Today's Marketers Need A New Playbook: Advice From Gap, Duolingo, And Amex
780 segments
Okay, so I'm going to start with a bit
of audience participation because I know
people love this early in the morning.
I wanted to get a show of hands.
Who thinks brands are taking fewer risks
in marketing today than 10 years ago?
So maybe being too short-termist,
following the data. Going to stick your
hand in the air.
Okay, so I think we've got a pretty
confident bunch here actually. Okay.
Anyway, for for those of you who aren't
sure, this panel's going to be all about
the risks of playing it safe in
marketing. And I'm hoping you can leave
full of inspiration and with ideas about
how to improve the work that you're
doing in your own marketing departments.
Um so I wanted to start by asking each
of you about a time when you took a risk
in your marketing recently. And
Elizabeth, how about I start with you?
When have you taken a risk?
>> Uh sure. I think the thing that comes to
mind when you ask that question is when
we made a decision to start our in-house
agency on brand.
>> Okay.
>> And
let me tell you a little bit
about it. When I slipped into the seat
uh there were about six people in the in
the agency working on internal comms.
And I really felt like those
capabilities could be a significant
differentiator.
Um and being forward fast forward to
today and we've got 150-plus
team both based in New York and Atlanta.
And you ask why was it a risk? You know,
to sort of take it. If you think about
it, the type of people investment that
you have to make
to be committed to something like that.
And you're actually showcasing to your
internal clients
that you can do amazing quality work.
Uh that you're going to deliver on a
promise of quicker speed to market with
qua- cost efficiencies as well. And so
for me, it was convincing those internal
clients
uh that this was a differentiator in
terms of having those teams of brand
insiders
uh who could deliver on that promise
beam forward uh and we've done it I
think one campaign at a time, one client
at a time in terms of making a
difference.
>> And by clients you mean the C-suite?
>> Yes. Acro- acro- across the yeah across
the board. And I think for us it was
really a focus on leveling up the
standard of creative excellence uh while
delivering on that promise of speed to
market and and efficiency.
>> And I imagine that they have
relationships with your external
agencies too, right? And those that you
had to say goodbye to. Was was that part
of the persuasion?
>> Well, it absolutely is, but I think
we've come to uh
a formula that I think is the right one
for us in terms of a nice mix of those
external agencies as well as on brand.
And I think those perspectives both
internal and external are really
important uh to have great work.
>> Yeah, to keep you on your kind of
creative toes, I guess.
>> Exactly.
>> And Fabiola, how about yourself? A risk
that you took as a marketer recently?
>> Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Uh
well, we've been uh in this
re-invigoration journey and I don't know
if you heard about uh Cat's Eye Better
in Denim.
>> Yeah.
>> Uh we we took a big risk. You know, it's
it's only been
10 11 months since we launched it and it
feels like it was 5 years ago.
Um
we
we're leading we're this brand that is
an iconic American brand and when you
have so much to honor and to respect the
brand codes and the brand values and the
DNA of the brand, uh uh everything is at
risk, right? Because the brand has been
resting for a little bit before that.
And we needed to make sure that we get
the uh
the opportunity to reconnect with people
by Recruit Agency. That was very, very
intentional. And I think we did it. We
We broke the internet a little bit uh
for the first uh few days of the
campaign, but it was more importantly to
us to make sure that we have a point of
view, we draw we draw distinction, we
show authentically gap, and in a modern
way.
>> And what was the risk element of that?
What How were you feeling at the time?
Like the day before the launch?
>> I I think it was before then, when we
were shooting them. It's a lot of skin,
uh different genre,
uh new talent. They were not famous yet
when we actually uh showcased them. They
were out of the academy. It was betting
in talent, betting in our different
point of view. Uh when we were on set, I
I told my team, "I feel like this is
going to be the best one yet." Um
because it felt so so different, but it
was risk at everything. The The outfits,
the genre, the the talent, the the point
of view itself. And we launched a a a
2-minute um
content out there. So, it was everything
around every marketing lever were was a
risk.
>> Mhm. Mhm.
Um Now, Manu, I I wondered if you could
take us back to I'm guessing this would
have been 2022.
And you're with your CEO, I imagine. I'm
just creating this scene. So, you're
with your CEO, and you're like, "Right,
we're we're buying a Super Bowl ad.
Not one of the big ones. It's just going
to be 5 seconds. We're We're cool with
that.
But it's just going to feature our owl
farting out his own head.
>> Yes.
>> How did that go down?
>> Um, it was very weird.
>> [laughter]
>> Um,
but I think we proved that our content
first strategy over the years on social
media,
uh, really has paid off for the business
and we're able to build a brand that
really stood out. And what we said is,
okay, we don't want to spend crazy money
on Super Bowl. We're going to do a local
buy across different DMAs in the US.
And we could only afford 5 seconds. And
the idea was I could
>> is 5 seconds in a local buy?
>> We $700,000.
>> Okay. And so, by contrast, it would be
like what, eight eight million now is it
for 30 seconds in a national spot?
>> yeah. So, it was a we produced that
internally. And uh, yeah. I mean, we
said, okay, well, if we only have 5
seconds, how can we make those 5 seconds
as impactful as we can?
And because we know we're very good at
creating content for social media, we
take that same approach brought the owl
to TV to uh, fart his own face and say,
"Do your Duolingo."
>> Was that your idea? Was it like do you
workshop a fart?
>> Yeah, yeah, we did. We actually had
someone practicing farting with his
armpit for a week to actually get the
sound right.
Um, and then that's how we actually came
up with the sound.
>> And is is he really good at it now, this
person?
>> at it.
>> He brings it out at all the parties.
>> It's his trademark sound now.
>> Um,
changing gear a little bit. Um, we're
talking about risks here. Um,
and I wonder what goes into scenario
planning nowadays as a marketer. Like
you you don't need me to tell you that
we're living in very volatile times,
things are changing, you've got the
speed of AI, you have economic
uncertainty.
What does scenario planning kind of look
like at each of your brands right now?
Um, Fabiola, how about if I kind of
start with you cuz I guess
in retail, too, like you're constantly
watching things changing across the
seasons. Do you have Is it like an A
plan or a B plan or a C plan or a D plan
or an E plan? Like, how does it work?
>> In product, uh, we do. In marketing, we
don't. It's just that we have plan A,
plan A A, and that's it. So, it's, um,
we need to make sure that I think in the
media buy, we do.
Uh, on the creative side, we don't. We
We want to be bold. We have a point of
view. If it doesn't work, if the
audience is not voting for us, we will
learn from it, and we will apply it for
the next production, next campaign, next
initiative, next collaboration.
But, um, that's who we are. So, we do a
lot of,
uh,
creative planning, but the scenarios is
always one scenario that we go and we go
to Verona.
>> Is that unusual amongst the the peer
set, Elizabeth? Is that I mean, or or is
that becoming more of the way?
>> So, when I think about, uh, our plans
for the year, the customer's at the
center of it. Uh, and if needs are
changing, then we're going to adapt, uh,
to those changes. But, at the center,
our customer's passions, uh, are ones
that you would imagine from a dining,
from a travel, from a music, from an
entertainment perspective. And we're
going to find where they are, um, in
those channels, in those high-intention
environments.
Um, and when you focus on the customer,
the the outcomes, uh, are usually the
the right ones, uh, at the end of the
day.
>> But, I guess cuz I'm thinking you've put
experiences at the heart of your
strategy, right?
>> That's absolutely
>> peop- things that people can feel and
see.
Um,
but, you know, those can change. A a
weather event can can change things.
>> You're absolutely right, but you know,
sort of at the core we have a playbook.
It's a a consistent playbook uh not only
in terms of, you know, that experience,
but we're thinking about the pain points
that a customer may have. So, a fast
entry into an arena as an example, uh
access to those tickets that you can't
get,
uh or, you know, discounts uh from a
concession perspective. That end-to-end
journey, you know, we also think about
the customer traveling there or the
dining experience that they want. So, I
think that's what's unique and
differentiated for us, the ability to
kind of think about that end-to-end
journey. As well as we're thinking about
journeys
uh you know, in real life, but also on
the couch as well. And both of those are
important um at you know, as we plan
things.
>> And at Duolingo you're quite kind of
reactive to social trends. You're I
mean, you're you're creating some
yourself, but you're also kind of diving
in, getting sort of salty in the
comments and things.
Is that like a a planned thing? Is that
trusting your team? Like, how does that
work?
>> I I mean, that's the that's the DNA of
the the company. You know, our business
is is a retention business, right? So,
for us it's about ensuring that people
come across our brand every day
regardless of of the platform,
regardless of the channel. And um that's
our goal. It's every day creating
something that people will care about,
that will motivate them to do that
lesson.
And uh we approach marketing the same
way that our product team approach uh
product, which is AB testing all the
time, launching new things,
understanding what works, reacting to
culture, seeing an opportunity, and
being very very very fast. And so, our
strategy is is more um
the planning of it is more the way we do
it, right? Versus big moments that are
um way ahead of us. It happens
sometimes, like Super Bowl for example
this year with Bad Bunny, that was an
opportunity for us. We We planned that
in advance, but the day-to-day is
extremely built around this AB testing
of everything, because channels change
so much, algorithms change so much. You
can't expect the same thing tomorrow as
it was yesterday. So, you always have to
experiment and iterate.
>> And I mean, with those algorithms, I
mean, I think a lot of people in this
room will probably agree that like the
the era of the big kind of hero film
that you run for 3 months is sort of
largely over. Um
and a lot of the stuff now, um because
we're audiences are fragmented, it's
difficult to reach a big uh viewership
other than Superbowl and and some live
sports. So, you've got to do more things
to cut through.
And I'm wondering maybe perhaps with
Fabi, we can we can begin. How in such a
fragmented world, how does that shift as
a marketer how you plan that real cut
through? I mean, Cats Eye being like one
of your standout moments this this year.
Um
how do you make sure that that gets
through on all these different channels,
whether be it TikTok, be it um the live
experience, be it in store?
>> Absolutely, and thank you, Anna. I agree
with both of you. Consumer first, being
agile, and and really making sure you
develop content for the platform. Cats
Eye was developed for TikTok. Was
produced and designed and briefed for
TikTok content. So, our strongest piece
was a 60-second
>> would have been TV back in the day,
right?
>> Yeah, maybe. Yes, yes, for sure. Uh but
right now, we we did it for TikTok. And
that was the biggest performer at
TikTok. Young Miko, our spring campaign,
was designed for YouTube. So, because it
was a 3-minute piece of content, but
even that, we create 15s and 6s and 30s
and everything according to the
platform. And we try to bring something
new and some cuts and edits and
everything. we create content for our
retail uh uh experiences as well. And
And it is important to make sure that
because it's consumer first, it's
audience first, we actually produce and
edit the content according to the
platform. And in so far it has been
performing better when you think
platform first and you shoot it
accordingly to that. We shoot in
different formats because of where it's
going to live instead of shoot it,
produce it, and then adapt it.
>> So you won't just do a vertical video
and then sort of awkwardly try to cut it
kind of thing. You're thinking about how
that audience behaves.
>> shoot vertical. We shoot vertical and we
shoot a horizontal. So it takes you a
little longer in production, but we do
both. Yeah.
>> And Elizabeth, everyone's feed looks
different nowadays.
Um as I said as I said before there's
not this mass media moment. How How are
you in this in that time when everything
is so personalized? How do you make sure
that like the big idea is still cutting
through and the big memorable idea?
>> Yeah, no, you're you're absolutely
right. I mean
uh we all know this already, but the
average US consumer
uh
is on 11 video services.
Um and so that's uh you know, from a
linear a streaming a social perspective.
And I think uh what I am really proud of
in terms of our team is that they see
that media fragmentation not as a
negative, but as an opportunity to kind
of meet customers, you know, where where
they are. And I know you're asking about
that big idea. What I think has been so
special uh again and I'm going to focus
on the team is just the fact that we've
been able to use I think media and those
channels as a competitive
differentiator.
Um and the team
uh has has that deep kind of horizontal
expertise that's really important to get
that creative thread, that creative idea
that you're talking about moving through
all of those channels. But they also
have that sort of vertical knowledge to
make it special, to make it unique, to
make it sort of personalized. We work
hard at it and I see this as a
competitive advantage for us in terms of
the way we've taken a single
creative idea and sort of pulled it all
the way through.
>> There is a danger while it's important
to kind of create content with the
platform in mind. There can sometimes be
a danger in
optimizing too much for the algorithm.
One because the algorithm changes and
suddenly the thing that used to be
popular yesterday is not and you spent
six months shooting it and now you need
to rethink.
But also because sometimes you need to
kind of keep pushing the boundaries and
I know that's something that you've
spoken about before Manu and you're kind
of
rethinking that edgier side of your
brand.
>> Yes, I mean when it comes to our brand
we
became known for the very unhinged.
That's and and we have that opportunity
because our product is so wholesome and
what we offer to the world is free
education, right? So it's so genuine and
so altruistic that we can take more
risks in our marketing.
But I think there is also the risk of
you know, trying to always
go and chase the next big viral moment
by increasing the shock factor. And I
think we are
you know, we've become known for
you know, for people to expect the
unexpected from us. But when the
unexpected becomes too serialized or you
know, we have to reinvent basically our
playbook. And so
we're doing a lot of work in this
direction. I think what's interesting
with Duolingo is we're very well known
for short form content. So TikTok etc.
We're actually moving more towards
long-form content. So uh long-form
YouTube, etc. where we can actually
develop character stories differently.
So we launched for example our first um
Duolingo anime series in November. And
we saw this worked extremely well
because we were able to give a different
side of our brand. We were able to push
the character narratives in different
spaces. And we see, you know, retention
on long-form videos on YouTube versus
those short spikes that you see on
TikTok and other platforms. So it allows
us to like nurture engagement with an
audience and give them an opportunity to
come back to watch different uh episodes
at a time. Uh so we're really excited
about these type of strategies, right?
And that's very much about diversifying
how we reach people and how we appear in
content and the stories that we can tell
through those different mediums.
>> I think the thing I'm hearing from all
of you is you kind of constantly have to
adapt as a marketer. Um one thing I
wanted to get a status update on today
was was brand safety. I feel I've been
coming to Cannes for years and I
remember those years when the CMOs were
thumping their chests and they were
holding brands' feet to the fire about
content moderation and content
adjacency.
That's not happening as much anymore.
That that could be a a symbol that the
problem's gone away or it could be a
symbol that people are rethinking in the
marketing industry what brand safety
sort of means to them and how
comfortable they are with sometimes
letting the reins go a little bit. Um
Elizabeth, you work in a like very
highly regulated industry so you
probably have to think about this more
than anybody else on the panel.
>> Yeah.
>> Um how's your but how's your thinking
about brand safety sort of evolved over
the years?
>> Yeah, and I I think you're right that
there is an evolution if you think about
the beginning of, you know, sort of
digital advertising and how you had to
think about you know, media capabilities
and even the skill sets that your team
had um in order to to create and uh sort
of execute on work. But, you know, we're
a iconic 175-year plus brand. And so,
against the backdrop of all of that
changing, you have to think about how
you're going to keep that those
consistent global standards. Um and
that's what, you know, we're focused on.
And you have to think about it in terms
of the modernization of all the
platforms that you're sort of
referencing. And I think our jobs have
gotten easier with more automated
controls, um you know, sort of across uh
the board to make sure that you're level
set in terms of those consistent
standards. And then what we think about
are two things very clearly, just like
brand suitability in those environments.
And we're constantly looking for premium
high-attention environments where our
customers are. They have those passions
that I talked about in terms of dining
and travel, music, entertainment. We
need to be there, you know, for them in
all different environments, moments. And
And that's what we've worked hard on.
>> Are there any sort of new environments
that you're in now that perhaps you were
sort of observing but not ready to dip
your toe in a few years ago?
>> I think in particular when you look at
our sports ecosystem, the fact that we
are now partners with, you know, sort of
50 teams and leagues,
um
and you have to think about uh this
fandom in a very different way now. So,
when you ask that question, I think
about it from a creator perspective,
from an influencer perspective
perspective.
Uh and And that's where sort of we've
leaned in um because, you know, so many
of uh our Gen Z'ers are super fans, um
and they want that behind-the-scenes
story of sort of what's going on. And
we're trying to deliver it. You know, we
just launched um the story of my stong
with Olivia Rodrigo last week with her
honeybee story. and what's been so
special about that is that you get to
just see her here in that long-form
content that I think is actually much
more meaningful in terms of telling her
story and and our story together.
>> Because you're creating entertainment,
you're not just broadcasting an ad.
>> right.
>> And um Fabby, where where does kind of
brand safety sit on your kind of
marketing hierarchy of needs right now?
>> I think often as marketers, we we get
confused with brand safety and brand
codes. I think for us is is following
the brand codes is the most important
thing to be authentic, distinctive,
emotionally different,
and um brand safety for us is is not
what we're looking for. Is uh is more be
authentic to who you are, who we are,
but is is the era of disruption in the
universe and the field of play that you
own. And it is important for a brand
like that be democratic, be inclusive.
It's about self-expression.
If you use the term the terminology on
brand safety, you may go you you just
make
close yourself to opportunities. And and
and I think is this is the era where Gen
Z is asking you for more, millennials is
asking you for
uh anarchy are asking you for something
new and different, and Gen X are saying
take me back to the things that I love.
So, it's important to really make sure
that you don't get distracted to brand
safety versus following your DNA, your
brand codes.
>> Does does AI kind of add a new element
here? I'm seeing a lot of synthetic
content on my feeds right now. It's
easier than ever to kind of replicate
what brands are doing. Um you know,
Clippers, it's kind of hard to tell
what's real and what isn't and who's
behind um a certain piece of content.
Does that kind of factor in and how
you're thinking Manu at Duolingo and
this this kind of this new AI era and
what that means for how your brand show
up?
>> Mhm, not really. I think for us, you
know, back to your point around
authenticity and not giving people what
they expect from us, you know, our our
tone, our sense of humor. Um to me is
what makes the content genuine. And so
um you know,
when they look at content, they know
what it's what is coming from Duolingo.
They understand the the craft that goes
into this and um and you know, we have
very talented animators and illustrators
in the company and they create content
with us all the time. So we really try
to bring that craft as a differentiator.
That's why we you know, we we really
focus on on that to build our brand. Um
but I think ultimately the authenticity
of our content, people knowing our
brand, knowing our our sense of humor is
what matters the most for people to see
when a piece of content is genuine
versus parts of this ecosystem of you
know, AI generated content everywhere.
>> We've only got a couple of minutes left.
So I wanted to shift gears again. I
wanted to talk about what hiring looks
like for CMOs in 2026.
Are you hiring for kind of new types of
skills, new types of people than you
were say five years ago? Perhaps I'll
start with you Fabio. I'm kind of
interested in what you're looking for
right now in building your marketing
department.
>> When you're talking about our internal
hiring?
>> Internal hires, yeah.
>> I always said that you know, it sounds
like a an old way to recruit, but it's
uh hungry, passionate, uh curious, and
love the brand. I think is uh if you
don't
if you don't have an affinity to the the
that you're going to be working with,
Like, why are you Why are you
uh actually applying? And then it sounds
very uh I would say basic, but it it
hasn't changed for me. It's just with
the new generations, you really need to
spark curiosity, but brand affinity is
important because they don't last in
their jobs so long. So, if they love the
brand, if they love what they do, if
they're really eager to be part of it
because they love what they seen about
your brand, and whether it's content
because it's marketing, whether it's
business, product, retail, they have to
love the brand and feel affinity.
>> The iOS creating kind of a lot of angst
about say early career marketers. Um
does Again, does that factor in,
Elizabeth, when you're thinking about
and also internal training, too, right?
>> We're very [clears throat] focused on
uh just kind of democratizing those
capabilities and that learning path that
you're talking about and been very
focused on understanding those
capabilities, but I think even more
importantly than that is just to be able
to lead the change. And so, when you ask
about what are the you know, the
profiles
um or skill sets of the marketer of the
future, I think a lot of this is going
to be around the ability to be a keen
change agent and and lead others through
this. And in addition, I think
particularly for a brand like American
Express, I'm really looking for that
really high standard of creativity. I
think that's what's going to
differentiate us. I mean, we're all
going to have access to the same
capabilities at you know, sort of at the
end of the day. So, for me, it's that
high standard of creative excellence,
um a great mixture of sort of generalist
and specialist, you know, to sort of uh
help us through, and and those that are
curious. You mentioned before,
um those change agents. I think that's
going to be incredibly important and to
make sure that uh you are
uh showcasing use cases, training, uh
learning from each other, and creating
that strong engaged community.
>> Absolutely. Um
to end, I want to do a very quick uh
quick-fire rounds. Um, so I'm going to
run down the line.
Um, two questions. So, first question,
what's one trend the CMO community needs
to be talking less about at Cannes?
Start with you, Manu.
>> AI.
>> [laughter]
>> You beat me.
Um, I I agree.
>> You can say the same thing.
>> I agree, AI.
>> I'm not going to do the one word. I my
when you ask me that question, I just
want to make sure that we're thinking
about marketing plans not as
distribution plans. It's about that sort
of, you know, single creative idea uh
that can wow the customer. So, that's
where you need to lean in.
>> Okay, and one one trend that we need to
be talking more about.
>> Um
one trend. Oh my god, you got me at
>> What should I be reporting on? What
should I be digging into?
>> Um, I think uh being um
being more um agile. I think is agility
in marketing is so important these days
to really make sure that you pivot. You
you talked a little bit about it. Um,
being agile in marketing and especially
at the higher level, I think sometimes
we forget, we become bureaucratic. Uh,
we have to make decisions fast, and it's
not necessarily a trend, but it's
something that we need to remember. How
do you empower and enable your younger
teams by really following the the
strategy, the playbook, the things that
we need to do, and making sure that we
become agile marketers because our
audiences, our fandoms, our brand
lovers, they demand that they the
sagility and and and and really eating
content at the speed of culture.
>> I'm I'm afraid that really is all we
have time for. If we could give a big
hand to our fabulous panel of innovative
CMOs. Thank you so much.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video features a panel discussion with CMOs from American Express, Gap, and Duolingo, focusing on the risks of playing it safe in modern marketing. The panelists discuss their experiences with taking creative risks, the importance of maintaining an authentic brand voice, the necessity of agility in marketing strategies, and the changing landscape of media fragmentation and audience engagement.
Videos recently processed by our community