Pinterest Is Now A Shopping Destination — And Gen Z Likes It
545 segments
Hello everyone. [music] Good morning,
Bill.
>> Good morning.
>> Great to have you.
You've had 10 straight quarters of
double-digit user growth. Most recently,
631
million global active monthly users.
It's pretty good.
How is the consumer seeming right now
between Iran, tariffs, gas prices? Like,
what are you seeing?
>> There's just a little bit going on in
the world, right?
>> You know, it it's uh you know,
interesting like obviously, you know, no
comments on current quarter, all those
sort of disclaimers as a public company.
>> Check.
>> Um
but, you know, we've talked about this
on our our last earnings call and pretty
consistently that, you know, there's
been real resilience amongst consumers.
Um
and I think not only has there been
resilience, I think it's also there's so
much changing
in terms of the landscape with AI and
all these kinds of things.
Consumers, I think,
interestingly, are craving authenticity
and meaning and purpose and all these
things that are not really answered by
AI. And and so, I think that's something
that we're really paying close attention
to is that, you know, I'm an
entrepreneur uh by background, an
engineer, a technologist. And there's so
many great uses of AI, but there's also
a bit of a sort of counter movement to
that with consumers of as so much is
changing,
what do they reach for to sort of have
ballast in the ship uh to to sort of
hold on to in terms of like where they
find trust or meaning or purpose in
these things.
Um
but, from a, you know, shopping
perspective, you know, of those 630
million users, more than half the
platform's Gen Z. So, Gen Z's our
largest, fastest-growing demographic. Um
and more than half of our users are
there to shop. And so, we've seen that
shopping activity uh particularly in a
visual-first, AI-driven world, uh
there's tremendous engagement.
>> So, let's come back to AI, of course. Uh
but you have this incredibly intentful,
purposeful, excited, passionate user
base, but you've said yourself, we have
more work to do to ensure monetization
more fully reflects the strength of that
user activity. So, what's holding the
company back on monetization?
>> Well, I wouldn't say there's anything
holding us back. I mean, we've made I
came in as CEO 4 years ago, and the
purpose was
twofold. One, we wanted to prove there
was a more positive business model for
social media, that you didn't have to
use engagement via enragement to sort of
keep people glued to a screen, we could
actually try to build a more positive
space, one that would leave people
feeling better, and one that would leave
people feeling better about their time
spent, that it wasn't about maximizing
time spent, but about maximizing time
well spent.
And then the other side of that was
building out as a shopping platform. And
over the last 4 years,
you know, we're now
80 billion plus searches per month.
Uh
you know, which is just a massive amount
of search volume. Those searches are
primarily visual, so proving out a new
way to search. More than half of those
are commercial. And as is true with any
platform, you want to get the users and
the engagement first, and then the
monetization follows behind that. But
we've also 5x the number of clicks to
advertisers over the last 3 years. So,
so the ad platform has been growing, you
know, very nicely. We quadrupled the
growth rate of the revenue. And so it is
following, but of course you want to get
the user engagement first, and the
revenue follows in behind that.
>> Is part of it just the way advertisers
measure success? I I recently read in
Media Stack one of your executives said,
"95% of Pinterest impact is invisible to
advertisers who look at last click
data." Is that a problem that
advertisers are looking at the wrong
thing?
>> Well, I think that's not just about us.
I think that's been a big breakthrough
in advertising generally.
Uh is
it's one of those things not all that
matters is measured and not all that
measure not all that is measured is is
what matters. And, you know, great CMOs
have always known this that even though
the last click was the thing that was
the most measurable, uh you know, any
great CMO would know that well, okay, do
you really believe the whole decision
was made in the last 30 seconds before
that last click? Or
were there things before that around
building your brand and your customer
connection and how customers should
think of you and how they were
researching your product? So much of
that happens before that. And just to be
very fact-based about it, for most
commercial journeys, they tend to be
multi-day, multi-week, multi-month. And
depending on how high consideration the
purchase is, the longer that time period
tends to be. But even something like
apparel tends to be a multi-day
consideration period. So, if you're only
measuring the last click, you've
probably just found the tollbooth, but
you didn't find sort of actually the
sort of map somebody used to navigate
the journey. And that's not just about
us. I think just generally that's been a
major issue. But the good news is with,
you know, things like clean rooms and
other privacy-preserving technology, the
ability to go understand the full
journey of the user is getting better
and better and better both with that and
with AI-driven systems that can help you
understand the multiple touchpoints that
were on that journey. And when viewed
through that lens, you know, yes, we 5x
the number of clicks to advertisers over
the last 3 years, so we're driving a
tremendous amount of last click. But of
those 80 billion searches a month that
are happening, more than half are
commercial. And you know, it's a great
moment to engage when you can meet the
user in a place where they have intent
but haven't yet decided what to buy. So,
95% plus of our queries are unbranded.
So, back to like are you a toll booth or
are you actually helping drive a
decision? That's a very fact-based way
to measure that of like how many of the
queries actually have the brand in it
already? If the brand's in it already,
then they sort of made up some part of
their mind. Well, 95% of our queries are
unbranded, which means the user has
clear commercial intent, but hasn't yet
decided what to buy. But, I think part
of this that you're touching on around
measurement, not just for us, but just
in the industry generally, I think it's
what the great CMOs have wanted for
years and years. They just couldn't
convince their CFO um if it wasn't
measurable. Well, now that more of that
journey is measurable, that's letting
great CMOs say, "Yes, brand building
matters. Customer connection matters.
How our product is understood by the
customer matters." And those things
matter way before those last 10 seconds
before that last click.
>> So, I know it we're getting in the
nitty-gritty here, but here we are at
Cannes. So, how are you helping
advertisers make that case? Tell us is
this Pinterest performance plus or like
what are the tools you're giving to help
make the case?
>> Yeah, so we've uh so we have our own AI
automation suite that makes it really
easy to create campaigns, connect to
that high commercial intent on our
platform.
Uh Pinterest performance plus, uh our AI
automation suite has cut campaign
creation time in half. We're doing
things like creative optimization where,
you know, um
you know, great marketers, great
creatives are always going to want to
know that they're showing up the way
they want in front of their customers.
But, the ability to personalize and say,
"Okay, well, you know, say you have like
a great, you know, kitchen appliance,
you know, that you want to show up."
Well, that person is if they're going to
go spend $5,000 on a coffee maker or
something,
they're probably thinking about how
that's going to look in their kitchen.
And so, when you can personalize down to
a level of like not just showing them a
great coffee maker, but showing them a
great coffee maker that is like sitting
in a kitchen
like their kitchen, you're going to have
better conversion rates on that and it's
going to be brand enhancing. These are
the kinds of things you can do with with
AI-driven creative optimization that
don't have to be about turning over
control to a black box, but can be about
how do you take, you know, your great
brand architecture and then marry that
with great personalization. So, there's
things like that that we're doing. And
then, we've integrated with 30 plus
uh measurement partners to sort of meet
advertisers where they are around these
issues of measuring the full funnel.
>> Is that the Is that the issue with the
resistance to some of these tools? It's
a black box and some
advertisers worry they're seating
control over their campaigns.
>> I I think um to some degree, yes. I I
think there's an interesting
um
uh tension to work through is that on
the one hand,
uh you know, these AI-driven systems can
do a really tremendous job of you know,
finding opportunities that you never
could have found on your own,
personalizing to to levels that you you
couldn't have done on your own. At the
same time, great marketers,
of course, want to know how their brand
shows up and are understandably going to
want to
be able to sort of track that through
and see that their brand shows up in a
high-quality way that they feel good
about. It shows up in a positive
environment. You know, we we see this
One of the reasons we've uh put so much
effort into building more positive
space. One, I just think it needs to
exist in the world um as a parent, um as
a citizen, I think we we need to demand
more from our tech platforms than what
we've been getting uh in terms of safety
and what it means for our our
our children. Um
but, it's also a good business decision
because study after study after study
shows that there's better engagement and
better conversion when users see
products in a positive context, right?
And somehow as an industry, we got
convinced over the last, you know, 20
years that you would measure the you'd
look at the thing that came right before
your ad and the thing that came right
after your ad, that the 10 seconds
before your ad, the 10 seconds after
your ad, and as long as those were safe,
we call it brand safe. If I had pitched
you on that in sort of the
TV world to say, "Oh, I've got this show
that's like really terrible, it shows
all kinds of horrible stuff,
but for 10 seconds before your ad and 10
seconds after your ad, that's going to
be safe stuff, so go ahead and run your
ad on my TV show."
You'd have laughed me out of the room,
but we've started to accept that, not
started to, we you know, the industry
accepted that for the last 20-plus
years.
We want to prove and have been proving
that actually the broader environment
around that matters a lot more.
And in the studies are very consistent
around that.
And and I I think again, I think great
marketers have always known that, so
we're trying to give them tools to to
engage in a more positive space.
>> Positive the whole way, AI for
positivity. Let's let's get into it on
AI. So,
how much content on Pinterest is
AI-generated and do people care?
>> So, it's interesting, you know, we've
seen this multiple times, you know, the
ability to create content has been
democratized
tremendously, and it's not just with AI,
you know, when we all got a computer in
our pocket and then there was a phone,
you know, that on that phone you had a a
camera,
anybody can go create content. And
consistently you've seen that as content
creation has become easier, the volume
of content goes up tremendously. The
average quality goes down because
anybody can go shoot a photo. Um you
don't have to be a professional
photographer to take a photo on your
phone, uh including me, you know,
that'll like get half of, you know,
someone's head in the shot or whatever.
Anybody can take a photo. You get way
more content, but while the average
quality goes down, the total volume goes
up, and in the fact that
everybody can create and the distance
between someone seeing something in
their mind's eye and being able to go
create that piece of content. The fact
that that is collapsing, I think is
actually bringing a lot more human
creativity in the world. So, our job as
a platform is to not judge whether it's,
you know, digitally created, you know,
or AI, you know,
modified, but to say, "Is this a
high-quality piece of content that's
really relevant to this user?" And so,
as a platform, we're doing a lot to make
sure the quality of the content is is is
high, that the relevancy for the user is
good, and then also we're giving users
agency, which I think we've led the way
on this relative to other platforms in
we're labeling AI-generated content and
giving users tools to say, "Show me less
AI." If they don't want to see AI cuz
there is personal taste in this.
Um in not only is there personal taste,
it varies from moment to moment. There
are some moments where the AI-generated
content, you know,
uh
may appear, you know, as something that
you couldn't really do in real life.
Well, sometimes that's okay, right? Um
you know, how many, you know, if you my
my daughter's 12. Anybody that has young
kids, like this past Halloween, you
know, how many kids did you see with
like, you know, purple hair because of
like K-pop demon hunters? Well, like
that's digitally created content that
inspired something in the real world.
So, there's certain certain times when
that AI content is helping to inspire.
There's other times when somebody say
like, "No, I'm like actually trying to
buy I'm, you know, trying to redecorate
a room, and I want to see a sofa I can
actually buy in that room." This is one
of the things that we do is is help
translate between here's a piece of
content that may have inspired, that
maybe was created with AI, but then with
our visual search technology we make it
so that you can see the the buyable
thing in the real world. And we're
seeing that really resonating with
users, but we're in this transition
period where users are still trying to
figure out their own tastes and
preferences and our response to this is
do as much as we can to to filter and
sort high-quality content and give the
user agency so that they know when it's
AI generated and they have their own
controls to say show me less if they
don't want to see it.
>> Okay, working your way through. And then
just on the back end
uh you've been so all in on AI. How
about those bills? You got some token
maxing going on or how are you
controlling your costs there?
>> Well, you know, it's um
fortunately because we're a very high
commercial intent platform, we've
actually expanded profitability over the
last 3 years even as we have
dramatically increased the use of AI on
our platform because we're aligning use
of AI with high commercial intent
audience and high commercial intent
experiences that monetize really well.
Um
but I do think this is something that
people need to pay very close attention
to because I think we've been in this
mode as an industry of go go go, don't
be left out and then now, you know,
especially you start to move to
uses-based pricing,
the onus is much higher on platforms to
prove that there was a good ROI on that.
Um
and we've been very uh as a smaller
platform,
uh
you know, relative to some of the
giants,
we've had to take that approach from the
start. Uh you know, I talked about how
we are able to use open-source models
and post-train them on our high
commercial intent data and see, you
know, not only 90% lower cost than the
closed proprietary models, but also
better performance because we can train
it on our own data. And so I think some
of these issues of how do you get the
best performance,
open source can do a lot there because
you can post-train on your own data in
ways that you can't with proprietary
models, and you can get much much lower
costs on these things. But, I do think
we're just at the start of sort of a
reckoning of what are the real costs of
of these AI platforms where in some use
cases it totally makes sense, and other
use cases, once you start to pay the
real price of those tokens, it it may
not.
>> So, that's a conversation internally and
what keeping an eye on this kind of
thing?
>> Yeah, absolutely. And and one that we're
trying to help our our clients and
partners with as well.
>> You've talked in management about the
value of fast feedback loops, products,
and management. Could you just say what
what you mean by that and give an
example?
>> So, it's interesting like this um
I gave a talk on this in Davos in 2018
um
that was turned into a bit of a white
paper that uh back then I was saying
like, "Okay, AI is coming.
Like cloud compute, AI will be the
domain in terms like the sort of core
foundational models that AI will be
created by a small number of players
because it's so
uh you know, so CAPEX intensive. But,
in the same way that cloud compute, you
know, created all kinds of new
businesses that couldn't have existed
otherwise, and all kinds of
opportunities that wouldn't have existed
otherwise, that AI would do the same
thing. That AI would be put in the hands
of the many. And the thing that people
should think about is what are the
unique feedback loops in your business.
AI thrives on feedback loops. And so,
while most companies are not going to go
create their own foundational models,
what every company can do is think about
how do I serve my customer? What do I
what problem am I solving for them? What
makes me uniquely equipped to solve it?
And then, what are the feedback loops in
my business
that are unique to me that I can train
my that that that I can train AI on to
make my business better. I think that's
something that every single business can
think about. You don't need computer
science PhDs to do that. Um but
everybody should be thinking about what
are the feedback loops in their
business.
How do you tap into those and then how
do you how do you find you systems and
platforms are going to help you do that?
And again, part of what we're you know
what we're trying to do with our
platform is not only are we making that
commercial intent available, we're
trying to make it available in ways that
help our advertisers gain a customer,
not just a transaction. Part of why I
was so interested in doing visual search
and discovery is that you know more than
half the human brain is wired for visual
processing.
You know, you still have a lot of these
things that are like you know very text
based, but most commercial journeys are
tremendously visual. And how do people
tell their brand story? How do they
differentiate? How do they create
connection with customers?
Visuals are a huge part of that and we
want to make that accessible to all the
advertisers on our platform and do it in
a way where not only do they gain a
transaction, but they actually we take
the customers to our advertisers so that
our advertisers actually gain a deeper
relationship so they can start to have
their own feedback loops with those
customers to deepen the relationship.
>> Thank you, Bill. Great to have you.
Thank you, everyone.
Ask follow-up questions or revisit key timestamps.
This conversation features Pinterest CEO Bill Ready discussing the company's resilience, the importance of maintaining a positive environment for users and advertisers, and the strategic implementation of AI. He emphasizes Pinterest's focus on commercial intent, the evolution of advertising measurement beyond last-click attribution, and how the platform uses AI to enhance personalization and creative optimization while managing costs through efficient model training.
Videos recently processed by our community