The "Ben & Jerry's" of Peanut Butter | Noah Fisher Interview
1085 segments
We must bring
>> I'm I'm eating a pretzel.
>> snacking. You got the pretzels ready.
>> Yeah, the horchata chip is crazy to me.
>> I know. I know it's good. I mean, I can
only imagine cuz I haven't had it.
>> It's so good.
>> I've been very much enjoying the
s'mores. My entire family is a fan of
the s'mores flavor and more. We must
bring the one and only Noah Fisher,
co-founder. Oh gosh, Jack. Jack, come
on. Jack.
Our live studio audience wasn't quite
ready.
>> I was a little early.
>> Producer Jack.
>> A little early?
>> A little little a little early. We must
bring the one and only Noah Fisher,
co-founder and CEO of Backyard Peanut
Butter inside of this show. A co-founder
alongside the one and only Helen Mou,
who we met at Shopify. Introduced to
there, she is building out the retail
experience forever and ever, amen, over
at Shopify. We must bring the one and
only Noah inside of the show. Everybody
welcome the one and only Noah Fisher.
>> Co-founder and CEO of Backyard
Get in here, Noah.
Get inside this show.
>> How's it going, guys?
>> Dude.
>> I mean, even better now. It's even
better now, Noah.
>> No more boring Fridays.
>> No more boring Fridays.
>> We're We're going to do this now. We're
going to make this close out on a
Friday. Have some fun here. Really
excited to be with you guys.
>> Man, hey, welcome to the show, Noah.
We're so excited for you.
>> I'm excited to be here. You know, you
just mentioned it, but I I was getting
some flack in the family because I'm the
second member of the family to join the
show. So, I don't get to claim that I
was I was the first.
>> Damn.
>> But that's all right.
That's all right.
>> You know, we just we got you as soon as
we could, Noah.
>> Yeah. I know. You know, I can't win them
all. So, I'm I'm grateful for the
opportunity even if even if I follow in
my wonderful wife's footsteps here.
>> Brother, you've got to tell us You've
got to tell us about the origin story of
maximalist peanut butter. This is such
an interesting concept for me and I
think you I think you guys are doing
something unique in in the marketplace.
Tell me about this.
>> Yeah, yeah. So, we were sitting in our
backyard, which is where the name came
from, eating peanut butter and jelly.
And we said, "Man, peanut butter is
really boring. To change your sandwich,
you're always changing the other thing
that's with it. The jam, the fluff, the
Nutella." It's like, "What if you just
could change the peanut butter?" And we
started riffing, me and Helen, and it
was like
give or take 50% of what you see today,
we created in that sort of initial riff
session sitting in our backyard. Um
which was super cool, right? To be able
to start this together. I get to do it
full-time.
She still has her Shopify gig, as you
guys know.
Um but, super cool. And the concept of
maximalism started and is really biggest
in interior design, of which neither of
us have a background in. But,
it's to to to state the obvious, it's
the opposite of minimalism. And we saw a
world where everything was shifting
super minimalist. And we were like,
"What if we go the other direction? And
what if we try this concept of
maximalism?" So, like, more is more, but
there's an intentionality behind
everything. So, we're not just dumping a
whole bunch of stuff into our peanut
butter, but there's a lot of thought and
reasons and the and complexity in the
ingredients. But, really just trying to
bring some more fun and excitement to a
category that, you know, is beloved
everywhere. I mean, it's why our tagline
is "No More Boring Peanut Butter." And
why we adapted it, as I said today, to
have no more boring Friday afternoons.
>> Let's go.
>> No, I I got to know. I got to know. This
is going to be This is going to be a
rough question, and we can work through
it.
What's your favorite flavor? Because
right now, this horchata chip crisp is
This is I've been al- almost done this
one. I have crushed this one in like
>> Yeah.
>> in like a a half a day time period. It
is addicting. I know you got to be
>> The s'mores. That's that's chocolate.
>> You got to have the chocolate.
>> I've been crushing that, too.
>> This is my favorite favorite part
because you guys asked me that question,
and then you all started naming yours
before I had a chance, right? And it's
just like, what we're trying to build
here is this excitement around peanut
butter.
And people are like, this is my
favorite. But wait, actually, I love
this one when I'm doing that. And that's
really what we're trying to do. So,
Khan, I will answer your question. I'm
not trying to to avoid it.
I will say I love them all. I eat them
all every day. I actually brought I'm
going to go on this journey with you
guys. I brought them here. So, I'm going
to do it as well. I got my spoon. But
if it's a you know, it's to give a
little bit of a hint, right? Like, can I
can I stand up here? This one here.
That one right there.
>> Is that Is that buffalo?
>> You like the buffalo?
>> Let's go.
>> OH.
>> LET'S GO. BUFFALO.
>> SO, buffalo buffalo was a labor of love
creating that recipe. I've been a a
vegetarian now going on 20 years. The
hardest thing for me to give up were
buffalo wings. Yeah. And so, I'll do
buffalo flavored anything, literally
anything. And when we started this, I
was like, I'm going to figure out how to
do it with peanut butter. And
it took some time, but we got there. And
it's got one of the more I would say
unique lines up of use cases. And that's
one of the vectors in which we're trying
to build this maximalist. One is colors,
one is flavors, and and the last one is
use cases. So, buffalo is a blast. You
can use it on peanut noodles, chicken
sandwiches, burgers, cheese, grilled
cheese. So, it's like
it helps among some of the other ones,
but like it helps people understand what
we're trying to do and that we're
different than what they either see in
the market today or may have experienced
in the past.
>> Okay, Noah, talk to me about this like
vegetarian angle here because I think
this is really smart and and like serves
this sector of which now you have lived
for 20-ish years.
>> Yeah.
>> Um you know, and when I first saw
buffalo and when I first started
thinking about like the different um
types of food that you could include it
in. You know, usually in the American
mind, like peanut butter is associated
with sweet and sweet alone. It's like
peanut butter and chocolate, peanut
butter and jelly, peanut butter and
insert, you know, marshmallow. It's like
some kind of sweet type thing. But the
the capabilities that you brought here
with dill pickle, um with the buffalo,
with the everything bagel, you know, it
like it like brings it into a whole
another ballpark.
Like talk to me about this.
>> Yeah, so you nailed it on the head. Like
we started creating flavors and I was
thinking like, what do people already
put with peanut butter? And let me see
if I can get it all in the one jar and
sort of eliminate some of those steps.
As you said, Chris, like a lot of that
is chocolate. And as we started testing
this with consumers and we're happy to
chat about that if we have time, but
like we took a very uh it's embarrassing
to say this, but like we took a very
tech approach to this and we were like
MVPs. Like let's get this out in the
market. We had the same label on every
flavor because we're like, we don't know
which ones are going to be winners, so I
don't want to invest in labels.
>> Here we go.
>> And so we went to to market initially
with a lot of chocolate flavors. And I
learned pretty quickly people come to
the table with the preconceived
understanding of peanut butter and
chocolate, whether it's a Reese's peanut
butter cup or ice cream, whatever it may
be.
And if it doesn't taste just like that,
they're like, yeah, I don't really know
about this. So we actually paired back a
lot of our chocolate flavors and then
we've had a lot of success. I mean,
s'mores is still our number one seller,
super approachable, people get it. But
the savory ones that you just mentioned,
right? So, the dill pickle, the buffalo,
the everything bagel, like they have
really started to grow for us, and we're
getting a lot of consumer excitement
around those. And again, it helps
really demonstrate that what we're doing
is different than what's out there. Um a
ton of consumer education's required. I
mean, I've got a CPG background, talked
to consumers for my entire career. I
still was not prepared for the amount of
education that's required with what
we're trying to do with Backyard and how
to use it. But it's also one of my sort
of parts that I love the most about what
I get to do on a day-to-day basis.
>> I find that interesting.
Noah, what is the hardest part about
getting someone to switch over after
they have they know that same peanut
butter jar for 20 years? It's either a
creamy or a crunchy peanut butter. What
is that hardest part to get them to pull
over and try something else?
>> Yeah, the the funniest thing is like
when we go to consumer events, and we
were at a hot sauce festival last
weekend, which was
>> Let's go.
>> was our third year there, one of our
favorite events. It's like our best
single day event we ever do.
Um
And we talked to people there, but like
any event, it's that person who's
sitting there is like, "Nah, I'm good. I
like my plain peanut butter." I'm like,
"Just try it. Just try one. You pick
one." We developed a little spinning
wheel if they were hesitant to pick
their flavor. I was like, "Just spin the
wheel, and you can try
a hot sauce."
Cuz you get a lot of folks that are
like, "Nah, I'm good. I like my plain
peanut butter." You're like, "Just try
it. Just try it."
>> it.
>> Um and then they're like, "Oh my
goodness, this is awesome." And that's
where we love like getting these live
reactions from folks.
Um and it's just it's a great like that
does the selling for me.
>> And really what we're doing, like we've
got a good number of our flavors that
work in the traditional PB&J is a common
the horchata crisp goes great.
>> Oh.
>> If you can save half the time to stick
it in a in a
two pieces of bread versus just going
out with a spoon.
The Mexican hot chocolate goes really
well with raspberry jam just to balance
the heat in a sandwich.
But really what
I've identified and what I'm trying to
push and and educate as like it's
incremental, right? Like you can buy
three of our flavors cuz there's three
different use cases and you can also buy
your standard plain peanut butter that
you have at home. This is going to serve
sort of that purpose but a lot more. So
it's giving you that variety in a way
that we believe smooth and chunky isn't
giving the variety that folks may or may
not have realized they need in their
peanut butter world.
>> Talk talk to me
talk to me now about going from the
Clorox company and giant CPG, okay? It's
like Hidden Valley Ranch and you know,
Kingsford and you know, it's like talk
to me about going from like giant CPG to
being like nitty-gritty scrappy CPG
founder. Like what what is that like
process experience been like for you?
>> Yeah, mind-blowing in in in a quick
answer. But I'll say yeah, I spent
almost eight years marketing and selling
primarily trash bags and under the Glad
brand and we under the sort of the
Clorox umbrella,
super functional products that nobody
likes to think about but one of those
things that was a great training ground
for me to learn how to market, right? If
you can get somebody's attention around
those two products that they don't want
to think about unless they're having
some sort of
disaster in the case of bleach or like
nobody likes to think about trash. But I
can talk about days for trash bags back
in the day uh is a great party trick, by
the way.
Um
But yeah, super big company, like great
learning ground for me, but at the end
of the day, I was like, I'm just I'm
hungry, pun intended, for that ability
to own the end
own the end to end, really get in there,
work on a physical product that I can
get my hands on was really important for
me. Um and so we started this out of our
kitchen, which is actually directly
above where I'm sitting right now.
>> Let's go, baby.
>> Um and that's where the business
started, and for me it was like, all
right,
this is it, right? I had a big team by
the time I left CorDx. There was things
that I didn't like to do. I was like,
yeah, you know, I got somebody else on
my team to do it. Now it's like, oh,
that thing didn't get done? I'd have to
turn and look at myself. So, it was a
great transition. It's one of those
things where
I can never go back to a corporate world
at this point. Like, I have fully sort
of drink drank the
the entrepreneurial Kool-Aid, and uh
whether this belly's up in a year or
two, like, I'm I'll find the next thing,
and because it's just so energizing, the
ups and the downs, for sure,
um but it's something that I love, and
something that I never thought I'd do. I
mean, I started this full-time when I
was
37 or 38 years old, so it's like
I had to go through all the different
stops in my career in order to feel
confident that
I could do this without falling flat on
my face on day one.
>> Wow.
>> it, man.
>> I mean, No, do you you know, obviously
know about like the protein maxing trend
right now, the protein Like, are you
guys leaning into that? Because
inherently peanut butter has a ton of
protein in it. You guys are loaded up.
Are you trying to lean into that at all?
>> Yeah, it's something we haven't gone
full in yet, but it's it's certainly
what um to your point is like, it's sort
of the low-hanging fruit for us at the
moment. Um and that is really big, that
is really important. Um, we actually the
facility that we manufacture out of I
call it a micro facility that I
manufacture out of shares a building
with like a a muscle gym.
>> To to be kind.
>> And so it's like I get those folks
coming in and I I love chatting with
them cuz they're one super particular
about what they're consuming
>> Oh, I bet.
>> and two super thoughtful about all the
nutrition facts and the ingredients
>> 100%.
>> sort of how to maximize um, in this case
the protein intake. So, yeah, it's a
space we really want to lean into harder
um, and one that we think we got a lot
of runway with.
>> It it it uh, the product itself too it's
like there's no there's no hydrogenated
oils and such. Is that the case? No.
>> Yeah, so well so everything starts with
a natural peanut butter base. So, it's
peanuts and salt and then depending on
the flavor we layer in different
seasonings and mix-ins. And so some of
those mix-ins are going to come in with
ingredients that some folks um, are
choosing not to to consume in that
moment um,
or with that specific diet and so across
the lineup we've got things that are
going to meet the needs of of just about
everybody short of a peanut allergy
obviously um, but we're trying to have
at least one or two that can meet um,
what anybody's looking for while at the
same time
trying to minimize complexity from our
operational standpoint and not
proliferate our flavor lineup um, but
being really thoughtful about what that
looks like.
>> And let me also just say
it's it's like
powerful to me that you and Helen are
like a power couple, you know, she's
like she's like at Shopify and then like
we're talking with her and it just kind
of like
falls out of their mouth like oh by the
way, it's like oh yeah, and I'm a
merchant as well. I was like what?
Like
you know, LIKE WHAT ARE YOU A MERCHANT
OF? And then to find out you guys are
doing this together I think is uh, is
really so cool. I I
>> Yeah.
>> I I'm I'm like I'm ready to taste Noah,
but go ahead. What what were you going
to say?
>> I was just going to say we we love doing
it together. I mean we started it on the
side cuz it was a mix of our
professional backgrounds. So like before
I left Clorox we had started this. We
were going to like random farm events
and farmers markets just to again do
this like MVP testing.
But it's it's great, right? Like we
build everything off of Shopify. We
leverage just about anything Shopify has
on its platform which is phenomenal. We
like roll into events like this hot
sauce festival. As you guys know like
Helen works on the retail team.
>> Right.
>> We show up with all these point of sale
devices and it's like
our vendor neighbors are looking at us
like what are you guys doing? We're like
well we got to test these you know five
different functions this weekend.
And so Helen's able to tap into it a lot
at work.
And I don't want to speak for her, but
like there's an element at Shopify. You
guys know it well, right? There's a
different level of credibility when you
are a merchant and you are using it
yourself.
Actually transacting with consumers.
And we get to do that. And then I also
have a direct line when something's not
working. I'm like hey, you know I get
prioritized. I know my you know GMV is
not at a level where I get direct help,
but I would like that direct help. So
it's it's a partnership that works both
ways.
>> I love that.
>> That's incredible.
>> I I've got
I've got buffalo here. Your favorite
Noah. I find it
fascinating that it's got this like bite
of spice in here. It really it really
does. Talk to me about about buffalo.
What you pair this with? You know, your
thoughts on this.
>> Sure. Now I'm eating this so I got to
talk with peanut butter in my mouth.
Yeah, it's got crunch in there too.
>> I shouldn't want you guys to do the
journey without me.
>> It's lovely.
>> Yeah, so the buffalo as I mentioned
earlier like great with cheese.
So we have people that put it on
charcuterie boards. So any sort of cured
meat as well, cheese,
celery, carrots, um but you guys
familiar with the ants on a log snack
back in the day?
>> Yeah. Yes.
>> So we do it with celery, buffalo peanut
butter, and blue cheese crumbles.
>> Great.
>> That sounds awesome.
>> can bring it to any bring it to any
holiday party you're going to in the
winter and you guys will be you know,
the only one showing up with that. It's
awesome.
>> The blue cheese crumbles.
>> peanut noodles, yeah, peanut noodles you
can thin it with soy sauce or not.
Chicken sandwiches, burgers,
it's it's I put it on like I crust the
tofu before I put it on our our grill.
So I love it. Apples, they all go great
on apples. Just that sort of the
sweetness and the tang from the apple
goes really nice.
>> It's got it totally tastes like it
tastes like buffalo wings. It tastes
like buffalo wings. It's got that crunch
in there. I would imagine this would
absolutely kick on some noodles. I think
that would be great.
The blue cheese ants on a log thing I
think I I find I find fascinating.
>> great with Ritz, too.
A super funky savory
um oatmeal.
Fear and I have those really well.
>> Yeah, what do you got there?
>> I got a salted caramel pretzel here,
which is why I pulled out the
gluten-free pretzels.
So I'm trying to pair
>> Oh, you're going to pretzel on pretzel.
>> Pretzel on pretzel. That is
that is the definition of maximalist
right there.
>> Oh, yeah.
>> Pretzel on pretzel. I love that.
>> 100%. Yeah, this is let's see yeah, talk
to us about the salted caramel pretzel.
>> Yeah, so this one's this one's fun,
right? Like it's got we also try to play
a lot with textures. And so this one
you're getting a
Yeah, so you you got the creamy peanut
butter base and you're getting a chewy
caramel bite and then the crunchy
pretzel piece. Um one of the cool things
that we
I'll say it's cool from an operational
standpoint.
I don't break anything down like in the
mixing process breaks it down. So like I
don't mind if a whole pretzel shows up
in there or if it gets broken into 10
pieces.
>> Yeah.
>> It uh it presents some issues when I'm
trying to scale and use some larger
automated machinery, but for the time
being like it works great for what we
want. Um
Yeah and so this one just again the
texture play. It's another one of those
flavor profiles that people already
understand. So it's really approachable.
Um it's one of our our top sellers. It's
an online only one that we sell cuz it
just
>> Oh.
>> it does well there. Yeah.
>> This
this one and I have to say I like the
big chunks of things. Yeah. It reminds
me of
you know when ice cream you get cookie
dough and then you get a huge thing of
cookie dough and it's like Yo, I hit the
mother lode.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Dig that thing out of
there. Get it out. Yeah.
>> It's it's like Ben & Jerry's-esque. You
know, Ben & Jerry's got the chunks, you
know.
>> Just just so everybody knows that's
watching like I didn't I didn't ask
Chris to say that, BUT IT IS
RIGHT LIKE I GET I GET A LOT of
inspiration from from Ben & Jerry's
honestly from a branding like I think
they're they've got a one of one brand,
right? And there's there's no way you
can copy what they're doing. Um
But really like I don't check me on the
history here, but prior to Ben & Jerry's
like it was pretty smooth peanut butter.
Maybe you Excuse me. There we go. Smooth
ice creams, right? Like you get a little
bit of chunks of strawberry or chocolate
chips and they were like, "Hey, sort of
like hold your Häagen-Dazs. I'm going to
show you what ice cream can be."
>> Right.
>> Um and so I again take a lot of
inspiration from what they do from a
flavor development just from like what
they're putting in ice cream. Um and
they are
you know, they don't call it that, but
they also would take it a maximalist
approach.
>> I I totally agree.
>> You think you're going to borrow that
kind of like collab piece that they do
with A great example is they did the Ben
& Jerry's Tonight Show ice cream. And
it's like Jimmy Fallon and then Ben &
Jerry's. Do you think you're going to go
that pairing where you're trying to tap
like big influencers, big athletes, and
then you make this limited run batch,
but it is like
only it's going to be
you know, LeBron James limited run
batch, only LeBron James favorite
flavors.
>> Or Kawhi Leonard, you know, maybe
Toronto Raptors, you know, Kawhi, I
don't know.
>> I was born and raised in Philly, so my
my picked by LeBron James there. Yeah,
so LeBron, if you're listening, hit me
up. We can do a collaboration together.
Yeah, it's something we'd love to do.
I've talked to a couple other folks
in New England. We're based in New
Hampshire. So, I've got some other
people in sort of
adjacent e categories that I think could
be really interesting to partner with.
But that that limited run and the sort
of like the sneaker drop mentality is a
big thing that we want to do.
Um
Also a great way for us to sort of test
out, right? It's like the the
big brother version or grown-up version
of the MVP that we were doing when we
launched. It's like, "Hey, can I just do
500 jars straight off our website?
>> Yeah.
>> And see how it goes, right? And And if
it goes well, then we can start to build
off of that. And if it doesn't, then
it's fine. There's no love lost. And I
think that's another great thing for me
that at the end of the day what gives us
a little bit of insulation from
competition is like this brand we're
building and this concept of maximalism.
Like I can basically put whatever into
peanut butter, and it's not going to
it's going to build the brand up. It's
not going to degrade it. Right? And it's
not, you know, it's not like I It's
built into our DNA that I can take these
really wild
sort of flyers on something. And if it
doesn't taste good, then it doesn't
taste good, right? Like we can move on
to the next one cuz it still fits our
our brand persona, which is super
exciting for me and and feel like it
gives a lot of runway. It also is like,
"Hey, how do I prioritize as a solo
entrepreneur?" It's a constant
challenge.
>> Totally.
Okay, two The first one that I tried
when my package came in here. First one
I tried was dill pickle.
Which like actually has pickles in it.
Number one.
>> Let's go.
>> I I mean, if you've If anybody's watched
the show before,
I'm a fan of pickles. I drink pickle
juice on the show. I have the gallon
>> Do you have your gallon with you?
>> It's in my fridge.
>> He has a gallon of pickle juice that he
drinks on the
show. And it
>> It's a bit of a shock. It's a bit of a
shock. It's a shock thing where every
time he does it, it is a It's a visible
sight. So.
>> There it is. I'm sorry that the koozie I
sent you won't fit on a gallon jug.
>> Smells good.
>> It's a old
frosty cold one. It also holds a jar of
peanut butter if you want to take that
on the go as well.
>> The The The dill pickle I found
incredibly tasty. But my first thought
was like, I don't know I don't know what
I'm going to put it on. But I But you
know, I think there's there's got to be
some great things in here. I You've sent
over It looks like cheese, crackers,
celery, carrots, charcuterie. The
charcuterie I think is interesting.
>> Yeah, so similar to the buffalo like it
can It pairs up with a lot of the same
types of ingredients.
I I'll I'll be fully honest here on that
one. Like we get so many people when
we're at events that like, "That sounds
gross."
And it's like, "Just try it. What are
you going to get a chance to try?" And
you're like, "Fine, I'll try it." "Oh my
god, that is so much better than I
thought. Or like, wow, that's actually
not bad. Or like, that's
amazing. Like Or like we get a lot like
the mind like real life mind-blown
emojis.
Um
And that's the one where it's like, if I
can get somebody to try it, I know I've
got them somewhere in the portfolio. If
it's not that one, like they're going to
be like, oh wow, this is like I need to
try something else.
>> Yeah.
>> But that's a great great one for us to
really just push out there. And so
anytime I'm out doing sampling, I bring
that one with me even if I don't have it
to sell because it just again
encapsulates what we're trying to do
and and really draws people in. And
again, if like that's not their thing,
then they're going to find a different
one that is their thing and and I'm cool
with that at the end of the day.
Whichever jar they're taking home.
>> This s'mores, my kids have just been
locked in spooning this thing. It's got
like actual like little marshmallows in
here.
>> Yeah, so it's got those like Lucky
Charms type marshmallows with a little
nice little crunch in them.
Um
a it's a true gelatin-based marshmallow.
It doesn't hold up any oils. Like it
seizes up pretty quickly.
So good.
>> An interesting thing with this too is
like this is very much a better for you
peanut butter. We've had a lot of
protein founders on the show where they
have made protein powders that are
better for you protein powders cuz they
found the whey was making you feel
horrible and then they have this better
for you protein, you feel good
afterwards. Same thing here. If I were
to try to slam a jar of Jif, I'd feel
horrible afterwards.
But I can tackle one of these and I
actually feel great and like I can move
around. I can go ride my bike and do all
these things.
I think this is just a massive lane
where it's like this is better for you
peanut butter, but it's also got a crazy
unique twist on any flavor lane that you
want to go down, we probably got you
covered.
>> Yeah. Yeah, it's it's true. And we we
joke like we want to make peanut butter
forward flavored peanut butter.
And so like
if you look at a jar of ours like our
nutrition facts, they don't vary all
that much from
>> Yeah.
>> a standard natural peanut butter
that you would buy at any grocery store.
>> Yeah.
>> And you're going to where it is
variable, it's getting picked up in some
of the other mix-ins like the
marshmallows and the s'mores or the
Um but that absolutely is true and we
you know, we get a lot I know we're all
sort of sitting here just jokingly with
spoons but like we get a lot of
consumers who say I just you know, like
I take a jar I open a jar and I take a
spoonful and that's my sort of night
time ritual now. Like I'm not doing the
ice cream.
We do have a couple that go great with
ice cream by the way. So if you want to
pair them but we get a lot of folks who
are just like no, I'm just I'm just
going to go take a spoonful of your
peanut butter cuz it just elevates
and so it's it's one of those things
where it's like we can meet a lot of
needs and again back to me as a sole
entrepreneur, it's like all right, where
where do I really want to push on those
needs
and
and really start to build what we're
trying to do here and grow what we're
trying to do here in a way that's
exciting and and really thinking about
the long term.
>> No number one seller is the s'mores. Is
that is that the case?
>> S'mores sort of channel agnostic is our
is our best one. It's super
approachable. I think it works across
age groups use cases.
But then depending on where we are like
that hot sauce festival, s'mores was our
number one but then the three savory
ones were two, three and four right
behind.
Yeah. Yeah.
The Mexican hot chocolate would crushed
it there as well. People are always
surprised by by spicy peanut butter
which I was too as well but it's it's a
ton of fun.
Our eight-year-old or excuse me, almost
8-year-old in a week and a half
daughter, she like microdoses the
Mexican hot chocolate cuz I've told her
she can build You can build your heat
tolerance up.
And so that's been that's been her
source of of building that up, which is
which is cool. I love it.
Um
>> Noah, what are you cooking up next? Like
do you have any flavors that you are
{quote} like prototyping right now where
you're like, "Hey, we might be dropping
these one to three new SKUs. We're kind
of cooking these up working prototyping
them out a little bit."
>> Yeah, so there's two that I'm working on
right now with various degrees of
success. One is a even spicier peanut
butter than our Mexican hot chocolate.
And that really comes out of the the hot
sauce festival, which we hear year over
year like,
"Hey, we want something that's even
hotter." So right now the heat's coming
in through cayenne, and that's pretty
low level in in a hot sauce world. So
where can we look to bring that up in a
way
>> Ghost pepper?
>> And that's also Yeah, so like there was
even pepper X where we were people
Um
So I don't know if I want to go that
far, but yeah, like how can we really up
the ante from a spice perspective
because that to me really pushes open
the door into a very different market
where I'm I you know the hot sauce
people like super foodies
and really again understand what they're
doing. So that's one we want to do. The
other one
and I'm sort of working on its pairing
with it. So but I'm going to send you
guys some SAMPLES IS BACON.
>> OH, YES.
>> LET'S GO.
>> YES, BRO.
>> That is absolutely the move, Noah. Bacon
peanut butter
>> Does it need to go with something else?
Is it bacon and or is it just like
Yeah, hands off. Let let's let bacon do
it.
So we're working on that, but you guys
will be first in line for uh consumer
feedback on that one for sure.
>> That just run. sounds to me like a grand
slam, bro.
>> Yeah, that's a home run. I appreciate
that.
>> Bacon peanut
>> Yeah, it's fun, right? And like I've got
a never-ending list of flavors that I
would love to do. Um but again, it's
like as I started this, we make one size
of jar, and it was all about like how do
I minimize complexity? How do I minimize
like spreading out our cash, right?
We're bootstrapping this business. Um
and everything gets fed right back in.
And so it's like
more flavors is fun and exciting. It
also has more complexity and more
forecasting that
I don't really need to be doing at the
moment. Um and so it's it's balancing
that, and that's where that sort of
sneaker drop play we talked about,
Colin. I think it'd be really
interesting cuz this is going to give me
more confidence
of like, "Hey, let's actually go deep in
this cuz we sold 500 jars of this one
flavor in a week." And
that's as good a signal as I could ever
get.
>> You know, I'm sure you know this. I
don't know if Colin Doherty knows this,
but Elvis's favorite sandwich
>> Oh, yeah.
>> I'm hip. I'm hip.
>> Peanut butter, bacon, and banana.
>> Peanut butter, bacon, and banana. Yeah,
well, you know, you're you're you're
opening up my spot, I guess, here.
>> You called it the Elvis?
>> That's the other ingredient that that's
the other ingredient I've been trying to
figure out.
>> Yeah.
>> The banana flavor so so peanut butter is
a really strong flavor, and getting
other ones to sort of rise up to it or
even above it is a challenge. So like
coconut, like true coconut just doesn't
doesn't do it. Um and I don't want to go
like artificial flavor coconut type
stuff. Um so banana's one of the things
I'm I'm working on. So I've got
I've lost track of the different forms
of banana I have over in our our factory
that I'm trying to test out uh to to
pair with the bacon. So that's that's
the number one sort of
uh
uh pairing option to date with the
bacon. It's just a
They're not It's not working as well as
I would like. But, that's okay. We're
going to do it. We're going to figure it
out.
>> Understandable.
>> Well,
I tell you what, I have definitely not
had a boring Friday. And that's because
you have come to us, Noah, and delighted
our taste buds.
>> Let's go.
>> I love that.
>> And you know, tickled our brains, our
entrepreneurial brains, to consider how
one shall win in the CPG and consumer
world.
Uh brother, I'll tell you what, if you
if you can make a bacon peanut butter,
and I don't I don't hardly care what
else you put in there, I'm there.
>> Good to know. I'll keep that in mind.
>> We're going to be subscribed.
I think my s'mores are going to be gone
by the end of the weekend. I hid it from
my kids so that I could have I could
have plenty here when we got you on the
show. Tell us this. Tell us this, Noah.
>> Yeah.
>> Uh where to find where to find you,
where to follow you, where everybody
should go. backyardpeanut.com
for sure, but give us the whole list,
Noah.
>> Yeah, backyardpeanut.com, powered by
Shopify.
Um
you can get there on our website. We
ship all across the country.
You got all our flavors available there.
We're in a bunch of independent sort of
mom-and-pop shops throughout the
Northeast, which are good partners for
us, but we're really focused on on the
D2C channel. Thinking there's a lot of a
lot of runway there to go with.
Um so, that's a good spot for us
as well. But, yeah, come on out. Follow
backyard peanut butter on all the
socials.
Uh really trying to build that out. So,
any user-generated content out there,
send it our way, folks. We love to have
it.
Um
can't wait.
>> Noah, can can people subscribe on here?
I don't I don't Right now, I don't know
if I see a subscription button on this
thing.
>> We We do not We do not have a
subscription button.
We We
We
>> I think it's time.
>> Are you Are you getting texted by the
Shopify folks while we're on this call
saying we should do that? Cuz it's
>> No, but it's it seems like a genius idea
to me, which is why I keep hitting this
Shopify thing.
>> It's It's a regular It's a regular
conversation we have. So, it's like,
yeah. Well, well, it'll be there by
fall.
>> All right.
Let's go.
Let's go.
>> And now that you're here, we'll we'll be
It'll be there by fall.
>> Incredible, man. Noah, we love what
you're doing. We love the innovation in
CPG. I don't know why all of the
innovation always comes from CPG, but it
does. And we love the fact that you and
Helen are doing this together. And
brother, I can't wait for me and mine to
eat up the rest of this. And
we'll be looking on the lookout for
bacon bacon-flavored peanut butter to
come. Brother, appreciate you making the
time to join us. And we look forward to
having you back, man. Thank you.
>> Thanks for having me, man. Can't wait.
Talk to you later. Appreciate it.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
In this video, Noah Fisher, co-founder and CEO of Backyard Peanut Butter, discusses the origins and unique approach of his company. Emphasizing a 'maximalist' philosophy in a market typically dominated by minimalism, Backyard Peanut Butter offers a wide range of creative and savory flavors. Noah shares the journey from developing the concept in his backyard to building the brand using Shopify, highlighting the importance of consumer education and testing, and touches on future product plans, including a potential bacon-flavored peanut butter.
Videos recently processed by our community