HomeVideos

Time to Short the S&P 500?

Now Playing

Time to Short the S&P 500?

Transcript

466 segments

0:00

So, is it finally time to short the S&P

0:02

500 and to bet on a bigger decline from

0:05

current levels? Well, Bank of America

0:07

seems to think so. So, in this article

0:09

that came out on the 11th of April, it

0:12

says Bank of America is advising that

0:14

investors short the S&P 500. Now, for

0:17

those of you who don't know, to short is

0:19

to short sell, which to is to bet

0:22

against the market. So, if the market

0:23

goes down, you make a lot of money. If

0:25

the market goes up, you lose a lot of

0:27

money. So, their chief investment

0:29

strategist, Michael Harnett, said the US

0:32

is moving away from the world's main buy

0:34

of goods and the go-to place for global

0:37

investments. And he called this shift

0:39

the end of US exceptionalism and the

0:42

start of a US rejection period. So, get

0:44

out, sell everything. So, should we

0:45

listen to this advice? Let's find out in

0:47

this video.

0:49

[Music]

0:59

Now, before I analyze the markets and to

1:01

see if it's a good time to short the

1:03

markets, always remember that in the

1:05

long run, the market, the stock market

1:07

will always go up in the long run.

1:08

Because in the long run, corporate

1:10

earnings will always grow at about 8%,

1:12

you add in share buybacks and dividends

1:14

and money supply, you get about 10%

1:16

return a year over the long run. But in

1:19

the short term, remember that no one can

1:21

predict the direction of the market with

1:23

100% certainty because anything can

1:26

happen and there are too many moving

1:27

parts. So any kind of short-term

1:29

prediction is really based on

1:31

probability and there's no 100%. So if

1:34

you do want to short the markets after

1:36

this video, uh remember to always have a

1:38

stop-loss because if you don't short

1:40

with a stop loss, your loss is

1:41

unlimited. Okay, so let's get down to

1:43

it. So let's take a look at a few

1:45

things. The first thing is let's take a

1:46

look at the technical chart patterns.

1:49

And uh by the way, for those of you who

1:52

think that the S&P 500 is in a bare

1:54

market, it is not in a bare market.

1:57

Well, at least not yet. Now, remember

1:58

the definition of a bare market is when

2:01

the price closes, drops, and closes 20%

2:06

from the high of the market. So, what

2:08

happened to the S&P 500 was it got very

2:10

close to a bare market. So on this day

2:12

it actually dropped over 20%. But by the

2:15

end of the day it closed above 20%. So

2:18

since then uh it's not closed below 20%.

2:21

So technically the S&P 500 is still in a

2:25

bull market. Now having said that the

2:27

technical pattern show that the market

2:29

is in a confirmed downtrend both in the

2:32

shortterm frame and the medium-term

2:34

frame. So you can see over here the 20

2:37

EMA which is the red thin line is below

2:40

the 40 EMA the blue thin line. So that

2:43

signals that yeah we are in a downtrend

2:45

as you can see a wave up a wave down

2:48

wave up wave down and now wave up. So it

2:51

is making lower highs and making lower

2:54

lows. So we are in a downtrend. Now, at

2:57

the same time, you can see the 50 moving

2:59

average in blue, the thick blue line,

3:01

has crossed below the 150 moving

3:04

average, signaling a medium-term

3:06

downtrend. And some of you would know

3:08

that when the 50 crosses below the 200,

3:10

they say that, oh, that is a death

3:11

cross. So, technically, yeah, we are in

3:14

a downtrend. And remember that in a

3:16

downtrend, prices don't drop in a

3:18

straight line. They still move in wave

3:21

patterns. Wave again, wave down, wave

3:24

up, wave down, wave up, wave down. So

3:26

you can see that it has formed that

3:28

pattern, right? We've got a first wave

3:29

down and then we've got a wave up that

3:32

found resistance at the 200 day moving

3:34

average, wave down again, then wave up,

3:37

found resistance at the 20 EMA, then

3:41

wave down, and now wave up. And right

3:45

now, you can see that uh the candle that

3:48

just closed yesterday closed below the

3:50

20 EMA. So based on technical patterns

3:55

you can see that there is a level of

3:58

resistance at the 20 EMA. So that's the

4:01

first level of resistance. So for people

4:03

who think that you know the downtrend is

4:05

in force then yeah this could be a good

4:09

place to short the market where you

4:11

could place an order to short the market

4:13

if the price breaks below the low of

4:15

this candle but to put a stop loss above

4:18

that swing high. So this could be a

4:20

possible short entry. And again,

4:22

whenever you want to short a stock or

4:24

short the market, you place a stop loss,

4:27

you calculate your risk-to-reward

4:28

ratios. So that if the market goes up,

4:30

hits the stop loss, you lose, you know,

4:32

1 hour, but if it goes down, you can

4:34

make 2 hour, 3 hour. All right? So I

4:36

wouldn't say that uh this is completely

4:39

a bad trade. It is a reasonable uh short

4:42

trade if you are thinking the downtrend

4:44

is going to continue. Now at the same

4:46

time you also notice that if you connect

4:48

this swing high to this swing high this

4:50

is also a level of resistance. So if it

4:55

breaks above this level which is the 20

4:58

EMA then could find this uh trend line

5:01

resistance before it comes down again if

5:04

you think the downtrend is going to

5:05

continue. All right. So I think

5:07

basically that is the short thesis from

5:09

a technical

5:11

perspective. But as you know when you

5:13

analyze the markets you have to look at

5:15

two sides of the coin. Okay. So that's

5:17

the bearish thesis technically. How

5:19

about the more bullish thesis? And at

5:22

the end you judge which is stronger.

5:25

Now, if you take a look on the other

5:26

hand at the higher time frame, which are

5:29

the weekly candles, it tells you a

5:32

slightly more bullish picture. On the

5:35

weekly time frame, you can see that this

5:37

was a major swing low that was made

5:40

somewhere in August. And right now, we

5:43

have got the market going down and um

5:46

going below this recent swing low and

5:49

closing back above that swing low with a

5:52

strong bullish candle. This is what we

5:53

call a bear trap. Uh it's also called a

5:57

force bottom as my buddy Elson True

6:00

likes to call it or simply a force

6:02

double bottom pattern. So this is

6:04

actually quite a bullish signal on the

6:08

uh weekly candles, right? So based on

6:11

this, we may see a uh rebound back up

6:15

there based on the weekly candle. So

6:16

sometimes the daily time frame could be

6:19

bearish but the weekly time frame could

6:22

be bullish and say which one do I listen

6:24

to? Okay. Well, generally the higher

6:28

time frame patterns are stronger than

6:30

the lower time frame patterns. Reason to

6:32

be bearish one, reason to be bullish

6:35

one. So from a technical perspective, I

6:38

would say that uh it's still a 50/50 of

6:42

where the market's going to go in the

6:43

short term. However, let's take a look

6:46

at something which I think is more

6:47

powerful. If you listen to the interview

6:49

by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent in

6:52

the last I think it was yesterday or day

6:54

before, he gave a very interesting clue

6:57

about where he thinks the market is

6:58

going to go in the short term. Now, say

6:59

why should I listen to him? Well, first

7:01

of all, he's a Treasury Secretary, which

7:03

is no big deal, right? But I think

7:04

what's a bigger deal that Scott Bessant

7:06

is probably one of the smartest guys in

7:08

finance in the administration. So for

7:11

those of you who don't know, he used to

7:13

be a hedge fund manager who worked

7:15

together with George Soros and they made

7:17

billions of dollars shorting the British

7:19

pound back in the 1980s. So he's one of

7:22

the uh few treasury secretaries that's

7:25

not more of an not really an academic

7:27

but he's a practitioner in terms of the

7:29

market. So it is worth at least

7:32

listening to what he says. So this is

7:33

what he said in a recent interview. He

7:35

said if we measure the uncertainty of

7:38

the market by the VIX, the VIX is the

7:40

volatility index. I don't want to make

7:42

market calls. That's what he says. But

7:45

it seems the VIX has spiked and likely

7:47

peaked. So what he's saying is that I

7:49

don't want to make a market call, but

7:51

he's making a market call. Okay. Now, if

7:53

you read between the lines, what he's

7:55

trying to tell you is that the market

7:58

has already bottomed. Now again, can we

8:00

completely trust them? Of course not.

8:02

They may have an agenda, right? But let

8:05

me talk a bit about why I find this very

8:06

interesting. Now if you don't know the

8:08

VIX is known as a volatility index and

8:11

it's also known as a fear index. So when

8:13

people are scared when there's a lot of

8:15

fear the VIX goes up. So when the VIX is

8:18

very high it's a measure of extreme

8:19

fear. When the VIX goes down it means

8:22

people are no longer fearful. Now you

8:24

will notice a very interesting pattern

8:26

in the markets of how the market bottoms

8:30

correlate with VIX movements. Let's take

8:32

a look. Now last week the VIX went above

8:36

60. Now let me show you this chart. This

8:38

chart that you see over here this is the

8:40

VIX the volatility index and you can see

8:43

this is the 60 level. Watch this level

8:47

very important the 60 level and watch

8:48

the 35 level and I'll explain why in a

8:50

short while. So like I said last week

8:53

the VIX went above 60 and that signifies

8:58

extreme fear. People were scared

9:01

shitless. Now, it's very rare that the

9:03

VIX goes above 60. In fact, in the last

9:06

35 years since 1990, the VIX has only

9:10

gone above 60 uh three times uh

9:14

excluding this time. So, total four

9:16

times, right? So, you can see that the

9:18

one time it went above 60 just before

9:20

this was last year, August 2024 during

9:24

the Japanese uh stock market crash went

9:26

above 60 during COVID the COVID

9:29

pandemic. People were scared shitless.

9:31

it went above 60 during the great

9:34

financial crisis of 2008 2009 it went

9:37

above 60. Now what's interesting is

9:40

during the dotcom crash in 2000 the VIX

9:44

did not go above 60. In fact they even

9:46

come close to going above 60 but it did

9:48

go above 45. Right? So that tells you

9:51

that in the old days people had bigger

9:53

balls than they do have today. We a

9:55

bunch of today. Okay. Now you

9:57

may say so why is this important?

9:59

because I found an interesting pattern

10:01

that whenever the VIX goes above 60 and

10:05

then drops below 35, it usually signals

10:08

the bottom of the crash. Let me show you

10:10

what I'm talking about. So, first of

10:12

all, you can see that the chart below,

10:14

this is the S&P 500 and the chart above

10:18

that is the VIX. So, let's go back to uh

10:21

the great financial crisis of 2008 2009.

10:24

So, you can see that this was the

10:26

financial crisis. The market went into a

10:28

bare market over here and then it

10:30

bottomed here. There was a bottom and

10:32

then the bull market started. So you can

10:34

see that when the market was going down,

10:36

people were losing their Ah,

10:38

right. They all scared shitless, right?

10:40

And what happened to the VIX? You can

10:42

see that the

10:43

VIX uh went above 60 right there. Okay,

10:47

went above 60. People like scared

10:48

shitless. Now again, what's important is

10:51

to watch when it drops below 35. 35 is a

10:56

magic number. So you can see that right

10:58

it d and then it dropped below 35 right

11:02

here. Can you see that? Okay. And if you

11:06

bought there that would have been buying

11:09

right near the bottom. Okay. Now and

11:13

then it dropped below 35 again here. And

11:16

by that by that time the market would

11:19

have already gone up uh quite a bit but

11:21

you would still have gotten in early in

11:23

the bull market. So that was the GFC of

11:27

2009.

11:28

Now the next instance when the VIX uh

11:32

went above 60 was COVID that happened 5

11:35

years ago if you recall. So again we

11:36

have COVID crash. Ah right people losing

11:39

their again. And then we got the

11:41

VIX the fear index measuring fear and

11:43

panic went above 60. Again very rare

11:47

happened only four times in the last 35

11:49

years including this time. But again

11:53

what's the magic number? magic number is

11:54

drops below 35. So when did it drop

11:57

below 35? It dropped below 35 actually

12:00

right there this week. All right. And if

12:03

you entered there, you would have

12:04

entered here. Not exactly at the bottom,

12:08

but you would have gotten in again early

12:11

enough to write the new bull market over

12:14

there. So that was 2020.

12:17

And then let's look at 2024 moving

12:20

closer to where we are today which was

12:22

the Japanese uh black market crash uh

12:26

caused by the unwinding of the yen carry

12:28

trade. This happened August last year.

12:30

Now bear in mind I'm looking at weekly

12:32

candles. These are weekly candles and

12:34

you can see that for a very brief moment

12:36

what happened? Yep. The VIX spiked up

12:39

went above 60 extreme fear and then

12:42

within that same week it dropped back

12:45

below 35. And that again signal the

12:48

bottom of the S&P 500. If you got in

12:50

right there, uh you would have rode the

12:52

bull market all the way back up. So

12:54

where are we now? So right now we are

12:56

here right the market has dropped ah

12:59

this year 2025 and the VIX has spiked up

13:03

to just above 60. And guess what? Have

13:07

we gone below 35? Yes we have. We have

13:11

just dropped below 35. And this is what

13:15

Scott Bessant was probably talking about

13:18

that he says the VIX has peaked and his

13:21

hint is the market has

13:23

bottom. So again, is this a guarantee

13:25

100% go all in? No, there are no

13:27

guarantees in the market. In the short

13:29

term, anything can happen. This is just

13:32

a probability. But I think it's a pretty

13:34

good probability. Okay. So if you ask me

13:36

to short the market, I'll think twice.

13:39

Okay. Now uh how about let me show you

13:44

the uh.com crash in uh 2001. Now like I

13:48

said during the com crash that was a

13:50

bare market but the VIX never went above

13:52

60. And don't ask me why. I guess people

13:54

were not as scared that time. They were

13:56

like you know don't worry we're okay

13:58

right? So let's look take a look at

14:00

that. So this was again the bare market

14:02

of 2001 2002 and again if you look at a

14:06

VIX it did not uh go above 60 but it did

14:10

go above 45 which is quite scared still.

14:14

All right 60 is scared shitless. 45 is

14:17

scared with a bit of left. Right.

14:20

So you can see that uh it went above 45

14:24

right there. Can you see that right

14:26

there? It went above 45. And again, same

14:28

rule. We want to get in when it drops

14:31

below 35. So went above 45 and it

14:35

dropped below 35 right here. Okay? And

14:39

lo and

14:42

behold, that was somewhere here. Now,

14:46

was it exactly at the bottom of the

14:47

market? No. We can't always buy right at

14:49

the bottom, but as long as we buy, you

14:51

know, near the bottom, you know, plus or

14:53

minus a few, five, 10% is pretty good,

14:55

right? So if you got in there, you may

14:57

have seen like a bit of a double bottom

14:58

pattern, but then you have gotten in

15:02

uh way before the huge bull run took the

15:05

market higher. So once again, in in the

15:07

short term, no one can predict for sure

15:09

where the market is going. There are too

15:10

many uh unknown variables. You don't

15:13

know what C or Trump's going to say the

15:15

next day. But we look at probabilities.

15:17

We look at technical patterns. We look

15:18

at the VIX. We look at all kinds of

15:20

stuff. And by looking at all kinds of

15:21

stuff, am I 100% convinced that I'm

15:24

going to short the market? Not really.

15:26

Right. So, in fact, if anything, I'm

15:27

still leaning slightly bullish in the

15:30

short term, but of course, in the long

15:32

run, I'm always bullish. People say,

15:35

"Edom, you're permable." Yes, thank you.

15:37

I am a permable because I know in the

15:39

long run, the market always goes up. And

15:40

remember that if you're not too

15:42

interested in, you know, trading the

15:44

short term, you can ignore everything I

15:46

just said and just buy good companies

15:49

that are at a discount. And that's what

15:51

I did, you know, the last couple of uh

15:54

uh days. In fact, last week, you know,

15:55

added to my Nvidia, I added to Meta, I

15:58

added to Microsoft, I bought more

16:00

Mastercard, I bought more S&P Global,

16:03

and I added some new stocks like Idex

16:05

Laboratory. So, I use this opportunity

16:07

to add more shares of high quality

16:10

companies. And even if it does go down a

16:12

bit more, I mean, who the hell cares,

16:13

right? Long run, it always goes up. So

16:15

you know people always tell me Adam I

16:18

will only buy

16:19

stocks when there are no problems in the

16:22

world when all the crisis are resolved.

16:25

Now will that ever happen? Okay. Will

16:27

your life ever have no problems? Yes.

16:31

It's called death. The day you're in the

16:32

graveyard you got no more problems. As

16:34

long as you're alive you will always

16:36

have problems. Same thing in the stock

16:38

market. The stock market will always

16:40

have a crisis it's worried about.

16:42

There's always something to worry about

16:45

about and there's always a smart reason

16:47

people tell you to sell or short the

16:49

market. But as I always say,

16:51

macroeconomic or geopolitical factors

16:54

should never be a reason to sell the

16:55

market. And in the words of the great

16:58

Peter Lynch, he said, "Your ultimate

17:00

success or failure to build wealth will

17:03

depend on your ability to ignore the

17:06

worries of the world long enough to

17:09

allow your investments to succeed. If

17:12

you take a look at this 15-year period

17:14

when the S&P 500 gained

17:17

830%.

17:18

830%. But most people would not have

17:21

been able to compound their wealth at

17:24

800%. Why? Because there was so many

17:26

reasons to sell. It was so many things

17:28

to be scared of. If you take a look at

17:30

all these you know crisis that happen

17:33

whether S&P downgrades US debt or Ebola

17:37

virus or US government shutdown or there

17:39

was an earnings recession or you have

17:42

got the uh yield curve inversion over

17:45

there. You got the COVID pandemic. You

17:47

have the storming of the US capital.

17:48

You've got a delta variant. You've got

17:50

Omicron variant. Russian invasion of

17:52

Ukraine. S&P enters a bare market here.

17:55

US inflation hits a 40-year high.

17:57

collapse of Silicon Valley Bank. You've

18:00

got China ever ever grand group

18:02

collapsing. US national debt tops 35

18:05

trillion. You've got a Sam rule

18:07

recession indicator trigger. If you read

18:09

all this news, you'll be scared out of

18:12

the markets and you'll never have the

18:15

chance to compound your wealth. All

18:16

right? So, think long term, but in a

18:19

short term, again, if you want to trade,

18:20

that's great. Have a stop-loss in place,

18:22

have profit targets in place, but only

18:24

take high probability trades. Thank you

18:26

for listening and I'll see you guys in

18:27

the next video. May the markets be with

18:29

you. If you want to catch my latest

18:30

videos, click on the subscribe button

18:32

right now. Click on the bell so you get

18:35

instant notifications once I upload my

18:37

latest video. If you want to check out

18:39

my online courses, go to

18:42

piranhaprofits.com where you're going to

18:43

learn how to invest and how to trade the

18:45

financial markets and create an income

18:47

from all around the world. If you want

18:50

to join my live Wealth Academy program,

18:52

go on to wealthacademy global.com and

18:55

find out more about how you can learn

18:56

investing and trading live online. This

18:59

is Adam Coup and may the markets be with

Interactive Summary

The video analyzes whether investors should short the S&P 500 following Bank of America's recommendation to do so. While examining technical indicators that suggest a potential downtrend, the presenter also highlights a bullish case based on historical volatility index (VIX) patterns, which often indicate market bottoms when the index drops below 35 after a major spike. Ultimately, the speaker argues against shorting and advocates for a long-term investment perspective, emphasizing that investors should ignore short-term geopolitical and macroeconomic fears to successfully build wealth.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts