US Military Installation in Strait of Hormuz a 'Very, Very Hard Sell,' Says Jen Gavito
89 segments
Jen, it's great to see you. And I want to go back a couple of weeks
from when you talked to us because you've got a lot of people talking here
in the NEWSROOM, as you described, a millennia old empire.
Right. And the prospects of toppling the
ayatollah. Every simulation you said the military
has done is that if you took out the ayatollah, you empower the IRGC.
I know that you're a sage gen, but I could also ask you if we've simply
forgotten some of the lessons of the past.
First of all, Jerry, thanks for having me back.
It's great to see you. You know, this is a circumstance in
which I wish I had not been right. But I do think that that is, in fact,
what we are. What we are seeing a lot of attention
is, of course, being paid to the lines of succession, particularly as various
regime figures are killed in U.S. and Israeli strikes.
But particularly with the with the naming of Mossad, I
mean, excuse me. And, you know, whether whatever state he
may be in, all reports are that that this was an installation more or less by
the IRGC. So I do think we're seeing that
consolidation of power. What do you think of the talk of troops
on Kharg Island? Occupy that position and use it as
leverage to reopen the strait? Is this something that could work?
I mean, certainly not on its own. I as Secretary Panetta said, I think
that, you know, you would have to secure parts of of the Iranian border itself in
order along the along the Gulf, in order to air along the strait, in order to
really secure a passage. I would note that the reason one of the
many reasons that this has not been undertaken in the past, despite decades
of, I think, U.S. administrations, Israeli governments
wanting to dislodge this, this regime is precisely for this reason, because the
ability of Iran to to disrupt the strait has been well known and always seen as,
you know, no pun intended, but the nuclear option.
And that does seem to be where we are at now.
And getting it back open is proving, I think, to be every bit as difficult as
everyone feared. Boy, so the secretary also talked about
what would be required to keep the strait open, the number of troops
involved, and we've already started to pulverize.
There are military capability in that area.
General Dan Cain said A-10 Warthogs are at it.
We've got Apache helicopters at it. If this continued for some more time,
another month even. Would that be an easier exercise or is
it simply just not acceptable to be wrong once if
you have an errant attack coming off a speedboat that hits a cargo vessel, then
all of this is for not exactly you know, it's not just about air or land
superiority. It's it's the fact that it doesn't take
a lot for for Iran to continue to disrupt, whether it's drones, whether
it's mines, you know, exactly as you say, whether it's a speedboat passing
by. And so now that this has been unleashed
and convincing, you know, and it's not about going on TV and telling people
that it is now safe for transit, but it's about insurance companies and
transit lines having that confidence. And so restoring the confidence that
Iran will not utilize those tactics in the future, I think is going to be a
very, very hard sell regardless of what we do militarily.
And the other thing I would note to that is, you know, I think there's no doubt
that there have been significant tactical successes through this.
And yet we still keep we still keep attacking.
Right. Which says that despite the president's
assertions, we have not, in fact, taken out all of their capabilities.
And so those can continue over time to be rebuilt, reasserted.
And so, you know, it really muddies the water as far as what an off ramp to this
could could in reality look like. When you were acting principal deputy
assistant secretary of state for Near Eastern affairs, what would your thought
have been right now on a potential regional conflict?
How close are Iran's neighbors to engaging?
So I think we are continuing to see them do everything in their power.
I mean, they take hit after hit and are clearly resisting
what is a very understandable instinct to hit back out of concerns that the
damage that we've seen so far just expands if they engage in this conflict
in an offensive way. That being said, you know, as as you've
alluded to, the the economic and global economic damage globally, but certainly
to to the Gulf states and their long term economic visions cannot be
overstated. It is it is catastrophic.
And so I am watching that carefully. How how long can they endure this
without feeling like they need to take a more direct role in it?
No, that would be a big deal. And I can only imagine the market
reaction. What's $200 billion tell you?
Jen, before you leave us today, that's the figure we're expecting for a
supplemental budget request and people are trying to read into that.
Does that mean restocking all of the supplies we gave to Ukraine, or is this
implying some sort of anticipation of a longer conflict?
What do you buy with 200 billion? You buy a lot with $200.
And there's no question that our stockpiles do need to be replenished.
And so from that angle, I think that those numbers are not as stunning as one
might think. But it also does suggest that this
conflict, you know, which initially was described as very short, we're now
several weeks and I don't see a resolution to this in the next two or
three, two or three weeks at least. And, you know, if you do insert boots on
the ground, rather, whether on Kharg Island or on the coast of Iran itself,
and that that complicates certainly what the outlook is for then pulling them
back and for this conflict really coming to resolution.
So I think the 200 billion number is is is concerning.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The discussion centers on the geopolitical situation in Iran, particularly concerning the Strait of Hormuz and the potential for conflict. It's noted that while military actions have had tactical successes, Iran's ability to disrupt shipping through various means (drones, mines, speedboats) remains a significant challenge. The economic impact on Gulf states is catastrophic, leading to concerns about their long-term stability and potential involvement. The conversation also touches upon the substantial supplemental budget request, its implications for replenishing supplies and the potential for a protracted conflict, and the complexities of deploying troops.
Videos recently processed by our community