HomeVideos

The Biggest Lie in Economics (And You Still Believe It)

Now Playing

The Biggest Lie in Economics (And You Still Believe It)

Transcript

408 segments

0:00

October 29th, 1929.

0:02

>> [music]

0:02

>> Black Tuesday. The stock market dropped

0:05

by 12% in a single day.

0:07

Fortunes vanished in hours. Banks

0:09

collapsed in waves. Businesses shut

0:11

down. By 1933, 25% Americans had no job.

0:15

Bread lines stretched for blocks.

0:17

Families who once owned homes were now

0:19

living in cardboard shacks and

0:20

Hoovervilles.

0:21

"What am I supposed to tell the kids?"

0:24

"That's okay, Jeff. Tell them we'll

0:26

figure it out.

0:27

We always do." They didn't figure it

0:30

out, not for a long time. Their kids

0:32

grew up thinking full meant not hungry

0:35

enough to cry. So, Franklin Roosevelt

0:37

came in and threw everything at it.

0:39

Public works,

0:40

>> [music]

0:40

>> relief programs, new agencies, big

0:43

government on a scale America had never

0:45

really seen before. The New Deal put

0:47

millions [music] back to work building

0:48

bridges, dams, and highways. And to be

0:51

fair,

0:52

it helped. But it did not finish the

0:54

job. [music]

0:55

10 years after the crash, in 1939,

0:57

unemployment was still hanging around

0:59

15%. Yet, suddenly,

1:03

we interrupt this broadcast. The

1:06

Japanese have attacked Pearl Harbor. The

1:08

United States is at war.

1:11

And overnight, everything changed.

1:13

Factories that had been gathering

1:14

[music] dust roared back to life. But

1:17

now they were building tanks instead of

1:19

tractors. 17 million new jobs appeared.

1:22

Ford's assembly lines started rolling

1:24

out bombers instead of cars. Defense

1:26

[music] spending rocketed from 1.4% of

1:28

GDP to over 37%. Unemployment dropped

1:32

below 2%. Jeff got called to the

1:34

Cleveland tank plant. For the first time

1:36

in years, his family had a steady

1:38

paycheck. And just like that, on paper,

1:40

America looked incredible. So, later

1:42

Keynesian economists took one look at

1:44

this and said, [music]

1:46

"Uh of course. When people stop

1:47

spending, the government spends for

1:49

them.

1:50

>> [music]

1:50

>> World War II proved it. Case closed,

1:53

right?"

1:54

Wrong.

1:58

Let's test this so-called wartime

1:59

prosperity.

2:01

It's 1944. Jeff's family sits around

2:03

their kitchen table. We're out of sugar

2:05

[music] coupons until next month. Again?

2:08

And the meat allocation got cut. 2 lb

2:10

for the whole [music] family for the

2:12

week.

2:13

Well, at least according to the

2:14

newspaper, we've never been more

2:16

prosperous. Great.

2:18

I'll tell the children to eat the

2:19

newspaper.

2:20

This was the reality behind the numbers.

2:23

Yes, GDP was soaring.

2:26

But Americans were living under some of

2:27

the strictest rationing in US history.

2:30

Gasoline, meat, sugar, coffee, cheese,

2:33

even shoes rationed.

2:35

Car production had been banned since

2:37

1942.

2:39

By 1944, almost everything was

2:41

controlled except eggs and dairy.

2:44

Americans were saving over 25% of their

2:46

income.

2:47

Not because they'd all suddenly become

2:48

financially responsible. [music]

2:50

There was basically nothing to buy.

2:53

That's the trick.

2:54

>> [music]

2:54

>> The wartime boom was a statistical

2:56

illusion.

2:57

GDP goes up the same $10 million

3:00

whether a family builds a house or the

3:02

government builds a bomb and drops it

3:03

into the sea.

3:05

Same number.

3:06

Very different outcome for the family.

3:08

>> [music]

3:09

>> Jeff was earning more money than ever.

3:11

And his family was eating less than when

3:13

he was broke.

3:14

>> [music]

3:14

>> But the real test came after the war

3:16

ended.

3:17

1945, the guns go quiet, 10 million

3:20

soldiers are about to flood the job

3:22

market, government spending is about to

3:24

drop over 60%.

3:27

Holy crap.

3:28

>> [music]

3:28

>> Without government spending, we're

3:30

looking at the greatest period of

3:31

unemployment and industrial dislocation

3:33

any economy has ever faced. That's a

3:36

bold claim, Professor Samuelson. I will

3:38

literally [music] win the Nobel Prize.

3:40

Write it down.

3:41

I resonate with you, Professor. I'm

3:43

predicting an epidemic of violence.

3:46

And you are?

3:47

Also a future [music] Nobel laureate.

3:50

You're welcome.

3:51

Gentlemen, I am President Truman and I

3:54

also say [music] mass unemployment is

3:56

obvious. It's coming. So, everyone

3:58

agrees?

3:59

Without government [music] spending,

4:01

America collapses.

4:03

They were completely wrong.

4:05

Bomb factories became appliance

4:06

factories. Car plants switched from

4:09

tanks to Chevrolets. Shipyards pivoted

4:11

[music] from destroyers to fishing

4:12

vessels. Over 20 million people were

4:15

released from war-related work.

4:17

Unemployment peaked [music] at just

4:18

3.9%.

4:20

Truman himself later called it "The

4:21

swiftest and most gigantic changeover

4:23

that [music] any nation has made from

4:25

war to peace."

4:27

The economy didn't just survive the

4:28

spending cuts, it thrived because of

4:30

them.

4:31

Resources locked inside the war machine

4:33

flowed back into making things [music]

4:34

people actually wanted.

4:36

The Keynesian prediction was tested in

4:38

real time. It failed, but nobody updated

4:41

the textbooks. So, if the war didn't fix

4:43

the economy,

4:44

what did?

4:47

To answer that, we have to go back to

4:49

the moment the real damage started.

4:52

1914, World War I.

4:55

Countries are mobilizing millions of

4:57

soldiers, digging trenches across entire

4:59

continents,

5:00

building battleships, artillery,

5:01

uniforms, all of it, all at once, on a

5:04

scale the world has never seen.

5:06

All of it costs money, enormous,

5:09

staggering amounts of money.

5:11

Now, normally, a government funds a war

5:13

the same way it funds everything else,

5:15

taxes.

5:16

But, there's a limit to how much you can

5:17

squeeze out of your citizens, especially

5:19

when half of them are already in the

5:21

trenches.

5:22

Tax revenue runs out, the treasury runs

5:24

dry, and the war isn't over.

5:27

So, what do you do?

5:30

Well, just print it.

5:32

But, there was a problem. Back then,

5:34

>> [music]

5:34

>> most of the world was on the gold

5:35

standard, which meant governments

5:37

couldn't just print whatever they

5:38

needed. Every dollar, every pound, every

5:40

franc had to be backed by actual gold.

5:43

So, one by one, they ditched it. Gold

5:46

standard gone. Then the war ended, but

5:49

the printing did not.

5:51

Countries kept [music] printing money to

5:52

make their currency cheaper, which makes

5:54

their exports cheaper.

5:56

Other countries buy more of your stuff.

5:58

Sounds great. Until everyone figures out

6:00

the same trick.

6:02

France devalued. Britain devalued to

6:04

undercut France.

6:05

Germany printed so aggressively that a

6:07

loaf of bread cost 200 billion marks.

6:10

A housewife in Berlin needed a

6:12

wheelbarrow full of her life-saving cash

6:14

just to buy groceries.

6:16

A race to the bottom. Every country

6:18

destroying its own money to steal trade

6:20

from its neighbors. [music]

6:21

In the end, nobody gains an advantage.

6:24

All you're left with is money nobody

6:26

trusts.

6:27

World trade collapsed by 66% between

6:30

1929 and 1934.

6:33

Bad time for the economy. Good time for

6:35

the sponsor break.

6:36

Right now, your AI workflows are

6:38

scattered across too many tabs, and

6:40

you're likely paying multiple $20 AI

6:42

subscriptions. Chat LLM by Abacus.AI

6:46

[music] fixes this by putting every

6:47

top-tier model into one single

6:49

dashboard.

6:51

I'm talking about ChatGPT 5.2, Gemini 3

6:54

Pro, Claude [music] 4.5, and DeepSeek

6:57

all in one place. You don't even have to

6:59

choose. Their route LLM navigator

7:02

automatically picks the best model for

7:03

your specific prompt.

7:05

But it goes way beyond just chatting.

7:07

You can chat with large PDFs, generate

7:10

professional PowerPoint presentations,

7:12

and even use the Abacus AI agent to

7:14

build full apps and websites from

7:16

scratch.

7:17

If you're worried about sounding like a

7:18

robot, [music] their humanize feature

7:20

helps you ditch AI detectors entirely.

7:23

You get all of this, plus image and

7:25

video generation from Sora 2 and Kling

7:27

3.0, for just $10 a month. That's way

7:30

cheaper than paying [music] for them

7:31

separately.

7:33

Stop overpaying and start building

7:35

smarter.

7:36

Head over to [music]

7:36

chat.llm.abacus.ai/ccy

7:40

or click the [music] link in my

7:41

description to get started. Trust me,

7:44

your browser tabs will thank you.

7:47

Back to the video. [music]

7:49

People were starving, humiliated, and

7:51

convinced the system is broken. So, they

7:53

became very interested in any man

7:55

standing on a podium promising to fix

7:57

everything.

7:59

Germany chose Hitler.

8:00

Italy chose Mussolini. Japan chose

8:02

military expansion.

8:04

The path from a printing press to a

8:05

battlefield was shorter than anyone

8:07

imagined.

8:08

So, by 1944,

8:11

delegates from 44 nations gather at a

8:13

giant hotel in New Hampshire and finally

8:15

figure out the way to fix the economy.

8:18

It is called the Bretton Woods system.

8:20

And their solution was almost

8:21

offensively boring.

8:23

>> [music]

8:23

>> Every currency gets pegged to the US

8:25

dollar. And the US dollar gets pegged to

8:27

gold.

8:28

$35 an ounce, fixed.

8:31

That was the anchor.

8:33

Now, if a government got a little too

8:34

excited with the printing press, there

8:36

was a limit. A hard stop.

8:38

No more turning your currency into

8:40

confetti just to [music] goose exports

8:42

for 6 months.

8:43

And for the first time in decades, money

8:46

meant something again.

8:48

Take Friedrich in post-war Germany.

8:50

His city is rubble. His father's machine

8:52

shop is half destroyed. But now, the

8:55

money in his pocket is tied to a money

8:56

[music] system he can actually trust.

8:59

So, he takes out a loan, rebuilds,

9:01

hires, expands. Multiply Friedrich by

9:04

millions.

9:05

That's the miracle.

9:07

Germany boomed. Japan boomed. France

9:10

boomed. Countries that had just been

9:11

flattened by war came roaring back.

9:14

Why? Because underneath all the

9:16

reconstruction and industry was one

9:18

boring, but essential foundation. Stable

9:21

money.

9:22

Money with an anchor.

9:23

Money politicians [music] couldn't

9:25

casually print. That was the real cure.

9:28

But, the system still has one fatal

9:31

flaw.

9:34

Bretton Woods told every country on

9:35

Earth, "Tie your currency to the dollar.

9:38

Trust the dollar.

9:40

But it never answered one question.

9:41

[music] Who watches America?

9:43

If France printed too many francs, the

9:45

peg would break.

9:47

If Japan got reckless with the yen,

9:48

[music]

9:49

markets would punish them overnight. But

9:52

the United States was the peg.

9:54

America could spend money it didn't have

9:56

>> [music]

9:56

>> and force the rest of the world to

9:58

accept the bill.

9:59

For a while, America behaved itself.

10:01

>> [music]

10:02

>> Then came the 1960s, Vietnam, Lyndon

10:05

Johnson's Great Society, [music] a war

10:07

overseas and a welfare state at home.

10:10

Sir, can we afford both?

10:12

Why should we?

10:13

We can just do it?

10:16

And so America flooded the world with

10:17

dollars.

10:18

>> [music]

10:18

>> Yet, the gold in Fort Knox stays the

10:21

same. So now there were way more dollars

10:23

floating around than gold to back them.

10:25

>> [music]

10:26

>> And one man looked at this arrangement

10:27

and said, "This is nonsense." Charles de

10:30

Gaulle, [music] president of France,

10:32

realized that if every country tried to

10:34

cash in its dollars for gold at once,

10:36

America would run out. So he decided

10:38

France would not be the idiot standing

10:40

at the back of the line.

10:41

>> [music]

10:42

>> He sent ships and planes to America in

10:43

1965 and said, "Bonjour.

10:46

>> [music]

10:47

>> We would like to withdraw our gold. You

10:49

print more dollars without more gold

10:51

behind them. The dollars the rest of us

10:53

hold become worth less. That is robbery

10:55

with better tailoring."

10:57

Other countries started getting the same

10:59

idea.

11:00

>> [music]

11:00

>> By 1966, the US had just 3.2 billion

11:04

dollars in gold to cover 14 billion

11:06

dollars [music] in foreign dollar

11:07

claims.

11:08

In 1971, West Germany left Bretton Woods

11:11

entirely.

11:12

Britain requested 3 billion dollars in

11:14

gold. A full-blown bank run. Except the

11:17

bank was the United States of America.

11:20

So on August 13th, 1971, Nixon [music]

11:23

gathered his top advisers at Camp David.

11:25

No press,

11:26

no Congress,

11:27

just a room full of men staring at

11:29

numbers and sweating.

11:31

Two days later, Nixon interrupted

11:33

millions of Americans watching

11:34

television and announced,

11:36

"My fellow Americans,

11:38

effective immediately,

11:39

>> [music]

11:39

>> the United States will suspend the

11:41

convertibility of dollars into gold.

11:43

This is a temporary measure

11:46

that will probably last [music] forever.

11:49

Thank you."

11:50

That was it. The gold anchor was gone.

11:53

Every currency in the world was now

11:54

backed by nothing but a government's

11:56

promise [music] not to print too much.

11:58

So, how did that go?

12:00

Gold, fixed at $35 under Bretton Woods,

12:03

hit over $5,000 by 2026.

12:07

Within 2 years of Nixon's move, the oil

12:09

crisis hit,

12:10

inflation surged, [music] growth

12:12

stalled.

12:13

Economists were so confused, they had to

12:15

invent a new word for it, stagflation.

12:18

Then came '74, '79, [music]

12:21

the savings and loan crisis, the dot-com

12:23

bust, 2008.

12:26

Every decade, [music]

12:27

another mess.

12:28

Every mess, the same solution.

12:31

Print more.

12:32

And every time somebody questioned

12:34

whether this was sustainable, someone

12:36

would drag out the same old line,

12:38

"Well, World War II proved government

12:40

spending fixes the economy."

12:42

No, it didn't.

12:44

But the myth survived because it was

12:45

useful.

12:46

If people believed war spending created

12:48

prosperity, then deficits sound smart,

12:51

printing sounds necessary, [music]

12:53

and every crisis becomes an excuse to do

12:55

more of the thing that caused the

12:56

instability in the first place.

12:59

As a wise man once said, "There is no

13:01

subtler, no surer means of overturning

13:03

the existing basis [music] of society

13:06

than to debauch the currency."

Interactive Summary

Loading summary...