an addiction. The minute you
said it was, and I kind of link it to,
you know, heroin addiction, which is
providing a you know, a certain
psychological or physiological
benefit to me,
temporarily,
I of course it's a [ __ ] addiction. Of
course work is an addiction. Of course I
have that addiction.
Work can be an addiction. Work can also
be fulfilling and a manifestation of
your creative urges,
but it's so it's not the
but it's strange to say
not that I recommend it, but it's
possible even to use heroin in a
non-addictive way.
I don't personally get it and I would
never want to,
but the addiction is never in the
behavior itself, it's in your
relationship to the behavior. So if
the particular activity gives you
temporary relief or pleasure and
therefore you crave it,
but it causes harm in the long term and
you can't give it up, you've got an
addiction and I don't care what the
activity is. Could be drugs and all the
other things that we mentioned. And it
and
and it employs the same brain circuits
by the way. The workaholic is after the
same brain chemical that the cocaine
addict is after,
dopamine.
You know,
and people can be in the even addicted
to their own stress hormones like
adrenaline. You know, the so-called
adrenaline junkies. There's such a
thing. You know, so almost anything can
be addictive
if it serves the purpose of temporarily
easing some distress but causing harm in
the long term. Is is escapism the right
word to use then for it if we're
cuz it it doesn't sound as much like
we're escaping
rather than we are seeking something.
We're seeking relief
from a certain mental state.
Like like
I just gave you a definition of
addiction so think I don't know what
addictions you've had or haven't or have
or haven't beside you know, but what did
that do for you
temporarily?
It gave you something. It made me feel
like I was valid and I was pursuing
a sense of accomplishment and validation
and I was a sense of worth. Worth, yeah,
I was worthy. Yeah. Is that something
that people need or not?
Yes. Yeah, that's a good thing.
But the real question is
why did you ever get the idea that you
didn't have the worth? Why did I get the
idea that I didn't have the worth?
That's where trauma comes in. Cuz I was
called the N-word when I was eight by a
kid in school. Exactly. And then then I
no one was nice to me after that. And
because your mother screamed at your
father. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, and
and and so all that together. And so
and that's emotionally painful. Like
what's it feel like to be not to have a
sense of worth? That's painful. And so
that's where my mantra is don't ask why
the addiction, ask why the pain.
And if you want to understand why the
pain, you have to look at that person's
life.
And what the benefit of the addiction
is. That's something that you say in in
your previous book that I found
it's a it's a flipping of narrative
where you say we should be asking what
the benefit of the addiction is. Well,
and like in your case,
it gives you a sense of worth. Well,
okay,
I'll say to you
if you come to me cuz you say like I'm a
workaholic, it's causing some harm in my
life, it's keeping keeping me from
intimate relationships, it makes me
stressed and tired, whatever it is.
The first thing I would ask you for you
of you is
what is it doing for you? And you say a
sense of worth. And I'd say, you know
what?
You deserve to have a sense of worth.
I totally understand why you'd want to
engage in an activity that gives it to
you.
But given that it's causing you harm,
let's look at why you don't have a sense
of worth and how else you might develop
it that isn't harmful to you, you know?
So but you you start with what's right
about it. What are you looking for? And
what you're looking for is always valid.
And how one would go about How would one
go about getting that sense of worth?
I'm asking for a friend.
Well,
that would be a matter of
some form of work.
People who meditate
often
deal with that issue through the
meditation, not always.
Certainly therapy,
you know?
By recognizing also that what you're
doing to get the sense of worth doesn't
really do it for you. Just by getting
honest about it, you know?
So there's all kinds of ways, but
the first step is the recognition.
That's the first step that you say is
missing missing from the book, which is
that sort of awareness. The next thing
which I've been it's been really front
of mind in my life recently cuz I've
been asked this a few times on stage and
I've been trying to find the words to
really
articulate the importance of it is and
this is one of your four A's in this
book about how to heal is authenticity.
Really interesting concept because I've
been trying to articulate why the fact
that I've just shared all this stuff
with you
and the fact that I do this every week,
I'm I'm getting closer and closer to
that sort of authentic self where
there's really the mask is kind of
dropping on me. Why that's been so
healing for me? Why is authenticity such
a good way an important way for us to
heal?
It's much more than the way for us to
heal. It's actually who we are. Like
what you're asking what you're asking is
why is it important for a creature to be
true to its own nature?
Cuz
that's what we're meant to do. Are we
meant to be here as ourselves?
You know, and and and when we're not
ourselves because we had to abandon
ourselves or
betray ourselves or disconnect from
ourselves in order to survive,
we lost connections with our essence.
And
I mean how does it feel
to
be a successful CEO and you know,
more than realizing your
financial dreams,
but to be a workaholic and and and and
and not to be available to yourself
in areas of your life that really matter
to you
as opposed to
being honest about your stuff,
sharing it with other people,
dropping the veil, dropping the I mean
to answer your question,
what does it feel like I mean that can
you sense the difference in your body?
Feel the lighter. Well, yeah. Expansive.
Exactly. Well, that's the answer. Yeah.
That's why it's important.
Is it I so many of us so many of us
live inauthentic lives because as you
said it's it's because either
because from an early age we were
escaping
some kind of you know, reality in order
to help us to survive or then the other
thing that happens a bit later on in
life is we develop an identity which
becomes a career which becomes a social
circle which becomes a prison
of
our inauthentic selves. We get trapped
in there.
You know, because I was good at
something or because I you know, I I
felt accepted in this job as a lawyer.
So I am now living inauthentically as
this robot in this prison. Um
and it's a it's a
there's often a real perception of risk
and loss and danger
of trying to get out of that prison, of
trying to get close to our authentic
selves.
We feel like we'll lose our friendship
circle. We'll feel like we'll we'll let
our parents down who wanted us to become
a lawyer.
You know, all of these things.
I guess you see that a lot in your in
your work. Well, that there is that risk
and but here's the issue. As a child,
you had no choice
but to go for
acceptance and being approved of and
being received
under any under any conditions. No
matter what you had to give up of your
authenticity. You had to give up your
authenticity. You had no choice in the
matter.
At a certain point as adults, we get we
learn that this lack of authenticity
this disconnection from ourselves, this
separation from our good feelings
is costing us.
It's costing us in terms of our physical
health, our our our peace of mind, our
relationship, our mental health and so
on.
You'll never be as vulnerable again as
you were as when you were a child.
You'll never be as helpless, as
dependent, as
resourceless.
No, it's true that if you developed a
whole set of relationships based on your
inauthentic persona, some people
in your life may not like it if you
gradually move towards authenticity.
They may not like it. It's not what they
wanted from you.
You're going to find out who your
friends are.
You're really going to find cuz your
real friends will say, "Oh, we're so
happy for you.
We were waiting for this."
Other friends will say, "It's not what I
signed up for." You know,
the question is you still have to
decide.
As an infant, as a young child, I had no
agency
in the choice of authenticity and
attachment. Now I do.
Which one do you want to go with? What
is the cost of being inauthentic?
I can't make that decision for anybody
else. Nobody can make that decision for
anybody else, but
most people will find that choosing
authenticity has benefits
way beyond whatever they might lose.
That's what I find.
And you said the word that agency, which
is the second of the four A's on how to
heal. Now agency when when you when I
read that word, I I hear like personal
responsibility, taking personal
responsibility over my life. Exactly.
But it also means not letting you know,
you don't use trauma you don't wear
trauma as a badge,
you know, or you don't use it as a get
out of jail pass in the game of
Monopoly. "Oh, I was traumatized so I
can't
I can't be any other way." You know, I
mean giving all the power to the puppet
master.
Exactly.
So agency means actually I take
responsibility, not for what happened to
me.
Not even how I interpreted the world as
a result going backwards, but how I
interpret the world from now on. Do I
still want to interpret the world and my
role in it based on some decision I made
when I was a 1-year-old. That's where
agency comes in. Agency also means that
if I have
any kind of dysfunction or illness, it's
not just that I put my hands in the
hands of a put my my faith in the hands
of a a physician or a healer, but I I
have a I make the decisions. I listen to
the advice. I accept some, I don't
accept some, but I'm the one who's
making the decisions along with what
seems right to me.
So, agency.
It's interesting in your in your work
throughout your work you use
alliteration as a lot as a way to kind
of summarize and make ideas really
memorable.
It really helps. It's an old trick. It's
a trick. It's a writing trick, right?
it also works, you know, the before ways
or
uh
The four arms I don't I don't want to
say you know what I'm I'm I'm
I'm denigrating my work if I say it's a
trick. No, it's just something just the
way things occur to me. That's all it
is.
One of the one of the um
alliteration devices you use is also
relates to limiting beliefs and how we
can undo Yeah. self-limiting beliefs
with the five Rs. Yeah. Relabel,
reattribute, refocus, re- re- value, and
recreate.
Yeah. Now, from what I
understood of those, relabeling is
the story and the belief that is
limiting to us.
Well, well,
let's take something like um your
workaholism. Yeah.
I need to go to work. I need to do this
work. Yeah.
Relabeling is
I don't need to do this work. I just
have a belief that I need to do this
work. Okay. So, that relabeling just
takes a degree of separation from the
behavior.
And and actually it's true. It's not
that you need to do all this work. You
have this belief. So, relabeling just
says it for what it is. By the way,
I have to
acknowledge that I these these five Rs,
only one of them is mine. I stole the
other four
from a psychiatrist.
That's honest. I I just I I I mentioned
that in the book, but I I find it very
helpful technique, but the the it was
developed for people with
obsessive-compulsive tendencies. So, the
relabel is not that I have to wash my
hand 100 times. I just have a belief
that I have to wash my hand 100 times.
Uh that's the context in which it was
developed. I think it works for all
kinds of belief all kinds of
dynamics. And then if I and then so I've
relabeled it.
I don't have to work to feel a sense of
validation, but I have a belief that I
do. That's right. And then I reattribute
it, which is the second R. Which means I
get clear on where it's come from. Yeah,
so
let's say you have the belief that
you're not worth it.
It's not true that I'm not worth it. I
just have a belief that I'm not worth
it.
Okay?
It may not be true that I'm not worth
it, but I do have a belief that I'm not
worth it.
Re- um attribute means
this is an old brain circuit sending me
an old message. It's got nothing to do
with reality. It has to do with some
experience that I had a long time ago.
That's the reattribute. You just say
where is it actually coming from?
There's a circuit in your brain that's
wired with the message
you're not worth it.
And it's going to keep repeating that
message.
Well, you say, "Okay, that's where it's
coming from." Until I refocus, which is
the third R. Yeah. So, refocus is just
to give yourself some space.
So, if you have a say
I need to go to work,
uh okay, refocus means well, for 5
minutes
maybe in 5 minutes I go to work, but for
5 minutes I won't. I'm going to
put on some piece of music or go for a
walk or meditate or whatever. So, you
refocus, you put your attention
somewhere else.
I just just so that to prove to yourself
that you actually have some agency over
your brain.
If only for 5 minutes.
If you have this belief that I'm not
worth it.
Well, you can go back to it in 5 minutes
if you want.
Just for 5 minutes though consider all
the ways that you've made a
contribution.
Consider all the ways that people have
acknowledged your
benign presence in their lives.
The times that people have told you that
they've loved you or that you told
somebody else. Just for 5 minutes hang
out with that.
5 minutes later you want to go back to
this belief that or if you can't help
going back to this belief that you're
not worth it, well, that's okay. But at
least create some space. It's all about
creating space
between yourself and these beliefs or
these behaviors.
And in that 5 minutes you're you're
basically accepting new evidence to be
true or you're proving that other
evidence is true. I didn't need to go
and work. Well, you're also proving that
you don't have to spend all your time
subjected to those beliefs. You can take
a hiatus from it.
At least for a while. And then they are
not you. They're not you, yeah. And then
revalue.
Um
revalue re-evaluate really what it
should mean or
maybe more accurately devalue because
you say, "What has it been the actual
value? This belief that I'm not worth
it. What has been the actual value of it
in my life? Or this tendency of mine to
be a workaholic. What has it been the
actual value?"
Oh, it made me tired. It made me
alienated. Or it keeps me depressed. Or
it keeps me
hopelessly trying to prove something
which I can never prove to myself anyway
through external activity. So, you
actually look at what has been its
actual impact on your life.
What has been its real value?
Um Sometimes the value is positive
though, right? Like I think about my own
workaholic workaholism, if that's the
term. I think oh, there's some there's
some positives here. Yeah. Not
negatives. Yeah. Well,
it is the positive due to workaholism or
is it due to your capacity to work hard
in in in behalf of a goal? They're not
the same.
Mhm. Your capacity to work hard to
achieve a certain goal is simply a gift
that you have.
And something that maybe takes some
discipline and application on your part.
That's not workaholism. That's just
a strong positive work ethic.
The workaholism is when you're driven to
work
you actually don't need to.
It's funny cuz it reminds me of that
analogy I've been talking about in the
last couple of episodes of this podcast
the distinction between being driven and
being dragged. Yeah. It's like am I
which side of the lorry am I flying down
the motorway? Am I attached to the front
and am I running and pulling the lorry
or am I just like my ankles attached to
the back of the lorry as it flies down
the motorway because I'm being dragged.
Well, if I may, I would say that neither
of those are particularly desirable.
Neither. Um but but but but but it's the
distinction that I made before between
being driven and being called. Yeah. Cuz
if you're called, you see if I call you
say, "Steven, would you come and have
dinner with me?"
You can say yes, you can say no. I just
gave you a call and you can say
literally I'm talking about a call now,
you know, a telephone call. You know,
you can say yes, you can say no. It's a
decision though. But but but but it's
the distinction that I Yeah. When you're
dragged or pushed or pulled, you're not
making the decision.
to the decision
Yeah. That's right. to the activity.
One of the um one of the really
interesting things I wanted to talk to
you about is is ADHD. Yeah. Um I've had
a few of my friends in my close
friendship circle diagnosed with ADHD
recently. Um and then I looked into some
of the statistics around ADHD.
Um and I found this statistic that said
in the 1980s one in 20 US children were
diagnosed with ADHD. Today the number is
roughly one in nine. Yeah. Um
and just generally I you know, around me
there's it feels like and this could
just be because of my own little narrow
circle or it could be because of a wider
thing happening in society. It feels
like there's been an increase in
diagnosis of mental illness and things
like ADHD. And the cause is when I spoke
to my friend about what he believed the
cause of um his ADHD was and he's posted
this on LinkedIn and talks about it very
publicly now.
Um
it seemed to point to he seemed to
believe it was relating to
some kind of genetic or Yeah. heritable
um factor. Yeah. Now,
the issue the issue that I've sort of
been contending with myself and why I
spoke to Johann Hari about this and
others about this is
if I if I am to accept that, then I am I
feel like I'm accepting that we're being
born somewhat broken. And this is almost
what Johann Hari talked about in in the
early stages of his teenage years where
he he was made to believe that there was
this chemical imbalance in his brain and
therefore he was born broken and here's
a medication to solve it.
Yeah.
So, but I don't want I don't believe
that. I don't I don't personally believe
that we're we're born broken. Well, um
any evidence on the subject
might do what I think Johann and
actually did is to read my book on ADHD.
It's called Scattered Minds.
And um
I was diagnosed with it in my 50s and so
were a couple of my kids. But I but I
never bought into the idea this is a
genetic disease or that it's a disease
at all, genetic or otherwise. Um
Now, as for the rising number of um
people being diagnosed with it, there
could be two reasons at least. One is
we're better diagnosis, so before we
wouldn't have noticed it, but now we
are.
Or genuinely there's more people who are
having trouble in certain ways such as
with attention and impulse control and
so on.
But either way, the fact is that many
more children being diagnosed and
medicated
for this condition particularly in the
US, but also increasingly
here in the UK as well. And in China and
elsewhere.
Now,
um
as I said earlier,
if we
the fact is here's the actual reality.
Nobody's ever found a gene for ADHD.
Nobody's ever found a gene that says,
"If you have this gene, you're going to
have ADHD." No No genes have ever No
group of genes have ever been found that
says if you're going to have this gene,
you you're going to have this condition.
Nor ever will be. And no such gene or
group of genes have ever been found that
if you don't have these genes, you will
not have the condition.
Now, there are some diseases that are
genetic. One runs in my family, muscular
dystrophy. If you have the gene, you're
going to have the disease. My mother had
it, my aunt had it.
That's a genetic condition. And if you
have it the gene, you'll have the
disease.
Very rare those kind of diseases.
No, no.
There are some genes that the more of
them you have,
the more likely you are to have any
number of mental health diagnoses, ADHD,
depression, anxiety,
um even psychosis, bipolar illness.
But there's no group of genes or set of
genes or gene that themselves determine
anyone condition.
As a matter of fact, you can have those
same genes and not have any condition
whatsoever.
So, something's being passed on, but
it's not any kind of condition that's
being passed on. What's being passed on
is sensitivity.
And the more sensitive you are,
the more you're going to feel whatever's
going on in the environment. So, you
take the same sensitive kid with these
genes that confer greater sensitivity on
them. And sensitive means
to feel, from the Latin word to feel,
sincere. The more sensitive you are, the
more you're going to feel. The more you
feel, the more bad stuff happens, the
more pain you're going to be in.
And the more compensating you're going
to have to do.
At the same time, with those same genes,
if you're treated well and you grow up
in a healthy environment, you'll just be
creative and happy and joyful and a
leader and a artist or a shaman or or a
very creative CEO or whatever you're
going to be.
So, the genes don't determine. They make
you more sensitive to the environment.
Environment. Now, if you go back to what
I said about the tuning out, it's simply
a defense.
So, the more sensitive you are,
and the stress in the environment, the
more you're going to feel the stress,
the more you're going to need to escape
from it by tuning out.
So, you didn't inherit ADHD, you
inherited a sensitivity that makes it
more likely under stressful
circumstances that you will revert to
tuning out when your brain is
developing.
Which, by the way, is an organ that
develops physiologically under the
impact of the emotional environment.
So, if there's a lot of stress in a
child's life, and what I'm saying is in
this society, is that more and more
parents are stressed. Not cuz they don't
love their kids, not cuz they're not
doing their very utmost to provide for
them,
but because they're more stressed for
all kinds of social, political, economic
reasons. I mean, if you look at
inflation in Britain,
which is a high risk right now,
more people are going to be stressed
financially.
Financial stress on the parents
translates into physiological stress in
the children.
Those children may want to tune out cuz
it's too much to be in the present. Some
of them will be diagnosed with ADHD.
They didn't inherit anything in terms of
a disease. They're just reacting to the
environment. So, if we're diagnosing
more and more kids these days, I think
it's because the parenting environment
has become much more stressed.
And that's backed up in this book where
you mentioned that study of 65,000
parents. Yeah. Um and their children
with ADHD, right?
You say Well, there's more trauma in
their lives. Yeah, so the the children
had ADHD. The study was 65,000? I forget
the You're better than I am. I read
65,000. I read it I read it You even
wrote the book, so I didn't.
Yeah, but many thousands of kids, yeah.
So, cuz I found that to be really really
sort of supportive of what you just said
where
I'm again I'm I'm saying this from
memory, but a study of 65,000
children and their parents and they
found that those parents who had more
adverse
traumatic events in their lives
ended up having having a higher chance
of having a child that had ADHD. Well,
look, if you look at um
in the United States at least,
poor kids and kids of so-called color
are much more likely to be diagnosed
with ADHD.
Interesting. Now, why would that be the
case? Cuz they're living with so much
more stress.
Men as well, right? Men as well? Adults,
you mean? Men, yeah. So, I read that
more men more boys are diagnosed
Yeah, more men are diagnosed partly
because in men the
the symptom of hyperactivity seems to be
there more often. So, when a kid is
sitting in school and they can't sit
still, that's obvious. And the teacher
will notice it. The girl who's kind of
dreamy and tunes out,
kind of fades away at the back of the
class, she doesn't create any problems.
So, they don't
That's one of the reasons. But also,
um
funny to say,
but young boys
infant boys are more sensitive to
environmental environmental pressure
than girls are.
For some strange reason. So, they're
more likely to be affected by these
factors.
Seeing a boy like that in the class
that's fidgety, that has a poor
attention span, bad response to stress,
we medicate. Mhm. What is the impact of
that approach to treatment? Medicating
super early.
I used to
when I worked as a physician, I would
certainly prescribe medication
sometimes.
Um it's a question of who's prescribing
it and with what intention.
If I understand that the real problem in
this child is not that there's anything
intrinsically wrong with the child,
but that they were developed in a
stressed environment. And those stresses
are still acting on them.
And one of the stresses is the parents
don't understand the kids' behaviors.
And they tend to react rather harshly.
Then if I change if I can help the
parent understand the sensitive nature
of their child,
which also means that when positive
changes occur in the environment, the
kid will be very responsive to that as
well. If the parents can create a
positive, accepting, understanding
atmosphere in the home and work on their
own stresses so they don't unconsciously
pass them on to their kids, that kid
will change very quickly.
And I say, well, if in the short term
the child wants the medication to
function better, and no child should be
forced to take medication,
and medication are never
the final answer. They're the very most
they're a stopgap. There's no proof
whatsoever that medications help anybody
heal from ADHD.
They simply suppress symptoms, which may
be helpful in the short term, but for
God's sakes, go to work on the long-term
development of that child. And what does
that mean?
Create the conditions in which healthy
development takes place. That child will
do very, very well. If you think the
problem is a disease, they're just going
to medicate away the symptoms of.
What about for adults though? My my I'm
thinking of my friend that he's he's in
his 30s and he got the diagnosis of ADHD
in his 30s. He's been given this
medication which he presumably has to
take for life. He's told me the
medication has helped helped him focus.
Has helped him focus. Has helped him
focus. Yeah, it's been a game changer,
Steve, you know. Yeah, yeah. I I've
taken medication myself for ADHD and it
helped me focus. It helped me write my
first book.
Um I didn't take it for this one. As a
matter of fact,
more recently when I when I was
beginning to write the medication, I
thought maybe I would take a bit of
stimulant like I used to and just to see
if it helps me write the book better.
All it did All it did is give me side
effects.
My brain has changed. I don't need it
anymore. You know? So, I I I would say
to your friend, if the medication is
helping you right now and it's not
causing you side effects,
I got nothing against it.
And
you might want to give it a break
you know, every weekend if you don't you
know, you might want to use it for when
you're having to work or having to you
know, really concentrate, but it's up to
you. If it helps you function, take it.
But go to work on the traumas and
stresses that are driving the ADHD going
back to your childhood.
And you know, I may say my book on ADHD,
Scattered Minds, does outline some ways
to do that. Um
you might find that you don't need the
medication
uh so much anymore or not at all,
perhaps. Number one. Number two,
even if you do, your life will be so
much fuller and so much more um less
stressed if you deal with the underlying
factors than if you simply medicate the
symptom.
Is there I always think in life there's
a cost for all these things. We used to
medicate and stimulate ourselves. And
so, I always I always ask myself like
there's got to be a It's almost like
there's got to be a catch here. And even
for coffee, I'm like, what's the catch?
It can't just be all up and positive.
And with with my friend when he said
when he had the conversation with me
about being on this this medication for
life, my first thought is like, okay,
well, what's the cost? It's going to
make you really focused and better at
work. But what is the
what is the long-term cost of
I'd have to
talk to your friend. Friend, those are
good questions to ask.
When I took medication,
it made me a much more efficient
workaholic. You know? It did nothing for
my workaholism. Just made me much better
at it cuz I could stay up later now and
I was more focused. I could even more
things done. You know? So,
um you got to deal with these other
issues.
Did you Did you?
I did. Did I deal with them? Yes. I
have. And
there's so much more like like dealing
with the trauma. Like I'm telling you if
your friend's got ADHD,
I can tell you he had a stressed early
few years.
And his parent was Her parents were
stressed. His parents were stressed. So,
deal with that.
Deal with what conditions are you
creating now in your life that create
more stress for you?
Are you taking care of your body? Are
you exercising? Are you eating well? Do
you get out there in nature? Nature has
a certain kind of harmony to it, which
actually calms the mind.
You know? So, are you doing all these
things?
If you're not, all you're doing is
medicating a symptom.
If you are taking the medication
specifically to help you focus, but
you're working on these other issues,
you'll have a much fuller life and you
may find you don't need the medication
after all.
You You came off the medication for your
ADD. Yeah.
Um
because I'm a
cuz I'm just not that medically well
versed, what's the difference between AD
ADD and ADHD? It's you know it's a kind
of a confusion. ADHD simply means that
the hyperactivity is present. Okay. So
you can have ADD with or without
hyperactivity. Okay. So the actual you
know, proper way to write it is ADD
and in brackets HD so that and
indicating that the hyperactivity may or
may not be there. Got you. So you you
you were on medication, you did the
work, you know, not on medication.
Yeah. Um do you still have the symptoms
of ADD?
To some degree, but not in a way that
anyway blights my life. Like one thing I
can pretty be sure that when I go on a
speaking trip I'm going to lose
something. And I'll lose my
my portable electrical
tooth cleaner or I'm going to In this
case, I left my rain jacket in Budapest
when I came here on
I I You can take it for granted that my
attention will just not notice something
that I haven't packed yet. That's okay.
I'm going back to Budapest next week so
I'll get to get my rain jacket back. But
sometimes it's the cost of being me. So
what, you know? So no, not in every way
but that's not the point. Nobody's life
has to be perfect. It just has to be a
life that I I want to live and I can
enjoy living
that I have, you know? So who cares if
sometimes I forget something or I lose
something or
even if I'm listening to a symphony and
I can't keep my attention on it.
Okay, so I can't.
This you you talk about this
toxic society. Yeah.
Do you think society's getting more
toxic and if so, why? What measure shall
we use? Your measure. You know, if you
use the measure of the number of kids
being medicated
or number of adults having chronic
illness autoimmune disease um number of
students uh university students
uh
being depressed contemplating suicide um
number of children in the United States
killing themselves
um
the number of people on medications of
all kinds
um the degree of safety that people have
in society the the rancor or peace that
characterizes political discourse in
this world
um
the
intolerable fact that eight people in
the world I think own as much as the
bottom half
as the bottom 3.5 billion.
You know, if I look at all those things
by those measures, if you look at what's
happening to the environment
if I look at the fact that the people
who are the worst polluters in the
environment also happen to be the most
successful people in a by a certain
measure of success
um
by any number of parameters if I look at
um
oh
racism still affects the lives of so
many people
um and not just affects it in an
emotional sense but actually
physiologically
you know
then yeah
it's a this is a toxic society and those
measures are getting worse they're not
getting better and inequality is getting
worse here in the UK and elsewhere.
So yeah, I think it's getting more
toxic. What's the antidote? What's the
antidote? Well, um how about we go back
to this word awareness? Like like people
just have to get that this is how it is
and in the last chapter I don't lay out
a political program. You know, I don't
see that as my role to do that.
I have my own political ideas and
preferences but
I don't want to impose them on the
reader. But I do say
first of all we have to lose our
illusions
that this is that this normality is
actually healthy or natural. We have to
just get
cognizant that what we consider to be
normal is actually bad for us.
Um
number one, number two um
just if we introduced
the concept of trauma into health care
like the average doctor again, strange
to say, doesn't hear a single lecture in
their medical training about the impact
of trauma on physical or mental health
which is astonishing
given that it was a British psychologist
Dr. Richard Bentall who pointed out not
that many years ago that the evidence
linking what we call mental illness and
childhood adversity is about as strong
as the evidence linking smoking and lung
cancer
and the average physician
doesn't hear a word about that. It's
astonishing.
Education, teachers if they understood
child development, brain development
the developmental factors that I that
children need that I
cite in this book and if they understood
how trauma affects kids' capacity to
learn, to pay attention
and to behave in functional ways
the Daily Telegraph
here in London not that long ago
was bemoaning the fact that kids aren't
caned anymore in schools.
I mean they were what they were what
they were moaning about is that we no
longer traumatize kids quite as harshly
as we used to.
That's what it that's all it does,
caning.
So if teachers understood that the
behaviors on the part of children are
actually manifestations of emotional
dynamics of frustration and needs not
being met and and and and very often of
trauma, that would change the
educational system.
If the legal system understood it
that that most people facing the
criminal justice system are actually
traumatized people, they could actually
be rehabilitated
uh
and and and and healed if we understood
that instead of just exposing them to
harsh punishments or actually treated
them like human beings
who may have done things that aren't
acceptable but that came from
traumas they couldn't have helped and
that they can be helped back to um
healthy functioning as we know from lots
of experience.
Just that little trauma information
would change society.
So that's what I can offer as a
physician.
What about parents?
What do they need to know? Yeah, well if
parents actually understood first of all
that the first three years are
everything that if you if you if they
get the template right in the first
three years, they can hardly set a foot
wrong afterwards.
But but on the other hand, if we're not
present for our kids emotionally, if we
don't understand them, if we don't see
them
if we don't
attune to their emotional states
we're going to hurt them.
And if they understood what the needs of
children are when I mentioned some of
them for play, for
ex- experience of all emotions, for
unconditional loving attachment for the
child
being able to rest from having to work
to make the relationship work
so the child doesn't have to be good or
nice or beautiful or
or or or successful or they just have to
be.
So we don't impose conditions on our
approval and acceptance on them. If
parents just understood that
and if they understood how important it
is that they take care of their own
emotional needs
so that the child doesn't have to take
responsibility
like perhaps you did for the parent
stresses.
If parents understood all that and if
society actually understood how
important parenting was and it supported
parents who needed the support to be
there for their kids
it wouldn't be financially
costly, it would save us a lot of money.
Not to mention we'd have a lot more
happier kids
who don't need to be on medications. So
yeah. And lastly, schools. Schools?
Well, again like I said about educators
if if educators Well, here's the thing.
If you look at how does the human brain
develop? I quite an article I quote an
article
from the Harvard Center on the
Developing Child that appeared
in the journal Pediatrics, official
journal of the American Pediatric
Academy in 2012, February.
The article said that the human brain
develop through a complex process that
begins before birth and continues into
adulthood.
Okay? Now that means A we take care of
the emotional needs of pregnant women.
Number one. Number two, if it continues
into adulthood continues into adulthood
then the job of the schools if they
understand it right is not to teach kids
what year
the Battle of the Battle of Austerlitz
took place or the Battle of Battle of
Waterloo
um or or you know algebra a- any of the
any of that stuff.
The most important job of the schools is
to promote healthy brain development.
With a child who's with healthy brain
development will actually be naturally
curious. They'll want to know about
history.
They'll be keen to
to absorb the skills of algebra. They'll
want to know how to use a computer and
they'll want to know um
how to
write properly. A kid will want to do
that spontaneously cuz mastery and and
and learning, these are human hungers,
they're human needs.
So
in other words, the most important job
of the schools is not to cram the kids
full of information
but to help them develop healthy brains.
What does that require?
Safety above all, lack of pressure
healthy relationship with nurturing
adults.
And if the kids are not going to spend
their time with their adult but they but
they parents which they can't in this
society like they used to throughout
human evolution, let them spend their
time with adults who are emotionally
nurturing and emotionally penetratingly
attentive to the child's needs. Now
you're going to have schools that are
going to really kids
teach kids something and where kids will
want to learn.
And it's very simple.
It doesn't take more training and it
doesn't take more Well, it does take
some training perhaps but not more than
what teachers are getting now.
So that's what it would take in
education.
I was thinking there about the
importance of doing
certain psychological tests on certain
teachers because if they are also
passing on a generational cycle Yeah. of
their own at a time when my brain is
still being developed, they can have a
huge impact positively or negatively on
my Absolutely.
on my life in the same way that my
parents could. Absolutely.
It's quite remarkable. Teachers don't
know how much power they have because of
the vulnerability of the young brain.
Mhm. Um and well-meaning teachers
will sometimes behave in ways that are
really hurtful to kids just cuz they
don't get it. Not cuz they don't mean
well. So, I've had many adults sit in my
office
say
with tears in their eyes about something
a teacher said to them three decades
before.
Like, the classroom
uh the classroom will continue when
Johnny comes back to Earth.
This kind of sarcastic little dig
can undermine a child's dignity and
sense of self so easily. So, if teachers
just understood how powerful they are
and how important they are in helping to
promote healthy brain development,
I think their profession would take on a
whole new meaning that would be much
more satisfying than it is right now.
It's not the fault of individual
teachers. We're talking about a system
that isn't that is toxic.
Gabor, we have closing tradition on this
podcast. Oh, okay. Where the previous
guest asks a question
for the next guest. Okay. I didn't get
to see it until I opened the book. So,
there's a question written here for you.
Before I ask you this question, I did
have a my question of my own, which was,
you know, you're you're in your 70s now.
Um
what are you still working on in terms
of your own traumas? Is Is there
anything even though you're you're in a
a later stage of your own life that you
you're still
sort of struggling with as it relates to
that puppet master pulling on the
strings and
that kind of analogy that we gave
earlier.
Yeah.
Um
it's
a sense of peace
when I'm not doing anything.
Just being.
The capacity just to be.
Um that's something I'm
still looking for. Not well, not looking
for like I was looking for a lost puppy,
but
I'm still searching myself for.
And where exactly does that come from in
your own diagnosis?
How about if I tell you when I find out?
I mean, I can give you a textbook
answer,
but it wouldn't be authentic. Okay.
So, you don't know
entirely.
some I have some sense of I have some
ideas and then and
it
it really means
being okay with my mind the way it is
and not needing it to be any different.
That's really what it means.
Which means if I'm sitting there
for 5 minutes, I don't have to reach for
the cell phone to occupy my mind.
And now in the midst of this busy book
tour and all the speaking I do,
I don't I don't do enough to to take
care of that quiet
little voice inside myself. I don't.
I think it would take some attention.
I can't either though. I can't sit for
two I couldn't 5 minutes. I couldn't sit
for 5 seconds without grabbing my phone.
It's weird. I noticed the other day that
I was like going to the toilet. And I
had no intention of using my phone in
the toilet.
Yeah. But I went to get my phone to go
to the toilet.
be alone with yourself. Yeah, I can't be
alone with myself. Yeah. I can't
sitting for 30 seconds, you know, my
brain Is that Is that because they've
built these algorithms to to stimulate
my dopamine or is it because there's
something in me I guess it goes back to
your point about addiction. Well, it's
both. I mean, they they certainly create
algorithms to stimulate your brain and
get you hooked on that dopamine hit.
Mhm. They sure for sure they call that
neuro marketing. Mhm. Neuro marketing.
Can you Can you get that? Yeah, neuro
marketing. They they work on your brain
to get, you know, to get you addicted,
but it's also comes from an earlier
discomfort with the self that predates
any cell phone use. It goes back to
earliest childhood where it couldn't
have been comfortable to be
just with yourself
because of the circumstances.
Interesting.
Interesting. Yeah, my cuz I got friends
that don't have the same the same
addiction with their cell phones that I
do. Mhm. They they they don't they can
take it or leave it. They put it outside
their bedroom when they go to bed
charging in the kitchen. I'm like, how I
have to hold mine like my pillow. Yeah,
exactly. Well, like your little safety
pillow. And what's the first thing you
do when you wake up in the morning? I
grab it with one eye open and all that
gunk in my eye. I'm like trying to just,
you know, Yeah. Yeah. Well, how about
both you and I work on not doing that so
much? Okay. I'll give you my number.
You'll Let Let me We shouldn't We
shouldn't discuss by phone how we're
getting on with this. That's just
another reason to use my phone. Yeah.
But next time I speak to you in person,
you can update me on a how you getting
on with that. I am I am I am working on
it. I'm working on it.
I think I've got to become more
cognizant of the cost of that addiction.
Well, exactly.
To really I know one of the costs is
meaningful connections and presence
within with
and in and the cost to in- interpersonal
relationships, but
maybe I haven't had the the cost
um impact me enough yet. Maybe.
The question left for you
by I don't know the signature. So, I'll
have to figure that out later, but is
what's your selfish dream?
I I you know what? I'm not sure how to
sit with that question cuz not that I
get out of it, but I just don't have
looking at my own reaction to it. Um
You know what? At this point,
I I I
I don't have too many
What does it mean selfish, by the way?
Let me ask you that. What does that
mean?
Something that
is for me at the expense of others?
I don't think I have any dreams like
that left.
I might have it not might have I did
have
at some point.
But if I have a dream
for myself in that sense of
self-enhancing dream, something that
enhances my
ego or something, well, if
this book sold a billion copies, well,
that that would be a nice selfish dream,
you know?
But
I don't know how else to answer that. Um
I do have dreams, but they're more about
the state of the world that I'd like to
see.
The the world I'd like to see
future generations inherit. Selfless
dreams. Yeah. Well, I don't know if
they're selfless cuz it certainly
involves
my own history and certainly would make
me feel better, you know? So, in that
sense, it's selfish, you might say.
But they're not they don't have to do
with personal
I have enough.
You know, I've done enough and I have
enough. So, I don't have any
anything any anything lacking that I
need to dream about.
All of our selfless dreams are also very
much selfless selfish in that regard as
well. They They're going to help us by
Selfish in a different sense. I mean,
any dreams I have about for a better
world it certainly are certainly have
the function of making me feel better.
Of Of Of maybe even
the the stuff that happened to me or the
stuff that happened to you,
it would mean a lot to me if they didn't
happen to any more children,
you know? So,
in a sense that it would mean a lot to
me, you might say it's selfish, but it's
not purely about me. It's about
something larger. I'm not trying to
paint myself as some kind of a
altruistic saint. I'm just saying that
would make me feel better. If I really
knew that kids in Gaza didn't have to
face face face any more bombings,
if kids in Israel didn't have to face
any more uh
danger of terrorist attacks, if um not
that I see any equality there, but I'd
like I'd like that for both of them. If
kids in Ukraine
didn't have to live under the
the threat of
missiles falling,
if people in Russia didn't have to feel
with the live with the fear of
perhaps a nuclear conflict or their
young men being conscripted into a war,
if uh
if kids in Britain,
you know, didn't have to live in
poverty,
wouldn't that make you feel better, you
know? So, to the extent that it makes us
feel better, you might say it's selfish,
but
is it?
Gabor, thank you.
Well, my pleasure. Thank you so much.
Thank you so much for for writing a such
an important book. I I think my only
wish is that I discovered this book
sooner.
Cuz I think so many of my I think it
would have liberated, that's a good
word, uh liberated me from a series of
things that would have helped me to live
a much better life and to understand
myself. That's That's the point of
awareness that we talked about.
that your advanced age is over, isn't
it?
We all We all I think we all want the
answers even sooner because we we we
reflect on some of the consequences or
the mistakes or the that we made. Not
that those are I mean, present by any of
those, but it it's, you know, and so so
wonderful that this book now exists.
You're You're a name that I I started to
be peppered with by my audience over and
over again, specifically in the last 12
months. People
really really young people were
messaging me and asking me to have a
conversation with you about the topics
we talked about today, things like ADHD
and their trauma and and so much. And
you know, I sit here every day talking
to
um
a lot a lot of people on this podcast.
And
um I think my understanding of trauma
has forever been
redefined by both this conversation
today, but also by your book. And I
really I'm so thankful to you because I
think that will help me speak on the
topic with more accuracy.
Um and therefore um hopefully help other
people understand their their own trauma
in a more um meaningful way.
It's just such an important book. Well,
thank you so much. Thank you so much for
giving me the platform to
to talk about my work and and just the
opportunity to meet you. Thanks a lot.
And it's written in such an accessible
way, which is so important because that
means it can reach even more people.
Thank you so much. Okay, thank you.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
Dr. Gabor Mate, a renowned expert in addiction, stress, and childhood development, joins Steven Bartlett to discuss his book, 'The Myth of Normal'. They explore how childhood adversity—not just major traumatic events, but also small-t trauma from unmet emotional needs—shapes our development and can lead to adult illness and patterns of behavior. Mate explains how we often unconsciously adopt survival strategies, such as workaholism, which society may reward but which ultimately fail to fill internal emptiness. The conversation also covers the importance of reconnecting with one's authentic self, the role of awareness in healing, and how our early templates and societal pressures define our health and view of the world.
Videos recently processed by our community