HomeVideos

List vs. Loll: The Deadly Difference in Ship Stability

Now Playing

List vs. Loll: The Deadly Difference in Ship Stability

Transcript

305 segments

0:00

You're standing on the dock. You see a

0:03

ship floating at an angle, maybe five or

0:06

10° off level, leaning to one side. Your

0:10

first thought might be that something's

0:11

wrong. The ship is sinking or in

0:14

distress, but not always. Ships tilt for

0:18

different reasons. Some tilts are normal

0:21

and fixable, and some look perfectly

0:24

stable and are actually a moment away

0:26

from capsizing. Understanding the

0:29

difference matters. So, how do you tell

0:31

them apart? That's what we're going to

0:33

work through today. When a ship tilts,

0:36

it's not just one thing. The maritime

0:38

industry has different names for

0:40

different types of tilt because each one

0:42

[music] means something specific.

0:44

There's a list. Heel, angle of lol, and

0:47

trim. Each of these has different

0:50

causes, different stability

0:52

characteristics, different levels of

0:54

danger, and of course, different fixes.

0:57

A ship leaning 10° to port could be

1:00

perfectly safe in the middle of a normal

1:02

turn or about to capsize, depending on

1:05

the type of tilt it is. List is the one

1:08

most people have seen without even

1:10

realizing it. A ship with a list is

1:13

leaning to port or starboard and it

1:16

stays there. The tilt doesn't go away

1:18

when the wind dies down or the waves

1:20

stop. Even in completely calm water, the

1:23

ship remains at that angle. The cause is

1:26

almost always uneven weight

1:28

distribution. Cargo loaded heavier on

1:31

one side than the other. Containers

1:33

stacked unevenly, grain or other bulk

1:36

cargo shifting during voyage, fuel or

1:39

ballast tanks emptied or filled in a way

1:41

that puts more weight on one side. It

1:44

can also be caused by flooding. If water

1:47

enters one side of the ship through a

1:48

damaged compartment, for example, but

1:51

not on the other, the ship will list

1:53

towards the flooded side. Now, here's

1:55

the question you're probably asking. Is

1:58

this dangerous? A small list isn't

2:00

usually a serious problem. At 2 or 3°,

2:03

it's barely noticeable. 5° obvious to

2:07

anyone [music] on the dock. 10° or more

2:09

starts affecting how the ship operates.

2:12

Crew can't walk normally. equipment

2:15

doesn't sit level and cargo handling

2:17

becomes difficult. Here's the reassuring

2:20

part. A ship with a list is still

2:23

stable. Look here. The center of gravity

2:26

is offset from the center, but it's

2:29

still below the metaentric height,

2:31

meaning a positive GM. Think of it like

2:34

a weeble. It's leaning, but the weight

2:36

distribution still wants to pull it back

2:38

toward [music] a resting point. It's

2:40

found a new equilibrium at that angle.

2:43

It won't keep tipping on its own. That

2:46

makes list fixable. Crew can

2:48

redistribute cargo or pump ballast water

2:51

from one side to the other to counter

2:53

the imbalance. Basically removing or

2:56

adding weights in the right places.

2:58

Fairies develop a small list sometimes

3:00

when vehicles aren't parked

3:01

symmetrically. Container ships

3:03

occasionally show a list after loading

3:05

if the weight distribution wasn't

3:07

calculated correctly. In both cases, the

3:10

crew corrects it. List is a manageable

3:14

problem and it is universal. No matter

3:17

where the ship was built or where it

3:20

sailed to, which is exactly like SE eim,

3:23

who [music] are sponsoring today's

3:24

video, SY saves you the stress of buying

3:27

and registering a new local SIM whenever

3:30

you travel to a new country. No physical

3:33

card or new setup every time you cross a

3:36

border. Install it once and it works for

3:38

every trip after that. Think about the

3:41

last time you flew somewhere. You land,

3:43

you turn your phone off airplane mode

3:45

and start looking for signal. Then

3:47

you're either hunting for a SIM kiosk in

3:49

the arrivals hall, hoping the one

3:51

outside the station isn't a scam, or

3:53

bracing yourself for whatever your

3:55

roaming bill is going to look like at

3:57

the end of the week. With Sale, you skip

4:00

all of that. You set up your plan before

4:02

you leave home, and the moment you land,

4:04

[music] you're connected. The setup

4:07

couldn't be easier. Download the sale

4:09

app. Pick your data plan from hundreds

4:12

of options, regional, global, or country

4:14

specific. And at checkout, apply the

4:17

coupon code navigation 15 for an

4:20

exclusive discount. They cover over 200

4:23

countries with global and regional plans

4:26

if you're hitting multiple destinations.

4:28

The app warns you at 80% usage [music]

4:31

so you don't get caught out. Works on

4:34

iOS and Android with a built-in ad

4:36

blocker that cuts your data use by

4:39

nearly 30%. Get an exclusive 15%

4:42

discount on sale eim data plans.

4:45

Download the SY app and use code

4:47

navigation 15 at checkout. The QR codes

4:51

on the screen and links in the

4:53

description below. Now back to ship

4:55

tilts because not every problem is as

4:58

easy to fix as a list or with sail eim.

5:03

Heel looks similar to list. The ship

5:06

leans to one side but the cause and

5:09

behavior are completely different. Heel

5:12

is temporary. Sometimes it's caused by

5:14

an external force such as a strong wind

5:17

pushing against the side of the ship and

5:18

her superructure. And when that force

5:21

stops, the ship returns to upright.

5:23

Sailing vessels heal dramatically under

5:25

wind pressure. It's a normal part of how

5:27

they sail. The most common occurrence is

5:30

during turning. You know the feeling.

5:32

You're in a car going around the bend

5:34

and your whole body leans to the

5:35

outside. A ship does exactly the same

5:38

thing. The faster the ship, the tighter

5:41

the turn, the more it heals. Waves can

5:44

cause temporary heal as they pass. So

5:47

can cargo operations. A crane lifting a

5:50

heavy load out to one side shifts that

5:52

balance momentarily.

5:54

So, what brings the ship back upright?

5:57

The same stability that keeps it afloat

5:59

in the first place. As soon as the force

6:01

disappears, the ship's weight

6:03

distribution [music] pulls the ship back

6:05

to level. It doesn't need the crew to do

6:07

anything. It just corrects itself. It

6:10

only becomes dangerous when the healing

6:12

force exceeds the ship's stability

6:14

limits. extreme weather, an overloaded

6:17

ship or a combination of forces can push

6:20

a ship past the point where it can

6:22

recover. But under normal conditions,

6:24

heel is just part of how ships move

6:26

through water. The angle of lol is one

6:30

that fools people. A ship with an angle

6:32

of lol is leaning to one side, sitting

6:36

at a steady angle. It looks like a list.

6:39

The ship is floating. It's not visibly

6:42

sinking and everything seems under

6:44

control. But she is in critical

6:47

condition and could capsize at any

6:50

moment. So why is a ship that looks

6:52

stable actually on the edge of

6:53

capsizing? Think of a stable ship as a

6:56

weighted toy. The heavy part is at the

6:58

bottom, the light part at the top. That

7:01

low weight is what pulls it back upright

7:04

whenever it tilts. In technical terms, a

7:06

stable ship has a metaentric height

7:08

above its center of gravity. positive

7:11

GM. An unstable ship looks almost

7:14

identical, but its center of gravity is

7:17

above the metaentric [music] height.

7:20

Now, tilt both of them. Here's what

7:23

happens. For the stable ship, as it

7:25

tilts, the buoyancy shifts to the low

7:27

side and the weight stays on the heavy

7:30

side. Those two forces acting on

7:32

opposite sides create a writing moment.

7:36

A force that pushes the ship back

7:38

upright. Tilt it, it corrects. For the

7:41

unstable ship, the forces flip. Weight

7:44

on the low side, buoyancy on the high

7:47

side. Instead of a writing [music]

7:49

moment, you get a capsizing lever. Now,

7:52

because GM is negative, the ship can't

7:54

stay upright. It tips to one side,

7:56

[music]

7:57

but it doesn't capsize immediately. It

8:00

settles at an angle known as the angle

8:02

of lol, [music] where it finds a

8:04

temporary fragile equilibrium. And this

8:08

is what makes it so dangerous. The ship

8:11

looks stable, but it has almost no

8:14

writing energy. Any disturbance, a wave,

8:18

a gust of wind, crew moving cargo can

8:21

push it past that tipping point. And

8:23

once it goes, it capsizes fast. There's

8:27

another counterintuitive part. A ship at

8:30

an angle of lull can flop to either

8:32

side. It might be leaning to port one

8:34

moment, then suddenly roll through

8:36

upright and settle to starboard. That

8:38

sudden movement alone can be enough to

8:41

capsize it. And correcting it the wrong

8:43

way makes it dangerous. For list, you'd

8:45

pump ballast to the high side to level

8:47

the ship. Do that with an angle of lull

8:50

and you trigger a violent roll to the

8:52

other side. The correct fix is to

8:54

[music] lower the center of gravity. Add

8:56

weight low in the ship. Remove weight

8:58

from up high. Fill or empty tanks to

9:01

eliminate the free surface effect,

9:03

[music] but it has to be done carefully

9:05

and in the right order because the ship

9:08

has to pass through the unstable upright

9:10

[music] position to recover. The Herald

9:13

of Free Enterprise capsized in 1987.

9:17

Water flooded onto the car deck. The

9:20

center of gravity rose and stability was

9:22

gone. People died. The European Gateway

9:26

capsized in 1982 under similar [music]

9:28

conditions.

9:29

That's the difference between list and

9:31

lol. A ship with a list is stable and

9:34

leaning because of uneven weight. A ship

9:37

at an angle of lol is unstable and

9:39

leaning because it's lost the ability to

9:41

write itself. Everything so far has been

9:44

about a ship leaning sideways. But

9:46

there's one more direction forwards and

9:49

backwards. That's trim. If the bow sits

9:52

lower than the stern, the ship is down

9:55

by the head. If the stern sits lower

9:57

than the bow, it's down by the stern.

10:00

Trim is measured by the difference

10:01

between how deep the ship sits at the

10:03

front and how deep it sits at the back.

10:06

The causes are similar to list just

10:08

along the longitudinal axis. Cargo or

10:11

ballast concentrated towards the bow or

10:13

the stern, flooding in a forward or aft

10:16

compartment, fuel burning off from tanks

10:19

at one end of the ship during voyage.

10:21

Trim usually isn't an immediate danger

10:24

the way angle of law is, but it affects

10:28

how the ship performs. Too much weight

10:30

forward and the bow digs into the water.

10:33

This can affect steering and slow the

10:36

ship down. The propeller at the stern

10:38

might rise too high, losing efficiency

10:40

or even breaking the surface. Too much

10:43

weight aft and the bow rises high. That

10:47

can reduce visibility from the bridge

10:48

and change how the ship handles.

10:51

Sometimes a ship is deliberately trimmed

10:53

by the stern because that keeps the

10:55

propeller fully submerged and working

10:57

efficiently. Bulk carriers adjust it

11:00

depending on the cargo. Tankers manage

11:02

it constantly throughout loading and

11:04

discharge. So, back to you on the dock

11:08

looking at that ship leaning at an

11:10

angle. When you see a tilted ship, it

11:12

isn't always in trouble. If it's

11:14

healing, it's in the middle of a turn or

11:16

the wind is pushing it. It'll come back

11:19

on its own. If it's listing, the weight

11:21

is uneven. The crew knows they're

11:24

already fixing it. If it's trimmed, bow

11:27

or stern sitting low, that's probably

11:29

deliberate. The one that matters is the

11:32

angle of lull because it doesn't look

11:34

like an emergency. The ship is floating.

11:38

The deck is steady. Everything seems

11:40

under control. But the ship has lost its

11:43

stability. And a single wave or a shift

11:45

in weight can send it over. The MVC wall

11:49

covered in our video on the inclining

11:51

test is [music] the most recent reminder

11:53

of what this looks like when it goes

11:55

wrong. Cargo shifted, the ship listed,

11:57

[music]

11:58

and what looked manageable at first

12:00

ended in capsize. If you want to hear

12:03

more about the MVC wall, please check

12:05

the link in the description down below

12:07

[music] if you haven't yet seen that

12:08

video. If you enjoyed this video, please

12:12

make sure to like and subscribe if you

12:14

haven't already and ring that

12:16

notification bell to stay uptodate with

12:18

all of our latest videos. Before you go,

12:21

a quick thank you to SY ESIM for

12:23

sponsoring today's video. If you travel

12:26

and you're tired of hunting for SIM

12:28

cards and airports, Syim works in over

12:31

200 countries. Install it once and use

12:34

everywhere. Code navigation 15 gets you

12:37

50% off and the QR code is on [music]

12:40

the screen right now. The link is in the

12:43

description below. Thank you very much

12:46

for watching and we'll see you all in

12:48

the next video.

Interactive Summary

The video explains the different reasons a ship may appear to be tilted while on the water. It differentiates between 'list' (caused by uneven weight distribution), 'heel' (a temporary tilt caused by external forces like wind or turns), 'angle of lol' (an unstable condition caused by a high center of gravity that can lead to capsizing), and 'trim' (the ship's angle relative to its length). Understanding these types of tilts is crucial for maritime safety, particularly because the angle of lol is especially dangerous as it may appear stable despite being on the verge of capsizing.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts