HomeVideos

What Happened To The Bodies At Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

Now Playing

What Happened To The Bodies At Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

Transcript

529 segments

0:00

At 8:15 a.m. on August the 6th, 1945,

0:05

a single plane dropped a single bomb on

0:10

a single city on Japan's Honchu Island.

0:13

When that atomic bomb exploded over the

0:16

city of Hiroshima, it caused devastation

0:19

on an untold scale. The blast killed

0:23

more than a 100,000 people, left many

0:25

more with horrifying injuries, and

0:28

introduced the world to the power of a

0:31

nuclear weapon. 3 days later, at just

0:33

after 11:00 a.m. on August the 9th,

0:36

another plane dropped another bomb and

0:38

devastated another city. This time, it

0:42

was Nagasaki on Kyushu Island. This

0:45

second nuclear attack added tens of

0:47

thousands to the death toll and made it

0:49

very clear to Japan what kind of

0:51

weaponry they were facing.

0:54

But what came next? What happened after

0:57

all of this? Now you might already know

0:59

the answer to that. What came next was

1:02

the Soviet invasion of Manuria and the

1:04

Japanese surrender. What happened after

1:06

this was the beginning of the Cold War

1:08

and the age of nuclear anxiety.

1:11

But what about on the ground on what

1:14

used to be the streets of Hiroshima and

1:17

Nagasaki? Specifically, what happened to

1:21

the piles of bodies that were left

1:23

behind by the nuclear blasts? The

1:25

wounded, traumatized populations of two

1:28

cities now had to deal with the grim

1:31

logistics of handling all those dead.

1:34

But how would this even be possible in a

1:37

shattered, irradiated landscape? and

1:40

what lessons would be learned by

1:42

understanding how these people died.

1:46

Today, we're telling the story of the

1:48

bodies left behind at Hiroshima and

1:51

Nagasaki as we look into the aftermath

1:54

of the first and so far the only nuclear

1:58

attacks in human history and the grizzly

2:01

cleanup operation that followed.

2:08

Before we explore what happened to these

2:10

bodies, we need to get to grips with

2:12

just how many bodies were left after the

2:15

strikes. This is actually not an easy

2:17

question to answer. For Hiroshima, the

2:20

1945 population was around 340,000.

2:24

Around 40% of these people are believed

2:26

to have died by November of that same

2:28

year. As for Nagasaki, the details are a

2:31

little sketchier, but the best estimates

2:34

place the city's population between

2:36

195,000 and 240,000.

2:40

By the end of 1945,

2:42

somewhere between 60,000 and 80,000

2:45

people had lost their lives as a result

2:47

of the bombing. Addressing the

2:49

uncertainty, the Manhattan Project's

2:51

chief medical officer, Colonel Stafford

2:53

Warren, had this to say in a speech to

2:55

Congress in February 1946.

2:58

I'm embarrassed by the fact that we

3:00

could not come back with any definitive

3:02

figures that I'll be able to say were

3:04

more than a guess. The only actual fact

3:07

that we could get was that at the

3:09

beginning of October 1945, Nagasaki had

3:12

recorded the burning and cremation of

3:14

40,000 bodies. It's my belief that there

3:17

must have been 20 or 30,000 more in the

3:20

ruins, buried or consumed by the fire.

3:24

So, the simple answer of how many bodies

3:27

we're dealing with is we don't know.

3:30

This is why the estimated combined death

3:32

toll ranges from 110,000 to more than

3:36

210,000 with many more people dying

3:39

later on from related illnesses and

3:41

injuries. As well as uncertainties over

3:43

the population, the condition of the

3:46

bodies has also made accurate

3:47

assessments difficult. Some victims were

3:50

identified or died much later. And these

3:53

fatalities were fairly easy to count,

3:55

but many others were not identified.

3:58

Some were simply too close to the

4:00

hyperenter of the blast. In other words,

4:03

the place directly beneath the bombs as

4:05

they detonated. The bodies of these

4:07

people were almost completely and

4:09

instantly destroyed. They were not,

4:11

however, vaporized. It's a common

4:13

misconception that victims were reduced

4:15

to dust and vapor by the force of the

4:17

explosion, leaving no trace of the

4:19

physical person behind. This idea has

4:22

grown out of the disturbing shadows that

4:24

were found on the streets and walls of

4:26

Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the aftermath

4:28

of the bombing. But these shadows are

4:30

not the eerie remains of people.

4:32

Instead, they're the result of something

4:34

called thermal bleaching. The intense

4:36

blast scoured surfaces with thermal

4:40

energy. Any surface that was subjected

4:43

to this energy was bleached, becoming a

4:45

lighter color. If the thermal energy was

4:47

blocked though, for example, by a tree,

4:49

by a building, or by a person, then the

4:53

nearby surface was left untouched. This

4:55

resulted in disturbing shadows cast upon

4:58

the ground, which serve as frozen

5:00

imprints of the victim's last moments.

5:03

Rather than being vaporized, these

5:05

bodies would have been incinerated by

5:07

the heat. This means there would have

5:09

been traces of the victim left like

5:11

teeth or bone fragments. However, these

5:14

remains were often not identifiable as a

5:16

specific person or even a person at all.

5:19

This may have given the impression that

5:21

bodies closest to the hyperenter simply

5:23

vanished. Kumiko Arakawa experienced

5:25

this as she navigated the landscape of

5:27

destruction in Nagasaki. Kumiko

5:30

described an eerie scene. I don't recall

5:32

seeing a single corpse. It sounds

5:35

strange, I'm sure, but it is the truth.

5:38

There are countless tombstones all over

5:40

Nagasaki with a name inscription, but no

5:43

ikotssu cremated bone remains. But

5:46

Kumiko's experience is an unusual one.

5:50

Elsewhere in the city, bodies were

5:52

strewn across the ground. A huge number

5:55

of bodies. Shako Matsumoto was only a

5:58

young girl when the bomb hit. She

6:01

remembered the aftermath of the attack 3

6:03

days later.

6:04

I will never forget the hellscape that

6:06

awaited us. Half burnt bodies lay stiff

6:10

on the ground, eyeballs gleaming from

6:12

their sockets. Cattle lay dead along the

6:14

side of the road, their abdomen

6:16

grotesqually large and swollen.

6:19

Thousands of bodies bopped up and down

6:22

the river, bloated and purplish from

6:25

soaking up the water. This was a serious

6:29

issue for city authorities. If the two

6:32

municipalities were going to be reborn

6:33

in a post-war world, they'd first need

6:36

to deal with the thousands of bodies

6:39

that choked the streets. What's more,

6:41

this would need to be done quickly. The

6:44

bombs struck Hiroshima and Nagasaki on

6:46

August 6th and 9th with temperatures

6:48

reaching 32° C and an average relative

6:52

humidity of between 70 and 80%. August

6:56

is the hottest and most humid month of

6:59

the year in these parts of Japan. Bodies

7:03

decomposed rapidly in these conditions.

7:05

17-year-old Yoshiharu Tara remembered

7:08

the scenes from Nagasaki.

7:10

It was summer, so the corpses rotted

7:13

quickly. At first, the stench of the

7:15

decomposing corpses was terrible, but

7:18

after a while, I didn't notice it. But

7:21

how could the city authorities hope to

7:25

dispose of all these human remains so

7:27

quickly? How could they even get to the

7:30

bodies? Surely both cities were now

7:32

no-go areas racked with residual

7:35

radiation from the atomic blasts. Well,

7:38

actually, this wasn't a problem. It's

7:40

certainly true that many people received

7:42

critical doses of radiation poisoning,

7:44

but these victims were people who were

7:46

exposed to the initial blast itself. The

7:49

dangers of residual radiation weren't

7:52

quite so high. Remember, the Fat Man and

7:55

Little Boy bombs were the first of their

7:57

kind. This type of weapon had never been

8:00

used before and has mercifully never

8:03

been used again since. There were

8:05

certainly devastating bombs, but they

8:08

weren't exactly wellhoned killing

8:10

machines. The bombs exploded a

8:12

significant distance above the cities of

8:14

Hiroshima and Nagasaki, sending most of

8:16

the radiation away from the cities.

8:18

themselves. Jeffrey Hart of the

8:20

Radiation Effects Research Foundation

8:23

explained more. Because the burst

8:25

heights of the bombings of Hiroshima and

8:27

Nagasaki were at 600 m in the air and

8:31

503 m respectively, most of the

8:33

radiation, about 90%, was pulled up into

8:36

the atmosphere. Of course, there was

8:38

still a lot of radiation on the ground,

8:41

just not nearly as much as we might

8:43

expect. Also, any radiation that did

8:46

make it to the ground became relatively

8:48

safe quite quickly. The Hiroshima bomb

8:50

used uranium 235 to fuel its nuclear

8:53

chain reaction. The Nagasaki bomb used

8:56

plutonium 239. Both of these isotopes

8:59

have extremely long half- livives. The

9:02

plutonium half-life is 24,110

9:06

years, while the uranium has a halflife

9:09

of more than 700 million years. While

9:12

these are pretty dizzying numbers, they

9:15

don't tell us that much about how

9:17

dangerous the radiation was. Professor

9:19

Derek Hass explains more. Rate of decay

9:22

is inversely proportional to half-life.

9:25

So something with a long half-life is

9:28

not very radioactive.

9:30

The most dangerous isotope left over

9:32

from the bombs would have been iodine

9:35

131, but this has a very short halflife.

9:38

Professor H continues, "Within 1 day,

9:41

the radioactivity would have decayed by

9:43

a factor of 100,000. After 10 days, by a

9:46

factor of 1 million. After 10 years,

9:48

it's gone down by a factor of a

9:50

billion." So, in the days and weeks

9:52

following the blasts, wandering into the

9:55

disaster area wouldn't have been the

9:57

death sentence. We might assume residual

9:59

radiation actually wasn't a huge danger.

10:03

Far more dangerous was the wreckage and

10:05

rubble left behind by the explosion. As

10:08

Colonel Stafford Warren said, tens of

10:10

thousands of bodies were trapped within

10:12

destroyed buildings, and digging these

10:14

bodies out was a hazardous task. Rather

10:17

than risk Japanese lives with the job,

10:20

the authorities relied on forced

10:22

laborers from Korea. Shim Jinta was only

10:25

3 years old when the bomb fell on

10:27

Hiroshima, but his parents were both

10:29

Korean forced laborers and were

10:31

secondclass citizens in Japanese

10:33

society. Shim had this to say in a 2025

10:37

interview with the BBC. Korean workers

10:39

had to clean up the dead. At first, they

10:42

used stretchers, but there were too many

10:44

bodies. Eventually, they used dust pans

10:48

to gather corpses. Many forced laborers

10:51

died on these missions, which

10:53

contributed to the disproportionately

10:56

high death toll among Koreans in

10:58

Hiroshima and Nagasaki. is believed that

11:01

57% of the Koreans in Hiroshima died in

11:05

the bombing and its aftermath. By

11:07

comparison, the overall death toll in

11:09

both cities is thought to be just under

11:11

40%. But despite these hazardous

11:14

conditions, many bodies were recovered

11:17

and removed from the desolated cities.

11:20

So what actually happened to those

11:22

bodies? For the citizens left behind in

11:25

Nagasaki Androshima, they now wished to

11:27

process their grief and say full-on

11:29

goodbyes to loved ones taken too soon.

11:32

This meant holding funeral rights. In

11:35

Japan, theerary process begins very

11:37

quickly after death. Awake or a suya is

11:41

the first step in which friends and

11:43

family members offer their condolences

11:45

and honor the dead with prayers and

11:46

observances. Close family members may

11:49

remain with the dead body all night,

11:52

offering a final vigil as the deceased

11:54

makes their journey beyond the realm of

11:56

the living. Typically, the funeral

11:58

itself begins the day after the wake.

12:01

The deceased is given a new Buddhist

12:03

name which will prevent the dead

12:04

returning to the living world if their

12:05

old name is called. Flowers may be

12:08

placed around the head of the deceased

12:09

and then the casket is closed. The body

12:12

is then cremated. After cremation,

12:15

relatives use large pairs of chopsticks

12:17

to remove charred bone fragments from

12:19

the ash and transfer them to a

12:21

ceremonial urn. The process is bound up

12:24

with ritual and is conducted with great

12:26

care as friends and relatives give the

12:29

deceased the appropriate sendoff.

12:31

Colonel Warren's report tells us that

12:34

cremations were certainly taking place

12:36

in Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the

12:37

aftermath of the bombings, but as the

12:40

funeral process was so long and

12:41

meticulous, it was often impossible to

12:44

conduct properly. Yoshino Yamawaki was

12:47

11 in 1945 and remembered how he and his

12:50

brothers cremated his father's body.

12:53

Yamawaki's account is long and detailed,

12:56

but we've included a large portion of it

12:58

here because it gives a harrowing

13:00

depiction of what many residents would

13:02

have experienced in the aftermath of the

13:04

bombings. My brothers and I gently laid

13:07

his blackened, swollen body at top a

13:09

burnt beam in front of the factory where

13:11

we found him dead and set him a light,

13:14

his ankles juttered awkwardly as the

13:16

rest of his body was engulfed in flames.

13:19

When we returned the next morning to

13:21

collect his ashes, we discovered that

13:23

his body had been partially cremated.

13:25

Only his wrists, ankles, and part of his

13:28

gut were burnt properly. The rest of his

13:31

body lay raw and decomposed. Finally, my

13:35

oldest brother suggested that we take a

13:37

piece of his skull based on a common

13:39

practice in Japanese funerals in which

13:42

family members pass around a tiny piece

13:44

of the skull with chopsticks after

13:45

cremation. As soon as our chopsticks

13:49

touched the surface, however, the skull

13:51

cracked open like plaster and his halfc

13:54

cremated brains spilled out. My brothers

13:57

and I screamed and ran away, leaving our

14:00

father behind. We abandoned him in the

14:04

worst state possible. Yawaki's story is

14:08

horrific, but he was at least able to

14:10

find his father's body. Many other

14:13

bodies went unidentified and unclaimed.

14:16

Ko Agura remembered how bodies were

14:19

strewn around her neighborhood with no

14:21

one to name them or to tend to them. She

14:24

recalled rivers and channels packed

14:26

tightly with bodies, some without limbs

14:28

and all in extreme states of

14:30

decomposition.

14:32

8-year-old Kahuko was tasked with

14:35

helping carry bodies to mass cremation

14:37

sites. She said, "Even children like me

14:41

had to help carry bodies on straw mats."

14:45

Koko believed that her father cremated

14:48

700 people on the street in front of

14:50

their home. There would have been little

14:52

time for traditional rights or

14:54

observances. On the island of Ninoima,

14:58

Nihi Hiroshima, tens of thousands of

15:00

wounded were taken as doctors fought to

15:03

save their lives. Thousands of them

15:06

died. In the words of journalist Robert

15:08

Rand, their identities were lost in the

15:11

mayhem of emergency cremations and

15:13

burials. Noshima harbors the unmarked

15:16

graves of thousands of unidentified

15:18

bodies. University researcher Rebono

15:22

still returns to Noshima each year to

15:24

search for these graves. He believes

15:26

that locating remains and giving them a

15:29

proper funeral can help to bring peace

15:31

to the few survivors who remain. Ko says

15:34

until that happens, the war is not over

15:38

for these people. Now, cremating the

15:41

bodies was certainly an important task.

15:44

But for the victims who survived the

15:46

bombs, there was something else that was

15:48

even more important. Getting effective

15:51

treatment for the grim symptoms of a

15:53

nuclear attack. The people of Hiroshima

15:56

and Nagasaki had been exposed to a new

15:58

and terrible weapon, and no one was

16:01

quite sure of its true power. Across

16:03

both cities, people who'd survived the

16:05

force of the blasts started to succumb

16:08

to mysterious illnesses. Their bodies

16:11

seemed to be quite literally failing.

16:14

But I said Suttobinaga was 18 at the

16:17

time and had been living around 1

16:19

kilometer from the main strike of the

16:20

bomb that hit Nagasaki. He was severely

16:23

burned but made it to hospital. Here,

16:25

however, his fellow victims died one

16:28

after another, day after day. But I said

16:31

remembered the blood in my urine dyed

16:34

the white toilet bowl red. I'm the next

16:37

one. I thought I stared at the blood

16:40

with despair.

16:42

Over in Hiroshima, Kaiser Sawada was 9

16:45

years old and living 1.8 km from the

16:48

center of the blast. Kaiser recalled how

16:51

her three-year-old sister struggled to

16:53

survive. My sister's hair came out by

16:56

pulling lightly, and her cheek had a

16:58

hole large enough to expose her tongue,

17:01

which was split in half. A month later,

17:04

Kaiso's sister and her aunt, were both

17:06

dead. Over the next years, most of

17:09

Kaiso's family, including her younger

17:11

brother, would die of cancer, a brutal

17:13

remnant of the bomb's destructive power.

17:17

It was in everyone's interest to find

17:20

out what was going on and to understand

17:23

the true impact of the radiation.

17:25

Japanese doctors and scientists needed

17:27

to ascertain how they would treat the

17:29

survivors and prevent a longlasting

17:32

health catastrophe. American military

17:34

scientists wanted to know exactly what

17:37

their new weapon was capable of.

17:39

Radiation poisoning was not entirely

17:41

unheard of in the 1940s. As early as the

17:44

1920s, women working with radiumbased

17:46

paint at instrument factories in the

17:48

United States had begun to exhibit

17:50

disturbing symptoms. Workers had got

17:53

into the habit of licking their brushes

17:54

before painting the radium onto dials

17:56

and watch faces, which led to a buildup

17:59

of radium in the bones of the jaw. Many

18:01

suffered damage to their jaws through

18:03

radiation poisoning as the bones

18:05

fractured and degrading. At least 50

18:08

women died as a result. A decade later

18:10

in 1934, the pioneering scientist Mary

18:13

Cury died of a plastic anemia. Her death

18:16

was not fully understood at the time,

18:17

but was found to be the result of

18:19

long-term radiation poisoning. Mary

18:22

Cury's papers are still highly

18:23

radioactive and are too dangerous to be

18:25

handled without protective clothing and

18:27

equipment. However, even though

18:30

radiation poisoning had occurred before,

18:32

the events at Hiroshima and Nagasaki

18:34

were unprecedented. so unprecedented

18:37

that a new word was created to describe

18:39

the patients. They were the hibakusha or

18:42

the bombaffected people. To figure out

18:45

what was going on, doctors and coroners

18:47

conducted autopsies on many of the

18:49

bodies exhibiting the most extreme cases

18:51

of radiation damage. One of these bodies

18:53

was that of the 36-year-old stage

18:56

actress Midori Naka. Naka actually

18:59

survived the initial blast and was

19:01

pulled from the ruins of a destroyed

19:02

building. But her injuries were severe.

19:05

Open sores blooded her body and doctors

19:07

found themselves unable to battle her

19:09

baffling symptoms. The radiation

19:12

destroyed her white blood cells which

19:14

left her body with no way to stave off

19:16

infection. She died on August 24th and

19:19

became the first victim of the bombings

19:21

to have radiation poisoning officially

19:24

listed as her cause of death. Naka's

19:27

life was over, but her story was not.

19:30

Her body was simply too valuable to

19:32

medical science. As grim as it sounds,

19:35

knowledge gained from studying Naka's

19:37

remains may have helped many people to

19:39

get the treatment they needed to stay

19:41

alive. But Japanese doctors still had a

19:44

fight on their hands to gain the insight

19:45

they needed. Despite entering into a

19:48

partnership with Japan in the years

19:49

after the war, the Americans were not

19:51

too keen to share the results of their

19:53

own research. President Truman's Atomic

19:56

Bomb Casualty Commission or ABCC was

19:59

more concerned with safeguarding

20:00

valuable data on their new weapon rather

20:02

than actually treating its victims. As

20:04

author Susan South had said, even

20:06

Nagasaki and Hiroshima doctors treating

20:09

Hibakusha on a daily basis had no access

20:12

to these critical findings that could

20:14

have supported their diagnosis and care.

20:17

Nishimi, a physician working in

20:19

Nagasaki, expressed his anger against

20:21

the American policy. The ABCC's way of

20:24

doing research seemed to us full of

20:26

secrets. We Japanese doctors thought it

20:29

went against common sense. A doctor who

20:32

finds something new while conducting

20:33

research is obligated to make it public

20:36

for the benefit of all human beings.

20:40

Many of the tissue samples collected by

20:42

the ABCC, including hearts, lungs, and

20:44

brains of victims, remained in storage

20:46

in the USA for decades after the end of

20:49

the war. It wasn't until May of 1973

20:52

that the Americans began repatriating

20:54

these materials. By this time, many of

20:57

the samples had been mislabeled,

20:58

misidentified, or simply lost. The

21:02

atomic bombings of 1945 are still etched

21:04

into the identity of Hiroshima and

21:06

Nagasaki. Journalist Justin McCur

21:09

described how even as late as 2016, the

21:12

bomb's hyperenter was still used as a

21:14

point of reference in Hiroshima. A

21:17

particular street is about 1.5 km away,

21:20

a building 500 m north. No further

21:23

explanation is required.

21:26

But despite the looming shadow of

21:27

nuclear destruction, both cities have

21:30

recovered. By the early 1950s, their

21:32

populations had returned to pre-war

21:34

levels, and both cities have become

21:36

cultural and economic hubs in the New

21:38

Japan. In both Hiroshima and Nagasaki,

21:40

there are somber memorials to the

21:42

destruction that was wrought here in

21:44

August 1945.

21:46

But perhaps the most important memorial

21:49

is the more subtle, the continued

21:51

existence of the cities themselves. For

21:55

a while in 1945, it looked like both

21:57

cities had been wiped off the map, but

22:00

they have both since recovered. This

22:03

recovery was always going to be a long

22:05

and painful road. But it would not have

22:08

been possible at all without that first

22:10

step. And this step was of course the

22:13

process of bearing away the bodies of

22:15

those who died. The first victims of a

22:18

new and terrible weapon.

Interactive Summary

On August 6th and 9th, 1945, atomic bombs devastated Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing over 100,000 immediately and tens of thousands more, marking the world's introduction to nuclear weapons. The immediate aftermath involved the grim task of handling an unknown number of bodies, which decomposed rapidly in the August heat and humidity. Contrary to common belief, residual radiation was not a primary obstacle to cleanup, as most radiation went into the atmosphere. Korean forced laborers undertook the hazardous recovery of bodies from the wreckage, suffering disproportionately high casualties. Traditional Japanese funeral rites were largely impossible, leading to emergency cremations and mass burials, often with unidentified remains. Survivors faced mysterious illnesses, later termed "hibakusha," due to radiation poisoning. While Japanese doctors sought understanding, American authorities prioritized safeguarding data over sharing critical research findings for treatment. Despite this, both cities remarkably recovered, becoming thriving hubs by the 1950s, with their continued existence serving as the most significant memorial to the atomic bombings.

Suggested questions

11 ready-made prompts