HomeVideos

How to Set & Achieve Goals | Huberman Lab Essentials

Now Playing

How to Set & Achieve Goals | Huberman Lab Essentials

Transcript

900 segments

0:00

Welcome to Huberman Lab Essentials,

0:01

[music] where we revisit past episodes

0:04

for the most potent and actionable

0:06

science-based tools for mental health,

0:08

physical health, and performance.

0:11

I'm Andrew Huberman and I'm a professor

0:13

of neurobiology and opthalmology at

0:15

Stanford School of Medicine. Today we're

0:18

talking all about goals and the science

0:20

of goal setting and achieving your

0:22

goals. So when we think about goal

0:24

seeking and the pursuit of goals of any

0:26

kind in the brain, it doesn't matter

0:28

what the goal is. It involves a common

0:31

set of neural circuits. One of the brain

0:34

areas is the so-called amydala. The

0:36

amydala is most often associated with

0:37

fear. So you might say, "Wow, how is

0:39

that involved in goal- directed

0:41

behavior?" Well, a lot of our goal-

0:43

directed behavior is to avoid

0:44

punishments, including things like

0:46

embarrassment or financial ruin or

0:49

things of that sort. And so the amygdala

0:51

and some sense of anxiety or fear is

0:53

actually built in to the circuits that

0:56

generate goal seeking and our motivation

0:58

to pursue goals. The other areas are the

1:01

so-called vententral strriatam. The

1:03

strriatam is part of what's called the

1:05

basil ganglia. The basil ganglia is a

1:08

neural circuit that can very simply be

1:09

described as a neural circuit that helps

1:12

us generate go meaning the initiation of

1:14

action and no go the prevention of

1:17

action type scenarios. Let me make that

1:20

even simpler. The vententral stratum is

1:22

part of this thing called the basil

1:23

ganglia. The basil ganglia has sort of

1:25

two circuits within it. One circuit is

1:28

involved in getting us to do things like

1:29

I'm going to get up tomorrow and I'm

1:31

going to run 5 miles first thing in the

1:32

morning. I don't know if I'm actually

1:34

going to do that, but I'm just using

1:35

that as an example. Another circuit

1:37

within the basil ganglia is a no-go

1:39

circuit. It's the one that says no, I'm

1:41

not going to go for the second cookie or

1:43

the third cookie. I'm not going to eat

1:46

that. And then the go circuit would be

1:47

the one that's responsible for instead

1:50

eating something else. Okay. So we have

1:51

go and no go circuits within the basil

1:54

ganglia. So we've got amydala. So think

1:56

of as kind of fear and anxiety and

1:58

avoidance. We've got the basil ganglia

2:00

which are for initiating action and

2:02

preventing action. And then there is the

2:05

so-called cortex. The cortex is the

2:07

outer shell of the brain. And there are

2:08

two sub regions of the cortex that are

2:09

involved in goal- directed behavior. One

2:12

is the lateral prefrontal cortex.

2:13

Prefrontal cortex is involved in

2:15

so-called executive function. Things

2:17

like planning, thinking about things

2:19

under different time scales. So not just

2:21

what we want in the immediate term, but

2:22

what we might want tomorrow or the next

2:25

day and how our actions currently are

2:26

going to relate to the future. And the

2:28

so-called orbrontal cortex. Orbital

2:31

frontal cortex has a large number of

2:33

functions. But one of the key functions

2:35

of the orbital frontal cortex, it's

2:37

involved in meshing some emotionality

2:39

with our current state of progress and

2:42

comparing that emotionality to where we

2:45

it might be when we are closer to a

2:48

goal. Okay. So there basically four

2:50

areas. One involved in anxiety, one

2:52

involved in emotion, one involved in

2:55

planning, and another involved in this

2:57

go no-go action. Okay. If we want to

3:00

make this even simpler, I'll just do

3:01

this one more time. Think anxiety and

3:03

fear. It's the amydala. The second is

3:05

involved in action and inaction.

3:08

Remember go and no go. So that's the

3:10

basil ganglia. The other one is involved

3:14

in planning and thinking across

3:16

different time scales. So that's lateral

3:18

prefrontal cortex. And then the fourth

3:20

one is involved in emotionality. Where

3:23

we sit emotionally at present compared

3:25

to where we think we will be emotionally

3:28

when we reach some particular goal. And

3:30

that's the orbital frontal cortex. What

3:32

is going on in these circuits can

3:34

basically be boiled down to two

3:36

particular things. The first is value

3:39

information. Trying to understand

3:41

whether or not something is really worth

3:42

pursuing or not. The other component of

3:45

this neural circuit is associated with

3:47

action. Which actions to take and which

3:50

actions not to take given the value of a

3:54

particular goal in a given moment's

3:56

time. You're going to hear me say over

3:58

and over again in this episode, the

3:59

value information about a goal is so

4:02

key. Here's why. There is basically one

4:05

neurotransmitter or rather neurom

4:08

modulator system that governs our goal

4:11

setting, goal assessment and goal

4:13

pursuit and that is the neurom modulator

4:15

dopamine. Dopamine is the common

4:17

currency by which we assess our progress

4:20

toward particular things of particular

4:22

value. In fact, dopamine is the way that

4:25

we assess value of our pursuits. There

4:28

are basically only three or four

4:29

elements to goal setting and goal

4:31

pursuit. Basically, an individual or set

4:34

of individuals has to identify a

4:36

specific thing that they're going to

4:38

attain. Assessment of what whether or

4:40

not one is making progress towards those

4:42

goals is a second but necessary step.

4:44

And then there's the business of goal

4:46

execution. And that brings us back to

4:47

the neural circuit components. Remember

4:49

this neural circuit involving those four

4:51

things earlier, the amygdala stratum or

4:53

frontal cortex and the prefrontal

4:55

cortex. They work together to divide the

4:58

whole process as I mentioned before into

5:00

two general categories. The first is

5:02

assessing value. Knowing whether or not

5:05

where one is at one given moment relates

5:08

to some external thing. Are things going

5:10

well or are things going poorly? And

5:13

knowing how to gauge that accurately.

5:15

And then action steps, goes and no goes.

5:18

do more of this, do less of that, do

5:20

this, don't do that, etc. So now we are

5:23

going to shift back to the neuroscience.

5:24

And as we do this, I'd like you to keep

5:27

in mind what are some things that you've

5:29

either accomplished or that you'd like

5:30

to accomplish going forward. Because as

5:33

we do this, we can build toward a set of

5:34

protocols that at the end, you'll be

5:36

able to very quickly plug in your

5:38

particular goals and a route to those

5:40

particular goals that's grounded in the

5:42

science that I think are going to be

5:43

very effective in allowing you to reach

5:45

those goals more quickly and with indeed

5:48

less effort. In fact, let's start with a

5:50

tool. Now, the first thing to do is to

5:53

understand the difference between

5:55

perpersonal space and extrapersonal

5:57

space. Perpersonal space is a key

6:00

concept in neuroscience because you have

6:02

particular neural circuits and

6:04

particular chemicals that are geared

6:06

toward what are called consumatory

6:08

behaviors. Meaning using things and

6:10

consuming things and enjoying things

6:12

that are in your immediate parersonal

6:14

space. Within my current parersonal

6:17

space is my interosception, my

6:20

understanding or perception of my

6:22

internal body. So, how quickly I'm

6:25

breathing, my heart rate, the feelings

6:27

on the surface of my skin, etc. But also

6:30

within the confines of my perpersonal

6:32

space is this coffee mug that if you're

6:34

listening to this, you can't see this,

6:35

but I'm lifting lifting up a coffee mug.

6:37

I'm going to take a sip of coffee.

6:39

That's a consumatory behavior. I have

6:41

the coffee. I don't have to do much or

6:42

motivate much to get it. Contrast that

6:45

with the so-called extrapersonal space.

6:48

Extrapersonal space is everything beyond

6:49

the confines of my reach. How we feel

6:52

about a particular goal is truly a

6:54

feeling that we experience in the here

6:55

and now even though the goal is in the

6:57

future. Okay.

7:00

If we are going to evaluate whether or

7:01

not we made progress today or yesterday

7:03

or not, that's an evaluation of how we

7:06

feel in the immediate perpersonal space.

7:10

However, moving toward any goal involves

7:13

orienting our thinking towards the

7:15

extrapal space. I'm just going to seed a

7:18

little bit of the later conversation by

7:19

saying that when we focus on an external

7:22

point, we are in a process of

7:25

exterception. It's the focus on the

7:27

extra personal space, not the

7:29

perpersonal space. Work at NYU in

7:32

particular in the laboratory of a a

7:34

phenomenal researcher in their

7:35

psychology department um by the name of

7:37

Emily Bettis, B A L C I S. Emily Bettis

7:42

has done really nice work on this.

7:44

they've done is they've had people focus

7:47

their visual attention on a goal line of

7:49

some sort and then to engage in some

7:52

sort of behavior that requires a lot of

7:54

effort. The long and short of these

7:56

studies is that when people have to

7:58

focus their attention on one location

8:00

like a goal line, they are much more

8:02

effective in reaching those goals and

8:05

they achieve them with the perception

8:07

that they expended less effort. And what

8:09

they did is they had a group of people

8:12

exercise wearing 15 pound ankle weights

8:15

and they had to basically move a certain

8:17

distance or run a certain distance to

8:19

reach a goal line. One group was focused

8:21

on the goal line, visually focused on

8:23

the goal line. The other group was not

8:25

told to visually focus on the goal line.

8:28

And what they found was that the group

8:30

that focused on the goal line did was

8:32

able to achieve reaching that goal with

8:36

17% less effort. and that it got there

8:40

23% quicker. Simply by looking at the

8:43

goal line does something to the

8:45

psychology and and physiology of these

8:47

people that allows them to move forward

8:50

with less perceived effort and to do it

8:53

more quickly. So what is special about

8:55

focusing one's visual attention at a

8:57

given location? Well, it turns out that

8:59

we have two branches of our visual

9:01

system. So visual information all comes

9:03

in through our eyes, but then it can

9:04

head down two different pathways. one

9:07

pathway is engaged when our vision is

9:10

brought to a common point, what we call

9:11

a virgin's eye movement. So if we're

9:12

focusing very intensely on a given

9:14

point, regardless of how far away from

9:16

us that point is, our visual system

9:19

engages a certain set of neurons, neural

9:21

circuits that are involved in resolving

9:24

fine detail and that can evaluate small

9:26

changes over small periods of time. The

9:29

other pathway through the visual system

9:30

is a so-called magnosellar pathway. And

9:32

this is a pathway that's involved in

9:34

taking in global information about lots

9:36

of things that are happening around us.

9:38

Movement of things to our right,

9:39

movement of things to our left, things

9:41

that are happening down on the ground

9:42

and all around us. And that pathway

9:45

involves a sort of relaxation, if you

9:47

will, of the neural circuits that are

9:49

associated with alertness and attention.

9:51

When you focus your eyes on a particular

9:53

location, blood pressure goes up. And

9:56

there are some other systems that are

9:57

coordinated with it in your brain and

9:59

body that start releasing adrenaline,

10:02

low amounts of adrenaline in most cases.

10:04

And that adrenaline further readies your

10:06

body for action. Conversely, when our

10:09

visual system is in a mode of looking at

10:11

everything when the aperture of our

10:13

visual system is very broad,

10:16

we know that there's also a reduction in

10:18

our goal- directed behavior and a

10:20

reduction in blood pressure. What many

10:22

of you are probably thinking is okay

10:23

well that's some physiology there's some

10:25

psychology but how do you actually apply

10:27

this towards setting and achieving goals

10:29

well you do that by understanding that

10:32

your mental frame and your attention are

10:35

always either positioned to your

10:37

perpersonal space focused on your

10:39

immediate possessions and state or

10:42

towards things outside you but that you

10:44

also have the ability to dynamically

10:46

travel back and forth between those if

10:48

you already know what goal you want to

10:49

pursue maybe it's a workout maybe it's a

10:51

cognitive work of some particular sort.

10:53

Again, the process is very simple.

10:54

You're going to focus your visual

10:56

attention on one point beyond your

10:58

perpersonal space. So, it could be on

11:00

your computer, it could be on the wall,

11:01

it could be a horizon, it could be at a

11:03

at a distance, and you're going to focus

11:05

your visual attention there. And with

11:06

some effort, you're going to hold your

11:08

visual attention for 30 to 60 seconds.

11:10

You might blink, that's okay, but you're

11:12

going to try and hold your visual

11:14

attention there. So, no moving your head

11:15

around, um, no diverting your attention

11:17

to other locations. Again, it places

11:19

your brain and body into a state of

11:20

readiness. And then the idea is to move

11:22

into the particular actions that bring

11:24

you closer to your goal. Okay, we

11:26

haven't yet talked about how to set

11:27

goals and how to assess progress. This

11:29

is simply how to pursue goals. Okay, but

11:32

the visual component is important. In

11:34

fact, I would argue that the visual

11:37

system and harnessing your visual

11:38

attention to a narrow point is going to

11:40

be the most effective way to get your

11:42

brain and body into a mode of action to

11:44

pursue whatever goal it is you're trying

11:46

to pursue. So, does visualization work?

11:50

Well, turns out that visualization of

11:53

the big win, the end goal, so the Super

11:55

Bowl win or eight gold medals in the

11:58

Olympics or graduation from the

12:01

university of your choice or making a

12:03

certain amount of money or finding the

12:05

partner of your choice, etc.

12:07

That visualization is effective in

12:10

getting the goal pursuit process

12:12

started, but it actually is a pretty

12:15

lousy and maybe even counterproductive

12:17

way of maintaining

12:19

pursuit of that goal. In fact, there's a

12:22

much better way to maintain ongoing

12:24

action toward a goal that also involves

12:27

visualization. But it turns out it's not

12:30

about visualizing success. It's about

12:33

visualizing failure. If you look at the

12:35

literature, the scientific literature,

12:37

there's a near doubling near doubling in

12:40

the probability of reaching one's goal.

12:43

If you focus routinely on foreshadowing

12:48

failure, you think about the ways in

12:50

which things could fail if you take

12:52

action A or you take action B and

12:55

instead therefore you take action C. If

12:57

we think back to the neural circuit

12:59

associated with assessing value in our

13:03

goal pursuits, this makes perfect sense.

13:04

The amygdala, that center of the brain

13:06

that's involved in anxiety and fear and

13:08

worry, well, the amygdala is one of the

13:10

four core components of our goal setting

13:13

and goal pursuit circuitry. And so,

13:15

while I'd love to be able to tell you

13:17

that all you should think about is

13:18

rainbows and puppies and all the

13:20

wonderful rewarding things that are

13:21

going to happen when you achieve your

13:23

goals, the truth is you should be

13:26

thinking mainly about how bad it's

13:28

really going to get if you don't do it.

13:30

How disappointing yourself you're going

13:31

to feel. How it will negatively impact

13:34

you if not in the immediate term, in the

13:35

long term, if indeed your goal is to

13:38

reach your goal. And the more specific

13:40

you can get by writing down or thinking

13:42

about or talking about how bad it will

13:44

be if you don't achieve your goals, the

13:46

more likely you are to achieve those

13:48

goals. If you're going to visualize in a

13:50

positive way, do that at the very

13:52

beginning of some goal pursuit. Maybe

13:53

intermittently every once in a while.

13:55

You imagine the big win of, you know,

13:57

scoring perfect on an exam or winning

13:59

the championship or the great

14:00

relationship. Most of the time if you

14:02

want to be effective you should be

14:03

focusing on avoiding failure and you

14:05

should be really clear about what those

14:06

failures would look like and feel like.

14:08

Now let's talk about goal setting. The

14:11

goal should be significant. We are told

14:13

it should be inspirational. It should be

14:16

aggressive yet realistic. But what does

14:18

that really look like and what does that

14:20

correspond to and how do we actually

14:21

make that happen? Turns out that the

14:24

probability of achieving a goal goes up

14:29

or down depending on whether or not one

14:31

visualizes or sets a goal that is easy,

14:35

moderate, or impossible. Turns out that

14:38

if the goal is too easy, it's too within

14:41

reach, it doesn't recruit enough of the

14:44

autonomic nervous system to make pursuit

14:47

of that goal likely. Also, if a goal was

14:50

too lofty, if it was too far from their

14:53

current abilities,

14:55

it didn't recruit enough systolic blood

14:57

pressure. Even if people could get very

15:00

excited about something mentally, it

15:02

simply didn't place their body into a

15:04

state of readiness because they it

15:05

wasn't tangible that they could actually

15:07

perhaps really achieve it. So it turns

15:10

out that when goals were moderate, when

15:13

they were just outside of one's

15:15

immediate abilities or that one felt

15:17

that yeah, that would take a lot of

15:18

effort but it's within range or maybe in

15:22

range like maybe I can do it, maybe I

15:24

can't, then there was a near doubling of

15:27

the likelihood that they would engage in

15:30

the ongoing pursuit of that particular

15:32

goal. The goals need to be realistic and

15:34

truly challenging. Don't set goals that

15:37

are so challenging and so lofty that

15:40

they crash that blood pressure system in

15:43

the other direction and make you or

15:45

anyone feel unmotivated. Now, I'd like

15:47

to talk about three particular areas of

15:49

scientific study that point to goal

15:52

pursuit, goal assessment, and goal

15:54

achievement. Any discussion about goals

15:56

and goal pursuit would be incomplete

15:59

without a discussion about the molecule

16:01

dopamine.

16:02

Dopamine is often thought of as the

16:04

molecule of pleasure and reward, but

16:07

actually it is the molecule of

16:09

motivation. This is best illustrated by

16:12

a classic set of studies that have been

16:13

carried out in both animals and in

16:15

humans. The animal study can be

16:17

described the following way. Two rats

16:20

each in a separate cage. You can provide

16:22

those rats with the opportunity to

16:25

indulge in something that they like like

16:27

food or mating or heat if it's cold in

16:31

the environment or a cool spot in the

16:33

cage if it's warm in the environment and

16:36

so forth. And what you find is that rats

16:39

will very readily approach the rewarding

16:43

thing. They will mate, they will eat,

16:45

they will pursue something that is of

16:48

pleasure. Now, if you are to take one of

16:51

those rats and deplete its dopamine

16:53

neurons, you can eliminate its dopamine

16:55

neurons or block dopamine in the brain.

16:57

What you find is that those animals will

16:59

still

17:01

enjoy pleasure. However, their

17:04

motivation to achieve pleasure is vastly

17:08

reduced. In fact, if you place the item

17:11

of pleasure, the mate, the food, etc.,

17:14

even just one rat's length away from

17:16

that rat, the rat without dopamine will

17:19

not even move one length of its own body

17:21

in order to achieve that pleasure. And

17:23

there are naturally occurring

17:24

experiments in humans that mimic that

17:26

result very accurately.

17:29

There are certain conditions in humans

17:30

where there is a depletion of dopamine.

17:32

And what you find is that the depletion

17:34

of dopamine does not inhibit an ability

17:37

to experience pleasure necessarily. It

17:40

inhibits an ability to pursue or go

17:42

through the series of action steps in

17:44

order to achieve pleasure. So, dopamine

17:47

really sits at the heart of our

17:49

motivational state to seek out goals and

17:52

to seek pleasure. And this is true for

17:55

immediate goals that take place within a

17:57

time frame of minutes or a time frame of

17:59

a day or the time frame of a week or the

18:01

time frame of a lifetime. Dopamine is

18:04

the common currency by which we pursue

18:06

goals. Now, dopamine does a number of

18:09

things that are very interesting. I'm

18:11

going to describe a few of them as they

18:13

relate to goal seeking behavior. First

18:15

of all, there's a fundamental feature of

18:18

how our brain releases and uses dopamine

18:22

that's called reward prediction error.

18:24

And the simplest way to think about

18:25

dopamine reward prediction error is that

18:29

dopamine is released in the greatest

18:31

amount and places uses into a greater

18:33

state of motivation. When something

18:36

happens that's positive and novel. If

18:39

you don't expect something positive to

18:41

happen, you're just going about your day

18:43

and something positive happens, dopamine

18:45

and a lot of dopamine is released.

18:48

However, if we anticipate something

18:51

positive is going to happen and then

18:53

that thing happens,

18:55

we experience dopamine as part of the

18:58

anticipation. So, even before we get the

19:00

reward, there's an increase in dopamine.

19:03

It's not as high as it would be if

19:05

something really novel and unexpected

19:07

and positive happened, but we do get an

19:09

increase in dopamine. And then when we

19:11

actually experience the reward, we

19:14

experience the positive thing, there's a

19:16

smaller increase in dopamine. Okay? So

19:18

again, the biggest increases in dopamine

19:20

are response to things that are positive

19:23

and unexpected.

19:25

Lesser dopamine is released when we

19:27

anticipate something good will happen.

19:29

And when that happens, yes, we get some

19:31

dopamine and we also get some dopamine

19:33

when the positive thing happens. There's

19:35

also the case in which we predict that

19:36

something good will happen. When that

19:38

happens, there's an increase in dopamine

19:40

just as it was before. But then if that

19:42

thing doesn't happen, for instance, our

19:43

friends don't show up for dinner, then

19:45

there's a drop in dopamine below our

19:47

initial baseline. That drop in dopamine

19:50

is the chemical essence of what we call

19:52

disappointment.

19:54

Now, this dopamine reward prediction

19:57

error, as it's called, can be leveraged

19:59

toward trying to reach our goals because

20:02

it tells us where we should set our

20:04

milestones.

20:06

We can't be in a mode of simply being

20:09

focused on the finish line. So

20:12

understanding what we know about reward

20:13

prediction error. We can make better

20:16

choices about where to place the

20:18

milestones, how far out in the future to

20:21

place milestones. So then the question

20:23

becomes how often or at what intervals

20:26

should one assess progress. I think that

20:28

checking in at the end of a week,

20:29

looking back on the previous week, and

20:31

assessing how well you performed in

20:33

pursuit of a given goal or how many

20:35

times you did something that you wanted

20:36

to do or avoided something that you

20:38

didn't want to do. I think that's a

20:40

reasonable and tractable schedule to

20:43

assess once a week. This dopamine system

20:46

is critical to reup to remind ourselves

20:49

that we are on track if indeed we are on

20:51

track because dopamine itself provides a

20:55

state of motivation and readiness to

20:57

continue in the regular pursuit of our

20:59

goals. Another very interesting aspect

21:01

of dopamine is actually how the dopamine

21:04

system interacts with the visual system.

21:06

When we are focused on a particular

21:08

point in visual space or a particular

21:11

goal or horizon, all those systems, our

21:14

blood pressure, epinephrine, and indeed

21:16

dopamine get recruited to put us into a

21:19

state of readiness and willingness to go

21:21

pursue things in that extra personal

21:22

space. When our visual attention is very

21:26

diffuse, all of that relaxes and we tend

21:29

to be more comfortable staying in the

21:30

place that we are in our perpersonal

21:33

space. And the effect works in the other

21:35

direction too.

21:36

When dopamine is increased, our visual

21:39

attention for particular things out in

21:41

space increase. So the way it works is

21:43

reciprocal. When we use our visual

21:46

system in a particular way, bring it to

21:48

a point of focus, it recruits chemical

21:50

and neural systems in our brain and body

21:51

that put us into a state of readiness

21:53

and pursuit. And when we increase

21:57

certain chemicals in our brain and body

21:59

like epinephrine, like dopamine, then we

22:01

also allow our visual system to be in a

22:04

state of looking out at particular

22:07

locations in our visual world. So the

22:09

system works in both directions. And

22:11

some people leverage this by using

22:13

things like caffeine or taking things

22:14

like elyroine to increase dopamine. And

22:17

again, it works both ways. There's no

22:18

right or wrong way to do it. I'm a

22:20

particular fan of using behavioral tools

22:23

always prior to using supplementation or

22:26

any kinds of other tools because

22:28

behavioral tools have a very unique

22:30

feature that supplementation and other

22:32

chemical tools don't, which is that

22:34

behavioral tools used over time engage

22:37

neuroplasticity. As we start to practice

22:40

using our visual system to harness our

22:42

attention to particular locations and in

22:44

that way move toward particular goals,

22:45

we get better and better at using those

22:47

systems. In fact, the systems for focus

22:49

and motivation themselves have

22:51

plasticity. So, we get better at being

22:53

motivated and focused when we place our

22:55

visual attention at a given location.

22:57

I'd like to just briefly recap what I've

22:59

covered up until now. First of all, set

23:02

goals that are challenging but possible.

23:04

Those moderate goals, not super easy,

23:06

not super difficult, but moderately

23:08

challenging goals seem to be the most

23:10

effective in moving people towards their

23:12

goals over the short and long term.

23:14

Second, plan concretely. You need a

23:16

concrete set of actions that you're

23:18

going to follow in order to reach your

23:20

goals. Third, foreshadow failure. It

23:23

turns out that imagining success and

23:25

visualizing success can be useful at the

23:27

outset of a goal and maybe every once in

23:30

a while in pursuit of that goal, but

23:32

that it's not terrific for putting you

23:34

in constant pursuit of that goal.

23:36

Rather, foreshadowing failure,

23:38

visualizing failure and all the terrible

23:40

things that it's going to bring seems to

23:42

be more effective. And that maps very

23:43

well to what's known about the neural

23:45

circuitry and the involvement of the

23:46

amydala.

23:48

Focus on particular visual points as a

23:51

way to harness your attention and to

23:53

remove distractors. Removing distractors

23:56

and getting your body and brain into a

23:58

mode of activation, getting that healthy

24:00

increase in systolic blood pressure that

24:02

puts you into forward motion towards

24:04

your goals is absolutely key. So that's

24:06

a brief summary of what I've covered up

24:08

until now. But I want to be sure to

24:11

include a tool that's been especially

24:13

powerful for me that's grounded in the

24:15

neuroscience research and in the

24:16

psychology research. And as I describe

24:19

this tool next, I think you'll see the

24:21

ways in which it meshes nicely with the

24:23

work that Emily Balsetus and colleagues

24:25

have done. This is something that I've

24:28

personally been doing for many years

24:30

based on my understanding of the visual

24:31

system and the understanding that indeed

24:35

we can move our cognition and our

24:37

perception from a place of

24:40

interosception and focusing on our

24:42

perpersonal space that space within us

24:44

and immediately around us and on the

24:46

things that are immediately accessible

24:48

to us. that we can shift from that mode

24:51

to this mode of exterception of focusing

24:54

on things outside the confines of our

24:56

skin and that are beyond our reach that

24:58

are literally goal- directed behaviors

25:00

and goal- directed thoughts. And

25:02

[snorts] this is something that in the

25:04

past I've talked about a little bit and

25:06

I've talked about something called

25:07

space-time bridging. And we haven't

25:09

talked too much about the time domain of

25:10

the visual system today. But spac-time

25:14

bridging is simply a way of using one's

25:17

visual system to focus on the

25:18

perpersonal space and interception and

25:21

then gradually in a deliberate way

25:23

stepping one's focus into the

25:25

extrapersonal space and then back to the

25:27

perpersonal space in a way that gives

25:29

you a lot of flexibility and control

25:32

over that ability in your daily life. So

25:36

I'm going to first describe the tool and

25:38

then I will explain more about the

25:39

underlying science and the underlying

25:41

mechanism.

25:43

Here's how you would do this. What you

25:45

first do is you would close your eyes

25:47

and you would focus as much of your

25:50

attention including your visual

25:52

attention on your inner landscape on

25:55

your interosception. So that would be

25:56

your breathing, your heart rate, maybe

25:58

even the surface of your skin, but

25:59

really focusing internally. And you

26:01

would do that for a duration of

26:04

approximately three slow breaths. Then

26:07

you would open your eyes and you would

26:09

focus your visual attention on some area

26:11

on the surface of your body. So for me,

26:13

the way that I typically do this will be

26:14

to focus on say the palm of my hand. So

26:16

I'll focus my visual attention on the

26:18

palm of my hand. And I then do three

26:21

breaths again focusing on my internal

26:24

state. But now I'm splitting out a

26:26

little bit of my attention from

26:27

interosception to exterception. I'm

26:29

focusing on something outside me. The

26:31

ratio or the split of attention is about

26:34

9010. About 90% of my attention is

26:36

focused internally, but I'm also

26:39

focusing some of my attention

26:40

externally. Okay, most people can do

26:42

this pretty easily. Then there's a third

26:45

what I call station. I now move my

26:47

visual attention to outside my body to

26:50

some location in the room or if I'm

26:52

outside in the external environment,

26:53

something in the range of 5 to 15 feet

26:55

away. And I'm trying to move 90% of my

26:58

attention to that external object. As I

27:01

breathe, I'm paying attention to those

27:02

three breaths. So that's why there's

27:03

still 10% that's focused on my internal

27:05

landscape because I want to pay

27:07

attention to those three breaths, but

27:08

I'm focusing as much of my attention

27:11

outside of myself, maintaining just a

27:13

little bit on my internal state so I can

27:15

measure the cadence of those three

27:17

breaths. Then I move my visual attention

27:19

to yet another station which is further

27:21

away. Typically a horizon or something

27:23

as far off in the distance as I can

27:25

possibly see. Again, for the duration of

27:27

three breaths.

27:29

And at that point, I'm trying my very

27:31

best to move 99 if not 100% of my

27:35

attention to that external location.

27:38

Okay? And then what I typically will do

27:41

is I will try and expand both my vision

27:45

and my cognition to a much broader

27:48

sphere. This is that magnosellar vision

27:49

that we talked about before where I'm

27:51

not focusing on a particular location on

27:53

the horizon. I'm trying to dilate the

27:55

aperture of my field of view so I can

27:56

see as much of the visual landscape as

27:58

I'm in as possible. Again, for the

28:00

duration of three breaths. Then I would

28:03

return immediately to my internal

28:05

landscape. I would close my eyes and I

28:07

would do three more breaths focusing

28:09

entirely on my interosception on my

28:12

internal landscape or what we called

28:14

before my perpersonal space. And I would

28:17

work through each of those stations

28:18

maybe two or three times. The entire

28:20

thing takes about 90 seconds to 3

28:23

minutes depending on how many breaths

28:24

you do. What is all of this doing? Why

28:26

do I call this space-time bridging and

28:28

why is this useful for goal setting?

28:30

>> [clears throat]

28:30

>> The reason I call it spac-time bridging

28:32

is that the visual system is not just

28:35

about analyzing space. It's actually how

28:38

we batch time. It's how we carve up

28:40

time. And the simple way to state this

28:42

is that when we focus our visual

28:44

attention on a very narrow point that's

28:47

close to our body and our immediate

28:49

experience, we tend to slice up time

28:52

very finely. We're focused on our

28:54

breathing. We're focused on our

28:56

heartbeats. In fact, our breathing and

28:58

our internal landscape and our

28:59

heartbeats become the sort of seconds

29:01

hand if you will on our experience. We

29:04

are carving up time according to our

29:06

immediate physiological experience.

29:08

Whereas when we focus our visual

29:10

attention outside our body, not only do

29:12

we engage that exterceptive extrapol

29:16

system and we start to engage the

29:17

dopamine system, the goal- directed

29:19

system, but we also start batching time

29:22

differently. When we focus our visual

29:24

system into a broader sphere of space or

29:27

into a space beyond the confines of our

29:29

skin, we start carving up time. Our

29:31

frame rate changes. Now this is useful

29:35

in the context of goal setting, goal

29:37

assessment and goal pursuit because with

29:40

the exception of a very few isolated

29:43

examples, almost all goals involve

29:46

setting some goal that's often the

29:49

future and then carving up the time

29:51

between now and the achievement of that

29:53

goal into milestones that range in

29:56

duration. And the rewards even if we try

29:59

and just make them every week are going

30:01

to come at some unexpected intervals.

30:04

And that's actually can be helpful for

30:05

reinforcing behavior. Intermittent

30:07

reward that's intermittent and random is

30:10

the most effective reward schedule we

30:11

know.

30:13

But the problem is always how do we keep

30:15

our cognition in line with the long-term

30:17

goal while also being focused on these

30:19

more immediate goals. This behavior or

30:22

this practice rather is teaching us to

30:24

use our visual system and thereby our

30:26

cognitive system and thereby our reward

30:29

systems to orient to different locations

30:32

in space and therefore at different

30:34

locations in time. And that is the

30:37

essence of goal-directed behavior. That

30:39

is the essence of setting a goal. It's

30:42

about thinking about what you want. Then

30:43

it's about setting milestones that are

30:47

intermediate to that goal. Then it's

30:49

about assessing whether or not you're

30:50

reaching those milestones. And then it's

30:52

of course about updating your goals if

30:54

you need to update your goals. All of

30:56

that is an enormously confusing batch of

30:59

challenges if you think about it all at

31:01

once. But if you break it down into

31:03

these elements that the visual system

31:05

can help you find and move towards those

31:07

milestones. I think there's ample

31:08

evidence to support that. What's very

31:10

clear is that an ability to move from

31:13

different visual stations and to do that

31:15

in a deliberate way, in a focused and

31:18

conscious way clearly maps to an ability

31:20

to conceive of different goals over

31:22

different periods of time and I do

31:24

believe can be greatly beneficial in

31:26

allowing one to set particular goals and

31:29

then move through the milestones to

31:31

those goals and to constantly update

31:33

one's pursuit and reward in reaching

31:35

those milestones and eventually the

31:37

overall goal. Per usual, I covered a lot

31:39

of material today. We talked about some

31:41

of the neuroscience and psychology and

31:43

popular understanding of goal seeeking

31:46

behavior, how to assess goals, etc.

31:48

Talked about the use of the visual

31:49

system to better achieve goals and

31:52

indeed things like visualization and why

31:55

forecasting failure can be more

31:57

effective than forecasting success. And

31:59

in addition, I described this practice

32:00

that one can incorporate as a daily or

32:03

semi-aily practice of so-called

32:05

space-time bridging of using the visual

32:07

system and your ability to deliberately

32:09

step your visual system from stations

32:12

that are within your body so-called

32:14

perpersonal or interceptive space out

32:16

into the world further and further and

32:18

then back again in sequence as a way to

32:20

harness and cultivate and build up these

32:23

systems that link vision, space, time,

32:27

reward systems, and so forth.

32:28

Ultimately,

32:30

as you set out to accomplish your goals,

32:32

there are going to be a number of basic

32:34

steps that everyone will have to follow.

32:36

You'll have to clearly identify what the

32:38

long-ching ultimate goal is. You'll have

32:40

to identify what the milestones will be.

32:43

You might not know all of them at the

32:44

outset, but you ought to have some idea

32:46

about the intervals at which you are

32:48

going to set those milestones and set

32:51

your reward schedule for assessing

32:54

progress in route to those milestones

32:56

and your ultimate goal. My hope is that

32:58

you'll be able to incorporate these

32:59

tools, if not all of them, perhaps just

33:02

one of them or two of them in pursuit of

33:04

whatever particular goals you happen to

33:06

be focused on at this point and in the

33:08

future. And last, but certainly not

33:10

least, thank you for your interest in

33:12

science.

33:16

>> [music]

Interactive Summary

This video discusses the science of goal setting and achievement, highlighting key neural circuits and neurotransmitters involved. It explains how areas like the amygdala (fear/avoidance), basal ganglia (action/inaction), and prefrontal cortex (planning/emotion) contribute to goal-directed behavior. Dopamine is identified as the primary neurotransmitter for motivation and reward assessment. The video also introduces practical tools, such as focusing visual attention on a specific point to enhance action and reduce perceived effort, and the importance of visualizing potential failures rather than just successes to increase motivation. It further details a technique called 'space-time bridging' which uses visual focus shifts between internal and external states to manage time perception and enhance goal pursuit.

Suggested questions

6 ready-made prompts