HomeVideos

Why Right-Wing Populism Is Taking Off Around the World | The Ezra Klein Show Clips

Now Playing

Why Right-Wing Populism Is Taking Off Around the World | The Ezra Klein Show Clips

Transcript

161 segments

0:00

I read a statistic in the Wall Street

0:02

Journal over the weekend that kind of

0:05

made me want to take out a pitchfork.

0:07

So, the net worth held by the top.1% of

0:10

households in the US reached 23.3

0:14

trillion in the second quarter this year

0:17

from 10.7 trillion a decade earlier. So

0:20

from 20 from 10.7 to 23.3 in one decade.

0:24

That's according to the Federal Reserve

0:25

Bank of St. Louis. the amount held by

0:28

the entire bottom 50% increased to $4.2

0:32

trillion from 900 billion over that

0:35

period.

0:37

So

0:39

let me just do this. What do you think

0:40

when you hear that? So I think that we

0:44

have massive increasing inequality.

0:47

We have it in at a scale that most

0:50

people are not even able to comprehend

0:52

because it's really what you're talking

0:54

about is not the real story is not about

0:56

the 0.1%. It's not even about the 01%.

1:00

It's about the 0.001%.

1:02

In other words, we have essentially the

1:04

same tax policy for somebody who makes a

1:07

lawyer in New York who's making3 or$4

1:09

million a year and somebody a hedge fund

1:12

manager or a tech billionaire who's

1:14

making a billion dollars a year. And we

1:17

have the same tax policy, in fact, a

1:19

favorable tax policy for the guy who's

1:22

worth 25 billion and makes nothing in

1:24

income every year, makes it all through,

1:27

you know, capital gains or borrowing

1:30

against his stock portfolio. In other

1:31

words, we have an accumulation of wealth

1:34

on the high end that is extraordinary. I

1:37

mean, and and it's and it's it's

1:39

something that we have no public policy

1:41

knows what to do about. As I say, you're

1:43

taxing the guy who makes $4 million and

1:46

$400 million the same. But when [snorts]

1:49

you ask about this new politics, so

1:52

let's go to a place like Sweden. Sweden

1:55

does not have a huge income inequality

1:57

problem. They've actually done a very

1:59

good job. They have very high taxes.

2:01

They have lots of redistribution. Sweden

2:03

has a major upsurge of right-wing

2:06

populism that is fundamentally driven by

2:09

culture and immigration. You say maybe

2:11

it's that we should have pro protected

2:13

our manufacturing sector better. Germany

2:16

protected its manufacturing sector. The

2:18

second largest party in Germany now is a

2:20

right-wing populist party motivated

2:22

largely by cultural issues. Maybe we

2:25

should have um coddled people with a

2:28

bigger safety net. Nobody coddles people

2:30

with a bigger safety net than France.

2:33

France's percentage the government the

2:35

state percentage of you know uh GDP is I

2:38

I forget it's like 58 55 58% highest in

2:42

the in the in the western world and you

2:45

know right now Marine Leend if the

2:48

election were held tomorrow she'd be the

2:50

next president of France. So my point is

2:53

the the income you know these income

2:55

inequalities and dysfunctions obviously

2:58

cause enormous anxiety, anger whatever

3:02

but the the age we are living in. I

3:05

would argue these things get channeled

3:08

through cultural um discontents and you

3:12

see that with immigration being the

3:14

issue that that got Trump elected and

3:16

then reelected and Trump is very smart

3:19

politically. He knows what works. A and

3:21

that tells you that there's something

3:24

going on here that we're not capturing.

3:26

An entirely materialist conception of

3:28

politics, I think, is not meeting the

3:31

moment. Well, if if I were to take this

3:33

from the more materialist left, uh I

3:35

want to spend one more moment on this. I

3:37

think what they would say is

3:40

it's that the left parties aren't

3:43

meeting the moment. So, so you I always

3:45

find it strange how much symmetry you

3:48

have in political trends across very

3:51

different countries, right? As you say,

3:53

many of those countries have they have

3:54

different tax structures, they have

3:56

different economic structures, but one

3:57

thing they all have in common is that

4:00

the left in those countries has become a

4:03

much more highly educated and usually

4:07

richer coalition. uh Petti uh with

4:10

co-authors has done a lot of work on

4:11

this talking about the Brahman left that

4:13

has sort of emerged in in wealthy

4:15

countries all across the world and and

4:17

the argument you'll hear I don't myself

4:20

totally buy it but I would like to hear

4:22

your your thinking on it is that as

4:24

these parties have become not the

4:28

working-class parties of the past but

4:30

the educated parties of the present the

4:34

highly educated parties of the present

4:36

that they became became what's called

4:39

neoliberal that they gave up on the old

4:41

class struggle and that as such the the

4:44

sort of choice on economics muddled and

4:46

that led to the class realignment that

4:48

you're talking about where you know

4:50

instead of the Democratic party winning

4:52

the working class and Republican party

4:53

winning the the rich Donald Trump won

4:56

you know most voters making less than

4:58

$50,000 a year. uh do you buy that that

5:02

it's simply the the abandonment of you

5:05

know working-class populism uh among the

5:08

parties of the left? No. And I'll tell

5:10

you why. Because you if and it really

5:12

helps to have a comparative perspective

5:14

and because so much of the time I'm

5:16

thinking about what's going on in other

5:18

countries. So look at France. France had

5:22

no neoliberal revolution. France never

5:25

had a Margaret Thatcher, never had a

5:27

Ronald Reagan. The person who was who

5:29

was president of France in that period

5:31

was Francois Mitron, a socialist. France

5:35

has never had any of the neoliberal

5:37

revolution. And yet it has perhaps the

5:40

strongest of the right-wing populist

5:42

movements. And so I think I I think it

5:45

doesn't fundamentally get, as I said,

5:47

the moment we're in. But I do think that

5:49

there's a very important point it makes,

5:51

and I try to make this in the book.

5:53

There is a so if the culture is one

5:55

piece of this class is another and this

5:58

is something we in in America find

6:00

difficult to talk about but it is as you

6:02

say the the left has become largely

6:05

populated by kind of an elite

6:06

professional class which is the new kind

6:09

of uh managerial elite technocratic

6:12

meritocratic elite and that reality has

6:17

distanced it from the working class. But

6:20

why? because of culture because they no

6:24

longer speak or understand or or

6:27

articulate the values of that working

6:30

class on cultural issues. As you know,

6:33

Ezra, the polling is very clear. The

6:35

public is very content with the

6:37

Democratic Party's positions on economic

6:39

issues. The place where they where

6:42

particularly the working class disagrees

6:44

with the Democratic party is not on its

6:46

economic policies.

Interactive Summary

The video discusses the significant increase in wealth inequality in the US, where the net worth of the top 0.1% has more than doubled in a decade, while the bottom 50% has seen a much smaller increase. This growing gap is attributed to tax policies that disproportionately favor the extremely wealthy. The discussion then broadens to examine how similar trends of rising inequality and the emergence of right-wing populism are observed in other Western countries like Sweden, Germany, and France. Despite differing economic and tax structures, these countries share a common challenge: the left has become more educated and wealthier, distancing itself from the working class. This shift is not solely due to economic policies but is also influenced by cultural issues and a perceived disconnect in values between the educated elite and the working class, which populist movements have effectively capitalized on.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts