HomeVideos

What If? Napoleon

Now Playing

What If? Napoleon

Transcript

454 segments

0:00

In 1805, Napoleon Bonapart had a bold

0:03

idea to conquer the British before they

0:06

could interfere with his plans for the

0:08

continent. On the northern coast of

0:10

France at Bologn, he gathered nearly

0:13

150,000 men and 7,000 horses for an

0:17

invasion of Great Britain. Thousands of

0:19

specially built flat bottom barges were

0:21

assembled in the harbor, ready to carry

0:23

French troops across the channel. His

0:25

admirals hated the design and warned

0:28

they would sink in the rough seas. But

0:30

Napoleon overruled them, confident that

0:33

he could overwhelm their defenses.

0:36

The only obstacle was the Royal Navy. As

0:39

long as the British commanded the

0:40

channel, Napoleon's army remained

0:42

stranded. To open the way, a Franco

0:45

Spanish fleet under Admiral Pierre

0:47

Charla Vilnov had to break out of a

0:50

blockade in the Spanish port of Kadis,

0:53

join with reinforcements, and sweep the

0:56

British aside.

1:00

Before we continue, I'd like to thank

1:02

today's sponsor, Agent Opus. The first

1:05

AI video agent built specifically for

1:08

social media. Agent Opus can turn any

1:10

idea, a script, blog post, audio clip,

1:12

or even a headline into polished,

1:14

sharable content. And it's designed to

1:16

help creators boost their output, reach

1:18

new audiences, and bring their ideas to

1:21

life faster than ever. Just describe

1:23

what you want to cover, the tone or

1:24

style you're aiming for, and include any

1:26

background details like your topic,

1:28

audience, or key creative notes. You can

1:31

also upload your own assets or reference

1:33

materials. From there, Agent Opus can do

1:36

the rest, including craft a script,

1:37

source visuals, build storyboards, and

1:40

even produce finished content. Right

1:42

now, Agent Opus is in beta with a full

1:44

public launch on December 1st. To

1:46

celebrate, they're hosting a human

1:48

versus AI live event on December 2nd,

1:50

where two professional editors will go

1:52

head-to-head against two creators using

1:54

Agent Opus. Each team will have 60

1:56

minutes to produce a complete video

1:58

using the same parameters. Whether the

2:00

humans or AI come out on top, one thing

2:02

is certain. Agent Opus isn't replacing

2:05

human creativity. It enhances it and

2:07

helps it shine. To learn more about

2:09

Agent Opus, the human versus AI

2:11

challenge, or to sign up when it

2:12

launches, click on the link in the

2:14

description below.

2:17

The upcoming confrontation off Cape

2:19

Trafalgar would come to be one of

2:21

France's greatest naval defeats, ending

2:24

hopes of an invasion across the channel.

2:28

But what if the battle had gone the

2:29

other way?

2:39

Privately, Napoleon was unsure about the

2:42

invasion. But rather than confusing the

2:44

Admiral T by changing orders and

2:46

revising new plans, he stuck to his

2:48

guns. Instead of scattering his fleets

2:51

across the Atlantic, Napoleon made sure

2:53

they were coordinated against the main

2:55

British threat. In Kadis, Vilnov broke

2:58

free of the blockade before the British

3:00

were able to starve him into submission.

3:02

Admiral Horatio Nelson was able to

3:04

confront the combined Franco Spanish

3:06

fleet off Cape Trfalgar.

3:09

The British columns attempted to break

3:11

up Vilnov's formation and finish off the

3:14

broken sections one by one. But Vilnov

3:16

had prepared for this tactic. Instead of

3:19

barging into a disorganized battle line,

3:21

the British were instead met by superior

3:23

numbers and a disciplined wall of

3:25

broadsides that tore into their columns.

3:28

Despite better training and drilling,

3:30

the Royal Navy's gamble was too much to

3:32

pull off. The HMS victory was left

3:35

battered, while Admiral Nelson himself

3:37

was struck down, leaving Admiral Cutbert

3:40

Collingwood to order a withdraw of his

3:42

remaining ships from the battle. As the

3:44

Royal Navy was left bloodied and

3:46

scattered, Vilnov was able to carry

3:48

enough ships north to secure the

3:50

channel. Napoleon seized the moment

3:54

at Bologn. The beating of drums signaled

3:57

the Arma Donglair to begin loading onto

4:00

the barges. However, the abominable

4:03

weather, which had been plaguing the

4:05

channel for months, had not let up. Only

4:08

a year earlier, Napoleon had personally

4:10

ordered a naval exercise in stormy

4:12

conditions against the pleas of his

4:14

admirals. The result was disastrous.

4:17

More than 20 guns sloops were flung

4:19

ashore, and over 2,000 men drowned as

4:22

waves tore their vessels apart. Every

4:24

man at Bologn knew the sea could be a

4:27

deadlier enemy than the British. Still,

4:30

the emperor was determined to cross the

4:32

channel, ordering over 2,000 vessels to

4:35

ferry men, horses, and cannon across the

4:38

narrow sea. The channel was rough, as

4:40

more than a dozen vessels were lost due

4:43

to waves, and harassment from British

4:45

ships desperate to defend their waters.

4:47

But with the French fleet holding the

4:49

line, the bulk of the French army

4:51

eventually landed. Veterans who had

4:53

marched in Egypt and Italy now set foot

4:56

on English soil. Britain's defenders

4:58

were thinly stretched with 116,000

5:01

regular troops spread across the whole

5:03

country. The other home guards consisted

5:05

of militia men, volunteers, and

5:08

temporary garrison troops known as the

5:10

fencables. Courageous though they were,

5:13

they could not match the professionalism

5:15

of France's battleh hardened army. More

5:17

importantly, these forces were scattered

5:19

across the country and weren't

5:21

concentrated against the French landings

5:23

where a beach head was secured on the

5:25

coast of Kent. Supply lines were soon

5:27

established and French columns pushed

5:29

inland. Panic spread throughout London

5:32

at the news of their approach. To

5:34

preserve the capital and avoid

5:35

destruction from French reprisals,

5:37

British ministers sued for peace. By

5:40

early 1806, Britain accepted a

5:42

humiliating treaty. France would

5:44

dominate the continent as the invasion

5:46

army would withdraw to deal with the

5:47

Austrians and Russians while Britain was

5:50

forced to recognize Napoleon's new

5:52

European order. The consequences were

5:55

immense. Britain had been the bank and

5:57

backbone of every coalition. Now its

6:00

subsidies dried up, leaving Austria and

6:03

Russia unable to rebuild for another

6:05

round. Prussia held back, wary of facing

6:08

France alone.

6:11

Crucially, Napoleon had no need for the

6:14

continental system since a blockade of

6:17

Britain was now unnecessary. That single

6:20

change spared Europe the ruinous

6:23

campaigns in Spain and Russia. Without

6:26

either front to drain his strength,

6:28

Napoleon was free to concentrate his

6:31

forces on the continent as once

6:33

subjugated powers like Austria and

6:36

Prussia conspired against French

6:38

dominance. For Britain, it would take

6:41

many years before they could rise up to

6:44

challenge the continent once again.

6:55

After the historical defeat at Trafalar

6:58

in 1805, Napoleon abandoned hopes of

7:01

invading Britain. Instead, he turned his

7:04

attention to the continent where French

7:07

armies smashed Austria at Osteritz,

7:09

humbled Prussia at Yenna, and forced

7:12

Europe into submission. By 1807, France

7:16

and Russia were the only dominant powers

7:18

left on the continent, but Britain

7:20

remained defiant. Its navy ruled the

7:22

seas and its gold financed new

7:25

coalitions. Unable to invade, Napoleon

7:28

sought to strangle Britain with the

7:30

continental system, closing Europe's

7:32

ports to British trade. The policy

7:35

weakened allies more than it hurt

7:36

Britain, breeding resentment. Russia,

7:39

whose economy depended heavily on

7:41

overseas commerce, suffered most of all.

7:44

By 1810, Zar Alexander I had reopened

7:47

his ports to British merchants. The

7:49

FrancoRussian Alliance collapsed.

7:52

Napoleon saw betrayal. If Russia defied

7:55

him, others might follow. To reassert

7:58

his authority, he gathered the Grand

8:00

Arma, the largest force Europe had ever

8:03

seen, and prepared to march east. Over

8:06

1812, more than half a million men

8:08

crossed the Neman River into Russia,

8:10

determined to force Zar Alexander back

8:13

into an alliance. Yet, the campaign was

8:15

less a clash of armies than a struggle

8:18

against distance itself.

8:21

Russia's vastness swallowed Napoleon's

8:23

columns. Roads were poor, villages

8:26

sparse, and the countryside stripped

8:28

bare ahead of him. The Grand Arma was

8:31

accustomed to feeding itself off of

8:34

conquered land, but found little to eat

8:37

as they marched further into the Russian

8:39

interior. Supply lines stretched across

8:42

hundreds of miles, and every step

8:45

forward made them more fragile.

8:48

Historically, the reckless advance into

8:50

Russia and burning of Moscow destroyed

8:54

the Grand Army. But what if Napoleon had

8:57

stopped short, dug in, and forced the

9:00

Russians to fight on his terms?

9:03

A relentless drive toward Moscow could

9:05

have stretched Napoleon's army to

9:07

breaking point. Well aware of King

9:10

Charles I 12th and his doomed

9:12

expedition, Napoleon decided instead to

9:15

halt his advance at the newly captured

9:18

city of Smolansk, which had long served

9:20

as a fortress on Russia's western

9:22

frontier. French logistics took

9:24

advantage of the summer conditions to

9:26

prepare for the coming winter,

9:28

strengthening the city's medieval walls,

9:30

stocking magazines, and supplying depots

9:33

through convoys coming back over the

9:35

Neman.

9:37

With the Russians wary of a direct

9:39

confrontation, Napoleon was

9:41

uncharacteristically content with

9:43

digging in over the winter. For the

9:45

Russian commander Mika Kudos, this was a

9:49

major problem. Instead of chasing

9:51

Barkley Datali's forces through a

9:53

scorched desert, the Grand Darm had

9:56

entrenched itself, forcing Barkley to

9:58

abandon his Fabian strategy. Since he

10:01

could no longer lure Napoleon deeper

10:03

into the interior, Kudazof, Barkley, and

10:06

the other generals faced the unnerving

10:08

reality of a massive, wellsupplied host

10:11

dug in on their doorstep. For months,

10:14

Napoleon's forces weathered the harsh

10:16

winter conditions, dealing with creeping

10:19

attrition and fending off skirmish

10:21

attacks from Russian probes until the

10:23

emperor's rising impatience could no

10:25

longer be contained. By March of 1813,

10:28

the winter thaw had barely begun when

10:30

the Grand Army resumed its campaign

10:32

toward Moscow.

10:34

When General Kudazoff's army gathered to

10:37

contest the approaches near Burudino,

10:39

the French were ready for them. Thanks

10:41

to his winter quarters at Smealansk,

10:44

Napoleon had preserved thousands of men

10:46

from severe attrition. As French columns

10:49

pressed forward with greater cohesion,

10:51

they struck with overwhelming force.

10:53

Napoleon then used the Imperial Guard to

10:56

charge in and break the enemy lines.

10:58

Russian commanders who had been undone

11:01

by their own scorched earth policies now

11:03

saw their army collapse in the field.

11:06

The road to Moscow lay open, but the

11:08

harsh campaign combined with the bloody

11:11

fighting at Bodino had shaken the

11:13

emperor. Rather than risk getting

11:15

trapped in the capital, Napoleon chose

11:17

to consolidate his strength, withdrawing

11:19

to his wells supplied bastions around

11:21

Smelinsk while the Russians dealt with

11:23

the consequences of their scorched

11:25

earth. With his main force shattered and

11:28

a French army entrenched to the west,

11:30

Zar Alexander sought terms. A treaty

11:33

signed at Smealinsk ended the campaign,

11:36

reducing Russia to neutrality, if not

11:38

outright submission, while the French

11:40

army stood undefeated. For both allies

11:43

and enemies, it seemed that the emperor

11:45

had now mastered nearly all of Eastern

11:47

Europe.

11:49

News of the Russian defeat meant that

11:52

Austria and Prussia hesitated to form a

11:55

six coalition. Without Russia, neither

11:59

dared to defect. Freed from the Eastern

12:02

front, Napoleon was able to turn his

12:04

full attention to Iberia, where he could

12:07

drive out the British expedition. With

12:10

Spain under his control, a stronger

12:13

French presence could focus on

12:15

suppressing the Spanish guerrillas that

12:17

remained. Britain would be left

12:20

isolated, stripped of its foothold on

12:22

the continent.

12:34

Historically, the catastrophe in Russia

12:36

in 1812 shattered Napoleon's Grand Arma.

12:40

It went from the most formidable army in

12:42

Europe to a mere shell, hollowed out by

12:44

hunger, disease, and cold. Few than a

12:47

quarter of its men returned home. The

12:49

aura of invincibility that had carried

12:51

Napoleon through a decade of victories

12:54

was gone. Across Europe, his enemies

12:56

sensed weakness. Prussia rose in revolt.

12:59

Austria abandoned neutrality. And with

13:01

Russia and Britain, they formed the

13:03

sixth coalition. By 1813, vast Allied

13:07

armies pressed into Germany, determined

13:10

to break French dominance. Napoleon

13:12

rallied fresh conscripts and fought

13:14

brilliantly, winning battles at Luden,

13:17

Boutin, and Dresden. Yet the strain on

13:20

his empire was immense, and his German

13:23

allies wavered. Bavaria and Vertonberg

13:26

feared invasion while Saxony was already

13:28

being pilferred by the Grand Army. Many

13:31

of the princes uplifted in 1806 through

13:34

Napoleon's Confederation of the Rine now

13:36

wondered if survival meant abandoning

13:39

him. In reality, those doubts proved

13:43

fatal. One by one, Napoleon's German

13:46

allies slipped away. And at Leipzig,

13:49

their betrayal sealed his fate. But what

13:52

if instead of defecting, the

13:54

Confederation of the Rine stood firm?

13:57

The Emperor's humiliation in Russia left

13:59

his allies in the Confederation more

14:02

doubtful of French power. But rather

14:04

than take his usual heavy-handed

14:06

approach, Napoleon instead listened to

14:09

the council of his advisers, who all

14:12

stressed the need to reassure the

14:14

Germans.

14:16

First, Bavaria was promised Austrian

14:18

tiroll alongside pledges of French

14:21

protection on its frontier. Verenberg

14:24

exhausted from its contributions in

14:26

Russia would be granted rights over its

14:29

Swayabian neighbors and respit from

14:31

French requisitions. Saxony was shielded

14:34

from the worst depradations of

14:36

Napoleon's army. While King Frederick

14:39

Augustus was promised a free hand in

14:41

Poland as well as greater autonomy

14:44

within the Confederation, Napoleon made

14:46

it clear that a French-led Confederation

14:48

of the Rine was not only the best

14:50

safeguard of their independence against

14:53

Austria or Prussian domination, but a

14:55

chance to secure land, power, and

14:57

greater security.

15:00

By October 1813, the Sixth Coalition had

15:04

amassed three great armies around

15:05

Napoleon in Germany. From the south came

15:08

the army of Bohemia under the prince of

15:11

Schwartzenberg. To the north advanced

15:13

field marshal Gbert Leberisht vonluker's

15:16

army of Slesia and from the northeast

15:19

moved the army of the north under crown

15:22

prince Bernodot of Sweden. Their plan

15:24

was simple. Converge on Leipzig and

15:27

crush France from three directions

15:29

counting on Napoleon's German satellites

15:31

to crack under pressure.

15:34

On October 16th, more than 257,000

15:38

men from Russia, Austria, Prussia, and

15:41

Sweden faced off against the Grand Army,

15:44

fielding barely half that number.

15:47

However, the French lines held firm

15:50

thanks to the presence of German allies

15:52

of the Confederation of the Rine. Near

15:55

the village of Wacau, Napoleon struck

15:58

first, concentrating over 160,000 men

16:01

and 600 guns into a massive hammer blow

16:04

against Schwarzenber's Austrians. French

16:07

columns advanced under a storm of cannon

16:10

fire while Saxon batteries rained shells

16:13

into the Prussian flanks. Despite the

16:15

threat of an incursion at the rear in

16:17

Lindenau, Marshall Naye core was kept

16:20

close to the wider formation and drove

16:22

straight into the coalition center. By

16:24

dusk, the army of Bohemia reeled back in

16:27

disorder.

16:31

To the north at Mukern, Prussian attacks

16:34

battered against French and Verdenberg

16:36

defenses, but were thrown back with

16:38

crippling losses. With Blucer checked

16:40

and Schwartzenberg reeling, Napoleon

16:43

prepared his final stroke. On the third

16:45

day, he unleashed the Imperial Guard at

16:48

last. Their bayonets tore into the

16:50

exhausted Allied lines and the coalition

16:53

host meant to crush him by sheer weight

16:56

dissolved into a route. The great battle

16:58

of nations had become Napoleon's

17:00

greatest triumph on German soil. The

17:03

consequences were immediate. Austria was

17:06

left humiliated and immediately sought

17:08

peace. Prussia was bled white and

17:10

returned to submission at the cost of

17:13

several punishing treaties. Russia found

17:15

its strength completely spent and could

17:18

not carry the war alone. Britain

17:20

remained defiant in Iberia and at sea,

17:23

but it was also isolated with no

17:25

continental allies left to subsidize.

17:28

Thanks to their loyalty, the

17:29

Confederation of the Rine emerged

17:31

stronger than before.

17:34

Napoleon now held the keys to Europe

17:36

once more. With the sixth coalition

17:38

eliminated, the emperor could turn his

17:40

attention to the Iberian Peninsula,

17:42

using his German allies to bolster the

17:45

weakened Grand Army and purge the

17:47

bleeding ulcer once and for all.

17:49

Wellington's army was forced back into

17:51

Portugal and Spain fell under tighter

17:53

French control. Guerilla resistance

17:56

lingered, but could no longer threaten

17:57

the survival of the empire.

18:00

By 1815, Napoleon's dynasty seemed

18:03

secure. His brothers and marshals sat on

18:06

thrones from Madrid to Naples, from the

18:08

Rine to Warsaw. The empire's borders

18:11

were quiet, its legitimacy unquestioned.

18:14

The field of Leipzig, which could have

18:16

easily been the tomb of French power,

18:18

became the site of Napoleon's resurgence

18:20

as the master of Europe.

18:27

While plausible, all three scenarios

18:30

depend on Napoleon reigning in his

18:32

ambitions, knowing when to withdraw,

18:35

giving his allies more freedom, and

18:37

consolidating power instead of chasing

18:39

new wars. But Napoleon's rule was built

18:42

on military glory. And both his finances

18:46

and reputation relied on constant

18:48

victories. Even with Trafalogar won,

18:51

Russia beaten or Leipzig reversed,

18:54

France would gain time, not certainty.

18:57

Lasting peace needed compromise, and

19:00

Napoleon never stopped pushing. In the

19:03

end, the empire might have lasted

19:05

longer, but whether it could have truly

19:07

come out as the victor remains to be

19:10

seen.

Interactive Summary

The video explores alternate historical scenarios for Napoleon's reign, focusing on three key turning points: the potential success of his invasion of Britain, a different approach to the Russian campaign, and the loyalty of his German allies at the Battle of Leipzig. It posits that had Napoleon succeeded in invading Britain, his dominance over Europe might have been solidified, avoiding costly campaigns in Spain and Russia. Alternatively, a more strategic approach in Russia, by entrenching rather than advancing, could have preserved his Grand Army and led to a negotiated peace. Finally, if Napoleon's German allies in the Confederation of the Rhine had remained loyal at the Battle of Leipzig, he might have secured a decisive victory, consolidating his power across Europe and potentially altering the course of history.

Suggested questions

5 ready-made prompts