HomeVideos

Money Printing Explained: Why It’s Different This Time

Now Playing

Money Printing Explained: Why It’s Different This Time

Transcript

549 segments

0:00

The United States government spends

0:02

roughly [music] $2 trillion

0:04

per year more than it takes in. It runs

0:07

entirely on borrowed money.

0:10

So, how exactly is that same country

0:13

able to turn around and lend tens of

0:15

billions of dollars to other nations?

0:18

And the answer starts with a keyboard

0:21

and it ends with the price of your

0:23

groceries. Every week for the past

0:25

month, the same questions keep coming up

0:27

[music] in the comments. Mainly, where

0:30

does this money come from? And this is

0:32

the question behind every headline you

0:34

cannot quite explain. It is the question

0:37

almost nobody in finance or Washington

0:39

will answer plainly. But by the end of

0:40

this video, you will understand the

0:42

answer, the full machine from top to

0:45

bottom.

0:45

>> [music]

0:45

>> And once you can see it, you can't unsee

0:48

it. But first, a story because the

0:50

system that we live in under today is a

0:52

more sophisticated version of a machine

0:54

that was built 300 years ago. In 1716,

0:57

France was [music] broke. The old king,

1:01

Louis XIV, had just died and left the

1:03

country buried under a war debt it could

1:06

never hope to repay. The treasury was

1:08

empty.

1:09

>> [music]

1:09

>> The economy was frozen. And into that

1:12

desperation walked a Scotsman named John

1:15

Law, a gambler, a charmer, a man who had

1:18

once been sentenced to death for killing

1:20

somebody in a duel and had to flee his

1:22

own country to save his own life. Now,

1:25

Law had an idea so seductive that the

1:27

French government handed him the keys to

1:30

the entire economy. And the idea was

1:32

this: Stop using gold as currency. Gold

1:35

is heavy. Gold is scarce. And there is

1:37

never enough of it. Instead, let's

1:39

create our own currency. Let the bank

1:41

print paper money, paper that you can

1:44

create as much of as you need whenever

1:47

you need it. Now, for a while, it was

1:49

magnificent. The paper money flooded

1:51

France. Stock in John Law's companies

1:54

went straight up and ordinary people got

1:56

rich overnight. In fact, the word

1:58

millionaire was coined in Paris during

2:01

these years to describe the people that

2:02

got fabulously wealthy on John Law's

2:05

paper money. So, it worked right up

2:08

until the moment when a few people got

2:09

nervous about the quality of their paper

2:11

money and asked to trade it back in for

2:14

gold. Because here is the thing about

2:16

money that you can create from nothing.

2:18

It works perfectly as long as nobody

2:21

asks for the real thing. But, the second

2:23

people start asking, the illusion

2:25

collapses. And in 1720, it collapsed.

2:28

The paper in France became worthless,

2:30

and France was burned so badly it would

2:32

not trust paper money or even the word

2:35

bank for the better part of a century.

2:37

Now, I want you to hold that story in

2:39

the back of your mind because the system

2:41

that we live under today is a more

2:42

sophisticated version of John Law's

2:45

system, but we simply just got better at

2:48

hiding the gold problem. So, let's get

2:50

back to our question. Where does the

2:52

money come from? Let me start at the

2:54

very bottom because everything else is

2:56

built on top of this. The United States

2:58

government spends more than it collects

3:00

in taxes. Not occasionally, every single

3:03

year by a very wide margin. In a typical

3:06

year today, it spends roughly two

3:08

trillion dollars more than it takes in.

3:11

So, where does that missing two trillion

3:13

dollars come from? Let me tell you, they

3:15

borrow it. The government covers the gap

3:17

by selling IOU's. That's a Treasury

3:20

bond. A Treasury bond is nothing more

3:23

than a promise. Lend the government

3:25

money today and it will pay you back

3:27

later with interest. A two-year bond

3:29

pays you back in two years. A 10-year

3:32

bond in 10. That is the whole product.

3:34

For decades, these IOU's were considered

3:37

the safest investment on Earth because

3:40

everybody assumed the US government

3:42

always pays its debts. So, the world

3:44

lined up to buy them. Other governments,

3:46

pension funds, banks, you and me. So,

3:49

that is the first answer. Where does the

3:51

government's money come from? It borrows

3:53

it by selling bonds, by selling IOUs.

3:57

But that just moves the question back a

3:59

step because now we have to ask, who

4:01

buys the bonds and what happens if not

4:04

enough people want to? And that is where

4:06

this whole thing gets interesting. Now,

4:08

the government does not sell its bonds

4:10

on a website like eBay. It sells them at

4:12

an auction, the same way you would sell

4:14

a painting to whoever bids the highest.

4:18

But here is the part that almost nobody

4:20

knows. The government doesn't simply

4:21

hope that enough buyers show up to buy

4:24

its debt. It has a guaranteed list of

4:26

buyers who are legally required to show

4:30

up and they are called the primary

4:32

dealers. There's about two dozen of

4:34

them, 24 big banks and trading firms

4:37

like JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs. In

4:40

exchange for special access, each one of

4:43

them is obligated to bid at every single

4:46

Treasury auction. These are the buyers

4:49

of first resort. They are the reason the

4:51

auction always clears even on the days

4:53

when real demand is weak. So, picture

4:56

the machine so far. The government needs

4:58

money. It prints up a stack of IOUs and

5:00

holds an auction. The primary dealers

5:03

are forced to bid so the auction clears.

5:06

The government gets the money that it

5:08

needs. Everybody gets to go home. But

5:10

the dealers, those primary dealers,

5:12

don't want to sit on all those bonds,

5:14

all those IOUs. So, they turn around and

5:16

sell them again to everybody else, to

5:19

Japan, to pension funds, to you. This

5:22

reselling happens in what is called the

5:23

secondary market and the secondary

5:26

market is where the real story lives.

5:29

Now, here is the one rule you need to

5:30

understand about this and it is much

5:32

simpler than Wall Street would like you

5:34

to believe. When lots of people want to

5:36

buy bonds, the price goes up and the

5:39

interest rate actually goes down. When

5:41

lots of people want to sell bonds, the

5:43

price goes down but the interest rate

5:45

goes up. Price and interest rate move in

5:48

opposite directions, always. Now, why is

5:51

that the case? Think of it from the

5:52

buyer's side. If a bond pays $50 a year

5:55

in interest, and I can buy it for

5:57

$1,000, that's a 5% return. But, if

6:00

everybody's dumping that same bond, then

6:02

I can scoop it up for 80 cents on the

6:04

dollar, so $800, I'm still getting my

6:07

$50 per year payment, but on a smaller

6:09

outlay. My return just jumped. The

6:12

effective interest rate rose, not

6:15

because the government offered more, but

6:17

because the price of the asset fell, and

6:19

the payment remained the same. Now,

6:21

scale that up. When the world is

6:23

predictable and everybody has confidence

6:25

in the US Treasury market, prices are

6:27

high and the government borrows cheaply.

6:29

But, when holders start selling all at

6:31

once to raise cash, maybe to buy oil on

6:33

the open market, prices fall and the

6:36

interest rate the government has to pay

6:38

on its next round of borrowing climbs.

6:40

The interest rate has a name. Wall

6:42

Street calls it the yield. And, the

6:44

yield is the single most important

6:46

number in the global economy. Now, here

6:48

is a confusion that I see constantly,

6:51

and it's worth clearing up. Most people

6:52

think the Federal Reserve sets the

6:55

interest rates, and it does, but only

6:58

one of them. The Fed sets the overnight

7:00

rate, the base rate, the rate banks

7:02

charge each other to borrow for a single

7:05

night from each other. And, that is the

7:07

rate you hear about on the news when the

7:09

Fed cuts or hikes rates. But, that is

7:12

not the rate that sets your mortgage.

7:15

Your mortgage, your car loan, the rate

7:17

your government pays to borrow for 30

7:19

years, those track the long-term

7:21

Treasury yields, and those yields are

7:23

not set by the Fed. They are set by the

7:26

market, by supply and demand, by buyers

7:29

and sellers every second of every day.

7:31

And, that is why the Fed can cut its

7:32

base rate and mortgages can go up

7:35

anyway. The Fed controls the overnight

7:37

rate, but the market controls the rate

7:40

that actually runs your life. And, when

7:42

the world starts selling US bonds, the

7:45

market drags that rate higher, no matter

7:48

what the Fed wants. So, now you

7:50

understand the engine. The government

7:52

borrows by auction. The primary dealers

7:55

backstop the auction. The bonds trade in

7:58

the secondary market, and supply and

7:59

demand in that market set the price, the

8:02

borrowing cost for the entire economy.

8:05

There is just one problem. What happens

8:07

when the selling gets so heavy that the

8:10

yield climbs to a level that the

8:12

government cannot afford? And this is

8:14

where money is actually created. When

8:16

real buyers will not show up at a price

8:18

the government can live with, when the

8:20

yield threatens to spiral, the Federal

8:23

Reserve steps in and buys the bonds

8:25

themselves, keeping price high and rates

8:28

low. And the Fed does not buy them with

8:30

money it earned, or money it taxed, or

8:33

money it borrowed. It buys them with

8:35

money it creates on the spot. Somebody

8:37

at the Federal Reserve enters a number

8:39

into a computer, and dollars that did

8:41

not exist 1 second ago exist now. The

8:43

Fed uses those brand new dollars to buy

8:45

the bonds nobody else wants, which props

8:48

the price back up and pushes the yield

8:50

back down. There's no printing press,

8:52

there's just a keyboard. That's all it

8:53

takes. The primary dealers are the buyer

8:55

of first resort. The Federal Reserve is

8:58

the buyer of last resort, the one with

9:00

an unlimited checkbook, because its

9:02

checkbook is conjured from nothing. When

9:04

you hear the term quantitative easing,

9:06

or QE, this is all it means, the Fed

9:09

creating new money to buy the

9:11

government's debt when the world will

9:13

not do it. So, now you have the full

9:14

answer to where the money comes from. It

9:16

comes from two places. The government

9:18

borrows it by selling bonds, and when

9:20

there are not enough buyers, the Fed

9:22

creates it out of thin air and buys

9:24

those bonds themselves. Now, hold on to

9:26

that, because we're about to watch the

9:29

same trick do something that should not

9:32

be possible. Here is a question that

9:34

should stop you in your tracks. We just

9:36

established that the United States

9:38

borrows roughly $2 trillion

9:40

per year because it does not have enough

9:43

money. It needs the rest of the world to

9:45

keep lending to it every quarter just to

9:47

keep the lights on. So, how exactly, if

9:49

that's the case, is that same country

9:52

able to turn around and lend tens of

9:54

billions of dollars to other nations?

9:56

Because that is what's been happening.

9:58

Over the past 2 months, the United Arab

10:01

Emirates and reportedly a whole string

10:03

of Gulf and Asian countries have gone to

10:06

Washington asking for emergency dollars

10:09

for what is called a currency swap line,

10:12

a short-term loan of dollars from one

10:14

central bank to another.

10:17

Now, how does a country that runs

10:18

entirely on borrowed money suddenly

10:21

become a lender? And the answer is the

10:24

same keyboard. When the Fed extends a

10:27

swap line, it does not dip into a vault.

10:30

It does not pull the dollars from

10:32

taxpayers. It's not lending money that

10:34

it has, it's lending money that it

10:35

creates. It types those dollars into

10:38

existence on demand and sends them to

10:40

the foreign central bank. So, the

10:42

contradiction dissolves the moment you

10:43

understand the keyboard. A broke man

10:46

cannot lend you his savings, but a man

10:48

with the money printer can send you a

10:49

stack of fresh bills all day long. The

10:52

United States is not lending from a

10:53

position of wealth, it is lending from a

10:56

position of unlimited money creation.

10:58

Those are very different things. Now, a

11:00

couple of sharp questions have come up

11:02

here and they deserve straight answers.

11:04

Some of you in the comments with

11:06

previous episodes have asked, "Why

11:08

doesn't the country requesting the swap

11:10

line just use its US Treasury bonds as

11:13

collateral to borrow the dollars, a

11:15

normal loan against assets, instead of a

11:18

special swap line?" And the truth is

11:20

that it could. That's called a repo. But

11:23

pledging these bonds, or worse, selling

11:25

them to raise the cash, puts pressure

11:28

right back on the bond market we just

11:30

discussed, the exact thing Washington is

11:33

so desperate to avoid. The swap line is

11:35

cleaner because the Fed simply creates

11:37

the dollars and no bonds have to be sold

11:39

or leveraged. Now, others have asked,

11:42

"Isn't it the Treasury doing this? And

11:43

doesn't the Treasury have only a limited

11:46

pot?" And that's also correct. And this

11:47

is the key. The Treasury does have the

11:49

funds for this, but it's like a garden

11:51

hose or a water can, right? It's finite

11:54

and it can run dry. Where the Federal

11:56

Reserve is a fire hose with no off

11:59

switch. So, when the demand for

12:00

emergency dollars gets large, and it is

12:03

getting large, the real backstop, the

12:05

only one big enough, is the Fed. Which

12:08

means the man who inherits this entire

12:10

problem is the next chairman of the

12:12

Federal Reserve. Now, swap lines are not

12:15

new and it's worth knowing where they

12:16

came from because the history tells you

12:19

exactly how this ends. They were born in

12:22

the panic of 2008 when the global

12:24

financial system seized up and the whole

12:26

world was suddenly short of dollars. And

12:29

the Fed opened swap lines to a handful,

12:32

a small handful of major central banks

12:34

like Europe, Britain, Japan, Canada,

12:37

Switzerland to keep the system, the

12:39

global system from collapsing. And it

12:41

worked. The dollars went out, the crisis

12:44

passed, and the dollars were paid back.

12:47

The Fed did it again in 2020 when the

12:49

pandemic froze markets. Same playbook

12:52

and same small club of trusted

12:55

economies. Same outcome. The loans were

12:57

repaid and the created dollars vanished

13:00

back into nothing. And that is the

13:02

crucial detail. The system stayed honest

13:05

for one reason. The loans got paid back

13:08

and the new money disappeared again. No

13:10

permanent harm. The keyboard giveth and

13:13

when the loan matured, the keyboard

13:15

taketh away. But notice who was

13:16

borrowing. A tiny exclusive list of the

13:20

most stable and creditworthy economies

13:23

on Earth. But now, watch what's

13:25

happening to that list. Last year, the

13:27

club began to crack open, and Argentina,

13:30

a country with one of the most volatile

13:32

currencies on the planet and a long

13:34

history of default, was let in. Then,

13:37

over the last 2 months, the United Arab

13:39

Emirates came knocking. And in testimony

13:42

before the Senate, the Treasury

13:43

Secretary confirmed that a number of

13:46

Gulf and Asian allies have requested

13:48

swap lines of their own. This is my

13:50

thesis, and I want to be clear about it.

13:52

The list of countries borrowing

13:54

emergency dollars from the United States

13:56

is about to expand dramatically. And as

13:59

it does, the whole structure gets more

14:01

fragile, not less. And here's why. As

14:05

long as the borrowers are rock-solid

14:07

economies that pay the loans back, the

14:09

dollars vanish and the system stays

14:11

clean. But the longer this war drags on,

14:14

and the more countries run short of

14:15

dollars, the longer that list grows, and

14:18

the less credit-worthy the new members

14:21

are, and the less likely it becomes that

14:23

the loans truly get repaid. And what

14:26

happens then? The loans don't get

14:28

repaid, they get rolled. The deadline

14:31

gets pushed or extended, or a new loan

14:33

just replaces the old one. On paper, it

14:35

says repaid, but nothing was actually

14:38

repaid. The balance just moves into the

14:40

future. Now, Wall Street has a name for

14:42

this. They call it amend, extend, and

14:44

pretend. You amend the terms of the loan

14:46

to extend the payment deadline and

14:48

pretend that everything is fine. But the

14:51

moment the loans stop getting repaid,

14:53

the created dollars stop vanishing. They

14:55

pile up, and they never come back down.

14:57

And that is the answer to the people

14:59

asking where the limit is. There is no

15:01

clean wall the system slams into. There

15:03

is a slow tide, a pile of money conjured

15:07

from nothing, that simply keeps rising

15:09

with each rolled loan, forever.

15:12

And this is no longer theoretical. Now,

15:14

why is that my thesis? Because the

15:16

longer the Strait of Hormuz stays

15:19

closed, the longer the list of countries

15:21

that are going to run out of food or

15:23

fuel, and they'll have to raise cash to

15:26

buy what they need on the open market

15:28

because supply chains can't predictably

15:30

provide it any longer. The best way for

15:33

them to raise that cash is to sell US

15:35

Treasuries. But, too much selling of US

15:38

Treasuries crashes that market exactly

15:40

what the Fed is trying to avoid. So, how

15:43

do you convince a cash-strapped economy

15:45

not to sell their most liquid asset,

15:48

being US Treasuries, to raise the money

15:50

they need to buy food and fuel? Well,

15:53

you lend them the cash they need. You

15:55

offer them a swap line. And this is no

15:57

longer theoretical. The data this month

15:59

confirmed the cascade has already begun.

16:02

In March, Japan sold more US government

16:05

Treasuries than it had in 4 years. China

16:08

sold, too. So did a long list of others.

16:11

One country, Turkey, sold its American

16:14

bonds so aggressively that it ran out

16:16

and then had to start selling its gold.

16:18

This is what a cash squeeze looks like.

16:21

That is the forced selling I warned

16:23

about. It's here. And watch how

16:25

Washington is responding. In the past 2

16:28

months, the Treasury Secretary has twice

16:30

lifted sanctions on Russian oil in the

16:33

middle of a war to give desperate

16:34

countries somewhere else to buy fuel so

16:37

they don't have to sell their American

16:39

bonds to afford it. The US is also

16:41

draining its emergency oil reserve at

16:43

the fastest pace in history and shipping

16:46

it abroad. Same purpose. The entire

16:49

machine is now bent towards one job,

16:52

stop the world from selling America's

16:54

debt.

16:56

Which brings us to the deepest question

16:57

of all, and the one I most want you to

17:00

sit with. If the United States is

17:02

quietly bailing out the rest of the

17:04

world, keeping the bond market from

17:06

crashing and keeping everybody else's

17:07

lights on, then who actually loses? The

17:10

countries getting the dollars or the

17:12

dollar itself? And let me answer as

17:15

plainly as I can. The country that gets

17:18

the swap line is fine. They get their

17:20

dollars and they keep their lights on.

17:22

The bond market is fine. It does not

17:24

crash because there's no force selling

17:26

into it. Washington gets to look like

17:29

the hero.

17:30

So, who pays? The dollar pays. Every new

17:33

dollar created from nothing makes every

17:35

existing dollar worth a little less. And

17:39

that loss does not show up in a headline

17:42

or a bond auction. It shows up quietly

17:45

in your life, in the price of your

17:47

groceries, in your rent, in a paycheck

17:49

that buys a little bit less than it did

17:51

a year ago. And that is where the bill

17:53

goes. Not to the nation that got bailed

17:55

out, but to the person holding and

17:57

earning dollars, to the worker whose

17:59

wages never quite keep up. That is

18:02

inflation. And inflation is like a

18:04

secret but deadly weapon that

18:06

governments use all the time because

18:07

inflation happens over years. It's

18:10

invisible. Nobody can trace the price of

18:13

eggs back to a decision made at the

18:15

Federal Reserve 2 years earlier. So,

18:17

nobody gets blamed or the wrong person

18:20

does. The politician blames greedy

18:23

corporations or foreign countries or

18:25

immigration or the last administration.

18:28

The central bank's name is never on the

18:30

list of enemies. So, given a choice

18:32

between a crash in the bond market that

18:34

everybody sees and a government that

18:36

runs out of money or a slow erosion that

18:39

nobody can pin on them, they always

18:42

choose the erosion every single time.

18:44

Every central bank in history, when

18:46

forced to choose, makes the same call.

18:49

And some will tell you this is not a

18:50

flaw in the system. This is the system

18:52

working exactly as it's designed, a

18:55

machine for quietly moving wealth from

18:58

the people who hold dollars to the

19:00

people who hold assets. Now, I won't go

19:02

as far as to say that somebody sat in a

19:04

room and drew this plan up to rob you

19:06

specifically, but I will tell you this,

19:08

designed or not, that is precisely what

19:11

happens and almost no one notices while

19:14

it's happening. That is John's law

19:16

machine, 300 years later, running on a

19:19

keyboard instead of a printing press.

19:21

Now, a few of you will ask the only

19:23

question that actually matters in your

19:25

own life. You'll say, "Okay, great. What

19:28

do I do with this information?"

19:30

Now, I'm not going to tell you what to

19:32

buy or sell or what to do with your

19:33

investment portfolio, but I will tell

19:35

you how I think about it. If the bill

19:38

for all of this gets paid through a

19:40

slowly shrinking dollar, then the worst

19:43

place to be is sitting in cash and on

19:46

paper promises measured in that dollar.

19:49

And the best place to be is in the real

19:51

things, the scarce things, the things

19:53

that cannot be typed into existence on a

19:56

keyboard. Things like energy, hard

19:58

assets, gold, the boring physical stuff

20:02

that holds its value when the measuring

20:04

stick is shrinking. When France finally

20:07

woke up from John Law's dream, the

20:09

people who were wiped out were the ones

20:11

holding the paper. The people who came

20:13

through held something real, and that is

20:15

the whole lesson 300 years later, but

20:18

nothing has changed. So, the next time

20:20

you hear that another country got a swap

20:22

line, or that the bond market held, or

20:25

that the economic crisis was avoided, I

20:28

want you to remember what you know now.

20:30

The crisis was not avoided. It was just

20:33

moved. It was postponed. It's been

20:35

hidden, not in the bond market, but in

20:38

the dollar. It's been hidden in your

20:39

pocket. The money comes from nowhere,

20:42

but the bill goes to you.

20:45

Honest question, what am I missing? Let

20:47

me know in the comments. If you enjoy my

20:49

content, my name is Jay Martin, and this

20:51

is the Jay Martin Show. We drop videos

20:53

just like this every week right here on

20:55

the channel. If you enjoy it, do me a

20:57

favor, click like, hit subscribe, but

20:59

most importantly, share this video with

21:03

a friend, somebody that you know needs

21:05

to see it. For more on this topic, check

21:08

out one of these videos and I will see

21:10

you next week.

21:12

>> Beautiful.

Interactive Summary

This video explains the mechanics of how the US government manages its massive deficit through borrowing and, when necessary, the creation of new money by the Federal Reserve. It details the process of Treasury bond auctions, the role of primary dealers, and the impact of the secondary market on interest rates. The narrator argues that 'swap lines' to other countries are effectively funded by printing new money, which ultimately leads to inflation. This process, likened to a 300-year-old financial experiment, results in the erosion of the dollar's value, which the narrator suggests is an invisible tax on ordinary people's purchasing power.

Suggested questions

4 ready-made prompts