HomeVideos

There’s Nowhere Near Enough Senior Housing | Josh Pristaw on Demographic-Guaranteed Demand

Now Playing

There’s Nowhere Near Enough Senior Housing | Josh Pristaw on Demographic-Guaranteed Demand

Transcript

1575 segments

0:00

The whole institutional core real estate

0:02

index is $280 billion. So like there's

0:05

3x all of the core real estate owned by

0:07

institutions is under construction or in

0:09

planning in data center. So when we look

0:11

at it I think the absorption of that

0:13

probably takes longer than people think

0:15

it will.

0:15

>> Today's episode is brought to you by the

0:17

Fundrise income fund. You'll hear more

0:19

about the income fund later in the show,

0:21

but for now let's get into today's

0:23

interview. Today we're going to be

0:24

talking all things real estate. I'm

0:26

joined by Josh Prristow, managing

0:28

director and president of Clarion

0:29

Partners, a real estate investment firm

0:32

managing over $70 billion. Josh, welcome

0:34

to Monetary Matters.

0:36

>> Thanks, Jack. Pleasure to be here.

0:37

>> So, Josh, you've got a huge portfolio in

0:40

industrial

0:41

apartments or multifamily, and I know

0:43

you're also investing in senior living.

0:45

So, I want to get into that, but first,

0:49

let's talk about a giant boom in the

0:53

real estate market, which is data

0:54

centers. Many of your competitors are

0:56

plowing billions and billions of dollars

0:58

into data centers. Are you involved and

1:01

why or why not?

1:02

>> We're not directly involved. So, we

1:04

haven't made any investments

1:05

specifically in the construction of data

1:06

centers. Where we are somewhat on the on

1:10

the periphery, but benefiting from that

1:11

boom, I would argue in a lower risk way

1:14

is in our industrial business. As you

1:16

mentioned, uh we're pretty significant

1:18

there. We've got about 42 billion

1:20

dollars of industrial logistics assets

1:23

in the United States. And so we are

1:25

benefiting from the supply chain. So a

1:28

lot of the the subcontractors, the

1:30

people that are storing and

1:31

manufacturing equipment that eventually

1:33

goes into data centers are our tenants.

1:35

And we're seeing pretty significant

1:37

demand in the markets we're in in

1:40

general uh driven by both e-commerce

1:42

sales but but also to a certain extent

1:44

the data center construction boom. But

1:47

to come back to like the specific idea.

1:49

So, I think it helps to take a step back

1:50

and articulate a little bit who is

1:53

Clarion and what do we do? Well, we're

1:55

overwhelmingly a manager of open-end

1:58

evergreen funds that are either core or

2:00

core plus in risk profile. And so, what

2:03

do people look for in that type of uh

2:05

vehicle? They look for income. They look

2:08

for sort of durability, diversification,

2:11

and low volatility. Um, and when we

2:13

think about how we deliver that, we

2:16

struggle a little bit with the data

2:17

center opportunity. So you know our uh

2:20

when you look at the core uh real estate

2:23

world uh the Odyssey index which is the

2:26

institutional sort of benchmark is about

2:28

280 billion total. Um we happen to have

2:30

the fourth largest fund with about $18

2:32

billion and then if you look at the

2:35

whole like non-treated REIT world that's

2:37

another $140 billion. So you add it all

2:39

up you got $400 billion. One of the

2:42

things we struggle with is that the

2:44

sheer size of some of these data center

2:47

investments don't fit particularly well

2:49

in these core open-end funds. So in our

2:52

$18 billion Odyssey fund, we don't have

2:56

any asset that's worth more than $500

2:57

million. Coming back to this idea about

3:00

diversification

3:02

and so fitting a 5102 billion asset in

3:06

one of these funds, we don't think makes

3:08

sense. The other thing I would say that

3:10

we struggle with is when we look at what

3:13

types of assets do we want to be in our

3:16

uh vehicle as well. We want

3:18

diversification. So there's a size

3:19

question. But fundamentally we're

3:21

looking for things where we have

3:23

conviction that in the future it will be

3:25

worth materially more than it is today.

3:27

Uh and when you look at data centers

3:29

there's undeniably there's demand from

3:31

the tenants. There's great tenants. But

3:33

you know what's the value of that

3:34

residual asset 10 or 15 years from now

3:37

when Microsoft Meta or Google chooses to

3:41

leave it? What will they how will the

3:43

technology change? We just struggle to

3:45

see how it fits in a very long-term

3:49

open-end evergreen vehicle. And but most

3:52

of the capital that's been raised and is

3:54

being deployed that you articulated is

3:56

on the development side. It's it's

3:57

people that are looking for, you know, a

3:59

20 plus internal rate of return that's

4:01

all predicated on somebody like a

4:03

Clarion in a core open-end fund buying

4:06

that for more of a a lower stable

4:09

return. And we find there's some

4:11

challenges in fitting it in in our

4:13

vehicles today.

4:14

>> Several of your investments are are

4:15

indirect beneficiaries from the data

4:17

center boom because they're logistical,

4:19

but you currently don't have any direct

4:22

investments in data centers. And Josh, I

4:24

think what you're saying is that even

4:26

though you're you're one of the largest

4:27

real estate investors, that the check

4:30

size is just too high and for you to

4:33

remain diversified. So that that is

4:36

really striking to me. It just shows

4:38

just how large the capital demands are

4:40

and kind of just how how how kind of

4:43

crazy it is.

4:45

>> Yeah. to to build on that

4:47

the if you look at according to Jones

4:50

Lang Lasowl the the total sort of North

4:53

American data center construction phase

4:57

right now that's underway is about a

4:58

trillion dollars um that largely

5:01

excludes what the the tenants are going

5:03

to the hyperscalers invest in that space

5:05

so it's a pretty significant investment

5:07

as I mentioned the whole institutional

5:09

core real estate index is

5:12

$280 billion so like there's 3x all of

5:15

the core real estate owned by

5:16

institutions is under construction or in

5:18

planning in data centers. So when we

5:20

look at it, I think the absorption of

5:22

that of all that development probably

5:24

takes longer than people think it will

5:27

and it's going to require public

5:29

markets, private infrastructure funds,

5:32

some real estate funds, although if you

5:33

look at the institutional core real

5:35

estate funds, they don't really have

5:36

much exposure to data centers for the

5:38

reasons I I described.

5:40

>> Tell us about you said it's going to

5:42

take longer than people expected. you

5:43

you we we are seeing headlines of data

5:46

centers are being delayed. Tell us just

5:49

how significant that is.

5:50

>> Yeah, so I was alluding to something

5:52

slightly different, but I think the but

5:53

what you're talking about is, you know,

5:56

I'll go back to the demand for the

5:58

computing power, the t the sort of the

5:59

tenant need and ultimately the consumer

6:01

need is self-evident, right? Like more

6:03

and more people are adopting these AI

6:06

tools. It's creating demand for more

6:07

data center space. But like building and

6:10

delivering these things is essentially

6:12

like you know that is that is not a

6:14

futuristic expert like exercise that

6:17

requires municipalities approving it. It

6:19

requires utilities building power lines

6:22

and water and sewer. And you're seeing

6:24

increasingly some local communities

6:27

object to the size and scale of these

6:30

facilities in their communities and and

6:32

slow down the construction of that. But

6:34

also you have basic supply chain needs.

6:35

you you have or challenges where there's

6:38

simply like more demand for labor in

6:40

certain places. There's more demand for

6:43

uh different components that go into

6:44

building these facilities that in it in

6:47

the supply chain is having a hard time

6:49

keeping up with the demand for it. Now

6:52

my comment was a slightly different one

6:53

which is the the ability for I would say

6:56

the institutional investment world to

6:59

absorb the finished product once it's

7:02

done I think will take longer than

7:04

people expect in their business plans.

7:07

So if you if you take a step back I I

7:09

described this sort of Jones Lang Lasal

7:11

study that talks about a trillion

7:13

dollars under construction. Blackstone

7:15

recently launched a successful uh

7:17

externally managed listed vehicle to

7:20

take advantage of this buying

7:21

opportunity. I think they raised $2

7:23

billion. So that's two and that's the

7:26

biggest one and the only one of its

7:27

kind. So the biggest and the most

7:29

successful you know global private

7:31

equity firm raised a couple billion

7:33

dollars which is very you know

7:35

impressive but that's 2% of what's under

7:37

construction today. So the ability for

7:41

vehicles to absorb and buy all this

7:43

stuff will take longer than everyone's

7:45

business plans because you know in order

7:47

to generate a 20% plus return most of

7:50

these business plans assume you buy the

7:52

land you lease it to a hyperscaler you

7:55

build it and then you sell it to someone

7:57

I think it will that that sale process

7:59

will take longer than people thought

8:01

>> because there's not enough

8:02

>> you're yeah you're you're talking about

8:04

just the pure finances that the the

8:07

buyers of the the data centers don't

8:09

have as much money as as the data

8:11

centers are kind of now worth and being

8:12

constructed and that someone's got to

8:14

buy that and if someone's taking a risk

8:16

maybe in like a closedended fund or an

8:18

institutional investor they have to sell

8:19

it to somebody and that somebody is you

8:21

or someone like you or a public type of

8:24

REIT but like I think the the data

8:25

center reats are pretty much legacy

8:27

REITs and then you know Blackstone

8:29

floated this one thing that's exciting

8:31

but you said it's it's $2 billion so

8:33

just the you're you're not seeing who's

8:35

going to be the end buyer there. Yeah,

8:36

the market will have to mature and grow

8:38

and I just think that will take longer

8:40

and so you'll have the expected returns

8:43

for some people. The re the actual

8:45

returns for some, but certainly not all

8:46

will sort of revert to more lower

8:49

long-term average returns as opposed to

8:52

20% in perpetuity because you just you

8:54

can't sustain that if you don't sell it

8:56

right away.

8:56

>> I I see what um so you said the largest

8:59

like check or property that you have is

9:01

is $500 million. that, you know, that is

9:03

a lot of money for one real estate

9:04

project, but it's it's not enough for

9:06

these cutting edge data centers. Would

9:08

you ever consider doing something like a

9:10

co-invest or, you know, is is $500

9:12

million going to get you anywhere in the

9:14

data center world? Could it get you into

9:15

the inference market if not into the the

9:17

training market?

9:18

>> Look, it's not a huge area we're

9:20

spending a ton of time trying to break

9:22

into. One of the other reasons I

9:24

mentioned too, it's not just the size.

9:26

It's if you have a, you know, a 10 or a

9:29

15-year lease with a hyperscaler, the

9:32

credit is amazing. Um, you're going to

9:34

get paid, but what is that worth seven

9:36

years into a 10-year lease? Who like

9:39

what is the will they renew? Is there

9:42

new technology that someone else will

9:44

come up with that makes what they'll pay

9:47

different? Will SpaceX put data centers

9:50

in space? So, it's not just the size.

9:52

There's a few things that that are

9:53

challenging. The other thing I would say

9:55

for us is that um one of the best

9:57

elements of the data center investment

10:00

opportunity is because of that the

10:02

nature of those credit tenants um the

10:04

ability to put material amounts of

10:06

leverage on it is attractive but the

10:08

core you know open-end universe of real

10:11

estate funds generally operates at

10:12

pretty low leverage. So most of the one

10:16

of the main drivers of benefits to drive

10:18

returns core real estate investors don't

10:21

really do because they're not going to

10:23

put 75% leverage on an asset. Um and so

10:26

it just when you add them all up we just

10:28

have found more compelling opportunities

10:30

given our size and scale in other

10:33

sectors like industrial uh logistics

10:36

really driven by e-commerce. You

10:37

mentioned senior housing and then we

10:40

quite like the prospect of of housing

10:43

going forward in general just given the

10:45

the demographic tailwinds of the

10:48

millennial generation entering peak

10:50

household formation age and the baby

10:52

boom generation sort of exiting

10:54

household formation age where they need

10:55

things like medical services and senior

10:57

living.

10:58

>> So you said housing are that you talking

11:00

about multif family so apartment

11:01

buildings? Yeah, multif family could be

11:02

built to rent individual town homes or

11:04

or single family homes, but yeah, market

11:07

rate rental housing.

11:08

>> Okay, tell me about what's going on in

11:11

the apartment market. I know in 2020

11:13

2021 rents were skyrocketing, interest

11:17

rates were close to zero, so real estate

11:19

returns were looking exceptional. Fair

11:21

to say that the past 5 years has been a

11:23

little bit more challenging. How do you

11:25

evaluate the market right now? We tend

11:26

to look at things that based on

11:29

demographics and long-term trends. And

11:31

one of the things I love about

11:32

demographics is they're inevitable. So,

11:34

you know, absent sort of a major health

11:36

crisis or a war, you can pretty much

11:39

predict how many people they're going to

11:41

be in this country at different stages

11:43

of their life over the next 10 or 15

11:45

years. Uh, and so you can make

11:46

predictions about what the demand is

11:48

going to be for certain types of real

11:50

estate services. So coming back to your

11:52

direct question, you know, you had a

11:54

couple things in the last few years

11:56

around multif family specifically um

11:58

which is you had in 2022 interest rates

12:00

spiked which caused a broad readjustment

12:04

in really all asset classes. Uh in

12:06

multif family uh you've seen you know

12:08

prices in in some markets drop you know

12:11

20 or more percent from peak to trough.

12:14

So the pricing has reset at the same

12:16

time following the the peak those low

12:21

interest rates you had a surge of new

12:23

supply which is really being absorbed

12:24

over the last couple years and this

12:26

year. So when we look forward we

12:29

basically see the demographics of people

12:32

that are aged the population 35 to 49 is

12:36

over the next 10 years is going to grow

12:37

by something like 6 and a half to 10

12:39

million people. And that's peak

12:41

household formation age 35 to 49. That's

12:43

people get married, they partner up,

12:45

they have more pets, they need more

12:46

space, and they they that's when they

12:48

tend to need more shelter. So, we think

12:51

that the gross amount of demand for

12:54

housing and rental housing is going to

12:56

accelerate in the next 10 to 15 years

12:58

and the market will get better going

13:00

forward. Right now, we're in the tail

13:02

end of absorbing this excess supply. It

13:04

was under construction, particularly in

13:07

some of the southeast and southwest

13:08

markets when interest rates were very,

13:10

very low. But looking forward, we think

13:12

it it looks quite strong. But one of the

13:14

things we we also watch is job growth.

13:16

So what we've done in our our our

13:19

research and our data science team is

13:20

we've mapped for every single asset

13:23

class in real estate, what is the the

13:25

factor or the the the the dynamic that

13:28

most drives rental growth. And some of

13:31

them are quite obvious. So for for

13:33

multif family, that's office using

13:34

employment. So what we really need, you

13:36

know, the combination of demographics

13:38

and office using employment where these

13:40

buildings are located drives the demand

13:42

for multif family and in general we're

13:45

pretty optimistic about housing over the

13:46

next 10 years.

13:47

>> So if if office using employment goes

13:50

down, obviously not great for office as

13:52

an asset class, but you're saying that

13:54

it's that that's also key for apartment

13:57

buildings because the reason people want

13:59

to live in an apartment is so they can

14:00

live close to an office. Yes, it's part

14:02

of that, but it's also uh it's a proxy

14:05

for when people have jobs,

14:07

they tend to get their own shelter,

14:09

right? When young people get a job, they

14:12

move out of their of their parents

14:14

house. When you find more job growth,

14:18

then people have fewer roommates. So

14:20

it's the factor that we've identified in

14:23

our data science something called a

14:25

recursive factor edition where we run

14:27

basically use AI to run thousands of

14:29

different models to uh and then back

14:31

tested against the actual data to

14:33

identify what combination of outcomes

14:36

and factors most were most likely to

14:38

drive the what what happened. And so for

14:41

multif family that was essentially job

14:43

growth. So yeah people moving out of

14:46

their parents house or no longer living

14:48

with roommates when they got a job. Tell

14:50

us about a very key factor which is the

14:52

supply of multif family which was very

14:54

high 2020 2021 the market's been

14:56

digesting that tell us about that phase

14:59

and how much supply has come on is going

15:03

to come on long and and you know is how

15:05

much investment has there been in new

15:06

projects recently.

15:07

>> Sure. Well, there's been a there was

15:09

really a a record amount of deliveries

15:12

over the last few years and that was

15:14

really a function of almost free cost of

15:17

capital during

15:19

coming out of COVID where interest rates

15:21

were were hovering around zero. That

15:24

combined with an acceleration of of

15:26

demand sparked a lot of construction.

15:28

What we're seeing in our own data and we

15:30

have about12 billion dollars of

15:32

apartments that we own is that the

15:34

market is stabilizing and the lease

15:36

trade out. So that's like you know a

15:38

lease trade out is when what was

15:40

somebody when you release it to somebody

15:42

new how does it compare to where the

15:45

last person who rented that unit what

15:47

they paid. And so we're seeing a a

15:49

stabilization and in some markets an

15:51

acceleration of in a positive way of the

15:55

lease tradeouts. And so we think the

15:57

market is is moving in the right

15:59

direction there, but it's there's a lot

16:00

of dispersion nationally. So you look in

16:02

some markets like San Francisco where in

16:05

our portfolio we're seeing really

16:06

significant rent growth and that's

16:09

really driven by there's no new supply

16:12

but also all the job growth around AI in

16:14

the Bay Area. And then there's other

16:16

markets where we're still seeing

16:18

negative rent growth because there's

16:20

incremental new supply that's still

16:22

being delivered and absorbed. So, it's

16:24

not a blanket statement where housing is

16:26

good everywhere. You have to sort of

16:27

pick the right locations, but our

16:29

long-term conviction in housing is you

16:31

still want to follow the U-Hauls and

16:32

follow the jobs. And so, we still think

16:35

that sort of the southeast and southwest

16:37

where you're going to have long-term job

16:39

growth is where the best places are to

16:42

think about investing in housing.

16:45

>> Just how much are rents going up in in

16:47

San Francisco? If you look at the

16:49

market, I think in the last year they've

16:51

gone up over uh when you count also the

16:54

burnoff of concessions. So in a lot of

16:56

places you had people giving two months

16:59

free rent, not necessarily San

17:00

Francisco, but where there's been a lot

17:02

of new supply to induce people and

17:05

incentivize them to move in. So you've

17:07

seen some places where peakto trough net

17:11

effective rents that's adjusted for

17:12

those concessions have improved by like

17:14

20%. Which is a huge number.

17:17

>> Wow. That is that is huge.

17:19

>> Now, now there are some markets that's

17:21

probably more in markets where you had a

17:23

pretty significant fall from the peak to

17:24

trough and it's now coming back up again

17:26

to get back closer to the peak. But na,

17:28

you know, if you look nationally on

17:31

multif family, new leases are pretty

17:33

much flat year-over-year. So adjusted

17:35

for inflation, they've gone down, but on

17:37

a nominal basis, they're basically flat.

17:40

>> What about New York?

17:41

>> New York has been going up. There's no

17:42

new supply. Um, so if you look at places

17:44

like New York, San Francisco, even the

17:47

Midwest, the story been has been where

17:49

places where there have been very few uh

17:51

units delivered,

17:53

>> you're seeing uh relatively positive and

17:56

strong rent growth by historical

17:58

standards. In the places where you've

17:59

seen a ton of new supply, you've seen

18:02

the other dynamic, but some of those

18:04

high supply markets are starting to

18:06

turn. One of the ones that's looking

18:08

pretty that has stabilized and is

18:10

looking quite positive is Austin.

18:12

>> So Austin was like a poster child for a

18:16

really poor performer in the last couple

18:17

years because there was so much new

18:19

construction but our data and our own

18:21

perform our own portfolio plus the

18:23

market dynamic the marketwide portfolio

18:25

research that you can get suggest that

18:27

it's stabilized and sort of moved from a

18:29

declining market to an improving market.

18:31

>> I hope you're enjoying today's episode.

18:33

One of the most powerful vehicles in

18:34

finance for generating reliable,

18:36

consistent cash flow is real estate

18:38

income. It's a yield generating strategy

18:40

that's backed by more than just cash

18:42

flows. It's backed by hard assets like

18:43

property and land. Investors in real

18:46

estate credit tend to hold priority

18:47

positioning, meaning they typically get

18:49

paid first. Real estate income is a

18:51

hands-off, highly structured investment

18:53

designed to deliver consistent and

18:54

insulated returns. No operational

18:56

friction, no management headaches, just

18:59

precision, priority, and predictable

19:00

yield. Historically, many of these real

19:02

estate credit strategies were reserved

19:04

exclusively for institutional investors,

19:06

but now they are available to all

19:07

investors thanks to the Fundrise Income

19:10

Fund, which has more than $600 million

19:12

invested and a 7.9% distribution rate.

19:14

The income fund aims to deliver high

19:16

current yields from a diversified

19:18

portfolio of Fundrise's most favored

19:20

real estate back fixed income

19:21

strategies. Visit fundrise.com/m

19:24

to learn more and invest in the Fundrise

19:25

Income Fund. That's fundrise.commm.

19:28

Past performance does not guarantee

19:30

future results. current distribution

19:31

rate as of June 30th, 2026. Carefully

19:33

consider the investment material before

19:34

investing, including objectives, risk,

19:36

charges, and expenses. This and other

19:38

information can be found in the income

19:39

funds perspectus at fundra.com/income.

19:41

This is a paid advertisement. Thanks for

19:43

listening. Let's get back to today's

19:45

interview. So, you said you like

19:46

demographics because it's in kind of

19:48

guaranteed what's going to happen.

19:51

>> Inevitable. Nowhere is that more more

19:52

apparent than in senior housing. Tell us

19:55

about that asset class, the trends you

19:57

see there. Yeah, I it's one of our

19:58

highest conviction investment themes

20:00

right now, Clarion, and it's all about

20:02

demographics. So, if you look at the the

20:06

data, it suggests that 10,000 people

20:08

turn 80 years old every day in this

20:10

country. That's relevant because when

20:13

people turn 80, uh it's increasingly

20:15

difficult for them to live safely by

20:17

themselves in their homes. So, what

20:18

happens? they move out, they sell those

20:21

homes and based on historical levels,

20:24

somewhere around 10% of them choose to

20:26

live in senior living. Now, uh if you

20:29

just hold that constant, um what that

20:31

means is that sort of demand for that

20:34

that population is going to of 80 year

20:36

olds going to double uh by 2040. And so

20:39

just to meet the demand for the the

20:41

larger cohort, that inevitable cohort of

20:44

people, we will need to build something

20:46

like 125,000

20:48

senior housing beds every year for the

20:51

next 15 years. Now, the peak that's ever

20:54

been built in this country in a single

20:56

year at one time was 56,000 units. Uh

20:59

the current pipeline is about 25,000. So

21:01

what we love about this business is you

21:04

have to quintuple the supply chain

21:06

capacity to deliver these units and

21:09

sustain that for something like 15

21:11

years. So the demand is inevitable. It's

21:13

coming. By the way, that assumes that

21:15

that penetration rate, the people, the

21:17

percentage of people that no longer live

21:20

at home that move into senior housing is

21:21

only 10%. I personally think that's

21:22

going to be higher because people are

21:24

wealthier and they have more capacity to

21:26

to to spend money to do it than previous

21:28

generations. But when you look at that

21:30

sort of 15-year demand for new product,

21:34

it looks a lot like us to what we saw 15

21:37

20 years ago in industrial when the

21:39

e-commerce boom was coming and the

21:42

demand was going to be for 10 or 15

21:44

years really difficult to keep up with.

21:46

And that's why you saw such sustained

21:48

rent growth, cash flow growth, and

21:50

appreciation, which gets us really

21:52

excited as a long-term investor in real

21:54

estate. Why hasn't the real estate

21:56

investment community stepped up, the

21:58

developers stepped up and built what is

22:01

necessary? Why is there such an under

22:02

supply?

22:03

>> Well, that I think they will. There's

22:05

been a few reasons. I think there was a

22:06

previous wave. There's an expression

22:08

like you know 80 is the new 70. So I

22:11

think people try to like and I lived

22:14

through this with my own parents. People

22:16

generally choose to stay in their home

22:19

as long as possible. And what a lot of

22:23

supply was built a decade ago in

22:26

anticipation of people in hitting 70 and

22:29

then moving into these facilities. But

22:31

people don't move when they're 70. They

22:32

move when they're 80. And so that was

22:35

absorbed number one. Number two, I think

22:38

people had some more difficult

22:40

experiences with the asset class during

22:41

COVID. And so people sort of backed away

22:44

from it. But you know, capital markets

22:47

and and capitalism work. So as the

22:49

demand comes, you will see people scale

22:52

up and invest in building more

22:54

facilities. We've we committed to our

22:56

first groundup development of

22:59

>> and we actually broke ground on it last

23:00

week in housing

23:03

>> and so we expect to do a lot more of

23:04

that. Clarion has a history of doing a

23:06

lot of groundup development. In the last

23:07

10 years, we've done something like 24

23:09

billion dollars of groundup development.

23:12

A lot of that was in industrial. And so

23:14

what when I mentioned before when we

23:16

we're preparing ourselves for like an

23:19

investment opportunity in the

23:20

development of senior housing that looks

23:22

like what we did, you know, 1015 years

23:25

ago, you know, through today in

23:27

industrial because we see the same kind

23:29

of long-term tailwinds. Now, we've also

23:32

bought something like a billion dollars

23:34

and about 2,000 units of senior housing

23:37

in the last six, seven months. So we're

23:40

both buying existing where we think the

23:42

fundamentals are going to be really good

23:44

but also looking at developing in you

23:46

know really good neighborhoods.

23:48

>> What what happened during COVID with the

23:49

asset class

23:50

>> people got COVID and and didn't survive.

23:52

So I it was a it was a challenging it's

23:54

an operational asset right. So while

23:57

we're not the manager you hire managers

23:59

to manage for you. um that is a

24:01

traumatic experience when you have a

24:03

pandemic that's sort of running through

24:05

your properties and there's a human toll

24:08

associated with that. Uh and I think

24:10

people the demand for really any sort of

24:13

cohabitation or public spaces dropped a

24:15

lot. So you know hotel nobody you know

24:18

people didn't want to go to hotels they

24:19

didn't go to concerts they didn't want

24:21

to live in a facility with a hundred

24:22

other people. They just lived at home

24:23

with their families. So demand dropped

24:25

off for that.

24:26

>> I got it. That makes sense. So you said,

24:27

okay, so you said that you you you built

24:30

a a tremendous amount of properties in

24:33

industrial and you prefer to to build

24:35

rather than buy, but you do both.

24:37

>> No, I would say we we we do both. Uh I

24:39

would say um if you can developing

24:42

things is generally more complicated

24:43

than buying them. Um now if you can make

24:45

a an attractive spread or a margin for

24:50

a higher return for taking that

24:52

development risk relative to buying

24:54

something existing, then we'll we'll

24:55

explore that. What we see right now is

24:58

that you can do both. And when we look

25:01

at the sheer need for more senior

25:05

housing facilities, it's going to create

25:08

a really attractive development

25:09

opportunity. And so we're mobilizing

25:11

capital, both financial capital and

25:14

human capital, because you need

25:15

expertise to be able to do that, to

25:16

oversee the construction to to make sure

25:19

you're you're building the right design,

25:21

the right product that people will

25:22

actually want to live in. And so you're

25:24

saying we're, you know, you're big in

25:25

industrial, but you're you're not big in

25:28

senior uh housing right now, but you

25:30

want to be big. You have you have plans

25:31

to become big in that asset class.

25:33

>> Depends on your definition. You know, uh

25:35

we're at about a billion dollars in 2000

25:37

units, but I think for relative for our

25:40

size, um we see the opportunity for

25:42

quite a lot of growth. It's it's one of

25:44

our I would say newest sectors. We've uh

25:47

hired a dedicated health care team

25:49

including specialists in senior housing

25:52

but also outpatient medical

25:56

more like doc medical medical office

25:57

buildings but it's our fastest growing

25:59

asset class and so we would expect that

26:01

to be pretty large uh really in the next

26:04

12 to 24 months so materially m

26:06

multiples bigger than what it is today

26:08

at a billion dollars. Is it that there's

26:10

a company, let's say I have a company,

26:12

you know, taking care of elderly people

26:14

and then you're my landlord, I rent the

26:16

property from you, or is it you're kind

26:18

of like running the business and then

26:19

you hire me as a management team?

26:21

>> It's more like the hotel business. So,

26:23

and I think the model has evolved over

26:25

time. It's a great question. Um, so what

26:27

you're what your first question was, is

26:29

it really like a a lease thing where we

26:30

lease the building to you as the

26:32

operator, you make fixed payments, and

26:34

then you take care of the residents?

26:36

That is not the way it works today.

26:38

works more like a hotel where we would

26:40

own the building and then we hire a

26:43

management company,

26:46

you know, like the senior housing

26:47

equivalent of a Marriott or a Hilton

26:51

brand and they manage it. They train the

26:53

employees. They're effectively they they

26:56

they uh they provide the services. They

26:59

charge a management fee for that like a

27:02

Marriott or a hotel management company

27:04

would do. And then we own essentially

27:06

the economic risk of of the rents and

27:10

the expenses like after that that

27:12

management company gets paid their for

27:14

their services.

27:15

>> Okay. So that kind of sounds like a

27:16

different from a lot of real estate

27:17

businesses in which you you know you

27:19

borrow money you raise money you build

27:21

or buy the property and then you collect

27:23

rent. This time you kind of are

27:26

running the business but you're paying

27:27

you're paying a management team but it's

27:28

it's it's different. It's a bit of a

27:30

hybrid between like, you know, if you

27:31

take industrial or office where you sign

27:34

perhaps a long-term lease with a

27:35

commercial tenant and that tenant pays

27:38

you monthly rent, you know, anywhere

27:39

from 5 to 10 to 15 years and then on a

27:43

day-to-day basis, you you know, you you

27:45

probably unless there's a decision about

27:47

capital or leasing the space or

27:49

financing, there's less dayto-day.

27:51

The senior housing business is closer

27:54

to,

27:55

you know, multif family here. So, people

27:57

are still signing, excuse me, like

27:59

one-year leases. Um, you just have more

28:02

provision of service and you have more

28:04

employees than you would have in a

28:05

multif family building. So, in a multif

28:06

family building, you might have um a

28:08

resident manager, you might have a

28:10

couple maintenance people, uh you might

28:12

have some on-site leasing people. And

28:14

so, maybe you had five people in the

28:15

property. Here, you're going to have

28:17

more people because you're providing,

28:19

you know, essentially more care and

28:21

service, and you're providing three

28:22

meals a day to the residents. So it

28:26

doesn't it's it's like somewhere between

28:28

a hotel and a multif family.

28:30

>> What does the supply

28:32

forecast or or picture look like over

28:34

the next few years for this asset class?

28:36

Like are there a lot of Josh Pristos who

28:38

say I want to be very involved in this?

28:41

>> Look, I think there's a growing number.

28:42

I think part of our job as investors is

28:44

and and a big part of our screening is

28:46

to look for the places where um there

28:48

isn't a lot of new supply. And so, uh,

28:50

where we're really leaning in as an

28:52

organization is we have 16 people on our

28:55

data science and our research team that

28:57

build essentially criteria and screening

29:00

tools for us to identify locations where

29:02

we think we're going to have the best

29:03

long-term performance. And so, some of

29:05

the things that go into that for senior

29:06

housing are availability of labor

29:09

because um, as we talked about, you

29:11

have, you know, a bunch of employees

29:13

that are providing services to those

29:14

residents and you actually, you know,

29:16

you you need the people. the business

29:18

doesn't work without it. So availability

29:20

of labor is is one part of it and then a

29:23

big part of it is how much incremental

29:25

supply is already in the planning stages

29:27

and how easy is it to to sort of scale

29:30

up supply. So um we look at what is our

29:33

expected demand based on the growth of

29:35

the 80-year-old population in that

29:37

region which again the demographics is

29:39

sort of inevitable. we can predict that

29:41

and then we basically are subtracting

29:43

how much so we know how many if we think

29:46

the 80-y old population is going to grow

29:48

by 10,000 people in an area and we think

29:51

10% of them are going to elect for

29:53

senior housing because that's what

29:54

they've historically done. We know

29:56

there's demand for a thousand units of

29:59

this space over the next 10 years. And

30:01

so we can then look at well what's the

30:03

total number of beds that are existing?

30:05

How many more are in the planning

30:06

stages? and we can have a view as to

30:08

whether or not there's going to be more

30:10

demand or more new supply. And we're

30:12

basically being very picky about the

30:15

locations where we are willing to buy

30:17

and even pickier where if we're going to

30:19

build uh new construction.

30:20

>> In terms of maintenance, how does it

30:22

differ from other asset class? like you

30:24

have to do a lot of improvements or

30:26

>> it's close to apartments where you've

30:29

got kind of across from apartments and

30:31

and uh and hotels because you've got a

30:35

bunch of bedroom, you know, rooms like

30:38

units that have bathrooms and and sort

30:41

of kitchenet type equipment and then you

30:44

have dining room facilities and fitness

30:45

centers and things like that. So you

30:47

definitely have

30:49

it's not as much FFN wear and tear as

30:52

hotels which are like daily stays where

30:55

people cycle in and really beat the

30:56

daylights out of them and you have to

30:57

like upgrade them quite frequently but

31:00

it's more than just apartments because

31:02

you have more common spaces uh and

31:04

you're providing uh more food and

31:06

beverage.

31:06

>> That makes sense. And

31:09

what are the valuations of these types

31:11

of properties compared to multif family

31:13

compared to industrial which are kind of

31:15

cheaper and I guess you can share what

31:18

you know how you're measuring that in

31:19

terms of a cap rate or something.

31:20

>> So these trade they have historically

31:23

traded wider than multif family or

31:27

industrial

31:28

um more capital is flowing into them. So

31:31

that that spread has compressed.

31:33

But what we think is attractive is when

31:36

we look at our internal forecast for

31:38

what the you know long-term rent and

31:42

cash flow growth is. It's really

31:44

attractive. So it's not simply just a

31:46

question of what's your going in cap

31:47

rate or your going in yield. What's your

31:49

expected growth and cash flow over time?

31:51

And across all of our sectors, senior

31:53

housing is the one that has the most the

31:56

highest projected forward cash flow

31:58

growth of any asset class. So, we're

32:00

getting both a better goingin yield

32:03

generally speaking and better cash flow

32:05

growth, but we think you should because

32:07

as you highlighted quite astutely, Jack,

32:09

it's a an operating business. So, like

32:12

there is, you know, we have more

32:14

employees, we have more services we're

32:16

providing. That's a business that has

32:18

more risk and so you should get

32:20

compensated better for it.

32:21

>> That makes sense. Tell us about your

32:23

your massive footprint in industrial.

32:26

How long have you been involved in that?

32:28

And talk about the tailwind of

32:30

e-commerce as as that and also is you

32:34

know what has the performance not you

32:35

know not of your funds but like just of

32:37

that asset class been and you know are

32:40

there people who are doubters who say

32:42

like it can't it can't go on.

32:44

>> Sure. Well, there's always doubters, but

32:46

uh I would say so we've been in the

32:48

business since the early 2000s and we

32:51

have and as I mentioned, we've got about

32:53

42 billion dollars of industrial assets

32:56

across funds and joint ventures and

32:58

separately managed accounts in the

32:59

United States. Uh I think we're the

33:00

third largest uh industrial owner in the

33:02

US. So we know the space really well. It

33:05

has performed great and I think it goes

33:07

back to this idea that it has a very

33:10

strong structural long-term demand

33:12

drivers and our our research that same

33:15

16 person you know global team that that

33:18

does this analysis that identifies what

33:20

the factors are that most impact rent

33:22

growth have done the same work for for

33:25

industrial and logistics and our

33:27

conclusion is that's all about

33:28

e-commerce sales. So the thing that's

33:30

the most impactful about driving the

33:33

demand for a square foot of industrial

33:36

space is a dollar sales of e-commerce.

33:41

And so when we look at it, our research

33:44

suggests that e-commerce growth, the

33:46

annual e-commerce growth over the next

33:48

10 years is going to grow by a trillion

33:50

dollars per year. So that is a huge

33:52

number, right? So, and what that means

33:55

is 10 years from now, the annual amount

33:56

of sales that are sort of pumping

33:58

through distribution centers and

33:59

warehouses that people that are the

34:01

result of people clicking on their their

34:03

phone to buy stuff will be a trillion

34:04

dollars a year more than it is today.

34:06

Uh, and that is going to provide really

34:08

sustained long-term demand for

34:10

warehouses. Now, is the growth are you

34:13

going to see rent growth of 10, 15, 20%

34:17

per year like you saw 5, 6, 10 years ago

34:21

when e-commerce sales were growing by

34:24

20% per year? No, we don't expect that.

34:27

We expect that, but we expect sort of a

34:29

consistent normal like marching growth

34:32

in rents and demand as a result of that

34:36

e-commerce sales tailwind. Tell me about

34:38

who the tenants are and to what degree

34:41

the e-commerce providers want to own

34:44

their own industrial facilities versus

34:46

be a tenant and rent it out from someone

34:48

such as yourself.

34:50

>> Yeah. Well, we generally see some some

34:52

do a bit of both, but but most people

34:54

like the flexibility of being a tenant

34:56

because their their demand, the amount

34:58

of sales they have in a given location,

35:02

how they choose to serve those clients.

35:04

Do they want, you know, four facilities

35:08

that are each 500,000 square feet spread

35:10

around a municipality or do they want

35:14

three that are a million square feet? Do

35:16

they want like last mile facilities

35:17

closer in? That changes based on the

35:20

composition of their their customers and

35:23

how they choose to manage their supply

35:25

chain. So what we see is um while they

35:28

sometime they own some things, there's

35:30

no problem being, you know, being a

35:31

tenant in our facilities. Um and what we

35:34

increasingly see going back to your

35:35

question about you know sort of

35:37

derivative of your question about data

35:39

centers is a question around power. Um

35:41

so when when we're talking to our

35:43

tenants which are large e-commerce

35:46

users, thirdparty logistics providers,

35:48

retailers managing their distribution,

35:50

they're increasingly looking at, you

35:52

know, what does their business look like

35:54

in the future? How much power will they

35:56

need in each warehouse when more and

35:58

more things become mechanized or or

36:01

powered by robots?

36:03

and how much machinery and data are they

36:06

pushing through there. And so while

36:07

they're not necessarily data centers,

36:10

the the the sort of inexitable march

36:13

towards the need for more power as more

36:15

things are connected to the internet of

36:16

things and more and more I guess robot

36:20

like mechanized workforce is something

36:23

we're we're increasingly focused on

36:24

because our clients the the tenants are

36:26

focused on

36:27

>> is the mechanization of the workforce

36:29

and of you know basically using robots

36:31

in warehouses is that something that's

36:32

increasing a lot right now?

36:34

>> I think so. Yeah. Well, we well we we

36:36

one of our uh two ways. One, um we're

36:39

seeing as companies are growing and

36:42

pushing more inventory through

36:45

ever bigger,

36:47

you know, warehouse spaces, they're

36:49

doing that. In some places, they're

36:51

working 24 hours a day, you know, and

36:53

leveraging both human labor and, you

36:55

know, mechanized labor through robotics.

36:57

Uh the other thing that we're seeing is

36:59

I think one of the hottest markets that

37:01

we're invested in in industrial right

37:04

now is in Northern California. Similar

37:06

to what we talked about with the um the

37:09

multif family, but the advanced

37:10

manufacturing uh that's going on in

37:13

Northern California that's around AI

37:15

around robotics is creating a a

37:17

tremendous amount of demand for

37:20

industrial warehouse advanced

37:23

manufacturing space that has high power

37:25

needs. Can you explain to to me like I'm

37:27

a total beginner which you know I am.

37:29

What an in a factory or a warehouse a

37:32

distribution center. What is the asset?

37:34

You know it's pretty obvious to everyone

37:36

listening. An office okay you go in

37:38

there it's it's got electricity. You

37:41

know people know what an office is and

37:43

it's got amenities. Same for apartment

37:47

buildings. It's got all these units

37:49

rooms beds. You know if it's a more

37:52

expensive building maybe it's got a gym.

37:54

like what what are people getting when

37:57

they sign a lease in an industrial

38:00

facility? What do they what do they want

38:02

and what are they saying like oh this is

38:04

this is what's important to me.

38:05

>> Sure. So not just like all buildings

38:08

have you know call it four walls and a

38:10

roof. So but how those are configured

38:13

and how people or goods and services go

38:16

in and out of them is totally different

38:17

right? So generally speaking, you know,

38:20

a a warehouse is going to be a single

38:22

story and it's going to have a very high

38:25

ceiling. So somewhere between 36, you

38:27

know, or 40 feet for new like sort of

38:30

higher quality stuff. It's going to have

38:32

a much more what we call durable slab.

38:35

So if you're if you're putting heavy

38:37

machinery on it and you're or and andor

38:42

you have all kinds of you know like

38:46

vehicles driving around on that floor

38:48

and moving very heavy things the the the

38:50

sort of durability of that slab that

38:53

foundation needs to be more than if just

38:55

people are walking in and out of it

38:57

because it's the lobby of their

38:58

apartment building. So, I would say the

39:00

the slab is one sort of a very very

39:03

important thing would be access because

39:04

for depending on what what you're

39:06

storing there, what you're doing, you're

39:08

going to have 18 wheel trucks coming in

39:10

and out of there. So, you need to have,

39:12

you know, the ability for a bunch of

39:14

trucks to get and out. You need the

39:15

ability for them to turn, right? Because

39:17

they have a big turning radius and you

39:18

need docks. So, that means these these

39:20

can back up, they can like open their

39:22

trailer and something gets loaded off,

39:24

like loaded on and they leave. Um, so

39:27

you need and you probably you may need,

39:29

you know, more considerably more power

39:31

if you're running, you know, machines

39:33

than you would if you have a bunch of

39:35

people live in an apartment building

39:37

that really only use it for, you know,

39:39

microwaves, ovens, light bulbs, and like

39:41

to recharge their their uh their iPad.

39:44

So for industrial, you're going to have,

39:46

you know, again, you're going to have

39:47

more docks that how people get in and

39:49

out, trucks get in and out is super

39:51

important. Um, you're going to have a

39:52

very sturdy floor or slab. Uh, and you

39:55

know, depending on what you're doing,

39:56

you may have a very a smaller portion.

39:59

You're gonna have higher ceiling because

40:00

you stack stuff very high. Um, but you

40:03

may not actually have air conditioning

40:04

in all of it. You may just have like a

40:05

small office that might be five or 10%

40:07

of the overall space that's air

40:10

conditioned and the rest of it is is

40:12

unairc

40:19

depending on what you got going on in

40:20

there.

40:21

>> That makes sense. So we can put this

40:23

chart up for for our viewers. Claring

40:25

partners had had a piece on the

40:27

completion and net absorption of this

40:29

asset class and you show how net absorpt

40:32

so people basically becoming tenants was

40:36

extremely robust from you know 2010 to

40:39

you know 2021 but supply grew up a lot.

40:42

So completion and there was a few years

40:44

2023 and 2024 where there were more

40:46

units completed than there was

40:48

absorption. So there's been a little bit

40:49

of digestion in this asset class. What

40:52

gives you the confidence that the trends

40:53

are going to reverse? Like has there has

40:55

has there been less investment and less

40:57

completions in this asset class because

40:59

of that?

40:59

>> Well, look, two things. Free markets

41:01

work. Uh that's why we all have jobs.

41:04

And so what you're seeing is as that

41:05

vacancy as the new deliveries exceeded

41:08

the net absorption, so vacancy was going

41:11

up, uh you've seen people start less

41:13

projects. We've already seen that revert

41:15

where now you have positive net

41:18

absorption. So the leasing is exceeding

41:20

the new deliveries. Part of that is

41:22

because interest rates went up. It's

41:24

more difficult for people to get

41:25

financing uh that works that pencils for

41:28

those projects. But I guess just maybe

41:30

the the most direct thing I would say is

41:32

you know we're we're seeing tremendous

41:34

demand and absorption in our existing

41:36

portfolio. So I think we'll break ground

41:38

on something like 10 million square feet

41:39

of new projects this year is our

41:41

expectation and that's all driven by

41:43

what we're what we're seeing. So we

41:45

signed in the first quarter of 2026

41:48

something like 8 million square feet of

41:50

new leases across our global portfolio

41:52

which I believe is the best total new

41:55

leasing quarter we've ever had in the

41:57

history of Clarion in 44 years uh in

41:59

industrial. So we're seeing the

42:02

businesses that that operate in the

42:04

space

42:06

need like in this sector need space uh

42:08

as their businesses are growing and they

42:11

have demand and as long as you're got

42:14

the right product in the right location

42:15

we're pretty optimistic about the future

42:17

and we're going to keep building into

42:18

that.

42:18

>> The strength in that demand certainly it

42:21

indicates a strength about the asset

42:22

class but do you is there any

42:24

macroeconomic signal that you see as

42:25

someone who's managing a lot of whoa

42:27

things are kind of heating up here?

42:29

Yeah, I mean we've definitely seen that

42:32

that that demand is driven by it's

42:34

actually it's like a pretty broad broad

42:35

base. So we've seen demand across um

42:38

that what you would expect as a result

42:40

of the e-commerce trend and growth in

42:42

e-commerce sales. We have seen growth in

42:45

I would say manufacturing adjacent needs

42:48

and some of that is is a and some of

42:50

that is the in addition is that that

42:52

data center adjacent demand. So it's

42:55

pretty broad brush where we're seeing

42:57

the demand across the board and a lot of

42:58

that was what we what we saw was after

43:02

liberation day a number of businesses

43:05

maybe paused a little bit and and we're

43:06

waiting to see where that shook out like

43:09

where were what were the tariffs going

43:10

to be

43:12

how long would they be for like you know

43:15

they they were moving around a little

43:16

bit and so people chose to just pause

43:18

and wait and see what happened but

43:20

eventually people go on with their

43:21

business they they they still have

43:23

demand

43:24

to to to basically distribute their

43:27

goods to their customers and they can't

43:29

just wait for perfection or absolute

43:32

certainty. At some point they just make

43:34

a decision based on the best of

43:35

information they have and that led that

43:38

has led to a pretty good 2026 for us so

43:41

far.

43:41

>> Earlier you you mentioned core and core

43:44

plus explain what that is and why that's

43:46

significant for the asset class.

43:47

>> Sure. Well, when we think about there's

43:49

like sort of four risk different

43:52

different risk spectrums that you tend

43:54

to see in real estate as institutions

43:56

define it. Core, core plus, value ad,

43:59

and opportunistic. And those describe

44:01

sort of ranges of returns and ranges of

44:04

risk. And so the most the lowest risk,

44:07

most stable

44:09

with the highest component of income is

44:11

core. Uh and that's probably you know

44:14

low sort of high single digits in

44:18

perpetuity

44:19

returns

44:21

across the industry is when people sort

44:23

of people think about it. You know you

44:25

probably add a couple hundred basis

44:26

points for core plus core and so core

44:28

properties are going to be extremely

44:30

well leased in great locations in

44:32

excellent condition relatively new

44:34

product. So core plus might be a

44:37

combination of some of that core plus

44:39

maybe sprinkling in some development to

44:41

add extra return and extra alpha. It

44:44

might be looking at projects that are

44:46

where that have some below market rents

44:48

or aren't quite stabilized but are still

44:50

very high quality. And then when you

44:53

look at value ad you're going further up

44:55

the risk spectrum. You're probably going

44:57

to put more leverage on it. So core

44:58

tends to be less than 30% loan to value.

45:02

Val core plus tends to be in that 40 to

45:05

50% range.

45:07

Value ad and opportunistic tend to be

45:09

sort of 65 or 70% loan to value. So

45:12

you're taking more risk. You'd expect

45:13

more return. And usually with value ad

45:16

or opportunistic, you're doing something

45:18

more fun a fundamental change to that

45:20

asset. You might be completely

45:22

redeveloping it. It might be vacant and

45:24

you have to, you know, just start from

45:27

zero. Or it might be just a piece of

45:29

land that you're going to develop ground

45:30

up or or something where you're going to

45:32

take it and change the use like take an

45:34

office building and convert it to an

45:35

apartment building. That's going to be

45:37

more value add and opportunistic. And

45:38

the more risk you take and the more

45:40

leverage you put on it obviously the

45:42

higher return you want.

45:43

>> And so you're operating mainly in the

45:44

core and core plus universe.

45:46

>> Yep.

45:47

>> Yeah. And so would that would that

45:49

correlate as well with the rating of an

45:52

you know a class A type business would a

45:55

property would more be a core or core

45:58

plus?

45:59

>> It tends to be. Yeah. So you what you'd

46:01

normally see is the sort of o owning

46:04

long-term class A assets tends to be

46:07

more of a core or a core plus. You might

46:09

see a value adder opportunistic business

46:11

trying to manufacture class A core or

46:15

core plus assets and then sell them.

46:16

What happens if a a a core or a core

46:19

plus strategy owns a class A property,

46:22

it's performed really well, but they've

46:23

owned it for 15 years and maybe it's

46:25

kind of on the margin. It's no longer

46:26

class A. Would they sell that to someone

46:30

else in the the chain, more of a value

46:32

ad person, or or do they just hold?

46:34

>> Look, I we we believe in active

46:36

portfolio management. So, so, so first

46:39

of all, I'd say sometimes you can have

46:40

assets that aren't class A that are

46:41

great assets to own. So, you might have,

46:44

you know, really well-located garden

46:46

apartments that are a little older, that

46:48

are at an affordable rent that always

46:50

see quite a lot of demand. There might

46:51

be really some older, very infill

46:54

industrial warehouses in locations. It's

46:57

hard to build new construction. And so

47:00

the tenants accept a little older

47:02

building with maybe not as modern specs,

47:04

but over overwhelmingly you want to own

47:06

class A class A buildings. Our job and

47:08

what I one of the things we're really

47:10

proud of is you don't want to wait until

47:12

the asset is functionally obsolete or no

47:14

longer class A to sell it because then

47:16

you're selling a problem that somebody

47:17

else has to fix. And so we're really a

47:20

huge proponent of active portfolio

47:23

management. So when we look back at our

47:25

history in most years, we're actually

47:27

selling as much as we're buying. We're

47:29

always pruning the portfolio and

47:31

identifying the assets that they're not

47:34

yet they've not yet made the transition

47:36

from maybe class A to class B or there's

47:39

something that we're but we want to do

47:40

it before it becomes obvious to the

47:42

market. And it's a little bit the

47:43

philosophy that that that sort of

47:45

populates our view on the data center we

47:47

were talking about, which is it's

47:49

probably fine for some period of time,

47:51

but if you have a 10-year lease, five

47:54

years from now, if you want to sell that

47:56

data center, there's not enough

47:58

transaction history for us that we've

48:01

seen yet of people buying the data

48:03

centers that only have five years left

48:05

of term on that lease. And what does the

48:07

market value that? How do they value

48:09

that? So, that's like there just needs

48:11

to be, I would say, more

48:13

pricing discovery on how that asset

48:15

class trades because our our our general

48:18

model would look to transition out of

48:20

assets well before it looks like they

48:23

may be a problem.

48:24

>> I know when the Fed raised rates in

48:26

2022, volumes and the transactions that

48:30

real estate participants did went down

48:32

because, you know, stated values and

48:34

market values diverge. So, it's very

48:37

hard to to get liquidity there. Has that

48:39

changed? Is is like are we fully past

48:41

that now? and people are transacting a

48:42

lot or is there still some some

48:44

transition that we need to get there?

48:46

>> Yeah, so I think there's been a broad

48:48

market recovery or at least the start of

48:50

one. So we we like to think about 26 as

48:52

the 2026 is the start of a new cycle. Um

48:55

so you've had a few things have have

48:57

have started that new cycle. So I think

48:59

you've had seven quarters in a row now

49:01

of private market positive returns. So

49:05

usually like that sort of signals like a

49:07

it's not just a dead cat bounce here

49:08

like you know asset values have dropped

49:11

to the point where there's price

49:13

discovery and enough volume that people

49:15

are comfortable. Um you've had you know

49:17

rates come in or at least stabilize and

49:21

then uh what we see is the fundamentals

49:23

look really strong. So, and you touched

49:26

on a few of these with previous

49:27

questions, but when you look across the

49:29

universe of things like new construction

49:31

starts, deliveries, positive net

49:33

absorption, you know, are we are we

49:35

absorbing more space than we're

49:37

delivering every year? Pretty much every

49:39

asset class with the exception of

49:41

non-class A office and life science is

49:45

looks better and more healthy than the

49:46

long-term averages. So, what we see and

49:49

what the market sees is fundamentals

49:51

look really good. There's not a lot of

49:52

new construction. what is being

49:54

delivered is more than being absorbed

49:56

and you have the prices have dropped 20

49:59

25% sometimes more in some asset

50:02

classes. So the pricing is attractive

50:04

and then when you look at it on a

50:05

historical basis compared to multiples

50:08

in the equity market high yield spreads

50:11

you know investment grade spreads real

50:12

estate is sort of quite fairly valued

50:16

and so we're seeing transaction volumes

50:19

grow. They're not what they were in 2021

50:22

uh and 2020, which were kind of record

50:24

all-time highs with zero interest rates

50:26

or very low interest rates, but they've

50:28

come back a lot and they're at a very

50:29

healthy level.

50:31

>> So, you you think we're in a new cycle

50:34

because the the rate maybe perhaps the

50:37

the rate hike cycle disencourage supply

50:40

and and that word now, you know, that's

50:43

been full fully digested and that the

50:45

demand is outstripping supply across the

50:47

vast majority of asset classes. Yes,

50:49

that plus prices adjusted in response to

50:53

that rate hike to a level that the

50:55

market has there's enough price

50:57

discovery in enough transactions that

50:59

people are comfortable and when you look

51:01

at those yields or multiples or cap

51:03

rates relative to historical standards

51:06

and

51:08

relative to other asset classes in the

51:12

that people could invest their money

51:13

today. It it's it's stimulating

51:16

confidence in more real estate

51:17

transactions because it it feels fair.

51:19

>> Would you say class A office is also

51:21

recovering?

51:22

>> I would say class A office is

51:24

recovering. Now there's definitely a

51:26

sort of a a sort of tale of halves and

51:28

halves. So the highly amenitized newer

51:31

product or newly renovated with

51:33

significant amenities in certain

51:35

locations, there's quite a lot of

51:36

demand. I think if you're in sort of

51:39

older, weaker subm markets or buildings

51:42

and more suburban office in certain

51:44

parts of the country, it's still a

51:46

pretty cold winter out there. And our

51:48

long-term view on that asset class is

51:50

not particularly positive. We think

51:53

you're going to still have like

51:55

depreciation and declining values in the

51:58

really nontrophy assets and and and the

52:01

trophy ones, it does present a similar

52:03

challenge to what we talked about in the

52:05

data centers. If you look, you know, I'm

52:06

calling in today from one Madison

52:08

Avenue, um, which is a brand new

52:09

building. It's a great building. It's

52:11

one you'd love to own, but it's

52:13

probably, I don't know, somewhere

52:15

between a billion and $2 billion for a

52:16

building like this. So, that going back

52:19

to how do these fit in a core uh

52:22

diversified fund? It's pretty

52:24

challenging. So, we're underweight

52:26

office. I suspect will stay there. But

52:29

will people make money

52:33

in their opportunistic funds buying

52:35

office buildings and trading in leasing

52:37

them up and trading out of them in a

52:39

moment play right now. I think they

52:40

will. That's not the core business of

52:42

Clarion right now. We're really focused

52:44

on, you know, long-term cash flow

52:46

growth, diversification, low volatility.

52:49

Office has a lot of volatility as

52:51

tenants come in and out because very

52:52

capital intensive to replace the

52:54

tenants. Why is it so capital to capital

52:57

intensive to replace the tenants?

52:58

>> So the the market standard for uh what a

53:02

tenant gets to lease a space in terms of

53:04

a tenant improvement allowance or free

53:06

rent is pretty significant. So you know

53:10

that could be hundreds of dollars of

53:12

square per square foot of they call it

53:15

landlord inducements either cash or free

53:18

rent for a period of time. So, if you

53:21

think about that, that impacts the if

53:22

someone invests in your fund and you're

53:24

you're you're trying to pay a consistent

53:26

dividend, uh that impacts your ability

53:28

to pay that dividend. Uh you contrast

53:30

that with industrial, which has super

53:32

low capex requirements. So, if somebody

53:35

leaves, you're not giving them hundreds

53:36

of dollars a square per square foot.

53:39

You're giving them, I don't know, a

53:40

couple bucks, five bucks. Um so, the

53:43

volatility of the cash flow is much

53:44

lower in that business. I I a

53:47

counterpoint to your bearish case on

53:50

class B class C office is who's building

53:53

class B class C office right now?

53:55

Doesn't everyone know that it's a bad

53:56

idea? And isn't that going to lead to a

53:58

>> Nobody ever builds people only build

54:00

class A anything. I think the issue is

54:02

there's not a lot of tenant demand for

54:04

it. All the tenants want to go up and to

54:06

the right into the higher better amen

54:08

the higher quality better amenitized

54:09

assets.

54:11

And so look, I think the story around

54:13

one of the interesting stories around

54:15

New York is it's probably been among the

54:18

most successful in stimulating a

54:21

conversion of older office buildings

54:23

into residential. So you're actually

54:25

seeing a reduction in supply in those

54:27

types of those buildings because they're

54:29

not because someone's leasing them. Some

54:32

people are, but not because there's this

54:34

overwhelming demand for office users,

54:36

but because you're just taking them out

54:37

of stock by converting them to

54:39

apartments. Yeah. So this no one ever

54:41

built a class B or class C building. So

54:44

class B and class C buildings are former

54:46

class A buildings that are now old.

54:48

>> Yeah. Or or someone made a mistake and

54:51

built something that nobody wants.

54:52

Right. They messed up the specs somehow.

54:55

Like uh they built a building that they

54:58

thought like looked good on paper, but

54:59

in practice it's not it's not it's

55:01

functionally obsolete or like people

55:03

it's not really what people want and so

55:04

they have to charge a low a discount to

55:08

to find demand for it. Josh, I I got a a

55:11

question. It's about private credit. So,

55:13

on a fundamental basis, not very related

55:16

to what you your asset class at all, but

55:19

I imagine that you are raising money

55:21

from similar types of investors, you

55:22

know, in the al alternatives bucket.

55:25

What have you observed as we've seen,

55:28

you know, net outflows from some of

55:29

these private credit funds, and that's,

55:30

you know, public information. Is is is

55:34

that affecting the broader fundraising

55:36

environment for alternatives broadly or

55:39

is it kind of just a hyperspecific thing

55:41

to direct lending in in private credit?

55:43

>> So far I think it's fairly specific to

55:46

direct lending. We clarion is not really

55:48

in that space. We have some real estate

55:50

debt but um we don't tend to raise

55:52

separate pools of capital for it. Um but

55:54

what I would say is I think real estate

55:56

is a bit of a beneficiary because it's

55:58

the ultimate halo trade. you know, heavy

56:01

asset, low obsolescence. So, it doesn't,

56:04

you know, a lot of the private credit

56:07

concerns seem to be around software and

56:09

disintermediation from AI, but it AI

56:13

isn't going to change the the the need

56:15

for someone to have shelter when they go

56:17

home at night. It's likely not going to

56:20

change the the fact that people's Amazon

56:23

packages get sent from some warehouse to

56:26

their doorstep, you know, every day. And

56:28

so we think real estate is a net

56:30

beneficiary of concern around some of

56:33

the corporate private credit just

56:35

because it is by definition a very low

56:38

obsolescence uh business.

56:39

>> Makes sense. Josh, we'll link in the

56:41

description several of the the pieces

56:43

from Clarend Partners. Thank you so much

56:45

for coming on Monetary Matters.

56:46

>> Appreciate it. Thanks for having me.

56:48

>> I hope you enjoyed today's interview.

56:50

Remember to check out the Fundrise

56:51

Income Fund. Click the link in the

56:53

description to learn more about its

56:54

assets and strategy. Until next time.

56:59

Thank you. Just close the door.

Interactive Summary

The video features an interview with Josh Pristow, managing director at Clarion Partners, regarding the current real estate investment landscape. They discuss the major boom in data centers, why Clarion remains cautious about investing in them due to their massive size and potential for technological obsolescence, and the firm's preference for industrial and housing sectors. The conversation also covers the importance of demographics in real estate, the current state of the apartment market after excess supply, the high conviction for senior housing due to an aging population, and the outlook for industrial logistics driven by e-commerce.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts