HomeVideos

The Self-Help Trap - What 20+ Years of “Optimizing” Has Taught Me

Now Playing

The Self-Help Trap - What 20+ Years of “Optimizing” Has Taught Me

Transcript

140 segments

0:00

Yeah, I would say a few things. So,

0:03

one of the risks of

0:07

personal development or let's just call

0:10

it more broadly self-help is that it can

0:13

very easily become self-infatuation or

0:16

self-obsession.

0:18

And the

0:21

counterbalance to that, the bet that

0:25

offsets it is

0:27

dun. It's very simple. relationships

0:30

really doubling down, tripling down on

0:32

relationships. We are evolved to be a

0:34

social species and whenever you are in

0:38

isolation physically or simply in

0:40

thought loops in your own head, that

0:42

tends to catalyze or

0:46

worsen tremendously any type of

0:48

instability or OCD or depression or

0:52

anxiety or fill-in- thelank psychiatric

0:54

condition. So

0:56

my

0:58

policies that which were already in

1:00

place last time we spoke that I have

1:03

really

1:05

continued to invest into are doing a

1:10

past year review every year looking at

1:13

my top relationships that are nourishing

1:17

energizing energy in as opposed to

1:19

energy out and then blocking out time in

1:23

advance for the entire year for extended

1:25

periods of time with those people. Now,

1:27

extended will depend on your

1:28

circumstances. For me, that could be

1:30

anywhere from a long weekend to a week

1:34

spending, say, 5 days in the wilderness

1:37

in Montana with some of my oldest,

1:38

closest friends, etc., etc.

1:41

And that will do. Not to denigrate

1:45

therapy in any way, but sometimes

1:49

talking more about your problems if it

1:51

were to solve all of your problems would

1:53

have worked already. And there's a place

1:55

for talk therapy. There's a place for

1:57

talk therapy, but it is not, nor does it

2:01

need to be the only tool in the toolkit.

2:03

So simply spending time around your

2:05

silly, dumb, amazing friends and

2:08

laughing whether it's around a bottle of

2:11

wine or a meal or a campfire really

2:14

really goes a long way. So that's one

2:16

piece of it.

2:16

>> I'm curious like you mentioned that in

2:18

recent years you've at the top of every

2:20

year you kind of make a plan to see the

2:22

people who to use the cliche fill your

2:25

cup. Um, had you gone through a period

2:28

like I like I did where there was a a

2:31

certain amount of isolation or um in in

2:35

attention to this to this lever.

2:37

>> Oh, for sure. And I think

2:42

there were a few different reasons for

2:43

that. Uh, I don't know if hindsight's

2:46

2020, but I think it's easier to see

2:48

from my vantage point now that

2:52

and it's a balancing act because there's

2:54

there's compulsive socializing because

2:56

you are

2:59

incredibly uncomfortable or afraid of

3:02

being alone or with yourself,

3:05

>> right? There's compulsive socializing to

3:08

distract yourself, like protect yourself

3:10

from yourself, which is problematic.

3:14

And then there's compulsive isolation.

3:16

And I would say I probably leaned far

3:20

more towards the compulsive isolation.

3:22

And there were two reasons for that. One

3:24

was workcoholism back in the day for

3:28

sure. and I just

3:31

felt like I was more effective, able to

3:34

produce, more, able to focus on

3:36

business, finances, whatever it might be

3:38

in isolation. And there might be some

3:39

truth to that.

3:41

Then I would say there was also this

3:45

belief

3:46

that I think at the time was really

3:51

implicit. I don't think I explicitly

3:53

grasped it, which was, and I've I've

3:56

written this incredibly long essay that

3:59

maybe I'll publish at some point, but

4:02

talking about some of the dangers of

4:04

self-help, and one of them is the

4:07

following, which ties into what we're

4:08

talking about and leaning towards

4:09

isolation.

4:11

this implicit belief or explicit that

4:15

you need to work on yourself and fix

4:18

yourself and quote unquote do the work

4:20

and then you'll be ready to interact

4:22

with other people and have a significant

4:24

relationship and engage with your family

4:28

if that is an option or you want it to

4:30

be an option etc etc. So in effect, the

4:35

the analogy that I've drawn for some

4:38

friends is

4:40

you want to play soccer, but first

4:43

you're going to read all the textbooks

4:44

and get a master's degree and PhD in

4:47

soccer. And then you're going to

4:49

practice dribbling and penalty shots and

4:51

so on by yourself.

4:53

And and you want to become as perfect a

4:57

player as possible by yourself before

4:59

you ever actually get on the field and

5:01

play the game of soccer. and you can

5:02

start to believe that you're playing

5:04

soccer by yourself. There's always more

5:07

room for improvement. You're never going

5:09

to be perfect. And if you get caught in

5:13

that trap, which is the partial trap of

5:15

self-help, you're always polishing this

5:20

self.

5:21

And it can become this real recursive

5:24

dangerous trap, this fixation on the

5:26

self.

5:27

And you never actually [ __ ] play

5:29

soccer.

5:33

And at a point you start to believe that

5:37

you are but you're not. You're

5:39

simulating by yourself life but not

5:43

actually engaging with life. And

5:46

I have

5:48

who knows maybe this is a function of

5:49

getting older. I don't think so

5:51

necessarily but for so many decades I

5:54

was interested in the cutting edge the

5:56

cutting edge of everything. and I still

5:58

am, but I've become interested equally

6:02

in things that have lasted millennia

6:06

or more than millennia.

Interactive Summary

The speaker discusses the potential downsides of personal development, noting it can lead to self-infatuation or obsession. He emphasizes that the critical counterbalance is investing in relationships, as humans are inherently social and isolation exacerbates psychological issues. The speaker's personal strategy involves an annual review of nourishing relationships and proactively scheduling extended time with close friends. He admits to a past period of compulsive isolation, driven by workaholism and a belief in needing to perfect himself before fully engaging with others. This

Suggested questions

5 ready-made prompts