HomeVideos

Coffee Expert Blind Review Cheap Coffee

Now Playing

Coffee Expert Blind Review Cheap Coffee

Transcript

442 segments

0:00

Go.

0:01

>> Oh, dude. No. I'm actually very

0:03

impressed. Holy crap. What the heck? Hi,

0:06

my name's Kim.

0:07

>> I'm Naelli.

0:07

>> And we're Cher Brew Coffee. We're a

0:09

coffee pop-up based out of LA. We focus

0:11

specifically on specialty lattes.

0:13

>> Today, we're blind tasting six different

0:15

grocery store coffee beans.

0:17

>> They're all inexpensive except for one.

0:19

So, we're going to use our expertise to

0:20

try and find which one it is. Okay. This

0:22

is going to be coffee number one.

0:24

>> Ooh, let's smell it.

0:26

>> Okay. Just smells There's nothing that

0:29

stands out. You can smell it's just dark

0:30

and

0:31

>> Yeah, it's defin definitely a darker

0:32

rose. Smells good though. Smells good.

0:34

>> It smells like what my dad would drink

0:36

growing up. Feels like when we would

0:38

clock off work and all of our clothes

0:39

would just smell like coffee and you get

0:41

in your car

0:42

>> and you be like, "Wow,

0:45

awful."

0:46

>> I'm going to smell like sweat.

0:48

>> Sweat and coffee.

0:48

>> Sweat and coffee and sadness.

0:52

>> All right.

0:54

I wonder if you can smell

0:56

>> What do you think?

0:56

>> Just like coffee scent. You don't really

0:59

get anything out of it. Chocolatey.

1:01

>> Get a little bit of lime. Like a weird

1:03

zesty. I think it smells nice.

1:05

>> Like she loves everything but also hates

1:07

everything at the same time. So you

1:08

don't really know what you're going to

1:09

get.

1:11

>> Very true. That that brewed really nice.

1:13

Did you see that? It's really nice.

1:14

>> I was being a little a little mean and a

1:16

little harsh. It's actually pretty good.

1:17

Poor.

1:18

>> Let's try. Cheers.

1:24

>> Well, it's not that's not what I thought

1:26

it was going to taste. It coats your

1:27

mouth immediately, but not the way that

1:29

like regular ground coffee does. Just

1:31

goes immediately

1:32

>> to the back of your back. Not even like

1:35

acidic. It's like a weird shock like

1:37

chemical.

1:38

>> So, it's like bitter. It's not a good

1:40

bitter.

1:40

>> It's like a very hurtful bitter

1:43

>> sad thing. There's no acidity to this.

1:46

I'm like 99% sure this is very cheap. It

1:49

also doesn't have any flavor that stands

1:51

out to me. It's just black coffee. I

1:53

would add a bunch of sugar and a bunch

1:55

of milk to this. My mom would love this.

1:57

As it cools down, it just gets blander.

1:59

>> Yeah,

1:59

>> I feel like it was already bland from

2:01

the beginning.

2:01

>> I would give this like a six out of 10.

2:05

>> Give it a three out of 10.

2:08

>> Okay.

2:09

>> Oh,

2:11

>> yep. Pizza. This is like very basic.

2:14

This is something that like a grandpa

2:16

would get,

2:17

>> which is interesting cuz I heard pizza

2:18

was actually like pretty okay when

2:20

Starbucks came up.

2:21

>> I've never had pizza. It's like a white

2:23

elephant gift where it's like everyone's

2:25

like fighting to give it away.

2:26

>> Oh, thanks.

2:29

>> This is coffee number two. Oo, it's

2:32

nice.

2:33

>> You have depth in this one.

2:34

>> Mhm. It's kind of bright.

2:36

>> Mhm. Very nice.

2:39

>> I feel like you can smell some fruits in

2:42

that.

2:42

>> See?

2:42

>> Go try it.

2:44

>> Still very light.

2:45

>> The grind size on this looks so much

2:48

different than the dark roast, which

2:50

seems pretty promising. You ready to try

2:52

it?

2:53

>> Yeah.

2:53

>> Okay.

2:57

>> That's really light.

2:58

>> It is very light.

2:59

>> Yeah. Both the flavor and the body.

3:01

>> And it's not very bitter, which is like

3:03

pretty good. I would probably take my

3:05

time and really sip on this cuz it's

3:06

very teaike. I don't really get notes

3:08

out of this. I feel like you got more

3:09

out of the scent.

3:11

>> There's nothing again that stands out

3:12

about this slight like dryness towards

3:15

the end like the aftertaste. Like when

3:16

you eat some almonds.

3:17

>> Yeah.

3:18

>> That's the only flavor that I could tell

3:19

you for this coffee. some nutty like

3:21

almond. It's just bland. There's nothing

3:24

special to it. And it's not bad.

3:26

>> Yeah. No, it's not bad.

3:27

>> As it cools down, you do get some slight

3:30

maybe like raisiny subtle sweetness.

3:33

>> It It almost like becomes a little bit

3:34

more bodied as it's cooling down.

3:37

>> Starting to taste like hay.

3:40

>> Oh, I

3:41

>> dry.

3:42

>> Very woody. You're definitely never

3:43

going to find any kind of hay flavor on

3:46

like a quality cup of coffee. I don't

3:48

think hay is something people want. This

3:50

is like a three out of 10. Very

3:51

inexpensive.

3:52

>> Four out of 10 for me because I don't

3:55

know. I guess I like hay. I don't know.

3:59

>> Stop.

4:00

So, this is what my dad drank growing

4:02

up. I can see why this was like a pretty

4:05

decent cup of coffee.

4:06

>> If you're going to drink it with your

4:08

sugar, your milk, it's fine, but it just

4:10

gets really bad at the end. It makes

4:13

sense that this has chory because

4:14

chugory is also very like heyy nutty but

4:17

there's not much flavor to it. It's just

4:19

hey coffee number three. You do get some

4:23

dark chocolate slightly sweet. Yeah,

4:25

it's just basic.

4:26

>> Yeah, almost like smokeoky.

4:30

>> It smells a little fruity, a little

4:33

sweet. It's blooming which is a good

4:35

sign. Blooming is when you wet the

4:37

coffee and it kind of rises. That means

4:38

there's gas in it still. When it's an

4:40

old coffee it's not going to do that.

4:41

So, it could be a good sign.

4:43

>> You were able to smell it a little sweet

4:45

here. And you can definitely smell how

4:46

it's a little bit sweeter here. Seems

4:48

pretty good.

4:49

>> Like maybe like a tangerine. Slightly

4:51

citrusy, but I can't I'm not going to

4:53

say like lemon or anything. Just it's

4:55

like the orange peel.

4:56

>> It does have like that heart of an

4:58

orange.

4:58

>> It's not too bold.

5:02

>> This the aroma doesn't transfer to the

5:05

taste.

5:05

>> No. Cuz we were smelling a lot of

5:07

tangerine, but then you taste it and

5:09

it's just like a dark roast and it

5:11

leaves like a metallic taste.

5:13

>> Metallic is not desirable.

5:15

>> No,

5:16

>> there's there's no acidity in this. Body

5:18

is quite heavy and the aftertaste is

5:21

dry. So,

5:22

>> it's very very dry after.

5:23

>> This is also probably pretty

5:24

inexpensive. This is so far the only one

5:26

I would drink. As it cools down, you get

5:29

more sweetness and less metal. I'm also

5:31

getting like a slight like plum.

5:33

>> I can taste the stone fruit. I like this

5:35

one. This is like seven out of 10 for

5:38

me.

5:38

>> Really? This is like a two out of 10 for

5:40

me.

5:41

>> Two?

5:41

>> Yeah. Just because there's nothing I

5:43

want versatility.

5:46

>> Oh, come on. That makes sense why it was

5:48

so dark.

5:50

>> You think this is double roasted?

5:51

>> I don't think maybe this one is not good

5:53

quality. It just isn't.

5:55

>> But it's also not the worst. I don't

5:56

mind it. I thought that was pretty good.

5:58

>> Have you ever had

5:59

>> No.

6:01

>> I've never gone to Starbucks to get a

6:02

brewed coffee. I don't.

6:03

>> Yeah. There's nothing wrong if you do.

6:05

>> Yeah, I'm not judging you if you do.

6:08

>> Get your cup of coffee.

6:09

>> Exactly.

6:10

>> Coffee number four.

6:12

>> Wo.

6:13

>> Yeah,

6:14

>> that's nice. That's really nice.

6:15

>> Say it was like very pro. Okay,

6:16

>> this is very promising. You could just

6:18

tell the coffee grinds. They're very

6:20

light. They have a good texture and the

6:22

aroma

6:24

is amazing. That's sweet. I get

6:26

cherries.

6:27

>> Oh yeah,

6:28

>> that's crazy.

6:28

>> Yeah, this is full full body.

6:31

>> Amazing fruits. Not like citrus, not

6:33

heavy citrus, but

6:36

>> that smells so good. It smells like a

6:39

cherry Laffy taffy, like a candy. This

6:41

looks really nice. It also bloomed,

6:43

which means there's still gas in there.

6:45

It's still fresh. It's smelling like a

6:47

lemon tea. Some slight like jasmine. I'm

6:50

90% sure this is the expensive one. I'm

6:53

positive this is a good color, too. Oh,

6:55

yeah.

6:56

That's nice. You see how it's like a

6:58

light amber, light brown, reddish

7:01

almost? Yeah,

7:02

>> that's what you want.

7:05

>> Oh, yeah. This is like biting into an

7:07

apple. This is really sweet, flavorful.

7:09

It's fruity. The acidity is a medium,

7:12

but it's balanced because the flavor is

7:14

not too strong.

7:14

>> And there's no bitterness that coats

7:16

your tongue and it almost gets like

7:18

acidic. It gets acidic as it's cooling

7:20

down.

7:20

>> You wouldn't want to add milk and sugar

7:22

to this. That would just ruin this cup.

7:25

I am pretty firm on this being

7:26

>> so far from the four that we've had. It

7:28

definitely is

7:29

>> not necessarily floral, but it's very

7:31

tea like.

7:31

>> It's very teaike.

7:32

>> I would throw this over eyes.

7:35

>> For me, this is like a nine out of 10.

7:37

Maybe even a 10 out of 10.

7:39

>> A nine out of 10 for me as well. You

7:42

think it's a local?

7:42

>> It might be.

7:43

>> What did we counter?

7:45

>> Oh, it might be actually.

7:47

>> Three, two, one, go.

7:52

>> Oh, dude. No. I just had a conversation.

7:54

>> You're messing with us.

7:56

McDonald's has like amazing coffee and

8:00

I've never had it this way.

8:01

>> I'm going to McDonald's after this.

8:03

>> I told you she would drink a McDonald's

8:05

coffee.

8:05

>> I will drink a McDonald's coffee and

8:07

apparently

8:07

>> Wow.

8:08

>> It's a 10 out of 10.

8:09

>> I'm actually very impressed. Holy crap.

8:12

What the heck?

8:13

>> I could have sworn this was going to be

8:14

like counterculture intelligencia stump

8:17

town.

8:18

>> Here's coffee number five. Do I know

8:21

anything anymore?

8:22

>> No, cuz we got to lock in cuz we got got

8:24

last time. So, I feel like this is a

8:27

medium roast.

8:28

>> I like this coffee grind. It looks nice

8:30

and even. Mhm. This smells really good

8:33

to me. This is sweet.

8:34

>> That's so crazy. Now, we're like

8:36

psychologically

8:37

just like

8:38

>> No, I know. We know.

8:40

>> Do we?

8:41

>> I don't know.

8:43

>> This could be the expensive one.

8:46

>> No, I don't want to say anything now.

8:47

This could be. It's definitely It's not

8:50

hay. No, it's very fruit notes.

8:52

>> Yes. It's not as strong as the other

8:54

one, but it is sweet. You do get some

8:56

fruiness. Maybe like some blueberries,

8:59

>> cherry,

9:00

>> a little bit of chocolate notes.

9:01

Nothing's really standing out to me

9:02

about this one either. Um,

9:04

>> that's also common for like quality

9:06

coffee. Sometimes it just like doesn't

9:08

shine. It's just

9:10

>> Oh, this smells really nice.

9:11

>> We're not wild.

9:12

>> Smells kind of like a sweet lemon.

9:13

>> Oh, it does. It looks great.

9:15

>> It looks good.

9:15

>> It's just like a even dip.

9:17

>> Color is also nice on this one. Do you

9:19

want to know? You saw that last time.

9:20

>> I know, but I know, but

9:23

>> trust me on this one. Looks promising.

9:25

>> Cheers.

9:26

>> Cheers.

9:29

>> I feel like you just lost all the notes

9:31

to it.

9:32

>> This is very bland. Just a regular cup

9:34

of coffee. This would be good to have

9:36

just black like this. There's no

9:37

acidity. There's no real flavor notes.

9:40

>> Barely a body to it. It's like enough to

9:42

like hold it together, but

9:44

>> almost teaike. Kind of watery. Yeah.

9:46

>> So, coffee being teaike isn't

9:48

necessarily a bad thing. It could be

9:50

something that people want and look for.

9:52

It's pretty balanced. This could be the

9:54

expensive one. Honestly, it doesn't

9:55

taste cheap, but it also doesn't taste

9:58

exciting and amazing. I'm a little torn

10:00

on this. This for me is like a seven out

10:01

of 10.

10:02

>> This like a 6 out of 10

10:04

>> for me.

10:06

>> Duncan,

10:08

>> didn't I say the worst?

10:09

>> We were talking about how the worst cup

10:11

of coffee she's ever had from

10:13

>> was Duncan. And it it tastes like

10:14

Sharpie. Um, this doesn't taste like

10:16

Sharpie though, so maybe they gave me

10:18

something else.

10:19

>> And she gave it a seven out of 10.

10:21

>> I mean, that's not bad. If I had to go

10:23

to Duncan, I would.

10:24

>> Coffee number six.

10:26

>> It smells nice. A little bit raisiny.

10:28

It's like dried fruit.

10:29

>> Yeah, actually does smell nice. It does

10:32

smell very sweet. And the color is nice,

10:34

too.

10:35

>> I don't know anymore. I don't know if I

10:38

can trust myself. This could be the

10:39

expensive one.

10:40

>> I think this could be more than the last

10:43

one. Sorry. I don't like the way that

10:45

this is brewing on here. It's just

10:47

falling down. That could mean that the

10:49

coffee is old. Usually, when the coffee

10:51

is fresh and there's still some gas in

10:53

there, it's going to take a while. All

10:55

the other coffees have taken their time

10:56

to kind of flow through the coffee. The

10:58

water. It's a good color.

11:03

>> Ooh, that is really nice.

11:04

>> That looks really light, though.

11:05

>> It looks really light, but it looks

11:07

good.

11:08

>> Cheers.

11:09

>> Cheers.

11:09

>> Are we done?

11:13

This tastes like tea to me. This doesn't

11:15

taste like coffee.

11:15

>> I was going to say I'm not mad at it.

11:17

>> This tastes like a black tea. It's nice

11:18

and juicy. It's got a medium acidity

11:21

flavor. I'm not getting anything that

11:23

stands out. Maybe like slight peach,

11:25

some sweetness. It's really nicely

11:27

balanced.

11:28

>> Yeah. I don't think this is something

11:29

that you would add milk to or like

11:31

sugar.

11:32

>> I don't get a strong coffee flavor now,

11:34

so I can't imagine what adding milk

11:36

would do to this.

11:37

>> Yeah, it covers what a quality coffee

11:39

would be. It could be the quality one.

11:41

It's just not fresh. As it cool down,

11:44

straight up just black tea.

11:46

>> I like a black tea.

11:46

>> I like a black tea.

11:47

>> They're doing the same thing.

11:48

>> This is like an eight or a nine out of

11:50

10 for me.

11:51

>> This is like an eight.

11:52

>> Eight and a half.

11:54

>> Yeah.

11:55

>> Oh, Chamberlain. Chamberlain coffee.

11:58

>> Have you ever had them?

11:59

>> No. Berry, citrus, maple.

12:01

>> The maple I didn't really get that much.

12:03

>> Is this considered specialty coffee

12:05

>> of the bunch? The most expensive one.

12:07

>> Wow. I don't think I've ever tried their

12:09

coffee. I know they opened a shop

12:11

recently. Doesn't have a roast date.

12:13

>> I just wish it was a little bit more

12:14

fresh.

12:15

>> Well, this is supposed to last you till

12:16

September of 2027.

12:18

>> Oh, that's crazy.

12:20

>> It's a good cup. It's a good cup. How

12:22

much was this?

12:24

>> You can get a better for cheaper for

12:26

sure.

12:27

>> McDonald's.

12:30

>> Get the McDonald's one. Um, shout out to

12:32

McDonald's.

12:33

>> Yeah, literally. because I am actually

12:36

impressed and I'm not mad. And it's not

12:37

about me. It's not about me.

12:39

>> Stopping at McDonald's to get coffee

12:41

now.

12:41

>> Yeah. No, literally.

12:42

>> It just goes to show you that you don't

12:44

need an expensive 20 $25 bag of coffee

12:48

to have something that tastes good. Just

12:50

got to use your mocha master and brew

12:53

your coffee. It It's good.

12:54

>> Goes to show how subjective coffee can

12:56

be. And it's also really fun when we

12:58

think we know everything and then we

13:00

don't. You should always be open to like

13:03

new information and growing and it's

13:05

okay if you're wrong.

13:06

>> I still think you should support your

13:07

local roster.

13:08

>> 100% always support your local coffee

13:11

shop and coffee roaster. The McDonald's

13:13

is good also.

Interactive Summary

Kim and Naelli from Cher Brew Coffee, a pop-up based out of LA specializing in specialty lattes, conduct a blind tasting of six different grocery store coffee beans. Their goal is to identify the single expensive coffee among five inexpensive ones. The tasting yields surprising results: Coffee Number 4, which received the highest ratings for its sweet, fruity, and balanced profile, turns out to be McDonald's coffee. Conversely, Coffee Number 6, Chamberlain Coffee (the actual expensive one), was rated well but not exceptionally, with comments suggesting it wasn't as fresh as desired. The experience ultimately demonstrates the subjectivity of coffee taste, proving that quality and enjoyment don't always correlate with a high price tag, while also reinforcing the importance of supporting local roasters.

Suggested questions

6 ready-made prompts