"Addictions almost always start with trauma" - Bessel van der Kolk (Part 4)
507 segments
Yeah, but that's a really interesting
point that's very rarely made in our
field. It's very rarely made in our
field. People don't tend to make that
point. They're usually saying things
like, oh, you know, come and talk it out
more, get into your body more. the
actual the kind of utilitarian view of
recovery is as good as recovery looks,
as recovery does, as recovery lives, is
often lacking. But you're very
passionate about that.
>> I am. And so the goal of treatment is
not to talk about your trauma.
>> Right.
>> The goal of treatment is to be fully
arrive on September 30th, 2025.
>> Mhm.
>> I hope got the date right actually.
>> Not bad. But that's really the goal is
are you a life and what will give you a
sense of fulfillment and pleasure and
the pleasure word is the f word is
always left out. Fun.
>> Fun. Fun. That's what I was thinking of.
Yeah.
>> If you feel traumatized, you can't have
fun.
>> Yeah.
>> So, it's really important to get a sense
of pleasure and get your reward system
working that makes you feel I feel
alive. I feel well. I don't feel like a
victim. So being able to do things that
really give you a sense of agency is
unbelievably important.
Well, I personally think you're lots of
fun, but that's because I kind of like
talking about really nonfun things like
trauma. Um,
I think this is a really good point and
you know, I'm really grateful for that
because actually what I want people to
try to take on board is not just this
kind of you talk about expansion versus
contraction. I don't want people to
contract into what's wrong with me and
how do I get someone to fix it for me,
but to expand into what's right with us
and how do we nourish and support that
with each other. That's important. What
is working?
Um, for example, today in a panel in
Oxford and somebody said, uh, I feel
like you don't really listen to me. And
so they talked about how to deal with
this. And I would have said, "Oh, but do
you remember somebody who did listen to
you?"
I what I would say. And do you remember
what it felt like when somebody really
listened to you? Right?
>> And what you usually will find is that
nobody ever listens to me.
>> Right?
>> And then the question comes, how can you
get people to listen to you? And maybe
moving together in sync might be
helpful. Or maybe being a member of a
theater group and acting a particular
role and feeling you're a vital part of
the theater group might be very
important or part of a music group that
your contribution becomes important and
you listen to each other. Yeah.
Okay. Well, on the subject of listening
to each other, we're going to transition
into taking questions.
Um because I'm sure that many people in
the audience have many things they want
to ask and we'll only be able to pick
out a few. So forgive me.
How can psychedelics be used to treat
trauma in people suffering from
addiction without creating the risk of a
new dependency?
Um so addictions are very highly related
to trauma.
>> Yeah. I like to say that if I little pen
with heroin here, I say, "Hey guys, I
have a little pen of heroin. come from
America, so you have nothing to worry
about. And if you want some heroin, come
over here. Most of you would say, "This
guy's crazy." But there's probably going
to be two or three people in this room
who feel so terrible that you will say,
"I'll take some heroin because I cannot
stand the way I feel." So people take
drugs not in order to part their family
or ruin their family's finances. They
take drugs because they cannot stand the
way they feel. And so drugs is a way of
healing themselves or at least
functioning well. And so when you deal
with drug addiction, you need to really
work with what was so unbearable that
made it. And so you deal with a
troubling issue. But now when when you
don't take drugs, you go into withdrawal
and you your old trauma comes back even
more. And so withdrawal in and of itself
will break will break big break your
demons. And so the question is can we
hold people long enough to feel their
demons and to help them to move through
it and it takes time and it takes a very
safe environment. Um again we are
exploring psychedelics where the pain
often times comes up but after a while
you start feeling safe and so that's
true for treating addictions also.
Addictions are almost invariably start
with trauma. And then you need to help
both the withdrawal symptoms, but also
what was unbearable about your internal
world and how can you learn to own the
sensations in your body and tolerate the
sensations you have in your body.
So really the organism needs to be taken
care of.
>> It's fascinating.
Um,
if a child has PTSD but is too young for
EMDR,
can they overcome PTSD with play therapy
or will they need EMDR when they're
older? Now, EMDR is one nice technique.
I don't think anybody is too young to do
EMDR actually. I think and a kid doesn't
just get PTSD, you know, very at the
core is a study here in London by Anna
Freud with a generation that grew up
under these Nazi bombers from 1942 to
1945 here in London. And they discovered
that the kids who were sent off to the
countryside did very poorly. But the
kids who stayed in London did okay
because kids take their cues from their
parents. And kids can become very
scared. But as long as my mom or dad are
there and I feel loved by them, I'm
going to be okay. And so kids who even
under the most adverse circumstances if
they feel like somebody is looking after
them and has their is taking care of
them they won't get traumatized by and
large. So if a kid has PTSD, you wonder
what is going on in the environment that
this kid is not comforted only by their
parents presence and that indeed that
may happen but a play therapy would be
the first treatment of choice where the
kids really gets to play it out and can
see and feel what makes them feel
better. I would not start with EMDR with
kids. The kids are are filled with rich
fantasy lives and you use the fantasy
life to help them to script alternative
outcomes. Huh? Uh when you're
traumatized, everything always has the
same outcome. Somebody touches your
shoulder, that means you're going to get
raped.
Once you're better, somebody touches
your shoulder. Maybe somebody's happy to
see you. Maybe somebody's stumbling.
Maybe somebody tried to rape you. And
your mind is wide open. So you try to
open up this kid's mind to really feel a
whole bunch of different sensations and
really feel much more open to
experience. So I would not start with
EMDR. Yeah.
>> But you can do EMDR with very small
kids.
>> Here's one of your favorite questions.
Where do you think the next breakthrough
in treatment will come from?
>> Next breakthrough? God knows. I cannot
predict the future
but um a big breakthrough but we I see
breakthroughs all the time but the but
the very most compelling breakthrough
right now is psychedelics.
Uh and our research on psychedelics was
really had amazing results. Actually one
of our papers declared one of the test
most important scientific papers of the
year in overall science. a very big big
thing and and psychedelics people's mind
gets opened up. They may go into very
dark places but you don't get stuck and
psychedelics clearly help people to get
unstuck. And so I can give you an
example. I wrote a scientific paper
about it is that after three sessions of
MDMA XZ therapy with psychotherapy
uh the people who got therapy only
improved a little bit. The people who
got therapy plus MDMA
uh they had a dramatic change in their
self-compassion.
They they felt like oh I was such a
little kid. I did not know any better or
I loved my daddy and he did this to you
and I was paralyzed and I feel so bad
for this little kid and you really have
compassion for yourself. Usually people
have shame about it. I feel I was so
weak. I was so little. I was so stupid
and that becomes a part of your internal
self-perpetration.
You can really hate yourself have me so
vulnerable on psychedelics over and over
again. We see that people say that poor
kid what I went through. I was just a
kid. I did not know any better. If that
would happen to me today, I'd kick him
kick kick his ass and defend myself. But
back then, I couldn't. But it didn't end
there. after they really got to feel
like I was a beautiful little kid who
just people did this to me and I didn't
deserve this. The next thought they
often times have is and I feel so dead
bad for my father who used to beat me up
all the time because he never got to
appreciate that he had this beautiful
child me and got to feel the pleasure of
being the father of a beautiful child.
So he missed the boat also, but I got
treated. He didn't. That was a mortal
response. Pretty good, huh?
And just to come back to the question,
I've heard you say on occasion things
like, you know, 50 years time, people
will look back on my book and say, "What
was that nonsense about?"
>> Maybe
>> you're very humble about the possibility
of being swept away by advances. You
just don't know where they're coming
from.
>> Absolutely. You know, we are we live in
the culture we live in and you know like
like I'm a big fan of Darwin. Darwin
published his paper on a book on the
emotional expression of animals men that
he shows photography to to show people's
expressions. Today you would do the most
sophisticated neuroiming scan or a
genetic analysis. We have a different uh
tools. We have different ways of
measuring things. And today we think
those pictures are stupid. I don't think
they are actually but but we we have
moved and we see the world in different
way. What I also see is that people
discover new things
like neuro feedback let's say but they
lose old things. For the last 100 years
the best treatment that people knew for
trauma was hypnosis.
In the US nobody does hypnosis anymore.
So we have lost an important therapeutic
tool because we want something new. So
there's there's many different options
and oftent we lose old options. Yeah.
Well, speaking of that, we have another
question which is since publishing the
body keeps a score, what new research
has surprised you the most about trauma
and the body?
>> What new research has surprised me most?
Certainly our psychedelic research has
oh the the the brain circuitry stuff
>> brain circuitry
>> the brain circuitry
>> and how we started off looking at
specific brain areas and now we're
thinking about what part of the brain is
working together with other parts of the
brain and people have identified three
networks one network is the salience
network and it tells you how your mind
automatically interprets something as
being dangerous or safe. And so let's
say it's not happening. Yeah, somebody
just did it. Often times somebody coughs
when they say this. You all heard it,
but it went into your brain and your
sisters network said that's completely
irrelevant. So you ignored it. But if
the person who molested you was
coughing, you might may now sit here and
hear somebody cough and you go like
every time that person coughs like that.
So you're saying this network is off and
that that faces the challenge is how can
we change this neural circuitry so that
actually you can hear the same thing but
you go like oh there's somebody coughing
so we have found different states of
being including the thing I talked about
earlier about the default note network
was very important finding is that many
time people when there is no trauma they
don't feel anything but they feel alive
when they are hurt or in danger. I saw
this very clearly. I've worked closely
with a journalist advanced journalism
program at Harvard, the Neiman
Foundation, and we'd get mid-career
journalists from who had been in
Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Congo and
Libya. And they were terrific war
correspondents and they come back to
Cambridge, Mass, which is almost as nice
as Cambridge, England. And they fell
apart because their brains were not
capable of dealing with quiet and with
peacefulness.
And so these are very important
discoveries in that. And so the focus
now becomes how can I help a person
whose brain has been wired for danger to
learn to be calm and safe. And we
actually have some methods of doing
that. Neuro feedback being one of them.
Psychedelics being another one. And
there's probably other ones as well.
>> Yeah.
>> That's exciting. Um kind of going down
that theme a bit further. The question
is, how do you navigate the tension
between evidence-based protocols and the
more body-based experimental practices
that don't yet have the same research
base? That is the purpose of our
foundation
>> of which he is a board member. Um, TRF,
the Travel Research Foundation, because
I've been really impressed because I'm a
researcher. I can get money to study
project but I couldn't get money to
study
neuro feedback. I got some money to
study theater very difficult but when I
study want to study tango dancing and
get funded by the National Institute of
Health there's no way they're going to
give me money for that. Yeah. So our
foundation is focused on creating more
evidence-based treatments. So we look
out for programs that look really good
and we say we're going to help you to
study it. We're going to look you up
with some some researchers. So have a
new evidence base for that particular
treatment because as we talked about
earlier medicine is stuck in chemical
models. You can get money to study
chemistry. You cannot study u singing
for drama.
And so if we say like we're involved in
a beautiful theater program called
Shakespeare in the courts as a
Shakespeare program for uh juvenile
delinquents and you may not think about
America as a civilized country but I
live in a very small little very
civilized place and when you're a
juvenile delinquent in my little country
and you break into a home you steal a
car you have a 50 chance% chance that
the judge will condemn you to become a
Shakespearean actor. Not bad. And so
these kids start doing theater. They
have never stood up straight. They've
never actually shown anybody because
they're always ashamed and frightened.
And they learn how to live in their
bodies and they learn how to interact
with people and they have an experience
they've never had of speaking their
mind, speaking a role, being a powerful
king, being a nasty person. And that's
what it feels like and they feel in
their body. So we're funding that
program to find out how effective it is
for the treatment of trauma. NIH would
never give us money for that. Yeah.
Great.
Change tax slightly. With the current
global conflicts, what are your thoughts
on how this exposure to violence will
affect today's children in the present
and later in their lives?
Boy, that's a very painful question.
Actually, I had a my son
fell in love with an Irish girl and she
said, "I want to get married because I
want to get a visa to stay in America."
So, he married her and when he got
married, he says, "Dad, I'm not married.
I'm married for the visa." But slowly,
he fell in love with her and they moved
to Ireland. My grandchildren live in
Ireland and boy am I grateful that my
grandchildren live in Ireland because if
they live in the US right now they would
be exposed to all this craziness from
our government but luckily they're
sequestered away from it and it will be
some years before they discover how
crazy the world is. Uh and so creating
very safe environments for your kids is
terribly important and hopefully you
still do that here. Yeah. Yeah.
Okay, I'm going to finish up with a
pretty straightforward question which
you can give a long or short answer to,
but if you could change just one thing
in mainstream healthc care's approach to
trauma, what would it be?
That's a 50
million question, isn't it? Um,
why one thing?
One thing
I think I wrote a book that made one big
difference. Um
I would introduce
action
ethnicity
movement. I would ask
let me just fantasize that if people go
to the doctor they actually help that
doctor to take care of other patients
>> to help their doctor take care of other
patient
>> help other patients so they can actually
feel that they can make a difference in
other people's lives.
>> Yeah. But that's here's an example of to
actively engage in your life and to not
passively wait for somebody to fix you,
>> but actually have to contribute
something in order to get something
back.
Just a fantasy.
So I mean in a way the the theme of the
evening is kind of expansion and
connection, collaboration,
movement, action
and and we pulled ourselves away from
the kind of narrow silos of healthcare,
psychotherapy, modalities.
>> That's not science. That is the that's
not the science of healthcare. as the
insurance-driven
>> right
>> institutional stuff. There's no science.
>> Yeah.
>> You are I mean you're advocating
>> for the humanity.
>> Yeah.
>> Of treatment to emerge for people to
collect and to help each other.
>> We are also learning a good amount how
the brain functions.
>> Yeah. And we really learning that your
sensory experience is the core of your
motivation and your aliveness. And so
really focusing on your sensations and
working with your sensations as you
move, as you sing, as you dance, as you
move your body, as I talk to you, and to
really feel what it feels like to be
with you and feel the vitality of my
organism with you is terribly important.
Yeah. Yeah. And and you are enacting the
cure you advocate. You come here to
speak to thousands of people. You bring
your body. You bring your instrument.
And you share to some degree to did he
or did he not have
>> I call what we did here preaching. And
we in a Methodist church so it makes
sense that I'm preaching. But if I
really did what I wanted to do, I would
have got you up on your feet and we
would sang together.
>> Well, that's a promise for next time.
Okay, ladies and gentlemen, Dr. Vessel
Vand.
Heat. Heat.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The discussion emphasizes a shift in trauma treatment from merely discussing past trauma to fostering a sense of fulfillment, pleasure, and agency in the present. Key breakthroughs include psychedelics, particularly MDMA-assisted psychotherapy, which has shown remarkable results in developing self-compassion and breaking cycles of shame. The conversation also explores the intricate relationship between trauma and addiction, noting that drugs are often used to cope with unbearable feelings. For children with PTSD, the importance of a secure parental presence and the efficacy of play therapy over EMDR are highlighted, aiming to broaden their perception of outcomes. New research focuses on brain circuitry, specifically the salience network and default mode network, to help rewire brains for calm and safety. The role of foundations like TRF is crucial in funding research for body-based and experiential therapies (e.g., theatre, dance) often overlooked by traditional medical funding. The speakers advocate for a more human-centered, active, and connected approach to healthcare, where sensory experience and mutual contribution are central to healing.
Videos recently processed by our community