HomeVideos

The Oubliette: History's CRUELEST Punishment

Now Playing

The Oubliette: History's CRUELEST Punishment

Transcript

266 segments

0:00

It's the 19th of December 1702. We're in

0:03

the Bastile, an enormous prison complex

0:06

in Paris. And in the absolute lowest

0:09

boughels of this fortress of

0:11

incarceration and torture, stands a man

0:14

who has spent the last 33 years rotting

0:18

behind bars. Well, actually, it would be

0:21

more accurate to say he has been rotting

0:23

under bars as he suffers one of the

0:26

worst fates possible. The ubliet, a

0:29

pitch black underground dungeon the

0:32

victims are tossed into, left with

0:34

nothing but darkness and scuffling rats

0:36

for company until they're completely

0:39

forgotten to the world and finally

0:42

succumb to malnutrition

0:45

or madness. And as for the man currently

0:48

in the ubliet under the Bastile, nobody

0:51

knows for certain how long he's been

0:53

there or why he's been imprisoned in the

0:56

first place. Guards are under strict

0:58

orders never to communicate with him,

1:01

only breaking the silence to toss down

1:03

flasks of feted water or scraps of moldy

1:06

bread. So extreme is his seclusion

1:08

within the dungeon that these guards

1:10

don't even know his name or what he

1:12

looks like. Most have never seen his

1:15

face through the pitch black cell. Those

1:17

that have gotten close enough to

1:19

actually make out his features are sworn

1:21

to an oath of complete silence. To most

1:25

of the gods, he's known simply as the

1:29

man in the Iron Mask. It's the only name

1:32

we have for him that survives to this

1:34

day. And although many have tried to

1:36

uncover his true identity, no one is

1:38

certain who this prisoner in the Ullet

1:40

is. The oolet itself comes from the

1:43

French word ooier, which means to

1:46

forget. For the man in the iron mask,

1:49

it's most certainly been effective. No

1:52

one can remember his true identity, and

1:55

after three decades of wasting away in

1:57

total darkness, neither can he. This was

2:01

one of the very few confirmed cases of

2:03

the obliet's use. You could argue that

2:05

this was because it was an exceptionally

2:07

rare punishment. But perhaps the real

2:10

reason that records are so scarce is

2:13

simply because of how effective the

2:15

ooiet was at making people utterly

2:18

forgotten and forever erased from

2:21

history. But what actually was the

2:24

ooiet? And who was the man in the iron

2:27

mask?

2:30

[Music]

2:33

In the medieval and early modern period,

2:36

prison was not a go-to punishment like

2:38

it is today. Instead, punishment was

2:40

swift and public with an emphasis on

2:43

corporal punishments like flogging or

2:45

capital punishments like hanging. This

2:48

is partly because keeping a peasant

2:50

behind bars and feeding them every day

2:51

whilst they can no longer contribute to

2:53

farming or labor would have been an

2:55

outrageous expense at the time. But it

2:58

was also because of some religious

2:59

beliefs around crime and punishment in

3:01

medieval Europe. Serious crimes like

3:04

murder were believed to add a kind of

3:06

moral pollution to the community. And so

3:08

a public execution or punishment was

3:11

seen as a way of cleansing the moral

3:13

community of that corruption and

3:15

restoring things to a state of harmony.

3:18

So when someone was actually put behind

3:20

bars, it usually meant that they weren't

3:22

just criminals, but were instead

3:24

hostages from wealthy families or rival

3:28

political factions, and they would be

3:29

held in captivity while their captor

3:31

used them as a bargaining chip for

3:33

negotiations and settlements. For this

3:36

purpose, most captives would be kept

3:38

inside a castle dungeon where they would

3:40

wait until a settlement was agreed, at

3:42

which point they would be let free to go

3:44

on their way. But in some cases, far

3:47

deeper within the complex was a very

3:49

particular kind of dungeon called the

3:52

Uliet, where people could be locked away

3:54

for far longer periods of time, often

3:58

forever, and far away from the public

4:01

eye. Unlike a normal prison cell, an

4:04

ooliet was usually a narrow vertical

4:07

shaft, sometimes barely wide enough to

4:09

stand or sit in, with a single trap door

4:12

at the top. No windows, no light, no

4:16

comfort. Victims were lowered in through

4:18

the trap door and left in total

4:20

darkness. The only sounds were that of

4:23

your own breath, the scurrying of rats,

4:25

and the drip of water echoing off of

4:28

cold stone walls. Often times the ubliet

4:31

was so tight that the victim would be

4:33

forced to stand for the entirety of

4:35

their time within leaning on the slimy

4:38

mossridden face of the stone walls or

4:40

worse against the remains of those who

4:43

had come before and were discarded in

4:45

the hole to perish. Since the whole

4:47

thing was at the very bottom of the

4:49

castle's structure, waste from latrines

4:52

and rotten groundwater would often pull

4:54

at the base of the ubliet, leaving the

4:56

victim kneede in stinking water, who

4:59

would be unable to see what was

5:00

underneath the surface since everything

5:03

was pitch black. First, the darkness,

5:06

not just nighttime dark, but a

5:08

suffocating absolute black. The kind of

5:12

dark where your eyes never adjust. Where

5:14

you can't see your own hand in front of

5:16

your face. Days and nights blur into

5:19

each other. Time stops existing. Then

5:22

there's the cold. The uglier was dug

5:25

deep into the stone, damp, bitterly

5:28

cold. The air stale and heavy. Your

5:31

clothes, if you had any, would stay

5:33

permanently wet. Your skin would

5:35

blister. Your joints would ache

5:37

constantly. You'd never get dry or ever

5:40

get warm. And worst of all, the silence

5:44

broken only by distant echoes, the sound

5:46

of rats, or the occasional clang of the

5:49

trapoor far above. No voices, no

5:52

sunlight, no human contact, just endless

5:56

solitude. You wouldn't even know how

5:57

long you'd been down there. Weeks,

6:00

months, years. You'd lose track of

6:02

everything. Speech, memory, your sense

6:06

of self. And eventually, if starvation

6:08

or thirst didn't kill you, your own mind

6:11

would. Few people who went into an

6:13

ubliet ever came out. And if they did,

6:16

they rarely came out sane. There were

6:19

many ways to die in a hole like this,

6:21

but none of them were quick. Starvation

6:23

was common. Some were thrown down with

6:26

just enough food and water to prolong

6:28

the suffering. Crusts of stale bread,

6:30

filthy water dripped down from above. It

6:33

kept them alive just long enough to make

6:35

them wish that they weren't. Then there

6:38

was exposure. These pits were deep stone

6:40

shafts, always wet and as we said,

6:43

always cold. Hypothermia could take you

6:46

slowly, especially in winter. Infections

6:49

would fester in the filth. And you can

6:51

imagine where you would need to go to

6:53

the bathroom. In this situation, rats

6:56

would gnaw at you while you slept,

6:58

standing up, or while you were too weak

7:01

to stop them chewing on you. But worst

7:04

of all was the mind. The total silence,

7:07

the complete darkness. It could break a

7:10

person long before the body gave out.

7:13

Locked away with nothing but your own

7:15

thoughts. Not knowing if it's a day or

7:17

night, if it's been a week or a year,

7:19

the brain starts to fracture.

7:21

Hallucinations set in. Memory slips. You

7:25

forget your name. You forget the world.

7:27

Some prisoners reportedly began to speak

7:30

to walls, to sing to themselves for

7:32

hours, or simply to stop responding

7:34

altogether. The ubliet didn't need

7:38

torturers. The ooiet was the torture. We

7:42

don't have diaries from victims, but we

7:45

do know what happens to a human mind

7:46

under similar conditions because modern

7:48

psychologists have studied it by looking

7:50

closely at solitary confinement,

7:53

especially in supermax prisons. And the

7:55

effects are disturbing. After just a few

7:58

days in complete isolation, inmates

8:00

report anxiety, paranoia, insomnia,

8:04

hallucinations, even full-on psychotic

8:06

breaks. And these are people who still

8:08

get food, lighting, warmth, and maybe a

8:11

toilet. Now imagine what it's like in an

8:15

ooliet. No light, no human voices, no

8:19

clear sleep cycle, no stimulation,

8:22

nothing. The brain needs stimulation to

8:25

stay grounded in reality. And if you

8:27

take that away, the mind starts creating

8:30

its own. That's when the walls start to

8:33

breathe. That's when you hear voices

8:35

that aren't there. That's when you start

8:36

to believe you're being watched or eaten

8:39

alive from the inside. In short, the

8:41

ubliet doesn't just punish the body. It

8:44

strips away a person's sense of time,

8:46

place, identity, and eventually sanity.

8:50

By the time starvation or infection

8:52

finally sets in, the person who dies in

8:54

the pit might no longer resemble the

8:56

person who went in. And maybe that was

8:58

the point all along, not just to make

9:00

someone disappear, but to unmake them

9:03

completely. So, how often was this

9:07

punishment actually used? Well, the

9:10

ublier is one of those punishments that

9:12

barely leaves a trace. And that's the

9:14

point. It was designed to make people

9:16

vanish quietly and completely. Because

9:20

of that, we don't have long lists of

9:22

names or detailed court records. Most

9:25

who were thrown in were meant to be

9:26

forgotten. That's what makes tracking

9:29

real cases so difficult. You don't

9:31

record what you're trying to erase. But

9:35

the concept appears in whispers and

9:37

rumors across Europe. In the L Valley,

9:40

some castles have narrow stone shafts

9:43

that match the exact design, hidden

9:45

behind walls or beneath trap doors just

9:48

wide enough to let someone in. In

9:50

Scotland and Germany, some accounts

9:52

described bottle dungeons, deep pits

9:54

beneath towers where political enemies

9:57

or traitors could be sealed away without

10:00

trial. And then there's the one case

10:02

that might prove the obli wasn't just a

10:04

legend. The individual with whom we

10:07

started this episode, the man in the

10:10

iron mask. He was arrested in 1669 under

10:14

a false name. And for the next 34 years

10:17

he was shuffled between the most secure

10:19

prisons in France. Pignarel Exil Samari

10:23

and finally the Bastile. His guards were

10:26

given strict orders never to speak to

10:28

him, never let him be seen and above all

10:30

never reveal his identity. At all times

10:33

he was forced to wear a mask. Some said

10:36

velvet or black. Some claimed it was

10:38

iron, hence the name to keep his face

10:40

hidden even in death. He died in 1703

10:44

and was buried under yet another false

10:46

name. To this day, no one knows who he

10:49

really was. Theories have spiraled for

10:51

centuries. A disgraced noble, perhaps an

10:53

Italian diplomat, the twin brother of

10:56

King Louie, perhaps even a valet who

10:58

happened to know too much about royal

11:00

corruption. None have ever been proven.

11:03

And that was the whole point. A human

11:06

being with a name, a personality, a

11:09

past, and hopes for the future had been

11:13

removed from history, memory, and even

11:16

themselves, remaining only as semi-

11:19

mythical legend. A man behind an iron

11:22

mask. The Ullet wasn't just a hole in

11:26

the ground. It was an act of erasure.

Interactive Summary

The video discusses the 'ubliet,' a brutal form of medieval and early modern imprisonment where individuals were confined in pitch-black, narrow underground dungeons for extended periods, often indefinitely. This punishment was designed not just to inflict suffering but to completely erase the victim from history and memory. The video explores the horrific conditions of the ubliet, including extreme darkness, cold, isolation, and the psychological torment that led to madness or death. It also delves into the mystery of the 'Man in the Iron Mask,' a prisoner held in the Bastille under strict secrecy, whose identity remains unknown, serving as a prime example of the ubliet's purpose: total erasure. The effectiveness of the ubliet is highlighted by the scarcity of records, as its very nature aimed to make its victims forgotten.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts