HomeVideos

Pinterest Is Now A Shopping Destination — And Gen Z Likes It

Now Playing

Pinterest Is Now A Shopping Destination — And Gen Z Likes It

Transcript

545 segments

0:07

Hello everyone. [music] Good morning,

0:08

Bill.

0:09

>> Good morning.

0:09

>> Great to have you.

0:11

You've had 10 straight quarters of

0:13

double-digit user growth. Most recently,

0:16

631

0:18

million global active monthly users.

0:20

It's pretty good.

0:22

How is the consumer seeming right now

0:24

between Iran, tariffs, gas prices? Like,

0:27

what are you seeing?

0:28

>> There's just a little bit going on in

0:29

the world, right?

0:31

>> You know, it it's uh you know,

0:33

interesting like obviously, you know, no

0:36

comments on current quarter, all those

0:37

sort of disclaimers as a public company.

0:39

>> Check.

0:39

>> Um

0:40

but, you know, we've talked about this

0:42

on our our last earnings call and pretty

0:44

consistently that, you know, there's

0:45

been real resilience amongst consumers.

0:48

Um

0:49

and I think not only has there been

0:51

resilience, I think it's also there's so

0:53

much changing

0:55

in terms of the landscape with AI and

0:57

all these kinds of things.

1:00

Consumers, I think,

1:02

interestingly, are craving authenticity

1:05

and meaning and purpose and all these

1:08

things that are not really answered by

1:10

AI. And and so, I think that's something

1:12

that we're really paying close attention

1:13

to is that, you know, I'm an

1:15

entrepreneur uh by background, an

1:17

engineer, a technologist. And there's so

1:20

many great uses of AI, but there's also

1:22

a bit of a sort of counter movement to

1:24

that with consumers of as so much is

1:27

changing,

1:28

what do they reach for to sort of have

1:31

ballast in the ship uh to to sort of

1:33

hold on to in terms of like where they

1:35

find trust or meaning or purpose in

1:36

these things.

1:37

Um

1:38

but, from a, you know, shopping

1:40

perspective, you know, of those 630

1:42

million users, more than half the

1:43

platform's Gen Z. So, Gen Z's our

1:45

largest, fastest-growing demographic. Um

1:48

and more than half of our users are

1:50

there to shop. And so, we've seen that

1:52

shopping activity uh particularly in a

1:54

visual-first, AI-driven world, uh

1:57

there's tremendous engagement.

1:59

>> So, let's come back to AI, of course. Uh

2:02

but you have this incredibly intentful,

2:05

purposeful, excited, passionate user

2:08

base, but you've said yourself, we have

2:10

more work to do to ensure monetization

2:13

more fully reflects the strength of that

2:16

user activity. So, what's holding the

2:18

company back on monetization?

2:21

>> Well, I wouldn't say there's anything

2:21

holding us back. I mean, we've made I

2:23

came in as CEO 4 years ago, and the

2:27

purpose was

2:28

twofold. One, we wanted to prove there

2:31

was a more positive business model for

2:32

social media, that you didn't have to

2:34

use engagement via enragement to sort of

2:37

keep people glued to a screen, we could

2:39

actually try to build a more positive

2:42

space, one that would leave people

2:44

feeling better, and one that would leave

2:47

people feeling better about their time

2:48

spent, that it wasn't about maximizing

2:50

time spent, but about maximizing time

2:52

well spent.

2:53

And then the other side of that was

2:56

building out as a shopping platform. And

2:57

over the last 4 years,

3:00

you know, we're now

3:02

80 billion plus searches per month.

3:05

Uh

3:06

you know, which is just a massive amount

3:08

of search volume. Those searches are

3:10

primarily visual, so proving out a new

3:11

way to search. More than half of those

3:13

are commercial. And as is true with any

3:17

platform, you want to get the users and

3:19

the engagement first, and then the

3:20

monetization follows behind that. But

3:22

we've also 5x the number of clicks to

3:24

advertisers over the last 3 years. So,

3:26

so the ad platform has been growing, you

3:28

know, very nicely. We quadrupled the

3:31

growth rate of the revenue. And so it is

3:34

following, but of course you want to get

3:36

the user engagement first, and the

3:37

revenue follows in behind that.

3:38

>> Is part of it just the way advertisers

3:41

measure success? I I recently read in

3:43

Media Stack one of your executives said,

3:45

"95% of Pinterest impact is invisible to

3:48

advertisers who look at last click

3:51

data." Is that a problem that

3:53

advertisers are looking at the wrong

3:55

thing?

3:55

>> Well, I think that's not just about us.

3:57

I think that's been a big breakthrough

3:59

in advertising generally.

4:01

Uh is

4:03

it's one of those things not all that

4:06

matters is measured and not all that

4:08

measure not all that is measured is is

4:09

what matters. And, you know, great CMOs

4:12

have always known this that even though

4:14

the last click was the thing that was

4:16

the most measurable, uh you know, any

4:18

great CMO would know that well, okay, do

4:21

you really believe the whole decision

4:22

was made in the last 30 seconds before

4:24

that last click? Or

4:27

were there things before that around

4:28

building your brand and your customer

4:30

connection and how customers should

4:31

think of you and how they were

4:33

researching your product? So much of

4:36

that happens before that. And just to be

4:38

very fact-based about it, for most

4:40

commercial journeys, they tend to be

4:42

multi-day, multi-week, multi-month. And

4:44

depending on how high consideration the

4:46

purchase is, the longer that time period

4:49

tends to be. But even something like

4:50

apparel tends to be a multi-day

4:52

consideration period. So, if you're only

4:54

measuring the last click, you've

4:56

probably just found the tollbooth, but

4:59

you didn't find sort of actually the

5:02

sort of map somebody used to navigate

5:03

the journey. And that's not just about

5:05

us. I think just generally that's been a

5:07

major issue. But the good news is with,

5:10

you know, things like clean rooms and

5:12

other privacy-preserving technology, the

5:14

ability to go understand the full

5:17

journey of the user is getting better

5:19

and better and better both with that and

5:22

with AI-driven systems that can help you

5:23

understand the multiple touchpoints that

5:25

were on that journey. And when viewed

5:27

through that lens, you know, yes, we 5x

5:30

the number of clicks to advertisers over

5:31

the last 3 years, so we're driving a

5:33

tremendous amount of last click. But of

5:35

those 80 billion searches a month that

5:36

are happening, more than half are

5:38

commercial. And you know, it's a great

5:41

moment to engage when you can meet the

5:43

user in a place where they have intent

5:45

but haven't yet decided what to buy. So,

5:47

95% plus of our queries are unbranded.

5:50

So, back to like are you a toll booth or

5:52

are you actually helping drive a

5:53

decision? That's a very fact-based way

5:55

to measure that of like how many of the

5:57

queries actually have the brand in it

5:58

already? If the brand's in it already,

6:00

then they sort of made up some part of

6:02

their mind. Well, 95% of our queries are

6:04

unbranded, which means the user has

6:05

clear commercial intent, but hasn't yet

6:07

decided what to buy. But, I think part

6:09

of this that you're touching on around

6:11

measurement, not just for us, but just

6:12

in the industry generally, I think it's

6:14

what the great CMOs have wanted for

6:16

years and years. They just couldn't

6:18

convince their CFO um if it wasn't

6:20

measurable. Well, now that more of that

6:22

journey is measurable, that's letting

6:24

great CMOs say, "Yes, brand building

6:26

matters. Customer connection matters.

6:28

How our product is understood by the

6:30

customer matters." And those things

6:31

matter way before those last 10 seconds

6:34

before that last click.

6:35

>> So, I know it we're getting in the

6:36

nitty-gritty here, but here we are at

6:38

Cannes. So, how are you helping

6:40

advertisers make that case? Tell us is

6:42

this Pinterest performance plus or like

6:44

what are the tools you're giving to help

6:46

make the case?

6:48

>> Yeah, so we've uh so we have our own AI

6:50

automation suite that makes it really

6:52

easy to create campaigns, connect to

6:53

that high commercial intent on our

6:55

platform.

6:56

Uh Pinterest performance plus, uh our AI

6:58

automation suite has cut campaign

7:00

creation time in half. We're doing

7:02

things like creative optimization where,

7:05

you know, um

7:07

you know, great marketers, great

7:08

creatives are always going to want to

7:10

know that they're showing up the way

7:13

they want in front of their customers.

7:15

But, the ability to personalize and say,

7:17

"Okay, well, you know, say you have like

7:19

a great, you know, kitchen appliance,

7:22

you know, that you want to show up."

7:24

Well, that person is if they're going to

7:25

go spend $5,000 on a coffee maker or

7:27

something,

7:29

they're probably thinking about how

7:30

that's going to look in their kitchen.

7:32

And so, when you can personalize down to

7:34

a level of like not just showing them a

7:35

great coffee maker, but showing them a

7:36

great coffee maker that is like sitting

7:38

in a kitchen

7:39

like their kitchen, you're going to have

7:41

better conversion rates on that and it's

7:43

going to be brand enhancing. These are

7:44

the kinds of things you can do with with

7:46

AI-driven creative optimization that

7:48

don't have to be about turning over

7:50

control to a black box, but can be about

7:52

how do you take, you know, your great

7:54

brand architecture and then marry that

7:56

with great personalization. So, there's

7:58

things like that that we're doing. And

7:59

then, we've integrated with 30 plus

8:02

uh measurement partners to sort of meet

8:03

advertisers where they are around these

8:05

issues of measuring the full funnel.

8:06

>> Is that the Is that the issue with the

8:08

resistance to some of these tools? It's

8:10

a black box and some

8:12

advertisers worry they're seating

8:13

control over their campaigns.

8:15

>> I I think um to some degree, yes. I I

8:18

think there's an interesting

8:21

um

8:22

uh tension to work through is that on

8:24

the one hand,

8:26

uh you know, these AI-driven systems can

8:28

do a really tremendous job of you know,

8:31

finding opportunities that you never

8:33

could have found on your own,

8:34

personalizing to to levels that you you

8:37

couldn't have done on your own. At the

8:38

same time, great marketers,

8:41

of course, want to know how their brand

8:43

shows up and are understandably going to

8:47

want to

8:48

be able to sort of track that through

8:50

and see that their brand shows up in a

8:51

high-quality way that they feel good

8:52

about. It shows up in a positive

8:53

environment. You know, we we see this

8:56

One of the reasons we've uh put so much

8:58

effort into building more positive

9:00

space. One, I just think it needs to

9:02

exist in the world um as a parent, um as

9:05

a citizen, I think we we need to demand

9:07

more from our tech platforms than what

9:08

we've been getting uh in terms of safety

9:11

and what it means for our our

9:14

our children. Um

9:15

but, it's also a good business decision

9:18

because study after study after study

9:21

shows that there's better engagement and

9:24

better conversion when users see

9:26

products in a positive context, right?

9:29

And somehow as an industry, we got

9:32

convinced over the last, you know, 20

9:34

years that you would measure the you'd

9:39

look at the thing that came right before

9:40

your ad and the thing that came right

9:41

after your ad, that the 10 seconds

9:43

before your ad, the 10 seconds after

9:44

your ad, and as long as those were safe,

9:46

we call it brand safe. If I had pitched

9:48

you on that in sort of the

9:50

TV world to say, "Oh, I've got this show

9:52

that's like really terrible, it shows

9:53

all kinds of horrible stuff,

9:55

but for 10 seconds before your ad and 10

9:57

seconds after your ad, that's going to

9:59

be safe stuff, so go ahead and run your

10:00

ad on my TV show."

10:02

You'd have laughed me out of the room,

10:04

but we've started to accept that, not

10:06

started to, we you know, the industry

10:07

accepted that for the last 20-plus

10:09

years.

10:10

We want to prove and have been proving

10:13

that actually the broader environment

10:15

around that matters a lot more.

10:18

And in the studies are very consistent

10:19

around that.

10:21

And and I I think again, I think great

10:23

marketers have always known that, so

10:24

we're trying to give them tools to to

10:26

engage in a more positive space.

10:28

>> Positive the whole way, AI for

10:29

positivity. Let's let's get into it on

10:31

AI. So,

10:34

how much content on Pinterest is

10:36

AI-generated and do people care?

10:40

>> So, it's interesting, you know, we've

10:41

seen this multiple times, you know, the

10:44

ability to create content has been

10:46

democratized

10:48

tremendously, and it's not just with AI,

10:51

you know, when we all got a computer in

10:52

our pocket and then there was a phone,

10:54

you know, that on that phone you had a a

10:56

camera,

10:58

anybody can go create content. And

11:00

consistently you've seen that as content

11:02

creation has become easier, the volume

11:06

of content goes up tremendously. The

11:08

average quality goes down because

11:10

anybody can go shoot a photo. Um you

11:13

don't have to be a professional

11:14

photographer to take a photo on your

11:15

phone, uh including me, you know,

11:17

that'll like get half of, you know,

11:19

someone's head in the shot or whatever.

11:21

Anybody can take a photo. You get way

11:23

more content, but while the average

11:26

quality goes down, the total volume goes

11:29

up, and in the fact that

11:32

everybody can create and the distance

11:34

between someone seeing something in

11:36

their mind's eye and being able to go

11:38

create that piece of content. The fact

11:39

that that is collapsing, I think is

11:41

actually bringing a lot more human

11:43

creativity in the world. So, our job as

11:44

a platform is to not judge whether it's,

11:49

you know, digitally created, you know,

11:52

or AI, you know,

11:55

modified, but to say, "Is this a

11:57

high-quality piece of content that's

11:59

really relevant to this user?" And so,

12:01

as a platform, we're doing a lot to make

12:03

sure the quality of the content is is is

12:06

high, that the relevancy for the user is

12:08

good, and then also we're giving users

12:10

agency, which I think we've led the way

12:12

on this relative to other platforms in

12:14

we're labeling AI-generated content and

12:17

giving users tools to say, "Show me less

12:20

AI." If they don't want to see AI cuz

12:21

there is personal taste in this.

12:24

Um in not only is there personal taste,

12:26

it varies from moment to moment. There

12:27

are some moments where the AI-generated

12:31

content, you know,

12:33

uh

12:34

may appear, you know, as something that

12:36

you couldn't really do in real life.

12:38

Well, sometimes that's okay, right? Um

12:41

you know, how many, you know, if you my

12:44

my daughter's 12. Anybody that has young

12:46

kids, like this past Halloween, you

12:49

know, how many kids did you see with

12:50

like, you know, purple hair because of

12:52

like K-pop demon hunters? Well, like

12:55

that's digitally created content that

12:57

inspired something in the real world.

12:59

So, there's certain certain times when

13:02

that AI content is helping to inspire.

13:05

There's other times when somebody say

13:06

like, "No, I'm like actually trying to

13:08

buy I'm, you know, trying to redecorate

13:10

a room, and I want to see a sofa I can

13:13

actually buy in that room." This is one

13:15

of the things that we do is is help

13:16

translate between here's a piece of

13:18

content that may have inspired, that

13:20

maybe was created with AI, but then with

13:22

our visual search technology we make it

13:24

so that you can see the the buyable

13:25

thing in the real world. And we're

13:27

seeing that really resonating with

13:28

users, but we're in this transition

13:30

period where users are still trying to

13:32

figure out their own tastes and

13:34

preferences and our response to this is

13:36

do as much as we can to to filter and

13:40

sort high-quality content and give the

13:42

user agency so that they know when it's

13:44

AI generated and they have their own

13:46

controls to say show me less if they

13:47

don't want to see it.

13:48

>> Okay, working your way through. And then

13:50

just on the back end

13:52

uh you've been so all in on AI. How

13:54

about those bills? You got some token

13:56

maxing going on or how are you

13:58

controlling your costs there?

14:00

>> Well, you know, it's um

14:03

fortunately because we're a very high

14:04

commercial intent platform, we've

14:06

actually expanded profitability over the

14:08

last 3 years even as we have

14:11

dramatically increased the use of AI on

14:13

our platform because we're aligning use

14:15

of AI with high commercial intent

14:18

audience and high commercial intent

14:20

experiences that monetize really well.

14:23

Um

14:23

but I do think this is something that

14:25

people need to pay very close attention

14:27

to because I think we've been in this

14:29

mode as an industry of go go go, don't

14:33

be left out and then now, you know,

14:36

especially you start to move to

14:38

uses-based pricing,

14:40

the onus is much higher on platforms to

14:43

prove that there was a good ROI on that.

14:46

Um

14:47

and we've been very uh as a smaller

14:49

platform,

14:51

uh

14:52

you know, relative to some of the

14:52

giants,

14:54

we've had to take that approach from the

14:55

start. Uh you know, I talked about how

14:57

we are able to use open-source models

15:00

and post-train them on our high

15:01

commercial intent data and see, you

15:04

know, not only 90% lower cost than the

15:08

closed proprietary models, but also

15:10

better performance because we can train

15:12

it on our own data. And so I think some

15:14

of these issues of how do you get the

15:16

best performance,

15:18

open source can do a lot there because

15:21

you can post-train on your own data in

15:22

ways that you can't with proprietary

15:23

models, and you can get much much lower

15:26

costs on these things. But, I do think

15:28

we're just at the start of sort of a

15:29

reckoning of what are the real costs of

15:32

of these AI platforms where in some use

15:35

cases it totally makes sense, and other

15:37

use cases, once you start to pay the

15:39

real price of those tokens, it it may

15:41

not.

15:42

>> So, that's a conversation internally and

15:44

what keeping an eye on this kind of

15:45

thing?

15:46

>> Yeah, absolutely. And and one that we're

15:47

trying to help our our clients and

15:49

partners with as well.

15:51

>> You've talked in management about the

15:53

value of fast feedback loops, products,

15:55

and management. Could you just say what

15:57

what you mean by that and give an

15:58

example?

15:58

>> So, it's interesting like this um

16:02

I gave a talk on this in Davos in 2018

16:04

um

16:05

that was turned into a bit of a white

16:06

paper that uh back then I was saying

16:08

like, "Okay, AI is coming.

16:10

Like cloud compute, AI will be the

16:12

domain in terms like the sort of core

16:15

foundational models that AI will be

16:18

created by a small number of players

16:21

because it's so

16:23

uh you know, so CAPEX intensive. But,

16:27

in the same way that cloud compute, you

16:29

know, created all kinds of new

16:30

businesses that couldn't have existed

16:32

otherwise, and all kinds of

16:33

opportunities that wouldn't have existed

16:34

otherwise, that AI would do the same

16:36

thing. That AI would be put in the hands

16:37

of the many. And the thing that people

16:39

should think about is what are the

16:40

unique feedback loops in your business.

16:42

AI thrives on feedback loops. And so,

16:44

while most companies are not going to go

16:46

create their own foundational models,

16:48

what every company can do is think about

16:51

how do I serve my customer? What do I

16:53

what problem am I solving for them? What

16:55

makes me uniquely equipped to solve it?

16:57

And then, what are the feedback loops in

16:59

my business

17:00

that are unique to me that I can train

17:03

my that that that I can train AI on to

17:07

make my business better. I think that's

17:09

something that every single business can

17:11

think about. You don't need computer

17:12

science PhDs to do that. Um but

17:15

everybody should be thinking about what

17:16

are the feedback loops in their

17:18

business.

17:19

How do you tap into those and then how

17:21

do you how do you find you systems and

17:23

platforms are going to help you do that?

17:25

And again, part of what we're you know

17:27

what we're trying to do with our

17:28

platform is not only are we making that

17:31

commercial intent available, we're

17:33

trying to make it available in ways that

17:35

help our advertisers gain a customer,

17:38

not just a transaction. Part of why I

17:40

was so interested in doing visual search

17:43

and discovery is that you know more than

17:46

half the human brain is wired for visual

17:48

processing.

17:50

You know, you still have a lot of these

17:51

things that are like you know very text

17:53

based, but most commercial journeys are

17:56

tremendously visual. And how do people

18:00

tell their brand story? How do they

18:01

differentiate? How do they create

18:03

connection with customers?

18:06

Visuals are a huge part of that and we

18:09

want to make that accessible to all the

18:11

advertisers on our platform and do it in

18:13

a way where not only do they gain a

18:15

transaction, but they actually we take

18:16

the customers to our advertisers so that

18:19

our advertisers actually gain a deeper

18:21

relationship so they can start to have

18:23

their own feedback loops with those

18:25

customers to deepen the relationship.

18:28

>> Thank you, Bill. Great to have you.

18:29

Thank you, everyone.

Interactive Summary

This conversation features Pinterest CEO Bill Ready discussing the company's resilience, the importance of maintaining a positive environment for users and advertisers, and the strategic implementation of AI. He emphasizes Pinterest's focus on commercial intent, the evolution of advertising measurement beyond last-click attribution, and how the platform uses AI to enhance personalization and creative optimization while managing costs through efficient model training.

Suggested questions

3 ready-made prompts