HomeVideos

Why You Need Constant Reassurance

Now Playing

Why You Need Constant Reassurance

Transcript

491 segments

0:00

So, what is social support actually

0:02

mean? Does it just having people around

0:04

you? No. It is being able to re-engage

0:07

with the things that trigger your trauma

0:10

and being safe despite the trauma

0:13

signals being active in here. Really

0:15

important to understand. The way that

0:17

you heal from trauma is by teaching your

0:20

body that the reaction that you have is

0:23

actually the wrong reaction. It's

0:25

natural, it's normal, but it is

0:28

inappropriate. We don't need to react

0:30

this way. It's safe.

0:32

>> Somebody said that it must be like

0:34

exhausting how much you have to reassure

0:36

me.

0:36

>> Exhausting.

0:37

>> [laughter]

0:38

>> First of all,

0:40

uh I love reassuring. And second of all,

0:42

it's so easy. It's so easy. My job is so

0:45

easy. My super hot friend wants to be

0:48

told that she looks hot or she looks

0:49

good. Oh, no. Oh, no. The easiest a bad

0:52

And if you are with a bad

0:54

you need to have a bad mentality.

0:56

And nobody understands that. We're art.

0:59

People need to see you, okay? I My job

1:02

is to reassure you and and feel proud

1:05

when I'm out with you and everyone

1:06

stares at you. I have the easiest

1:07

job in the world, okay? So, no,

1:09

it's really not difficult.

1:10

>> Okay, this is a case of someone asking

1:13

reassurance about their need for

1:15

reassurance. Like, that's what this is.

1:17

It's like, "Hey, can you reassure me

1:19

about how much I need to be reassured?"

1:21

So, here's a couple of things to

1:23

understand. When people are like, "Oh,

1:24

reassurance is the easiest for a woman.

1:26

I wonder why men thinks it think it's so

1:28

hard." Okay. So, I don't know why people

1:30

have to bring gender into it, right? But

1:32

this is the internet where it's like,

1:34

"Let's rage bait this by making it a men

1:37

versus women thing." So, a couple of

1:39

things to understand about needing

1:40

reassurance. The first is that many

1:42

people who need a lot of reassurance,

1:45

there are two ways that this can go.

1:47

Either this can get better or it cannot

1:50

get better. So, a good example of this

1:52

is borderline personality disorder where

1:54

these people have a severe fear of

1:56

abandonment. And they need constant

1:58

reassurance that this person is not

2:00

going to leave them, not abandon them,

2:01

etc. Whereas what we know actually is

2:03

that people with borderline personality

2:05

disorder, the majority the vast majority

2:07

of them, over 90% of them get better

2:10

within 10 years of a stable

2:12

relationship. 50% of them no longer meet

2:15

criteria after 2 years of a stable

2:17

relationship. And so if you're someone

2:19

who needs constant reassurance, the vast

2:22

majority of humans who get reassurance

2:26

will be better,

2:29

but it takes years. It'll start to sink

2:31

in after years of reassurance. And And

2:34

so this is for one thing to understand,

2:36

right? Like is like that it does seem to

2:38

work. So one good example of this is,

2:41

you know, I was working with a family

2:43

that told me that they're they kept on

2:45

finding that they had adopted a child

2:47

and they said, "You know, we keep on

2:49

finding ants in the child's room." They

2:51

basically have one behavioral problem

2:53

and they always have ants. Why do they

2:54

have ants? Because they have half-eaten

2:56

food tucked away inside all their

2:59

drawers and then the ants find it. And

3:01

we've tried to explain, "Hey, you can't

3:03

have food here. There's plenty of food

3:04

in the pantry. Like please stop keeping

3:06

your food here. We have ants. We have to

3:08

call the exterminator again and again

3:09

and again." The kid keeps doing it.

3:11

Otherwise the kid like listens to

3:12

things. And so the kid grew up, was in

3:14

an environment where there wasn't food

3:16

security. And so we're talking like from

3:18

the age of three or four or five,

3:21

learned how to hide food. And then gets

3:23

adopted at the age of nine and then

3:25

tucks things away. And the parents are

3:27

like, "There's a pantry. Like they can

3:29

go into the pantry and they can grab

3:30

whatever they want. We've shown him the

3:32

pantry like 15 times. It's not

3:34

clicking." Exactly. It takes some time

3:37

to click. And this is where if we look

3:39

at

3:40

you know, this is kind of an interesting

3:41

question. What does getting better look

3:44

like in a situation like this? So there

3:46

was a great question about, you know,

3:48

why do some people develop PTSD from

3:50

traumatic events when others don't? And

3:52

this is what's really interesting. So,

3:54

if we look at one of the most protective

3:56

factors from preventing the development

3:58

of PTSD, it is social support. You can

4:01

look at people who have been experienced

4:03

some kind of trauma, like physical

4:05

assault or emotional abuse, sexual

4:06

assault, take your pick. And not all of

4:08

them end up with PTSD. And even then,

4:11

what's what's kind of interesting is

4:13

that the majority of people who end up

4:14

with PTSD, so probably the highest

4:17

indicator of trauma in some studies,

4:20

single instance of sexual assault is the

4:22

most likely to result in PTSD. But, what

4:25

we see is that more than half of people

4:27

who have PTSD will no longer have it at

4:30

the end of 1 year, even if they've had

4:32

sexual assault. Those are the people who

4:34

develop in the first place, okay? Which

4:36

is less than half of people. So, the

4:37

question is how, right? How is it that

4:39

some people do develop PTSD? Some people

4:43

don't develop PTSD? Like, what's the

4:45

difference? And for people who do

4:47

develop it, what determines whether they

4:50

get better or they don't get better? And

4:52

this is where social support, and

4:54

specifically what I would call

4:55

corrective emotional experiences, are

4:58

really, really, really important. And

4:59

this is why reassurance works. So, I

5:02

want you all to imagine for a moment

5:03

that someone has been sexually

5:04

assaulted. They have early stages of

5:07

PTSD, they've had it for about 2 months.

5:09

What does the process of healing over

5:12

that PTSD look like? Since this was

5:14

sexual in nature, when they are in a

5:17

committed relationship with their

5:18

partner and they start to get sexual,

5:21

the trauma triggers. They start to clamp

5:24

down, they go into a freeze mode, they,

5:27

you know, it's like their their body

5:29

goes into survival mode instead of

5:31

relaxing, being vulnerable with someone,

5:34

being able to engage with someone. And

5:35

this is the really important thing, what

5:37

happens next? If their partner is able

5:40

to give them the space to breathe that

5:42

way, and then they, you know, cool it

5:44

for now, try again maybe an hour, try

5:47

again a week later, not push it. Then

5:50

what we're starting to do is we're we're

5:51

starting to enroll exposure and response

5:53

prevention. Because after a sexual

5:55

assault, the body learns that sex is

5:58

dangerous. I keep seeing comments, "Dr.

6:00

K, how do I apply this to a situation in

6:02

my life?" That's literally why we

6:04

created a coaching program. Our coaches

6:06

are certified on an evidence-based

6:08

curriculum designed to help you get

6:10

unstuck. This involves analyzing your

6:13

patterns, increasing your understanding,

6:15

and working with you week to week to

6:18

help you develop a plan to create

6:20

lasting change. So, if y'all are

6:21

interested, check out the link in the

6:23

description below. So, what is supposed

6:25

social support actually mean? Is it just

6:27

having people around you? No. It is

6:29

being able to re-engage

6:32

with the things that trigger your trauma

6:35

and being safe despite the trauma

6:38

signals being active in here. Really

6:40

important to understand. The way that

6:41

you heal from trauma is by teaching your

6:44

body that the reaction that you have is

6:47

actually the wrong reaction. It's

6:49

natural, it's normal, but it is

6:53

inappropriate. We don't need to react

6:55

this way. It's safe. The trauma is

6:57

triggered, it's safe. Trauma is

6:59

triggered, it's safe. Trauma is

7:01

triggered, it's safe. And this is what

7:03

good social support literally does. So,

7:06

the child hides the candy bar, parents

7:08

come in, say, "Hey, you don't have to

7:10

hide the candy bar." Child doesn't get

7:11

it. No no real consequence. Okay, you

7:13

feel that way? Okay, fine. We're going

7:15

to take the candy bar because there's

7:17

ants. You can hide another one. And this

7:19

is what's really I just

7:21

You know, I was talking about this. I've

7:22

told this story for I never realized

7:23

this. No wonder the child keeps hand

7:25

hiding the candy bar because it keeps on

7:27

getting taken away by the parents. Wait,

7:29

what? I just had a breakthrough. Man,

7:31

talk about failing your patients. I I

7:33

don't know why Did you guys realize

7:35

that? Did y'all pick that up? Actually,

7:37

we're like we're doing it again. Did you

7:39

guys see that? Seems obvious now, right?

7:41

Right? So, it's so interesting. What an

7:43

[laughter] epic fit. All right, the kid

7:45

got better. So, that's the good news is

7:46

that you can miss some of these things

7:48

and you can still provide the right

7:49

support without doing things precisely

7:52

correct. But, this is what what we need

7:54

we need corrective emotional

7:55

experiences, which was originally not

7:57

related to trauma. I mean, that's been

7:59

that's a a deep part of the

8:01

psychoanalytic and psychodynamic

8:02

literature, okay? About like even the

8:04

childhood traumas that we have, we're

8:05

looking for corrective emotional

8:07

experiences through psychotherapy,

8:09

through transference,

8:10

countertransference, and all that kind

8:11

of stuff. But, the the way that we heal

8:13

trauma is by, you know, we have one

8:15

experience and then we learn, "Oh, this

8:17

is scary." And then we have to have

8:19

other experiences that show us that this

8:22

is safe. And the problem is that our

8:24

brain is wired to weight negative more

8:27

than positive. We literally will weight

8:29

a negative experience three to 10 times

8:31

as much as a positive experience. So, if

8:34

you guys ever have ever had a cat,

8:36

right? You can pat a cat for 1 year and

8:39

be friends with a cat, but if you have a

8:40

single bad altercation with a cat, the

8:43

cat will keep a grudge and remember.

8:45

They don't keep a grudge, they're just,

8:47

you know, that's just how they work.

8:48

They're now wary of you, right? And it's

8:50

like you can be married for 20 years,

8:51

one instance of betrayal heavily

8:54

outweighs 19 or even 20 19.9 years of

8:58

fidelity. That's just how we're wired.

9:00

With people who heal from trauma, we

9:03

have to have these corrective emotional

9:05

experiences. We have to have other data

9:07

points that will help us put the

9:10

negative thing in context. And because

9:12

of if we look at the example of

9:13

fidelity, this is why people need so

9:16

much reassurance, right? And this is why

9:18

if we look at I think something like 96%

9:21

95 or 90 95 to 98% of people with BPD

9:25

are in remission 16 years after

9:28

diagnosis. So, 50% at 2 years, 90% at

9:32

like 10 years, 98% at 16 years. I think

9:36

were the stats that I remember off the

9:38

top of my head. Right? So, so you need a

9:40

lot of those data points. Now, here's

9:42

why I think we're seeing a huge spike in

9:44

trauma, because those corrective

9:47

emotional experiences, those social

9:49

support structures, the repeated chances

9:52

for salvation

9:55

are disappearing from society. We live

9:57

in a world where people get blocked. We

9:59

will live in a world where we're working

10:01

remotely. We live in a world where once

10:03

I get dumped and something bad happens

10:05

to me, I go to places on the internet

10:08

where we can have an experience like

10:10

this and look at what the top comment on

10:12

Instagram is. Is this because it's

10:15

upvoted the most? Is this because

10:16

Instagram knows this is going to get the

10:17

highest level of engagement? But it's

10:19

like boom, ragebait. Ragebait, right?

10:22

It's like what? So, I think the reason

10:24

we're really seeing a spike in in

10:25

trauma-related things is because if you

10:29

kind of screw up, you get punted off the

10:32

escalator and you kind of get left

10:34

behind. And there isn't an opportunity

10:37

for corrective emotional experience.

10:39

This person says, "Oh my god, like is it

10:41

hard to reassure me?" I want y'all and

10:43

this is beautiful and heartwarming and

10:45

whatever, right? So, I fine. But I want

10:48

y'all to think about this person's

10:50

response and how easy or difficult is it

10:54

to find someone like this to provide you

10:58

with reassurance, right? And then we run

11:00

into another problem, which is beauty is

11:02

in the eye of the beholder, totally

11:04

fine. But like what happens if you're

11:06

not the most beautiful person on on the

11:08

planet? What if you're south of five out

11:10

of 10? Then how hard is it to find a

11:12

person like this, right? And then we

11:14

begin to see not that this person is

11:16

doing anything wrong or anything like

11:17

that and I'm not saying that this person

11:19

is a 10 or whatever. I really do believe

11:20

that beauty is in the eye of the

11:21

beholder, but it's like now we begin to

11:23

see why everyone is so

11:25

traumatized all the time, because the

11:27

basic elements of what is required for

11:30

correction do not or harder to find. And

11:33

it does require a large dose. So, this

11:35

person requires reassurance about

11:37

needing to be reassured. Seems like

11:39

they're getting it. We can put this in

11:41

the W column. The challenge is that so

11:44

few people, if we're talking about

11:46

gender dynamics for a moment. Now now

11:47

there's a big movement, right? To like a

11:49

man's emotions are no longer somebody

11:53

else's responsibility. They have to

11:54

handle them on their own. And I'm not

11:56

disagreeing with the argument. I think

11:57

that self-sufficiency is really really

11:59

really important. But then the question

12:01

is like who does the work? Who does the

12:03

work of social support, trauma healing,

12:04

things like that, right? And I'm not

12:06

saying this is right or wrong. This is

12:07

just how things are. And as society

12:11

changes, the first most important thing

12:13

to do is to understand why things are

12:15

changing. What is the mechanism? Good

12:17

diagnosis precedes good treatment. Then

12:19

we can figure out what comes next,

12:21

right? And this is another I so I was

12:23

like looking at this. Why do some people

12:25

develop PTSD after from traumatic events

12:27

when others don't? So, I was trying to

12:29

answer this question. I came across this

12:31

paper. Experience of trauma and PTSD

12:33

symptoms in autistic adults. Risk of

12:35

PTSD development following DSM and

12:38

non-DSM-5 traumatic events. So,

12:40

basically, if you look at our diagnosis

12:42

of trauma, we have a kind of event that

12:46

qualifies for trauma. So, here are the

12:48

examples of things. Sexual abuse,

12:50

physical abuse, serious injury,

12:52

abduction, sudden death of close friend

12:55

or family member, suicide attempt by

12:56

close friend or family member, serious

12:59

injury to another individual, learning

13:01

witnessing sexual abuse, threats to

13:03

one's life from another individual,

13:05

suicide attempt. So, in the diagnosis of

13:08

PTSD, these are DSM-5 traumatic life

13:13

events. This is what causes PTSD, okay?

13:17

Here's what's really scary. Although

13:19

rates of criterion A trauma exposure

13:21

have been found to be 25% in individuals

13:24

with ASD, we just looked at criterion A.

13:26

That's like the bad stuff that we

13:27

normally think about with trauma. More

13:29

than 50% of individuals with autism

13:32

spectrum disorder were were reported by

13:34

a parent report to experience at least

13:35

one event in their lifetime which was

13:37

interpreted as traumatic. 47% of all

13:41

females and 70% of males reported having

13:44

experienced a life event that they found

13:46

to be traumatic which did not meet DSM-5

13:49

criteria. Bullying, non-traumatic

13:51

bereavement, and traumas relating to

13:53

mental health problems such as anorexia

13:55

or breakdowns. In addition, abandonment

13:58

by a significant other mother wife and

14:00

stress associated with social

14:02

difficulties were also reported by

14:04

multiple individuals. So, here's what's

14:06

really scary. These are the kinds of

14:09

things that people on the spectrum will

14:12

will experience as traumatic.

14:14

Bereavement, police visit to the house,

14:16

bullying, abandonment, death of a pet,

14:19

psychological therapy. Therapy is in of

14:22

itself traumatic to some people on the

14:23

spectrum. Injury of family member,

14:25

parents divorce, ASD diag- The process

14:28

of getting diagnosed with autism is in

14:31

and of itself traumatic. Own violence to

14:33

other, right? So, when they lose control

14:36

because they're behaviorally

14:37

dysregulated and hurting someone.

14:39

Boarding school, their own illness, just

14:41

having autism. Vomiting is huge. Grossly

14:45

under appreciated source of trauma for

14:47

people on the spectrum. Social

14:49

difficulties. I was like, "Okay, why do

14:51

people recover? How do people not

14:53

recover?" What I stumbled into is

14:55

actually way scarier, which is that if

14:57

we look at specifically people on the

14:59

spectrum, their capacity to experience

15:02

trauma is elevated. There are lots of

15:04

experiences that that non- I was about

15:07

to say normal neurotypical human beings

15:10

experience that are not traumatic. And

15:12

let's understand why. Because when I get

15:14

bullied, I have a brain that knows how

15:17

to form social connections. I have a

15:20

brain that empathy is more easily

15:22

accessible. I have a brain that doesn't

15:24

need a script, a strategy, or a game

15:28

plan for social interactions. I can feel

15:31

my way through life. You know, when I'm

15:33

capable of feeling my way through life,

15:35

my capacity for social support is

15:37

increased. So, on the spectrum, we have

15:40

a two challenges. The first is that the

15:43

experiences that other people may have

15:46

which are not traumatic are traumatic

15:48

for us. And that's because of the way

15:50

that our brain processes this

15:51

information. The amount of emotional

15:54

activation that we get when we get

15:56

bullied, the persistence of bullying,

15:58

the frequency of bullying. And then we

16:00

lack the social support that is

16:02

necessary to protect us from the trauma,

16:05

to stabilize us afterward. And so, one

16:07

of the things that I stumbled into,

16:08

which I was

16:10

really kind of like, honestly proud

16:12

about and also happy about, was the

16:15

realization that when you get diagnosed

16:17

with ADHD when you get diagnosed with

16:19

ADHD late in life, you also have a mood

16:22

disorder until proven otherwise. See, as

16:25

a psychiatrist, I used to think, "Okay,

16:27

this person's diagnosis is ADHD. And

16:29

they may have depression, they may have

16:31

bipolar, but I that was like a maybe."

16:33

Now, my thinking has shifted. If they

16:36

have adult diagnosed ADHD, I am assuming

16:40

the burden of proof has now changed in

16:43

my mind. They have depression until I'm

16:45

sure they don't. It's not a possibility,

16:48

it is true until it is proven otherwise.

16:50

And having worked with people on the

16:51

spectrum, what I'm now realizing after

16:54

seeing this paper, it like clicked for

16:55

me.

16:56

I was like, "Oh, these people have

16:58

trauma until proven otherwise." I'm

17:00

going to operate under the assumption

17:03

47% of women and 78% of men who are on

17:07

the spectrum. Staggering percentages are

17:11

traumatized by things that we do not

17:14

usually assess for in an intake. cuz

17:17

literally when I'm I have a script when

17:20

I'm reviewing evaluating someone for

17:22

trauma in the emergency room. Have you

17:24

ever been physically abused, emotionally

17:26

abused, sexually abused? What was

17:27

growing up like? I don't ask, "Have you

17:30

ever seen a therapist and found yourself

17:32

feeling traumatized by that process?

17:35

Have you been bullied? Have you ever

17:36

lost a pet?" Right? And I don't know

17:38

that these need to be screening

17:39

questions because I was one person that

17:41

said loss of a pet. Right? And this is

17:42

the important thing. Losing a pet is

17:44

hard for everyone, but it has a greater

17:47

likelihood of becoming PTSD if you're on

17:50

the spectrum. Right? That's what's

17:51

really scary about this.

18:16

>> [music]

Interactive Summary

The video discusses the role of social support and 'corrective emotional experiences' in healing from trauma. It explains how trauma teaches the body to react inappropriately to perceived threats, and how consistent, supportive interaction can rewire this response. The host also highlights why people on the autism spectrum are at a higher risk of developing PTSD from events that may not be considered traumatic by standard DSM-5 criteria, emphasizing that clinicians need to adopt a broader perspective when evaluating patients.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts