Why Planning Better Habits Fails ADHD
395 segments
So, in a neurotypical brain, I think you
can let reward motivate you. The problem
is that in a neuroatypical brain, the
reward is usually insufficient to
overcome the difficulty of the task. One
of the most tricky things about ADHD is
that good habits are protective against
ADHD. But, the problem is that in order
to form a habit, you have to do
something really consistently. And if
you're someone with ADHD, doing things
consistently is really hard, right?
We're distracted, we have difficulty
focusing, we can't do the same thing day
after day after day. One of the most
ironic things is that habits will
protect you from a lot of the problems
of ADHD. The real tragic thing is that
even though the habit circuitry is
relatively intact in ADHD, it's
difficult to form good habits if you
have ADHD. So, if you've got ADHD,
you're distracted, it's difficult
for you to focus, it's difficult to stay
consistent, so you can never form a
habit. But, the really interesting thing
is once you form a habit, it will take
over even if you are distracted. Because
let's think about what a habit really
is. So, in my mind, if I've got ADHD and
I'm thinking about something else, and
my body is moving around doing random
things, what is it that's controlling
the random things that my body is doing?
Those are actually my habit That's my
habit circuitry. Right? So, the really
interesting thing if you look at what a
habit is, a habit is behavior that
happens on autopilot. A habit is
behavior that is programmed. A habit is
behavior that does not require your
attention, and in fact takes over when
your attention is somewhere else. And
this is exactly why they are so useful
for people with ADHD. Because imagine
for a moment that you did get
distracted, that you did wander around,
but there was an autopilot circuit in
your brain doing all of the right
things. Putting your keys where they
belong, putting your wallet away,
starting to do the dishes. Imagine you
could program your autopilot stuff when
you get distracted. That's what we're
going to talk about today. So, one of
the trickiest things as a psychiatrist
is trying to help my patients build good
habits. And this is where we have to
understand the neuroscience, okay? So,
ADHD is a disorder of two things. The
first is it's a disorder of our frontal
lobes, which allow us to plan and
execute tasks, allow us to restrain
impulses, retain focus, right? That's
That part of the brain is weak, the
frontal lobes. The frontal lobes are
basically the is the master controller
of the other parts of your brain.
They're like the orchestra conductor
that makes sure all the different parts
of your brain are working together. So,
in ADHD, this circuit is weaker or
impaired. So, your brain acts in a very
disorganized fashion. All your brain
parts are on kind of autopilot. The
second thing that's really different in
ADHD is your dopaminergic circuitry and
your reward circuitry. So, this is the
nucleus accumbens, the ventral tegmental
area. So, we see alterations in
dopaminergic sensitivity. This means
that some tasks give you a ton of
dopamine, like video games, pornography,
other random things when you're really
excited about something, right? You get
a bunch of dopamine from it for about a
day or so. And then your dopaminergic
circuits acclimatize very easily, so you
don't stay interested in things for
long. The other problem is that normal
tasks for a neurotypical brain will give
you a healthy amount of dopamine, but in
ADHD, it's hard to get that dopamine
flowing with boring stuff, regular
stuff, okay? Now, there's a completely
separate circuit of the brain, which is
the endocannabinoid habit circuitry.
This is the dorsal lateral striatum.
This is also sensory motor parts of the
brain, and this is actually
endocannabinoid receptors. So, this is
like a completely separate part of the
brain, okay? The habit circuitry is
relatively intact. So, what we want to
do if we've got ADHD is create a
situation where when our mind wanders,
when our dopaminergic circuitry is going
off track, our endocannabinoid circuitry
is doing exactly what it should be
doing. The tricky thing is that in order
to train the endocannabinoid circuitry,
in order to build a good habit, we need
consistency. And so, if you're having
trouble building consistent action, I
hope today's video will help, but I'd
also recommend you check out our
coaching program. We have a bunch of
neurodiverse ADHD coaches, and we've had
thousands of clients with ADHD. And
coaches are really good at helping you
solve for your individual problems so
that you can actually achieve what you
set out to. And so, we're going to talk
about how to build good habits in ADHD.
So, the problem here is that a lot of
the advice that we get about building
good habits doesn't work great with ADHD
because it assumes a neurotypical brain.
So, great example of this is, you know,
there's a book by James Clear called
Atomic Habits. It's an awesome
bestseller, and he basically breaks it
down really simply. He says, "There's a
cue, there's a craving, there's a
response, and there's a reward." The
problem is that for this cycle to be
intact, you need a relatively
neurotypical
dopaminergic circuitry. So, let's start
with a cue. So, he says, "Make something
in your environment that triggers you,
reminds you to do the task, right? Like,
create a sensory trigger." Makes perfect
sense. The problem is that if you've got
ADHD, that cue doesn't work nearly as
well because your brain is also picking
up all these other random cues. Like,
"Oh, yeah, like I see this I left a
to-do list on my fridge. Let me Let me
look at the to-do list. Oh, I see the
to-do list. I need to do something." And
then you start to walk, you turn around,
and then you look out the window and you
see something else that you need to do.
So, cues don't work quite as well. The
other problem with ADHD is that we tend
to be less responsive to the same cue
after time. So, if you're someone who
like leaves a reminder on your fridge
and it reminds you the first day,
reminds you the second day, but then on
the third day you filter it out, it
stops working. Second thing, once you
see the cue it triggers a craving, which
is great, except your craving circuitry,
which is dopaminergic, dopamine in the
nucleus accumbens, gives you cravings,
gives you pleasure, and gives you
behavioral reinforcement. That is also
altered. And so, when you see the cue on
the fridge, it may trigger a craving,
but there are lots of other cravings
that you have, and the the biggest
problem is actually in the response,
which is that the joy that you get from
completing a task may be down-regulated
significantly if you have ADHD. That's
the whole problem with the disease is
that, you know, finishing my to-do list
just doesn't give me the dopaminergic
reinforcement that like getting high
does. And so, this becomes a real
problem. So, this is great advice, and
if you can use it to build habits, like
I'm sure people with ADHD have benefited
from this, but my point is that it's
harder to apply. So, instead what we
need to do is figure out a strategy to
build habits that fits our neurotypical
brain, that actually doesn't rely on
dopamine, that actually really focuses
on the endocannabinoid circuit. So, how
do we do that? Step number one,
understand how long it takes to build a
habit. So, there's this stupid idea
floating around, I don't even know where
it came from, that habits take 21 days
to build. Research shows that habits
take anywhere between 18 and 254
days to build, with the median amount of
time being about 66 days, okay? So, step
number one that a lot of people with
ADHD mistake that they make is that they
try to build too many habits at the same
time. The habits that they try to build
are built are chosen out of desperation.
I need this to be habitual. I need this
to be habitual. I need to do this to be
habitual. And so, then what you do is
you're working on this and you're
working on this and you're working on I
know what I'm going to do. I've got
ADHD. I'm going to work on habit one on
Mondays, habit two on Tuesdays, habit
three on Wednesdays. You're building way
too many habits. So, what I recommend to
people that I work with is you pick one
habit, just one, and you're going to do
it for 66 days. You're going to do it
for two months. One habit every two
months. Now, if I say that to you, your
response is going to be, "Dr. K, that is
so long. That's not going to be enough.
I can't do a habit just every 66 days,
right? That's like that that feels
impossible. It feels like it's not going
to be enough." Exactly. So, your
response to this question has to do with
your frontal lobes, which do a very bad
job at projecting how things are going
to be in the future. And the
dopaminergic parts of your brain are not
going to like that. They're like, "Give
me a habit now. I want to have it in 21
days. I want a big habit. I want a good
habit."
Don't listen to those parts of your
brain. Pick a habit, stick with it for
66 days. You're only going to do one
thing for 66 days. "But what about all
the other parts of your life? Leave them
as the mess they are. Continue working
on I don't care. You're going to fix
this one thing." Second thing, what kind
of habit should you build? The key thing
is to make it very small. So, a good
example of what I would recommend is put
your keys away. Never put them down.
Really simple. So, if you've got ADHD,
what tends to happen is when we get
distracted, I've got keys and I'm going
to set them down somewhere. And this
seems like such a small thing. But when
I talk to my patients, what I find is
that a disproportionate amount of their
stress comes from trying to find their
keys. Like, once every week, I'm looking
for my keys. I'm late to a social event.
I'm late to work. I'm late to something
else. I'm stressed out about it. Now I'm
spending all of my energy looking for my
keys, so I'm cognitively exhausted by
the time I go to work. I'm 30 minutes
late and I'm already spent for the day.
Ruins my whole day. So, one of the key
things I found working with people with
ADHD is they grossly underestimate the
value of very small things. So, for two
two months, we've got one job, which is
to put your keys away. Never put them
down. Now, how do we make this more
possible, okay? What we want to do is
focus on a transition. So, the
transitions are the most dangerous parts
for people with ADHD. Once I get down
and I activate hyperfocus.exe, I'm doing
pretty good. But it's in between things
that I waste so much time. I they'll
even be really productive, right? Like I
got two hours of work done, then I got
home, and then two hours disappeared. I
don't know where they went. So, focus on
that habit building during a transition.
So, when I come into the house, I want
to, you know, put my keys away in the
same spot every single time. And the
cool thing about that is that if you
train that behavior, then your mind will
do it even if you're distracted. Okay?
So, you want to focus on the transition,
focus on doing one thing right during
the transition. Put your keys away. You
can pick whatever else it is. It doesn't
really matter, okay? Is you really want
to make it easy to do the task. So, what
I strongly recommend is that you
organize your environment to make it
easy to do the task. So, if we're
putting our keys away, we want to
designate a basket for our keys. And
there's a lot of good evidence that
shows that organizational tools will
buffer us against the problems of ADHD.
So, if I have something like a
bookshelf, if I have a particular place
to put things, that works incredibly
well. So, we want to organize the we
want to focus on the transition, which
is the when we are going to build the
habit, and we also want to focus on the
dimension of where. So, where is this
action kind of taking place? So, we can
create a basket for our keys, or it
could be something as simple as when I'm
transitioning from work to home, I'm
going to stop at the gym. So, try to
anchor the when and the where to build
this habit. And it's okay for the habit
to be small. Next thing that we want to
do, and this is really, really, really
important, is think about what will make
it hard to engage in the behavior. So,
in a neurotypical brain, I think you can
let reward motivate you. The problem is
that in a neuroatypical brain, the
reward is usually insufficient to
overcome the difficulty of the task. So,
when I'm working with patients with
ADHD, there's a lot of research that
shows this. There was one study that
tried to get 437 people to exercise
every week. And what they found is
focusing on building a complex plan
actually reduced the average amount of
exercise by 217 minutes. And planning
for obstacles, focusing on the
difficulty, what makes it hard to
exercise, actually increased exercise
time by 184 minutes. Okay, so this is
what's insane. Building a complex plan,
especially if you've got ADHD, is not
what leads to really good results.
Focusing on the things that will mess
you up, which is usually what happens,
right? That's the problem with ADHD, is
that you have the best of intentions,
but then you some problem gets in the
way. So, the next thing that we really
want to focus on is what is the
obstacle. Anticipate ahead of time what
the obstacle will be that will get in
the way. And so, if you put these things
together, hopefully what you can do is
build one habit. And if you can build
one habit over the course of 2 months,
it may not have a big impact. But here's
the other really, really, really big
thing. When I talk to my patients with
ADHD, what we tend to focus on is
building six habits per year. We're
going to take six things that you are
now programming your body to do
automatically. And that removes the load
of six problems from your life. Over the
course of 4 years, that's going to be 24
problems that you don't deal with. The
other little secret thing, just to give
you guys like your ventral tegmental
area, your dopaminergic stuff, and your
your frontal lobes that that want things
faster. What I'm going to tell you is
once you start implementing this method,
you will get better at the method. And
so, you will be able to handle larger
habits or implement habitual change more
frequently because you will develop the
habit of building habits. And once that
happens, the whole the whole ballgame
changes. So, if you guys want a
complimentary perspective to like
neuroscience and habit building,
strongly recommend you check out our
lecture on puer aeternus, which is a
Jungian sort of big picture approach to
understanding how ADHD shapes your life.
It's not really ADHD, but so many people
in the lecture were like, "Oh my god,
this describes me so well, and I used to
think I had ADHD. Now I realize I'm also
a puer." And if you want to know what
the hell that means, check out the link
in the description below. It'll take you
to our website. It's an awesome lecture.
People really love it. Check it out with
our free trial and see if it's for you.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
Loading summary...
Videos recently processed by our community