HomeVideos

The Biggest Lie in Economics (And You Still Believe It)

Now Playing

The Biggest Lie in Economics (And You Still Believe It)

Transcript

408 segments

0:00

October 29th, 1929.

0:02

>> [music]

0:02

>> Black Tuesday. The stock market dropped

0:05

by 12% in a single day.

0:07

Fortunes vanished in hours. Banks

0:09

collapsed in waves. Businesses shut

0:11

down. By 1933, 25% Americans had no job.

0:15

Bread lines stretched for blocks.

0:17

Families who once owned homes were now

0:19

living in cardboard shacks and

0:20

Hoovervilles.

0:21

"What am I supposed to tell the kids?"

0:24

"That's okay, Jeff. Tell them we'll

0:26

figure it out.

0:27

We always do." They didn't figure it

0:30

out, not for a long time. Their kids

0:32

grew up thinking full meant not hungry

0:35

enough to cry. So, Franklin Roosevelt

0:37

came in and threw everything at it.

0:39

Public works,

0:40

>> [music]

0:40

>> relief programs, new agencies, big

0:43

government on a scale America had never

0:45

really seen before. The New Deal put

0:47

millions [music] back to work building

0:48

bridges, dams, and highways. And to be

0:51

fair,

0:52

it helped. But it did not finish the

0:54

job. [music]

0:55

10 years after the crash, in 1939,

0:57

unemployment was still hanging around

0:59

15%. Yet, suddenly,

1:03

we interrupt this broadcast. The

1:06

Japanese have attacked Pearl Harbor. The

1:08

United States is at war.

1:11

And overnight, everything changed.

1:13

Factories that had been gathering

1:14

[music] dust roared back to life. But

1:17

now they were building tanks instead of

1:19

tractors. 17 million new jobs appeared.

1:22

Ford's assembly lines started rolling

1:24

out bombers instead of cars. Defense

1:26

[music] spending rocketed from 1.4% of

1:28

GDP to over 37%. Unemployment dropped

1:32

below 2%. Jeff got called to the

1:34

Cleveland tank plant. For the first time

1:36

in years, his family had a steady

1:38

paycheck. And just like that, on paper,

1:40

America looked incredible. So, later

1:42

Keynesian economists took one look at

1:44

this and said, [music]

1:46

"Uh of course. When people stop

1:47

spending, the government spends for

1:49

them.

1:50

>> [music]

1:50

>> World War II proved it. Case closed,

1:53

right?"

1:54

Wrong.

1:58

Let's test this so-called wartime

1:59

prosperity.

2:01

It's 1944. Jeff's family sits around

2:03

their kitchen table. We're out of sugar

2:05

[music] coupons until next month. Again?

2:08

And the meat allocation got cut. 2 lb

2:10

for the whole [music] family for the

2:12

week.

2:13

Well, at least according to the

2:14

newspaper, we've never been more

2:16

prosperous. Great.

2:18

I'll tell the children to eat the

2:19

newspaper.

2:20

This was the reality behind the numbers.

2:23

Yes, GDP was soaring.

2:26

But Americans were living under some of

2:27

the strictest rationing in US history.

2:30

Gasoline, meat, sugar, coffee, cheese,

2:33

even shoes rationed.

2:35

Car production had been banned since

2:37

1942.

2:39

By 1944, almost everything was

2:41

controlled except eggs and dairy.

2:44

Americans were saving over 25% of their

2:46

income.

2:47

Not because they'd all suddenly become

2:48

financially responsible. [music]

2:50

There was basically nothing to buy.

2:53

That's the trick.

2:54

>> [music]

2:54

>> The wartime boom was a statistical

2:56

illusion.

2:57

GDP goes up the same $10 million

3:00

whether a family builds a house or the

3:02

government builds a bomb and drops it

3:03

into the sea.

3:05

Same number.

3:06

Very different outcome for the family.

3:08

>> [music]

3:09

>> Jeff was earning more money than ever.

3:11

And his family was eating less than when

3:13

he was broke.

3:14

>> [music]

3:14

>> But the real test came after the war

3:16

ended.

3:17

1945, the guns go quiet, 10 million

3:20

soldiers are about to flood the job

3:22

market, government spending is about to

3:24

drop over 60%.

3:27

Holy crap.

3:28

>> [music]

3:28

>> Without government spending, we're

3:30

looking at the greatest period of

3:31

unemployment and industrial dislocation

3:33

any economy has ever faced. That's a

3:36

bold claim, Professor Samuelson. I will

3:38

literally [music] win the Nobel Prize.

3:40

Write it down.

3:41

I resonate with you, Professor. I'm

3:43

predicting an epidemic of violence.

3:46

And you are?

3:47

Also a future [music] Nobel laureate.

3:50

You're welcome.

3:51

Gentlemen, I am President Truman and I

3:54

also say [music] mass unemployment is

3:56

obvious. It's coming. So, everyone

3:58

agrees?

3:59

Without government [music] spending,

4:01

America collapses.

4:03

They were completely wrong.

4:05

Bomb factories became appliance

4:06

factories. Car plants switched from

4:09

tanks to Chevrolets. Shipyards pivoted

4:11

[music] from destroyers to fishing

4:12

vessels. Over 20 million people were

4:15

released from war-related work.

4:17

Unemployment peaked [music] at just

4:18

3.9%.

4:20

Truman himself later called it "The

4:21

swiftest and most gigantic changeover

4:23

that [music] any nation has made from

4:25

war to peace."

4:27

The economy didn't just survive the

4:28

spending cuts, it thrived because of

4:30

them.

4:31

Resources locked inside the war machine

4:33

flowed back into making things [music]

4:34

people actually wanted.

4:36

The Keynesian prediction was tested in

4:38

real time. It failed, but nobody updated

4:41

the textbooks. So, if the war didn't fix

4:43

the economy,

4:44

what did?

4:47

To answer that, we have to go back to

4:49

the moment the real damage started.

4:52

1914, World War I.

4:55

Countries are mobilizing millions of

4:57

soldiers, digging trenches across entire

4:59

continents,

5:00

building battleships, artillery,

5:01

uniforms, all of it, all at once, on a

5:04

scale the world has never seen.

5:06

All of it costs money, enormous,

5:09

staggering amounts of money.

5:11

Now, normally, a government funds a war

5:13

the same way it funds everything else,

5:15

taxes.

5:16

But, there's a limit to how much you can

5:17

squeeze out of your citizens, especially

5:19

when half of them are already in the

5:21

trenches.

5:22

Tax revenue runs out, the treasury runs

5:24

dry, and the war isn't over.

5:27

So, what do you do?

5:30

Well, just print it.

5:32

But, there was a problem. Back then,

5:34

>> [music]

5:34

>> most of the world was on the gold

5:35

standard, which meant governments

5:37

couldn't just print whatever they

5:38

needed. Every dollar, every pound, every

5:40

franc had to be backed by actual gold.

5:43

So, one by one, they ditched it. Gold

5:46

standard gone. Then the war ended, but

5:49

the printing did not.

5:51

Countries kept [music] printing money to

5:52

make their currency cheaper, which makes

5:54

their exports cheaper.

5:56

Other countries buy more of your stuff.

5:58

Sounds great. Until everyone figures out

6:00

the same trick.

6:02

France devalued. Britain devalued to

6:04

undercut France.

6:05

Germany printed so aggressively that a

6:07

loaf of bread cost 200 billion marks.

6:10

A housewife in Berlin needed a

6:12

wheelbarrow full of her life-saving cash

6:14

just to buy groceries.

6:16

A race to the bottom. Every country

6:18

destroying its own money to steal trade

6:20

from its neighbors. [music]

6:21

In the end, nobody gains an advantage.

6:24

All you're left with is money nobody

6:26

trusts.

6:27

World trade collapsed by 66% between

6:30

1929 and 1934.

6:33

Bad time for the economy. Good time for

6:35

the sponsor break.

6:36

Right now, your AI workflows are

6:38

scattered across too many tabs, and

6:40

you're likely paying multiple $20 AI

6:42

subscriptions. Chat LLM by Abacus.AI

6:46

[music] fixes this by putting every

6:47

top-tier model into one single

6:49

dashboard.

6:51

I'm talking about ChatGPT 5.2, Gemini 3

6:54

Pro, Claude [music] 4.5, and DeepSeek

6:57

all in one place. You don't even have to

6:59

choose. Their route LLM navigator

7:02

automatically picks the best model for

7:03

your specific prompt.

7:05

But it goes way beyond just chatting.

7:07

You can chat with large PDFs, generate

7:10

professional PowerPoint presentations,

7:12

and even use the Abacus AI agent to

7:14

build full apps and websites from

7:16

scratch.

7:17

If you're worried about sounding like a

7:18

robot, [music] their humanize feature

7:20

helps you ditch AI detectors entirely.

7:23

You get all of this, plus image and

7:25

video generation from Sora 2 and Kling

7:27

3.0, for just $10 a month. That's way

7:30

cheaper than paying [music] for them

7:31

separately.

7:33

Stop overpaying and start building

7:35

smarter.

7:36

Head over to [music]

7:36

chat.llm.abacus.ai/ccy

7:40

or click the [music] link in my

7:41

description to get started. Trust me,

7:44

your browser tabs will thank you.

7:47

Back to the video. [music]

7:49

People were starving, humiliated, and

7:51

convinced the system is broken. So, they

7:53

became very interested in any man

7:55

standing on a podium promising to fix

7:57

everything.

7:59

Germany chose Hitler.

8:00

Italy chose Mussolini. Japan chose

8:02

military expansion.

8:04

The path from a printing press to a

8:05

battlefield was shorter than anyone

8:07

imagined.

8:08

So, by 1944,

8:11

delegates from 44 nations gather at a

8:13

giant hotel in New Hampshire and finally

8:15

figure out the way to fix the economy.

8:18

It is called the Bretton Woods system.

8:20

And their solution was almost

8:21

offensively boring.

8:23

>> [music]

8:23

>> Every currency gets pegged to the US

8:25

dollar. And the US dollar gets pegged to

8:27

gold.

8:28

$35 an ounce, fixed.

8:31

That was the anchor.

8:33

Now, if a government got a little too

8:34

excited with the printing press, there

8:36

was a limit. A hard stop.

8:38

No more turning your currency into

8:40

confetti just to [music] goose exports

8:42

for 6 months.

8:43

And for the first time in decades, money

8:46

meant something again.

8:48

Take Friedrich in post-war Germany.

8:50

His city is rubble. His father's machine

8:52

shop is half destroyed. But now, the

8:55

money in his pocket is tied to a money

8:56

[music] system he can actually trust.

8:59

So, he takes out a loan, rebuilds,

9:01

hires, expands. Multiply Friedrich by

9:04

millions.

9:05

That's the miracle.

9:07

Germany boomed. Japan boomed. France

9:10

boomed. Countries that had just been

9:11

flattened by war came roaring back.

9:14

Why? Because underneath all the

9:16

reconstruction and industry was one

9:18

boring, but essential foundation. Stable

9:21

money.

9:22

Money with an anchor.

9:23

Money politicians [music] couldn't

9:25

casually print. That was the real cure.

9:28

But, the system still has one fatal

9:31

flaw.

9:34

Bretton Woods told every country on

9:35

Earth, "Tie your currency to the dollar.

9:38

Trust the dollar.

9:40

But it never answered one question.

9:41

[music] Who watches America?

9:43

If France printed too many francs, the

9:45

peg would break.

9:47

If Japan got reckless with the yen,

9:48

[music]

9:49

markets would punish them overnight. But

9:52

the United States was the peg.

9:54

America could spend money it didn't have

9:56

>> [music]

9:56

>> and force the rest of the world to

9:58

accept the bill.

9:59

For a while, America behaved itself.

10:01

>> [music]

10:02

>> Then came the 1960s, Vietnam, Lyndon

10:05

Johnson's Great Society, [music] a war

10:07

overseas and a welfare state at home.

10:10

Sir, can we afford both?

10:12

Why should we?

10:13

We can just do it?

10:16

And so America flooded the world with

10:17

dollars.

10:18

>> [music]

10:18

>> Yet, the gold in Fort Knox stays the

10:21

same. So now there were way more dollars

10:23

floating around than gold to back them.

10:25

>> [music]

10:26

>> And one man looked at this arrangement

10:27

and said, "This is nonsense." Charles de

10:30

Gaulle, [music] president of France,

10:32

realized that if every country tried to

10:34

cash in its dollars for gold at once,

10:36

America would run out. So he decided

10:38

France would not be the idiot standing

10:40

at the back of the line.

10:41

>> [music]

10:42

>> He sent ships and planes to America in

10:43

1965 and said, "Bonjour.

10:46

>> [music]

10:47

>> We would like to withdraw our gold. You

10:49

print more dollars without more gold

10:51

behind them. The dollars the rest of us

10:53

hold become worth less. That is robbery

10:55

with better tailoring."

10:57

Other countries started getting the same

10:59

idea.

11:00

>> [music]

11:00

>> By 1966, the US had just 3.2 billion

11:04

dollars in gold to cover 14 billion

11:06

dollars [music] in foreign dollar

11:07

claims.

11:08

In 1971, West Germany left Bretton Woods

11:11

entirely.

11:12

Britain requested 3 billion dollars in

11:14

gold. A full-blown bank run. Except the

11:17

bank was the United States of America.

11:20

So on August 13th, 1971, Nixon [music]

11:23

gathered his top advisers at Camp David.

11:25

No press,

11:26

no Congress,

11:27

just a room full of men staring at

11:29

numbers and sweating.

11:31

Two days later, Nixon interrupted

11:33

millions of Americans watching

11:34

television and announced,

11:36

"My fellow Americans,

11:38

effective immediately,

11:39

>> [music]

11:39

>> the United States will suspend the

11:41

convertibility of dollars into gold.

11:43

This is a temporary measure

11:46

that will probably last [music] forever.

11:49

Thank you."

11:50

That was it. The gold anchor was gone.

11:53

Every currency in the world was now

11:54

backed by nothing but a government's

11:56

promise [music] not to print too much.

11:58

So, how did that go?

12:00

Gold, fixed at $35 under Bretton Woods,

12:03

hit over $5,000 by 2026.

12:07

Within 2 years of Nixon's move, the oil

12:09

crisis hit,

12:10

inflation surged, [music] growth

12:12

stalled.

12:13

Economists were so confused, they had to

12:15

invent a new word for it, stagflation.

12:18

Then came '74, '79, [music]

12:21

the savings and loan crisis, the dot-com

12:23

bust, 2008.

12:26

Every decade, [music]

12:27

another mess.

12:28

Every mess, the same solution.

12:31

Print more.

12:32

And every time somebody questioned

12:34

whether this was sustainable, someone

12:36

would drag out the same old line,

12:38

"Well, World War II proved government

12:40

spending fixes the economy."

12:42

No, it didn't.

12:44

But the myth survived because it was

12:45

useful.

12:46

If people believed war spending created

12:48

prosperity, then deficits sound smart,

12:51

printing sounds necessary, [music]

12:53

and every crisis becomes an excuse to do

12:55

more of the thing that caused the

12:56

instability in the first place.

12:59

As a wise man once said, "There is no

13:01

subtler, no surer means of overturning

13:03

the existing basis [music] of society

13:06

than to debauch the currency."

Interactive Summary

The video explores the economic history from the Great Depression, through World War II, and into the post-war era, challenging the widely held belief that WWII spending brought prosperity. It details the catastrophic Black Tuesday crash and the subsequent New Deal efforts, which provided some relief but didn't fully resolve unemployment. The narrative then shifts to the war, showing how massive government spending created jobs and increased GDP but also led to severe rationing and a lower quality of life for many Americans, revealing a "statistical illusion" of prosperity. Post-war predictions of economic collapse due to reduced government spending were proven wrong as the economy thrived, pivoting from war production to consumer goods. The video then delves into the root causes of economic instability, tracing it back to World War I when countries abandoned the gold standard and engaged in competitive currency debasement, leading to hyperinflation and the collapse of world trade, which fostered the rise of extremist political movements. The Bretton Woods system was established to create stable global currencies pegged to the US dollar and gold, fostering a period of economic boom. However, America's excessive spending in the 1960s, unbacked by gold reserves, led to a "bank run" on the dollar, culminating in Nixon's decision in 1971 to abandon the gold standard. Since then, the world has faced recurring economic crises, often met with the solution of printing more money, a cycle perpetuated by the myth that government spending, as seen in WWII, inherently fixes the economy, ultimately debauching currency and undermining societal stability.

Suggested questions

7 ready-made prompts