HomeVideos

The Angel Too Evil for Heaven

Now Playing

The Angel Too Evil for Heaven

Transcript

483 segments

0:00

He was appointed tusked with accusation,

0:03

death, and judgment already decided. He

0:05

carried out his work with full authority

0:07

and complete loyalty. Every charge he

0:09

delivered was sanctioned. He became the

0:12

one who spoke what heaven wouldn't say

0:14

aloud. He took on the work that kept

0:16

holiness clean by pushing its weight to

0:18

elsewhere. Over time, that burden marked

0:22

him. His service placed him too close to

0:24

suffering, too close to judgment, and

0:26

too close to what heaven preferred to

0:28

keep unseen. Eventually,

0:31

he stood apart, no longer welcome among

0:33

those untouched by his work.

0:50

Samuel appears gradually on the edges of

0:53

Jewish writing in the places where

0:54

questions about judgment, suffering, and

0:56

responsibility start to pile up.

0:59

He surfaces later in Jewish writings,

1:02

especially in rabbitic discussions and

1:03

mystical texts that try to explain how

1:05

divine judgment actually works behind

1:07

the scenes. These texts are wrestling

1:09

with uncomfortable problems and sail

1:12

appears where those problems refuse to

1:14

go away.

1:15

From the beginning, his name carries

1:17

heaviness. Samuel is commonly translated

1:20

as poison of God or severity of God.

1:24

Both readings point to the same idea.

1:26

He's linked to harm that is allowed,

1:28

even required. Harm that serves a

1:32

purpose.

1:33

Early descriptions place him among

1:35

angels operating with authority. When he

1:38

actually does so because he's been given

1:40

permission. There's no suggestion that

1:42

he sneaks into his role or takes it upon

1:45

himself. He is sent. What stands out

1:48

immediately is that Sail is never

1:51

gentle. While other angels protect and

1:54

heal or guide, Somay confronts.

1:57

His presence signals that something has

1:59

already gone wrong and that consequences

2:01

are now unavoidable.

2:03

In these early writings, he's often

2:05

positioned opposite humanity,

2:06

challenging people rather than helping

2:08

them. He presses weaknesses instead of

2:11

covering them. He brings attention to

2:13

failure where others would prefer to

2:15

look away.

2:17

It makes him useful.

2:19

As Jewish thought develops, angels begin

2:21

to take on clearer roles. Some are

2:24

associated with mercy, some with

2:26

protection, and some with healing or

2:28

guidance.

2:29

Samiel's role sharpens. He becomes more

2:32

closely associated with accusation and

2:34

harm and eventually death.

2:38

Writers become more honest about what

2:40

his role implies. Crucially, there isn't

2:43

an early version of Sam that later

2:45

becomes corrupted. He appears already

2:47

burdened from the moment his name is

2:48

used. He's tied to severity.

2:52

This makes him difficult to place. He

2:54

belongs among the angels, but his work

2:56

makes people uncomfortable with that

2:58

fact. From his earliest appearances, Sam

3:01

forces writers to confront how judgment

3:03

is carried out, who bears the name for

3:06

suffering, and whether divine authority

3:08

can remain untouched when its agents

3:10

aren't.

3:12

That tension is there from the start.

3:15

Everything that follows grows out of

3:17

this unease.

3:23

There's no room for error. Every action

3:25

is recorded and every consequence is

3:28

earned. That level of accountability is

3:31

what separates a lucky guess from a

3:33

professional strategy.

3:35

If you're looking to bring that kind of

3:37

discipline to your own execution, you

3:40

need the right environment to do it.

3:42

That's why I've partnered with Playbit

3:44

for today's video. Playbit is a leading

3:46

trading community with over 1,000

3:48

members run by professional traders.

3:50

Inside you'll find in-depth education

3:52

that actually explains how the markets

3:54

move, structure, price delivery,

3:56

liquidity, execution. They cover the

3:59

fundamentals, advanced strategy, risk

4:01

management, and prop firm readiness. All

4:04

the tools needed to build wealth. Monday

4:07

to Friday, there's live trading. Real

4:09

traders, real results, wins and losses,

4:11

full transparency. You watch the

4:13

sessions live. Ask questions, see setups

4:16

forming, understand the logic, and if

4:19

you want, follow along, earn while you

4:22

learn. You may assume you need thousands

4:24

to get started. That's where the prop

4:26

firms come in. They let you trade with

4:29

their capital rather than your own in

4:31

exchange for a share of the profit. But

4:34

passing their evaluations takes

4:35

discipline and precision. With Playbit's

4:38

help, you can get funded and start

4:40

trading serious capital while keeping

4:42

your own money safe. They break down the

4:44

rules, show you how to avoid common

4:46

traps, and teach you how to trade the

4:48

way prop firms actually want to see.

4:51

Still not convinced? Go check out the

4:54

walls of gains. A live feed of member

4:57

results. funded passes, withdrawals,

5:00

consistent trades, daily results from

5:02

members like this, this, this, and this.

5:07

This isn't a get-rich quick scheme. It

5:09

takes time and real commitment. But this

5:11

could be a start to financial freedom.

5:14

You can try Playbit completely free for

5:16

7 days. No commitment, no excuses, just

5:18

you, the charts, and a community built

5:20

to win. Nothing to lose and everything

5:23

to gain. Click the link in the

5:26

description.

5:29

In Jewish tradition, judgment begins

5:31

with a charge. Before anything can be

5:33

taken or broken, a voice must speak. And

5:36

that voice belongs to Samo. When he

5:39

speaks, a process begins that cannot be

5:41

reversed. The book of Job offers one of

5:43

the clearest examples of this. The scene

5:46

unfolds in heaven among the Benha

5:48

Elohim, the sons of God. Among them is

5:52

ha Satan, the accuser, a title, not an

5:55

identity. God points to Job and declares

5:58

him blameless. But the accuser asks a

6:00

single question.

6:03

Does Job fear God for nothing?

6:06

That question changes everything. It

6:08

challenges the legitimacy of divine

6:10

favor. Because of that question, a test

6:13

is authorized. Job's protection is

6:15

withdrawn. His wealth collapses. His

6:17

children are killed and his health

6:19

fails. His friends turn on him because a

6:21

single voice removed the comfort of

6:23

assumption.

6:25

Once the charge was spoken, the silence

6:27

broke and the sentence had somewhere to

6:29

go. That is what Samuel does. He brings

6:33

forward the claim that changes the

6:35

atmosphere. The moment he speaks,

6:37

innocence is no longer assumes. Guilt

6:40

becomes traceable. The room becomes a

6:43

courtroom

6:45

and everything soft begins to harden.

6:50

He is feared because he removes

6:51

ambiguity. In religious life, ambiguity

6:53

is comfort. As long as fault remains

6:56

unnamed, it can be softened or excused.

6:58

But once the charge is spoken, once it

7:00

is clear and exact, that comfort

7:02

disappears.

7:04

In later mysticism, Sam becomes

7:06

associated with the sitra Ara, the other

7:09

side, the realm of harsh severity. But

7:12

even there he remains within the

7:13

structure. He evaluates. When the mass

7:16

becomes too much to bear in silence, he

7:19

names it. It is accuracy that makes him

7:22

terrifying. His speech is cold,

7:25

measured, and correct. He doesn't

7:27

embellish or exaggerate. He doesn't need

7:28

to. His authority lies in truth stated

7:31

clearly.

7:33

In some traditions, Sail appears at the

7:35

moment of death as the one who reads the

7:37

record. He's the voice that speaks when

7:39

nothing else can be said. Whether he

7:41

whispers or declares it loudly, the

7:43

charge lands with finality. In every

7:46

life, there are things we hope remain

7:47

hidden, even from heaven.

7:49

Summer El is the one who finds them and

7:51

brings them to the surface. This is what

7:54

he was appointed to do. Verdicts begin

7:57

with clarity and he is the one who

7:59

carries it.

8:01

Some's presence is often felt in his

8:03

stillness. He possesses a way of simply

8:06

remaining in place, quiet, watchful and

8:08

entirely unmoving. You realize very

8:11

quickly that everything stops where he

8:13

begins. This is the side of him that

8:14

defines the boundary. His shadow becomes

8:17

the gap between where you are and where

8:19

you want to be. And that no, the sheer

8:23

immovable reality of his position is

8:26

what we eventually fear as force against

8:28

us. In the old stories, angels are given

8:32

specific parts of the world to look

8:33

after. Some bring life or offer a hand.

8:37

Sil is different. He's placed exactly

8:40

where mercy reaches its limit.

8:42

There's a famous story about Abraham on

8:44

his way to sacrifice his son. It's a

8:46

heavy silent journey and some shows up,

8:49

but he remains apart from the argument.

8:51

Instead, he becomes a deep rushing river

8:54

right in the middle of the path. He

8:56

challenges the man to keep walking. He's

8:58

there to see exactly what the mission is

9:00

worth to the one carrying it out.

9:02

Abraham pushes through, but the pattern

9:05

is set. When your heart is being tested,

9:08

Samuel is the one you must face. When

9:10

someone stands in your way with that

9:12

much conviction, you eventually stop

9:15

seeing the command and start seeing an

9:17

enemy. It feels personal. The world

9:19

feels small because he is the only thing

9:21

in the room that won't budge. The truth

9:24

is that he is acting out of pure

9:25

loyalty. He's the only one who's

9:28

actually honoring the original world,

9:30

doing exactly what he was told to do.

9:33

The pain we feel is simply what happens

9:34

when a limit is reached.

9:37

He ensures the end of the line remains

9:40

the end. But because he is so steady and

9:43

because he never blinks, he becomes the

9:46

image of suffering.

9:48

Eventually, we stop seeing a servant and

9:50

start seeing a monster, we believe that

9:51

he's the reason the path is blocked,

9:53

even though he was only ever told to

9:55

watch the door.

9:57

And he does.

10:00

Some avoids the flashy destruction. He

10:02

leaves the fire and the crumbling walls

10:04

to others. His role is much quieter,

10:06

much heavier. In the later stories, his

10:09

name begins to surface right at the edge

10:10

of ruin. He is there moments before

10:13

kingdoms fracture, before cities fall,

10:15

and before the protection people counted

10:17

on suddenly vanishes. At first, it looks

10:20

like a coincidence. Then it feels like a

10:23

warning. Eventually, it becomes a

10:25

certainty.

10:27

You realize that he can bring about a

10:29

ruin without ever raising a hand. And

10:31

once he does, the very idea of recovery

10:34

starts to feel impossible. In deeper

10:36

mystical writings, he is the last figure

10:38

ever to be seen before a life or

10:40

structure gives way. When he enters a

10:43

picture, the script is nearly finished.

10:45

The sentence has already been written.

10:48

He's simply the one who reads the final

10:50

word aloud.

10:52

There is an old pattern in these texts

10:53

where some appears during the most

10:55

decisive turns in history. moments when

10:58

people are teetering between a second

10:59

chance and total collapse. You can see

11:02

this in the story of Exodus during the

11:04

final plague. The ancient texts speak of

11:06

a destroyer sent to carry out the last

11:08

judgment. The blood on the doorpost was

11:11

a boundary line, a warning to that

11:12

specific shadow. Do not enter here.

11:16

While the tower leaves this figure

11:18

unnamed, many later traditions identify

11:21

this destroyer as Samile.

11:23

They see him as the one who must be held

11:26

back because his entry means the line

11:28

has already been crossed. That image of

11:31

a figure so heavy it must be restrained

11:33

is what defines him. He appears when

11:36

judgment is no longer a threat but a

11:39

reality.

11:41

He arrives at the exact moment when it's

11:43

too late for change. In the zohora some

11:46

belongs to the left hand side of the

11:48

divine, the side of severity and hard

11:51

truths. When that side outweighs mercy,

11:55

collapse follows. He doesn't need to

11:57

push the scale. He simply appears when

11:59

it's already tipped. This is the

12:02

recurring theme. The soul at the final

12:05

breath, the kingdom at the brink of

12:06

ruin. The person who has crossed one

12:09

threshold too many.

12:11

He arrives to witness the turning point.

12:14

And that is what makes his arrival so

12:16

haunting.

12:18

It's the timing. His name works like a

12:22

siren. It's quiet, but it's final. It

12:25

says the test is over. The window has

12:29

collapsed. What follows is now

12:31

consequence. Even those who believe in

12:34

miracles know that there is a moment

12:35

when the line is no longer theoretical.

12:38

Samuel is the one who marks it. He can

12:41

leave the weapons behind.

12:44

Sile possesses a perfect kind of

12:45

loyalty. He was given the hardest

12:47

assignments and fulfilled them with

12:49

absolute precision. Every charge he

12:51

spoke, every gate he guarded, it was all

12:53

done under authority. Yet he remains on

12:55

the outside, existing in a state of

12:58

being unwelcome.

13:00

This is because obedience when taken to

13:02

its furthest edge becomes something no

13:03

one wants to look at. In the stories of

13:06

the heavenly, there are those who return

13:08

and are restored to honor. But Samile

13:10

remains where the work ended. Over time,

13:13

the figure who once stood in the light

13:15

of holiness begins to be seen

13:17

differently. He becomes a shadow that

13:20

carries the scent of the end. There is a

13:23

difference between those who speak of

13:24

hard truth and those who have to enforce

13:26

it. Some made the consequences real. He

13:31

followed every warning through to its

13:32

conclusion. While others moved freely

13:35

through the heights, he found the doors

13:37

slowly closing behind him. He became

13:39

avoided.

13:41

That is the burden of service when the

13:43

command is clean but the work is heavy.

13:46

His proximity to suffering began to

13:48

define him. He was the one who stayed in

13:51

the room after every plea had failed,

13:53

every defense had crumbled.

13:56

That kind of presence becomes too much

13:58

for those who want the sentence executed

14:01

but don't want to remember the cost.

14:04

In the deeper mystical text, he begins

14:06

to absorb blame for the very things he

14:08

was told to do. His name starts to blow

14:10

with the idea of the enemy. The memory

14:12

of his work done on behalf of a power

14:14

that remains distant clings to him like

14:16

a shadow. He is still faithful, but that

14:19

faithful now makes him dangerous to be

14:22

around. His existence is a paradox. To

14:24

be the one who enforces the end means

14:26

living in the wreckage of what fell.

14:29

Others serve once and return to grace.

14:31

Samale serves continually without

14:34

relief. He is the reminder that judgment

14:37

has a price. He is the one who occupies

14:38

the space where mercy is not extended.

14:41

And once you have stood in that place

14:43

long enough, it begins to shape how you

14:45

are seen. Others can feel it. His

14:48

arrival is no longer tolerable to them.

14:51

Eventually, Samuel becomes the one who

14:53

isn't invited back. Those he served no

14:56

longer want to see what their own orders

14:58

look like once they are fully obeyed.

15:00

His exile is the result of a service

15:02

rendered too completely. He is the

15:05

figure who did everything asked of him

15:08

and was left outside the gate. He

15:11

remains unclaimed.

15:14

He never changed sides. But over time,

15:16

people stopped believing that could be

15:18

true.

15:19

The further history moved from judgment,

15:21

the more unbearable Samuel became. He

15:24

carried out what others commanded, and

15:26

that only made him more dangerous in

15:27

their eyes. The fact that he followed

15:29

orders without rebellion, that he

15:31

enforced suffering without protest,

15:33

meant there was no rebellion to punish

15:35

and no crime to explain him. That made

15:38

him harder to contain.

15:40

Writers then tried to contain him

15:42

another way. They began to move him

15:44

first away from the heights, then toward

15:46

the shadows. His proximity to heaven

15:48

became too uncomfortable. So the story

15:51

shifted. He was paired with Lilith, the

15:54

first wife of Adam, cast as a seducer,

15:57

corruptor, and figure of poison and

15:59

temptation.

16:00

Where once he was an enforcer of

16:02

holiness, now he was made into the

16:05

author of sin. The work he did was

16:07

reinterpreted as motive. This was a

16:10

psychological recoil, a way of coping

16:12

with the memory of a servant who

16:13

followed command so completely that the

16:15

results became indistinguishable from

16:18

cruelty.

16:20

Judgment could remain necessary, but the

16:22

one who carried it out had to be thrown

16:25

into the pit.

16:27

That's how demonization works. The label

16:30

becomes a mask that keeps the real story

16:32

out of view. In later cabalistic text,

16:35

Summer is repositioned again. He's no

16:38

longer just heaven's servant. He's now

16:40

the prince of demons, the consort of

16:42

Lilith, the arch adversary aligned with

16:45

the other side. His story is dismantled

16:48

piece by piece. The records of his

16:50

authority are blurred, and the weight of

16:52

what he did is turned into a personal

16:54

hunger. The horror of what he was asked

16:56

to do is replaced by the comfort of

16:58

imagining he chose it for himself. But

17:01

even in these darker portrayals, traces

17:03

remain. He's still organized, still

17:06

precise, still executing decisions that

17:09

don't begin with him. Even in hell, he

17:12

watches. He waits. He obeys.

17:16

The shape is still there, just buried

17:18

beneath layers of accusation that were

17:20

never part of the original design.

17:23

This is what history does when it

17:24

doesn't know where to place fear. It

17:27

holds it up, reshapes it, and files it

17:29

under evil. Doing this, calling it evil,

17:33

makes it easier to move on. Samiel isn't

17:36

reclassified because he changed. He's

17:39

reclassified because he didn't.

17:44

Samuel stayed in line. He spoke only

17:46

when required doing the same work over

17:48

and over long after everyone stopped

17:50

watching. And that's the horror.

17:54

When you picture a fallen being, you

17:56

expect defiance. You expect a war in

17:58

heaven, a throne overturned. But somehow

18:01

served completely.

18:04

He did the task everyone else avoided.

18:06

The executions, the accusations, the

18:09

moments that closed history rather than

18:11

opened it. And when it was done, there

18:14

was a silence,

18:16

just distance, a quiet, uneasy

18:19

withdrawal from the place that had sent

18:21

him. He's a theological embarrassment.

18:25

When you look too closely at him, you

18:27

start to ask questions about obedience,

18:30

about how far holiness is willing to go,

18:32

about what gets discarded once the

18:34

judgment is carried out.

18:36

Sile's horror is that he stayed true to

18:39

heaven.

18:41

It's that heaven turned from him and

18:44

he's still there, still watching to be

18:47

recalled, still listening for a command.

18:50

His stance is one of continuation.

18:53

He is the angel who followed the letter

18:56

of the command until the command itself

19:00

became unbearable to witness.

19:03

So we flinch. We flinch because he

19:05

didn't break. Because he did everything

19:07

right and was still left outside. Heaven

19:10

has room for martyrs, for prophets, for

19:12

rebels who fall and rise again. But it

19:14

seems the limit is reached with one who

19:16

did the job no one else would and never

19:19

stopped doing it. And that's where he

19:21

stays, apart from redemption,

19:25

just waiting,

19:27

forever obedient,

19:29

forever outside.

Interactive Summary

The video explores the figure of Samuel (or Samael) in Jewish tradition, portraying him not as a conventional evil entity, but as a loyal, obedient servant tasked with carrying out divine judgment, accusation, and harm. From his earliest appearances, Samuel is associated with severity and is described as performing essential, yet uncomfortable, duties that confront weakness and remove ambiguity. Over time, as his proximity to suffering and his unwavering obedience made humanity and even heaven uneasy, his role was reinterpreted. He was gradually pushed to the theological periphery, eventually becoming demonized and seen as the author of sin or the prince of demons, despite never rebelling or changing sides. His story highlights the burden of enforcing difficult truths and the psychological recoil that leads to the reclassification of figures who unflinchingly fulfill uncomfortable commands. Ultimately, Samuel remains a paradox: forever obedient to heaven's original will, yet eternally exiled and misunderstood for the very loyalty that defines him.

Suggested questions

6 ready-made prompts