Elon Musk on AGI Safety, Superintelligence, and Neuralink (2024) | EP #91
677 segments
the Advent of super intelligence it it
is actually very difficult to predict
what will happen next so I think there
you know there's some chance um uh that
it will end Humanity I I think that's
you know like I said I probably agree
with Jeff Hinton that it's about um I
don't know 10% or 20% or something like
that the probable uh positive scenario
outweighs the negative scenario it it's
just that there's a it's difficult to
predict
exactly so here's a deal we're on we're
on X video and we're over starlink
elon's airborne right now on his way to
La Elon good
afternoon uh good afternoon
congratulations on uh on all that's
going on you know the conversation
yesterday Elon is one that you're well
familiar with and have been talking to
the world about which is is digital
super intelligence Humanity's greatest
hope or its greatest fear and I would
love to have you sort of speak to that
for a few
minutes I mean it's it's called The
Singularity for a reason um as a as you
know the singularity Institute and
whatnot um so when you have a s you know
sort of the Advent of super intelligence
it is actually very difficult to predict
what will happen next so I think there
you know there's some chance um uh that
it'll end Humanity I I think that's you
know like I said I would probably agree
with Jeff Hinton that it's about um I
don't know 10% or 20% or something like
that um and then I you know I think
there's I think that the the probable uh
positive scenario outweighs the negative
scenario it it's just that there's a
it's difficult to predict exactly um but
I I think we are headed for um you know
as as I think is the title of your book
abundance uh is the most likely
outcome so yeah a lot a lot of
celebration on on that and and I think
one of the things that you've said is
we're going to get to abundance on the
backside of of AGI on the backside of
humanoid
robots yeah um you know I think
hopefully we can uh have an outcome that
is half similar to uh the in Banks uh
culture books um which is I think
probably the the best envisioning of um
a semi
utopian uh AI future um and I I think
the best we can do is it's definitely
going to happen so and it's happening
fast so that I think that really we just
want want to try to steer it in um as
positive a direction as possible to try
to do whatever we can to um increase the
probability of a of a great future
um for this I think uh the way in which
U sort of an AI or an AI is created uh
is very important
um you you you kind of do kind of like
grow grow an AGI um it's it's almost
like like raising a a kid but that's
like a Super Genius Like Godlike
intelligence kid um and it matters kind
of like how you rais the kid you know um
one of the things I think that's
incredibly important for AI safety is to
have a a maximum sort of Truth seeking
and uh Curious AI um so I've thought a
lot about AI safety um and my My
ultimate conclusion is that the best way
to achieve AI safety is to um just just
just grow the
AI you know in terms of the foundation
bottle and the fine-tuning um to be
um uh really truthful like like don't
Don't Force It to lie like even if the
truth is
unpleasant it's very important don't
make the AI lie u in fact the you know
the the sort of one of the really the
core the core plot premise of 20 you
know 2001 at SP Odyssey was things went
wrong when they forced the AI to
lie you know like the the um the AI was
uh not allowed uh
let the crew know about the monolith
that they were going to see but it was
also how to take the crew to the
monolith and so the conclusion of the AI
was to kill the crew and take their
bodies to the monolith and so the lesson
there being uh Don't Force an an AI to
to lie or do things that are
axiomatically incompatible like to do
two things that are actually mutually
impossible uh so um you know that's what
we're trying to do with with xai and and
grock is to say like look we want to
just have a maximally truthful uh AI
even if what it says is not politically
correct uh if you wanted to focus on um
being as as accurate you're getting
you're getting a a round of applause
from the audience on on uh on those
comments here uh you know I saw your
Tweet the other day I had I had Ray KW
and Jeffrey Hinton on stage with me
yesterday as as well as uh madat and
then Eric Schmidt and a number of
individuals and I saw your your Tweet
about
um yeah Ry was was generally correct
ahead of many people but we're likely to
have call AGI what you will have AGI
next year and then by 2029 having AI
equally intelligent to the entire human
race um speak to that speed because that
is
insane yeah so I mean I have to give
credit to Ray kwell and being actually
remarkably um accurate in his
predictions so um
um in fact if anything like I think he
was perhaps a bit conservative uh in his
predictions um so if you look at the
amount of of AI compute and the talent
the the sort of human talent that is
going into Ai and the amount of compute
that's going into AI um it's you know at
this point it's it's it appears to be
increasing by a factor of 10 the AI
compute the dedicated AI compute appears
to be growing by a factor of 10 every
six months
you know like so it's like like
basically close to i' say almost like a
100x Improvement per year at least for
the next few years um in AI compute
coming online um and it seems like
probably a lot of the the data centers
maybe most of the data centers that
currently do kind of conventional uh
compute will transition to uh AI
compute
so
um it's it's certainly a good time to be
Nvidia obviously um it's like you know
and you got to also give credit to to
Jensen uh and the the Nidia team for
kind of seeing this coming and um making
what at least currently is the the best
uh AI Hardware out there um
so so so when you have that that level
of compute uh uh growth and
um it's it's sort of on steroids Next
Level it's you know terms of how much
computer's coming online then you're
you're just going to have acceleration
that uh is unprecedented in fact I've
never seen any technology grow as fast
as as AI uh and I've seen a lot you know
I've seen things fast but I've never
seen anything this fast um but you know
like I said I think the the most likely
outcome is um a positive one
um and um you know I think in that
positive scenario there's still
challenges of like well how do we as
humans still have
relevance you know um how do we find how
do we find
purpose how how do we find purpose but I
mean I think sort of a high class
problem to say like well the computers
are so good at at at doing everything
and and
um like said I thought your book is
pretty accurate in terms of the future
being being one of abundance where
essentially goods and services will be
uh in available in such quantity that
that really uh they'll be available to
everyone like basically if you want
something you can just have it
essentially
um because if you got Ai and Robotics uh
the cost of goods and services uh is uh
almost nothing um so um you know if if
you think of like what is an economy an
economy is basically number of people
times average productivity per person at
the point at which you have say Advanced
robotics U and this you know this Tesla
developing Optimus um obviously we have
our cars which are really robots on on
four wheels um and the you know with the
the the latest version of um full stoft
driving which is um AI end to end
photons in and controls out um it really
is um it's really fully AI at this point
um and uh it looks like a car but it's
really a robot on on on Wheels um and uh
and you add the humanoid robots in there
there's there's really no limit to what
the economic output no no meaningful
limit to what the econ economic output
would be so you know looking on the
bright side uh the we are headed for a
future of abundance
um that I think that's the most likely
outcome I think the only scarcity will
that that exists will be scarcity that
we just decide to create artificially
like let's say we just decide that
there's a unique work of art or
something okay well it's just you just
it's just artificial scarcity but but
any kind of goods and services I think
will be extremely abundant everybody I
want to take a short break from our
episode to talk about a company that's
very important to me and could actually
save your life or the life of someone
that you love company is called Fountain
life and it's a company I started years
ago with Tony Robbins and a group of
very talented Physicians you know most
of us don't actually know what's going
on inside our body we're all optimists
until that day when you have a pain in
your side you go to the physician or the
emergency room and they say listen I'm
sorry to tell you this but you have this
stage three or four going on and you
know it didn't start that morning it
probably was a problem that's been going
on for some time but because we never
look we don't find out so what we built
at Fountain life was the world's most
advanced diagnostic Centers we have four
across the us today and we're building
20 around the world these centers give
you a full body MRI a brain a brain
vasculature an AI enabled coronary CT
looking for soft plaque dexa scan a
Grail blood cancer test a full executive
blood workup it's the most advanced
workup you'll ever receive 150 GB of
data that then go to our AIS and our
physicians to find any disease at the
very beginning when it's solvable you're
going to find out eventually might as
well find out when you can take action
Fountain life also has an entire side of
Therapeutics we look around the world
for the most Advanced Therapeutics that
can add 10 20 healthy years to your life
and we provide them to you at our
centers so if this is of interest to you
please go and check it out go to
Fountain
life.com back/ Peter when Tony and I
wrote our New York Times bestseller life
force we had 30,000 people reached out
to us for Fountain life memberships if
you go to Fountain life.com back/ Peter
will put you to the top of the list
really it's something that is um for me
one of the most important things I offer
my entire family the CEOs of my
companies my friends it's a chance to
really add decades onto our healthy
lifespans go to fountainlife
decomp it's one of the most important
things I can offer to you as one of my
listeners all right let's go back to our
episode you know I can't imagine anybody
who's done a better job peering into the
future by actually creating the future
I'm curious how far out do you think
you're able to see how many years out
Beyond Today given the speed of
change
well when when things are changing
rapidly the the ability to predict the
future I think is uh becomes a lot
hotter because of the rate of change is
so great
um but I think some things are fairly
obvious to predict which is that we'll
have um AI or AI That's at a level that
it can really do almost any cognitive I
think really not almost really any
cognitive task that's just a question
when one could debate is it you know
smarter than any human at the end of
next year or is it two years or 3 years
but it's not more than five years that's
for sure um so um yeah and get
prediction predictions predictions I'm
sort of say giving predictions at the
50th percentile of probability so not
not not like it will definitely happen
but if you say what if you ask me like
what's the 50th
percentile um where it's like you know
your kind of over under is kind of even
that that's where I why why I I think
it's probably end of next year before AI
can do better than any individual human
could do um and then uh but there's it's
it's a much higher bar to say well is it
small than um you know human
intelligence collectively but if the
rate of change continues uh that's why I
think probably 2029 or maybe 2030 is
where
um digital intelligence will probably
exceed uh all human intelligence
combined um and and I think it's always
helpful to look at these like
fundamental ratios um you know sort of
physics first principles approach to to
looking at things and um and and
probabilistic yeah and and probabilistic
yeah so yeah it's probabilistic so um
the
uh yeah so um if you look at the ratio
of digital to biological compute so like
like you know all all of say all of the
higher level cognitive if you sum up the
higher level cognitive capacity of of
humans um and then what is the and think
of that as compute then uh well and then
compare that to what what is the uh
digital compute um and the rate at which
this is growing is just bugles the mind
so that's why I think it's you know I
think 2029 or 2030 or thereabouts is is
a it's not a that's I think a reasonable
time frame for where you'd expect the
the cumulative digital compute to
probably exceed the cumulative
biological compute of higher level brain
functions um and then from from then
forever yeah and still and in
dispatching and and uh diverging forever
from there
yeah and and then yeah where do things
go from there I I don't know probably
continues um the I we are moving from
you say if you look at the the living
factors you know the what what is the
constraint on growth um you like last
year it was clearly uh AI chips were the
constraint on growth um then then this
year the one of the biggest constraints
maybe the biggest constraints on on
growth um are voltage step down
Transformers because you know the the
just just getting the power from like a
utility at 300 kilovolts all the way
down to below one volt for the computer
is is a massive amount of voltage uh
step down so it's it's a you know my
sort of very Niche and perhaps not that
funny joke is uh that uh we need
Transformers for Transformers um so we
need voltage Transformers or AI you know
neural net Transformers um that that is
literally the issue uh this year um and
then if we're saying like next year and
years beyond that it's actually just
it's going to be constraints on um
electrical
power um and you've got uh both AI with
very big demands for electrical power
and the transition to sustainable energy
with electric vehicles whatnot also
needing electrical power so it's uh it's
just a lot a lot of electrical power
needs
you know Elon one of
the one of the things that you said
early on when you when you founded
neuralink um which has been amazing
congratulations on that um and we talked
about this with Rey yesterday talked
about high bandwidth BCI uh was I
wouldn't put words in your mouth but I
would say it would be more along the
lines if you can't beat them join them
um when it comes to uh uh you know
merging the neocortex and the cloud can
you I I'm looking forward to it I'm just
curious what your thoughts are about uh
what's driving that I mean add adding
adding that additional uh computational
capacity and sensory capacity to the
neocortex yeah I mean again this is
actually something that in Banks uh in
the culture books which I really
recommend everyone read um that in the
uh culture books there's uh something
called a neural lace so all the humans
have neural lace that's kind
[Music]
of um a very essentially A high
bandwidth uh brain to computer interface
um and
um in at least in the culture books the
it's so good that it actually retains
all of your memories and kind of brain
state so even if your physical body dies
you can kind of re reincorporate in
another physical body and retain you
know pretty much your original memories
and and brain State um
so now is long way from that um we only
just had our first um uh neural link and
a human which is going it's going quite
well um the uh the first patient is
actually able to uh control their
computer uh just by thinking so like
this first the first uh product we call
telepathy where you can control your
computer and phone and through and
through your computer and phone almost
anything just just by thinking you just
lie there and think and you can move the
the mouse coaster around the screen and
things and like you know the we're g to
do patient has agreed to do sort of a uh
like I think a live demo of just it is
qu quadriplegic uh where he literally is
just controlling the the screen he can
like um play video games download
software uh like really anything you can
do with a mouse um just by
thinking um which is pretty wild it it
is it is pretty wild uh let let's turn
to one
last I should say there's a long way to
go from that to uh a whole brain
interface so our current uh neur link
just has a th000 electrodes I think
ultimately you need something which
which has you know probably 100,000 or
or a million electrodes now these are
very tiny very tiny electrodes that
they're tiny wires way smaller than a
human hair um and um you know so there's
this I I just want to emphasize a long
way from from where NE link is today to
having a whole brain interface like um
like the neural a and the Ian Banks uh
novels uh but this this is definitely
physically
possible um and um you know it's sort of
kind of like if you can't beat him join
him you
know um so you know a human brain which
is has a lot of constraints it's you
know it's it's yeah they only have about
maybe 10 watts of higher brain function
um and uh we do a lot with our little 10
watts it's not you know it's impressive
you know that we we' we've buil with um
such a low power computer
really it you know I sort of think it's
like it's it's not bad for a bunch of
monkeys you know
um I'll get some good laughs from that
we've all watched you go from the uh the
Roadster to the model 3 and Y and and
from Falcon 1 to Starship so I think
going from the first implants to uh
something that's got more capacity it's
just just a matter of if not when or a
matter of when not if right hey everyone
I want to take a quick break from this
episode to tell you about a health
product that I love and that I use every
day in fact I use it twice a day it
seeds DS1 daily symbiotic hopefully by
now you understand that your microbiome
and your gut health are one of the most
important modifiable parts of your
health you know your gut microbiome is
connected to everything your brain
health your cardiac health your
metabolic health so the question is what
are you doing to optimize your gut let
me take a moment to tell you about what
I'm doing every day I take two capsules
of seeds ds01 daily symbiotic it's a
2in1 probiotic biotic and Prebiotic
formulation that supports digested
Health gut health skin Health heart
health and more it contains 24
clinically and scientifically proven
probiotic strains that are delivered in
a patented capsule that actually
protects the contents from your stomach
acid and ensures that 100% of it is
survivable reaching your colon now if
you want to try seed DS1 daily symbiotic
for yourself you can get 25% off your
first month supply by using the code
peter2 checkout just go to seed.com
moonshots and enter the code Peter 25
checkout that's seed.com
moonshots and use the code Peter 25 to
get your 25% off the first month of
seeds daily symbiotic trust me your gut
will thank you all right let's go back
to the episode um let's talk to I think
ultimately like said you'll have uh like
um you'll have uh kind of a whole brain
interface U that uh I guess is a sort of
perhaps a form of immortality and and
that if if it can um
uh kind of upload your brain State uh to
you know if your brain state is
essentially stored um you're kind of
backed up on a hard drive I suppose um
then uh you know you can always restore
that brain State into a a biological
body or or or maybe a robot or something
um and I want to emphasize again it's
like you know many years in the future
but but I I we're not breaking any laws
of physics like I think this is this is
probably something that will happen
um the
rate we're building digital super
intelligence it may just be that you
know we'll have digital super
intelligence and it'll just solve the
solve the problem for us um but uh in in
the meantime uh we we'll progressing
with our meat computerss and trying to
try to do do as good job as possible
that's was going to say the uh uh the
the tools that we have are growing at a
super exponential rate that are making
our linear projections of the future
seem boring in some
ways what one last topic my friend uh
which is where you and I first connected
in the world of space congratulations on
Starship 3 uh amazing amazing flight
just really spectacular and we all saw
uh a falcon 9 launch from Vandenberg
last night uh so that was great and uh
oh yeah um uh just again thankful for
the work you're doing you know I it's
fascinating because I grew up at the
late stages of the Apollo and into into
the uh into the uh uh shuttle program
and I can't imagine that any government
would be pushing space as rapidly and
dramatically as you are and so um uh
thank you for what you're doing there
that's all I can say uh absolutely well
I mean the the goal of SpaceX is is it's
just a a much bigger goal than any any
government program which is to
um uh rockets and spacecraft that are
capable of making life
multiplanetary so you know I mean step
one is actually having that as a goal if
you don't have that as a goal you're
definitely not going achieve it um if
you have it as a goal well now at least
you have a chance of achieving it um and
this the thing about Starship is it is
it is the the first rocket where uh
making life multiplanetary and you have
building a self-sustaining City on Mars
is uh is at least possible um uh it's
still obviously an immense amount of
work but but it is the first rocket word
um that is success of in making like
multi plator is at least one of the
possible
outcomes yeah
um I'm wondering if you're willing to
venture a guess on when you'll be on the
moon I think pretty soon
um I'd be surprised if it's if it's
longer than about 3 years uh to be
landing Starships on the moon um and uh
because the rate progression of Starship
is very rapid um you know we're hoping
to do at least uh another maybe five or
six flights this year and with each
successive flight making significant
improvements uh so I think we got a
decent shot of achieving um full
reusability of both stages uh the
booster and the ship uh this year um and
if not this year I think you know knock
on with it's like I think it's a very
high probability of achieving full
reusability uh next year which um really
is the fundamental breakthrough needed
to make life
multiplanetary
um
yeah for for those that that that that
don't don't know the rocket industry
that that well that they may not be
aware that that that this is really the
Holy Grail of rocketry is is full full
and Rapid reusability um because at that
point you're uh you're really just
constrained by your um propellant costs
and Starship you know almost 80% of
pallet is liquid oxygen which is very
low cost um and then the fuel is met
there sort of a little over 20% fuel
which is methane was the lowest cost
fuel so if you have um full rapid
reability uh then um your actual cost
per flight of Starship uh even though
it's it'll be capable of um we think
ultimately 200 tons to uh to orbit uh
will be maybe the
FL say you miss say 200,000 you
said the the the price of the fuel you
said for Starship flight would be how
much yeah the the the I
mean if Most states are um reusable and
with without a refurbishment then you or
without you know you'd have scheduled
maintenance just like a an aircraft but
uh with with if if you get to full
reusability where there's no um no work
required between fights then you you you
you then
um the cost you know is really uh you
the cost of repellent is maybe a million
dollars or less per flight um so then
it's
U number of
flights
magude better
than any
vehicle anybody listen I'm so grateful
thank you for your time today thank you
for not taking my advice when I tried to
get you to uh fund the original X prise
instead of starting SpaceX and uh and
you know everybody here in the room has
a we call a massive transformative
purpose in a moonshot and it's uh we're
living in a day where people can make a
you know to use Steve's word Steve Jobs
words the dent in the universe and
nobody's making a bigger Dent than you
um thank
you thank you for everything let's give
it up for Elon
[Music]
Musk
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This video features a discussion with Elon Musk about the development of AI, the future of human intelligence and augmentation through Neuralink, and the progress of SpaceX in achieving multiplanetary capabilities.
Videos recently processed by our community