Time to Short the S&P 500?
466 segments
So, is it finally time to short the S&P
500 and to bet on a bigger decline from
current levels? Well, Bank of America
seems to think so. So, in this article
that came out on the 11th of April, it
says Bank of America is advising that
investors short the S&P 500. Now, for
those of you who don't know, to short is
to short sell, which to is to bet
against the market. So, if the market
goes down, you make a lot of money. If
the market goes up, you lose a lot of
money. So, their chief investment
strategist, Michael Harnett, said the US
is moving away from the world's main buy
of goods and the go-to place for global
investments. And he called this shift
the end of US exceptionalism and the
start of a US rejection period. So, get
out, sell everything. So, should we
listen to this advice? Let's find out in
this video.
[Music]
Now, before I analyze the markets and to
see if it's a good time to short the
markets, always remember that in the
long run, the market, the stock market
will always go up in the long run.
Because in the long run, corporate
earnings will always grow at about 8%,
you add in share buybacks and dividends
and money supply, you get about 10%
return a year over the long run. But in
the short term, remember that no one can
predict the direction of the market with
100% certainty because anything can
happen and there are too many moving
parts. So any kind of short-term
prediction is really based on
probability and there's no 100%. So if
you do want to short the markets after
this video, uh remember to always have a
stop-loss because if you don't short
with a stop loss, your loss is
unlimited. Okay, so let's get down to
it. So let's take a look at a few
things. The first thing is let's take a
look at the technical chart patterns.
And uh by the way, for those of you who
think that the S&P 500 is in a bare
market, it is not in a bare market.
Well, at least not yet. Now, remember
the definition of a bare market is when
the price closes, drops, and closes 20%
from the high of the market. So, what
happened to the S&P 500 was it got very
close to a bare market. So on this day
it actually dropped over 20%. But by the
end of the day it closed above 20%. So
since then uh it's not closed below 20%.
So technically the S&P 500 is still in a
bull market. Now having said that the
technical pattern show that the market
is in a confirmed downtrend both in the
shortterm frame and the medium-term
frame. So you can see over here the 20
EMA which is the red thin line is below
the 40 EMA the blue thin line. So that
signals that yeah we are in a downtrend
as you can see a wave up a wave down
wave up wave down and now wave up. So it
is making lower highs and making lower
lows. So we are in a downtrend. Now, at
the same time, you can see the 50 moving
average in blue, the thick blue line,
has crossed below the 150 moving
average, signaling a medium-term
downtrend. And some of you would know
that when the 50 crosses below the 200,
they say that, oh, that is a death
cross. So, technically, yeah, we are in
a downtrend. And remember that in a
downtrend, prices don't drop in a
straight line. They still move in wave
patterns. Wave again, wave down, wave
up, wave down, wave up, wave down. So
you can see that it has formed that
pattern, right? We've got a first wave
down and then we've got a wave up that
found resistance at the 200 day moving
average, wave down again, then wave up,
found resistance at the 20 EMA, then
wave down, and now wave up. And right
now, you can see that uh the candle that
just closed yesterday closed below the
20 EMA. So based on technical patterns
you can see that there is a level of
resistance at the 20 EMA. So that's the
first level of resistance. So for people
who think that you know the downtrend is
in force then yeah this could be a good
place to short the market where you
could place an order to short the market
if the price breaks below the low of
this candle but to put a stop loss above
that swing high. So this could be a
possible short entry. And again,
whenever you want to short a stock or
short the market, you place a stop loss,
you calculate your risk-to-reward
ratios. So that if the market goes up,
hits the stop loss, you lose, you know,
1 hour, but if it goes down, you can
make 2 hour, 3 hour. All right? So I
wouldn't say that uh this is completely
a bad trade. It is a reasonable uh short
trade if you are thinking the downtrend
is going to continue. Now at the same
time you also notice that if you connect
this swing high to this swing high this
is also a level of resistance. So if it
breaks above this level which is the 20
EMA then could find this uh trend line
resistance before it comes down again if
you think the downtrend is going to
continue. All right. So I think
basically that is the short thesis from
a technical
perspective. But as you know when you
analyze the markets you have to look at
two sides of the coin. Okay. So that's
the bearish thesis technically. How
about the more bullish thesis? And at
the end you judge which is stronger.
Now, if you take a look on the other
hand at the higher time frame, which are
the weekly candles, it tells you a
slightly more bullish picture. On the
weekly time frame, you can see that this
was a major swing low that was made
somewhere in August. And right now, we
have got the market going down and um
going below this recent swing low and
closing back above that swing low with a
strong bullish candle. This is what we
call a bear trap. Uh it's also called a
force bottom as my buddy Elson True
likes to call it or simply a force
double bottom pattern. So this is
actually quite a bullish signal on the
uh weekly candles, right? So based on
this, we may see a uh rebound back up
there based on the weekly candle. So
sometimes the daily time frame could be
bearish but the weekly time frame could
be bullish and say which one do I listen
to? Okay. Well, generally the higher
time frame patterns are stronger than
the lower time frame patterns. Reason to
be bearish one, reason to be bullish
one. So from a technical perspective, I
would say that uh it's still a 50/50 of
where the market's going to go in the
short term. However, let's take a look
at something which I think is more
powerful. If you listen to the interview
by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent in
the last I think it was yesterday or day
before, he gave a very interesting clue
about where he thinks the market is
going to go in the short term. Now, say
why should I listen to him? Well, first
of all, he's a Treasury Secretary, which
is no big deal, right? But I think
what's a bigger deal that Scott Bessant
is probably one of the smartest guys in
finance in the administration. So for
those of you who don't know, he used to
be a hedge fund manager who worked
together with George Soros and they made
billions of dollars shorting the British
pound back in the 1980s. So he's one of
the uh few treasury secretaries that's
not more of an not really an academic
but he's a practitioner in terms of the
market. So it is worth at least
listening to what he says. So this is
what he said in a recent interview. He
said if we measure the uncertainty of
the market by the VIX, the VIX is the
volatility index. I don't want to make
market calls. That's what he says. But
it seems the VIX has spiked and likely
peaked. So what he's saying is that I
don't want to make a market call, but
he's making a market call. Okay. Now, if
you read between the lines, what he's
trying to tell you is that the market
has already bottomed. Now again, can we
completely trust them? Of course not.
They may have an agenda, right? But let
me talk a bit about why I find this very
interesting. Now if you don't know the
VIX is known as a volatility index and
it's also known as a fear index. So when
people are scared when there's a lot of
fear the VIX goes up. So when the VIX is
very high it's a measure of extreme
fear. When the VIX goes down it means
people are no longer fearful. Now you
will notice a very interesting pattern
in the markets of how the market bottoms
correlate with VIX movements. Let's take
a look. Now last week the VIX went above
60. Now let me show you this chart. This
chart that you see over here this is the
VIX the volatility index and you can see
this is the 60 level. Watch this level
very important the 60 level and watch
the 35 level and I'll explain why in a
short while. So like I said last week
the VIX went above 60 and that signifies
extreme fear. People were scared
shitless. Now, it's very rare that the
VIX goes above 60. In fact, in the last
35 years since 1990, the VIX has only
gone above 60 uh three times uh
excluding this time. So, total four
times, right? So, you can see that the
one time it went above 60 just before
this was last year, August 2024 during
the Japanese uh stock market crash went
above 60 during COVID the COVID
pandemic. People were scared shitless.
it went above 60 during the great
financial crisis of 2008 2009 it went
above 60. Now what's interesting is
during the dotcom crash in 2000 the VIX
did not go above 60. In fact they even
come close to going above 60 but it did
go above 45. Right? So that tells you
that in the old days people had bigger
balls than they do have today. We a
bunch of today. Okay. Now you
may say so why is this important?
because I found an interesting pattern
that whenever the VIX goes above 60 and
then drops below 35, it usually signals
the bottom of the crash. Let me show you
what I'm talking about. So, first of
all, you can see that the chart below,
this is the S&P 500 and the chart above
that is the VIX. So, let's go back to uh
the great financial crisis of 2008 2009.
So, you can see that this was the
financial crisis. The market went into a
bare market over here and then it
bottomed here. There was a bottom and
then the bull market started. So you can
see that when the market was going down,
people were losing their Ah,
right. They all scared shitless, right?
And what happened to the VIX? You can
see that the
VIX uh went above 60 right there. Okay,
went above 60. People like scared
shitless. Now again, what's important is
to watch when it drops below 35. 35 is a
magic number. So you can see that right
it d and then it dropped below 35 right
here. Can you see that? Okay. And if you
bought there that would have been buying
right near the bottom. Okay. Now and
then it dropped below 35 again here. And
by that by that time the market would
have already gone up uh quite a bit but
you would still have gotten in early in
the bull market. So that was the GFC of
2009.
Now the next instance when the VIX uh
went above 60 was COVID that happened 5
years ago if you recall. So again we
have COVID crash. Ah right people losing
their again. And then we got the
VIX the fear index measuring fear and
panic went above 60. Again very rare
happened only four times in the last 35
years including this time. But again
what's the magic number? magic number is
drops below 35. So when did it drop
below 35? It dropped below 35 actually
right there this week. All right. And if
you entered there, you would have
entered here. Not exactly at the bottom,
but you would have gotten in again early
enough to write the new bull market over
there. So that was 2020.
And then let's look at 2024 moving
closer to where we are today which was
the Japanese uh black market crash uh
caused by the unwinding of the yen carry
trade. This happened August last year.
Now bear in mind I'm looking at weekly
candles. These are weekly candles and
you can see that for a very brief moment
what happened? Yep. The VIX spiked up
went above 60 extreme fear and then
within that same week it dropped back
below 35. And that again signal the
bottom of the S&P 500. If you got in
right there, uh you would have rode the
bull market all the way back up. So
where are we now? So right now we are
here right the market has dropped ah
this year 2025 and the VIX has spiked up
to just above 60. And guess what? Have
we gone below 35? Yes we have. We have
just dropped below 35. And this is what
Scott Bessant was probably talking about
that he says the VIX has peaked and his
hint is the market has
bottom. So again, is this a guarantee
100% go all in? No, there are no
guarantees in the market. In the short
term, anything can happen. This is just
a probability. But I think it's a pretty
good probability. Okay. So if you ask me
to short the market, I'll think twice.
Okay. Now uh how about let me show you
the uh.com crash in uh 2001. Now like I
said during the com crash that was a
bare market but the VIX never went above
60. And don't ask me why. I guess people
were not as scared that time. They were
like you know don't worry we're okay
right? So let's look take a look at
that. So this was again the bare market
of 2001 2002 and again if you look at a
VIX it did not uh go above 60 but it did
go above 45 which is quite scared still.
All right 60 is scared shitless. 45 is
scared with a bit of left. Right.
So you can see that uh it went above 45
right there. Can you see that right
there? It went above 45. And again, same
rule. We want to get in when it drops
below 35. So went above 45 and it
dropped below 35 right here. Okay? And
lo and
behold, that was somewhere here. Now,
was it exactly at the bottom of the
market? No. We can't always buy right at
the bottom, but as long as we buy, you
know, near the bottom, you know, plus or
minus a few, five, 10% is pretty good,
right? So if you got in there, you may
have seen like a bit of a double bottom
pattern, but then you have gotten in
uh way before the huge bull run took the
market higher. So once again, in in the
short term, no one can predict for sure
where the market is going. There are too
many uh unknown variables. You don't
know what C or Trump's going to say the
next day. But we look at probabilities.
We look at technical patterns. We look
at the VIX. We look at all kinds of
stuff. And by looking at all kinds of
stuff, am I 100% convinced that I'm
going to short the market? Not really.
Right. So, in fact, if anything, I'm
still leaning slightly bullish in the
short term, but of course, in the long
run, I'm always bullish. People say,
"Edom, you're permable." Yes, thank you.
I am a permable because I know in the
long run, the market always goes up. And
remember that if you're not too
interested in, you know, trading the
short term, you can ignore everything I
just said and just buy good companies
that are at a discount. And that's what
I did, you know, the last couple of uh
uh days. In fact, last week, you know,
added to my Nvidia, I added to Meta, I
added to Microsoft, I bought more
Mastercard, I bought more S&P Global,
and I added some new stocks like Idex
Laboratory. So, I use this opportunity
to add more shares of high quality
companies. And even if it does go down a
bit more, I mean, who the hell cares,
right? Long run, it always goes up. So
you know people always tell me Adam I
will only buy
stocks when there are no problems in the
world when all the crisis are resolved.
Now will that ever happen? Okay. Will
your life ever have no problems? Yes.
It's called death. The day you're in the
graveyard you got no more problems. As
long as you're alive you will always
have problems. Same thing in the stock
market. The stock market will always
have a crisis it's worried about.
There's always something to worry about
about and there's always a smart reason
people tell you to sell or short the
market. But as I always say,
macroeconomic or geopolitical factors
should never be a reason to sell the
market. And in the words of the great
Peter Lynch, he said, "Your ultimate
success or failure to build wealth will
depend on your ability to ignore the
worries of the world long enough to
allow your investments to succeed. If
you take a look at this 15-year period
when the S&P 500 gained
830%.
830%. But most people would not have
been able to compound their wealth at
800%. Why? Because there was so many
reasons to sell. It was so many things
to be scared of. If you take a look at
all these you know crisis that happen
whether S&P downgrades US debt or Ebola
virus or US government shutdown or there
was an earnings recession or you have
got the uh yield curve inversion over
there. You got the COVID pandemic. You
have the storming of the US capital.
You've got a delta variant. You've got
Omicron variant. Russian invasion of
Ukraine. S&P enters a bare market here.
US inflation hits a 40-year high.
collapse of Silicon Valley Bank. You've
got China ever ever grand group
collapsing. US national debt tops 35
trillion. You've got a Sam rule
recession indicator trigger. If you read
all this news, you'll be scared out of
the markets and you'll never have the
chance to compound your wealth. All
right? So, think long term, but in a
short term, again, if you want to trade,
that's great. Have a stop-loss in place,
have profit targets in place, but only
take high probability trades. Thank you
for listening and I'll see you guys in
the next video. May the markets be with
you. If you want to catch my latest
videos, click on the subscribe button
right now. Click on the bell so you get
instant notifications once I upload my
latest video. If you want to check out
my online courses, go to
piranhaprofits.com where you're going to
learn how to invest and how to trade the
financial markets and create an income
from all around the world. If you want
to join my live Wealth Academy program,
go on to wealthacademy global.com and
find out more about how you can learn
investing and trading live online. This
is Adam Coup and may the markets be with
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
The video analyzes whether investors should short the S&P 500 following Bank of America's recommendation to do so. While examining technical indicators that suggest a potential downtrend, the presenter also highlights a bullish case based on historical volatility index (VIX) patterns, which often indicate market bottoms when the index drops below 35 after a major spike. Ultimately, the speaker argues against shorting and advocates for a long-term investment perspective, emphasizing that investors should ignore short-term geopolitical and macroeconomic fears to successfully build wealth.
Videos recently processed by our community